Perez v. United States of America, No. 1:2016cv22379 - Document 23 (S.D. Fla. 2016)
Court Description: ORDER DENYING MOTION TO VACATE, CORRECT, SET ASIDE SENTENCE. Closing Case. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 11/28/2016. (mmd) NOTICE: If there are sealed documents in this case, they may be unsealed after 1 year or as directed by Court Order, unless they have been designated to be permanently sealed. See Local Rule 5.4 and Administrative Order 2014-69.
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Perez v. United States of America Doc. 23 UN I TED STATES DI STRI COURT FOR THE CT SO UTH ERN DI STRI OF FLO RI A CT D M im iDi son a vii Cas Num ber:16e 22379- V- ORENO CI M AUDY PEREZ, M ova , nt VS. UNI TED STATES OF AM ERI CA, Re po nt s nde . ORDER DENYI M OTI TO VACATE.CORRECT.SET ASI SENTENCE NG ON DE TheM o n ,Audy Peez,fld a scond ors ce svepeii under28 U. C.j 2255 va t r ie e uc si tton S. s e ngt vac t ,c r c ,ors tasdehi 293 m o h s nt nce. The M ova cli hi s t nc e ki o a e ore t e i s nt e e nt a ms s en e e e nc me i unc tt ina unde Johns v Unie St e 1 S.Ct 2551( 5) whih nha e nt s onsiuto l r on . td ats, 35 . 201 , c hed t Ar e Ca e Crmi Ac ' r i ua c a evoi f va ne s Be us t M ova l he m d r er i nal ts esd l l us d or gue s . ca e he nt ha no s s t hown t Cour r i d on t r sdua c a e a s e ng a t M ova ' pror he t ele he e i l l us t entnci nd he nts i Fl rdabur a y c c i qualf unde t e e a e ofe esc a e oft Ar e Ca e r oi glr onvi tons iy r he num r t d- f ns l us he m d r e Crmi lAc , heCour de est moton. i na t t t ni he i THI CAUSE c m e be or t Cour upon M ovan ' M o i t Va t Se Asde or S a f e he t ts ton o cae, t i Core tSe e e( E.7) fldonJul 1 201 rc ntnc D. ,ie v 8. 6. THE COURT ha c i r d t m oton,t r pons pe tne pori oft r co d, s onsde e he i he es e ri nt tons he e r a be ngot r s f ly a s d i t pr s ,i i nd i he wie u l dvie n he emies t s A DJU D G ED t tt m oton i D EN I . ha he i s ED Dockets.Justia.com BACK GROUND l J l 1 9 ,aj r c n itd te M o a t Aud Pee ,o o e c u to p s s in o n uy 9 5 u y o v ce h v n , y r z f n o n f ose so f fr am byac n itd fl n i v oaino 1 U.. j9 2 g .Thep es n e c ivetg to ie r o vce eo , n i lto f 8 SC. 2 ( ) r -e tn e n siain r por sa e t M ova ha ni s pa ae Fl i convi i ns f r bur ar of a dwelng e t tt d he nt d ne e r t orda cto o gl y li (ommitd on sx dif e c te i ferntocc so ) t spa ae c ci f pose son of coc i a ins, wo e r t onvitons or s s i ane (ommitd ont difrntdae ) a oneconviton f bur ay ofadwelng wih afr r c te wo fee ts, nd ci or glr li t ieam (ommitd on t sme dae a t of Mova ' ni bur lres.The Cour s nt e t c te he a t s wo nts ne gai ) t e enc d he M ova on Se e nt pt mber28,1 995,a whi h tm e t Cour a e t pr - e enc i si a i t c i he t dopt d he e s nt e nve tg ton r por a s nt ed t M ova t 293 m o hs i pr s e . At t s nt i he rng, t s e t nd e enc he nt o nt m ionm nt he e enc ng a i hi Co r f u d te M o a twa s b e tt a e ha c d s ne e u e j 9 4 o te Ar d ut o n h v n s u j c o n n n e e tnc nd r 2 /) f h me Ca e r Crmi lAc. Seci 924/) of t Ar Ca e r Crmi Ac pr de f an r e i na t ton he med r e i nal t ovi s or e nc d s tncewheeac i na dee tvi aes1 U. C.j922( a ha a l s t e nha e ene r rmi l fndan olt 8 S. g) nd s t ea t hre prorc ci f avi e f onyors rousdl ofe e. 18U. C.j924( . TheM ova i onvitons or olnt el ei ' fns ug S. e) nt a l hi s e eand t El ve h Cic ta fr e wihou opi on. Unie St e v Pe e ppeaed s entnc he e nt r ui fim d t t ni td at s . r z, 1 3F.d 1 49( 1h Ci. 9 7 . 