Gordils et al v. Ocean Drive Limousines, Inc. et al, No. 1:2012cv24358 - Document 157 (S.D. Fla. 2014)
Court Description: ORDER Granting In Part Plaintiffs' 135 Renewed Motion for Partial Summary Judgment. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 5/28/2014. (jw)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Gordils et al v. Ocean Drive Limousines, Inc. et al Doc. 157 UN I TED STATES D I STRI T CO U RT C SO UTH ERN D I STR I O F FLO RI A CT D M I M ID I A VISI N O CA SE N O .12- 24358cvJLK J ) G ORD I S;FRAN SI (E LI SCO RAM O S; BEYM AR SA BO GAL;RI ER M OM LES; D PEDRO P.SO SA ;and a1 ot si iary- iuat d l her m l l s t e N le 29 USC 21 b , z# r 6(3 Pl ntf s ai if , OCEAN DRI LI VE MOUSNES J ; I SNC. OCEAN DRI LI O SI S,I C SO . VE M NE N FLA . ; RI CHA RD BEN NETTI and M ELI , SSA BEN NETTI , D ef nda s, e nt / OR DER GR ANT I G I PA RT PLAINTI N N FFS'R EN EW ED M O TIO N FOR PAR TI L SUM M AR Y JUD G M ENT A THI CA U SE com es bef e t Cour upon Pl ntf s' Re S or he t ai if newed M oton f i or Pa ta Su a y J dg nt( E.1 5 ,fld Aprl7,2 4. TheCo ti f l bre e o ril mm r u me D. 3 ) ie i 01 ur s uly i f d n he e d r ul i r ton he t m a t r 1 U pon r vi w oft r cor and ca ef consde a i , t Cour fndst t he te . e e t i hat he M oton s d be gr nt i par . i houl a ed n t Thi i a a to u e t FarLa r S a a dsAc (k FLSA' ,29 U. C.j s s n c i n nd r he i bo t nd r t ihe t ' ) S. 201e s q, o u padwa s Plitf mo sf rpa ta s t e .f r n i ge . anif ve o ril ummayj me tetbls n r udg n sa ihig t a ( )t e M o o Ca re Ex mp i n t t e FLS i i p ia e ( Pli tfs we e ht 1 h t r ri r e to o h A s na plc bl, 2) a n if r 'Defndansfl a Re pons on Aprl24, 201 ( E.1 8 .Dee d nsfldaRe l o Ap i2 , 01 ( E.1 2 e t ied s e i 4 D. 4 ) fn a t ie py n rl 9 2 4 D. 5 ) Dockets.Justia.com De e n s e o e un r t FLS a no i e nd n c nta t r ,a d ( ) t e fnda t ' mplye s de he A nd t nd pe e t o r co s n 3 h tm e durng w hi Pl i if waied f wor as i e sw ascom pe abl i i ch a ntf s t or k s gnm nt ns e. 1 SU M M A RY JU DG M ENT STA ND AR D . S umma y j gme i a r p it whe e t e pla ng a s ppo tng ma e i l r ud nt s pp o rae r h e di s nd u ri t ras e t bls t t r i no genui i s ast any m at i f tand t tt m ovi pa t i s a ih hat he e s ne s ue o eral ac ha he ng ry s e tte t j g nta amatroflw.Se Fe R. v.P. Ceotx Cop.v Catet nild o ud me s te a e d. Ci 56; l e r . r t, 47 U . 31 3 2 ( 98 .A f c i û ae i l i i i ma dee m i t o t o eun r 7 S. 7, 2 1 6) a t s i t ra' f t s y t r ne he u c m m ' de t a i abl s t ntve l . Ande s v.Li t Lobb Inc. he pplc e ubs a i aw r on bery y, ,477 U . 242, 248 S. ( 98 ) Ale 1 1 F.d a 6 I t r c r a a who e c ul n la a rto lf c 1 6 ; ln, 2 3 t 46. f he e o d s l o d ot e d a ina a t fnder t fnd f t nonm ovi pary,t r i no ge ne i s of f t f ti . See i o i or he ng t he e s nui s ue ac or ral M at us t El I s hia ec. ndus. Co. v. Ze t Radi Cor , 475 U. 57 58 ( 98 . The nih o p. S. 4, 7 1 6) nonm ovi pa t m us s ng ry t how s fc f st s pecii act o uppor t tt r i a ge ne diput 1 t ha he e s nui s e. d. Onamoin frs mmayj g ntt Co tmus viw t e de ea drs l to o u r ud