Gomez v. Dade County Federal Credit Union, No. 1:2013cv23882 - Document 21 (S.D. Fla. 2014)
Court Description: ORDER granting 15 Defendant's Motion to Dismiss. Plaintiff's Complaint is dismissed without prejudice, with leave to file an amended complaint by April 8, 2014. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 3/24/2014. (rtn)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Gomez v. Dade County Federal Credit Union Doc. 21 UN I TED STATES DI STRI CO U RT FOR THE CT SO U TH ERN DI STRI O F FLO RI A CT D M i m iD i s on a vi i C as Num be 1 23882- 1 - 0 % N 0 e r: 3C V M ANDRES GOM EZ, Pl ntf , ai if D A DE COUN TY FED ERA L CRED I UN I , T ON D e e nt f nda . O R D ER G R ANTI G D EFEN DA NT ' M O TI N TO D I I N S O SM SS Pl i ifAndr Go e ie alws ta i t f nda Da Co t Fede a Cr t on, antf es m zfld a ui gans De e nt de un y r l ediuni al gi vi ai ofTil 11oft Am e i nswih Dia lte Ac , 42U. C.j 1 01e s q. le ng oltons te l he rca t s biiis t S. 21 t e (i '.P an ifs e sad caao yj g n t a De e d n i i v o ai no t ADA a d a ç ADA' litf e k e lr tr ud me t h t f n a t s n i lto f he ) n p r n n ij n o d rdi gDee da tt b igisa tmai tl rma hn s( s it f l ema e t nu din ie n fn n o rn t uo t el c ie ATM ) n o ul c e e pla w ih t appr pr a e A D A r gul tons a dr q et t th Co r rti u iddint om i nce t he o it e a i , n e u ss ha t e u t eanj rs i o o e ur D e e ntr m a nsi e pla t ough pe i e m onior ng'a or rc riyi t eas ns e f nda e i n om i nce hr r odi t i , n de e tf ng he l s pr opos d by Pl i if and pa e ofc t a a t ys f s. e a ntf ; ym nt os s nd tonw ' ee Fort ras pr de bel t Cour fndst tDee ntsMotont Dimis( E. he e ons ovi d ow,he t i ha fnda ' i o s s D. No 1 )i g a tdp ru n t F d R. v. l b ()d et lc o sa dngu e Aril l1o . 5 s rne u s a t o e . Ci P. 2() 1 u o a k f tn i nd r t e 1 f c t Co tt i Thi a toni dimis wihoutprj c he nsiuton. s ci s s sed t eudie. 1.D i si scus on Pl ntf i a l ly blnd i vi w ho vi ie one ofD e e nt sA TM S l a e a 1 1 ai if s ega l i ndi dual st d f nda ' oc t d t 80 N, . t Av n e M imiFlrda3 3 (h S be ATM '. eSu jd ATM il e tdr u hy W 9h e u , a , o i 31 6 t eç jd su ' Th be ) s o ae o g l o emi fo hi h me Pan ifalg sta t eS be ATM i ia e si et t ebi dd et n l r m s o . litf le e h t h u j d e s n e e sbl o h ln u o Dockets.Justia.com t lc ofaf tonal ce gui ncef a ur i vi a i ofTil 11oft ADA , c he a k unc i voi - da e t e,n olton te l he a ompr he i e nsve ci lrg slw pr bii dicrm i ton on t ba i ofdia lt Spe fcal Pl i ifcli s vi iht a ohi tng s i na i he s s s biiy. cii ly, antf am t lck ofa f tona voi e gui nc f t e vi aes Se ton 707. oft 201 St ndar f he a unc i l e - da e eaur olt ci 5 he 0 a ds or Ac es i e Desg r espr c sbl i n, ul omul a e by t De t tofJ tc t i e e Til lIoft g td he parmen usi e o mplm nt te I he ADA. f r r l g s wil o tn et atmp t us t eS be t He u t al e he lc ni u o te to e h u j c ATM , swel soh r he e a la t e ATM S i De e ntsnewor be us t y a eco ninta wihi t ge a c z het c l n