Tiffany (NJ), LLC v. 925jewelrymax.com et al, No. 1:2012cv23518 - Document 13 (S.D. Fla. 2012)
Court Description: ORDER GRANTING APPLICATION FOR ENTRY OF PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 10/15/2012. (ail)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Tiffany (NJ), LLC v. 925jewelrymax.com et al Doc. 13 UNI TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT SOUTH ERN DI STRI OF FLORI CT DA CA SE NO.1 23518- V- TZ/ M ONTON 2Cl SEI S1 TI FFANY @ J,LLC, ) Pl ntf, ai if VS. 9ZS EW ELRYM AX. J COM , al, et . De e nt. f nda s / O R D ER G R ANT I G A PPLI A TI N FO R EN TR Y O F N C O PR ELI I RY I M NA NJU NC TI N O THI M ATTER i be or t Cour on t Oc obe 1 201 he rng o Applc to f S s f e he t he t r 5, 2 a i n ia i n or Enr o Prlmi ayIj ncin (h l p iainf rPr l n r Ij ncin' ( 5 . ty f ei n r nu to t e ç lc to o ei ay nu to ' DE-1 Ap mi ) By teisa tAp lc to , an if Tifn @ J,LLC (t an if' mo sf re tyo a h n tn p iain Plitf, fa y ) ç itf ) ve o n r f pl prl n r ij n to a an t De e d n s t Pate s i o Unic r rtd Aso ito ei ay n u cin g is fn a t he rn rhps r n opo ae mi s cains i ntfe o Sc dul C 'hert ( l tvey t ee de iid n he e G A' eo coleci l r fndant' f alege vi ai of t s' or l d oltons he ) La h m Ac 1 U. C. j1 1 a d 1 2 5 a a d( ) TheCo r h sc rf lyrviwe t si n a t 5 S. j 1 4 n 1 5 () n d . u t a a eu l e e d he ad Applc ton,t e ieCour fl a i ot r s f l ad s d i t pr m ies i a i he ntr t ie nd s he wie uly vie n he e s . Att he rng onl c he a i y ouns lf Pli ifwaspr s nta a lbl t pr s nte de e e or antf e e nd vaia e o e e vi nc s p rigt eAp lc to frP ei n r lj nci n ( 5 .Dee da t h v n trs o d dt u po t h piain o rlmiay n u to DE- 1 fn n s a e o e p n e o n teAp iain f rPrlmiaylj ncin, o ma a fln i t i c s , o h v De e d n s h pl to o ei n r nu to n r de ny ii g n h s a e n r a e fn a t c a ppea e i t s m a t re t ri vi l ort oug c r d n hi t e ihe ndi dualy hr h ouns l Beca e Pl i i fha s i fed t e. us a ntf s ats i he rquie nt f t is nc of a pr lmi r ij ton,t Cour wil grnt Pl ntf s e r me s or he sua e ei nay n unci he t l a ai if Ap lc t n frP ei n r lj n to . DE- ) p iai o rlmiay n u ci n ( 5 . o Dockets.Justia.com 1. Fac ualBacker t ound 1 Pl ntf r nuf c u e ,pr nots diti es a s ls i i e sa e c nl r e, ai if na a t r s ol e , srbut , nd el n nt rt t or ne c icu ig wihn t s j d ca d src, lx r g o u e mutpe fd r ly r gsee n ldn ti hi u iil itit u u y o ds nd r lil e e al e itrd tade r .