Avalon Risk Management Insurance Agency, LLC v. Taylor et al, No. 1:2013cv22800 - Document 34 (S.D. Fla. 2014)
Court Description: ORDER GRANTING NON-PARTIES PHILIP AND IVA DICHIARA'S MOTION TO QUASH. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 2/27/2014. (err)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Avalon Risk Management Insurance Agency, LLC v. Taylor et al Doc. 34 UN I TED STA TES D I STRI CO U RT FOR THE CT SOU THERN D I STRI O F FLOR I A CT D M i m iD i son a vi i C as N um be 1 22800- V- O R EN O e r: 3CI M A VA LON RI M GM T. N S.A GEN CY , SK I Pl i if a ntf , G REGO RY TA Y LO R, A D ELE RO SSA N O , J OHN RO SSAN O , J ES RO SSAN O , a AM nd THEAD OR A RO SSAN O , D e e nt f nda . O R DER G R AN TI G N O N - R TI S PH I P AN D I A DI H I R A' M O TI N T O N PA E LI V C A S O OUASH Thi ca e semmi fom an ac i i t Sou he n Diti ofNe Yor i bef e t s s s, t ng r ton n he t r srct w k, s or hi Cour onnon- tesPhii a 1 Dihi as(ole tvel ' t pari lp nd va c ar' c lci y ' nt' rnewe Motont Qua h Mova s' e d i o s ) Subpo .OnJ y 11 201 t sDititis d as ena ul , 3,hi src s ue ubpoenat J. M or n Chas Ba l t pr e o P. ga e rk o oduc M ova s Phii nd l i hi astna a r or . lp D i hi r w or dat a ntf A va on Ri k nt ' lpa vaD c ar ' i nci l ec ds Phii c a a ke Pl i i f l s M a ge e l u anc A ge y f om a l a t na m nt ns r e nc r t e s 2002 t ough 201 i pos tonsofl a s p. i alo hr 0 n ii e der hi He s s De e ntJ m es Ros a scousn.The s f nda a s no' i ubpoe w a i s d i Fl r da,de pie t f c t tt na s s ue n o i s t he a t ha he a tonocc si t Sout r DititofNew Yo k a t Di a aslvei Ne Yor a net ci ur n he he n src r nd he chir i n w k nd iher lve i no do bus nes i Fl i Pl ntf cont nds t tt s poe was i s d i t s di t i t i n r i s n orda. ai i f e ha he ub na s ue n hi s rc becaus J. M or Chas i t uct Pl ntf t serve t br e P. gan e ns r ed ai i f o he anch m anager of any l ocalbr anch ofi e of JP.M or n Chas Pl Re p.9.Thi C ou the d a he i on Febr tc . ga e. . s s r l arng uaa 14.201 For 4. ras mor f lydic s bel t non- ris Motont Quas i GRANTED.Pli if ae e ons e ul s used ow,he pa te ' i o hs antfs r gi e la t r iet i s v n e ve o efl he r ubpoe i t Sout r DititofNe Yor b or t J na n he he n src w k ef e he udgepr i ng esdi Dockets.Justia.com ov t c s Uli ael t sdic r r s,se i fom aNe Yor ac i a i vi er he a e. tm t y, hi s ove y eque t t mm ng r w k ton nd nvol ng t tna i r co dsofaNe Yo k no pary, ongsi N e Yor he i ncal e r w r n- t bel n w k. 1.Background Thi ca ea ieso ofana ton i t Sout r DititofNe Yor Pl i ifAva onRik s s rs ut c i n he he n src w k. antf l s Ma ge ntns a eAgenc (' on' ha alge t tDe e nt r ac pia ywheet na me l urnc y' Aval ' s le d ha f nda s an ons rc ) r hey s d s ey bondsi Pl ntf name t Pli tf sc t e sand cha ge pr m i sma tme ol ur t n ai ifs o a n if usom r r d e um ny i s hi he t Pli ifwoul acualyc r sphoni m one fom c t e sandfom Pl n ifb g r han antf d t l ha ge, i ng y r usom r r aitf y usng muli e fcttous e ii a nume ous co- ons r t s De e nt J mes Ros ano i i tpl i ii nttes nd r c pia or . f nda a s s a lgedl t l de