f nda ' t k, ca e he r nve e nd t n he ogr phi one ypialy ta l ,butdue t t i i c es i lt a Def nda ' lck ofa polc t e ur isATM S a e r ve s o her na c sbiiy nd e nts a i y o ns e t r A D A - m pla t he ca co i n , nnots ce s uly us t m . uc s f l e he Dee d n s e t d s s Pli t fs o an p ru n t F d. Ci P. 2()1 f r a k fn a t e ks o imis ani c mplit u s a to e R. v. 1 b () o lc f o s a ng unde A ri l 11 of t U nie St t s Cons iut on,a pur uan t Fed.R .Ci P. f t ndi r tc e l he td ae tt i nd s to v. 1 ()6 frf i r t saeacam.Be a et eCo r fn sPlitf lc Aril llsa dn i 2b () o al e o tt li u c us h u ti d an if a ks t e 1 tn ig,t c wilno a es Defnda ' 1 b)6)agument l t ddr s e nts 2( ( r . I .Le St I gal andar d t tn ig i a tr s od j rs ito a q e to whc mu tb a d e s d p irt a d l a dn s h e h l u idcin l u sin ih s e d r se ro o n s id p n e t f h me i o t p ris cams'U. Co svAr.1, 2 c.; uanv Deè d r n e e d n o t e rt f he a t ' li . S. n t t11 j , l1 f j . f n es s e ' , o ll e 5 4U. 5 5 5 0 61( 9 2 .Fu te ,stn igmus bed tnn n da o t tmea fWi f , 0 S. 5 , 6 - 1 9 ) rh r S a dn d s t ee i e s f he i t whi ht pl ntf scompl nti fl 'Fo sont Fami v Pi l Sunc tTr iAut i , c he ai if ai s ied. cu ' he l . nela y oas anst hor t y 3 F. 1 1 ( lhCi. 44 3d 263, 275 1 t r 2003) . t ve ufee St ng r qui e t f l i t e el m e s' ()t pl ntf mus ha s frd a andi e r s he olow ng hr e e nt . 1 he ai if û o c eea dp riulrz d' n k cua o i n n 'ij r n fc o alg l p oe tditr s; l n rt n a t aie 'a d û t l r mmie t'n u pi-a t f e al rt ce nee t c c a y ( )heemusbeac u a c n cinb t e teplitf sij r a ted fn n ' c n u ta 2t r t a s l o ne to ewe n h anif nu y nd h ee da ts o d c; nd ( )t t el eyta t ij r wil r d e s db afv rbl d cso 1 .W ihr s e tot e 3 imus b i l h the nu y lbe e r se y a o a e e iin.d t e p c t h k - 2- frt lme t b c u ePlitf i s igDee da tf rij n tv r le, emu tas alg ç r a is ee n, e a s an if s un fn n o nu cie eif h s lo l e ç e l e a a d i d ae -a o o e t a meey c n e tr lo h p teia -tr a o f tr ij r . n mme it s pp s d o rl o j cu a r y oh t l h e t f u u e n u y' c ' Wo de v Bo r o ge t o Un v r i s s o Ge . 2 7 F.d 1 2,1 8 ( 1h Ci. 01 ) o n . a d fRe ns f ie st '' f o, 4 3 26 2 4 1 t r 2 0 y y. ( mpha i byt Cour) l ADA c s s t plitf mus algeû conceea raitcpln of e ss he t. n a e ,he anif t le k a rt nd e lsi a whe hewoul vii't publcac om moda i a i Houson v M ar Su r kes I , n d st'he i c ton gan. t . od pe mar t, nc.733 F. 1 1 ( 1h Ci. ) s alo Woode 247F. a 1 (hepl ntf S ts a 3d 323, 340 1 t r 2001 ; ee s n, 3d t 284 t ai if k mus how s tcintlkei odt thewil afe tdbyt alge yunlwf c uc i t f ur ' Ci ufi e i lho ha lbe fce he le dl a ul ond tn he ut e. t ); y o o An lsv L n , U. 95 11 n8( 9 3 (û it er aiyo t tr a o rp ae ij r fL s gee . yo s 461 S. , 8 . 