Witkin Design Group v. Travelers Property Casualty Company of America, No. 1:2016cv20484 - Document 17 (S.D. Fla. 2016)
Court Description: ORDER DENYING 8 Plaintiff's Motion to Remand to State Court and GRANTING 4 Defendant Travelers' Motion to Dismiss Defendant Brown & Brown. Counts III and IV of Plaintiff's Complaint are DISMISSED without prejudice. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 4/18/2016. (brn)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Witkin Design Group v. Travelers Property Casualty Company of America Doc. 17 UN I TED STATES D I STRI CO UR T FOR TH E CT SO U THERN DI STRI OF FLO RI A CT D M i iD i si am vi on C as N um be 1 20484- V - O REN O e r: 6CI M W I I D ESI G RO UP,l C. TK N GN N , Pl ntf , ai if TRA VELERS PR OPERTY CA SUA LTY COM PA N Y O F A M ERI a BROW N & CA nd BR OW N O F FLO RI ,l C . DA N , D e e nt . f nda s O R D ER D EN YI G PLA I I S M O TI N TO REM AN D A ND G R AN TI G N NT FF' O N D EFEN DA N T TR AV ELER S PRO PERT Y CA SUA LTY C O M PA N Y O F A M E RI A ' C S M O TI N TO D I I D EFEN DA N T BR O W N & BR O W N O F FLO R I .I C. O SM SS DA N THI CAUSE c me beor t Cour u ()Deenda Tr velr Pr ry Cauat S a f e he t pon 1 f nt a es ope t s ly Co nyofAmeia' (é-a lr')M oi t DimisDee ntBr & Br ofFl i mpa rc s sl vee s' ton o s s fnda own -r own orda, l .(i own & Brwn' ( E.4) fld on Fe nc çBr o ' D. , ie l bruarv 1 201 a ( Pli ifW iki De in 0. 6; nd 2) antf t n sg Gr u , n .s(W ikn' M oi nt Re n ( E. ) fldo M a c 8 2 6.Bo hM oin i o p I c' t t i' to o ma d D. 8 ,ie n r h . 01 i ) t to s n t s i ur nc dipu e pr s ntt s m e que ton:whe her t Cour s hi ns a e s t e e he a si t he t houl di r ga d Br n & d s e r ow Br w n' c tze hi be us Fl i l w r quie t di m i s ofW iki s c a m s a ns Br o s ii ns p ca e orda a e r s he s s al t n' l i gai t own & Br own whie t i ur nc c a diput bewee W iki a Tr vlr i pe ng. Upon l he ns a e over ge s e t n t n nd a e s s ndi r vi w of t M otons t va i Re pons s and Re i ,t pe tne pori of t r co d, e e he i , he r ous s e ples he r i nt tons he e r and bei ot ng hem ie f l advi ed i t pr i es t Courtent t f l i O r s uly s n he em s , he ers he olow ng der. 1 . BA CK G R O U ND On De embe 7,201 Pli ifW iki Desgn Gr l .Ct iki ' fld t i tnt c r 5, antf t n i oup, nc W t n' ie he nsa ) c s a ns Dee nt Trveer Pr ry Ca uat Compa of Amei (s a es' a a e gai t fnda s a l s ope t s ly ny rca t velr' nd Tr ) Dockets.Justia.com Br wn & Br wn ofFlrd ,lc tBrm 1 & Br wn' i t Cic tCo r o t e Elve t o o oia n . s o s o ' n he rui u t f h e nh l J c a Cic t i a f M i m iDade Co y,Fl i Se D . 1 2 a 7. W iki D e i i a udi i l r ui, n nd or a unt orda. e E. - t t n s gn s Fl i c por ton w ih is pr nc pa ofi e l t i H olyw ood,Fl i orda or a i t t i i l tc oca ed n l or da. Tr ve e s i a a lr s Col e tc c por ton w ih ispr nc palpl ce of bus nes i Cor ec i ut D . 