me ,he ur t e he vi nc n e ove a1 i e e es i t lght m os f vor bl t t nonm ovi pa t See Ander on,477 l nf r nc n he i t a a e o he ng ry. s U . at255. H oweve ,a m er s ntla ofevi nce i s S. r e ci il de n uppor oft nonm ovi pa y' t he ng rt s d. f he po iin i i ufiintt dee tamoin frs mmayj g n .See i at252. l t sto s ns fce o fa to o u r ud me t evi e of e ed by t nonm ovi pary i m e el col abl or i not sgnii nty denc f r he ng t s r y or e s i fca l p o tve s r bai , ummayj gme ti pr p r Se i a 249 0. Ho ve,i rviwig t r ud n s o e . e d. t -5 we r n e e n he rc r e d nc ,t Co tma no u ra t j r s fncin of weg ng t e od vie e he ur y t ndetke he u y' u to ihi he e dence pr ry ofer by t pari . Latmer v.Roari To I ,601 F. 1 vi ope l f ed he tes i ng yz, nc. 3d 224, 1 7 ( 1h Ci. 2 0 (i a n if' e d nc mus b tke a f c vaue a a1 23 1 t r 01 ) lpli tfls vi e e l t e a n t a e l , nd l j siibl ifrnc saet bed a i hi fvo .Net rweno t dititc u taet u tfa e n ee e r o rwn n s a r i he r he src o r r o u e tkec e i iiy d tr nai nso weg t e de c .) nd ra r d b lt ee mi to r ih he vi n e' . ' I M O TO R CAR RI EX EM PTI l. ER ON Tht pa tes f l bref t M ot Ca r e Exem pton i s i r l ton t ri uly i ed he or r i r i s ue n e a i o D ef nda s'Rene ed M oton f Pa talSum m ar J e nt w i or ri y udgm e ,Se D , .134, 1 151, nt e E 43, The Court her eby adopt is r oni i is Or r Denyi D ef nda s Re w ed s t eas ng n t de ng e nt ' ne M oi f Pata Su r J dg n ( E.l )a d de isPli if'M oin t t ton or ril mmay u me t D. 6û n ne antfs to o he e ent i s xt t eeks a fndi t t Exempton does not a y i t s cas The r d i ng hat he i ppl n hi e. ecor c nti g nun dip e ofmaeilfc whih prcude s o ans e ie s uts tra a t c e l ummay j gme on t s r ud nt hi 1 SSue. I L EM PLO YE ES V ERSU S I EPEN DENT C ON TR ACTO R S I ND 4. Le St gal andar d , A de er i ton of e pl e s a us unde t FLSA i a ques i of lw .See t m na i m oym nt t t r he s ton a An e o v D & S Fa ms 8 F. 9 9 ( 1h Ci.99 ;Br we v Mer Da tn r . r , 8 3d 25, 29 1 t r1 6) ou r . to. de Cz@, 1 9 F.d 81 81 ( 1h Ci.998 ( iig V la r alv Wo ha 11 F. 2 / , 3 3 7, 8 1 t r1 ) ctn ilr e . od m, 3 3d 02, 2 ( 1h Ci.997 ) S i ir fnd n , we e , r is soff c. t lc sv Cabe 05 1 t r1 ). ubsda y i i gs ho v r a e s ue a t San e ie . l Wiig,1 F.Su 2 1 1 31 ( D.Fl.2 )( iig Pat lv Wa go,8 F. rn 47 pp. d 3 3,1 8 S, a 001 ctn e . r 03 2d 6 , 4 n.1( 1h Ci.98 ) 32 63 1 t r1 6). l i oy'u rt FLS lncud s t s f ro pe mi t wo k. 2 U. C.j Empl ' nde he A i l e o ufe r r t o r ' 9 S. i ' 2 3( . Dee mi a i o e o m e i a hi hl f cua s ue a de nds o t e 0 g) tr n ton f mpl y nt s g y a t lis nd pe n h t c no c r aiy ofa lt cr umsa e . La o v DHL Ex ( A) I . 68 F. s o mi e l e t l he ic tnc s' yt n . ' p. US , nc , 6 3d 1 7 1 7 ( 1h Ci.2 2) Th p ri s i e in i ir lva t Don an v Ne 1 2, 1 7 1 t r 01 . e a te ' ntnto s ree n . ov . w Fl l an Ho e,I . 