1 9 ) 'ts h e lt fhe h e t f e e td nu y I ta i rlv n t tesa dn iq iy n t h p an ifss b e tv a p e e ins' . h t s ee a t o h tn ig n ur , o t e litf u j cie p rh nso .) ' Plitf b a s h b r e o e tbihngh ssa dn t s eDee da t o ij n tv rle . anif e r t e u d n f sa ls i i tn ig o u fn n fr n u cie eif Bo h s v T wno n eI lt4 5F.d9 4, 7 ( 1hCi. 0 5 .lt ePlitf fist me th s c e e . o fpo c n e, 0 3 6 9 6 1 t r2 0 ) f h an if al o e ti b r e t eCo rlc s u idcin. ic s k eT ieo n in o o iav Flrd S aeAtlt u d n,h u ta k j rs ito M c o u e rb fl da s fFlrd . o ia t t hei c Com ', F. 1 1 ( 1hCi. n 226 3d 226, 230 1 t r 2000) Aril llssa ngr rme sa ye l t . tce l' tndi equie nt ppl qualy o ADA c s s No k n sv S a o s NB, C, 4 F d Ap x. 2, 5( 1hCi. 01 ) a e . r u a . e h r e LL 4 4 e . p 41 41 1 t r 2 1. Ch l ng st Aril llsa d n c n t u eaf cua atc o s b e tmatr u idito al e o tce I tn i g o si t a t l ta k n u j c te j rs ci n e t p ru n t Fe R.Ci P.1 ( )1 . Th scam c aln e ihe e itn e o s b e tmatr u s a t o d. v. 2 b ( ) i li h le g s t x se c f u j c te t j rs ito i fc,re p ci eo t epe dn s' L wr n ev Du b r 91 F.d 1 25 1 2 ( lh u idcin n a tir s e tv f h la ig . a e c . n a , 9 2 5 , 5 9 1 t ' Ci.1 . I a f t atc i ma t Cour ma wei e denc i l ngtsi r 990) f acual ta k s de, he t y gh vi e, ncudi e tmonyand a fda t, ndnopr s fi vis a e umptvetut ul s at c t pli if sal ga i .Ga cav Co nhav , i r hf ne s ta hes o a ntf le tons r i . pe er Beldr s ats M D.s P. ,1 F.d 1256,1261( 1hCi.1 ) l As oci e , ', A. 04 3 1 t r 997 . 11 A nal i 1. ys s The Cour tnds Pl ntf l ks A ri l ll s a ng. Pl ntf has f ie t s ts y t fr t ti ai i f ac tc e I t ndi ai i f a l d o a i f he is ee n o sa d n wh r h h si s tce t alg date l n i dae. .h e to f tr lme t f tn i g ee e a n uf inl l e s a a d mme it . t ra î uu e i y e r ij y. Woode 247F. a 1 (mphassi orgi l' nur ' ' n, 3d t 284 e i n i nal. Bec us sandi i dee ned a oft tme t compl nti tld ( eFoc on t a e t ng s tnni s he i he ai s ie se us he Fami 344F. a 1 ) t Cou tf esonPlitf' sa ngon Ocober25,201 I hi l y, 3d t 275, he r ocus anifs tndi t 3. n s Compli ,Pli ifsa lga i r ga di f ur ha m a ea f l s ant antf le tons e r ng ut e r r s olow : TheSu j c ATM i wi i teg o rp cz n ta Plitf tpc l ta es s a t be t s t n h e ga hi o e h t anify ial r v l a p r h y of i e e y a a tvte .Th Su j c ATM i lc tda p o i tl o e( )mie h s v rd y ci i s e b e t i s o ae p r x maey n 1 l fo Plitf sh me Pli t f l c niuet v st h Su j c ATM i tef tr r m an if o . ani wil o t o iit e be t f n n h uu e a pa tofhi e f t o l a ea e sbl ATM St theper o ly ca us wihi t s r s for t oc t cc s i e ha s nal n e t n he ge a c zo t the tpialy tave saspa tof hi r gul r a tvii ,a on ogr phi ne ha y c l r l r s e a c i tes nd b h l o t bid c mmu t, e eal. D. 1a j 1 J e af f he l o ni g n r l E E. t 0 . n y y Plitf wilc ni u t atmp t u e t S b e tATM b c u e h wa t t anif l o tn e o te t o s he u j c e a s e ns o @ i ntf c de iy onve e a e sbl ATM optons wihi t geog a c z t t he nint cc s i e i t n he r phi one ha t c l tave saspa' ofhi eve yday a tvii s a he w a st i r as A TM ypi aly r l ly t s r c i te , nd nt o nc e e a c si ii f rteb idc mmu iy g neal.Ho v r s ln a t eS b