1 3 2 1t r 1 9 ) l Aprl1 t M ova fld hi trtmotont va aet s nt eunde 28U. C.j n i 998,he nt ie s is i o c t he e enc r S. 2255. Them o i di notc l ton d halenget e he nhanc m e unde t Ar e nt r he med Ca ee Crm i lAc . On r r i na t J une 20, 201 t El nt Cicui gr nt d t M ova ' a hor z ton t f l a s c 6, he eve h r t a e he nt s ut i a i o ie e ond or s ce sve j 2255 peiin. The M o ntha be n i prs snc No mber9,1 - 264 uc si tto va s e n ion i e ve 994 m on hsa hehasa t nd boutt mor yea sl ton hi s nt nc wo e r ef s e e e. The M o nts s e cli i t c r nt m o i n i t t he no l er quaii s f a va ' ol a m n he ure to s ha ong lfe or n e l nce s nt nc underJohns 1 S. .a 25 rha d e e e on, 35 Ct t 63. The A nne Car e Crm i lA c detne a d e r i na t i s vi e flny a a ci puniha ebyi ionme f at m e e ng oneye rt t () olnt eo s ny rme s bl mprs nt or er xc edi a ha: 1 ha a a ee t t us ,at m p e us ort e t nedus ofphysca f ce a i tt pe s of s s n lm nt he e te t d e, hr a e e i l or gans he r on a t r ( i bur lr as ore ori or i ve us ofe osves or () ot r s nohe; 2) s gay, ron, xt ton, nvol s e xpl i ' 3 he wie , iv le c n c tat e e t as ro s tnilrs o y ia ij r t a oh r 1 U. C. n ov s o du th pr s ns e iu poe t ik fph sc l n uy o n te . 8 S. j a 9 4 e( )B) Th s t reca s sa ek o a t et lme t ca e't eç n meae ca s , 2 ()2 ( . e e h e lu e r n wn s h t e n s lus , h i u r td lu e' e ' e ' a t iesdualca ey r s ci l I r :Hie 825 F. 1 1 ( 1h Ci.201 . At nd he ç i r lus ' epe tvey. n e rs, ' 3d 297, 298 1 t r 6) t tm e ofhi s nt nc ng,t M ova ' pro Fl i co c i f bur a y of a d elng he i s e e i he nts i r orda nvitons or glr w li q aiida p e iaeo f n e j tf igt ee h nc me tu d ret e te e u r tdca s o u lfe s rd c t fe s s usiyn h n a e n n e ih r h n me ae lu e r t r sdua caus he e i l l e. l Johns t Supr m e Co thel i posng a i e s d s e e unde t r i l n on, he e ur d m i n ncr a e entnc r he esdua ca s (tl ie a o e vilts d e p o e s S e 1 5 S.Ct a 2 6 Fid n t e r sd a lu e iai z d b v ) oae u r c s . e 3 c . t 5 3. n i g h e i u l c a e l f t era nt a l us e t s unc t i y boutho m uc r s i t kesf a c i e t q lf a a vi e f l ny... w h ik t a or r m o ua iy s ol nt e o ( h s u c ran is p o u e mo e u p e itbii a ab ta ie s ta t Du P o e s Tl e e n e tite r d c r n rd ca lt nd r irrn s h n he e r c s y Cl et eae .'I a 255 (leai a d) aus olrts' d t 4 atrtons dde .Shorl t r fer i Welh v.Unie St e , ty heeat , n c td ats t Supr m e Cour hel is r i i Jo on a i s r toac i l t c s on c l t r lr e . he e t d t ulng n hns pple e r tve y o a es ola e a evi w 1 S. .1 7,1 ( 6) 36 Ct 25 268 201 . The El nt Cic t a horz t s M ova ' s ce s ve pe ii t de e m i w he her eve h r ui ut i ed hi nt s uc s i tton o t r ne t dh dititc u tv oae g rz')d ep o e srg t b e a cn h ss n e c b sd