Gandhi et al v. Carnival Corporation, No. 1:2013cv24509 - Document 15 (S.D. Fla. 2014)

Court Description: Order Granting Defendant's Motion to Strike and Motion to Dismiss Counts II, III, and IV of Complaint. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 3/14/2014. (bnt)
Download PDF
Gandhi et al v. Carnival Corporation Doc. 15 UNI TED STATES DI STRI COURT FOR THE CT SOUTHERN DI STRI OF FLORI CT DA M im iDi son a vi i Ca eNum ber 13s : 24509- V- ORENO Cl M PM CHIGANDHIand ABI SHEK GANDHI as , Pa e a Naur l Gua di ns of AM W A r nt nd t a r a GANDHI a m i ,a PRACHIGANDHIa , nor nd nd ABHI SHEK GANDHI l vi l , ndi dualy, Pl i if , a ntf s VS. CA RN I A L CO R PO RA TION , d/ a V b/ CARN I VAL CRUI LI SE NES,m C. , De e nt f nda . / O R DER G R AN TI G DEFEND AN T ' M O TI N T O STR I E and M O TI N TO N S O K O D I I C O U N TS l .1 1 and I ofPLA I TI S C O M PLA I T SM SS I 1. V N FF' N THI CAUSE c m e be o e t Coul upon De e nts M o i n t Sti Alegai i S a f r he ' t f nda ' to o rke l tons n Count l of Pl i if ' Compli a M oton t Di mi s Count 1, 11 a I of Pl ntfs antfs ant nd i o s s s 1 1, nd V ai if ' Compli ( E. 7 ,ie onJanuar 9. 4. sc e, c i acaebr hti a miat ant D. No. ) fld v 201 Thi as whih s s oug n d r ly, c n e sp ro a ij re alg dys san db Plitfsd rngt ec u s o ac us o o eo o c m es n lnu is le e l u ti e y an if u i h o re f r ie n n f Ca i Cor ai sc u s ve s s De e m val por ton' r i e s el. f ndant e kst srkepa t Count oft Compl nt nd s e o ti r of I he ai a dim i s t Com pl i ' Count l, II a I . Fo t f l ng r a ons t Cour gr nt s s he a nt s s 1 I nd V r he olowi e s , he t a s De e f ndan ' M o i t Dim is Count 1,1la I M or ove , t Cour gr nt Def nda ' ts ton o s s s I I nd V. e r he t a s e nt s M oto t Sti t r s is l t rr e e esi CountlofPli if 'Com pl nt alhough t i n o rke he e p a oquiu ef r nc n antfs ai , t he Cour r e ve isdec sononwhehe ar si s l t i t ci wil a opraelt ri t s t es r s t ii t r e p a oquiur nsnlton l be ppr i t a e n hi Cas e. Dockets.Justia.com Fa ualBa kc ound ct c r Pli if Pr c a Abhihe Ga antfs a hi nd s k ndhia lge t tt rda e ,Pl ntf Ar na Ga hi le ha hei ught r ai if ai nd , wa ij rdwh nh ram c u h i a ee ao d o o av se o eae b Dee d n Can v l s n u e e e r a g t n n lv t r o r n e s l p r td y fn a t r i a Co or i du i avoy a s a. or ngt t Compl i , ai wassa ngi ane e t r m aton rng age t e Acc di o he ant Ar na t ndi n l va o whenhe l ta m wasdr wn i o t s ei o whih o sde oft eeva o doo swa si i r ef r a nt he pac nt c ne i he l t r r s ld ng. The elvat door a lge y ate e t c os and ope wih he a m e r ppe untla he e or s le dl tmpt d o l e n t r r nta d i not r p s nge us d a c r1 g t as i ti r l s ng t ar . as e r e hai e o s s n e ea i he m Pl ntfsPr hiGa hi ndAbhihekGa ai if ac nd a s ndhi e t tAr i s t nedadee l c r ton plad ha ana usai p a eai t he lf ebow,a s