Promenade Plaza Partnership v. Centimark Corporation, No. 1:2014cv22784 - Document 59 (S.D. Fla. 2015)
Court Description: ORDER Denying Cross Motions for Summary Judgment. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 3/25/2015. (jw)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Promenade Plaza Partnership v. Centimark Corporation Doc. 59 UNI TED STATES DI STRICT CO URT SO UTH ERN DI STRICT O F FLO RI DA CASE NO .1 c 22784-11 4- v1 NG THE PROM ENADE PLAZA PARTNERSHI P, a Fl i pa t r hi orda rne s p, Pl ntf, ai if CENTI ARK CORP. a f egn cor aton, NI , or i por i Def nda . e nt / QRDER DENYI CRO SSS OTI NS FO R SVM M ARY JVD G M ENT NG M O THI CAUSE c me beo e t Co r up n c o sm oins f rs S o s f r he u t o r s- to o umma y j g n : r ud me t De e da tCe tmak' M o in f rS fn n n i r s to o umm ay J g n ( 3 )a Plitf Pr me a e s r ud me t DE 8 nd an if o n d ' M o in f rPa ta S to o ril umma y J g n ( 4 ) The moi nsa' f l b if d Thi a to r ud me t DE 0 . to l ul ree . s cin e y co e ns a r s t t tCe i a k i t led ove Pr e de' s ppi ce e i 2005 nc r oof ysem ha ntm r ns a l r om na s ho ng nt r n a 2006. The pa i ' a ee ent t i t l t r nd rtes gr m o nsa l he oof s t i ude a contac da e ysem ncl s r t td De m be 1 2005,a aw a r nt da e Aprl6, ce r 5, nd ra y t d i 2006. Pr omenade br ought t s ac i f dam a hi ton or ges a lgi va i le ng rous def t i t r ec s n he oof s t m t t wer i oxi a el ca e by t i ope c tuc i and/ f l e of t yse ha e l pr m t y us d he mpr r onsr ton or aiur he RoofSyse s'ort us ofi pr rm a e i l durng i t l to Pr e t m ' he e m ope t ra s i nsala i n. om nade a s c e l o ont nds t tc t i r par Ce i k pe f m e i 201 ha ca ed or c rbut t ce ti r ha eran e is ntmar r or d n 2 ve us onti ed o ra n oof dee t .Th p ris c o smoi ns fr s mma y j gme a d e s t e nar w is s fc s e a te ' r s - to o u r ud nt d r s hr e ro sue : ( )whih saelw a le ,a d e s q n l whih l tto p ro g ve sPr me d ' 1 c tt a pp is n on e ue ty c i ai ns e i d o m o na es mi cams ( )wh t r Pr me d s cams ae tme bar d u e t g v r n l iain li ; 2 ehe o na e' li r i - re nd r he o e nig i t to s m Dockets.Justia.com p ro a d ( )wh t r Pr me a e s po e ta d ma e a e lmie b t Ap i 20 6 e id; n 3 ehe o n d ' tn il a g s r i t d y he rl 0 W a r y.Upon c i r i of t pa tes' c os - otons a w ih t be ft of or rant onsde aton he ri r sm i , nd t he ne al t udest tt c os - i s d be de ed. ha he r s motons houl ni a gum e , t e cour concl r nt 1 h L St nda d o M o i n f S mar Judz nt a r n to or um v me S mmay j g n i a pr p it whe e t e pla n a s pp rig mae il u r ud me t s p o rae r h e digs nd u o tn tras e t ih t tt r i no ge ne i s a t any mat ralf tand t tt m ovi pa t i sabls ha he e s nui s ue s o e i ac ha he ng ry s e tte t j d n a amatroflw. eFe R. v. 5 ;Ceotx Cor v Catet 47 n ild o u gme t s te a Se d. Ci P. 6 l e p. . r t, 7 U. 31 ,3 2 ( 9 6 .A f c i i tra' i i i ma d t r ne t e o t o u de te S. 7 2 1 8 ) a t s v e il f t s y ee mi h u c me n r h ma ' a pl a e s sa tvelw. de s n v Li e t Lob y I c,47 U. 2 2,2 ( 98 ) The p i bl ub tn i a An r o . b ry b , n . 