o hi f e src o r i ltd pee s u r c s ih s y nh n ig i e tn e a e n s t prorFl i bur a y c ci nspurua t t r sdua clus oft Ar d Ca e rCrm i l i orda gl r onvi to s nt o he e i l a e he me r e i na Ac,whih wa de ae unconsiutonali Johns ' Theis saet ol ( )whehe t t c s clrd tt i n on. , sue r wof d: 1 t r he M ova m a t r qui ie s w i of t di t i t co ts r i e on t r s dual cl us a nt de he e s t ho ng he s rc ur ' elanc he e i a e t s nt i a ( whehe t Cour ne exa ne c rntlw ort 1 a t tme oft e encng nd 2) t r he t ed mi ure a he aw t he i he M o n ' s nt nci t de e ne w he he t Fl i bur a y c va t s e e ng o t nni t r he orda gl r onvi tons c s r a ci an e ve s 3 pr di t ofe e undert Ar e cae f ns s he med Car e Crm i Ac ' e e a e c a e - whih pr de e r i nal ts num r t d l us c ovi s a a t r tveba i f t s nt nci e nc m e , a f t by Johns n le na i s s or he e e ng nha e nt not f ec ed on. LEG A L STA N DA R D AN D AN A LY SI S Purua t 28 U. C.j 2255,aprs i f r cusody may mo t c twhih s nt o S. ioner n edeal t ve he our c i pos hi s ntncet va a e,s tasde,orc r c t s nt nc i i wasi m ed s e e o ct e i or e t he e e e f t mpos i vi a i of ed n olton fd r lc n ttto lo sau o y lw,wa i o e wi ou p o e j rs ito ,i i e c s o e ea o siuina r tttr a s mp s d t t r p r u id ci n s n x e s f h tema i m a t o ie b lw, ri oh r s s be tt c laea atc . U.. j2 5a . h x mu uh rz d y a o s te wie u jc o o ltrl ta k 28 SC. 25 4) Ho v r S a s c n o s c sie mo in mu tb c ri e ...y apa e o te a p o rae we e , t ) e o d r uc e sv to l s e e ti d b t n l f h p r p it c tof a as t c ai 'eihe () ne y dic e e de or ( a ne r e of our ppe l o ont n' t r 1 wl soverd vi nce 2) w ul c tt i nall m a r toa tve t c s s on c lt r l r vi w by t Supr onsiuto aw, de e r c i o a e ola e a e e he eme Cour,t t t ha prvi l una ia e.28U. C.j2255( e ousy valbl S. 1 $. Th Go en n ag e teM o a t a no me t esau o yciei o j2 5 49, c e v r me t r u s h v n h s t t h tttr rtra f 2 5 1 whih rq ie ad n v rve o t erc r . J r n v S c> De 'o r e to s 4 5 F.d 1 5 , e u rs e o o e iw f h e o d o da . e ' p t fco r cin , 8 3 3 1 1 58( 1h Ci. 357- 1 t r 2007) fe v.UniedSt e ,- F. ; one t ats - Supp. -,201 W L 4479390,*4( D. 3d - 6 S. Fl Aug.24,201 (ttng adititc tc a. 6) sai src our onducsdenov rviw afert Cour ofAppe s t o e e t he t al grnt la t fl as ce svepeii . a s e ve o ie uc si tton)1 A. M ova ' Bur non aSe ondorSuc si j2255Petton The nts de c ce sve ii The Elve h Cic t i g a i t s c sve pe ii n de e m i Pe e had m a a e nt r ui n r ntng he uc es i tto t r ned r z de prmaf ce s o n u d rj2 5 ( Th Go en n a g st a ap io e s e ig t fl a i a i h wig n e 2 5 1 $. e v r me t r ue h t rs n r e kn o ie s c sve j2 motonba e on t new c tt i lr l i John ca onl obai r i uc esi 255 i s d he onsiutona ue n son n y t n elef l r brcf s cesi peii f mdi 28U. C.j2244pr de The u i or uc sve ttons ot n S. ovi s: ( A clin prs ntdi as ondors c sveha sc pusa i tonunde s to 2254t t 2) al e e e n ec uc esi bea or pplcai r ecin ha wa no pr s nt d i a pr ora i a i s l be di m i s d unl s s t ee e n i pplc ton ha l s se es ( t ap i nts A) he plca howst tt cli rle onane r l ofc tt i lw,ma rtoacie