SPEIER-ROCHE v. VOLKSWAGEN GROUP OF AMERICA, INC. et al, No. 1:2014cv20107 - Document 45 (S.D. Fla. 2014)
Court Description: ORDER granting 34 Motion to Dismiss. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 4/30/2014. (bnt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
SPEIER-ROCHE v. VOLKSWAGEN GROUP OF AMERICA, INC. et al Doc. 45 UNI TED STATES DI STRI COURT FOR THE CT SOU TH ERN DI STRI O F FLOR I A CT D M i m iD i s on a vi i Cas Number 1 201 CI M ORENO e : 4- 07- VSANDRA SPEI ROCHE, ERPl i tf , a n if VOLKSW AGEN GROUP OF AM ERI A , I C . C N D/ a A UD I O F A M ERJ ,l C . A UD I A G b/ / CA N , andVOLKSW AGEN AG, . De e f ndan s t. ORDER DENYI G DEFENDANT' M O TI TO DI I AND DI I NG CASE N S ON SM SS SM SSI Thi ma trcome be or t Cour pur ua t De e s te s f e he t s nt o f ndan Vol wa n Gr of t ks ge oup Ameia l .ç fn a fl sMo int DimisPlitf Sa d aS ee- c (plitf '' rc ,nc (Dee d n ' to o s s anif n r p irRo he t anif )s s l Ame d dCo an p ru n t F d rlRue o Ci l o e u e1 ( )6 a 9b . e n e mplit u s a t o e ea ls f viPr c d r 2 b ( ) nd () Th g ava n ofPli ifsAme r me a ntf nded Compl i i t tt br pa andr t si he 2007Audi ant s ha he ake ds o or n r ( (het hi e'ar deeci a rquiefe ntrplc me ,i vi ai ofale e e s )7 t t cl' e f tve nd e r rque e a e nt n olton ve ) lged xprs a i pled wa r nte .l pe tnen pa t AudisNe Ve cl Li ie W a r nt e anst tt nd m i r a i s n ri t r, ' w hi e m t d ra y xpl i ha he Ve il' b a ep d a dr t r aettmst a aes be t od tro aind et n r l a, hces rk a s n oo s r çe h t r u j c t ee irto u o o ma we r i drvi ha t orcondii 'a cons nty lssbr kepadsand r or asie st ta eo y i ng bis tons' nd eque l it a ot s t m ha r nl c r f a lm ied wa r nt pe i oft ea le of1 mont / 2, m ies I he Ame ove ed or i t r a y rod he ri r 2 hs 1 000 l . n r nded Co an, anifcamsta tedee t o h r h ceaen ts b e tt t ec nsr it o a mplit Plitf li h t h fcs f e Ve il r o u j c o h o tan s f lm ied wa r nt s a tmpt t i i t ra y; he te s o nvoket a i ton ofal rwa r nt pe i by al gi he pplca i onge ra y rod le ng t the br kepad/ot rdef c sa er l t t ot r s uni ntted t a Syse 'c pone s ha r a r o e t r e aed o he wie- de ii û ke tm ' om Br nt Dockets.Justia.com a daet u s b e t oa48mo t /0,0 mi war ny n r h s u jc t - n h 5 0 0 l ra t. e Thi Cour tndst tPli iff l t a qua ey sa eavald ea eofa ton i a oft s tl ha antf ais o de t l t t i us c i n ny he eghtCount ofhe Amende Compli . 1ofhe cl msa etm e ba r a i a ton,ke i s r d ant A1 r ai r i - red, nd n ddii y e e nt ofe ycli sa em isng.Fort f e ng r s t sCour GRAN TS De e nts l me s ver am r s i he or goi ea on, hi t f nda ' M oto t Dim isast alCount. in o s s o l s 1 . Le lSt r ga anda d Unde Rul 8,apli tf mus pr de aS hor a pli saeme oft cai s r e a n if t ovi ç t nd an t t nt he l m howi s ng t a t epe d ri e tte t r l f'Fe . CW. 8 a( ) W he r ln o amoint ds s h t h la e s n ild o ei . dR. P. ()2 . n uig n e ' to o imis t e Rue 1 ()6 , c u t s ve t c mp an i t lg tmos f v rb et t panif md r l 2b () a o r mu t iw he o lit n he ih t a o a l o he litf a da s met ev r ct o welpe d dfcu lalg to s S a e v US. p'o at & n su h ea iy f l- la e a t a l ain . pe k r . De t fHe l e h Hu nS rs Ctsf rDie s Co to d Pr v n in, 2 F.d 1 71 1 7 ( 1h Ci. 01 ) ma e v . r .o s a e nr l r e e to 6 3 3 3 , 3 9 1 t r 2 0 . Howe r t st ne doesnotappl t l lc usons, nd s h concusonsi us be ve ,hi e t y o ega oncl i a uc l i ç t m rp r s po td by f t laleg tons'As of v I a , 5 U. 6 2, 9 ( 0 ) Th u hap o e up re acua l a i . hcr t . qb l 5 6 S. 6 67 20 9 . o g ' . c ompl ntç ai i notne d dea ld f t la lga i s i mus con a n f or t n lbe sand does e t ie acua le tons' t t t i ' e ha a l ' m c l i ns a af m ul cr ciai n oft e e nt ofac us ofa ton wilnotd 'Be l oncuso , nd or ai e tto he l me s a e ci l o. l ' Ata t Cop. . wo l 5 0U. 5 4, 5 ( 0 7 . ln i r v T mby 5 S. 4 5 5 2 0 ) c d cai ha f i plusbiiy whent pl i ifpl a f c ua c entt ta l t t l m s acal a i lt A he antf e ds a t l ont ha lows he cour t dr w t r a ona ei e e et tt de enda i la ef t miconduc aleg ' t o a he e s bl nf r nc ha he f nt s ibl or he s t l ed.' I , U. a 678. ssa r i S a n t a i oba lt r quieme , bu i a ksf qbal 556 S. t Thi tnda d s f ki o pr biiy e r nt' t t s or not m o e t n a s e pos i lt t ta de e r ha he r s biiy ha f ndan hasa t d unl w f l ' 1 l ot rw o ds t t ce a uly. d. n he r , he ' - 2- c pli mus co an te om ant t nt i lnough f c t r s ar as a t o aie e onabl expe t ton t tdico r wilr ve e c a i ha s ve y l e al evi nc 'oft r uie elm e .Twombl 55 U . a 556. de e' he eq r d e nt y 0 S. t 1. 