e t c e sblt o h ln o nt , e r l y y we e , o o g s h u j c ATM c i st vi a eSeci 7, a n ifwilbeuna et us i i depe nty ontnue o olt ton Pli tf l bl o e t n nde l a dwil e t ee y d tre fo v stngi.D. 1a !43 . n lb ,h rb , eerd r m iii t ( E. t ( 1 Bas d u e pon a i si i peror d On Pl i if sbehaf Pl i ifhasacua n nve tgaton f me antf l, antf t l no i t ta tonal tce ha ddii ATM Si De en ntsATM newor a esmia l i vi a i n f da ' t k r i l ry n olton he 0 a r . antf d st he e ddii l t ofCha e 7 oft 201 St nda ds Pli ifwoul vii t s a tona ATM Sbu pt r f rt vi a i ofwhi h hehasacua n tc .D. 1a !4 1 o he oltons c t l oie ( E. t 4 . ThoughDe e f ndant ce r i dpolcesr r ngt m a e e a ope ai n has ntalze ii ega di he nag m nt nd r to ofisATM S De e ntdoe nothaveapln orpolc t ti r as t , f nda s a iy ha s e onabl cacult y l aed t c eisATM St bei tm ey c m pla wih Cha e 7oft 201 St nda ds o aus t o n i l o ince t pt r he 0 a r , @ a i d mo tae b t f c t tt n t r r man o t f o la c E E. a s s e nsrtd y he a tha is ewo k e i s u o c mp in e.D. 1 t !451 . Th s alg to i lr ep r f c so teSu j c ATM , ndc n anmo eg n r l e r frn e e e l ains n ag at o u n h be t e a o ti r e eai d eee c s z t l d iin l o i dt a ATM S'h taen t a o 't a r o ADA- o in . f h S be t c mpla t l t e u j c ATM wa id e n n c mpl n, s n e d o -o i t a a d Pli tf itn t c n iu u igteSu jc ATM wh r i i o miefo h sh mea d n anif ne ds o o tn e sn h be t ee t s ne l r m i o n 'D f endantar guesi isM oton t Dim ist Pl ntf sCom pl ntshoul alo bedim ise nt i o s s hat ai if' ai d s s s d e p s a t Fe R. v. 1 b(1 o gr nd o moone s Th Cou td sn a dr s t tcai h r . uru nto d. Ci P. 2( ) ) n ou s f t s. e r oe ot d e s ha l m e e Asd s u sdbel Pl nifha f ie t stsyt frtelme o sa n i s e n ij c i ic s e ow, aitf s ald o aif he is e nt f tndig n e kig nun tve r le,s ciial wi r s e tt ale i ara a i dit t e toff t r ij r eif pe fc ly t e p c o lgng e l nd mme ae hra u u e n u y. h - 4- wihnh ste rp i z n , ti wo l b s fiin t alg a ij r n-a t s anif r vd s t i i i oga h c o e' h s ud e u fce to le e n nu pi f c a Plitfp o ie g ' f c ua s a t l uppor r l tngt a s cii vi a i t e ai o pe fc olton. Tha ,howe r i nott c e asPl ntf ha r a l conc ded i hi Opposton t t t ve , s he as ai if s e diy e n s ii o he Mo int Dimista, p n aF b ay2 2 4vii t t eS b e tATM ,h v ieg ia c to o s s h t u o e nlr 7, 01 st o h u j c te o c ud n e faur wa f l f tona.( E.18a 31 e t e s uly unci l D. t . M o e v r t s p o tt fcu l ta ko s b e t te j rs ito , f n a t ta he t r o e ,o u p r is a t a atc n u j c matr u idci n Dee d n atc s o isM oint Dimiss v rle o e afd vt d s rbn t eS be t t t o s s e ea mply e fia is ec iig h u j c ATM -a dal o n lATM Si n De e ntsne wor -a compla bot be or a a trPli ifsJ y 21 20l vii.Se D . f nda ' t k s int h f e nd fe antf ul , 3 st e E. 1 - ( fda i o M a l Feriaa ! 6 7. fd vto Ro e t Plsncaa ! 4 7 Afia i o 52 Afi vt f ra rer t ! - , i a i f b ro a e i t ! - ; fd vt f Af S e h n eMie a ! 