( De lrton of Stven Cosel i Suppor of Pli ifs Applcai f r maks See caai e tlo n t antf i ton or Te o ayRe tanigOre Iç sel De 1' !4) mp rr sri n d r ç tl c .J . co o ' Pl i ifi t owne a / e l i lce e oft f l ng ta m a kson t antf s he r nd or xcusve i ns e he olowi r de r he Prncpa Re se oft Unied SttsPae a Trde r Ofi ( l tvel t ' fa i i l gitr he t ae tnt nd a mak fce coleci y, he ' fny Ti M aksf: rf ) X ' * Tr adem ar k Re sr i gi t at on N um be r Reg s r i i t aton D ae t C l s/R e e as l vantG oods ew:A .c ç NY& o 00 35 3 ,2 ,7 Sept m be 5, I 01 . e r c 4 j wer a dwac e . e ly n th s X FF Y AX O 1 3063 3, J l 6, 9 0 I 01 j wer f rpes n l a , o uy 1 2 C 4. e ly o ro a we r n t ' j9 83 TI FANY & CO. F 12 8,8 ,2 1 9 i l ng wache . ncudi t s Fe ua y 22, I ;:j , br r ( 4 TI FFANY 12 , 9 ,2840 Fe ua y 22, I ( j . br r c )4 TI FFAN Y & CO. 1, 3, 28 306 I 01 cl hi a es ore - na y, C 4. ot ng cc s i s mel J 26,1984 c fi andke hol r une uflnks y de s T & CO . 1, 365 669, 18 93 18 93 j wer e ly. j wer e ly. December24, I 01 .a1y e o j wer ma eo , r C j 4 l tp s f e ly d f o 1 991 r - e ous t l nd/ t n pa tot pr ci me a sa orwih , pr ci ors m ipr ci sone . e ous e - e ous t s ' i.' Fj ' ; 1'ï 7.'r ('' ,' ,. 17 52 4 ,8 ,0 PERETTI 1787, , 861 , Au u t3 1 9 I 01 .j wer ; a l, a i g . g s , 9 3 C 4 e ly n mey e n n s I 01 j wer nn l, arng , C 4. e ly; mey e ri s Augus 1 1 t 7, 993 ne klc ,pe nt , a lt a rngs c a es nda s br cee s nd i m a ofpr i m eal de ecous t s. l The f cua ba ound i t ke fom Pl n if s Compl i , Applcai f Te por r a t l ckgr s a n r aitf ant i ton or m a y Re tai ng Or r a s pori e de i r s bm isons Pli if fld decar to a sr ni de , nd up tng vi nta y u s i . antf ie l ai ns nd e bis anne d t r t i s xhi t xe he e o n uppor of is Applca i f Tem por r Resr ni Or . The t t i ton or ay tai ng der de a a i a e a lbl i t docke a t f l ng e ti s De l r ton of St ve Coselo clr tons r vaia e n he t t he olowi n re : c a a i e n tl ( 5 1 , caai n o S e h n M . fi a ( 5 4 ,De lrto o M iha lPia o ( 5 DE- - 1 De lrto f tp e Ga fg n DE- - ) caain f c e c d DE- 1 J a dDe lr to o ErcRo ae ( 5 1 ) 3 ; n ca ain f i s lr DE- - 5 . ELSA PERETTI 1 I 01 .j wer na l e rig , C 4 e ly; mey, arn s 799, 2 27 , i ) ; ! i jg 4g5 o, ? , !' q' ,; . ; : TI FFAN Y & CO . j.t ij .1 r p ' u:h. 1. ; 1 968, 4 , 61 O c o r1 1 t be 9, 993 No e e 1 I 01 j wer ; a l , arn s v mb r 6, C 4. e ly n mey e rig , 1 993 ne kl es br celt,pe nt , ndrngs c ac , a e s nda s a i . I 01 a1 t C 4. 1 ypesoftmepice ,i udi i e s ncl ng A pr l1 1 i 6, 996 e pe aly wa c . s ci l t hes zj 4j y g y :g V ' Q$ x è Aug t2 ,1 9 us 5 9 8 2 359, 351 - J 20, une 2000 , . ne kl c , c a es penda s br c e sa rngs nt , a elt nd i ma ofva it ofm aeral i l ng de rey t i s nc udi pr i usm eal, ec o ts I 01 j wer a dwac e . C 4. e ly n th s I 01 boxes C 4. . I 01 j wer ; th s C 4. e ly wac e . I 01 C 4 . TI FFANY 2, 539 639, ATLAS 2886, 655 , dec a i boxe or tve s. Oc obe 22, 2 I 01 wa c . t r 200 C 4. t hes S pe 4r21 I 01 j wer rn s b a ees e tmb , C 4. e ly; ig ; r c lt; 200e e ni ;ne ac s pe nt . a ngs ckl e ; nda s The Tif M a ks a e us d i con c i wih t ma a t e a diti i ofgo i t fany r r e n ne ton t he nuf cur nd srbuton ods n he c tgores i ntfe a ae i de iid bove. ( e Cosel De l ! 