ve i ofoneofhert o r et l e rng endons a a facur l a ton,Pli tf Abhihe , nd r t e. n ddii a n if s k Ga ndhicai s t ha wines e Ara nas or a i e iet a aleg t t he ha s f r d l m o ve t s d ii ' de l n ntr y nd l es ha s ufe e e oi m tonaldi t e s as a r s t l t i Com pl i ,Pl i i f pl a t f l w i Count ag ns sr s e ul. n he r a nt a ntf s e d he olo ng s ai t Dee d n Canv l p oain:l ane lg nc cam f r a g so t emio c idAria (1 fn a t r ia Co rto () gie e li o d ma e f h n r hl an , 1) ' aca m f rda a purua t t ne i nti lc i ofe o i ldites ofAbhihe Ga hi li o m ges s nt o he glge nfiton m tona sr s s k nd ; (1)adama scam f me c e 11 ge li or dial xpens i ure b Prc Ga a Abhihe Gan ;a es nc rd y a hi ndhi nd s k dhi nd (V) a g scam r ltn t t ls o fl l o s ri m o Prc i nd i n Ab ih kGa d i l ad ma e li eaig o he o s f ii c n o t f a h Ga h a d h s e n h . a u Def nda Ca ni lCom or tonsr s e nt r va a i e ponde b flngisM oton t Sti Ale tonsofPli if d y ii t i o rke l ga i a ntfs' Compli a t Dimi sCou s1,1, nd I ofPl i if Compli , c t Cou t ddr s e ant nd o s s nt 1 11 a V antfs' antwhi h he r a e s s nOW . 11 1. Leaa St nda d l a r Th Co r h sj rs ito i t sa to p ru n t 28U. C.j 1 3 ( 0 6 . a to e u t a u idc in n hi cin u s a t o S. 3 3 2 0 ) An ci n iv l igp ro a ij re s san da o r as pwhl a s ai ac s i a miat .d j1 3 ( ) n o vn es n lnu is u ti e b a d hi ie t e s a e n d rly 1 . 3 3 1 . , s aloCar v Cr s Li s I .v Shut 499U. 585, (1 )Ar haws iv. ot, 0 ee s nial uie ne , nc . e, S. 590 991. c k Hani i35 , U. 5 2, 3 -3 ( 9 6 .t s l-ete ta g n rl tmelw a pl st a to sa iigfo S. 3 5 2 3 1 5 )l i wels tld h t e ea mmii a p i o cin rsn r m e alg dtrsi o te a o r as i sii i n via l wae s'Kef , 6 F.da 1 21 s e l e o t ' mmitd b ad hp al n a g b e tr. ee 8 7 2 t 3 ; e e c ng ' alo Be d v Nonvgi Carbbe Li s 900 F. 71( h Ci.1 ;Po drTal ,l .v s ar . e an i an ne , 2d 6t r 990) pe bot nc . Hawn, 4 U. 4 6( 9 3 . c r igy t p ee t cini c nr le b g n rl rtmelw. 3 6 S. 0 1 5 )Ac o dn l,he r s n a to s o to ld y e ea maii a S eEx c tv J t ito , n . . t o e ea d 40 U. 2 9 2 3( 9 2 ; r mo t n . . e e uie e Ava in I c v Ci fclv l n , 9 S. 4 , 5 1 7 ) Fo e s I s Co y v Rih r s n, 7U. 6 8, 7 ( 9 2 .nt ea s n eo aweld fn db d o ma i me1w . c a d o 45 S. 6 6 4 1 8 ) l h b e c f l- eie o y f rt a i r a i t a pa tc a cai ,g r lma ii e1 w i s eme e by eihersa e1w org ner l eltng o ri ul r l m ene a rtm a s uppl nt d t tt a e a c omm on 1w prnci es For a i pl . emos I .Co. 457 U . a 674. t ns , S. t Unde Fe rlRul ofCi lPr dur 8()2) apladi mus c ai ats ta pl n r dea e vi oce e a( , e ng t ont n shor nd ai sae e oft cai s t tm nt he l m howi t tt pl de i e ild t r le . Dim is lf f iur t sae ng ha he ea r s ntte o ei f' s s a or a l e o t t ' acai i wara t twhe i a ar t tt pl n ifhasltl orno c nceofs e s ie,whe l m s r n ed s n t ppe s ha he aitf ite ha ucc s , .. n t c he ompli on is f c make cla l bas l s a lga i orr le on l alt ore t ta e ant t ae s e ry ees le tons ei s eg he i s ha r ids u a l rte s'Wr l ov Ma t Ctt l le # k 4 F d Ap x5 5 5 6( 1h r2 0 ) n ip tbyme i s . u nn . ri p nys r . 