Rodriguez et al v. Liberty Mutual Insurance Company, No. 1:2016cv21926 - Document 45 (S.D. Fla. 2017)
Court Description: ORDER granting 22 Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment. Closing Case. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 3/2/2016. (mmd) NOTICE: If there are sealed documents in this case, they may be unsealed after 1 year or as directed by Court Order, unless they have been designated to be permanently sealed. See Local Rule 5.4 and Administrative Order 2014-69.
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Rodriguez et al v. Liberty Mutual Insurance Company Doc. 45 UNI TED STA TES D I STRI COU RT FO R TH E CT SOUTHERN DI STRI OF FLORI CT DA Cas Num ber 16- 926- V- ORENO e : 21 Cl M RI RODRI NA GUEZ a FM NCI nd SCO ROD RI EZ, GU Pl ntf s ai i f , VS. LI BERTY M UTUAL FI I RE NSURANCE COM PANY, D ef endant . O R DER G R AN TI G D EFEN DA N T ' M O TI N FO R SU M M A R Y JU D G M EN T N S O I 2005,Pli if fld apr pe t i ur ecli a t Def nda Li ry M ut lFie n antfs ie o ry ns anc a m nd he e nt be t ua r l ur nc Compa pai t m $9, 45. t c r t da ns a e ny d he 1 05 o ove he mage ca e by Hur iane Ka rna us d rc ti . Pli if a ce ed t pa e t t was a compa e by a lte i c tng t t i was a antfs c pt he ym nt ha c nid et r ndi a i ha t c pl t r vi of t cl i . Pl ntfs a e e t tamount i 2005, t n waied a de a om e e e ew he a m ai if cc pt d ha n he t c de untl 201 t r ue t an a a s , whi t i ur nce c i 5 o eq s ppr ial ch he ns a ompa de e . The Am e d ny ni d nde Co litsae a cam f rb e c o c nrc a d d caao yj d me t Boh camsa s r mp an tts li o r a h f o ta t n e lrt r u g n . t li s et Def nda f l t ac e nt aied o knowl edge t l s a f ie t r m i pa he os nd al d o e t yment The undiput d r cor . s e e d e de s vi nce hows t t Li t M ut c ha bery ual omplt d is r vi of t cai and pai Pl ntfs i e e t e ew he l m d ai if n 2005. Eve i t Cour w e e t c t ue t Am e n f he t r o ons r he nded Com pl ntas s a i a c a m f br ac ai t tng l i or e h se i fom t 201 de a of t a a s , t Cour w oul a y Fl i s St t e of t mm ng r he 5 ni l he ppr ial he t d ppl or da' a ut Li ttons j 95.1t ba t cai Tor l ot r s on t fcsoft sca ewo d t r miai , 1 o r he l m. ue hewie he a t hi s ul hwa t t pur e ofFl i s s a ut Fi ly,t Pl i t f sf l t c pl w ih t polc stm e y he pos s orda' t t e. na l he a n if aied o om y t he i y' i l n tc p o iin c e tn ap e u to o p eu ie u d rFlrd lw - a p e u to ta oie r vso s r aig r s mp in f rj dc n e o i a a r s mp in h t Pl i ifdi notr but A c or ngl , teCo r g a t s mmayj g n i fv ro Dee a tl a ntf d e . c di y h u t rn s u r ud me t n a o f fnd n . 1 ee d n Liet Muu l e v dt sato iv kigt Co r' dv ri uidcina tep risaefo D fn a t b ry ta rmo e hi cin n o n he u ts iest rs ito s h ate r r m yj difr sae .Thenotc saest Pl ntf s te ar resi t ale ng al st ai $11 ,81 54. feent t ts ie tt he ai if ubmitd epai tmae lgi os otlng 3 3. Dockets.Justia.com THI CAU SE ca e be or t Cour u S m f e he t pon Def nda ' M o i f Sum m a y J e nts t on or r udgm e nt ( E.22) fl on Ocober18.2016. D. , ied t THE COURT has c i r t moton,t