1 Fa t Ba kg ound c ual c r OnJ anua y 21 201 pli ifSa a SpeirRoc fl d he Amende Compli ti t r , 4, a ntf ndr e - he ie r d a n n he a o ec p in dp tt ca sa to Th Ame e Co litg n r l alg st a çth b v -a to e u ai ls cin. e nd d mp an e eal l e h ts l e ve y e l brki s t i t l i t 2007t prs ntAudiQ7ve cls(l as Ve ces' s fr fom a ng ysem nsaled n he o ee hi e t s hil ') ufe s r cl de ecst tc us n ong ot rt ngs t Cl s Ve ces br kepa an r t st we rout f t ha a e, m he hi , he a s hi l ' a ds d o or o a pr m a ur y a r quie r pl ce en a oxi a e y e y 7, t 1 000 m ies' Pl i if e t el nd e r e a m t ppr m t l ver 500 o 5, l . a ntf ' al ge t tt fe le s ha he r quenc o he Ve c er par i caespr t ewe ri vi ai of y f r hil e is ndi t ema ur a n ol ton wara tesofapr pe l f toni br ki s t m .He eghtc us sofa ton a ea f l : rni o ry unci ng a ng yse ri a e c i r s olows b e c o e p e swar ny( u t ) b e c o e p e sp r war ny( u t1) b e c o ra h f x rs ra t Co n I; ra h f x r s a t ra t Co n 1; r a h f wrte warn yu d rt eM a n s n itn ra t n e h g u o -Mos W ar nyAc,1 U. C. 2 01e s q t u t11; s ra t t 5 S. j 3 t e . co n 1) bra h o i idwarnt ofmec ntbiiyt e c f mple ra y rha a lt countl ;brac oft Fl i Dec ptvea V) e h he orda e i nd Unfi Trd P a tc sAc ( u tV) c mmo 1w fa d( u tVl; r a h o t ed t o g o ar a e r cie t Co n ; o n a ru Co n ) b e c f h u y f o d f i a df i d aig( u t l; n u j t n ih n ( u tVIl. u t X c n an a at n ar e ln Co n VI) a d nus e rc me t Co n l) Co n I o tis h p a rf r ifo y;s r que t adeca ai a t t pa te 'r s c i rght a doe no r ye or ele nl he e s s lr ton s o he ri s e pe tve i s nd s t s a e a c us ofa ton. tt a e ci Thef ct a a lge a ea f l a s s le d r s olows: ora utM a c 20, on bo r h 2007,Pli ifl s d a2007 antf ea e AudiQ7s tutlt ve cebe rngVe cel ntfc tonNumberW A1 41, 1085 (he por- iiy hil ai hil de iiai 8Y7 - 7 32 t 97 çve ce' fom a a t i dAudide e s pi Coc Gr Fl i Clhedeae s p' . d hil ' r n uhorze ) alrhi n onut ove, orda t lrhi ' The ) de e s p i nota na alr hi s med de e nt TheVe c ewa pur s d wih AudisNe Ve cl f nda . hil s cha e t ' w hi e Li tdW ar ny(teW arn f'. n rly t eVe il W ar nyc v r tec s o al a t mie ra t sh ra t l Ge eal,h hce ra t o e s h o t f lp rs f a lborne dedt r pai a ie on ave c edef tvei ma e i ,wor ns p orf cor nd a e o e r ny t m hil ec i n t ral kma hi at y pr parton f a pe i oftme e endi t t e le of48 mont or5 000m ie . e e ai or rod i xt ng o he arir hs 0, l s Se Exhi tA t Exhi t1 D . N o 34.H o e , he V e c e W a r t e es l pr dest t bi o bi , E. w ver t hi l r an y xpr sy ovi ha dtmss be t od tro aind et n nna we r d iigh bt o c n i o saec v rdf r ûe u jc t eei rto u o o l a , rvn a is r o dt n r o e e o i i d fcsi ma u a t rrsmaeil n wo k n hp/ r1 mo tso l , 0 mi s whc e e e e t n n fcu e ' tra a d r ma s i / 2 nh r 20 0 l , ih v r e oc ur frt The eie i l .:rz dic ,br epads..'Jf( c s is. s tms ncude.. tke s s ak .. ' emphassa d) ' t i dde . On M ar h 1 2008,whe t Vehil ' odo e e r ad 7, mie ,Pli ifb oughtt c 3, n he c es m t r e 673 ls a ntf r he Ve c e t t dea e s p f om whi h s l s d t c rasa r s toft V e c e ç aki a hi l o he l r hi r c he ea e he a e ul he hi l i ng m s alt noiewhe br ng.' Auditchni a r plc t fontbr ke r or , ds and que ype s n aki 'An e cin e a ed he r a ot s pa , s or ;t Ve c ewasu ens s he hil nderwa r nt a t stmea Pli ifwa notcha ge On M a c 23, ra y t hi i nd a ntf s r d. rh 2009,whe t odometrr d 1 61 mie ,Pli ifbr n he e ea 4, 9 ls a ntf oughthe ve ce ba k t t deaerhi r hil c o he l s p a drq e tdh rb a e b is e td AnAu i e l ca d tr ne ta h rt rk sg r) n e u se e rk s e n p ce . d tcmiin ee mi d h t e l a e wee b wihi s f t s cs'On M a c 30,2009,howeve ,Pli ifb oug he vehil bac and was t n a e y pe . ' rh r a ntf r ht r ce k a s d t r pl ehe r a br kepads On Fe ua y 22,201 Pl ntf b oughtt Ve c eba k dvie o e ac r e r a . br r 0, ai if r he hil c t t de l rhi f br ker parandpe s naly cove e t c tofr par ast odometrr ad o he a e s p or a e i ro l r d he os e i, he e e 2121 mie a t Ve c e' br ke a r o swe eno l rc r d by wa r nt Les t , 2 ls nd he hil s a s nd ot r r onge ove e ra y. s hm1 am o h lt r Pli ifpu c s d t Ve c ea t co l i n ofhe 3- ea l a et m . nt a e , a ntf r ha e he hil t he ncus o r y r e s er On Augus 25,2011 Pli ifb oughtt Ve ce i f s nic t t deae s p a a t , a ntf r he hi l n or e e o he lr hi nd n Auditchnii n a s fo a r arbr kepadr pl e e c a dvied r nt nd e a e ac ment t dea e s p ofe e t c r ; he l rhi f r d o ove - 4- 5 oft c tofr par On Fe u r 1 201 Pli ifbr ug t Ve cl t t deae s p 0% he os e i. br a y 8, 3, a ntf o ht he hi e o he lr hi f s r i ea r plc t fontbr kepadsa r or a i On Augus 20, 3, twhih or e v c nd e a ed he r a nd ot s gan. t 201 a c poi t Ve cl has43, 0 m ieson t ve ce' odom ee ,Pli ifhadt Ve ce s vie nt he hi e 68 l he hi l s tr antf he hil er c d a i a t Audide e pa taly c r t r parc t On Se e gan nd he alr ri l ove ed he e i os. pt mber30,201 Pli tf 3, a n if c omm e e t sltga i by flng aCompl i a i tVol wag Gr ofAm e i n,I , nc d hi ii ton ii ant ga ns ks en oup rca nc. AudiAG andVol wa n AG.Theonl oft t eena e De e ks ge y he hr m d f ndan st be s r ed i t o ev s Vol wa n Gr ofAm e i a l Pl n iffld he Am e d Com pl nton J r 21 ks ge oup rc n, nc. aitf ie r nde ai anua y , 201 i r s e, ks ge Gr p ofAm e i n, nc.tld t M otont Dimison whi h 4) n e pons Vol wa n ou rca l ,ie he i o s s c t sCour now r es hi t ul . 