7 S. 4 48 1 6 . c nonm ovi pa t m us s ng ry t how s fc f ct t s pecii a s o uppor t tt e i a ge ne di put 1 a t ha her s nui s e. d. t 2 6. amo in f rs mmayj g n ,t c u tmus viw t e d n e a d r s l a 1 5 On to o u r ud me t he o r t e he vie c n e ove 1 i er nc i t lghtm os f a e t t nonmovi pa t f a 255.I r e ng t nf e es n he i t avor bl o he ng ry. #, t n evi wi he r c r e d nc ,heCo tma no u e tk t j r sf ncin of ihi t e d n eo e o d vie e t ur y t nd ra e he u y' u to weg ng he vie c r unde t ng cr biiy det m i i .Latme v.Roarng To ,I ,601 F. 1 raki edi lt er natons i r i yz nc. 3d 224,1 237 ( 1h Ci. 01 ) 1 t r2 0 . Ez W hih La Go e ns Fl rdaorPe v v ni ? c w v r - oi nns l a a The pa tesdia e ove whi h l w gove nsPr ri s gr e r c a r omenade' cl m s Pr e de a gues s ai . om na r t t Fl i l w gove ns be us Doc e A205,whi h i pa tof t Contac ,s ys i ha orda a r , ca e um nt c s r he r t a t do s ûf e Co ta ts l bego e n d by t 1w oft plc whe et p o e ti l c td e : l' n r c hal -h v re he a he a e r he r j c s o ae g..Fl rd l'DE 4 1 a 4. n i r a g e t a Pe s l a i lw g vens be a et i , oia. e ' 4- , t Ce tma k r u s h t nn y v na a o r , c us he Aprl 2006 W a r nt s ys i doe S-hi W a r nt i i s i ra y a t s: i s r r a y s s ued a t Com or e ofi s of t he at fce 1TheCour he r a oxi a el one hourofor ar e on M ar l 5 201 5 a t Ja es t a d ppr m t y al gum nt ch 7 5 t he m La e Ki Feder J tceBuidi a Unie St t Courhous M i m i Fl i wr nce ng al us i l ng nd t d a es t e, a , orda. Ce i a k Cor a i i Ca ntm r por ton n nons g, Pe yl ni , a a or ngl i gover bur nns va a nd cc di y s ned by Penns va a lw . DE 38-1 A s mpl copy oft Aprl2006 W a r y i i or a e i o yl ni a ' ' . a e he i r ant s nc por t d nt t Conta ,a t pa tescont he r ct nd he ri emplt isf ur is nc a ed t ut e s ua e. Fl rda' c ce of lw r esde er i whe herFl i orPenns va a l w a i . o i s hoi - -a ul t m ne t orda yl ni a pples Am. Fami fteAs u an e Co o u u ,Ga v U.. r Co,8 5F.d 8 6,8 0 ( 1h l ' ' s r c . fcolmb s . . S Fie . 8 2 2 3 1 t y / Ci.1 8 ) Aso Co ti t e So t e n Ditito Flrd r c n l r c gnz d,i a c s r 9 9 . ne ur n h u h r src f o ia e e ty e o ie n a e i vi Ce i k a sm ia contac ua pr s ons t e i a ditnc i be w e n cl m s nvol ng ntmar nd i l r r t l ovii , her s s i ton t e ai b o h u e t Conr c a t os br u t s ll u de t W a rnt Dr t od r ug t nd r he ta t nd h e o gh o ey n r he ra y. f wo Hos t i M gmt,LLC v. Ce i ar Cor ,N o. 1 c 61 pialt y . ntm k p. 4- v- 802,201 W L 4825274,a *2 4 t s a ng hi he ur c ncu e ha he wo ( D. a Se t 2 2 4 ( o m , .. Under t ndi t s, t Co t o l d st tt t S. Fl . p . 5, 01 ) Blo J)2 c c of lw pr sons do not c lc .By t i e e s t r s t Fl i c c of l hoie- -a ovi i onfi t her xpr s e m , he orda hoie- -aw p o ii n i t e Co ta t g v r tth Co r c, a d t e Pems va a c ie o -a r v so n h nr c o e ns s l e nta t' n h r yl ni ho c - flw g ' pr v so i t Aprl 0 W a rnt g ven ith sW ar ny. o ii n n he i 20 6 ra y o r s û j i ra t ' g ' The Cour' concl i a ts uson bout whih 1w gover Pr enade' c ai s de e m i c a ns om s lm t r nes whi h lm ia i ofac i pr son gove ns Pr enade' cl m s The contacualone ye r c i t ton- - ton ovi i r om s ai ' . r t - a