Doe v. University of Miami et al, No. 1:2012cv23933 - Document 42 (S.D. Fla. 2012)
Court Description: ORDER Denying 24 Motion to Remand to State Court Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 12/27/2012. (jw)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Doe v. University of Miami et al Doc. 42 U NI TED STA TES DISTR I C O URT CT SO UTH ERN DI STR I O F FLO RI A CT D CA SE N O .1 23933- V- l G 2C1 K N MI CHA EL J ES ATTEA , AM Pl i if a ntf, UN I VERSI OF M I I( I TY AM M LLER SCHOOL OF M EDI NE) A CAREER CI , COUN SELI G CEN TER ,I , d/ a N NC , b/ / PHY SI AN ' D EVELOPM EN T PROGRAM , CI S LAW REN CE HARM ON ,PH D . & , A SSOCI ATES,P. . LA W REN CE HA RM O N, A, ROBERT HERN AN DEZ,M . . M ARK D , O' CONNELL, . , M D.GONZALO QUESADA, M . , A.GONZALO QUES D. P. , ADA, and A NA CA M PO,M . . D, Def nt . enda s / OR DER D ENY I G M O TI N TO R EM AND TO STA TE CO UR T N O TH I M ATTER com es bef e t Cour upon Pl ntf s M oton t Re and t S or he t ai i f i o m o S a eCo r ( # ,fld No mbe 2 201 TheCo r i bre e on t m at r lyo t t u t DE 24) ie ve r 9, 2. u t s i f d he te . r t r onsdicus ed bel Pl ntf M oton i deni he eas s s ow, ai ifs i s ed. Pl ntf orgi l fl t s cas i t 11 h J ci Cicui Cour f M i m i ai if i naly ied hi e n he t udi al r t t or a Da Count a l gi vi a i de y, le ng ol tons of f al a s a e l w .2 Pl ntf s r eder nd t t a ai i f e ved m os t 'De e da sfld aRe p ns ( /:1 o De e e 1 , 2. an ifsRe y( #37 wa fld f n nt i e s o e DE / ) n c mb r 2 201 Plitf' pl DE ) s ie 1 Dece ber24. m 2Pli ifsfvec un Co an ( #1 1 alg s vi a i softeAme ia wihDia lte Ac of antf' i -o t mplit DE - ) le e : olton h rc ns t s biiis t 1 9 ( u t1 a teRe a l ainAc o 1 7 ( nt1) b e c o fdu aydu is( n 11; 9 0 Co n ) nd h h bii to t f 9 4 Cou 1; r a h f i cir te Cou t 1) t b e c o c ta ta i tDe e da UM ( n l ;a bra hofc ta ta is De e da t r a h f onr c gans f n nt Cou t V) nd e c onr c gan t f n ns Dockets.Justia.com Def nt on Oct enda s ober 4,201 Def 2; endant M ar O ' k Connel was s ved on Oct r 8, l er obe 2 2, a d t e t Que a De e da t we e no s r e u i Nov mbe 5, 201 01 n h wo s da f n n s r t e v d ntl e r 2. De e n s tld No ie o Re va ( #1 o Ocobe 3 2 1 a s ri f e a fnda t se tc f mo l DE ) n t r 0, 0 2, s e tng ed r l q si n j id ci n un r 28 U. C.j 1 31 The No ie ofRe va al g d t ta l ue to urs ito de S. 3 . tc mo l le e ha l Def nda scons nt t r m ova .H ow e ,D ef nda A Ca e Couns i Cent r a e nt e ed o e l ver e nt r er elng e nd t H a m on D ef nda s di not sgn t N otce of Rem ovalnor di t fl t r own he r e nt d i he i d hey ie hei n tc o r mo l t e Que a a De e nt wee n tc ule b t o he De e a t o ie f e va ; h s d fnda s r o ons t d y he t r f nd n s a di no j i t e flng. ( N ovem ber 9, 2 2,De e a t A Ca e r Co ns lng nd d t o n h ii 3 )n 01 f nd n r e u ei Ce t r a t Ha mo De e a s fld No ie ofCo e tt Re o l( #8 a d n e nd he r n f nd nt ie tc ns n o m va DE ) n No i e o J i r( #9; /1 ) t Que a De e n s fld Notc o Co e tt tc s f onde DE DE / 0 ; he s da fnda t ie ie f ns n o Re va ( # )a No ie ofJ nd r( # o De e e 4,201 Pl itf n w mo l DE 25 nd tc oi e DE 26) n c mb r 2. an if o s ks r m and alegi t t Def nt ' r ovalw as untm el beca e i w as not fl d ee e l ng ha enda s em i y us t ie w ihi t ry daysoft fr tD ef nda bei s r on O c obe 4,2012. t n hit he i s e nt ng e ved t r The f r r ovalsat e i t be srcty i e r ed.Shamrock O i & Gas Cor ede al em t ut s o t i l nt m et l p. S es 31 U. 1 1 -0 61 S.Ct 8 ( 9 ) s el Cor v Am.Ho he t, 3 S. 00, 08 9, . 