andmase nd of hi fa andPl i ifaleg heus dor nia i na le y he ea r t nni t s r ud, antf l es e ga z tonal mes i l ng W ordwi Cons tng, nc. W ordwi Cons tng a Tr de Se vce ,a Uni r al ncudi l de uli l , l de uli nd a r i s nd ve s Tr de Cons tng t f rhe t s me. a uli o u t r he che Pl ntf st or i t te ensvedicl ur oft Di hi r sfna a r c dsi ne s a y ai if he y s ha xt i s os e he c a a' i ncil e or s ce s r 'ode e m i t s opeoft ilci a tvii c ' t r ne he c t he li t c i tes onduc e by Ros a a t tac t mone t t td s no, nd o r k he y,o he e e pos i e t twa de i t r r . Pli ifhaspr de t Cour wiht e ta a i xtnt sbl,ha s rved he efom ' antf ' ovi d he t t hr e r ns ctons bewe nJme Ros a a Phii Di aawhi t M ova sdonotdiput ( )I Augus2006, t e a s s no nd lp chir ch he nt s e: 1 n t Phii a dl lp n vaDi a as tac c fom t i Chas banka coun oJ mesRos a i t a chir en he k r he r e c tt a s no n he mount of$1, J sRosa tsii di hi depostont tPhii Dihir ofe l thi mone ( 200.ame sno e tte n s ii ha lp c a a tn en m y. 2) On M arh 24,2008,a c c f $9, fom t W ordwi Cons tng ba ac ountt J mes c he k or 400 r he l de uli nk c o a Ros a wasde ie i Ros a speronalba a ount Tha s day, a e Ros a wr t s no post d n s no' s nk cc . t ame J m s s no o e a c k f $ 400 t Phii Di aa,who de ie i i o hi J M or n a ount ( On hec or 9, o lp chir postd t nt s P ga cc . 3) Se e pt mber2 2011 J mesRos a wihdr w $7, i c h fom t W ordwi Cons tng 4, ,a s no t e 000 n as r he l de uli Sunf us ba a c . 000 i ca hwa t de ie i ot pe s lSunTnztba ac ount -r t nk c ount $6, n s s hen post d nt he r ona s nk c - 2- ofJ m e a The a Ros a $6, wa t n wie t Phii Di a a. a s nd odor s no. 000 s he r d o lp chir The pari enga d i ne i tons t nar ow t s pe oft s tes ge n gota i o r he co he ubpoena, ne i tons but gota i br down r ga di t wor ng ofa c i ntaiy pr so Ne rhel s Pl n iftld a oke e r ng he di onfde ilt ovii n. ve t es , aitf ie prposdAgredOr ronM otont Quah!lsi 1 ditnc c t oresoffna ilrc d.nt o e e de i o s itng 3 si t aeg i i nca e or I he agg e t Pl ntf i s e ng a a al a iatonsf ba ac ount ,wie ta f r ,c ks r ga e, ai if s e ki ny nd l pplc i or nk c s r r ns e s hec , de i si , t awal, nd a ountsa e t fom J nuar 1, post lps wihdr s a cc t t men s r a y 2006 t t pr s ntmadeunde o he e e r eihe oft o ba a countnum ber or i t nam esofPhii or1 Di hi r . t r w nk c s n he lp va c a a Oft 1 r quessf fna i lr c dss he 3 e t or i nc a e or ought M ovant now cons nt o s noft m . , s e t eve he The c e e do ons nt d cume s a e ' ny a a lwie ta f r , c c , de i si ,a wihdr wa s nt r ' a nd l r r nse s he ks post lps nd t a l r f r ncng' W ordwi Cons tng,l . W ordwi Cons tng a Tr de Se vi es Uni r a ee e i ' l de uli nc, l de uli nd a r c , ve s l Tr deCons tng, a e Ros a J Ros ano, a aRos a andGr or Ta orfo t a uli J m s s no, ohn s The dor s no, eg y yl r m he pe i ofJul 1,2006 t pr s nt TheM ova sha a s sat t tt woul agr t pr e rod y o ee . nt ve lo t ed ha hey d ee o oduc r or i ve i an ca h ta a tonsfom t pe i J y 1 2006t pr s nt I addii t t s ec ds nvol d n y s r ns c i r he rod ul , o e e .n ton o he e doc