8 at3. Br n m c i ut or a i t t i i a i s n m tc . E. ow & Br own i aFl i c por ton wih isprnci lpl c ofbusnes i Da ona Be h,Fl i . s orda or a i t t i pa a e i s n yt ac orda 1 d. W iki s Com pl nt s t f t f ur c us s of a ton. l Count 1 a I ,W iki s ks a t n' ai e s orh o a e ci n s nd I t n ee de l r ton t t c r e s s under i ur nc polc es i s d by Tr vel r ,a con e t t c a a i ha ove age xit ns a e i i s ue a e s nd t nds ha Tr vel r br a d t polc e by de ng W iki c r ge and r f i t i m ni y W iki a e s e che he i i s nyi t n ove a e usng o nde f t n. Se D . 1 2 a 1 -1 Count ll a I a e a ns Br e E. - t 3 7. s l nd V r gai t own & Br own- t age t tpr ur he nt ha oc ed t polci s f om Tr l r f W iki - a t y a l ge t t Br he i e r ave e s or t n nd he le ha own & Br n br c d t ow ea he he fduc a y dut t ti owed t W iki and w a ne i enti pr ur ng t polci s f W iki Se i ir y ha t o t n s glg n oc i he i e or t n. e i a 1 -20. d. t 8 On Febr r 9,201 Tr veesfld aNoi ofRe uay 6, a lr ie tce movalpurua t 28U. C.j 1 s nt o S. 441 ba e on di r iy ofciie hi Se D. 1 I t Notc Tr velr ar d t twhie bot sd ve st tz ns p. e E. . n he ie, a e s gue ha l h W iki a Br t n nd own & Br own a e Fl i c por tons Br r orda or a i , own & Br own' ciiens p çs s tz hi t i irlva tf rte p r s o dv riyj rs ito b c us Br wn & Br wn wa fa d ln l ree n o h upo e f ie st u idcin e a e o o s ru u e t y j ie a ad fn a t' D. 1a !5.Th n x d y Trvee sfldaM oi nt DimisBr wn on d s ee d n . E. t ' e e t a , a lr i e to o s s o & Br own,ar ui t tFl i 1w r r dimis lof Br g ng ha orda a equies s s a own & Br own whie t cove a l he r ge diput a ns Tr ve er i pe ng. See D . 4. W iki s e nty f l d a M o i t Re a s e gai t a l s s ndi E. t n ubs que l ie ton o m nd on M a c 8,201 a g ng t tTr ve e s c nnotde ons r t t tt r i dno pos i lt ... ha rh 6, r ui ha a l r n m t a e ha he e s s s biiy t t a va i c us ofa i n ca be pl d' a i tBr ld a e cto n e ' ga ns own & Br own unde Fl i l w . l a 2. r or da a d t Fi l aspa tofis Re pons t Tr vel r 'M oton t D i m i s Br naly, r t s e o a es i o s s own & Br n,W iki ow tn pr ed a lte da e Fe ua y 26,20l t tpur t t t e ilz 'a si a i bewe n oduc e tr t d br r 6 ha pored o t mora ie' tpulton t e m W i na Br wn & Br wn t sa tep o e d n sa an tBrwn & Br wnp n ig aj dca t nd o ki o o ty h r c e i g g is o o e dn u iil de e na i of t W iki Tr ve er c t nni ton he t n- a l s over ge diput D . 7- . The l te sa e t t t a s e. E. 1 e t r t t s ha he a e me wa ra d td i J nuay a Febr r 201 'a t ttg utf rt rmova of gre nt s e che surng a r nd uay 65 nd ha dbj o he e l t c e, heat che Agr e Or rwoul ha bee fl d i t sat c ta ton. 1 he as t ta d e d de d ve n ie n he t e our c i ' d. ' I. l D I U SSI N SC O a. W iki s M ot on to R em and t n' i The Cour w ilfr tde w ih W iki s M o i t Re a bec us i i ve t Co ts t l i s al t t n' ton o m nd a e t nvol