5 1 Oco r7 2 3S b e t tp a i ls t ! - 0; tbe , 01 u j c ATM Re o tAfia i o Try nGakisa p r; fd v t f a o s n t ! 4- Ap i2 , 01 S b e t ! 7; rl 4 2 3 u j c ATM Re o t.Th s wihr s e t oteSu j c ATM , an if a p r) u , t e p c t h b e t Plitf h s f ld t al gear la i e a et ea off ur vi ai aie o le ea nd mm dit hr t ut e ol ton. Co e u nl a yalg d///:ij r mu t eaet te eç d iin l' u p re l n n nsq e ty, n le e zl nu y s r lt o h s û dto a s p r o tdy o /r a ' c ompla ATM Si De e ntsnewor Howe r Pli tf pr de no s int n f nda ' t k. ve , a n if ovi s uppor i hi Co pl nt tn s m ai f t sas e ton ot rt n a c l or saeme t ta ii si ato pe f med on Pli ifs or hi s ri he ha onc us y t t nt ha n knve tg i n ror antf be l 'c ye ûa t lnotc 't tot rATM Sae smial i vi ai ( E.1a ! 441 haf onve d icua ie' ha he r i lry n olton. D. t . W i o t u p rigfcs a dfc dwi atd vi a s ri gta teSu jc ATM a do h r t u s p o t a t, n a e t f a t s etn h th be t h n h i s n t e ATM S i Def nda ' ne wor a e A DA - m pla , s h nake a s ri ta e not e il d t t n e nts t k r co i nt uc d s e tons i r ntte o he t as s umpton oftut ' F. , hc o v I al5 6U. 6 2, 6 - 8( 0 )(No d e ac mpli i r h. g.As r .p .qb , 5 S. 6 6 4 7 20 9 d r o s o ant ' s tc i i tndes S ked a s rinrl de d o ûurhe f t le nc me .' Plitf, ufs e f t e r na s eto s' voi f f t r acua nha e nt'' anif ). t rf r , sfie t alg ara a di daet ra o f tr ij r wi rs e totr u h u heeo e ha ald o le e e l n mme it h e t f uu e n u y t e p c t h o g o t h Def ndants ne w or e ' t k. l hi Opposton t t M o i t Dimis Pli tf a tm pt t bolt rhi a gu e n s ii o he ton o s s , a n if te s o se s r m nt r gar ng t e ' ddii ' non- om pla A TM S a a l ge t t a t r vi ii t pr rye di hes t tonal' a c i nt , nd le s ha f e stng he ope l fn t n n S b e t u ci i g u j c ATM , s bs q e t v stda oh r o he u e u nl iie n te ATM a 1 9 0No t Ke dal i (h y t 0 0 rh n lDrve te ' nd l ATM ' .( E.l a 3 .Th Ke d l ATM i lc tda p o i tl 1 mie fo t e t al Ke ' D. 8 t 1 e n al ) s o ae p r xmaey 6 ls r m h S be t u j c ATM .Plitf alg sh c udn t o eeata s cina t Ke d lATM b c u et anif le e e o l o c mplt rn a to the n al e a s he voie g da esopped f toni d i t c s oft ta a ton. d. Pl ntf poi st t c ui nc t unc i ng urng he our e he r ns c i 1 ai if nt o he Ke l ATM ' f l e ase denc ofDe e nda l S aiur vi e f ndantsûi tt i lf l e t ac eve a mant i ' kns iutona aiur o hi nd i an ADA a c si lt tr u ho tt e tr n t r , a dta f iet evilto o t Su j c ATM c e sbi y h o g u is n ie ewo k' n h tk l h o ain fhe b e t i ' wh .. . ma ha eb e rme id, o la c fiu e p rit ti De e d n ' ATM Newo k. ( E. y v e n e de c mp in e alr s e ss wi n fn a ts h t r ' D. ' 1 a 1 -2 .Hef r ralg si teOp osto t t eitnd t c n iu v st t eKe d l 8 t l1 ) u t le e n h p iin ha h ne s o o tn e iing h n al he i ATM .( E.1 Afi vi ofGome a ! 