lm ia i ofac i pr s on i t Aprl2006 W a r nt gove nsc ai st ta i e undert i t ton- - ton ovii n he i ra y r l m ha rs he Wa nunt r ng i r t da e t ta def c i m a eral orwor a hi or ot rbr ac y, unni i om he t ha f et n t i s km ns p, he e h or a o her cli i dicover or r ona y s d ha bee dicover ' D E 38-1 ny t am s s ed eas bl houl ve n s ed.' . Fl i s f - rs a ut oflm iai govel el m st ta ie unde t Contad,r ng orda' ouryea t t e i t ton ' ai ha r s ns r he r unni 2 The Dr woo o i i n a d e s d c c - fv n p o so r t e t n c oieoflw ft d p n o d r s e hoie o - e ue r viins ah r ha h c - -a pr s ons ovii . fo bh tme t e gae t d f c i d s ov r d o s u d ha e be n d s o e e wih t r m l e i h ltn l e e t s ic ee r ho l v e ic v r d t he t e e cs ofd d lg n e'Fl. a . 5. 13 ()3 x r ie ue ii e c . a Stt 9 1 ( )c . ' 1 TheLi t to o - me e Pr v so i t Aprl2 06W a r v mia in- fRe dis o iin n he i 0 r ant As m or f l e ai d i Pa t 11 be ow, t Cour cam ot concude t t e uly xpl ne n r 1 , l he t l l ha Pr omena scl i sne s arl a ie unde et t Contac ort Aprl2006 W arant as de' am ce s iy r s r iher he r t he i r y a ma t r of f t Centm a k neve t l s a gues t t Pr te ac . i r rhees r ha omenade' cl m s nec s rl a ie s ai es a iy rs unde t Aprl2006 W a r y asam at rofl r he i rant te aw. The Aprl2006 W a r nt by is e es t r s c r onl tlaks r uli f om i r a y, t xpr s e m , ove s y ûe es tng r d fcs i t mae il o wo k ns p i t e r of s r c s ( evie ) pe f r d b e e t n he tras r r ma hi n h o evie s r c s ro me y CentM a k.'DE 38-1 Thi Sl ks'W a r nt m us be r d as a lm iaton on t Conta t s i r ' . s iea ' r a y t ea i ti he rc' gene alwa r nt ofm a e i sa wor a hi r ra y t ral nd km ns p: The Co ta t r wa rn s t t Owne a d Ar hie tt t ( ) ma e il a nr co ra t o he r n c tc ha : 1 tras nd eq pm entf nihed unde t Conta tw ilbe new a ofgood qualt unl s ui ur s r he rc l nd iy e s ohewierqur d o p nni e b t eCo ta tDo ume t;( t e W o k wil t r s e ie r e t d y h nr c c n s 2) h t r l be fee fom def t no i r i t qualt r r or pe m it a r r ec s t nhe ent n he iy equied r ted; nd ( )t eW o kwil o f r t t r q r me t ofteCo ta tDo u nt. 3 h r l c n o m o he e uie n s h n rc c me s DE 44-1 a 2.Tha i,t t e e Pr e ,t t s o he xt nt om nade s ks t r cover f kl ks r uli fom ee o e or lea es tng r d fcs i t e mae i l o wo k n hi i t r o sr i e (e v c s p ro me b ee t n h tras r r ma s p n he o f e v c s s r ie ) e f r d y Ce i ak'Pr nade' r ovey i lmie by t t msoft tl ks'W a rnt ntM r ' ome s ec r s i td he er he lea ' ra y. 3Alhough t one- rlm ia i ofa ton pr s on i t Apr l2006 W arant a i st t he yea i t ton- - c i ovii n he i r y pple o ta c am s' t lm iaton i voi underFl i l w,Fl St .95. a t r f e ca dny l i ,' he i t i s d orda a a. at 03, nd he e or nnot gove' Pr e de' cl m s a ii unde t Contac . The one ye lm ia i i l n om na s ai r sng r he r t - ar i t ton s pemisbl u de Pe ns va alw, Pa Co . t t j5 01a , n e o c a ei Fl rda r s i e n r n yl ni a 42 . ns S a . 5 () a d nf r e bl n o i cou t ast Pr e rs o om nade' cl m sa ii unde t Aprl2006 W a r nt M az oniFar ,I s ai r sng r he i r a y. z ms nc. v E1 Du tDeNe r & Co. 761So. d 3 6 ( a 2 0 ;Bu r u s Co p.v Su tgs . . pon mou s , 2 0 Fl . 