nt, antfsakf ( )a anda1a iai f ba ac ount ma byM ova s ( ume s Pli if s or 1 ny 1 pplc tons or nk c s de nt,2) a a a1wietanse s c c ,de i clps a wihdr wal fom t tm epe i J nuar 1 ny nd 1 r r f r , he ks post i , nd t a s r he i rod a y , 2006 t pr e , t rornott pa te i t Sout m Diti tofNe Yor a ec o es nt whehe he ris n he he src w k r once ne a r d, nd ( a1ofM ova s a ountsae nt fom J nuar l 2006t pr en. 3) 1 nt' cc ttme s r a y , o es t I . nal i I A ys s O n D e m be 1, 3,a ne ver i ofRul 45 e e ed i o ef e t A m o ot rc nge , ce r 201 w s on e nt r nt f c . ng he ha s t Rul c he e hange t is ngCour f as d he sui tor ubpoe Compar Fe R. v. 45( ( (' s na. e d. Ci P. a)2) ' ubpoena a l c e oft br a Be aus he e kdown overt confde i iy pr s on, ova sdi nota ee t he i ntalt ovi i M nt d gr o t t he enns oft pr ed Order he opos . mu ts u fo t ec u t e et a toni p n ig'wi Fo me Fe R. v. 4 ()2 ()(A s is e r m h o r wh r he ci s e dn ' t r r d. Ci P. 5 a( )c ' ) h ' s ubpoe m us is ...f rpr ton ori peci n,i s pa a efom a s na t s ue: o oduc i ns to f e r t r ubpoenac omm a nga ndi pe s s at nda e,fom t c tf t diti twhe e t pr r on' te nc r he our or he src r he oducton or i pe ton i t be i ns c i s o ma '. s de.)The ubpoe i t sc ewa is donJ y 11, 3. ova stldt rfrtMotont ' na n hi as s sue ul 201 M nt ie hei is i o Qu honAug t5, 3, ndt ytl t i rne dmotont q s onSe e r23, 3. as us 201 a he ied her e we i o ua h ptmbe 201 To t ext t Cour wilde e m i whet rt s he ent he t l t r ne he he ubpoe wa pr ry is d,i a i For e na s ope l s ue t pples m r Rul 45a notc rntRul 45. e,eg.Br v.Br e nd ure e Se . , own own, 4 W L 1 201 72407( D.Ca. a r N. lJ nuay 1 201 (p yi Fonne Rul 45t s 5, 4) a pl ng r e o ubpoe is donSe e na s ue ptmber6, ) Cha 2013 ; pmanv Hian . ld Opeatn LLC,201 W L 68 r ig, 3 43473 ( N. De 26,201 ( yi fr rl est M oton t D. D. c. 3) appl ng o me ' o i o ul Quas Subpoe .l r i on t M oton t Quas howe r t Cour a i t r e l h na) n ulng he i o h, ve, he t pples he ec nty a n e Rue 4 Se J R Ene s,LLC v An Un n me d d l 5. e T tr. . k own Qu ni o Coo in Emead , a tt f l mba y r ls Ameh ss a dQu rzCr sas 2 3W L 6 7 9 a #12( D. a De .1 , 01 )( re , . ty t, n a t y tl, 01 5 0 41 t - S. Fl. c 0 2 3 To r s J) (ppl ngne l l 45t moi t qua hs a yi w ' e o ton o s ubpoe is dFe ua y22,20l . u na sue br r 3) 4.M otont Quas i o h UnderRul 26( , pa t i yobt ndicoveyr ar nga nonprviege matrt ti e b) a ry i ma ai s r eg di ny i l d te ha s z rlva t an pa t scli ordee e. Fe R. v. R. b)1 .' l nti or tonnee ee nt o y ry' am fns ' d. Ci P. 26( ( ) ûReeva nf mai ' d notbea s i eatt tili t dic r a ar r s na y c l ult d t l d t t dic r dmisbl he ra f he s ove y ppe s ea o bl a c a e o ea o he s ove y ofa s i ee de '/ Rul 45pr dest t u n atmel moton, diti tc t us qua h dmisbl vi nce. J. e ' ovi ha , po i y i a src our m t s or modiy a s f ubpoe t t t e r s dic os e of prviege or ot r pr e t d mater i no na ha ' quie s l ur r il d he ot c e t ,f e e in or wave a is' or is j cs a pe s t undue bur n.'Fe R. Ci P. xc pto i r pple i' tub e t ron o de ' d. v. 45( ( ( (i)(v)Ani vi l sandi t quas