5; s alo Unie Stts Trde r Se tlo c. ee s td ae a mak Re sr tons of t Tif ny M a ks a is at c d a Compost Exhi tA t t Coselo gita i he fa r t s ue ta he s ie bi o he tl Dec. 1) Defnda s t oug t I er t websts ope atng u r t domai na e e nt , hr h he nt ne ie r i nde he n m s ie tfe o S h d l ( ' rt (h ç u j c Do i Nn s),h v a v rie ,p o td d niid n c e ue t heeo te t b e t man me ' a e d e tsd rmo e , A' s o frdf rsl, n / rs l a latj wer s c a b a ees n c a e , e a t, a i g a d fee o ae a d o od, t e s,e ly, u h s rc lt, e klc s p nd ns e n n s n rngs wache ,cl hi ac es ores nn ey,c ti ,ke hol r ,a gitbo sbea i what i , t s ot ng c s i , m l uflnks y de s nd f xe rng Pl ntf ha de e m i d t be countreis i rnge e s r oduc i , and or c or bl ai if s t r ne o e f t , nfi m nt, epr tons / ol a e i tto sof h Tifn M ak .S eCo tloDe l! 9-4. miain t e fa y r s ( e sel c. ! 1 ) 4. A lhough e c D e enda m a notcopy a i rnge ea Tif M ar f e h t ah f nt y nd nf i ch f any k or ac ca e y of g t gor oodspr e e Pl i ifha s bm it d s f c ente de e s i e c D e e nt ot ct d, a ntf s u te ufi i vi nc how ng a h f nda ha i rnged, a las, o e o mo e o te Tifn M aks ( e Co tlo De l ! 11 1 ) s nfi t e t n r r fh fa y r . S e sel c. ! - 4. Def nda s a e notnow,norha t e r be a horze or lc ns d t us ,r pr e nt r ve hey ve en, ut i d i e e o e e oduc ,or e ma c efis rpr i ,and/ col a ei ttonsoft TifnyM aks ( eCoselo ke ountret, e oductons or orbl miai he fa r .Se tl De l!9. c. ) Pl ntf r t i AED l tgai ns I . a lc ns prvae i si tve fr , ai if e aned nvesi to , nc, ie ed i t nve tga i im and l si tve Cons t nt,a lc ed prv e i tg i e fl ,t i tga e t s l of nve tgai ula s iens i at nvesi atv i' o nvesi t he ae m c u tretv rinsofPli tf sp o ucsb De e d n s ( e Cosel De l! 1 De lrto o ne fi eso anif r d t y fn a t. S e tlo c. 0; caain o ErcRo ae i Su p r o Plitf sAp iai n frTe o ay Re tann Or e rRo ae f i s lr n p o t f an if pl to o mp rr sr i ig d r d s lr c De l' ! 3; caain o M ih e Pia o i S p o to P an ifsAp iain f rTe o ay c.q De lrto f c a l c d n u p r f litf ' pl to o mp rr c Re tann Or e rpia De 1'!3) sr iig d r t c do c.) . ' 6. I Aprl201 a Se e r201 Erc Ros lr(ç ae' ,an ofi rofAED n i 2 nd ptmbe 2, i ae $ 1r' Ros ) tce l v siain ,l c, a e a o d rfrte p rha eo ()e n n sb ai a lato e o t n e tg to s n .plc d n r e o h u c s f i a i g e rng t e s n f he Tifny M ak a is e i t sa to tr u h t e I tm e we st o e aig u e te S b e t fa r s t su n hi cin h o g h ne t b ie p rtn nd r h u j c Do i Na tfa yc na s l.o (i ak y rn b ai a la to e o t eTifn M aks man me if n a da a ec m; i) e i g e rng t e s n f h fa y r a is e i t sa to tr ug te I tr e we st o e ai u d rt e S b e tDo i Na t su n hi ci n h o h h n en t b ie p rt n e h u j c man me ng i f s o zo zc m;a d (i)ab a ee be rn a la to eo t Tifn M aksa is i t s n a hin l .o n ii rc lt ai g t e s n f he fa y r t sue n hi a to tr u h t e l tr e we st o eai u d r t e S b e t Do i Na cin h o g h n en t b i p r t e ng n e h u j c man me who e aee ly ol c m.