0 0) r o gh r . n o o amiI c, 7 So 2d 1 6 ( a 1 85 . fMi , n v4 2 . 1 6 F1, 9 ) Centm a k neverhel s a gues t tPr m enade' onl a iabl c es ofac i a e i r t es r ha o s y va l e aus ton r t e cove e by t fl ks' W a r nt due t t ll ks' W a r nt s i hos rd he iea ' r a y, o he iea ' r a y' ' usviy of Excl i t W a r nt and Li t i ofRe edi 'pr son: ra y miaton m es' ovi i CEN TI A RK EX PRESSLY DI M SCLA I S A LL EX PRESS OR I PLI M M ED W ARRAN TI I CLU DI G THE W ARRAN TI O F M ERCHAN TA BI TY ES N N ES LI AN D FI ESS FOR A PA RTI TN CULAR PURPO SE OR AN Y OTHER I PLI M ED W ARRAN TY .THI EX PRESS LI I S M TED W ARRANTY CON TA I THE SO LE NS AN D EXCLUSI W A RRAN TY AN D REM ED Y OF PURCHA SER AGA I ST VE N CEN TI ARK . THERE I N O EX PRESS W ARRAN TY OTH ER THAN THAT M S STATED I TH I W AR RAN TY. N S DE 3 - . eCo tc n l e t a t sp o iin mus b r a a r ltn o y t t s j c 8 1 Th ur o cud s h t hi r v so t e e d s e aig nl o he ub e t m at r of t i e ' W a r nt Fis, t t e ent t s pr son ca be r d t lmi te he i aks' r a y. rt o he xt l hi ovi i n ea o i t Pr e de' ava l e l r lefagai tCentm a k t ac i f il ,'r r e sofa om na s iabl egal e i ns i r o tons or seaks' ega dl s ny c n eva l b e c o o h rwr n o n r ltn t t epa te 'Co ta t( ih i go e n d o c i b e r a h r t e o gd i g eai g o h ri s nr c wh c s v r e b Flrd lw) t e Co r fnd t e lmiai t b un e s n bl S e Oc a Du e o y o ia a , h u t i s h i tton o e r a o a e. e e n n s f Huc is I ln De .Cor v Co a geo 46 S 2 43 ,4 ( a 4h DCA 1 5 th n on sa d v p. . l n l , 3 o. d 7 39 F1. t 98 ) ( s c c n r cu l p o ii n .. mu t b r a o a e t be e o c d' . Se o d, t e i u h o ta t a r vso s . s e e s n bl o i nf r e .) c n h ' pr son mus be r ad t he wih a lt pr son i t il ks' W a r y: i-hi ovi i t e oget r t a er ovii n he vea ' rant d- s l W a r nt Agr m e i unde sood t be t compl e a e usve war a y a ee ent ra y ee nt s rt o he et nd xcl i r nt gr m bew e n t Pur e a Ce i a k, s s ng al pror a ee ent ,whet r or or t e he chas r nd ntM r uper edi l i gr m s he al wrte a d a1ohe c mmu c to sbewe n t pa t sr l tng t t s j c ma t ro itn, n l t r o niai n t e he ri e a i o he ub e t te f e t sW a r nt ' DE 38 1 ( mph ss a e .Th Co r h dst a Pr me d sa albl hi r a y. ' - e a i dd d) e u t ol h t o na e' v ia e l galr i a i t Centm a k i lm ie t a i unde t ç e ks ' W a r y onl t t e elef ga ns i r s i t d o ctons r he i a ' l r ant y o he e e t t s h lga r i r l t s t iea r uli fom def t i t m a e i s o xt nt ha uc e l elef e a e o l ks es tng r l ec s n he t ral r wo k ns p i t er fs r ie ( evie )p ro me byCe tM ak. r ma hi n h oo e v c s s r c s e f r d ni r ' ' 11 1. H ast St ut ofL i iat ons E xpi e on Pl nt f C l m s he at e m t i rd ai i rs ai ? The Co t ha c ude t t Fl i s f - a sat e of lm iatons gove ns ur s oncl d ha orda' ourye r t ut i ti r Pr e de' c a ms arsng unde t Conta ,a t tt contac ualone ye r lm ia i om na s l i ii r he r ct nd ha he r t - a i ttonofac i pr son gove ns Pr e de' c am s a ii unde t il ks'W ar a y.Thr e - ton ovii r om na s l i rsng r he kea ' r nt e q e ton t e f