ha he am eis w ue onsiutonal a de er tv t cases on colat alr ew by t Supr e Cour ,t w as pr ousl unavaiabl ,... o l er evi he em t hat evi y l e' i hec n s f a how t tt r i a r a ona e lkelhood t thi Anne Ca e Crmi lAc s nt nc ha he e s e s bl i i ha s d r er i na t e e e wa dn f c 'bas d on t r i lcaus . Puta he w a t G ove n e pos t t ti i i a s t a t' e i he esdua l e not r y, he r m nt is ha f t s me e pos i lt t tPe ez' s ntnce wasbas on t r sdualclus , t ts r sbiiy ha r s e e ed he e i a e ha howi doesno ng t s ts yt ( ea o bl lkelhood'sa r . a if he û s na e i i r ' t nda d I grntngas ce svej2255peii t Elve hCic tsae t tamova ' cai n ai uc si tton,he e nt r ui ttd ha nts l m f is i i cam otbe detr i fom t r c d whe he t dititc tr le on t r i al f t l e m ned r he e or t r he src our e id he esdual c a e a s nt nc ng. l Re.. Moor ,830 F. 1 ( 1h Ci. 6) M o es iial Moor l us t e e i n e 3d 268 1 t r 201 . r pecfc l y, e sae t tamova ca tmee t bur ni aj2255pr e ngunls ç pr ve t thewa tts ha nt nno t he de n oc edi e s ç o s ha he s s ntnce usng t r i l caus a t t t us of t t clus ma a dif e e i t e e d i he esdua l e nd ha he e ha a e de fer nc n he s nt nc '1 a 1 e e e.' d. t 273. The M oor c tr s d t ti t dititc td nno t lone wa e our ea one ha f he src our t ca t el y o t o he ' whehe t r i ua clus wa us d i s nt nc ng, t d s r c c tm us de t r he t r' t r he esd l a e s e n e e i he i t i t our t ny he j2 5moin.I Th Go r me tu g st i Co r f lo Mo r t sa d r S ealo Zi a 25 to d e ven n r e hs u t o lw o e s tn ad. e s glr v Unie St e . t d ats, - F.Supp. 3d - , 2 6 W L 4 5 7 3 a * ( . Al. g. , 01 )( p li 01 2 7 7 , t 7 M D. a Au 8 2 6 a pyng Moor ' sa r ) feone 201 W L 44793 a *1 (ppl ng M oor s sa r ;Ki v es tnda d ; , 6 90 t 0 a yi e' tndad) ng . Unie St e , t d at s - F.Supp.3d - , 201 W L 4487785,a *1 ( D.Fl Aug.24,2016) Frz e v 6 t 0 S. a. ; tx/r . Unie St e , N o. 1 c 747, 201 W L 45363 a *5 (i ng t Moor fa wok t d at s 6- v6 29 t fndi he e rme r pe s sve . rua i ) Afe M oor a dif r pa of t Elvent Cicui quesi d t dec son' tr e, fe ent nel he e h r t tone he ii s i tuci n t dititcours I r Chanc 831 F. 1 , 1 ( 1h Ci. 6 ( s grei nsr to o src t . n e: e, 3d 335 339 1 t r 201 ) dia e ng wih M oo e a sai t an i ae nee notpr t dititc tsr inc on t r sdua t r nd t tng hat nm t d ove he src our ' ela e he e i l ca e a s ntncng t be e il t rle unde j 2255 a Jo s . The Chanc lne of lus t e e i o ntted o eif r nd hn on) ei t houghts sst ti i i a e i la t tme ofs nt nci whe he t c te nc d unde ugge t ha t s mm t ra t he i e e ng t r he our nha e r t r i lca e. Tr xlr 201 W L 4536329 a * . Ator la g e i t s c s ,bo h sde he esdua lus a e, 6 t 4 a r um nt n hi a e t i s a e t r e nt l ngua i bo h M oor a Chance i di t a i w a not nec s a y t t gr e he el va a ge n t e nd s ca s t s e s r o he Elve h Cic tsde son t aut i et s ond ors ce svepe ii . e nt r ui' cii o horz he ec uc s i tton Afe muc delbe ai t s Cour a ee wih t Govel e a e oys M oor s tr h i r ton, hi t gr s t he mm nt nd mpl e' gui e a i i t M ovan ' bur n t de danc s t s he ts de o monsr t he i e ild t r le . l t s case,t ta e s ntte o e if n hi he M ova