3 3 e . p' 3 , 3 1 tCi. 0 9 4 l ' n l / s eas As c o v I b l 1 9S. . 9 7, 9 -5 ( 0 9 ( c mplitmu tc n an s fi in e lo h rft . q a , 2 Ct 1 3 1 49 0 2 0 ) A o an s o ti u fce t f c ua m a tr ac e e a tue,t d tt acli t r le t ti pl i e on isf ce'n or rt a t l te , c pt d s r o s ae am o e if ha s ausbl s t a 'i de o s r ie a mo in t d s s ..Fo p r s so a mo i n t d s s ,te Co r mus v e te u vv to o imis) r u po e f to o imis h u t t iw h al gai oft Com pli i t lg m os f vor bl t Pl ntf,c i rt a lga i oft le tons he a nt n he i ht t a a e o ai if onsde he le tons he Co pli a tu a a e a 1 ea o bl i e e est r r m . Sc erv Rhode , 6U. m a nt s r e, nd cc pt l r s na e nf r nc he efo See heu . s 41 S. 232,236( 97 . 1 4) - 3- Leg lAna ys s a l i M oto t Sti Pli if 'Re e e e t t DocrneofRe I a Loquiu i n o rke antfs f r nc s o he ti s ns tm Pl ntfs cam f ne i ncei Count1pladst a iato oft docrneofr sf ai if' li or glge n e he pplc in he ti e pm l t r I t sM oton,De e oquiu . n hi i f ndan m ovest srke t as e ton ofr s is l t r wihi t t o ti he s ri e p a oquiu t n he Cou ,a g ng t ti i nota c us ofa to De e nt i co r c .t-he Su e e Cou thas nt r ui ha t s a e c i n. f nda s r e t sl pr m r de l a1w o r s,J l tri ad r t t tpemist tiroff tt drw i e e e o veoped a f e > w oquiu n mialy ha r t he re ac o a nfrnc s f ne l e c fo u e p an dcr u tn e .fxleo a kn b a kn v Fa r llie,nc, 0 gi n e rm n x lie ic msa c s' / / fL r is yL r is . r elv sI .8 6 g ' n F. 51 51 ( h Ci.986)( tngJohns v.Unie St e 333 U. 46,68,68 S. .391 92 2d 0, 2 4t r1 cii on td ats, S. Ct , L. 468( 9 ) Puta he wa i a rly, e is l t i r e nti deemi ngwhih Ed. 1 48 . not r y,n dmiat r sp a oquiur s elva n tr ni c c s so u x lie cru tn e s o l g t t ej r I a 51 Toiv k ted crn o r s a e f ne pan d ic msa c s h ud o o h uy.d t 2. n o e h o tie f e i al t ,t pli ife tbls $û1 t eve i ofatpewhihor naiydoesnotha ps oquiur he antf sa ihes 1( ) he nt s y c di rl ppen i t ea s n eo s me n 'n gie c ;()t ei snz n ai c usngt eij r wa , th t n h b e c f o o es e l n e 2 h n t me tlt a i h nu y s a te i g y me oft a i t wihi t e l i conr oft defnda ;(ndq( t a ci ntwa no duet he ccden, t n he xcusve tol he e nt a 3) he c de s t o a yv l naya t no c nrb to o tep r o t epli if' I a 51 ( oigOle v Sats n o u tr ci r o tiu in n h a t f h antf ' d t 3 qu t o ' n sn . t e Li ,378F. 21 220( h Ci.1 . ne 2d 7, 9t r 967) Re IJ l tri t notaspaaec eofa ton;at r ii a e de ir docrne s J oquiu s hus e rt aus ci r he ,t s n vi ntay ti t tpe m ist ti roff tt i e neglgenc fom cic sa ile denc Pu s tt Fe r ha r t he re ac o nf r i er r um t nta vi e. r uan o de al Rueo CiiPr c d r 1 4 t i Co r ma srk fo Pli tf pla igiv c to o r si a l f vl o e u e 2 9,hs u t y tie r m anifs e dn n o ain f e ps l q iu a i tra ma tr Fe . Ci . 