r pons , t peri nt pori of t onsde ed he i he es e he tne tons he r cor a beng ot r s f l a s i t pr m ie ,i i e d, nd i he wie uly dvied n he e s s t s A DJU DG ED t tt m oton i GR AN TED .I i al o ha he i s ts s ADJUDG ED t tal ot rpe ng motonsa eDENI asm oot ha l he ndi i r ED . Bac ound kcr Pl i if ,t i ur ds a e s ng t i hom eow ne ' i ur e c pa f da a a ntf s he ns e , r ui he r r s ns anc om ny or m ges s f r t t i pr pe t durng Huri ne Karnaon Augus 25,2005. TheDe e nt Li ry ufe ed o her o ry i rca ti t f nda , be t M ut lFie l ur nceCompa a kno ldge c r a ma apaymen t t Pli ifon ua r ns a ny, c w e d ove age nd de t o he antf Oc obe 23,2005 i t a t r n he mountof$9, 45. Pli if t sii d t we e dis tsi d wih t 1 05. a ntf s e tfe hey r s a ife t he a mount of t pa nt t y r eved i 2005. Des t beng dis ife Pl i if di no he yme he ec i n pie i s atsi d, antfs d t pur ue a diput wih Li ry M ut la t tm e. Al os t n ye r lt r on J y 8,201 s ny s e t be t ua t he i m t e a s ae , ul 5, Pl ntfs fld a s eme a cai i c ai if ie uppl nt l l m n onne i wih t Huni ne Karna l s a cton t he ca ti os nd de a d a aia . On Septm be 23,201 Li t M ut de i t a a s de m nde ppr s l e r 5, bery ual clned he ppr ial mand s a i t s a u e of lm ia i t tng he t t t i t tons e r d. Pl i if ' A m e d C o pl i i f br a h of xpie a ntf s nde m a nt s or e c c n rc a d a d ca ao y j d me t ta c v r g e it fr t ls . Mo e s e iial o ta t n e lrtr u g n h t o ea e xss o he o s r p cfc l y, Pl n if 'c ai f br ac of c r c s a es t tLi r y M ut lbr ac d t c r c whe i ai tf s l m or e h ont a t t t ha be t ua e he he ont a t n t f ie t S c wl a ld o i kno edge c r f t l s a or a knowl a ove age or he os , nd/ c edge t t pa e woul be ha ym nt d f t om i a orm a a pa e of i ur nc pr e t t I ur d. The dec a a or orhc ng; nd/ ke ny ym nt ns a e oce ds o he ns e ' ' lrt y j udgme c r que t t Cour hol S ove a doese s f t l s' nt ount e ss he t d ç r ge c xit or he os . ' Lie t Mu u lmo e f rs mmayj d me ta g igt Plitfs b e c o c n rc i b ry t a v d o u r u g n r un he an if' ra h f o ta t s ba r d bec us t undiput f t s re a e he s ed ac s how t tLi ry M ut pai a di notde Pli if s ha be t ual d nd d ny a ntf Nete p ryh sma eag me t o wh te tejzidcin l mo n h sb e me.l tea sn eo e ie c ih r at a d ru ns n eh r h l s ito a a u t a e n t n h be c f vd n e r p ee tdt tec nrr,h Co rfn ta tej rs ito a a u t a b e me. rs ne o h o tay te ut ids h th uidcin l mo n h s e n t 2 2005 c am . I a ton,t De e nta g sFl i ssaut oflmia i , s c i n 95. 1ba s l i n ddii he f nda r ue orda' t t e i t tons e to 1 r Pl i if 'c am s Li ry M ut lalo mai ai t tPli tfs f iur t gi pr ptnotce antfs l i . be t ua s nt ns ha a n if ' a l e o ve om i ne t a la lt i t sca e. ga es ny i biiy n hi s Le lSt nda d ga a r S mmayj d me ti a t rz dwh r te ei n g n n is eofmae ilfc Fed. u r u g n s uho ie e e h r s o e uie su tra a t . R. v P. 6 c.Thep rys e i gs mma yj d me tb a st eiiil u de o de nsrtn Ci . 