11 1. Leg A na ys s al l i A. P an ifsAl g to o Bra ho Ex r s W a rny( u t1 a d litf l ains f e c f p e s ra t Co n ) n e Brac oft Dut ofGoodFat ( e h he y ih CountVl)FalasaM atrofLaw l i te l Co n 1Plitf camst t fn a tt x r sl war ne t a (h Ve il wa lo n u t , an if li ha Dee d n s p e sy ra td h t te h ce s f e hi h q lt an a m i m um , g uaiy d, t ni woul a lywor pr ry' f t r Pl ntf al ge t t d dua l k ope l ' urhe , ai if le s ha ; De e ntbr c d t W a r nt % s li t Pl ntf a Cl sM e r t Cls Ve ces f nda ea he he r a y ç elng o ai if nd as by mbe s he a s hi l wih known Br ke Syse pr e s whih a e notofhi h q lt a whih f i pr ma ur l t a t m obl m , c r g uaiy, nd c al e t ey a orf i t f ton pr ry. She tna l cl m st tDe e ntbr ac d t Ve cl nd/ al o unc i ope l ' ' l ly ai ha f nda e he he hi e W a rnt by f ii t r para orr plc Pl i ifsa lge y def c i br ke whe t y ra y a lng o e i nd/ e a e antf le dl e tve a s n he f ie durngt Ve cl W a r nt pe i a ld i he hi e ra y rod. Thef men a pr e wih Pli ifscli i t t by t pl n lnguag oft unda t l oblm t a ntf am s ha , he ai a e he Ve c eW a r t t br son Pli ifsVe c ewe eonl cove e unde t W a r nt f t hil ran y, he ake antf hil r y rd r he ra y or he e rirof1 mont or1 000 m ie fom t da eofl as a i i undiput t tDe e nt a le 2 hs 2, l s r he t e e, nd t s s ed ha f nda ddn t hag Plitf f rb a rp i u tl he s eha e c e e t etmeo warny i o c r e anif o rke e ar ni a r h d x e d d h i f ra t c r ge t ti,a trmor t n t vemont a 1 000 mie ha expied a trhe las ove a , ha s fe e ha wel hs nd 2, ls d r fe r e e s g ng da e i ni t. Pl ntf a t st cr umve t W ara y lmia i by a gui t tt W a r nt ai if tempt o ic nt he r nt i t ton r ng ha he ra y tnusa iabl t b a spa t, i tng c a t t ea le of1 mont or1 000 mie e pplc e o r ke rs lmii over ge o he ri r 2 hs 2, ls fom t daeofla e, nota y t hercai bec us t a lged ç a Syse Def c 'i r he t e s do ppl o lm a e he le l ke tm Br e t' s c us byd ecsi maei a orwor a ed t t n tral nd/ def kmans p,(ndjc hi a ompone st taei tle i i;an nt ha r nsald n t d asar ul,t r or a t pa we ro pr m aur y. Putsmpl s i at mptng t al e es t he ot s nd he ds a ut e t el ' ' i y, he s te i o leg t tt r i adef c i t ve cl desg is l, hes m pt ofwhih i a de e tvebr ha he e s e t n he hi e i n te f t y om c s f c i ake c ompone ,s t a ia ec r gepe i i at r extndi t t e ri of48nt o he pplc bl ove a rod s e m e ng o he a ler mont o hs r 50, m ie . 000 l s Pli ifsa gume i unpe s sve. pl i t msoft Vehi eW a r nt a antf r nt s r ua i The an er he cl ra y nd Pl ntf sown alegai pr cudet Cour fom a i Pli ifspr e i e r t ton ai if l tons e l he tr doptng a ntf opos d ntm t ai a a ia et he cai s Pl ntf sown a lga i i t Ame s pplc bl o r l m . ai if le tons n he nded Compli lmi t ant i t he Cour ' c i ai t de e she Ve cl sbr kepadsa r or . ai ifsAmende ts onsder tons o f ct r hi e' a nd ot s Pl ntf d Co pli doesnotpla t tasngl c m a nt e d ha i e ompone ofhe Ve cl i al ge y def c i ot rt n nt r hi e s le dl e tve he ha t br kepa a r or Att i e i oft slws t t aleg t a de e 'wa de i d he a ds nd ot s. he nc pton hi a ui, he l ed d ke f ct' s fne br a p e t r i a' f h l rk p d a dr t r.( E.No 1 :1 . Ame d dCo lit s rmau e t r' t e i a e a s n o o s'D. . . , ) The n e mpan, we o b ' whih pu porst i e tt wor û yse 'i be wee t wor k a 'nd ç e t'does not c r t o ns r he d ç t m 'n t n he ds l ke' s br a t c , ' def i ntf a addii lcompone pa t t Ve cl oran û yse 't teihe f l ori de iy ny tona nt r of he hi e y s t m 'ha t r aied s s al dt bedef tve.CompaeCompli DktNo.1 !1wih Ame d Co ai , E.N o. lege o eci ( r ant . , t nde mpl ntD . 21 !1. litf frtb o g t e Ve cet t d aes i c mplii o t et q e kn 'o , ) Panif is r u h h r hil o he e lrhp o anng f h i u a ig' f s he br kes t de e s p dignos d pr emslm ied t t br kepa , fonta bac a r a ; he alr hi a e obl i t o he a ds r nd k, nd r or ,a fna l a lct d r paisi vedt fonta ba br ker or a t br kepa . ot s nd i ly, l ie e r nvol he r nd ck a ot s nd he a ds Alogehe ,t onl ça t'pla d i t Am e d Com pl ntr r ng t Ve ce' br kes t t r he y lc s' e de n he nde ai ega di he hi l s a a eale d pr m aur we ,a r pai, t br kepadsa r t s The ef e, t Pl i ifs r lge e t e ar nd e r of he a nd o or . r or by he antf al to a t pl n tr soft W a r nt t sCo tfndst tt a i bl wa r nt legai ns nd he ai e m he ra y,hi ur ha he pplca e ra y pe i he ei t twhih i r lva tt br kepa t- i.. t twhih i r lva t ve cepa t rod r s ha c s ee n o a rs .e, ha c s ee nt o hi l rs s be tt n r l a , x r sl lmingwarny c v r g t 1 mo t s 1 0 0mie . u jc o o ma we r e p e sy i t i ra t o ea e o 2 n h / 2,0 ls l i worh no i t tefo t a n t Pl i ifsat mpt t pl a a o t lmie t s t tng ha f rs ki o antf te s o e d r und he i t d W arn ytr b atiu igh rb a efiu et a u p cfe ç e e t h v b e rj ce ra t em y trb tn e rk al