has f l t s nt aied o how t thi s ntnce i r s bl lkel t f l wihi t s ope oft ha s e e s ea ona y i y o a l t n he c he ne co tt i lr e a unc d i Johns w nsiutona ul nno e n on. Ha t Co te d he ur nhanc t M ova ' s nt nce ed he nts e e unde t e r he nume a e ofe e ca e, he John on ' i lda i oft r s dua clus doesnot r t d- f ns s lus t n s s nvai ton he e i l a e a f c hi s nt nc f e t s e e e. I s hol ng,hi Cour i pe s dbyI r Holada 331F. 11 ( 1hCi.2003 , n o di t s t s ruade n e: l y, 3d 69 1 t r ) whe e ap io rfld as c pe ii ors e svepeii t vac t hi s nt ncebas o t r rs ne ie e ond tton ucc s i tton o a e s e e ed n he ne r e n unc d i Ati v Vigi a,536U. 304 ( 2) whih hed t texe uton ofa w ul nno e n kns . r ni S. 200 , c l ha c i mently dia e pe s vi a e t Ei h Amendme ' ba on cr l a unus l a l s bl d r on olt s he ght nts n ue nd ua p ns me t I Ho ld y, h Elv n h Cic i hed t a frte mo a tt ma aprmaf ce u ih n . n la a t e e e t r ut l h t o h v n o ke i a i s howi hew a e ild t fl a s ond peii ba ed on t ne r toa tve nle i Ati ,he ng s ntte o se ec tton s he w er c i l n kns mus de onsr t a d e ona e lkei t m tae ç as bl i lhood't the i C n f t'ment l dia e Holada 331 r ' ha s t ac' i aly s bld. l y, F. a 11 Fort s m er a on,a prs rtlng a s ond o s ce svepeii n ba e on t 3d t 74. he a es ione ii ec r uc s i tto s d he r e i Jo on s d onl obt i r i i he c s ul n hns houl y an elef f an how t r i a r as bl lkelhood t thi he e s e ona e i i ha s s ntncewasba e s ey ont rsdualca e. Consse wiht gae pi f tonofj ee s d oll he e i lus itnt t he tkee ng unci 2255(9,t sCour tndst M ova di notma t rquiie s ngt thi sntnc was 1 hi ti he nt d ke he e st howi ha s e e e e nce bas on t r i ua c a e Ha ng f nha d ed he esd l l us . vi ound t M ova f ie t s he nt a ld o how t s nt nci he e e ng j d e rle o te r sd a ca s (s o p s d t te e u rtd o fns sca s ) t Cout u g eid n h e i u l lu e a p o e o h n me ae - fe e lu e , he t' ne t ns t t i s of w he he t pr di t of e es qua i y unde t A nne Ca e r xt ur o he s ue t r he e ca e f ns lf r he d re Cr m i Ac ' e e a ed c aus i nal t s num r t l e. B.Pr i a eOfe e ed c t f ns s The r m ani is i whe he t Cour s d exa i c r ntl ort lw a t e i ng s ue s t r he t houl m ne ure aw he a t he tm e ofs nt i t de de whehe t pr di a e of e e qua iy t e nce undert a ts i e encng o ci t r he e c t f ns s lf o nha he c ' ot rcaus s t elment ore e a e ofe escaus Undiput y, i Pe e w a s nt e he l e , he e s num r t d- f ns l e. s edl f r z s e enc d t y,hi Fl i con c i f r bur a y of a dwe lng woul not qua iy as vi e ci oda s orda vitons o glr li d lf ol nt rmes unde t Ad' ee e so e r he s lm nt r numer t ofe e da e . Se De c aed- f ns s us s e s ampsv Unie St e 1 S. . td ats, 33 Ct 2 7 ( 01 ) Mahi v Uni d Sae ,1 6 S. . 2 ( 01 ) Un e De c mpsa dM ahs . 