11 . D. 8, fda t zt 1 Howe r sandi i dee m i dasof hetm ea whi ht pli if sc ve , t ng s tr ne t i t c he antf ompl i i fl d, nd a nt s ie a t r f ec l becr a e b c he e or amot e t d y onduc f m ont lt ri vi a ATM ofwhih Pli ifha t our hs a e nvol ng n c a ntf d noknowldgeonOcobe 25, e t r 2013. eFocu on t Fami 344F. a 1 Se s he l y, 3d t 275; t v SM / m Hary . pal Tr l Pl a LLC,755F.Supp.2d 1 5,1 7( D.Fl 201 ( di cou t i t Elve h ais az , 2l 21 S. a. 0) hol ng rs n he e nt Cic t a e i or c i ' i conf ng sa ng f ADA cha lnges a r quie a t l r ui r ç e autous' n m eni tndi or le , nd e r cua knowldge whe t c e n he ompl i i fl d ofpa tc arba e t ha sa ng t c le t e ant s ie ri ul ni r o ve t ndi o hal nge hos b rir) Th Co l tee o ea de s s h alg t ns e a dn t eS be t are s. e u' h r f r d r se t e l a i r g r ig h u j c ATM -heo l ATM t e o t ny t whi h Defnda s cii ly r f r i t Com pli t-a nott Ke l ATM . o c e nt pe fca l e e s n he a n nd he ndal M or ve ,e n we e t Cour t c i Pl i ifs r e al ga i r ga di t eo r ve r he t o onsder antf ec nt le tons e r ng he K e l ATM , a ntf ha n m e hi bur n ofde ons r tng a k onc e e a r ls i pl n' t nda l Pl i if s ot t s de m ta i t r t nd ea i tc a ' o c r t nt t Ken l ATM , nd t r f eha no s tce l al ge al e a i medit 't e t eur o he dal a he e or s t ufi inty le d t al nd m r a e'hr a o ft r ij r t stsyt ef s ee n o sa dn i s e igij n tv r le .Wo d n, 4 F.d f uu e n u y o aif h i t lme t f tn ig n e kn n u cie eif o e 2 7 3 r a 1 4; s o 733 F. a 1 t 28 Hou t n, 3d t 340.To a s st t e off t eADA vi a i i t cmtxtof s es he hr at u ur oltons n he c e sa ng,t Elve h Cicui empl a lt a iy ofc r um sa s't s,a hasl ke t t t ndi he e nt r t oys lot lt ic tnce ' e t nd oo d o he f l ngfco sa rlva :( pr miyoft publca ommodaton t pli ifshome ( olowi a tr s ee nt a) oxi t he i cc i o antf ; b) plitf patpar anifs s tonageofdeenda ' a commodaton;()t dei t s ofplitf' pl t f nts c i c he fniene s anifs an o rtr t d fn a tsa c mmo ain; n ()tefe u n y o pan ifsta e n a d fn a ts eu n o ee d n ' c o d to a d d h rq e c f litf r v l e r ee d n ' a om m oda i 1 a 1 cc ton. d. t 337. W ih r pec t t ipa tpa r ge'a k r que ofne by ta 'f t s neihe t t es t o he t s tona ' nd û e ncy f ar r vel' ac or , t r he Compl ntnorOpposton c ansa sngl alegai n t Pl i ifs ai ii ont i i e l to hat antf oughtt a e st Ke l o cc s he nda l ATM prort flngt lws t W ih r s c t t t i t nes 'f c or Pl ntf ' s ealeg i i o ii he a ui. t e pe t o he t nie s'a t , ai ifs ol l aton def rg r igteKe d lATM i ta h ln e d t c n iu t vst h Su j c ATM a dt oh r e adn h n al s h t e i tn s o o tn e o iit e b e t i n he te AT ie t d a o eb c u ete aene rmy h mea c n e in f rmet u e'( E.1 , M d n6e b v e a s h y r a o nd o v n e t o o s . D. 8 ' Af d vt fGo za ! 1 J e ha i a de ) W ihrs e t ot f r x miy' a t rteKe d l t a io me t I (mp ss d d . t e p c t he i o i t'fco ,h n al i p ATM i l a e r s oc t d oughl 1 mie fom Pli ifs hom e Thi ditnc by is f doe not y 6 ls r a ntf . s sa e, tel, s de o ta ePl i ifsi biiy t al gea f ur vi ai n,butt Coul a s no esPl i ifha m nsr t antf ' na lt o le ut e ol to he ' lo t t antf s f l d t pr de a s aie o ovi ny uppor a t why t Ke lATM i é nve e .z W he c i r d i t so he ndal s' co nint' ' n onsde e n ?Plitf fld aNotc o Su e nal t ort ( E. 0!ctngt ar c n deci on i t an if ie ie f pplme t Au h iy D. 2 ii o e e t si n he Ditito M i es t, z v. O Har i Ban Naton As oca i No.l - 30 ( M in. r src f nn oa Sawcyn BM rs k i al s iton, 3 2 9 D. n Ma . 