r o n ns e iid < fc' a e e n ee td d ' es whe e.n Calv.Chr lrCor , Fe Appx.38( Ci.20l1,a hee,hepli ifs le r I i yse p.426 d. 2d r ) s r t antf ued f br kepa a r orf iur out i t a i a e 1 mont 1 ,000 m iewa r nt Se ki t or a d nd ot a l e sde he pple bl 2h/ 2 l ra y. e ng o i nvoke al rwa r nt pe i a ia et dif r ntpa t, t pl ntf i Cal,lke Pl i tf onge ra y rod pplc bl o fe e rs he ai i f n i i a n if he e, l i e t tt padsa r or wer nott m s ve de e tve, butw or pr m a ur y due r c am d ha he nd ot s e he el s f c i e e t el t a uns cfe de e telewher i t ve cl Ashe e, t st ywasputf wa d a en t o n pe ii d f c s e n he hi e. r hi heor or r bs t he pla d f lzeofa s ci d tde e tve'pa tI at*3 5. n adecson a fr e byt Se ond e de aitr ny pe fe d f c i ' r. d. - I ii fim d he c Cic t t dit i tc the d pl i if s c ai s w e e c r ui, he s rc our l a ntf l m r over d e l i l t de t s r e e xc usve y m r he ho t r d a pa t'wa r nt a f t ke rs' ra y, nd ound no pla f dss br e ded a uppori t cli ofa de e te s whe ei tng he a m f c le r n tev h ces be t oaln e war nyp ro I a * h e il u j c t o g r ra t eid.d t 4 5. Bec us t a ia ewa r nt t nn he e i t tof1 mont / 2, m ies Pl ntf s a e he pplc bl ra y e r s ha 2 hs 1 000 l , ai if Coun f Bra hofExprs W arnt ( unt1 fis l i undiputdt tPli ifwa not t or e c e s ra y Co ) al.t s s e ha antf s c r ed f t br kepad a r orr plce ntwihi t 1 m ont / 2, miepa a ee sof ha g or he a nd ot e a me t n he 2hs 1 000 l r m tr t W a r nt applca et br ke pa t . c nno a s r acl m f br c ofe e swa r nt he ra y i bl o a rs She a t s e t ai or ea h xpr s ra y. Notbl e n i t Ame a y, ve f he nded Co pl ntesa ihe t exit nc ofa br a ofe e s m ai t bls d he se e e ch xpr s wa r t t wa r nt on t br kepadsa r t si Pl ntf ve cl e r d t vemont ran y, he ra y he a nd o or n ai ifs hi e xpie wel hs a t s las d t ve cl on t da eofM a c 20, fer he e e he hi e, he t r h 2008- we love fveye r bef r t s l ri a s o e hi ltg ton c ii a i omm e d on Se e be 30, 3. ordapr desa fve- a saut oflmia ins nce ptm r 201 Fl i ovi i ye r t t e i t to f brac ofe e swanunt cams Fl Stt j9 112)b) t-hea ia efve- rsaut or e h xprs y li . a. a. 5. ( ( .l- pplc bl i yea tt e l oflmia i c nno be n t nm lt rt t expia i oft wa r nt ast wa r nt di no i t ton a t gi o a e han he r ton he ra y he ra or d t e es l a r et pr vi wa r nt co r gebe xpr sy g e o o de ra y ve a yond t sdae..' c s cv.County Coac hi t .. M Kisi ' r h, I c, 0 9U. DitLEXI 1 4 8 a * 2 3 ( . Fl. b. 7, 0 9 . esaueo n .2 0 S. s. S 6 7 , t 3 - 3 M D. a Fe 2 2 0 ) Th tt t f lmiai nswoul ha be t r n whe Pl ntf s d ha dic r t alege i t to d ve gun o u n ai if houl ve s ove ed he l d unrpaie brkes tm dee tSe i a * - (i- saut oflmiai f ca e ofa ton e rd a yse fc. e d t 2526 t-he tt e i ttons or us s ci l bas d on abr c ofa e es wara y be nst r n whe apl ntf dic r , s d ha e ea h n xpr s r nt gi o u n ai if s ove s or houl ve dic rd,hebr a h oft e e swarnt 'l Pli ifwa putonnoi ofhe cli on s ovee t e c he xprs ra y. . antf s ' tce r am M a c 1 2008,whe byPl ntf sown c am ,he Ve cl nee d isfr talege y r h 3, n, ai if li r hi e de t is l dl i e atr 'br kepad a r orr plce nt Thus Pli tf se e swa r nt cai be me û m tte' a pr nd ot e a me . , a n if xpr s ra y l m cn untmey asofM a c 1 201 ove sx m ont be or t sltgai c i l r h 3, 3, r i hs f e hi ii ton omm e ed. nc Bec us CountIi dim is Pli ifsCoun VI,al gi br ac oft du y ofgoo a e s s s ed, antf t I le ng e h he t d f t a f i de lng,a s i dim is Pl i ifi r c l a lge t tt çm ple c nan of aih nd a r a i lo s s s ed. antf ncore ty le s ha he t i d ove t i good f ih and f i de i i a i pe ntdut a ma bebr c d e n i t r i no b ea h at ar alng s n nde nde y nd y ea he ve f he e s r c ofa c ta tsexpr s t r s'Fl i 1w hol t tt dut ofgood f ih çi no a a ta t on r c ' e s e m . orda a ' ds ha he y a t Es t n bsr c a i pende t r 'a r t t us bea hor d t t pe f manc o a e es nd nde nt e m' nd aher ç t nc e o he ror m e f n xpr s c rcua oblgai 'Flgs p Re or De .Cor v I e v 1 ' I ,28So.3d91 92 onta t l i ton.' a hl s t v p. . ntr al ntl nc. , 5, 4 ( a 3 DCA 2 0 .i-eec nb n c u eo a to f rab e c o t i le c ve a trf Fl. d 01 ) fl r a e o a s f ci n o r a h f he mpid o n n o -h g o fiha dfi d aig a e ta alg to t t ne p e str o tec nr c h sb e o d at n ar e ln ) bsn n le ain ha a x rs em f h o ta t a e n br a d.' d a 92 Pli ifsa lga i t Def nda vi aed t i i d cove ntofgo e che '1 t 4. antf le ton hat e nt ol t he mple na od f ih t o h br c oft e es wa r nt mus beba e on avald br a h ofwara y cai . at hr ug ea h he xpr s ra y t sd i ec r nt l m S eCe tro Ai Ca g v UPS Co, 0F.d 1 4 1 5 ( 1h Ci. 0 5 ; iu v V l wa n e nu in r r o . .42 3 1 6, 1 2 1 t r 2 0 ) f c l . oks ge Gr o j , 01 U. Dit LEXI 1 6 7 a *1 ( D. a De . , 01 )(ç c u ePlitfs p. fzn 2 3 S. s. S 71 2 , t 2 S. Fl. c 5 2 3 s a s an if Be ca nnotsa eac am f br a h oft wa r nt ... t rc n t y sa eacli f br a oft t t l i or e c he ra y neihe a he t t