s he ur ' s be tmatr u idcin, rt Co r' t o rt h a ac s . Untd Satsv Cot n 5 5 u j c- te j rs it o he u ts s we o e r a e' ie t e . to , 3 o p ' U. 6 ,6 0 ( 0 2 . Th ba i sau o y g a t o fd r lc u ts b e tmatr u idcin ae S. 25 3 2 0 ) e sc ttt r rns f e e a- o r u j c- te j rs it r o c nan d i 2 U.. j 1 31 a d 1 3 . S cin 1 31 p o i e f r çte ea-ueto ' o ti e n 8 SC. j 3 n 3 2 e to 3 r v d s o 'l d rlq sin' l j rs ito ,j 1 3 f rt d iest o ct e s i'j rs cin A fd r l o r h s( i ri o u idcin 3 2 o d lv ri f iz n hp'u idito . e ea c u t a k vest f g y i d y ctz ns i'j rs ito wh n t ee i c mp ee d v ri o ctz n hi a n tepa t sa d iie hp' u idcin e h r s o lt i est f iie s p mo g h ri n y e tepli ifp e e t acam ta e c e st rq ie j rs ito a a u t c re ty $ 50 0 h ant rs n s li h t x e d he e ur d u id ci n l mo n , u rn l 7 ,0 . f Se 28U. C.j1 e S. 332. The b r e o e tbihng f d rlj rs ito f lso te p ry wh i atmpi t u d n f sa ls i e ea u idcin al n h a t o s te t o ng iv k t ej rs it n o tefd r lc u t M c t v Ge .Moo sAc e a eCop. 2 8 U.. n o e h u idci f h e ea o r. Nut . n tr cptnc r , 9 S o 1 1 ( 936 . Courss d srcl c tuet r uie nt of28U. C.j1 (e 78, 89 1 ) t houl tity onsr he eq rme s S. 441 rmova l j rs ito )a d rma d alc s si whc s c j rs ito i d ubf l Sh mr c Oi d Ga u idcin n e n 1 a e n ih u h u idcin s o tu. a o k l r s Cop.v She t 31 U. 1 1 ( 941.M orove ,rmova sautsar c tuednarowl r . es, 3 S. 00, 09 1 ) e r e l tt e e onsr r y, a whe t pli ifanddefnda ca hont is ofj iditon,uncet nte a er ol d nd n he antf e nt ls he sue urs ci rai is r es ve i fvorofr nd. Bur s v Wi orI s Co. 31F. 1 na ema n . nds n . , 3d 092,1 ( 1h Ci.1 ;s e alo 095 1 t r 994) e s Klmpnerv Norhwe tr Mut L# I s Co. 1 F.Supp. 1 1 ( D. a.2001 ($ e . t se n ual n . , 96 2d 233, 237 S. Fl )t A p e u to i fv ro rma d i ne e sr b c u ei af d rlc u t e c st meiso () r s mp in n a o f e n s c say e a s f e ea o r r a he he rt f a pe dn mo ini armo dc s wh r s b e tmatr u idcinma b lc n i d p i e a n ig to n e ve a e ee u j c te j rs ito y e a kig t e rv s saeco tofisrg unde t Consiui t rs vec r se i isownc t.l tt ur t iht r he ttton o e ol ontoveris n t ours' . ' $An ac i fl d i s a e cour t t i r m ove t f r co t ba ed on di r iy ç ton ie n t t t ha s e d o ede al ur s ve s t j iditon û tbe r ma d t sae c ti t r i notc ee di riy bewe n t urs ci mus e nde o tt our f hee s omplt ve st t e he pa tes o one oft def nda si a ctze oft sa e i whih t s ti fl '' Shannon v ri , r he e nt s ii n he t t n c he ui s ied.' . Al reliFim,P. ,61 F.App' 86 870( 1h Ci.2015 ( i Stlwelv Alsat I . be t l r C. 0 x 6, 1t r ) quotng il l . lt e ns Co,663F. 1 1 ( t Ci.2011) . 