5 () a t e k n u r u g n e r h nta b r n f mo taig t a e e ofage ne is ofma e i lf c . Adik s v S.L Kr s drCo., 398 U. 1 1 he bs nc nui s ue t ra a t ce . I es S. 44, 57 ( 9 0 . Th p ry o p sn te moi n f rs mmayj d me tma n tsmpy r s u o mee 1 7 ) e a t p o ig h to o u r u g n y o i l e t p n r a lga i or de al of t pla n ; t nonle tons ni s he e di gs he movi pa t mus esabls t es e il ng ry t t ih he s nta el m e s ofis ca e on w hi h i w ilbe r t bur n ofpr a t i l Ceotx Cor v Cate t e nt t s c t l a he de oof t r a . l e p. . r t, 477 U. 317( 98 ;M atu hia Elc I s Co.v.Ze t Radi Cor ., 475 U. 574 ( 986) S. 1 6) s s t e . ndu . nih o p S. 1 . The normova m us pr s ntmor t n a s ntla ofe de i s ppor of t nonm ova ' l nt t ee e ha ci il vi nce n u t he nts po iin.A j r mu tb a l ra o a yt fn f rt en n v n . d r o v fi rt Lobb sto u y s e be e s n bl o id o h o mo a tAn e s n be y y, . I c, 7U. 2 2, 4 ( 9 6 . n .47 S. 4 25 1 8 ) Anal i vs s A . Br c ofCont a t ea h rc t-he e e nt of a br ac of co r c aci a e:( ) a vai c rct () a maei d- l me s l e h nta t ton r 1 ld onta ; 2 tral bra a ()da s' Abbot Labs,I v.Gen.El .Capial 765 So.2d737,7 ( a.5t e ch; nd 3 mage .' t nc. ec t, 40 Fl h DCA 2 0 ) Ats mmay j d me t t e p ris d s u e wheh r a b e c oc u r d Li ry 0 0. u r u g n, h a t ip t e te r a h c re be t . M ut s i di no br a h t i ur nc polc be us i 2005 i pai $9, 45. f t ual ays t d t e c he ns a e iy ca e n t d 1 05 or he c am a is i t sc e. Pli if as e tLi ry M ut br a he t c r c whe i de e l i t s ue n hi as antfs s r be t ual e c d he onta t n t nid Pl i if 'a aia r s on Se e antfs ppr s l eque t pt mber23, 2015. Teli y,Pli if Am e lngl antfs' nded Co pl ntsa est De e ntbr che t c r c by m ai tt he f nda ea d he onta t Cailng)t ()ac s li o:i knowl c r gef t Los ;a or(i ac f edge ove a or he s nd/ i) knowl t tpa twoul edge ha ymen d b f rh o n a d o (i)ma e a y pa me to i u a e pr c e s t t i s r d' The e o tc mig; n /r ii k n y n f ns rnc o e d o he n u e ' . br ac ofc r tcai sa e i t Am e e h ontac l m tt d n he nded Compli ti noti lne wih Pl ntfs posii an s n i t ai if ' ton a s mmayj d me t-t a teb e c o c nrc i ted nilo t er q e tf ra p asl The t u r u g n h t h ra h f o ta t s h e a f h e u s o p r ia . undiput e de doesnots s ed vi nce uppor t br c des rbe i t Am e t he ea h c i d n he nded Com pl nt Ra he , ai . t r i s w sLi ry M ut lac t ho be t ua knowldged co r ge f t l sand m a pa e t t Pl i if e ve a or he os de ym nt o he antfs i 2005. n Stt t o i tto s a ue fL mi in a Alhough t Am e d Compli f ie t sa e a b e h of c r tcli se i t he nde ant al d o t t r ac ontac am t mm ng f om t 201 de alof t a a s r ques , t Cour wilne t es e ua e whehert t r he 5 ni he ppr i al e t he t l verhel s val t t ha cam s r ie s mmay j d me t De e d n ag e Flrdas sau e o lmiain j 9 l1 li u vv s u r u g n . fn a t r u s o i ' ttt f i tto s 5 . i ttons ovi ha c i or ea h ba st cai . Fl i s sat e oflm ia i pr dest tan a ton f br c ofa pr t r he l m 2 orda' t ut opery i ur e c r tmus be fl wihi fve ye r oft c us ofac i a c ui . fi ns anc ontac t ied t n i a s he a e ton c r ng nares v. Uni e s Pr p.& Cas I s Co ,1 So 3 71 , 21( a 3 DCA 2 4 .Th fv - e rsaue v r al o . n . . 