am or e ch he i idcove ntofgoodf t andfi de i co ane i t tc r t' . c eDeen nt mple na aih ar alng nti d n ha ontac.) Be aus f da ' pai i f l f t onebr r pai on Pl i ifsve ce t toc ur e durng t wa r n y d n ul or he ake e r antf hi l ha e r d i he ra t pe i De e ntscompla wih iswa r t o i ato di no br c a co r c t t rod, f nda ' ince t t ran y blg i ns d t ea h ny nta t ha co d gi rs t acli f br a h oft i ple c nantofgood f t and f i deai ul ve ie o am or e c he m i d ove aih ar lng. Pli ifsAlegai nsi Cou s11 V a VIa eTi Ba r d a ntf' l to n nt 1, nd r me- re J tasPl ntf cli f rbr c ofexpr s wa r y a br ac ofgood f ih f i a us ai ifs a ms o ea h e s rant nd e h at al s tme- red a wel ason t mert,he cli sf br a h ofwrte wara y unde t i ba r s l he is r am or e c it n r nt r he M a n s n s W arn yAc ( u t 1) b e c o t eFlrd De e tv a dUn arTr d g u o -Mo s ra t t Co n 11; r a h f h o i a c p ie n fi a e PrciesAc ( a tc t CountV) a co ; nd mmonlw faud( tVl as fi astme- rd. a r Coun ) lo al i bare l he Am e d Compl nt Pl i ifde c i t s re ofti s mader ga di he n r nde ai , antf s rbes he e i s rps he e r ng r br kest he de l r hi A sdic s d s pr he tr tr pa rpe f r e i a s i ton w ih t a o r a e s p. s us e u a, r i s e i r o m d n s oc a i t he ale ç e t e' arnglged ' ma ur 'we i down ofhe br kepadsandr or putPl ntf on notc ofhe pr r a ot s ai if ie r pr e cai .Spe i a l t sat esoflm ia i on Pl ntf scli be n t r a of es nt l ms cfc ly, he t ut i ttons ai if a ms ga o un s M a c 13, r h 2008 t dae ofhe i talr pai a 7, m ie ,on t ba i ofwhih s now pla , he t r nii e r t 673 l s he ss c he e ds d f c i t eb a es se P an ifalg s tc o s r d n t x e tt h v t is c o e e tn h rk y tm. litf l e ,s l n ume s o o e p c o a e o n pe t r e l r plc t br kepadsa r or a t o y 7, t 1 000 m ies' By na ur ofhe saed e a e he a nd ot s fer nl 500 o 5, l . ' t e r tt e ca i ,Pli ifwa on notc ofaleg de e tofhe Ve ce' br ke ;t t saut r xpe ttons antf s ie l ed f c r hi l s a s hus he t t o y cl k be n r nni a t fr toft S xpec ed, e at e ' e i s I ed,t Ve c e' oc ga u ng t he is he s une t pr m ur ' r pa r . nde he hi l s W a r nt is fa sse wihno i ,a i s i a l lsedbr kepadsand r or a eûie st t ra y tel s it d t tce s t pecfc ly it a ot s r ttm ha a es b e t od tro aind et n r l a, rvngh bt o c n iin , e p e sy r u j c t eeirto u o oma we r d ii a is r o dto s' x r sl ' dicl i t ts pat c dfi durngt covea perod. ai ifha upt tveye r (n s osng ha uch rs oul al i he rge i Pl ntf d o i a s i t c eofhe e e swarnt cai )orf y r (o ohe cli e ptt eunde t he as r xpr s ra y l ms our eas fr t r ams xce hos r he Flrd De e tv a dUn ar a ePrcie Ac a dalg to o u j s e c me t t fl o ia c pi e n fi Trd a tc s t n l ains f n u t mi h n) o ie e s t ui. A lhough t M a nus M os A c c ai no e es s a ut of lm ia i ,Pl n if s t he g on- s t ont ns xpr s t t e i t tons ai tf cam frbr c ofwrte warnt unde t M a on os W ara yAc ( li o ea h itn ra y r he gnus -M s rnt t Count11 i 1) s untm e y be us t cours l t m os a ogous s a e s a ut t de e ne whi h s a u e of i l ca e he t ook o t nal t t t t e o t nni c ttt lmiai n t a pl. a e r v Ali Mf Cop.2 2U. DitLEXI 9 8 a * ( . F a i tto s o p y Sa v d a . b n g. r , 01 S. s. S 61 , t 7 M D. l. J n. 7 2 2 . u t h v c n iee saeLe nLa a dt elmiain p ro g v r ig a 2 , 01 ) Co rs a e o sd rd tt mo ws n h i tto s ei d o e nn wa r nt c am sunde asae' c ra y l i r t t s omm e calc i t rr vi w ofM ag o M os cl ms 1 a r i ode n hei e e nus n- s ai . d. t *7- (ppl ngFl i sLe La sat eoflmiato t aM a on- scam) Mur ngi 8 a yi orda' mon w t ut i t ins o gnus Mos li ; u v. r de Be Cr di Cop. 1 2 F.Su 2d71 79( . N . 2001 ( di lmiai Me ce s nz e t r , 9 pp. , W D. Y. ) hol ng i ttons pe i f rt U CC i m os a opr a e f r a M a r od o he s t ppr i t o gnus M os c ai , a s cons de i t on- s l m but l o i rng he LemonLa .Regadl sofwhiha l w) r es c naogouslmiatonspe i i a i hee, ai ifscli i ti rod s ppled r Pl ntf am i untm e y. sdem ons r t d s pr Pl i if sw a r nt c ai underFl i sU nionn s i l A ta e u a, a ntf ra y l m orda' f Co ril d i tmeb re i s b e t otefv - e rsaueo lmiain f rb e c o mmeca Co e s i ard f u j c t h i ey a ttt f i tto s o ra h f e es wara ycai . a.St .j95.12)b) Si lry,Flrda' Le La hasatr xpr s r nt l ms Fl at 1 ( ( . mia l o i s mon w hee ye rsaut oflmia i t tc a t t e i t tons ha omm e eswih t delver oft ve c e whih oc r d he e nc t he i y he hil , c cure r i M ac 2007.j681.02,Fl Stt( n rh 1 a. a.2006), ed a,201 U. DitLEXI 961 a *7,Saav r 2 S. s. S 8, t 8. Thi Cour t r by dimi s sPl n if sCot IIa tm eba r s t he e s s e aitf mt 1 s i red. TheCour fndst tPli ifsCou VIca m,a lgi c t i ha antf nt li le ng omm on lw fa i sm ia l a r ud, s i lry tmeb re . mmo lw fa dcamsi Flrd aes b e t oaf t -e rsau eo lmiains i - ar d Co n a r u li n o i a r u j c t oz y a ttt f i tto r p ro Fl. tt j9 1 ( ) . i p ro c mme e a th t t fcsgvn rs t t e eid. a S a. 5.13 () Ths eid o nc s tt e