as d)3)A)ii-i . ndi dua has t ng o h ubpoenawhees ' sape s liht r he ' ha rona rg o p iie ewi r s e t ot es be t te o t es b o n . S b rS .LLC v Pr cso ar r rvlg t e p c t h u j c matr f h u p e a' u Ai ys, h ' . e iin ie - 4- S .2008U. DitLEXI 3 ys, S. s. S 4578a #4- ( D. a. i 25,2008 .' na a docume sae t 5 S. Fl Aprl ) ' ncil Fi nt r ge r ly c i e co i nta bec us t i iat apa t sprva y i e ess'Se Su hi ne al onsder d nfde i l a e he mplc e ry' i c ntr t . e ns ne ' Shr ddig,LLC v Pr e Fr hi ng Cor ,2011U. Dit LEXI 11 65a *5( D.Fl e n . oshr d anc si p. S. s. S 31 t S. a. Se embe 30,2011 ( pt r ) Cooke, ) J.. Fr t is eoft s poe duc st um t J o ga om he s uanc he ub na e ec o pM r nchas on J y 11 201 t t e ul , 3 o he pr e Or s opos d der ubmit byPli if t s opeoft oft doc e ss htt bepr e ha ted a ntf,he c he he um nt oug o oduc d s be ns bsa i lyna r d. e u t ntal rowe Thus t sOr rwila e st documen si t pr pos Or a ,hi de l ddr s he t n he o ed der nd n tnt es b o n . d suse a o e t eMo a t h v c nsn e t p o u erq e t ( - i o i h u p e a As ic s d b v ,h v ns a e o e td o r d c e u ss d)()n t pr e or r as wel asr c ds i vi c h tans tons Thus t diput c e s he opos d de , l e or nvol ng as r ac i . , he s e onc m rque t () ( ,() ( ,() a ( . e ss a ,b) c, k) 1, nd m) Re t ( )()c bedic s t t r Reque t( as f S nyandala iai f quess a-c an s used ogehe . s a) ks ori a I pplc tons or ba a ount s te byPhii Di aaa / l Di aa. Re t ( and()a et s me nk cc s ubmitd lp chir ndor va chir ' quess b) c r he a ' e e t tt y as f t pa r k r a e t ba ac ount e ng i xc pt ha he k or he pe wor elt d o nk c s ndi n 5265 and - 1 800 , rs ci l Asa i ta matr ii unce rwhyt s cii ba a ount s e pe tvey. n niil te,t s la he pe fc nk cc s oughti ( a () n b) nd c woul notbec rdunde t br de s of() Pli ifha ma no s ngast how t d ovee r he oa r cope a . antf s de howi o he ba ac ounta i ai ofanon- ry, om eofwhi ma haveocc r dye r o de ade be or nk c pplc tons pa t s ch y ure a s r c s f e t e nt i quesi woul pos i yl a t a s i ee de Be us t Cour fndst t he he ve s n ton, d sbl e d o dmi sbl vi nce. ca e he t i ha t y i ea unduebur n,he erquet ar QUASHED. mpos n de t s e ss e Lie s ,Re u ss ( -m)c n bed s u s d j n l Re u s ()a k f ri n a d al k wie q e t k)( a ic se oit y. q e t k s s o t y n l a ac c ountsa e e t undert na e ofPhii Di a a a / l D i a a r l c i a a a l tt m n s he m lp chi r nd or va chi r ete tng ny nd l wieta f s c c ,de i si a wihdr wal f t perod bewe J y 1,2006 a t r r nser , he ks post lps nd t a s or he i t en ul nd he - 5- prs nt' Re t()s ks ala c e e .z ques 1 ee 1 c ountsaeme e ng i ' tt nt ndi n 5265 a ( wa sa1 a ount nd m) nt 1 cc s a em e s f ac ount t t nt or c 8001 'he e r . s eque t a e ove l br ad.Se Suns ne Shr ddi LLC v F ss r ry o e hi e ng, . Pr oshr edFr hi i Co p. 2011U . D it LEX I 11 1 a *6. a ntf t y i t tbe aus anc s ng r , S. s . S 3 65 t Pl i ifs heor s ha c e J m esRos a a Phii D i a as nte c ot rm o y a l a t h e tm e ove fveye rpe i a s no nd lp chi r e a h he ne t e s t r e i s ra i a rod, a bec us m a ofRos a st a a tons i ve c h, t nsve a i i