1 9. epup eo amo int srk i loce n o utr s mmaeil t . d R. v P. 24 Th r os f to o tie s i la e t u t pl di ,sr mlne ltga i a a d unnec s a y f r i o i matra ma tr .' p he ea ngs tea i ii ton, nd voi e s r o ays nt m e i l te s' M cnene v Mo rLumb drHa dwar ,I ,244 F.Supp.2d 393,402 ( D.Pa.2002) For l r y . ye er r e nc. E. . e mpl i fobe i rv.Ceebrt Cr s s J e Alona dim is d t pl ntf scli f xn e, n gege l i y uie , udg t ga s s e he ai if am or - 4- S lge eBasd on Re I a Lo tf'ex ani t t docti ofr sf w I t wa d i nc Neg e s ps quiu , pli ng hat he rne e rJ oquiur s i ppr itl i na opraey nvoked a ac us ofaci 2011W L 3703329,* ( D.Fl.Aug.23,2011. s a e ton. 7 S. a ) Si lry,Pli if heepl dr slJ l trwihi Count1 wheei t youghtt lmi t i mial antfs r ea e / J oquiu t n , r n he o i t her a l ga i ns i t Cou t t c e of a i of ne i nc A c di y,t Cour GR AN TS le to n hat nt o he aus cton glge e. cor ngl he t De e nt 'M o i t Sti Pl ntfs Ref e est t DocrneofRe I a Loquiu i Count f nda s ton o rke ai if ' er nc o he ti s ps tr n 1 Howe r t Cou tr e v isde son ast whe he a r s i a I t r i tuci wilbe . ve , he r es r es t cii o t r e ps oquiu nsr ton l a oprat l t r i t sca e ppr i e a e n hi s . B. CountI :N eg i ntI lc i ofEm otonalD it e s I lge nfi ton i sr s Count1 ofPl i ifsCompl ntr quessda 1 antf ai e t mage f De e ntsN e i entl lci of s or f nda ' glg nfiton Emotona Dites . r a et e pr domi nt e t whih a s s cl m sofneg i nti lc i of i l sr s The e r hr e e na t ss c s e s ai lge ntiton e i ldites a delmirco r f e i lda ge ( )t physca i c ts,( t motona sr s nd i t e vey or motona ma s: 1 he i lmpa t et 2) he z ofda rts, nd( t r ai b tndert tSe Cons . lCor v Gots l5l U. one nge eta 3)he eltve ysa es. e olRai p. . thal, 2 S. 532, 49( 994)Thephy i li ctetrquiest tapli ifseki dama f 546. 1 . sca mpa ts e r ha antf e ng ges oremotona i l ij r s h v c n e o a e u l s sane ap y ia i a tn matr o sih ) r nu yd e n uymu t a e o tmp rn o sy u ti d h sc lmp c ( o te h w lg to ij r u t t def nt c o he enda ' onduc . d.a 547. s c t s,t zoneofda rt t lm isr ove y f s t1 t The e ond e t he nge es, i t ec r or e to a ij r t p an if wh s san ap y ia i a ta ars l o ad fn n ' n g ie t moi n l n u y o litfs o u ti h sc l mp c s e ut f ee da ts e lg n c onduc o who a epl edi i e at rs ofphysc lhar byt tco tr r ac n mm di e ik ia m ha nduc . d a 5 5 The t l t 47- 48. t r lm ii t t t r l tve b t dert t e ua e a pl ntf r a i hi t a a i nt hid i tng es, he e ai ysan es, val t s ai ifs eltons p o n ccde vi tm ,hi pr m iy t an ac i nts e a w he he t pl ntf e re e s ck d t a ci s oxi t o c de c ne, nd t r he ai if xpe i nc d ho ue o s ns y a c e por neo obs r a e oft ac de . d e or nd ont m a us e v