67 F. 46 ( 1h Ci.1 2 . Th Elve t Cic tha putf rh ordi t l nc, 6 2d 8 1 t r 98 ) e e n h r ui s ot a e g tf co ts,i wh c no o f co i dee m i tve:( )naur a d g e o n i h -a t r e t n ih ne a t r s t r nai 1 t e nd e r e f c n r l of wo ke s ( d g e of s pe vso dr c o i die t of wo k;( ) rg t o to r r ; 2) e r e u r ii n, ie t r n r c, r 3 ih , die ty o i r c l t hie fr ,or mod f e o m e o ii ns ofwor r ;( r cl r ndie ty, o r , ie iy mpl y ntc ndto ke s 4) p rt stpa rtso meho o pa n ;()prpaainofpa ol a pa nto owe o e y ae r t ds f yme t 5 e rto yr l nd yme f wa s ( ) owne s p of f c l is whe e wor o c re ; ( ) wor r 'pe f r n e o ge ; 6 r hi a ii e t r k c ur d 7 ke s ro ma c f s e ilyj b itg a t t b i s ;a d ( )ive t nti e ui nta fclis 1 . p cat o ne r l o he usnes n 8 n sme n q pme nd a ii e . d t Al f ct sgo t t cor ques i i t put tve empl l a or o he e ton: s he a i oyee e conom i l de ndi on caly pe ng t put i empl r he atve oye ? #.Ana i Vss The i vi ndi dualdef nt t s ii d i t r ca t as t com or t D ef enda s e tfe n hei paciy he ae endant s' c r r t r pr s nttve u rRu e30( )6 . E.76 2,3: 5 o e ve ,t i i i a o po ae e e e ai s nde l b ( ) D. - 1 .M r o r he nd v du l Def endant have s i a ed t t i t com or e D ef nda i f s tpul t ha f he at e nt s ound t be t FLSA o he e pl r t t i vi m oye , hen he ndi dualDef ndant w oul bet i vi e s d he ndi dualFLSA e pl s D . m oyer . E. 76- 3: 4: . 2, 23- 1 The Cour a es es e f t i t n,a ong w ih t e putf ' by D e e t ddr s ach ac or n ur l t hos olh t f ndant s i t i Res n he r pons a fnds t tt a yss w ei hea l i f e, nd i ha he nal i ghs viy n avor of a em pl e n oym nt r atons p. el i hi i Cont oland Su vi on . r per si Ri r Be ti one of t i vi cha d nne t, he ndi dual D ef endant , t tfed t t t ot s es ii ha he her i vi lD ef nt M els a Be ti a he s ndi dua enda , i s ne t, nd uper s Pl i i f k n al a vied a ntf s s 1 venues oft i he t a por a i busne .'D . 76- 26: 2r ns t ton i ss' E. 2, 1 13. Def endantM els a Be tit tfed t t is nne t es ii ha Das Rod i ue ma g d t ofie b ,û a tt e e d o t da ' s a we e t iy rg z na e he fc ut ç l h n f he y, he ns r d o l ' Def nt M els a and Ri d Benneti D . 76- 37: 5- . Thus,t i vi enda s is char t . E. 3, 1 21 he ndi dual Dee f ndant c r l t o r ton. The t o i vi l D ef s ontoled he pe a i w ndi dua endant ens ed t t s ur ha Pl itfswe eû pjo ry d e s d, o ry s ve a rvi g on tme e c tr . D. 7 an if r t r pe l r s e pr pe l ha d, ri n l i , t e e a' E. 6 ' 2,26: 7-18. 1 i. iRkhtt Mod? Emplyme Cta /tl o o nt /l//?, z: N one of t Pl ntf s r ai ng i t s ltgaton pe f m e any m a he ai if em ni n hi ii i r or d nagem ent dute D . 76- 27: 9. l Pl ntfs f ied t f l t r quie ent s by i s. E. 2, 5f ai if a l o olow he e r m s et D ef nda s t w oul be r prm a e nt, hey d e i nded.D . 76- 27: 4. Pl ntfs di not s t r E. 2, 3ai if d et hei own s chedul s a i t d we e t f l t m aniess gi t t . D . 76- 27: e nd ns ea r o olow he f t ven o hem E. 2, 1722. ii Pay Rat t Payr l i. es t ol A lhough Pl ntf s we e pai on a c m i s on bass Pl ntf s i om e w as t ai if r d om s i i, ai if ' nc depe ndenton t r drvi t r es gi n t t .D . 76- 5: 4,76- 27: 3, hei i ng he out ve o hem E. 3, 10-1 . 2, 10-1 1 22. 