FLYLUX, LLC v. Aerovias de Mexico, S.A. de C.V., No. 1:2014cv20966 - Document 39 (S.D. Fla. 2014)
Court Description: ORDER Granting 29 Motion to Dismiss. Closing Case. Motions Terminated: 29 Defendant's MOTION TO DISMISS 25 Amended Complaint, FOR FAILURE TO STATE A CLAIM Defendant's MOTION to Dismiss for Lack of Jurisdiction 25 A mended Complaint, Defendant's MOTION to Dismiss 25 Amended Complaint, for failure to join a party under Rule 19 filed by Aerovias de Mexico, S.A. de C.V.. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 9/30/2014. (whl) NOTICE: If there are sealed documents in this case, they may be unsealed after 1 year or as directed by Court Order, unless they have been designated to be permanently sealed. See Local Rule 5.4 and Administrative Order 2014-69.
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
FLYLUX, LLC v. Aerovias de Mexico, S.A. de C.V. Doc. 39 UN I TED STATES DI STRI COURT FOR THE CT SOUTHERN DI STRI OF FLORI CT DA M i m iD i s on a vi i Cas Number 1 20966- V- ORENO e : 4CI M FLYLU X , LLC, Pl i if a ntf , AERO VI S DE M EX I ,S. . E C . . A CO A D V, De e nt f nda . / O R D ER G M N TI G M O TI N TO DI I N O SM SS A t a la nc Fl r ve ge y, yLux,LLC , ss ng a a r i , A e ovi s de M e c S. . D e C . . f i ui n ilne r a xi o, A , V , or c nc lng a o m ael 33 fi t f r i i dualtc t de s The ta la nc pur ha ed a eli ppr xi t y lgh s o ndvi ikehol r . r ve ge y c s r plce ntti sf t ec t e a me lght or hos usomer a i now s e ngr i buremen fom t De e s nd s e ki em s t r he f ndan , who t r ce ve pa e f he i tal lgh s TheD ef nda A e ovi sde M e c c ai st ha r f e i d ym nt ort nii f i t . e nt r a xi o l m o ve e unde d t mone ba kt a herta a nc i Ve z l t ta t da a i e m e ar bewe n Fl he y c o not r vel ge y n ne uea ha c e s n ntr di y t e yLux, LLC a Ae ovi deM e c Def nti movi t dim isa gui t Cour l ksdi st nd r as xio. enda s ng o s s r ng he t ac veriy j rs ito Th Co r a re wi Dee d n t tteCo r mu tc nsd r h nainaiiso te u idcin. e u t g e s t fn a t ha h u t s o ie t e to l e f h h t i vi tc t de sa fndst Pl ntf hasi opery agg egaed t cai st r c t ndi dual ike hol r nd i he ai if mpr l r t he l m o ea h he J i di tona a ount ' s ci l m ur . THI CAUSEc mebeor t Courupont Deenda ' M otont Dimis( E. 29) S a f e he t he f nts i o s s D. No. , fl on June 1 201 ied 2. 4. THE COURT hasconsder d t moton,t r pons or la gume ,a t pe tne i e he i he es e, a r nt nd he ri nt pori oft r co d,a be ng o he wi e f l a s d i t pr i e , i i tons he e r nd i t r s uly dvi e n he em s s t s Dockets.Justia.com AD JUD G ED t t m oton i GR AN TED . hat he i s 1 Background . l nDec m berzol Pl i if Fl e 3, a ntf , yLux, LLC, r ve a ntba e i e Y o k, ec e s ve a ata l ge s d nN w r s ur d e r l r s r to f i e na i lfr ta bus ne s c as ti ht f om D ef ntA e ovi de M exi e e va i ns or nt r tona is nd i s l s l g s r enda r as co, S. . d CV . Pl i ifr c ve e tc tr c pt c im i t or gi lr s r a i on De m be A,e a ntf e ei d - i ke e ei s onfr ng he i na e e v tons ce r 1 201 A f w da lt r Pli ifc l t c nget de t e l a i f t s r s vai . 