( e Ro ae De l ! 4- . Ro ae fn lz d p y n f r t ls lj wer z z.o S e s lr c. ! 6) s lr i aie a me t o he Tif ny- a d ea rngs pur s d t ough tfanyc fa br nde ri cha e hr if anadas ec vi Pa al .om a ypalt t Pa l o ht ypa a c t ,tfa v a a a ae g i.o ( e Ros lr De l ! 4 a Co st Ex bt A c omt ifn c n d s l@ mal m. Se c ae c . nd mpo ie hii atc dt rt )Ros lrfnaiedpa ntf t Tif brnde ke rngpurhas dt o ta he heeo. ae i lz yme or he fany- a d y i c e hrugh i f s o zo zc m va Pa pa t t e Pa pa a c u t wu o v ng gg @ c i.o ( e n a hin l .o i y l o h y l c o n , v u o l l malc m. S e Ro ae De l ! 5a Co o i Ex i tB atc e t rt )Ros lrfn lz dp y n f rt s lr c. nd mp st hbi ta h d heeo. ae ia ie a me t o he e 4 Tif ny- ande ba ee p rh sd t r u h whoe a ee ly ol c m v a Pa pa t t e fa br d r c lt u c a e h o g ls lj wer z z.o i y l o h Pa p la c u t c n s n h a 8 @ c i.o ( eRo ae De l ! 6 a d Co ost Ex i i y a c o n, l g he c u nc 8 mal m. Se s lr c. n mp ie h bt i c C atc t r t ) ta hed he eo. Ad ii n ly Roslr a c se ltr t we ie o eaig u d r t S be t d to al , ae c e sd nene bsts p rtn n e he u j c Domai Na e i ii d i t t bl beow ,a wen t ough t pur sng pr es z f n m s dentfe n he a e l nd t hr he cha i oc s or va i uspr t ,a 1butone ofwhi h bor c eret of a l as,one oft Tif ny M a ks a ro oduc s 1 c e ount f is , t e t he fa r t is ei t i a to 3(d. t!7 a d Co st Ex ii D t eeo. Fol wi g s b s in o hs su n h s cin. I a n mpo i hbt h rt ) lo n u miso f i e or r ,Ros lr r e ve i or ai f fnalzng pa e f e h of t iems or r d vi de s ae ec i d nf m ton or ii ym nt or ac he t de e a Pay a orbank ta f rt De e nt r s c i Pay la orba ac ount ,a f l ; pal nd/ r nse o f nda s' e pe tve pa nd/ nk c s s olows D om ai N am e n Pa m e M e hod nt t A c ount c 4 g se ly x.o z j wer ma c m Pa p l ya sl r z j wer y ho .n i g se l a oc ve a xuesne .t ba . m votco Bat Tr ns e rk a f r Pa Pa l HSBC Hongkong Br h; anc Ba A c nk coun N um be :******+*5838; t r Ac ountName:M a c ywal til ndusra Li t d; mie SwitCode:I f &HSBCHKHHHKH' ' f vora a 'mes ho m alc t i.om c rire ly o e ae .o a t j wer wh ls lrc m e Pa Pa 1 a mi a mi .o d n d nc m c nas u le sco hi hoes ir . m chi whol al 688.com 5 na es el Pa Pa 1 Pa Pa 1 oks on m ahoo.om .n c c c da hot lc nyi mai.om 2Ros l ri e i ly di notfna i hi pur has fom t l e ne we ie s ast a d a e nt ntona l d i lze s c es r he nt r t bst s o o voi c rb i f onti utng undst De enda s c f r . o f nt ' ofe s 3Alh u ha1 ftewe i