3d 329, 332 11h r ).Complt di riy rquie t i pli ifi a ee vest e rs hat f antf s no ctz n oft s m e sae asa def nt' Tr aglo v Am.Ex e s Co. 735 F. 1 iie he n tt ny enda . av i . ' pr s , 3d 266,1 268 ( 1h Ci.201 . The ei no diput t tc eedi st i l ki i t sc e unls t 1 t r 3) r s s e ha omplt veriy s ac ng n hi as e s he c tz ns p ofBr n & Br w n i di r r d. ii e hi ow o s s ega de Tr ve er , how e r a g s t t Br w n & Br n' c tze hi s d be dir ga de a l s ve , r ue ha o ow s ii ns p houl se r d u d rt d crn o çr u ue tj id r' F a d ln j ide ûsaj dcal c e td d crn n e he o tie f k a d ln on e . r u u e t on r d u iily rae o tie f ' i t t pr vi s a e pton t t r r m e of c pl t di r iy. Tri v John Cr mp ha o de n xce i o he equie nt om e e ve s t ' ' ggs . u To a I . 1 F.d 1 4,1 ( 1h Ci.1 ;se alo Stlwel 663 F. a 133 To yot, nc, 54 3 28 287 1 t r 998) e s il l, 3d t 2. e tb ih fa d ln j id r o a n n dv re d fnd n,t e r mo n pat mu t s tsy a sa ls ru u e t on e f o - ie s ee a t h e vig ry s aif t a 'bur n of pr ng by ce r a c ncng e de e t t eihe $ 1 t r i no s vy' de he ovi la nd onvi i vi nc ha t r 1 ) he e s 4 p siiiy tepan ifc ne tb ih a c u eo a to a ans ter sd n d fnd n ; r()te o sb l h litf a sa ls a s f cin g i t h e ie t ee a t o 2 h t panifh sfa due typ e j rs ito a fcst b igtersd n d fn a tnt saec r. li t a r u ln l ld u idcin l a t o rn h e ie t e e d n i o tt ou t' f ' Stlwe l 663 F. a 1 il l, 3d t 332. Tr vel r as e t t t W iki c r otpos i y s a e a c us of a to a e s s r s ha t n am s bl t t a e ci n a ns Br gai t own & Br n bec us Coun s I l a I a e pr m at e a t r or m us be ow a e t 1 nd V r e ur nd he ef e t di m i s d. s se Unde Fl rda l w,cai sagans an i ur nc a ntf f ii t pr ur c r do r oi a l m i t ns a e ge or a lng o oc e ove age notac r e untlt unde l ng ac i be we n t i ur d a t i ur nc c pa r ga di cu i he ryi ton t e he ns e nd he ns a e om ny e r ng c v rg h sb e r s l d.Se Blmb r v AA Ca . n .Co , 9 So 2 1 61 1 6 ( a o ea e a e n e ove e u e g .US s I s . 7 0 . d 0 , 0 5 Fl. 2001 (tW ) hol t t i t cic tnc pr e e hee,aneglgenc / prci c us of ) tg e d ha ,n he rumsa es es ntd r i emal a tce a e a ton a c ue whe t clen i ur dn a a t c l i of t r l t or u ryi ci c r s n he i t nc s m ges t he onc uson he e aed nde l ng ' J dca p o e dng .) Thsme n ta W i i scamsa an tBr wn & Br wnaec n ig n u iil r c e i s' . i a s h t t n' li g is o ' k o r o tn e t a pr m a ur ,as Br n & Br nd e t e ow own' la lt f r f iur t pr ur be om esan i s onl upon a s i biiy o a l e o oc e c s ue y fna de e m i ton t tno i ur nc co r ge e s sunde t polcy is by Tr l r . l,f i l t r na i ha ns a e ve a xit r he i s ued ave e s f or e m pl , t Cour fnds t t Tr vel r i la e t W iki u r t polc t n Br n & xn e he ti ha a e s s i bl o t n nde he i y, he ow Br own pr ry pr ur t i ur ncepolc a di notda a W iki On t o he ha i ope l oc ed he ns a iy nd d m ge t n. he t r nd, f t Cour de er i t t Tr l r i not la e t W iki unde t polcy, t Br n & he t t m nes ha ave e s s i bl o t n r he i hen ow Br own i potnta l la ef f ii t pr ur a qua ei ur nc c r s e ily ibl or a lng o oc e de t ns a e ove age. l is f lngs W iki doe not dipu e t t is c ai s aga ns Br n & Br n t ii , t n s s t ha t l m i t ow own a e r pr t e. I t a W iki a guest tt a oprae r emaur nse d, t n r ha he ppr i t emedy f pr m aur c am sagans a or e t e l i i tn i ur nc a nt i no dim i s l but ta a t m e or s a ' D . 