2 6 2 3 ; t s . t tts 3 Ct 2 43 2 6 . d r s a e n ti, Fl i sbur ar saut i non- ne i a i vii e a t r o e ca orda' gl y t t e s ge rc nd ndi sbl nd he ef r , nnotnow be us d asa e pr di ae ofe e unde t Ar e Ca e r Crm i lAc ' e e a e c a e The M ova ' e c t f ns r he m d r e i na ts num r t d lus . nt s a gume , of cot s , a s e t t De amps a M at s a y r toa tvey, whi h wholy r nt l e s um s ha r sc nd hi ppl er ci l c l i e t ditnci Congrs ma bewee afrtj2255peii a as co ors ce sve gnors he si ton e s de t n is tton nd e nd uc si p tto S e g n r l 28 U. C.j 2 4 ( a 2 51 De c mps a d Mati ae n t eiin. e e eal y S. j 2 4b) nd 25 ( $. s a n hs r o rtoa tvef t pur e ofas c ors e sve j2255peii bec us t y aenotne er ci or he pos s e ond ucc s i tton, a e he r w r es ofc tt i ll w m ade r t oa tve by t Supr m e Cour . See H i e ,8 F. a 1303 ul ons iutona a er ci he e t r s 25 3d t ( s Decampsi tno rtoaci f pur eso as ondors c svej2255moin') I Hie s d t er tve or pos f ec uc esi to '. n rs, t Elve h Cic ta d t tt tmat sgi whehera s nt i (hedeenda ')pror he e nt rui dde ha ç wha ter ls t t e encna, t f nts i c n ito sq ai dp ru n t ter sd lca s , ihwo l rnd rhi sn e c s be t o o vcin u lfe u s a t o h e iua lu e wh c u d e e s e tn e u j c t s c sve j 2255 chalnge unde John on,orpurua t t eeme s ca e,whi woul uc esi le r s s nt o he l nt lus ch d n t' 2 F.da 1 0 (mp ssa d d . o . 8 5 3 t 3 3 e ha i d e lz ' Gie te ln sa ig j rs r d n e r g r ig t mp ra c o fn l y o c i na v n h o g tndn u ip u e c e a dn hei o tn e f iai f rmi l t j d me t a d te src rq ie nso j2 5 1)frs c n o s c e sv p tto s t eCo r u g n s n h tit e u rme t f 2 5 o e o d r u c s ie eiin , h u t 2Ot cruicou t haveas f her ic t rs lo oundt tDe campsc nnotbea i r r ctvey. Ezelv.UniedSt e ,778 ha s a ppled etoa i l l t ats F.d7 2 7 3(t Ci. 1 ) h l n t a Dec mpsi n tan w r l o c n ttto la ma erto cieb te 3 6 , 6 9h r20 5 ( odig h t sa s o e ue f o siuina lw d er atv y h S pe Co r a dteeoeima n t ev a teb sso asc n o s c esv 2 5 moin ;nRe J cct u rme ut n h rfr t y o sr e s h a i f e o d r u c sie 2 5 t ) I . l / m, o ç 7 6F.d29 , 9 (t Ci. 01 )( l n ta teS p e Co t a n tma eDec mpsrto ciea dta 7 3 2 2 6 5h r2 5 hodig h t h u rme urh s o d s a era tv n h t Dec mpscnn tsrea teb sso as c n o sc e svej2 5 moin . sa a o ev s h a i f e o d r u c si 2 5 to ) 7 fnds t t De camps a M at s s ul not be a i d r toa i l . Consi t w ih t i ha s nd hi ho d pple e r ctvey s ent t he Elve h Cic ts gui nc i M oor ,t quesi i whehe at t tme of t s nt ncng e nt r ui' da e n e he ton s t r he i he e e i he rng a ofPer z' ot rf l ny c c i qua ii a vi e one unde t elm e s or a i ny e s he e o onvitons lfed s ol nt s r he e nt e nume ae ofe es clus of t Ar r t d- f ns a e he med Ca e Crm i l Act The undiput y qua ii d r er i na . y s edl lte unde t e r he nume ae caus r td l e. Ac di y,t Cour deni t m oton t va t t s nt nc bas on t M ovants cor ngl he t es he i o ca e he e e e ed he ' f l et s aiur o how ar as na e lkei e o bl i lhood t tt s nt ncng c tr i on t r i lc a eand ha he e e i our eled he esdua l us be aus hi Fl i bur ar c ci ns quaii a pr di a e ofe esundert e e a e c e s orda gl y onvi to lfed s e c t f ns he num r t d ofe esclus a t tm eofs e i . f ns a e t he i entncng DONE AN D ORDERED i Chn be s a M im i Fl i t s n m r t a , orda, hi ofN o mbe ve r 201 6. FEDERI . NO UNI TED STATES DI STRI J CT UDGE Copi f ni he t es ur s d o: Co e o R e or uns l f c d 8
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