lw:( )wh c o P o n d ' cam sa ie u de t e Co ta t ( )whih u si s h n ol o 1 ih f r me a e s li rs n r h n r c ; 2 c o t m a ieu de t eie k 'W ar ny;a d ( )aet ytm eba -d? f he rs n r h i a s' ra t n 3 r he i - ne l l te i tn c o smo insf rs mma yj g n ,a d a o a ag n ,t pa t s n h nsa t r s - to o u r ud me t n t r l r ume t he ri e f e e usve y on t i s ofm oit e i t r s t .The m o i do notaddr s ocus d xcl i l he s ue sur n he oof ysem tons es ot ralega i i Pl i if sCom pl ntt tar notpa e l r a ed t m oit e i t r he l tons n antf ai ha e t nty elt o sur n he oof s t m , i udi t f l ng: k oduc f l e a l sope a e wih expos d yse ncl ng he olowi i pr t aiur t ow l d r as t e fbegls/ o y se r i o c me ' ithe r o d e no h v T-on c v r wh c a e i r a sp l e tr enf r e nt; s l o f o s t a e j it o e s ih r ' g n e e a mulil ly ritr e to st p e e r fla ' S imp o e so i o te r of e d d t tp e a e n e s ci n o r v nt oo e ks' l l r p r l png f h o ;g s t '; a S r r t t Roof Sysem Conta t' Ce i k i t led a i e i , ysem ' nd k conta y o he t r c ,' ntmar ns a l n nf ror de e i a i pr t ror tng oductc l d Ver i o r t rt n a contaced- orpr ale s c a he ha r t f oduc cale Ca lse.Se t l d ril e DE 1,at8 -9. As t t s ale i ,Centm a k has not s o he e l gatons i r hown t tt a ie unde t ha hey rs r he ll ks'W a iea ' nunt Thes alega i a e smpl unaddr s d i t i t cr s m otons y. e l tons r i y es e n he nsant os - i ( b i d sus e b t epa t s c mp tnge e t, os r po t a ei t r c r ) alet ic s d y h ri ' o ei xp rs wh e e rs r n he e o d . e As f t alega i r l i t m oit e i t r s t m ,Ce i k does not or he l tons eatng o sur n he oof ys e ntmar ge nel diput t tû i i t la i Ce i a k r ur a wat pi t ttoode t nui y s e ha i ng nsa lton, ntM r upt ed dur er pe ha l d he Ba c k f r t r so e'DE 4 ,a 7! 8. e DE 5 ,a 2 ! 8. rh r r ,aJ nu r 20 6 d oc u niu e t r . ' 9 t Se 5 t Fu te mo e a ay 0 r fm osu es r y o d r d b Ce tma k s owst e e wa a a e o û mj it r ta pe oo it r u ve r e e y n i r h h r s n r a f k o su e r p d l be we r s t m s'e bef e Ce i k i t l d t r s t m a is i t s c e. t en oof yse ' ven or ntmar nsale he oof ys e t s ue n hi as DE 5 - ,a 4.l i as u ip e t a ith p e e e ofmo su e i a r ofs se i 5 1 t t s lo nd s utd h t l j e r s nc g it r n o y tm s comm on a eve y r has a l s s e am ount of m oit e i i.' DE 41 a 4 ! 1 nd r oof t ea t om sur n t ' ,t 6. Fi ly,i a i ce f r wor c pl t d o M a 7, 201 Ce i a k i or e Pr e de nal n n nvoi o k om e e n y 4, ntm r nf m d om na t t a uni ntsed num be of ipundur i t m e br ne.... e e due t i r c ha n de i r i es n he m a w r o ncor e t mae il us dt p t ht c r gils mplst a we et k n b Ce tmak. DE 4 1 a 3 . tras e o a c he o e sc a e h t r a e y n i r ' ' 9- , t 0 Pr m e de a s rs t t t s i ce i a adm is on by Centm a k t t i i or e l o na s e t ha hi nvoi s n si i r ha t nc r cty pe f m ed pat hwor i 201 whih ca ed orconti e t m oit e i t r s t . ror c k n 2, c us rbut d o sur n he oof ysem DE 49, a 1 Centm a k co e s t t is use of t tr ii r t m aera s' was a t 0. i r unt r ha t he e m incor ec t il' n i nnoce wa of e ani t t i f m e l us d m a era s f t m por y r r a