41 . d 9 7 Fl. d 01 ) e i ey a tt t oflm iai nsbegi t nm fo t dae oft br a h ofan i ur nc polcy, notfom t da e i t to ns o r m he t he e c ns a e i r he t ofl s Sae z v St e Far Fieand Cas Co , 6 S 2 6 6 ( a 3 DCA 2 0 ) os . n . at m r . . 8 1 o. d 4, 8 F1 . d 0 3. Reyi on Rio v St e Far Fl i I . Co ,1 3 So 3 1 1 ( l . d DCA 2 4 , l ng z . at m orda ns . 3 . d 1 4 Fa 3 01 ) Pli if a guet tt sa tng poi oft rsaut oflmia i i Septm be 23, antfs r ha he tri nt hei t t e i t tons s e r 201 ( n 5 whe Li ry M ut de e t a asl,rt rt Ocober23,2005 ( n Li ry M ut lpad be t ual nid he ppria) ahe han t whe be t ua i t $ 1 05) l Ri t i lrdsma acam on t rpolc i Ocobe 2005, and Stt hem 9,45. . n zo, he nsze de li hei iy n t r ae Fam pai t m i J r and Aprl2006. 1 I Oct r201 - f yea safe t pa e s r d he n anua y i d. n obe 0 our r tr he ym nt - t Ri m a an a tonalcli t twa de e . TheRiosfld s ti J y 2011and t he zos de ddii am ha s nid z ie ui n ul he i ur nc c pa a gue t saut oflmia i a i d t ba t s e ns a e om ny r d he t t e i t tons pple o r he uppl mentlcl m . The a ai Thid D it i t Cot tof A ppe he d t s a ut of lm ia i be n ac ui w he t O c obe r s rc l r al l he t t e i t tons ga cr ng n he t r 201 cli wasde e notwhen t i ta pa 0 am nid, he nii l ymen wa ma . t s de 2Fl i ssatt oflmiai wa a ndedi 201l Be us t daeofPl n ifsl socc rd i 2005 orda' t ue i ttons s me n . ca e he t aitf os ure n he ,t Co tw ila yt saut oflm iainsi efec a t tme. Bot pa tesa y t 2004veri o t saut i ur l ppl he tt e i t to n f t t he i h ri ppl he son f he tt e n t rbref. hei i s The Rio cour no e f c ualc r um sa es i s z t td a t ic t nc n uppo tofis hol ng. Fi s ,t Ri os r t di r t he z ' c ompl i w a cea t tt br a h wasf rt de a oft s e e a c am i 201 a di ant s l r ha he e c o he ni l he upplm nt l l i n 0 nd d notr f r nce a o he br c Sec nd, he i ur nc c pa m a no i c ton t tt 2006 eee ny t r ea h. o t ns a e om ny de ndi a i ha he pa e swe e f la fna pa ym nt r ul nd i l ymen s.Thid,t Ri osad s d t i ur t r he z vie he ns mwe co pa oft r m ny hei s e e alcli wihi t lm ia i pe i Thos cic t espa ty ditnguih Rio upplm nt am t n he i ttons rod. e r umsanc rl si s z fom t sc e r hi as . l t sca e unlke Rio,Pl ntf sAm e d Compl i f br a h ofcontac i f a n hi s , i z ai if nde ant or e c r t s or f iur t a kno e c r f t 2005 l sa f iur t m a pa e . A ddii ly, al e o c wl dge ove age or he os nd al e o ke ym nt tona l t Pl i if he e,unlke t Riosdi no a s t i ur nc co pa wihi t lm iai ns he antfs r i he z d t dvie he ns a e m ny t n he i tto pe i t tt we e dis tsi d wih t 2005 pa rod ha hey r s aife t he ymen .Fi ly, t l t e a c pa ng t t nal he e t r c om nyi he 2005 pa e i t s c e i c t s t t Li ry M ut l c ym nt n hi as ndia e ha be t ua omplt d is r vi w and is d a ee t e e s ue pa ntf rr part da yme o e i o mage pr ry. Alhough t r i no e de t t 2005 pa d ope t t he e s vi nce hat he yment waslbe e t ul a fna , t l te saest ti aco plt r viw oft c am . Se Luc ano a l d d l nd i l' he el r tt ha s m e e e e f ' he l i e i Untd Pr pe t ( Ca .I s Co ,1 6 S 3 1 08 1 1 ( a 4h DCA 201 ) (o dn i e o ry Q s n . . 