i he a t iig ie o h t me c us ofa ton we edicove e ors d ha be n di c r wih t e r ieofdue a e ci r s r d houl ve e s ove ed t he xe cs dii nc 'Ihi v Wet 1 U. Dit LEXI 21 a #1 1 ( . Fl.Se 30,1 lge e. s i . l 998 S. s. ' y S 248, t 6- 7 M D. a p. 998) (ii Be nar Schoni rSho n Ce e s Lt v JP. Elst rc,Cor ,1 F.d 11 3 ctng r d nge ppig ntr, d. . S. a ome is p. 02 3 7 ( 1hCi.1 ) Asdic sdspr Pli ifsVe ceunde e alge yû e t e'r 1 t r 997). suse u a, antf hil m nt le dl s maur'font pr b ake pa a r orr pl ce enton M a c 1 2008; a ntf w oul have di c r d nd ot e a m r h 3, Pl i if d s over d ors d e houl ha dic r d anyaleg fa on t tda e. ve s ove e l ed r ud ha t Ther f et a iabl f ye rlm iatons e or he pplc e our a i t i perod e r on M a c 1 201 i xpied r h 3, 2. Pl i ifsc antf omm on lw fa aleg ton f l f a addii lr as Even unde t a r ud l a i ais or n tona e on. r he mos lnintra ngofRul 9( ,healgai i he Ame dCompl ntdonoti l t e e e di e b) t le tons n r nde ai ncude s fcen deaist sat ac us ofa i ofal ge fa Gr e r 264 F.Supp. a 1 ufi i t t l o t e a e cton le d r ud. e nbe g, 2d t 073. I t sCic t algai offa byomisonmus stf t wihpa tc aiy,t( )pr iey n hi rui, le tons rud si t e orh, t riulrt é1 ecsl wha o sin weema e a ()t tmea dplc o . E )o sins a d( ) h c n e t t miso s r d , nd 2 he i n a e f . t miso , n 3 t e o tn . he .. . o s c sae n sa dt emn n ri whc t e mildt panif a d( )wh t h d fnd ns f u h ttme t n h n e n ih h y se he litf, n 4 a t e ee a t obt ne a ac e nc oft fa 'Br av. u Cr st Bl Shi d,11 F. 1 ai d s ons que e he r ud. ook Bl e os t ue el 6 3d 364, ' 1 ( 1hCi.1 . ai iffist etbls t s nec s ayee nt-s fist aleget 371 1 t r 997) Pl ntf al o sa ih he e e s r lme s he al o l he mea De e ntus d t pe eta et a lge fa f e mpl,ora f t i c tng t ns f nda e o m r t he le d r ud, or xa e ny ac s ndia i he fa sexitnce Se aloAprglano v Am.HondaM ot Co. l . 201 W L 5788 a *1 r ud' se . e s i i . or , nc, 3 771 t 0 ( D. a. t29,201 . rc S. Fl Oc. 3) He ommonlw faudalgai fisa nont sgr a r le ton al gai hi ound. Tur ng t CountV, heCour fndst tPl i iff ist sa eatm ey c e ofaci ni o t t i ha antf a l o tt i l aus ton purua t t Fl i De ptvea Unfi Tr Prci sAc ( s nt o he orda ce i nd ar ade a tce t FDUTPA) Thesaut of . tt e lmiai f Pli ifscam underFDUTPA i f ye s Fl Stt j95. 13)9 ( ) A i ttons or antf li s our ar. a. a. 1 4 4 2006 . FDUTPA c am ac r esa t tm eofpur ha eorl as ofapr uc , upon dic r ofa l i c u t he i c s e e od t not s ove y n alge dee t Mathe v. HondaMot Co.201 U. DitLEXI 90802,a *11( D. le d fc. t ws Am. or , 2 S. s. S t S. Fl. une6,201 .ti wel-ete t r i notdeay dic r r l ' pplca et FDUTPA aJ 2) l s lstld hee s û l ed s ovey ue'a i bl o cams Marbor ghHol n Gr p,Lt v. i - net,505Fe Appx.899,906( 1h li . l ou digs ou d. AzmutBe ti d. 1t Ci. 3 ; athews, 2U. Dit LEXI 9 02a * 11; ntBl Soltons l .v r201 ) M t 201 S. s. S 08 t 9- Poi ank ui , nc . To Am.I .2011U. DitLEXI 51 a *1 ( D. a. a 1 2011. a e yobo , nc, S. s. S 457, t 8 S. Fl M y 3, ) Bec us - 12- Plitf la e t es be tv h cei M ac 2 0 t ef u - e rlmi to p ro rno h r an if e s d h u jc e il n rh 0 7,h o ry a i t ins ei d a n e a FDUTPA cai i 2011 s r y r be or s c me d t sa ton. lm n , eve al ea s f e he om nce hi c i Pl ntf at mpt t i ai if te s o nvoket docrneoffa e c eam e ,o equiabl eso , he ti r udulnt onc l nt r t e t ppel t t lt sat eoflmiai ont s tmebar cai Howe r lllfa e o ol he t ut i ttons he e i - red l ms. ve,ia rudulnt c n e l n cam i s be t oF d R. v. 9 b ' r q ie n t a tecru tn e o c ame t li s u j c t e . Ci P. ( )s e urme t h t h ic msa c s c tttngfa s l besae wihpatc a iy.UnderRul 9( ,t cic tnc oft onsiui rud hal ttd t riulrt e b) he rumsa es he fa m us beale wih s iiiy,Le t ç r ud t lged t pec fct . he who,what whe wher a how'oft a lge , n, e, nd he le d fa d (iain o te j'Gr e eg 26 F. u p 2 a 1 7 * e as Moo ev fie t Na 1 ru . ctto mitd . e nb r , 4 S p . d t 0 3 s e lo r . b ry t ' , L# I s Co, 6 F.d 1 09 1 1 ( lhCi. 0 ) Asd s rb ds pr wi r s c t Co nt n . .2 7 3 2 , 2 2 1 t r 2 01 . e cie u a t e pe t o u h I , ai i f sAm e V Pl ntf nded Com pl i f l t aleg wih pa tc a iy a c a m soff a a nt ais o l e t r i ul r t ny l i r udul nt e c e ment M o eove ,t i onc al . r r o nvokea faudulntc e m e t l Pl i ifm us plad f c s r e onc al nt ol, antf t e at e t ihi t tDef nda dei r t l a a i y c eaed t m aeralf ct f t pur e sabls ng ha e nt lbe a ey nd ctvel onc l he t i a s or he pos o id cn h rt d lyfln ti a to S eLiu v V ls ge Gr o , 0l U. Dit f n u i g e o ea iig hs cin. e c l . o l wa n p. fAm.2 3 S. s. c LEXI 1 627 a *1 ( D. a. c.5,201 .Shefist algeanyelme sofa i S 71 , t 6 S. Fl De 3) al o le e nt ctve fa entc eam e O t pa tofDef nda , uc l s t ta s h a t delye Pli ifs r udul onc l nt n he r e nt m h e s ha ny uc c s a d a ntf ' flng be nd t sat e oflm iatons Pl ntf a lgato a ountt ac am ofme e l ii yo he t ut i t i . ai ifs le i ns m o li r f nondicl ur 'whi unde Fl i lw,i l ly i ufi e t t