nc he ci nt l - 5- TheElve t Cic thase i tya edt s condoft s t ss t z ofda rt s, e n h r ui xplcil dopt he e he e e t ,he one nge e t aspa toff rlmaii lw. Cha r v Car valCor aton,693F.3 133 ( 1h Ci. r edea rtme a See paro . ni por i d 3 1t r 201 (ttng,tfde a maii 1w ha a e .t tone ofda r ts ) The Cic ts 2) sai se r l rtme a d doptd..he z nge' e f'. rui' a dopto oft z ofda rt ti eo i t ntw ih isw i s ea a ce a e by c t s ti i i n he one nge es s ns s e t t de pr d c pt nc our s i tng n a r ly a t i dmiat nd he mpora e of f t rng unior iy i a r ly l w.See gene aly Smih v tnc ose i f m t n dmiat a r l t . Car v Cor ,58 F. zd 13 1 ( D.Fl 2008) Tas nar v.Ke lrs Wat Tour, nial p. 4 supp. 43, 353 S. a. ) si i y le' er s f L. , 0F. zd 1 8,1 ( D. a 2007) Purua tt azoneofda ra l i,e t i C.48 supp. 31 320 S. Fl. . s n o nge nayss ours n t eElv nhCic i l t e o eyfre to a ij r t tos plitfswh û u ti ap ysc l h e e t r ut i rc v r o moi n ln u y o h e anif o ' san h ia mi s i c a ar s t ade e mpa t s e ulof f ndan ' ne i en c ts glg t onduc , whoa epl c i i medit rs ofphysca t or r a ed n m a e ik i l ha m byt tc r ha onduc .' t 584 F. t'Smih, supp. a 1 zd t 354.Ac or ngl t pr vai i t spr e ng, c di y, o e l n hi oc edi Pl ntf she em us c ai m or t n m e ew ine sofat a a i eve t s ûc entypl d ne i en ai i f r tlm e ha r t s r um tc nt o uf i l ea glg t i lc i ofe i ldites . e Cha r a 1 nfiton motona sr s Se par o t 338. Eve vi w i t ale tons of t Com pl i t i t lg m os f a e t Pl i if , n e ng he l ga i he a n n he i ht t avor bl o a ntf s Pl i if he eha notplad s tce f c st s ts yt zoneofdange t s . Pl ntf Abhihe antfs r ve e ufi int a t o a if he r e t ai i f s k Ga hial ge o yt thewines e t alege i i nto t c i es p a t tasar ul o nd le s nl ha t s d he l d nc de n he nzs hi nd ha es t f hi die o e v tonsand hi a t m pt t he p hi da ht r hes f r e o i na dit es . H ehas s r d bs r a i s te s o l s ug e , uf e ed m t o l s r s nota l ed t the e t rs t i d a phys c li pa ta a r ul ofCa i l sa l ged ne i nc or leg ha ihe us a ne i a m c s es t m va ' le glge e t the wasa t l pl c i i e ae rs ofphysca ha m by Ca i lsal ge ne i e . ha c ualy a ed n mm di t ik i l r m va ' le d glg nce Thi Cour t r by dimi s Count1 oft Pli ifsCompl i . s t he e s s es 1 he antf ant The Cour not t tPl i if a t es ha antfs cknowldge t tt weghtofa t iy i t El ve h e ha he i u hort n he e nt Cic tdoesno r cog z a c a m f ne i en i lc i ofe o i r ui t e ni e l i or glg t nfi ton m tonaldit es . Aga ns t stdeof sr s i t hi i a hort Pl i if haveur dt sCour t adopthet r oft t eeprma yt ssouti da ut iy, antfs ge hi to t hid he hr i r e t lne bove, - 6- t r ltvebysa rt s ,orus he e. antfs a gume sa eunpe s svea s t Cour he e he e ai t ndv e tf e r Pl i if ' r nt r r ua i nd o he t r r esco it l wiht sCic tspr c nt Thez ofda rt s ha be n c e ry e t bls ul nssenty t hi