was nt y xpl i ng ha t or ry e t i l or e ar epais nd m e el r pl i t m w ih m a e i l f per a ntr par .DE 55,a 5.I ot w or ,t r y e acng he t t r a s or m ne e is t n her ds he pa te genui l diput t m e ng oft i ce. ri s ne y s e he ani he nvoi One concl i i i s a bl :t pa te genui y diput t ca e naur a us on s ne c pa e he ri s nel s e he us , t e, nd e e oft m oit e i t r s t .On t s r r t Cour c nno co ude as a xt nt he sur n he oof ysem hi eco d, he t a t ncl , m at r oflw ,t tt m oit e pr bl snec s rl consiut ,i whol ori pa t S e . te a ha he sur o em es a iy tt e n e n r, ' aks' l ' The e or t al ge def t i t r s t r atng t m oit e a e no nec s iy r f e, he le d ec s n he oof ysem el i o sur r t es arl gove ne by t i ea ' W a r nt s one- r lm iaton- - ton pr son.I i a ca di l r d he i ks' r a y' l yea i t i ofac i ovii t s r na prnci e of i er e a i t t a conta ' t r s unl s ot r ie i c ed, a e t be i pl nt pr t ton ha r cts e m , es he w s ndi at r o co tue ac di t t r pl i a or nar mea ng, as unde sood by t ave a nsr d cor ng o hei a n nd di y ni rt he r ge p ro A gr u o a r g p r o s a tn a t f cfnd ri t f r o aj r ae i t e e s n. o p f ve a e e s n , ci g s he a ti e n he o m f u y, r n h be tposton t a y t t r il ak't Pr e de' cl m s i lghtofal oft evi ncet s ii o ppl he e m se ' o om na s ai , n i l he de o 1e a d e a til Net rp ry i e tte t j g n a a matr o 1w a t whehe n d uc d t ra. ihe a t s n ild o ud me t s te f a s o t r Pr e de' cl m s a e ba r d by t one ye r lm ia i n- - c i pr s on i t Sl a ' om na s ai r r e he - a i t to of a ton ovii n he 'e ks' ' a r nt W r a y. 7 The Cour woul be a e t fnd t tPr e t d bl o i ha om nade' c ai sar tme- r e asa m at r s l m e i ba r d te ofl onl i i f aw y f t ound t t c rai 2009 e- l s ha e t n mais how t tPr e ha om nade was on notce ofis i t cl m sbr ai oughti t i tnta ton.I t e m aiss d ha c us Pr enade t di c r n he nsa c i f he - l houl ve a ed om o s ove any a l leged r def ct t ih t e r ie of due dii nc ' hen Pr oof e s i t he xe c s w lge er 't omenade' cl m s s ai r ltn t t s d fcswo l b tmebar d.Fl. a.95 1 ( )c . n o o t e e mal, eaig o ho e e e t u d e i - re a Stt . 1 3 ( ) I ne f h - i s Pr me d ' r ofn i pe t r( uro Roo i Co p. t dPlitf a f lo : o na e s o i g ns c o M tn fng r ) ol an if s o lws t t i ul ton i we on a oxi el 40% -50% oft e ie r a ea. hat he ns a i s t ppr mat y he ntr oof r g e tmaor c tt r ofi o ea e a ba e o t fe o t er o whe e our si t ) u he o n n r a nd s d n he e l f h o f r hew ake he i as um i t tt ot ra ea a e a s w e ....Thi t l ust t l d s s ng ha he he r s r lo t s els ha eihert i ul ton gotwe durng t i t l i orwe sm pl have notye t he ns a i t i he nsalaton i y t dicover wher t wa e i ent rng t s t m . s ed e he t r s e i he ys e DE 39- I t ot r e m ai,Pr m e 9. n he he - l o nade t d Centm a k t tPr e de Sdi c e drli ol i r ha om na ' d or ilngs t tr ve e aw e r aferyou advied t r wasdr ' DE 39-1 The quesi ofwhen ha e ald t oof t s he oof y. ' 0. ton a pa t s d ha dicover a l t ntde e tw ih t e r i e ofdue dii nce i or narl ry houl ve s ed a e f c t he xe c s lge s di iy a q sin o fc f r t j y. The 1w i ta r s c i t s m e i Flrd a ue to f a t o he ur a n h t e pe t s he a n o i a nd Pe ns v na. e Ca trv Br wn & Wil o T ba c Cop. 77 So 2 93 ,9 ( a n yla i S e re . o li n o c o r , 8 . d 2 37 F1. ams 2 0 ) Amod ov Rya Ho s I . 