lt sat e oflmiai ns Se s os e' ch, r orda a s egal ns fcint o ol he t ut i t to . e i a *1 18. a ntf cam oti d. t 7- Pli if l nvoket docrne offa entc e me orot r s t lt he ti r udul onc al nt he wie ol he a iabl sa ut oflm iatonsa t he cai . pplc e tt e i t i s o r l ms - 13- Plitf sAl g to of e c o Exp e sPa t a rny( u t l F is an if l ain Br a h f rs r W ra t Co n I) al e D ue t W a r nt Li ia i o r a y m t tons Pli ifc antf annotas e tt cli ss brngsi Count1 f rbr a ofe es s r he am he i n 1 o e ch xpr s part wa r t und Fl rdal w be a eal alege unr i bur e r paisoc ured l a tra ran y er o i a c us l l d em s d e r c r ong fe ny i vi lpa twa r nt ex r d. Pl i ifa t ly s i a e i he Re pons t De e ndi dua r ra y pie antf cual tpult s n r s e o f ndan ' ts M oint Dimista h rcam f rBra h o Ex rs P W a rny( u t1 o teFrt to o s s h t e li o e c f p e s M ra t Co n 1 f h is Ame e Co lit s o l b ds se , n t eCo rsa r e b c u ee c rparo nd d mpan) h ud e imis d a d h u t ge s e a s a h e i f Pli tf sfo a r arbr kepa a orr or t pl em or t n 1 m o hso 1 00 a n if r nt nd e a ds nd/ ot s ook ac e ha 2 nt r 2, 0 mie ahe t pr ousr pai on t tpa tc a c l s r he evi e r ha ri ulr omponen a t outi t wa r nt pe i t nd hus sde he ra y rod. D. Pl ntf' Cli f Br a hofl i W arnt ofMe c ntbiiy( ai ifs am or e c mpled ra y r ha a lt Count1 V) Fal on Ti i sa Prviy Gr is melnes nd i t ounds Tum i fnaly t CountI , t Cour fndst tPl ntf scl m f Br c ofl id ng i l o V he t i ha ai if ai or ea h mple W a r nt ofM e c t biiy f l f t r as . I f isa tm e bared,a do t ot rof ra y r han a lt ais or wo e ons t a l s i - r s he he Count lt ough VI.M or r t sCountf isf t i pe ntr as t tFl i lw s hr I eove , hi a l or he nde nde e on ha orda a r quiesprviy f i ple wa r nt cli s I t sc s ,no prviy e ssbe we Pli ifa e r i t or m id ra y am . n hi a e i t xit t en antf nd De e nt Acc di y,t Cour dimi s CountI . f nda . or ngl he t s s es V Un e Flrd lw,$ )c nr c a t n frb e c o i le warn yd e n ti wh r d r o ia a ta o ta t ci o r a h f mp id ra t o s o 1e ee ( o t r i no prviy ofco r c 'be we n apl i ifa def nda . We tnghou e Cor v Rui 5?7 he e s it nta t' t e antf nd e nt s i s p. . z, So. 5 596- ( a.3 DCA l ) s ealoFe lyv LA1Gam esSalsI ., 2009 U . 2d 96, 97 F1 d 988 ; e s hee e nc S. . DitLEXI 70 a *1 1 ( D. a.Aug.11 2009) Theprviy r quiementapplest l se s. S 430, t 8- 9 S. Fl , i t e r i o ea . aswela s l sta a tons O ' l s a e r ns c i . Connorv Kawas M ot sCor ., 699 F.Supp.1 38,1 43. aki or p 5 5 44 ( D. a 1 8 ) He e teAme d dCo an fist saeavai i idwar nycam S. Fl. 9 8 . r,h n e mpli t al o tt ld mpl e ra t li a i tDef nda , c net rl a e Pl ntf ' ve c ei 2007nors d i t he i 201 . A s gans e nt whi h ihe e s d ai ifs hil n ol t o r n 0 e ane by Brs on v For M ot Co., whe avehil i pur has diecl fom ade e a xpli d is . d or n c e s c ed r ty r alr s op edt t m a a t e -asoc ur e he e prviy e ssbewee t pli ifand pos o he nuf c ur r c r d r -no i t xit t n he a ntf ma a t e .602 F.Supp. 1 nuf c ur r 2d 227,1 , n. ( . F a 2 0 )afdi r lv n pa t v c td o 232 5 M D. l. 0 9 f ' n ee a t r, a ae n ot gr her ounds 3 Fe Appx. 433( 1h Ci. , 49 d. 1 t r zooglquotngBaie 1 Fe Appx. t894n.) t i ly, 68 d. a 1; s ealo Ce a aniv Ame i anHonda M ot r Co., 91 So. 8 8 ( a Dit CtApp. e s rs . rc o 6 2d 43, 47 Fl. s. . 2005) . Ha ngpla no hi t s vi e ded t ng o ugges an exc pton t t sge r r e, Pl n ifsi pled t y e i o hi ne al ul aitf m i wa r nt cli sar ba r by l k ofprviy.TheAme d Compli ma sno a lga i of ra y am e red ac it nde ant ke le ton eihe c r cualprviy orage nea nc r a i hi bewee De e t r onta t i t nui ge y eltons p t n f ndanta t de e s p nd he alr hi whih a r nge t l s a uli aepur ha eofhe vehil . A sa m a t r ofl w ,Pl n if s c ra d he ea e nd tm t c s r ce te a ai t f a lgai i i ufi i . le ton s ns tcent Oc v For Mot Co.992 So. 31 ( a.3 DCA 2008)i i tuci Oc ana . d or , 2d 9 Fl d s nsr tve. ana a fr d t dim is l on t pl di , ofi id wa r n y c am sagans def nda For . The fime he s s a , he ea ngs mple ra t li i t e nt d pl n ifi Oc aleg t tFor , asfa hie ,sxeciesconr o r 1 deaerl ai ai tf n ana l ed ha d rnc s r l r s e tol ve : ) l oc ton, sz , n n mb r d ae lg so d ae ' rmie ; )p ie gv nt d ae ' mply e ; ) ie a d u e of e lr o o n e lr p e s s 2 rz s ie o e lr e o e s 3 numbe ofbahr r t oomsde lrmus ma avalbl t t publc;4)tani a c riiai of ae t ke ia e o he i r i ng nd e tfc ton s lsa s r c pe s nne . 