7 a 5. l Bl be g,t ns a e ge s t s s a , l n ba e nt t y. ' E. t n um r he Fl i Supr e Cour di s a e t t d he de e e c m ove f a a t e or s a ' i or da em t d t t ha t t f ns an or n ba em nt t y' n cr um sa es whe t f iur t pr ur cli s ha not ye ac ue 790 So.2d a 1 ic t nc n he a l e o oc e am ve t cr d. t 065 ( empha i a d) Buts eque c s s ha cl ry esa ihe t tt pr rr medy f ss dde . ubs nt a e ve eal tbls d ha he ope e or pr m aur cli sagans a i ur nceage i dimi s l Forsa tr ,i i wel- t bls t t e t e am i t n ns a nt s s s a . tre s t s lesa ihed ha w he t pr a ur el m e ofa c n he em t e e nt ountf ilnotbe c e by t pa s oftm e' whi h i t s l w ur d he s age i ' c s he c s he e - di m i s i t a o i t r m edy. Se W e l Far I . Se v . US l . v a e r - - s s al s he ppr pra e e e ls go ns r s A, nc . Bl k he ,136So.3d 1 1 ( a2dDCA 201 ( di t tt a opraerme f ac s ar 235, 239 Fl 4) hol ng ha he ppr it e dy or pl i if s pr m a ur neglge m i r pr e a i cl m a ns hi i ur nc ag a ntf e t e i nt s e es nt ton ai gai t s ns a e ent v as v dimis l; hu kv Ba ko ,NA.8 2 S 2 2 , 5 ( l. d DCA 2 0 )( o igt t e s sa) S c . n fAm. , 6 o. d 0 2 F a 2 0 3 n tn ha wh n a a ton i ç e aur be us one ofis e s ntale e n c i s s m t e ca e pr t s e i l ment i c i ntupon t oc ure e s s ontnge he c r nc of a e nt t t m a or m a not occ ' a t he m e e pas age of tm e w il not c e t n ve ha y y ur' nd t t r s i l ur he p e t r ee n o te cam, t e d s sa wih u prj ie rt rt a a ae n ,i rmau e lme t f h li ' h n imis l t o t eudc , ahe h n b tme t s ' a oprae . And unde amos i ntc lcic tnce ,t te i t sDititha bee t ppr it) r l t de ia rumsa s he rnd n hi src s n o ds s tep e tr camsa ans i u a ea e t wi u p eu ie S eEv n tnl s Co imis h rmau e li g i t ns rnc g n s t t rj d c . e a so n . . ho v Prc z mos LLC,No. 1 1 77- V- ARTl . iexi , 3-41 Cl M NEZ,D. 86 a *4-5 ( D.Fl.J 11 E. t S. a une , 201 ( di t tt cai agans t i ur nc a nt S r bot prmaur 'a t ontnge 5) hol ng ha he l ms i t he ns a e ge s ç e h e t e' nd d i nt a c o t e o to oft e gn e lig ltg to ' a d dimisn t s camswih u p eu ie n h u c me h u d ryn j i ai n' n s sig ho e li i t o t rj dc be a e t d ne rrpe ';Pebb Clv an4 LLC v.Fie ' Fund I .Co. No.1 c us hey û may ve i n' l e el r man s ns , 4- 81 Cl HURLEY,201 W L 328247,a *3 ( D.Fl J n.23,2015 (a ) He nande v 496- V5 t S. a. a ) sme ; r z. lhn t l de l s Co,4 F.S p 3 1 2 , 1 2 -2 ( D.Fl.Se t 1 ,2 4 (a ) n i n m. n . . 4 y u p. d 2 0 2 3 4 S. a p . 