1 20l ) whe ent DititCo r c sd r dt s mef rfcor t a s s t tr a off t e 9, 4 , r i he src u t on ie e he a ou a t s o s e s he h e t uur vi atons. I fndi t t kpr m iy' and lfequency ofnear tavel'f or wei ol i n i ng hat he i oxi t ' %r by r ' act s ghed i f vorof na st ng,t Cour r i i par on t pl ntf ' f ualalega i t hef eque ed t ar t vi t andi he t eled n t he ai if s act l tons hat r nt he ea o si r t ant and s ,and t he tavel t t ar t vi tf i es aur s hops hat r ed o he ea o si rendsand a t outeach event 1 at tend r s. d. *6. Her Pl ntf has pr ded no such f ualsuppor,and asnot abovepr umabl di notknow of e, ai if ovi act t ed es y d t Kendal ATM ' exit e when he fl t sacton. The f s i Sawcz ar f t ditnguihabl he l S senc ied hi i act n yn e urher s i s e wh r ( t eplitf i t a c evii d /7 n -ompla ATM Sa i lde f csr g r n e c e e:a) h an if n h t as st 15 onc e 4 int nd ncu d a t e a dig a h vii i hsc mpl nt ( )e chATM r mane n c mpla ; nd( )t pai ifal ge i hi st n i o ai ; b a e i d on-o int a c he l ntf l d n s e c ompl ntt the vi t each ATM i t pas,t eby s ai ha sied n he t her uppori hi i entt r ul . tng s nt o et ' n t aiy wih t r m ani f c or ,a i lg ofPl ntf sr ce a ison t the now hasa ot lt t he e i ng a t s nd n iht ai if e nt dm s i ha wor ngATM wihi onem ieofhi hom e- hes m eATM t tf ki t n l s t a ha onnedt ba i ofhi Compl nthe s s s ai t Cour tndsPl i ifha f ie t m e thi bur n ofde he ti antf s al d o e s de monsr tng bot ai ea a i medit ta i h l l nd m r ae tr a o f tr ij r , a daû o ceea draitcp a 't rt l t teKe d l h e t f u u e nu y' n ç n rt n e lsi ln'o eu' o h n a ATM . e La ' c n S e mb v Ch l t Count 429F. . arote y, Supp. 130 l 1 (i ngpli iflc d sa ngunde ADA 2d 2, 309-0 fndi antf a ke tndi r whe e,nt rala, sc a twih t pr ry wa i r quen ,t ewe eot rf ciii cl e t r i e i hi ont c t he ope t s nfe t her r he a ltes os r o hi home,a t r we eno i s nd he e r mmedit orconc e eplnst r t ' ot rt n anons ii S s ' ae r t a o eul he ha n pectc é h' wi t r ur . o et n) I .C oncl i V us on Ac r ngl Def nda ' M oton t Dim is i GRANTED asPl ntf lc Ari l I1 co di y, e nts i o s s s ai if a ks tc e 1 sa dng Plitf sCo li ti d s se wi u p eu ie wih la e t fl a a n e tn i . an if mpan s imis d t t rj d c , t e v o i n me d d ho e c ompl nt Aprl8. ai by i 2014.l Pli iff ist fl a a nde c f antf a l o ie n me d ompli byt de dlne,heCour ant he a i t t m a c os t c e. y l e he as DoxE AxD ORDERED i cha n mber a M im i Fl i t s t a , orda, hi da ofM a ch,201 y r 4. A . , 4- E CO A. REN O UNI TED STATES DI STRI J CT UDGE Co e pr de t pis ovi d o: Couns lofRe d e cor - 8-
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