1 a 326. or ove , s alege t tFor C e r st tisde e s ae nd e vie r o l' d t ' M e r he l d ha d t quie ha t alr r 5)us ma a t e -upple comput s t r ;6)rpor ve ces e a s edeal, e nufcurrs id er ofwa e e t hil als nd al tis i l ng na ea add es ofpur has a r lt d i onna i , t ma a t e' pr de ncudi m nd r s c er nd ea e nf ton o nufcur r 7) ovi , - 15- wa rnys r iep i f rb F r M oo Co n ; n 8 a f r F r t erg tt e trte ra t e vc ad o y o d tr mpa y a d ) fo d o d h ih o n e h de l ' busnes pr miest a tt r or and o r tonsoft de l rhi ast s l sa aers i s e s o udi he ec ds pe a i he a e s p o a e nd sr i .'d I dimisngt ealgai a i uf i unde Rul 1 b)6)t e tbls e vce'I n s si hes le tons s ns fcent r e 2( ( o sa ih prviy,heOcana c t e t a e e it t our not d he bs nc -cqua l cons c ly piuoushe e ofS ny a lga i ofs m e r t le ton o a - oft t lt e s g ofa pr nc pala ntr l tons p, s h ast a lt oft prncpalt hie he el-al i ns i i - ge e a i hi uc he biiy he i i o r , fr ,ors r s de l rhi e oy sorde l rownerhi .' ie upe vie a e s p mpl ee ae s p vJ. Abs nthe efom t pl di i a a lga i t Pl ntf a anytm ec muni td e r r he ea ngs s ny le ton hat ai if t i om cae i a wa wih Defnda , t i c n ny y t e nt eiher n onneci n wih t las , s vii oruli t pur has of to t he e e er c ng, tma e c e hervehil a trt e ye so t r d. Be us t Am e d Co pl ntm a no ale ton of c e fe hr e ar n he oa ca e he nde m ai kes lga i eihe c r cualprviy orage nea nc r a i hi be wee De e t r onta t it nui ge y eltons p t n f ndanta t de e s p nd he alr hi whih a r ng d t l s a uli ae pur ha eofhe ve c e, a pladsno f csfom whih c ra t he ea e nd tm t c s r hil nd e at r c prviy oratuea nc r a i hi c n be i e r d, t Cour di m i s s t s Count it r ge y eltons p a nf re he t s s e hi . Eve i Pli ifwe e i c r t prviywih De e n f antf r n ontacual i t t f ndant a i ple wa r nt on he i d ra y r , ny m br kepadsa r or wa lmie i dur ton t 1 mont / 2,000- 1 . Vehi e' a nd ot s s i t d n ai o 2hs 1 mies The cl s W a r nt expr s l a cons c ra y e sy nd pi uousy lm ist dur ton ofa i ple wa r ntest t t l i t he a i ny m i d ra i o he enn oft a ia e e es wa r nt sa i tAny i i w a r nt , i l ng a wa rnt of he pplc bl xpr s ra y, t tng:s mpled r a y ncudi ny r a y m e c ntbiiy o wa r nt off s f apa tc a pur e, i lm ie i dur ton t t sa e r ha a lt r r a y hne s or riulr pos s i t d n a i o he t t d pe i o t s wrtenwara i s' rod f he e it r nte . ' Plitf' Un u tEn ih n Cli ( u tVIl F i a aM atro La an ifs j s rc me t am Co n 1) al s te f w s Plitf atmp si Co n VIIt a s r Ent eatmai 'acam f rt u te rc me t an if te t n u t I o se td h le t ' li o mj s n ih n i ve - 1 6- de piet e se e ofa e es wa r nt gove ni he rght . Thi a gume i c r r t s t he xit nc n xpr s r a y r ng r i s s r nt s onta y o t eweg t fa t rt h l igta a u j s e ih n cam c no l b p e i t eatr aie h ih o uho i o dn h t n nu t nrc me t li a ny e ld n h len tv y i o eo moepate c ne ttee itn eo a e prs c nrc g v r n tes be t ft e f n r r ris o ts h xse c f n x e s o ta t o enig h u j c o h diput Se ,eg. Zar e l v Pac Lf I s Co.75 F. p . d 1 8 1 2 ( D. l. 01 ) s e. e . , r la . # n . , 5 Su p 2 21 , 2 7 S. F a 2 0 . . Un e Flrd lw,û us e rc me ti a e utberme ywhc n c sa i fisu o a d r o ia a çmj t n ih n s n q ia l e d ih e e s rl al p n t y s howi t tan e e sc r texit .'Al ar z v Ro Carbbe Cr s s Lt 905 F.Supp. ng ha xpr s ontac ss ' v e . yal i an uie , 4 2 1 3 ,1 41( D. a 2 2 . a e utberme y a u j s e rc me t li c n o b d 3 4 3 S. Fl. 01 ) As n q ia l e d , n nu t n ih n cam a n t e mant i whe e apl ntf ha a a i aned r ai if s n dequaer m e a lw . Zar ela,755F.Supp.2d a 1 t e dy t a r l t 227. He e, a et r i a e e swa r nt go m i Pli tf srght , he u j te rc me t r bec us he e s n xpr s ra y ve ng a n if i s r nus n ih n cli m us f i. d.Pl i ifsf iur t sae acai f br c ofwa r nt doe no s vet am t a l1 antf a l e o tt l m or ea h ra y s t a he u j t n ih n cam. iu v ok wa nGr o , 01 U. Dit LEXI 1 6 7 a nus e rc me t li L c l .V ls ge p. fAm.2 3 S. s. S 71 2 , t *22n.2( D.Fl De 5, )(s- tPli if'warnt a FDUTPA camsma as prve S. a. c. 2013 ûlha antfs ra y nd li y lo o wih u me id e n ti c wh te teru j s e rc me t li s o l b ds se a t o t rt o s o mpa t eh r h i nu t n ih n cam h ud e imis d s duplc tve.) TheCour dimis CountVI1 iai ' . ' t s ses l. F. CountI X I i unne s a y f t Cour t cont m pl t w he he Pl i i fva i y s a esa c us of ts ce s r or he to e ae t r a ntf ldl t t a e aci n i Cou 1 , i i mer l apr ye f de a at y r le syld i t f m ofa fna to n nt X as t s ey a r or clr or e if t e n he or i l dam a i ppr it f co i r ton. i nd na opra e or nsde ai - 17- I . V Co l i ncuson Fort a or mento d r as ,t Cour tndst tPl n iff ist a quaey sa ea he f e i ne e ons he ti ha aitf al o de tl tt vald c us ofa ton i a oft ei Count ofherAm e i a e c i n ny he ght s nded Compl i .Ea h i tm e ba r d, ant c s i - re a i addii ke elm e sofhe ca msa em isng,r nde i t ecli sf rhe i ld. nd n ton, y e nt r li r s i e rng hos am u t r nvai De e ntVol wa n Gr ofAm e i a I ' M oton t Dim isi he e GRANTED and f nda ks ge oup rc , nc.s i o s s s r by t sc s DI I hi a e SM SSED . D N A DO D R DiCabraMi i li,i?oaoAr,04 O E N R EE n hme t a , od ts dy fpl 1. s m F rah i2 ' .v. . ' .. .... .. , . -; ,: .. Me , . e. e .'* ' ' Vy. Jr > j .A . . FEDE AP REN O UNI D STATES DI T STRI J CT UDGE Copi spr de t e ovi d o: Co e ofRe or uns l c d - 1 8-
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