1 01 ) sme ; l ons r I m . I . v Ban r ho e nde , nc . yon 1030- , LL C, N o. 1 61 32 2- 678- V - OK E, 201 W L Cl CO 3 47111 a * ( . . a.Aug.3 , 4)(a ll 55, t 8 S D F1 0 201 sme . W iki ar ue t t i a or nc w ih Bl be g,i ha a ee w ih Br n & Br n t t n g s ha , n cc da e t um r t d gr d t ow ow o s a is cl i s aga ns Br n & Br t y t am i t ow own pe ng r ol i of t W iki Tr ve er c r ge ndi es uton he t n- a l s ove a diput , a t t Tr ve e s notce of r m ova ha i s e nd ha a l r ' i e l s t ce s iy pr onged ltga i ' a unne s arl ol ii ton' nd i se p ry a dj dca r s u c s' D. 8 a 8 Asa i iilmatr te Co r f i t s e d td a t n u iil eo r e . E. t . wa ' n nta te , h u t al o e s h w t i alg d siulto i r lva t ot is eo wh t rW i n fa d lnl j ie Br wn o hs l e tp ain s ee n t he su f ehe t r u ue ty on d o e ki & Br own t t s l w s t e e i of r a i dem onsr t s t t W iki w a e t pr ve o hi a ui, xc pt ns a s t ta e ha t n nt d o e nt 1 The Cour no e t t t e le c es f om t s D i t i t f t t s ha wo ari r as r hi s rc ound t t r m a w a ha e nd s a po raeb c u eteewa S mbg iyi Flrd lw'rg ri wh te ge tr cams p rp it e a s h r s s iut n oia a ' e adng eh r rmaue li n a ans a i u a ea e td h ud b a tdo sa e o , ah r ds se wl u p eudc . g i t n ns rnc g n t o l e bae r ty d r r te , imis d t t rj ie' s ho ' S ri v Banne L( I s Co.No.1 22289- Vpelng . r # n. , 0C1 HUCK,201 W L 4063743,a *3( D.Fl 0 t S. a. Oc.1 201 ) s e alo Stel v M i contne Cas Co. No.07t 4, 0 ; e s e e . d- i nt . , 60789- V- ARIA,2007 Cl M t W L 3 43,a *3( D.Fl Nov.1 2007)(û t r t Cour ca s ywihcet nt t t 4585 t S. a. 4, k he ,he Fur t nnot a t rai y ha t c ai a ns FH B i ûr he l m gai t s f audul nt' gi n t f tt tFl i 1 w woul no a l di m i s l e , ve he ac ha orda a d t low s s a oft cli ' .TheCour fnds howe ,t ts e ntcaesfom t sditita eswhee he am.) ' ti , ver ha ubs que s r hi src nd le r ha r s ved t s ç m bi t i Fl i l 'i f vor ofdim i s l ve e ol hi s guiy n or da aw' n a n s sa. 6 Trv lr fo rmo ig t i c s t fd r lc u t M oe v r o e c u th sara y rj ce a ees r m e vn h s a e o e e a o r. r o e , n o r a le d ee td sm ia a gum en s a i lr r t boutt r e nc ofa s i a i t s a pr m a ur c ai si t con e ofa he el va e tpul t on o t y e t e l m n he t xt m oto t r m a i n o e nd. See M agnola i l c v Ge .I s n . . n n. o Am. No 1 - 0 7 Cl f , . 101 5 - V- KOVACHEVI D. 28 ( . Fl.Se .9,2011 ( nyi amotont rma e t ug CH, E. M D. a pt ) de ng i o e nd ven ho h t pli ifa i ur nce ag ntha a ee t a t t rdiput prort t i ur rsr m ova he a ntf nd ns a e d gr d o ba e hei s e i o he ns e ' e l o te a to t fd rlc u t. Fial,p bi p iy a d j dca e o o c n en a tal f h cin o e e a o r) n ly u lc ol n u iil c n my o c r s cu l c y fvo dim is i tad of an a t nt o sa See I ons e 201 W L 47111 a *8 a r s s al nse baeme r ty. r hor , 3 55, t CAd iin ly j diile o o fv r t e d s sa o t e e cams Pate s ul n tb s dto al, u ca c n my a o s h imis l f h s li . ris ho d o e e our ge t