68 1 41 ;Ru s l p. . me As u an e Co ,2 F.d 1 40 ( 1h Ci. 1 . s r c . 64 3 0 1 t r 200 ) Unde 28 U. C.j 1 ( ,a n tc o r S. 446 b) o i e f r m ovalm us be fl wihi t ry days of t def ndantr ei ng a copy ofpl adi e t ied t n hit he e ec vi e ngs t ta er mo b e ûl u n miy r er q r st talde e nt c ns n t a dj n a ha r e va l . s- na i t ul e uie ha l fnda s o e t o n oi -he notce ofr m ovali or f i t be ef e i ' Baie v.Jans Phar i e n der or . o t f ctve.' ly sen maceutca,I . i nc , Ph iin' De eo ntPr r m,La e c Hamo a Go aoQue a ( un V) Pl ntf' ysca s v lpme og a wr n e r n, nd nz l sda Co t . ai ifs Compl ntlssbot CountI a CountV s at y askcountl .' ai it h V nd epar el s V' 3Def dant Res et t i t M oton s aes:(l t NotceofRe oval t Uni st m en s' pons o he nsant i t t tn he i ver iy , he De e d nt mitke y sae t tt Qu s d Dee a t co e tdt rmo lAtt tmeo t e f n a s sa nl ttd ha he e a a fnd n s ns ne o e va . he i f h Notc couns f t Uni siy De endant beleved t taI r ni def ie, el or he ver t f s i ha l emai ng endant wer r ese ed by s e epr nt c ns l o t eHamon De e a t. ( /31 p. n.1 . ou e f r h r f nd ns' DE / , 3, ) ' 5 6 F.d 1 02,1 07 ( 1h Ci.2 ) To ca iy ho t c lult t e lmiai nspe i d 3 3 2 2 1 t r 008 . lrf w o ac ae h i tto ' ro when m uli e def tpl endant a e s ve at dif ent tm es Congr s e ded t Feder s r er d f er i , es na he al Cour sJ i di ton a V enue Cl rfca i A c of2011 Pub. w . o.112- 1 St t t ur s c i nd a ii ton t , La N 63, 25 a 75 Th lw a e d Se to 1 6( t sa e t f d f nd nt a e s r e a d fe e t 8. e a m nde ci n 44 b) o tt : i e e a s r e v d t if r n l tm es,a a l t r s ved def i nd a e - er endanttl a notce ofr oval a ca ler s r def nda ies i tm , ny r i - e ved e nt m a cons t t r ovaleven t y ent o he em hough t ea le - er def nda di notpr vi l hat ri r s ved e nt d e ousy i tae o c ns n t r mo l'28 U. C.j 1 46( ( ( .Thi c ng i f d r l1w niit r o e t o e va . ' S. 4 b)2)C) s ha e n e e a a was cons sentw ih t El ve h Cicui' hol ng i Baie v.Jans Pharmaceutc it t he e nt r ts di n ly sen i a, I .t tt t ry- lm ia i pe i f r m ova begi t r upon s vi of t nc ha he hit day i t tons rod or e l ns o un er ce he l t s r def nda .536 F. 1 as- e ved e nt 3d 202.Skem ovalby t l t s r d def s l he as- e ve bndanti pr s operi f al def nda s cons t r m oval eve i t l t s r def 1 e nt ent o e , n f he as- e ved endanttm el r m oves t i y e he c e a t t e r i of t pr vi l s rved def as fer he xpiaton he e ousy e endants t ry- y wi ' hit da ndow t o r mo 'J e v Co e ve. on s , mmon alh La Til I .Co , 9 F. p' 8 ,81 ( 1h Ci. ' we t nd te ns . 45 Ap x 08 0 1 t r 201 . 