7, 3. e ys a e , antf aled o ha he parur oc ton or he e e er tons De e n i s d ne e-i tr c pt t t Pl ntf ,i t na e ofis c i nt c i m i t f nda t s ue w tcke e ei s o he ai i f n he m s t le s onf r ng he c nge. The e w e e 33 s r t r s r tons ha r r epa a e e e va i . Pl ntf c pl nt c r c e i t t m s of t r e v t ons a t t e ai i fs om ai ha a t rzes he er he es r a i nd he el phone c onve s tons s tng up a c ra i eti nd hangi t r er tonsast pa tes a ee e . Pl i tf cl i s ng he es va i he r i ' gr m nt a n if a m De e f ndan a e t pr de Pl ntf s clen s w ih c m e c a tr tc a s a busnes - l s t gr ed o ovi ai i f i t t om r i l i s - l s nd i sc a s c r i ge by a r t s ve a i e na i a ra i o e r l nt r tonaldesi tons s h a D uba ,Fr nce,la y a l r el I tna i uc s i a t l nd s a . n e ha ,Pl ntf a lgesi agr ed t pa $238, 79,i adva e oft r er tons Pli tf xc nge ai if le t e o y 423. n nc he es va i . a n if a l gest tDef nda unia er ly c nce l d t r e v i ns w ihoutnotc or r i bur em e t le ha e nt l t a l a le he es r ato t ie e m s nt o Pl i i f A sa r s t D e e n de e 21 ofPl ntf sc t e st a lt t boa d t i fi s a ntf . e ul, f nda t ni d ai i f us om r he biiy o r he r lght . Pl i i ft n pur ha e r a m en f i sf t s c t er .A ddii l Pl i ifcl m st t a ntf he c s d epl ce t lght or he e us om s tonaly, a ntf ai ha i l r d ofs e f ur c nc la i ofisc t e s r s r a i a i pur has d r pl e e t ea ne om ut e a e l tons t us om r ' e e v tons nd t c e e ac m nt fi s f rt e c t er asw e l Pl i i fa t he t 33 e tc t t is Am e lght o hos us om s l . a ntf tac s he - i ke s o t nded Com pl nt ai . D e e nt ha m oved t di m i s c a m i Pl ntf ca f nda s o s s l i ng ai if nnot brng s t as an a nt f 33 i ui ge or i vi l,who i cai aet ralpa te i i ees.Defnda camst j nde oft 33 ndi duas m t l ms r he e ris n ntr t e nt li he oi r he idvd aswo d d sr y dv ri j rs ito a d t a i i i r p rt a ge aete cams n iiu l ul e to ie st u idcin n h t t s mp o e o g r g t h li . y Pl ntf cl i st c c ofl w di t t s t tM exi an 1 w a y a t ti i t pr pe pa t t ai if a m hat hoi e a c a e ha c a ppl nd ha t s he o r ry o - 2- brng t cai unde M e c n l w. i he l ms r xi a a II.LegalSt andard & Anal s ysi Fed r c t ha o i na s j tmatrj iditono c tovese bewe nS iie eal ours ve rgi l ubec te urs ci ver onr ris t e t tz ns c ofa Stt an ctz o s jcsofaf egn sae. 28 U. C.j 1 a( . Fed aldi riy ae d iiens r ube t ori tt ' ' S. 332()2) er vest j iditondoe note ompa sc r risb t nctz nsoff ei satsorrsde tale . e urs ci s nc s ontovese ewee iie or gn t e e i n insSe VantgeDrli Co.v Su,741F.d 535,538( t Ci.201 (i ng di riyj iditonwa a ilng . 3 5h r 4) fndi vest urs ci s lc ng whe epl n ifi i r a e i t Ca n ll a de e nti aTai ne eciien ; a ki r aitf s nco por t d n he yma sands nd f nda s wa s tz l s aloBa v Wrght44F. p. 1 1 ( D. a.1 )( ngnodi riyj rs ci ee s nci . i , Sup 2d 272, 275 S. Fl 999 Gndi vest u iditon exit w her pl ntf w as a cii of Ecuador and a Fl da r i s ed e ai if tzen ori esdentand where def endantwasa ctze ofEc d a aCalf ni rsde ) ii n ua or nd ior a e i nt. Pl nifb ar t bur nofesa ihi di riyj idito Mccor c v Ade hol,293 aitf e s he de tbls ng vest urs cin. mik . r t F.d1 1 ( 1hCi. 3 254, 257 1 t r2002) dli prs dt tafdeal our lcks urs ci i apatc ar . sts eume ha e r c ta j iditon n riul c s u tlh pan i d mo srtstec u t a j rs ito o e t es be t te .J ae nite lit f e n tae h o r h s u idcin v r h u jc matr' PMCC 2 0 f ' 05 C1 3 Coli s Lo ng, LC v. l sSout Beac LLC, o.l 20636- V- LTON A GA , 0 