so e ai t e teS b e tDo i Na sofe f rs l Tif n t o g l o h bst p r t md r h u j c man me fr o ae fa y e ng b a d die (e Gafg nDe l!2a dCo ost Ex ii A t eeo , ae itn in ly rn e tms s e fia c. n mp i hbt h rt ) Roslr n e to al e pur ha e non- fa br nde mer ha s fom s c sd Tif ny- a d c ndie r ome oft we iesoper tng unde t he bst ai r he Su jc Do i Na sa p r o hsiv siaiep o e s ( eRo ae De l! 7 n 1) b e t man me s a t f i n e tg tv r c s .Se s lr c . , . . 4Thef la ountnum be sofa lfnancali tt i a ot si i he en ha bee ul cc r 1 i i nsiuton cc mt dentûed r i ve n r da t t a ddi cos eofprvae fna ali or i n,i c pla e wih Fe R.Ci P. e c ed o voi s l ur i t i nci nf mato n om i nc t d. v. 52 a( ) .()4 . 5The é yme 'pagef t c na ç pa nt' or he hi whol s l 1 c we iepr dest ba ta f r e ae 688.om bst ovi he nk r ns e i or a i f rfnalzi pa e sf pur ha esi ntf ng t ba a counti or ton: nf m ton o i i ng ym nt or c s de iyi he nk c nf ma i Zho zuiShe Ba OfChi ;Ba Acc mtNumbe ***+ng n; nk na nk ot r **+********3- ( 580.See Gafg n De l!5a d Co o i Ex i t t eeo. fia c. n mp st hbiD h rt ) e 5 e tf a . c if n com Pa Pa 1 goods a com a a. Ba Tr nser nk a f l n f ' er ooki orew l m a lcom i. I ti land Comm e cilBa of ndusra r a nk Chi na; Ba A c ountN um be : nk c r +++++++++++++++ ?64q; Acc mtNa e:De Ja hun; ot m ng ic Swit f Code:SCBKCNBJ CI GDG' ' * 9 80303 a c .n m hoo.om c Ba ofChi Puta Br nc nk na in a h; Ba A c ountNum be :#*##** * nk c r - **+ +++ . ++1 961 ; Ac countNa e: i ng Ja m M nFe ing; Swit f Code:S tBKCHCNBJ 73C' ' h io d u. t ed u o ne Pa Pa 1 j 1 on 8 homal o oms 0 23 t i. m c i a hi nf s onzol c z.om Pa Pa 1 z humei 966 1 j welr o grsc m e leyf r il.o j wer - s.o e l ltc m Pa Pa l Pa Pa 1 ta ta 6 6 g i.o inin9 9 mal m c 11n 8 malc m iid1 9 i.o mode'wer . e l com Pa Pa l nvr nguicom e . ove c te . om r ari rc Ba Tr ns e nk a f r Pa Pa 1 admi a m i c n d n.om I ti land Comm e cilBa of ndusra r a nk Chi na; Bn A c ot tN um be :**##** nk c m r ++++++###?j5(; ) A cc ountN n e:YuFe Luo; m i Sw i tCode: CCBK CN B J N ' f CI FJ ' ea h m a lc i. om s s hoe buyc nmc hi om s s t r de. hoe ci a eom s l t e fcom t eis l . tfa ndcobr c e .om if nya a eltc tfa a if n ndcoe r i .om a rn c Pa Pa 1 Pa l ypa Pa Pa 1 Pa Pa 1 Pa l ypa Pa Pa l da i ze n n m a lc i.om l i 601 gm a lc u n i.om 461 431 87 6 .om c es m f n 1 ht e 68 . m co s 10224 ho m alc hi a t i.om 1i inkuai a c a a hoo.om tfa c j wer a .o 7 ifn oe l uc m Pa Pa y 1 j wer d s n usr la malc m e l ei a tai i.o fr t he ps l c isc a a e.om Ba Tr nser nk a f Pa Pa 1 rpl a -o sc m e i sj ya .o c m alc i.om 6 et y n 'p g f rtej y sb r tsc m we st p o ie t b n ta frif r t n Th i me t' a e o h o a - a aa .o pa b ie r vd s he a k rnse n o mai o f fnai ng pay e sf pur s si ntf ngt ba a co i or a i Ze Gongyong; or lzi m nt or