2) I t abo s yl a i a 1D ef nda spr ry s r d t r notce ofr m oval n he ve- t ed cton, l e nt ope l e ve hei i e w ihi t ry da oft l ts ved D ef ntr ei ng t Com pl nt The l s- er ed t n hit ys he as- er enda ec vi he ai . a ts v De e n s Gon ao Que a a a Go z l Que a , M . , P. , we e s r d o fnda t, zl s d nd n a o s da D. A. r e ve n N ove be 5, 2012. A cc di y, D e e m r or ngl f ndant had untl D ec ber 5, 201 f a 1 s i em 2 or 1 De e a t t c ns ntt r mo l On t td t , n t Qu s daDe e n stld t er f nd n s o o e o e va . ha a e whe he e a f nda t se h i Notce of Cons t Rem oval D ef nda s w er unani ous i r m ovi t t s Court4 i ent o , e nt e m n e ng o hi . Rem ovalw ast n ef ec i he f tve. A s cont a y s r r uppor f hi poston, Pl ntf cies t t e ca t or s ii ai if t o hre ses f t or he pr oposton t tt t ry- y lm ia i pe i be n t r w he t fr t Def ii ha he hi t da i t tons r od ga o un n he is endant wa sr e . e( # p. (ii Dib lv S. Tr c ig Co, 2F.S pp. d 1 1 , s ev d Se DE 24, 2) ctng e e . B. u kn .26 u 2 39 1 2 ( . Fl.200 ;Smi v He t Ct.o a e t y I . 25 F.S pp.2d 1 3 32 M D. a 3) t . alh r fL k 7r, nc, 2 h u 36 ( . Fl .20 ) Na h v Po tnb r 931 M D. a 03 ) t e . te e g, Su p. 8 2, 8 ( . Fl 1 2. p 2 25 M D. a. 9959 H oweve , t e ca es a e i pplc e as t r hes s r na i abl hey w er deci e ded unde t fr t s r r he is- e ved de e ntr e.Thi Courtnow mus appl t l t s rve def ndantr e i acc da f nda ul s t y he as - e d e ul n or nce wih t El nt Cic t s2008 hol ng i Baie a r enty a e d f de allw t he eve h r ui' di n ly nd ec l m nde e r a . A c di y, afer ca ef consi aton, i i O RD ER ED, AD JU D GED, and cor ngl t r bl der i t s DECREED t tPli tf sM o i nt Re a t S a eCo t( #24 be a i he e ha an if to o m nd o t t ur DE ) , nd s r by, D ENIED . DO NE AN D O RD ER ED i Cha ber a t J es La r e K i Fede a n m s t he am w enc ng rl J tce Buidi a Unied St t Courhous , M i m i Fl i t s 27t da of us i l ng nd t a es t e a , or da, hi h y D e m be ,201 ce r 2. r AM ES LA W REN CE K I G N I TED STATES DI STRI J GE CT UD SOU THERN D I STRI OF FLORI CT D 4Def endant Uni st ofM i i Roler Her ndez, M ar O ' s ver iy am , n t na k Connel,and Ana Campo f l t r l ied hei NotceofRemovalOc ober30,201 . Def i t 2 endant A Car rCouns i Cent Lawr s ee elng er, ence Har on, and m Lawr nceHar on,Ph. & Ass aes, P. ,fl t rN otce ofCons t Rem ovalon Novem ber9 e m D. ocit A. ied hei i ent o 201 . 2 , . ' Cc: Couns l rPl nt efo ai W M ar ow eJay Bl l ake M a l J.Bl r owe ake 2255 Gl desRd,Suie 324a t A Boca Ra on,FL 33431 t 305- 3379 670Fa 670x: 3380 Emal mj a @belo t ne i: blke ls uh. t Co e fo De e nt uns l r f nda s Er cD avi I i f i d scof I i fRa t & K oeni ber s cof ga z gs g 1 Brc lAvenue 200 ikel Suie 1 t 900 M i i FL 331 am , 31 3053733232 Fa 305- 3233 x: 373- Emal liof@ ilw.o i:sc f ra c m Ter a R agat es z l i of Ragat & K oeni ber sc f z gs g 1 Brckel A venue 200 i l Suie 1 t 900 M i m i FL 331 a , 31 305- 3232 373Fa 373x: 3233 EmalRa az ilw.o i: g t@ ra c m Sus V i ni W arner an rgi a I i of Raga z & Koe gs r sc f t ni be g 1 Brcke lAvenue 200 i l Suie 1 t 900 M i m i FL 331 a , 31 305- 3232 373Fax:3053733233 Emalwan r ilw.o i: r e@ ra c m John W .M aur o Bilng Cochr Lyl M aur & Ra s PA li an es o m ey, SunTr tCent r 6t foor us e, h l 51 Ea tLasOl Bl 5 s as vd. For La r e,FL 33301 t ude dal 95 764- 50 4- 71 Fa 954- 7279 x: 764- Emalj i:wm@ bcmrc m l .o Trac A.M iche l y t l Col ,Sc t& K i s ne,P. . e ot sa A 9150 Sout D a and Bl h del vd. 1 h Fl 4t oor M i m i FL 331 a , 57 786- 268 6441 Fa 305- 2294 x: 373- Emalta y. thel c ke lc i:rc mic l@ s lga.om 6
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