5 o. d 1 , 1 0 Fl . t 5 h l ig pa e t i ur d w a no a tnalpa en be us l te i ca ed pa e w a f pa tc a ym nt o ns e s t i ym t ca e e t r ndi t ym nt s or r i ul r rpaisa notot r) Notbl Pli if ha notpr de a ot ri e v ni fcori t e r nd hes. a y, antfs ve ovi d ny he ntr e ng a t n he l ye r pe i t a l t s Cour t tnd t r o- a rod o low hi t o i he eque t f a a s w a anyt ng ot r t n a s or ppr i al s hi he ha r ha he r ques t r e a dec de- d c am a isr ol i n. Gi n t d s i ia ii fom e s d e t o eviw a ol l i nd t es uto ve he i sm lrtes r Rio,t Cou tfndst saut oflm iai bar t Pl ntfs br ch ofc r c c am . z he r i he t t e i t tons s he ai if ' ea onta t l i Alowi t s c s t go f r d woul mea a i ur d i Fl i c d wai a l ng hi a e o o war d n n ns e n orda oul t n i fnie a ountoftm e,t ough m a huni a s a ot r di aser , t dem and appr s and nde i t m i hr ny c ne nd he s t s o ai al t n a gue t ca rer s br ac oc ur ed w he i r us t a ai a dem a , r her t w hen he r he r i ' e h c r n t ef ed he ppr s l nd at han i m a t a l ed unde a e t t pr pt d t a a s l de a . See e. ,Nardone v. t de he leg p ym nt ha om e he ppr i a m nd g. Re ol 333 So.2d 25,3 ( a.1 yn ds, 6 F1 976)C' pur esoft sauts oflmiai ae t The pos he tt e i ttons r o pr ec de e nt agans unus ly lng deaysi flng oflws t a t pr ve une c e ot t f nda s i t ua l o l n ii a uis nd o e nt xpe t d e or e e ofsa ec am s' . nf c m nt tl l i . ' ) B. Faiur t Compl wih Polc sCondii l eo y t i y' tons Eve i t Cour we e t tndt sa ut oflm iai wasnota iabl , t Pl i if n f he t r o i he tt e i t tons pplc e he antfs f ld t c aie o ompl wih t polc snotcec ton, whi pr desLi ry M ut wih abass y t he i y' i ondii ch ovi be t ual t i t de cove a o ny r ge. Thepolc pr de iy ovi s: 2. YourDute afe Los .I c e ofal st c r pr ry, you m us s i s t r s n as os o ove ed ope t t ee t tt f l wi a edone: ha he olo ng r a. G i nr ve omptnotc t us o oura nt ie o r ge An i ur s f l e t pr de tm ey notce i a lga ba i t de cove age t r ns ed' aiur o ovi i l i s e l ss o ny r mde Fl i l La r v.Cii n' Pr p. I . Cor . 1 So. 3d 470, 47 ( a 3 DCA 2 5 . orda aw. que tze s o ns p , 67 3 Fl. d 01 ) W hehe untmel notc ba s a cai i a t se a yss I The frt se i t deer ne t r i y ie r l m s wo- tp nal i. d is tp s o t mi whet r no i wa tmel foBelo v St e Far Fl I . Co. 1 2 So. 3d 595,599 ( a. he tce s i y. l . at m a. ns , 5 F1 2d DCA 201 ) l ten tc wa u tmey, rj dc t t ei u e i p e u d Banker Ins.Co. 4 . f h o ie s n i l p eu ie o h ns r r s r s me s . v Maca ,475 So.2d 1 6,1 8 ( a.1 ) I t s ond se t i ur hast bur nt . is 21 21 F1 985 . n he ec tp, he ns ed he de o o ec met ep e l to b p o n t a t ei u e wa n tp eu ie fo l 4 5 So 2 v ro h r sl in y r vig h t h ns r r s o rj d c d. Bel 7 . d mp o, a 599;Cl I .I v XL S i t I s Co. No.1 62028- V t ena nv nc. . pecaly n . , 0C1 SCOLA , 201 W L 1 2 004851 , a *4( D. a. a . 