cha e de iyi he nk c unt nf m ton: ng Ba ko Chn , zho M ain S b- a c Ba kAc o n Nu e * * * * ** * * 8 3. n f ia Fu u ja g u Br n h; n c u t mb r * * * * * * * 68 ( eGafga De l!5a Co o i Ex ii D t eeo. Se fi n c. nd mp st hb t h rt ) e 7 G y n'p g f rt tfa y oe ly u.o we iep o i e teba kta se The t me t' a e o he ifn c j wer a c m bst r v d s h n r n fr pa i or ton f tnalzng pa e sf ptr has si ntf ngt ba a ounti onnai n: nf ma i or i i i ym nt or lc e de iyi he nk cc nf to Li iW a BnnkofChi Ba Ac ountNumbe *#*#***#*###***1 4.SeeGafg n me ng; na; nk c r 31 ( fia De l!5a dCo ost Ex btD t eeo) c. n mp ie hii h rt . 6 tf a ood. om if n c Pa Pa l t ews o' k m ai. om lc tfa y e ly u lt o g ifn j wer o teu.r Pa pa y l io e f s ins p n soe g i.o l v my a ho ho pig tr mal m c w hol a e e el 201 c es l ' w r 2.om whol altfa l tcom es e if ny- s. whol altfa 'we l . m es e if n e le co oo .com S dsa Pa Pa l Pay l pa Pa Pa l PayPal s rc 936 m ai. t i ker lcom 1lnd189 g a lc ii m i.om o e n wi ni ndows hot lc mai.om 1 920568 956 q . com (e RoslrDe l !7a Co o ieEx ii D te eo. s e ae c. nd mp st hb t h r t ) 8 . M ih e Pia o (Tia o',a e o e o l e t ai e Co s la t,a c se c a l c d ç c d ' n mpl y e f nv si tv n utn s c e s d ) g t el tr twe i so e ai g u d rt Su j c Do i Nn sie ii d i t tbebeo h n ene bst p r tn n e he be t man me d ntfe n he a l lw, e a wen tlough t pur ha i pr es gf va i pr t ,m os ofwhih bor co e f t nd t lr he c sng oc s or rous oduc s t c e unt reis o , a la t o e o t Tifn M a k a is e i t s a to .0 ( e Piado Decl ! 4 a d f t e s, n f he fa y r s t su n hi cin 1 se c n . s der ca ve nf maton Compost Exhi tA t rt ) Folowi s isi ofhi or s,Pi do recei d i or i ie bi heeo. l ng ubm s on he t der d a ypa nd/ nk r f r o f fnalzi pa e f ea h of t iems or e vi Pa l a or ba tans e t or i i ng ym nt or c De enda s r s c i Pa la / ba ac ount ,a f l : f nt ' e pe tve ypa nd or nk c s s olows Dom ai Nam e n Pa m e M e hod nt t 9 r .om 98tadec m ale i a. m lr plc co Ba Tr ns e nk a f r Pa Pa 1 Ac ount c Ba o Chi Puta Br nc nk f na in a h; Ba Ac nk countNumbe : r ++##++##++#+++#Jg;j; A c un N a e: n G ui ng; co t m Li yi SwitCode:S f ' BKCH CNBJ C' 73 ' ka ei he en ma lc t rna l i.om 8 t The d payme 'pagef t g nt' or he oodsac we iepr de t ba ta f i or ai f r .om bst ovi s he nk r nser nf m ton o fna i ng pa e sf pur has i ntf ng t ba ac ounti or ai Xi i lzi ym nt or c es de iyi he nk c nf m ton: aweiChe Ba n; nk ofChi PuinBrnc Ba Ac ountNumbe *** ****na ta a h; nk c r ********8767.Se Gatga Dec. ( e fi n l !5a dCo ost Ex bt t eeo) n mp ie hiiD h rt . 