r ui' e ede . one nge e t s e l a l sa ihed f ru ei f d rlmaii c s s s ei a 1 3 - 8 a dwh l oh r u id cinsma f lw te o s n e ea rtme a e , e d t 3 7 3 , n ie t e j rs ito y ol h o r ltvebysa rt s f rneglge i lc i ofe oto ldite scli s a pton oft t s he e ea i t nde e t o i nt ntiton m i na sr s am , do i he e t r i no c pai ewiht goal ofma ii el w.' hena yi m a ii lw , c t mus a r s t om tbl t he s rtm a l W ppl ng rtme a ours t dhe e t t prnc plsofha mony a unio miy. Sut v Car v Cor , o he i i e r nd f r t ' er . ' nial p.2007W L 46621 *3( D. 44, S. Fl M a 1 2007) s aloDoev. lbrt Cr s ,I .3 F. 8 , ( t Ci. a. y 4, ;ee s Cee i uies nc, 94 3d 91 902 11h r2004)(t y she t p r o eb hndt ee ecs o ti Co r' a miat j rs ito i t p o ie f rteu fnn u p s e i h x r ie f h s u ts d r l u id ci n s o r vd o h nio y a iai ofge r lma ii 1 '.Cic tc t a r st c r us t zoneofda rt t pplc ton ne a rtme aw') rui ours cos he ounty e he nge es i a ia i ofge r lm a ii lw,a i i nott sCour' plcet a tm ptt at rm a ii n pplc ton ne a rtme a nd t s hi ts a o te o le rtme lw a dds p isu io mi S e eg.Ba k rv He c lsO fho e I .71 F.d20 , 2 ( t a n inlt t n fr t e , . , r e . r u e fj r , nc, 3 3 8 2 4 5h y. Ci. 3)(t rmaii l abysa rc nnotrc meeyf winesi ham t a he r201 d unde rtme aw, tnde a e over rl or t sng r o not r w he e t b t nde s f r d no ha m ortu'a .' . r he ys a r uf e e r let' l Co 11 M edialExpe es unt 1: c ns Count1Ioft Compli ta lge ve y smpl t tasaçdiec a pr m a er s toft I he a n le s r i y ha i r t nd oxi t e ul he ne i nc oft Def nt . Pr c Ga glge e he enda .. a hi ndhia Abihe Ga nd s k ndhii ure ce t n outofpoc t nc r d rai ke expe esf t hos t i ton a m edi lc r a tea m entoft rc l , A r i G a ,a ns or he pialza i nd ca a e nd r t hei hid a na ndhi nd w il i l i trs e ns i t f ur .'Howe r Pli if ' ai i Count (s i ne ' l lke y nc t uch xpe es n he ut e ' ve , antfs cl m n It Neglge e' ) s e t r ove Ge nss ofhos t i to gndlme c la nuri c r a te t ntof e ks o ec r dxpe e pialzain, a dia nd sng a e nd rame da ht rA r i ' ug e a na. ' Pli if ca antf s nnotr ove t s m e alege da a m uli e tm e ec r he a l d m ges tpl i s Pli if de a . antfs m nd r i b s m e ofAr i spas medial em ur e nt ana' t c expe e aswelasf t emedi le ns i Coun 1 a ns s l u ur ca xpe es n t4s ar ul, hi Cour GRANTS De e n ' M oton t DimisCountlId t isduplc t nalr es t t s t f nda ts i o s s 1 ue o t ia e tze. D, CountI Los ofCons tum V: s ori Co I ofPli if Co ai r que t damag f t l sofc ori oft unt V a ntfs' mpl nt e s s es or he os ons tum h em i nor daug e Ar naofPl ntfsPr c Ga ht r ai ai if a hi ndhia Abihek Ga hi Li Count1, nd s nd . ke 1 CountI f ist V al o sae acai unde g ne a ma ii el w . tt l m r e r l rtm a Ge r l a ii elw doesnot ut iel sofc ori cai s Se M ie v Ape a ne ne a m rtm a a horz os ons tum l m . e ls . xM ri Cop.4 8U. 1 ( 9 0 ; a v S ceyEx dto s I .39F. 