di c r i o nd a e ny s no' r ns c i nvol d as ex e i nd nvasve s ove y nt t M ovan s fna a r c dsi nec s a yt tac t mone a ç a c up't c hwihdr s he t ' i ncil e or s e s r o r k he y nd i t h 'he as t awal m oft de e nt t t ba l a ount oft M ova s ThePl ntf, he f nda s o he rk cc s he nt . ai if howe ,f l t e ai how ver ais o xpl n t s e nde di c r i r l vant The M ovant ha c e ed t pr hi xpa d s ove y s e e . s ve ons nt o oduc a lç ny and a lwi e e l s a 1 r ta f s c c ,de i s i ,a w ihdr w al' r f e i t D e e r ns er , he ks pos t lps nd t a s' e er nc ng he f ndan s M ova s ha a s t. nt ve l o cons nt d t pr e e o oduc r c ds i vi c h ta a i .Thus t r s e s t be no r e nt e e or nvol ng as r ns ctons , he e e m o el va i or a i t twoul notot r s bepr nf m ton ha d he wie oduce unde wha M ov shav ar dy c e e t d r t ant e lea ons nt d o poduc Theef e,t Cour QUASHESrquess( , 1,a ( . r e. r or he t e t k) () nd m) B.The Sub na wa Pr pe l I sue poe s o ry s d Unde For rRul 45( ( ,' s r me e a)2) ' ubpoe mus is ....f pr tonori pe ton,i A na t sue' or oduci ns ci f s par t f o a s e a e r m ubpoena c m a ng a pe s n' a t nd e, r m t cou tf t di ti tw he e om ndi r o s te anc f o he r or he s r c r t p od ton o i pe ton i t be m a ' M ovant c e tt i s nc oft s poe i t s he r uc i r ns c i s o de. ' s ont s he s ua e he ub na n hi di ti t3How e r m ova s a gum ent s d f lt s a t s Cour . nderf m e Rul 45,t sr c . ve , nt r s houl ai o w y hi tU or r e he pr rc t o i s as ope our t s ue ubpoe naw a t Cour w he et doc e st bepr s he t r o um nt o oduce w e e l a e Se d r oc t d. e Are v Jone ,693F. 1 1 ( t Ci.1 . il . s 2d 058, 060 11h r 982) z ai ifnow as t tt da e i que ton be J nua y 1,2006. pl ntf ks ha he t n s i a r X et rpa t ha addr s ed t cha t Rul 45.UnderRul 45 a r c nty ame d, ihe ry s e s he nge o e e s ee l nde t Subpoe s d be i s f om t Sout r D i ti tofN e Y or ' he na houl s ued r he he n sr c w k, wher t a ton i e he c i s pe ng. H ow e r t s ndi ' ' ve , he ubpoe w a i s bef e t r l t ef e t na s s ued or hat u e ook f c . - 6- I t c s atba ,Pl i ifc et is e as n he a e r antf hos o s u ubpoenaon JP.M or n Chas i t sditit . ga e n hi src a trc uli t JP. or Cha e who i tu t d Pli ift s r et br nc mana rofa fe ons tng he . M gan s , nsr c e antf o e v he a h ge ny l albr nc ofi ofJP.M or n Cha e.M ovant have ar d t ts r c i t s ditit i oc a h fce . ga s s gue ha e vie n hi src s i o r be a e t ofi t t ha e s mpr pe c us he fce ha ndl s ubpoe r quess i l atd i Dalas Te s.Thi na e t s oc e n l , xa s a gumen i unpe s sve. t ti whet rt pa t t pr r ts r ua i The es s he he ry o oducet doc he ument ' tol't m s ' r s'he con i t edititwhe et s n h src r he ubpoe wasis d. d.a 1 1. ova sha madeno s na s ue 1 t 06 M nt ve howi t tt ng ha he docume st bepr nt o oduce a enot' ontole ' J. M or n Cha e i t sditit Nori t r d r ' r ld'by P. ga c s n hi src . s he e e de e t tt y a e notc r l d i N e Y or Thus t Cour f nds t tt s vi nc ha he r ont ole n w k. , he ti ha he ubpoe w a na s pr r y i s d.l e JP.M or n Chas is l has not m a t e a gum e s or ot r i e ope