BC1 ln dgi L Phii p h h N 0Cl A 201 W L 431 7000,*1( D. a.Oc. 201 . S. Fl t22, 0) Ciie hi o heParis tz ns p ft te Atis i t sc s i wh t rt r i di riyj iditon whenata age ys eso sue n hi a e s ehe hee s vest urs ci rvel nc u n be l o iscu t r,wh ej nderwoul detoy c eedi riy.TheCour mus decde haf f t somes os oi d sr omplt vest t t i wh t e imusc n ie Plitf' ctz n hpo wh t ron r f an ifscin s s p r p it eh rt t o sd r an ifs iie s i r ehej ide o Plitf le t i a p o rae a t ra patesi i ee t dealRul ofCi lPr e e 1 a rquie a1fdeala tonsbe s he e l ri n ntrs.Fe r e vi oc dur 7() e rs l e r ci posc e i t na oft r lpa t i i e et Se Fe R.Ci P.1 a . tl pur eoft t r e utd n he me he ea ry n ntr s. e d. v. 7() s-he pos ha r e i t e e t de e ntt a i hi s f of e de e a de ens t tt def nthas ul s o nabl he f nda o va l m el vi nc nd f es ha he enda a an tt er a pa t i i tr s,a d t a s r hm fn lt o t ej d me t a d t th wil g is h e l ry n ne et n o su e i ai f h u g n , n ha e l be y pr ec e a i ta t rs tbr htby t r l ry i i e es on t s m em a t r' Te ys v ot t d ga ns no he ui oug he ea pa t n nt r t he a te . ' nn on . ASCAP, Fe App' 608,61 ( t Ci.201 . 477 d. x 0 11h r 2) I Ailne Re tng Cor v S an N Tr ve,I . 58F. 857,8 ( Ci.1 ) t n ri s pori p. . d a l nc, 3d 62 2d r 995 ,he Se ond Cicui he d t t i w oul not t n t c tz ns p of a c por ton t c t ol whe t c r t l ha t d i d he ii e hi or a i o on r n he co ai wa meel a tnga a ag ntrprs tngt i er t ofot r .I sae t tdgl s h porton s r y ci s n e e eeni he nt ess he s t ttd ha sin uc ac e t cii e hi of h r pr s t d i vi l c r sf di r iy pur es a t y a et r a as , he tz ns p t e e e en e ndi dua s ontol or ve s t pos , s he r he e l a s bs a i pa tes t t di put ' I t c e of a r i tc s a di t i t c thel t t nd u t ntal ri o he s e. n he ont xt ' ilne i ket , s rc our d ha 'l c tc tr prs n sa i pe n c r t' Ame i Ailne,I .v Au tn,778F. sFla h ike e e e t n nde nde t ontac. ' rcan ri s nc . si Supp. 72,76 ( D. 1 ) D. C. 991.Bas dont spr e nt i se ce rt tFl e hi ec de ,t e ms la ha yLux' ciiens pdoesnot s tz hi c nr l od tr nedv riyj rs ito b trt e t Co r mu t o kt t ectz n h po te o to t eemi ie st u id cin, u ah r he u t s l o o h iie s i f h 33 tc t de s i ke hol r . TheCour wilne rhees e mi t Pli ifsa g ntt tM e c n lw a ist t l ve t l s xa ne he antf r ume ha xi a a pple o de e m i t ç e lpa t i i e es . Pl i ifc t t El a 1 ' l . K o C a eN o. 20588, t r ne he û a ry n nt r t' a ntf ies o andi nt l nc v y, s r ' , 09. 201 W L 21 0 79770, ( D. a. b. 201 a PCz Cc ff .v.Vil Vee i y Cts, *4 S. Fl Fe 22, 0) nd ' 4 nve, nc lage trnar r. I .Cas No.11311 201 W L 37791 ,* 5( D. .Aug.31 201 t s nc, e - 9, 2 01 4- N. Ga , 2) o uppor isposton tt ii t tM e c n l w a i st de e m i t r al t i i e e t n t e c es how e r t c t ha xi a a pple o t r ne he e pary n nt r s .I hos as , ve , he ours ween te a nn tectz ns i o t ep rist v rf dv riyj rs ito Rah rt ec u t r o x miig h iie hp f h a t o eiy iest u idcin. te h o rs e we ee ge i de er i ngt pl i if ' t ndi r nga d n t m ni he a ntf s s a ngunde Ar i e11 H e e,he Cour i a c r a ni r tcl 1 . r t t s s e t i ng whet t her here i di iyJursdi i s verst ' i cton. To r ie a e t que ton i whet rt Cour s d c i rFl e t r t , he s i s he he t houl ons de yLux' c tz ns p, t t s ii e hi or ha o iscin s Cic t u tha eh l ta k o eedv ri o ctz n hpj rs ito u e 28 ft le t. ruiCo rs v ed h tf mplt ie st f iie s i u idcin nd r c y - 4- U. C. 1 3 ()it se b t ectz ns i o tera p rist t ec nr v ry, n tect e s i S. j 3 2 a s e td y h iie hp fh e l a t o h o to e s a d h iz n hp e i o na n wh meeys e o b h lo t era p ris s b in r d'As o .n . m 'Cop. fa ge t o rl u s n e af f h e l a t mu t e g o e . s c I s Mg t r e ' v. k Gen Agenc I . 