1 (t Ci.1 ; c s r , 9 S. 9 1 9 ) Ch n . o it pe iin , nc, 3d 398 9h r 994)Nihol p Per e Helco e s I ., l F.d 1 9 1 2 3( t Ci.1 9 ) Fr n o v Ro Ca bbe . tol um i ptr , nc 7 3 1 , 2 -2 5h r 9 4 ; a g yal ri an . Cr se , t ,891So. 2 1 0 ( a DitCtAp 2 05 . eSu rmeCo r hedi M i sv ui s L d. d 2 8 Fl. s. . p. 0 ) Th p e ut l n l e . Ape x M arne Cor t tda a f l sofs i t a e notr cove a eunderge r m a ii lw f i p.ha m ges or os oc ey r e r bl ne al rtme a or t wr ulde t ofas a . 498U. a 37. l ngM ie , courshavec itntyhel t t he ongf a h e man S. t Folowi ls t onsse l d ha ge a ma ii e lw does notpr de f l s of s ey orl s of c ori i c u s lne ner l rtm a ovi or os ocit os ons tum n r ie i p s e g rij r c s s S el r Ev r a sIl dBo tT u s LLC,484 F.Supp.2d 1259, 1 a s n e nu y a e . e n e eglde san a o r, 263 ( . Fl 2007)Al reli NCL Cor ., 20 8U. DitLEXI 5 7 9( D. l . uy29 2008) M D. a. ; be t lv. p 0 S. s. S 7 8 S. F a J l , Ci cam f l sofco o tum i notpemitdunde ge r maii l , and t ef em us A li or os ns ri s r te r neal rtme aw her or t bedimis ' Mari zv DannOce Towig, I c, 0 U. Dit LEXI 20 4 ( . Fl. s sed.l; tne . an n n .20 5 S. s. S 9 6 M D. a 2 0 )I b r e v Cee rt Cr ie, nc, 0 6U S. s. 0 5 ;s e n r . lb i us s I .2 0 y DitLEXI 9 9 4( D. a 20 6 (' h S 4 3 S. Fl. 0 ) 'T1 e g . Elve hCic tha r peaedl hel t m mii e1 w doesnotpenui C e over f l sofs ey e nt r ui s e t y d hat tm a t t c y or os r ocit o c ns rim i p ro a ij r c s s' (iigLo l v BrownM ari Ser ., 995F. 1565,1565 r o o t n es n ln u y a e .) ctn li u ' e ne v 2d . - 8- ( 1hCi.1 93). 1t r 9 ) Thewe le t bls dca el pr cudi t a s ri ofc ori ca msunde a ii l- sa ihe s aw e l ng he s e ton ons tum li rm rtme 1w lave ltl que ton f t Cour.Co I ofPl i ifsCom pl nti Dim is d. a e s ite si or he t unt V antf ai s s s e E. Concuson l i I s , t s Cour GR ANTS D e e n um hi t f ndants M o i t Sti a l ga i r f r i t ' ton o r ke le tons e e enc ng he docrne ofr s i a l t r fom Countl a GRANTS De e nts M oto t Dim iswih ti e ps oquiu r nd f nda ' in o s s t P eu ieCo n s1,I a dI o Plitf sCo litRe i alqutri n t s p rt c u eo rj dc u t Ill n V f an if mpan . sps o iu s o a e aae a s f a ton a opra ef c i r tonatt ssagei t c s M or ove ,hel r ga di Count1 c i ppr it or ons de ai hi t n he a e. e r t aw e r ng 1 a t a i a i o t zoneofda rt tha bee c e ry es a i he f us i f der l mi i e nd he pplc ton f he nge es s n l a l t bls d or e n e a m tm c es i t Elve h Cic t a has t 1 peri ntt Count 1 ' cli f l s of fla as n he e nt r ui, s he aw tne o V s am or os iil c ori Countlli a r pe ii pla f da es Ther f e onl CountIr m ans oft ons tum. 1 s e ttve e or mag . e or y e i he Pl ntf sCom pl i . ai if a nt DONE AND ORDERED i Chambe sa M i m i Fl i t s n r t a , orda, hi FE Copi pr ded t es ovi o: Couns lofRec d e or - 9- da ofM a c 201 y r h, 4. CO A . M NO TED STATES D I STRI J G E CT UD