7- i S v. peci t Job aly Plitfswe ec a fu s t y di no e ga ei as caie j whihr q rd anif r h ufe r ;he d t n g n pe ilz d ob c e uie a tonalt a ni ddii r i ng. The onl r r ent f t poston w a obt i ng a chauf e ' y equiem or he ii s a ni f rs r gitain ( c lc n e wh c ,De e ntRiha d Be et tsii d,r q r s on y a e sr to ha k ie s ) i h fnda c r nn ti e tfe e uie l physcalexam a f one t be dr fee.D . 76- 29; 1- 1.Thus no uni s lsar i nd or o ug r E. 2, 1 2 , que kil e r quie f Pl ntf s'postons. e r d or ai i f ii v Owne s p o . r hi fFaclte an n e t n i Equ nt iiis dl v sme t n kme Pl ntf s ne had t pr de a of t r ow n equi e .D . 76- 28: ai if ver o ovi ny hei pm nt E. 2, 1 4. The ca s Pl ntf s dr w er owned by D ef ndant D . 76- 27: 25. Pl ntfs r ai if ove e e s. E. 2, 23ai if wer notr quie t cl an t ve cl s t m s ves D . 76- 37: 38: ,76- 26: 6. e e r d o e he hi e he el . E. 2, 23- 9* 3, 2Pl i if di notadve ts t s ves D . 76- 27: 4- 6. a ntfs d r ie hem el . E. 2, 1 1 v. f n nt ' o s d Co sde ai s iDee da s Prpo e n i r ton D ef nda s ar e nt gue t t Pl i if had ot r wor prva el ar a ha a ntf s he k i t y r nged w ih t i vi l and, t r or a e not D ef ndi dua s he ef e, r endant FLSA e pl s' m oyees. Es e i l t s s ntaly, hi a gum e i l e t phr e leconom i aly de ndent' t m ea S ol s ce of r nt ntat s he as d c l pe ' o n l e our s lvelhood.' Tha i notw ha t FLSA i ends. SEmpl 'unde t FLSA i desned i i ' ts t he nt û oy' r he s pur ua t t t alt oft cicum s a s and t a s nt o he ot iy he r t nce he bove f t s. The f ct s s tf t ac or a or e orh above do notent t n w ha a i vi erai t n ndi dualdoes on of -i e. Ra he st f ftm t r he ocus i on what s t wor e r e was lke bet ee a pl i ifand a def he k nvionm nt i w n a ntf endant Thus,whe he or not . t r Pl ntf s had s r t y a r nged w or i ir eva t w he he or not Pl ntfs w er ai i f epa a el r a k s r el nt o t r ai if e Dee f ndant 'FLSA e pl es. s m oye Def nt a s m ai ai t Pl ntf s ar i pendent contact s becaus of enda s l o nt n hat ai i f e nde r or e wha Pl ntf s ls e on t r t r t ns Pl ntfs cl m e ce ai a ount as t ai if i t d hei ax e ur . ai if ai d rt n m s i pe nde ndentco r or on t i pe s ntact s her r onalt r t ns f t r l ax eur or he e evantyear H ow e ,t s. ver he FLSA em pl ent i r di notgover by t (abel puton t r a i hi by t oym nquiy ks ned he l ' he el tons p he pate o te c nta tc tolng ta rlto hi .'S anta v Jf y Kni t I c, ris r h o r c onr li h t eains p.. c lnd . eh ' gh, n . 721F. d 1 08,1 1( 1h Ci. 1 ) 3 3 31 1 t r 20 3 . D iti t c t ha f sr c our s ve ound t tt l ha he abelwor r us w ih r s t t t 1 i ke s ed t e pec o he RS s ir e r elvant i consde i whe her t pe s w a a i n i r ng t he r on s n ndepe nt c r ct . Clnc v. nde ont a or i y Gal diS.Ent r s ,l . 808 F.Supp.2d 1 ar e pries nc , 326, 1 9 ( . Ga 201 )( nd n t a 34 N D. . 