fl c ai st tm a ne r rpe Fii t s cl m s f ce t i ur nc a ntt nc a d o ie l m ha y ve i n. lng he e ai or s he ns a e ge o fl a r pons a pr ie es e nd ompt t pa tes t ltgae wha i t a opra e r m e pe ng s he ri o ii t t s he ppr it e dy ndi aj dc to o t eu d ryn a to .Th si awa t o tec u tsa tep ris rs u c s' . du iain f h n e lig cin i s se f h o r' nd h a t ' e o re .) e ' Th Co r te eo e tn st a W ikn h s fa d lnl j ie Br wn & Br wn t te e u t h rf r i d h t t i a ru u e ty on d o o oh i t ntc e be aus Count 1 l a I a e pr m at e a bec us t over ns a as c e s I nd V r e ur nd a e he whel i w e ghtof m ng i a t iy f vor dim i s l ove a a t m ent or s a of t e cl i s A c or ngl t Cour u hort a s s s a r n ba e ty hos a m . c di y, he t dir r Br n & Br n' c tze hi a f nds t t t r m ai ng pa tes W iki a s ega ds ow ow s ii ns p nd i ha he e ni ri t n nd Tr veer- a ec a l s r omplt l di r e.W iki sM oton t Re a i m us t e or beDENI e ey ve s t n' i o m nd s t her f e ED. b. Tr er 'M oton t D i m i sB r w n & Bro n avel s i o s s o w Th Co r h s d n e W i i sM oi n t Re n o te ba i o fa d e tj id r e u t a e id t n' to o ma d n h ss f ru uln on e . k C AIfn i o fa d ln j i e b asa i lctfn ig ta t ep an ifh sfi dt saea S idng f r u ue t ond r e r n mp ii i dn h t h litf a al o tt E e c u eo a to a an t h fa d ln l j ie d fn a t' Poy a tc, n . .T a s o x I c, a s f cin g is t e r u ue ty on d e e d n . lplsis I c v r n c ne, n . ' 71 F. 875,777( s Ci.1 3) s aloCar ir v Sear,Roe ckand Co.893F. 98 1 3 2d 1t r 98 ; ee s re e . s bu , 2d , 02 ( h Ci.1 5t r 990) Cf c e we have ar a c uded t t (he non- v s dee nt was Be aus le dy oncl ha t diere fnda j fa d lnl j ie ,wen e no c n ie a p la tsag me to t i pon f rh r S mmay ru u e ty on d e d t o sd r p eln ' r u n n hs it u te . u r j d me twi awa sbea p o it i fv ro ad fn n a an twh m te ei n p si ly ug n l l y l p r prae n a o f ee da t g i s o h r s o o sbit i ofr c r ') Asar ul,Tr l s M otont DimisBr & Br mus beGRANTED. e ovey. . ' es t aveer' i o s s own own t 11 1. CO N C LU SI N O Forf e ng r as ,i i or goi e ons t s ADJUDGED t tPli ifW iki De i Gr l ' M oton t Re nd ( E.8 i ha antf t n sgn oup, nc.s i o ma D. ) s DEN I a t t Def nda Tr vel r Pr ry Ca ua t Com pa of Am e i a' M o i t ED nd ha e nt a e s ope t s ly ny r c s ton o DimisDe e ntBr & Br ofFl i ,I ( E.4)i GRANTED. Acc di l i i s s f nda own own orda nc. D. s or ngy,t s f r he ut r ADJUDGED t Pl i ifW iki Desgn Gr up,l ' cli sa ns De e ntBr hat antf t n i o nc.s am gai t f nda own & Br wno Flrda l c ( u t 1I-l aeDI I ED wih u p eu ie o f o i , n .Co n s 1 V) r SM SS t o t rj dc . D ON E AN D ORD ERED i Cha be sa M i m i Fl i ,t s n m r t a , or da hi Z ofA prl201 i 6. FED ERI C . OREN O UN I TE TA TES D I STR I J G E CT UD Copi s f r s t e u ni hed o: Couns lofRec d e or 8
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