9Pi ado i e i naly di nottna i hi pur s s f om t l e ne w e iess ast a d c nt nt o l d i lze s cha e r he nt r t bst o o voi c r bu i f onti tng unds t D e e nt 'cofer . o f nda s f s 1Alhoughaloft we ie o rtngunde t Sub e tDo i Nnmesoferf s l Tifny 0 t 1 he bsts peai r he j c man f or ae fa b a d die (e Ga fg nDe l!2a dCo ost Ex ii A t eeo , c d itn in ly rn e tms s e f a c. n mp ie hbt h rt ) Pia o n e to al pur ha e no Tif br ndedm e c ndie fom s eoft we ieso r tngundert c s d n- fany- a r ha s r om he bst pe a i he Su j c Do i Na sa p r o hsiv siai ep o e s ('ePia oDe l!4, .1) be t man me s a t f i n e tg tv r c s .s c d c . n . e 7 Ba ofChi ; nk na Bn A c ountN um ber nk c : *+***+++++++*++81 32; A c ot tN a e:HuiD u; c m m SwitCode:S f t BKCHCN BJ 44W 'I 'I Bal Tr nse rk a f r Chi Merha sBa ( na c nt nk HongKong Brnc ; a h) s 4ne ac co ho ckl e. m s 4tfa .om ho if n c Ba Tr nser nk a f Pa Pal Ba Ac ountN umber ****#* #*# nk c : +++4801 ; Ac ountNa e:Cha eng Shi c m of ; SwitCode:C BCHKHH' f T CM ' s 1 0224 hot i. m hi a ma lco ( ePia oDe l!4a dCo o ieEx bt te eo. Se c d c. n mp st hiiA h r t ) Furhe m or , Tifny' couns , M r Gafi n, a es e De e nt ' I e net t r e fa s el . fga cc s d f nda s ntr we st o rtn u d r t e S be t Do i Na , e c l.o a d we t t r u h te b ie peaig n e h u j c man me c oyc m, n n ho g h pur hasng pr s vi t e col c onlne sor l Folowi s c i oce s a he c y.om i t e. z l ng ubmis o ofhi o de ,M r sin s r r . Ga tga r eve i or a i f fnai i pa e f r hi or r vi Pa lt De e nt ' fi n ec i d nf m ton or i lzng ym nt o s de a ypa o f nda s Pa ypala co ,asf l s c unt olow : D om ai N am e n Pa m e M e hod nt t A c ount c e ol . cc com Pa Pa l c' z m a lc i. om ( eGafga De l!4a Ex ii C te eo. Se fi n c. nd hbt h rt ) 1 Folowi t s ison ofPia sor rfo t l e ne we ieope ai unde t 1 l ng he ubm s i c do' de r m he nt r t bst r tng r he Su j c DomanNa male lc .o t bn kta se a c u tif r to wa p ovd dt bet i me lrpiac m,he n r n fr c o n n o mai n s r ie o hi vi t m a le ia.om webst Addii ly,Piado r c ve a e- a lfom t m a he lr plc c ie. tona l c e ei d n m i r he De e d n sv at eemala d e ssr ie male iac m p o dn t b r ta f ra c u t fn a t i h - i d rs e vc @ lrpl .o r viig he al rnse c o n c k i or ai f rhi o de vi t ma le ia. we ie. bn ta f ra ounti or ai nf m ton o s r r a he lr plc com bst The nk r ns e cc nf m ton pr de t Pi ad vi t malr plcac webst a vi t Defnda s e mai i i ntc ovi d o c o a he le i .om ie nd a he e nt ' - l s de i al e e f t Swi Codewhi i i ntfe on t m a le imc webst a , xc pt or he h ch s de ii d he lr plc om ie s IBKCHCNBJ '( ePi doDe l!4,n.4. i 4OO. Se ca ' c. ) 1M r Gafi n i e i ly di nottna ie hi pur has fom e ol com soast a d 2 . fga nt ntona l d i lz s c e r cc y. o voi co rbutng f ndst t Def nda s cof e s nt i i u o he e nt ' f r . 8 1 0. The ea tr Pli irs r pr s a i r vi wed a viua l i peced t web r fe , a ntf e e enttve e e nd s ly ns t he pa lsi ,ncudi i a s f t iemsbe i Pli ifstade a kspur has by Ros lr ge itngs i l ng m ge , or he t arng a ntf r m r c ed ae a deemi t ie t beno ge neveri ofPli ipspr t.