201 . t S. Fl M r 26, 2) The polcy he er quie ç o i r e r d d mptnotc .'' Fl i c t ha i e pr t d pr ptno i e pr ie orda our s ve nt r e e om tc r quie e s t m e n S t n a r ms bl tm e i viw of alt f c s a cic sa s of e r m nt o a i hi wi e ona e i n e l he a t nd r um t nce e c pa tc a c s 'fo lo,475 So.2d a 599. ç n ca es w he e t undiput f c ua r cor a h riulr a e. Be l ' t l l s r he s ed a t l e d e tbls snotc i s lt t no ra ona ej o c d fnd itmey,Fl i c t wildee sa ihe ie s o ae hat e s bl ur r oul i t i l orda ours l m t notc untm el a a m a t rofl .'N at' Tr tl .Co.v Gr he i e i y s te aw ' 1 us ns . aham Br her Cons r Co. 91 ot s t. , 6 F.S p 2 1 4 ,1 8( . F a 201 )(o ry a d ly u tmeya amatro lw) s ealo u p. d 2 4 25 M D. l . 3 f u - e r ea ni l s te f a ; e s Cl 201 W L 1 ena, 2 004851a * (ouryea dea untmel a amatroflw) H er Pl ntfs t4 f r ly i y s te a e, ai i f . waied amos t n yea st r por t s e nt lc am f a as l much l e t n a oft t l te r o e t he uppl me a l i or ppr ia , atr ha ny he ct d c es Ac or ngl t t n- a dely consiut sl t no i a am a troflw . ie as . c di y, he e ye r a tt e ae tce s te a H a ng f vi ound t notce l t a a m a t of l w , t r i a pr um pton t t Li ry he i ae s ter a he e s es i ha be t M uu l sp eu ie a ars l o t ed ly.Lo l 4 5 So 2 a 5 9 Pl i if havenot ta wa rj d c d s e ut f h ea Bel 7 . d t 9 antfs o, . tidt o ec metep e u to o p tfrhe ie c t a Li ryM uua wa n tp eudc d re o v r o h rs mp in r u o t vd n e h t bet t l s o rj ie . S lrd lw rc g ie t a a S s rr i prj dc d b u tmey n tc wh n t t oi a a e o n z s h t n i u e s eu ie y n i l o ie e he F n unde l ng pur e oft no i r quie e i fusr t d.''The YachtCl b on t l r oasal ryi pos he tce e r m nt s r ta e ' u he ntac t Condo.As oc I .v fe ngt I s. Co,5 9 Fe Ap x.8 5 8 1( 1h Ci. 01 )(uoig s . nc . xi on n . 9 d. p' 7 , 8 1 t r 2 5 q tn 1500 Co alTowe sCondo. s', I .v Ciien Pr p. n .Cor ., 1 2So 3 5 ( a 3 DCA r r As n nc . tz s o I s p 1 . d 41 Fl. d 20l3) Thepur eoft notc pr soni t e et i urra opporuniyt i tgae ). pos he ie ovii s o nabl he ns e n t t o nvesi t te d ma e Prj dc rs ls wh n u tmey n tc i d s a is rrs a l y t ( ) h a g . eu ie e ut e n i l o ie mpe e n n u e ' bit o 1 i i si t a cli ( defnd a cai or( mii t dn gest ough s te nto e ry nve tgae am, 2) e l m, 3) tgae ma hr etlme r a l rpais Se Cl 201 W L l e r. e ena, 2 004851a *6( i Kendal Lak s Towe sCondo Ass' I v. t quotng l e r n nc. . Pac I .Co. Lt ,201 W L 266 , a * ( D. a 2 2 ) . ns , d. 2 438 t 2 S. Fl. 01 ). Pli if t tfe t ti t i er e ng 1 yea st y m a r paist t rpr pe t a antfs esi d ha n he nt v ni 0 r he de e r o hei o ry nd had da magei 201 The ef t sce t nl woul m a i m or difc tt i tga edamage n 3. s acor rai y d ke t e fi ul o nvesi t se i fom Huni ne Ka rna i 2005. Thi Cour t r or fndst r or evi nc s t mm ng r ca ti n s t he ef e i he ec d de e hows Lie t M uu lwa p eudc db teu tmey n tc . c r n l t sCo r fn te ei n b ry ta s rj ie y h n i l oie Ac odigy,hi u t ids h r s o c v r g fr t e s p lme tl cam a d s mma y j dg n i g a td i fv r o te o e a e o h u p e na li n u r u me t s r n e n a o f h De e nt f nda . D N A DOI R DiCa bersatM iam i,Florida,this O E N I E n hm DE fofM arch 2017 f . FE A . REN O M UNI TED STATES D I STRI J D GE CT U . C opi f shed t es urni o: Couns lofRec d e or 8
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