1 F. 794,796( hCi.1 )(mpha i adde (ii Nav r Sav Ar . . y,nc, 49 3d 8t r 998 e ss d) ctng aro . As ' v fe 446 U. 458,461( 980);Ailne Re tn Cor ,58 F. at86 ( di sn . e, S. 1 ) ri s porig p. 3d 2 hol ng cii ns p of c por ton i no ope a i w he c por ton w a a tng a a a tze hi or a i s t r tve n or a i s c i s n gentf a he or not r pa t .TheCo tsrvi ofPlitf same dc antr ve st tFl ry) ur' e ew anif nde ompli e al ha yLux,nc. a tnga l was ci s a t a lag nt t r i no alega i ofa c r c be w e Fl r ve e ; he e s l ton ont a t t en yLux,l and D e e ntbe nc. f nda yond t he i vi l ri tc t a tc dt t Am e ndi dua ailne i ke s ta he o he ndedCom pl nt Ac di y,ti pr rf heCou t ai . cor ngl i s ope ort r t c n ie t e ctz n hi o FlLu ' cin s Be a e t e p ris a re t a j id ro te o o sd r h iie s p f y x s l t. c us h a t g e h t on e f h e e i vi ltckehol r woul desr y compl e di r iy,t Cour fnds t e i no di riy ndi dua i t de s d to et ve st he ti her s ve st J i di ton i t s c e. ' s c i n hi as ur Ag r g to o a ms g e a in fcli Eve i t Cour wer t fnd Pl i ifha m e t di r iy ofc tz hi r quie e , he n f he t eoi a ntf s t he ve s t ii ens p e r m nt t Plitf i i r p rya g e aigtecamst ra htej rs ito a a u t an if s mp o e l g rg tn h li o e c h u id ci n l mo n . I i w e ls t l d t t t he e m uli e pl i i f ale cl i s i t s m e c pl nt t t s l- e te ha i r w tpl a ntf s l ge a m n he a om ai , he c pl i m us aleg t tt cl i s ofe ch i vi om a nt t l e ha he a m a ndi dualpl ntf m e tt a ounti c t ove s ai if e he m n on r r y rquie . Be r v. 0.SmihElct. ods Co. 265F. x 772,777( 1hCi. ) e rment' aves A. ' t e r Pr . , App' 1 t r 2008 , . S t v GF Cop.2 6F.d 1 9 1 0 n6( 1hCi. 0 )(s n r l wh np an if j i i mih . # r , 3 3 2 2, 3 0 . 1 t r 2 01 t e al e litfs on n Ge y, one l w s t t va ue of t r c a m s m a not be a a ui , he l hei l i y dded t t r or S r t 't s ts y t oge he , agg ega ed, o a i f he a mounti conr ryr quieme f di riyj iditon.) n toves e r nt or vest urs ci ' . ' Pl ntf cl i st ti i no a e tng t va ueoft i vi tcke s but a he i s ng ai i f a m ha t s t ggr ga i he l he ndi dual i t , r t r s ui f risow n da age be aus i r pl c e ch oft c nce l d tc t . The Cour doe nota eet t o t m s c e t e a ed a he a le i ke s t s gr ha t i i ap o rwa t r a h tej rs ito a a u t Rah r tePlitf i a dn e c o is hs s rpe y o e c h u idcin l mo n . t e ,h an if s d ig a h f t clen s c a m s t t r t r a h t t es d. A cc di l t Cour doe no f nd t i t' li oge he o e c he hr hol or ng y, he t s t i he rq ie n so dvest j rs ito aeme a g a t t mo int ds s . e ur me t f i ri u id ci n r t nd r ns he to o imis y - DON E AN D OR DER ED i Cha be sa M i m i Fl i t s n m r t a , orda, hi /7 UyoSpe e,04 a fetmbr21. FED CO A .M OREN O UN I TED STA TES D I STRI J DG E CT U Copi pr ded t es ovi o: Couns lofRe or e c d - 6-
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