1 Fi i g h t Pl ntf s hol ng t s ves outt t 1 S a i ai i f ' di hem el o he R s ndepe ndent contac or doe notm a r t s s ke t e i e n ntc nta t r f rFLS pu pos s) Ha r l v Di d A Entra n n, h m nd pe de o r co s o A r e .; r e l . amon e t i me t I c,9 2 F.Su p.1 3 ( . FI .1 7)(û an if ' c r ce i ai n f rt x pu po e n. 9 p 34 M D. a 99 ipl itfsj ha a t rz to o a r s s g and t pr s on of e pl he ovii m oyee bene is a e notr l ft r e evant Def nda cie no cas w hi h . e nt t s e c cons der t e f or i t c extoft br d i ufbrorper i t w or defnii of i s hes act s n he ont he oa s f m to k' i ton e oy n c ti d i te FLS ';s e alo Robih au v Ra l Matra,l . mpl me t onane n h A.) e s ' c e x . dct eil nc, 6 F. 6 ( t Ci. 1 3 ( l r we e ç mpl y e ' e n t oug t y sg d 97 2d 62 5 h r 98 ) wede s r : o e s' ve h h he ine e contact sa i t w er i r t tng hey e ndepe ndentcontact s f ni hed t r ow n equi e a r or , ur s hei pm nt nd i ur nce c ns a over ge,w e e s fempl a r eloyed on t r t x r t ns a had t i own busi ss hei a e ur nd he r ne cr ) a ds . The f ct s gover ng Seconom i aly de nde ' do not ponder per ona t x a or ni ç c l pe nt' s l a r t ns. M or e ur eover , i e iel pos i e Pl ntf s w e e s mpl wr s ntr y s bl ai i f r i y ong i t r n hei pr r ton of t r t r ur epa a i hei ax et ns. A ccor ngl Pl ntf s' t r ur do not cr at a di y, ai if ax et ns e e ge ne is of m at r a f ct a D ef nt di not m ee t r bur n of s i a nui s ue e i l a nd enda s d t hei de how ng s h ads t Thus s uc ipue. , ummayj dg n mus b e ee t fndta Dee nt wee r u me t t e ntrd o i h t fnda s r Pl i if 'FLSA e pl s. a ntf s m oyer l EN GA G ED TO W AI V. T W. Le St gal andard De pendi on t nat e of t wor tm e s ng he ur he k, i pent waii f wor ca be tng or k n c mpe a l.Ar r& Co. .Wa oc , 3U. 1 6,1 4 (944 ; imor v S ( o ns be mou v nt k 32 S. 2 3 1 ) Skd e . w#tf Co,3 U. 1 4,6 S. .1 (94 ) Bid l v Cjpo . 23 S. 3 5 Ct 61 1 4 ; r wel . / fGad de ,A1 ,9 F.d 8 2, s n a. 70 2 0 8 8 ( 1h Ci. 1 92 . De em i ng whe he tme i c 0 1t r 9 ) tr ni t r i s ompe a e u e t FLS ns bl nd r he A Si ves s r i a cons r ton of t a eem ent bew een t pari ul r pari , snvol c utny nd tuc i he gr s t he tc a tes appr s l of t r pr tcal consr ton of t w or ng agr ent by c ai a hei ac i tuc i he ki eem onduct , consder ton oft na ur oft s vi e,and is r a i t t w aii tm e a al of i ai he t e he er c t el ton o he tng i , nd l t s r he ur oundi cicum s ances' Ski or 323 U . at1 ng r t .' dm e, S. 37. Som e f t s t cons de w he dec di t ext ntt w hi an ton cal' em pl ac or o i r n i ng he e o ch d l' oyee i f eet e ge i pe s s r o nga n r onala i tes i ude' ctvii , ncl . ( )wheh rt r wa a o p e s slvi r q r me t ( whehe t r 1 t e he e s n n- r mie i ng e uie n ; 2) t r he e we e e e sve ge grphia r srci ns o e oy es mov me s ( r xc s i o a c l e tito n mpl e ' e nt; 3) wh t rt fe ue y o c lswa u ul r srci e;( wh t ra fxe ehe he r q nc f al s nd y e titv 4) ehe i d tme lmi f r r s ns wa u ul r srci ;( ) whehe t e o c l i i t o e po e s nd y e titve 5 t r h n- a l e o e c d e sl ta e o c l r s nsb lte ;( whehe us ofa mplye oul a i r d n- a l e po i iiis 6) t r e y pa r c ul e s r srci ns a ( ) whehe t e e oye ha a t l ge o d a e e tito ; nd 7 t r h mpl e d c ual y e ngaged i pe s n r onalac i tesdurng cal-n tm e. tvii i li i fu v y v M er Dad Cn/ ,8 F.S p.1 70,1 76 ( D. a 1 4)( ii Owe v r e . to. e y. 70 up 5 5 S. Fl . 