l s ue nde d, . ga e t ef de hos r nt he w s o jce t t es b e a be td o h u po n . C.Sanctons are N otAppr at i opri e Rul 45d)1 (or l Rul 45()1)pr dest t e ( ( ) f mery e c( ) ovi ha A pa t or at ne r s ry tor y e ponsbl f i s ng a s r ng a s i e or s ui nd e vi ubpoe mus tke na ta ra o a ese st a odi osngu d ebu d no e p n eo a p r o s b e t o e s n bl tp o v i mp i n u r e r x e s n e s n u j c t t s bpoe The c tf t di t i twher c planc i r r d m us enf ce he u na. our or he sr c e om i e s equie t or t sdut a i pos a a opr a e s ncton ...o a pa t o a t ne w ho f ist hi y nd m e n ppr i t a i n r y r tor y al o com pl y. Fed. Ci P. d)1 . ht Mova sa t Pli ifhavea ke f s nci .Theorgi l R. v. 45( ( ) Bot he nt nd he antf s d or a tons i na s poe ha 1 caegore ofdoc e s Thepari sne i e untl he a rveda t na r d ub na d 2 t is um nt. te gotatd i t y ri t he r owe l ca e i si t pr 3 t gor e n he opos or r Oft e t M ovan sc ent o s ven, usc h t a a tons ed de . hos , he t ons t e pl as r ns c i . Be aus oft l ng nego i tons a t na r i oft s c e he o ta i nd he r ow ng he ubpoena e denc by t f c t tt , vi ed he a t ha he M ova t now cons t ove hal t r que t ,i c nno be s d t tt Pl ntf di nott ke ns ent o r f he e s s t a t ai ha he ai i f d a 'e onabese t avoi i posngunduebur ore ns ' t M ova s Thus t Cou t l ' as l t ps o r dm i den xpe e'on he nt . ,he r wil noti pos s nc i on t Pl ntf i f voroft m ova . m e a tons he ai i f n a he nt I is r pons bref Pli iff t tr ttm e as f Sa i .l make t r que t n t es e i , antf or he i s i ks or nctons t s he e s purua t Rul 37. s nt o e Howe , c 'c nnoti ver a oul a t mpos s tonunderRul 37f rco e anci e o nduc gove ne t r d by Rul 45.Se Baie I s,l .v CLJP,l ,270 F. D.662,67 73 ( D.F1 201 e e ly ndu . nc . nc. R. 2- N. a 0) ( s usi c s s. rhe, ai ifhasno madeamotont co l oduci ofdo nt a dic sng a e )Fu t rPl ntf t i o mpe pr ton cume s nd i nott pr va lng pa t i 1 c r ntm oton. t r as ,s ndi i f vorofPl ntf ar s he e ii ry n he ure i For he e ons a ons n a ai if e i p opr a e. na pr i t 1 1 Conc us on 1. l i THI CAUSE ca be or t Cour uponNon- ris Phii a I Di a asRe S me f e he t pa te ' lp nd va chi r ' newed M oi t Qua h( E. 1 ,fldonSe e r23. 4. ton o s D. No. 6) ie ptmbe 201 THE COURT hasc i r d t m oton,r s onsde e he i e pons a t pe tne po tonsoft r c d, e nd he ri nt ri he e or a bei o he wief l a s d i t pr mies i i nd ng t r s uly dvie n he e s , t s ADJUDGED t tt moton t quas i GRANTED. a ntfsa e gi n l vet r fl i ha he i o h s Pli if r ve ea o e ie n t Sou he n DititofNe Yor be or t J he t r src w k f e he udgepr i ng overt c e.Pli ipsM oton f esdi he as antf i or Sa tonsi DENI M ova s M oton f Sanci i DENI . lot rpe ng M otonsa e nc i s ED. nt ' i or tons s ED A1 he ndi i r DEN I A S M OO T. ED W- )/' . y br a y, 4. e g DONE AND ORDERED i Cha n mber a M im i Fl i ,t s ' da ofFe u r 201 s t a , orda hi .M a , -- , . kz' ' - v ' t y' , , o..; y zM' ' c , FEDERI A * ORE M . UN I TED STA TES D I STRI J G E CT UD Co e pr vi d t pi s o de o: Couns lofRe r e co d - 8-
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