5 A.d 1 2 1 6 ( .S r 1 ) l lg tofte 0 0; e . n me , nc, 95 2 23 , 23 Pa upe . 991 . n i h h pa tes'genui diput a t t ca e,nat e a e entoft m oit e i t r s t , ri ne s e s o he us ur , nd xt he sur n he oof ysem t Cour c udes t tr as bl pe s c d dia ee a t w he her t 2009 e- a l he t oncl ha e ona e r ons oul s gr s o t he m is s d ha ca e Pr houl ve us d omenade t dicovera a l d r def t w ih t e r ie ofdue o s ny lege oof ec s t he xe c s dlg n e Net e p ry i e tte t j d n a amatroflw a t wh t e Pr n d ' iie c . ih r a t s n ild o u gme t s te a s o e h r ome a e s cl m sa eba r by Fl i sf - a sat e oflm ia i . ai r red orda' our ye r t ut i t tons I . V A re Pl nt f D am aee Li i e bv t dt eaks 'W arrant ai i ps s m td he i u ' v? Ce i a k a guest tPr e de' pot nta da a s a e lm ied by t t l s oft ntm r r ha om na s e i l m ge r i t he e' m he kl ks'W ara y.I lghtoft Cour' de e m i i a t t lm ia i ofac i is iea ' r nt n i he ts t r naton s o he i t ton- - tons s ue, a bove,t Cour ca he t nnotconcude,asa m ate ofl w,whi h i a ofPr ena spot i l tr a c f ny om de' ental da ages ar lm ie by t t r s of t i e ' a r y.N et r pa t i entted t m e i td he e m he t aks'W rant l ihe ry s il o j g n a amatroflw o t i is e ud me t s te a n h s su . = V C onc us on l i Ther or i i ORDERED,ADJU DGED,and D ECREED: ef e, t s 1 De e a Ce tma k' M o in f r S . fnd nt n i r s to o umma y J d n ( 3 )be a d t r u gme t DE 8 , n he s ame i ,he e DEN I ;a s r by ED nd Plitf Pr me a e sM o in f rPa ta S mma y J d n ( 4 b ,a d an if o n d ' to o ri l u r u gme t DE 0) e n t s e i,her by DEN I he am s e ED. DO NE and O RDERED i Chambe s a t J m es Lawr nce Ki Fe r J tce n r t he a e ng de al usi Buidi a Unied St t Courhous ,M im i Fl i ,t s25t day ofM ar h,201 l ng nd t a es t e a , orda hi h c 5. < AM ES LA W REN CE KI NG UN I TED STATES DI STRI J CT SOUTHERN DI STRI OF FL CT cc: AI Couns lofR e I e cord N i asD .Si ri chol egf ed Segfi d,Ri r Hyman,Le ne ,De w -- e,M a s e al i re ve a, r r lalon' r, t . 20l A l m br Cicl ha a r e El vent Fl e h oor Cor Gabl ,FL 331 al es 34 Emal n ig re @shllw.o i: se fid r -a c m 9 A M at he R .Tuchm an t w Si gf i Ri a, ym a Le neret a . e red, ver H n, r .1 201Al mbr Cic e,Elve h Fl ha a r l e nt oor Cor Ga e FL 331 5108 al bls, 34- Emalmtc ma shllw.o i: u h n@ r -a c m Kat ri A bi lRober s he ne gai t Rum be ge , ik & Cal r rK r dwel l Brc lBa e Ce r Suie 3000 i kel yvi w nte, t 80 SW 8 h Stee t r t M i m i FL 331 a , 30 Emal a o e t@r mbeg rc m i: r b rs u r e .o M i hae Kevi G ut an c l n m Rum ber r Kik ,Cal ge , r dwel,P. l A. 80 S. .8t Ste t W h re Suie3000 t M i m i FL 331 a , 30 Emalmg t n@r r rc m i: uma umbege.o Gr egor M ark Pal er y m Rum ber rKik & Cal l ge r dwe l Brc lBa e Ce r ikel yviw nt e 80 SW 8t St e t h re Suie3000 t M im i FL 331 a , 30 Emalg l r rmb re .o i: pame@ u eg rc m 1 0
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