99 ctng ns . Lo alNo.l 9 As ' o We tr Pul a Pa r Wo k r,9 1 F. 3 351 (t c 6 , sn f se n p nd pe r e s 7 2d 47, 9h Ci.99 ) r1 2 #. Anal i yss The onl f s Pl ntfs putf t t a gue t t tm e s ntw aii f wor i y act ai if orh o r hat he i pe tng or k s com pens bl i t r a er i t t upon t rr ur fom l vi D ef a e s hei ss tons ha , hei et n r ea ng endant pr i es s' em s f a am ount of tm e, Def nt woul not gi t m wor Ther or Pl ntf s or ny i enda s d ve he k. ef e, ai if ag ,t y wee rqurd t watl g ho s bewe n j bs a c d notla t r ue he r e ie o i on ur t e o nd oul e ve he pr m ies Pl ntf s r y on onl t rown af i t asevi nce. e s . ai if el y hei fdavis de Def endant diagr w ih t s pi ur of t wor envionm ent Thei w ines ,a s s ee t hi ct e he k r . r t s f m erdipat herf t company,t tfe t tPl ntfs Sos Ram os a Sa or s c or he es ii d ha ai if a, , nd bogaldi d nothave t w ai f wor D . 76-1 25: 15,32: 1 1 A lhough Pl i ifG or ls di o t or k. E. , 8- . 1 - 3. t a ntf dii d s e i esha t w ai,he w asnotpr e e y da and w he he br om tm ve o t es nt ver y n oughthi w aii t s tng o Dee n Rihad Be net' atni Pli ifwa gve aj b.D. 7 1 26: 2 fnda t c r n tis te ton, antf s i n o E. 6- , 2-4. Pli ifM o ae ,on t e ot rha ,wa fe ue l watng f j .D. 7 2,29: 6 antf r ls h he nd s r q nty ii or obs E. 6121. The e cttm es a Pl ntf w asever w a tng a enote t i he xa i ny ai if y ii r s abls d. Dee f ndant cont t D ef s end hat endantRi d Benne t r r Pl ntf s t a rve char ti equied ai if o r i by 9: a i or rt be a s gned w or but t r i no evi 00 m n de o si k, he e s dence fom D e e nt t t r f nda s ha Pl ntfs we e notper it d t t ke l h or br ks of t pr i es D . 76- ,32: 6. ai if r m te o a unc ea f he em s . E. 1 5I f t Def n ac , endant 'wines t tsed t tD ef ntRi r Benne t t i t kee t ngs s t s esi ha enda cha d ti red o p hi û sc pa ei a hec l wi t d ie s'a dwo dgi t m j si t yc mpli d. s o c tc s oud t he rv r, n ul ve he ob f he o ane a h ' D . 76- 27: 3. Def E. 1, 4-1 endant a s cont nd t ta1 Pl i if f ee y l f f l s lo e ha l a ntf s r l e t or unch and woul r t n.D . 76-1 30: 0. d e ur E. , 9-1 Thus t r i a ge ne diput i t r d as t t m at ralf s s r , he e s nui s e n he ecor o he e i act ur oundi ng Pl i if f ee tm e a t r degr of i pende a ntfs' r i nd hei ee nde nce durng t tm e. Thi diput i hat i s s e fr co e s o e ls s ummayj dg n ont c r u me t he ompe a l n tr ofPli if'wattme ns be au e antfs i i . V .C ON CLU SI N O A cc di y,upon a ca ef r vi w of t r d and t Cour bei ot or ngl r ul e e he ecor he t ng henvie s f l advied,i i O RDER ED,A DJUD G ED ,and D ECR EED t tPl ntf s'Re uly s ts ha ai if newed M o i n f r Pa ta Su r J me t ( E. 1 5) be a t e s me i, he e to o ril mma y udg n D. 3 , nd h a s r by G R AN TED i par . Pl ntfs ar her f n t ai if e eby ound t be Def ndant 'e pl s unde t o e s m oyee r he FLSA . DO N E and O RD ERED i Cham be satt Ja esLawr nc K i Fede alJ tc n r he m e e ng r us i e B iigadUntdSae C utos, a , lrd ti1é dyo Ma 2014. uln n i tts or ueMimiFoiahs a f y d e h , * .. J M ES LA W REN CE K 1 N I TED STA TES D I ST JUDG E SOU TH ERN D I STRI O FLORI CT DA c c: A l Couns ofRe d 1 el cor
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