( e Coselo Dec. nd tr ned he tms o n- nui sons antf oducs Se tl l ! 1 . Ad iin l ,Plitf srp e e ttv rve d a d v s al i pe td t i msb ai g 1) dto al anif e r s naie e iwe n iu l ns ce he t y y e e rn Plitf ta e r o frd f rs l tz u h t el tr e we stso r t g u e teSu j c an ifs rd maks fe e o ae h o g h ne n t b ie peai nd r h be t n Dom an N a s a de e mi d t pr t t be una ho i e non- nui ve sons of i me nd t r ne he oduc s o ut rz d, ge ne ri Plitf sp o ucs ( e Co tloDe l! 1 - 4. an if r d t. S e sel c. ! 2 1 ) On S ptmb r ee e 2 2 Plitf fld is Co lit ( I a ans t e 01 , an if ie t mpan DE- ) g i t h De e nt f tade k c eretng a i rnge nt f le desg in of orgi f nda s or r mar ount f ii nd nfi me , a s i nato i n, c r qua tng,a co m o 1w unf rc ybe s ti nd m n a ai ompe ii On Se e r28,201 Pl ntf fld is tton. pt mbe 2, ai if ie t Ex Pa t Ap lc to f r Enr o Te o a y Re tann Or e ,Pr l n r lj n to a d re piain o ty f mp r r sri ig d r ei a y nu cin, n mi Or e Retan n t Tr n fro Ases Tid t t e Comtretn Op r t n ( 5 . On d r srii g he a se f s t e o h t ef i g eai DE- ) i o Oc obe 2,201 t Cour is d a Or er Gr ntng Te t r 2, he t s ue n d a i mpor r Resr i ng Or fx Pa t ay tani der re ( 9 a d tmp rrl r sr ie t Dee da t fo ifi gn t ePlitf sM aksa is e DE- ) n e o a i e tan d he fn n s r m n rn ig h an if y r t su . Pur ua t t Cour' Oc obe 2,201 Or ,Pl n ifpr de t De enda swih notcea s nt o he ts t r 2 der aitf ovi d he f nt t i nd c esoft Cour' Oc obe 2,2012 Or ra Pl ntf sEx Pare Applc ton f Enty ofa opi he ts t r de nd ai if t ia i or r Te o ay Re tanig Or e ,P ei n r Ij ncin,a d Or e Re tan n te Trn frof mp rr sri n d r r l a y nu t n d r srii g h a se mi o AsesTi t t Countretng Opeaton,vi emai t t e laddr ses r l ctd i t s t ed o he efii ri a l o he mai est ) ete e n he d man rgsr t n d t f rte S be tDo i Na s v a e i t te e i a d e se ) o i e itai ae o h u j c man me , i mal o h mal d r sts o p o i e o t Itr t we sts o rtn u e t S j c Do i Na s a /r r v d d n he n ene b ie peaig nd r he ube t man me ndo ee to ial va t e c n a ts b s in we p g p o i d o t we ie frt e S be t lcr nc l i h o tc u miso b a e r vde n he bsts o h u j c y 9 Doma n Na e . The e tr Pr sofSe vi we e fld c i ng s r c o t De e nt i m s r afe , oof r ce r ie onfnni e vie n he f nda s ( I a dDE-2 .3 DE- 1 n 1 11 I. I LEGAL STANDARD I o d rt o ti a p ei n r ij n t n,apa t mus d mo tae 1 l (h r i1a n r e o b an rlmi ay nu ci o ry t e nsr t d ) tee s ( s bsa ta lk lh o o s c s o t emeis ( )t a ir p rbl ij r wilb s fee i t e u tnil iei o d f uc e s n h rt; 2 h t re aa e nu y l e u frd f h rle i n tg a td ( )t a tetr ae d ij r o t ihst eham t r le wo l i lc o eif s o rn e ; 3 h t h h e tne nu y uweg h r he eif u d nfit n t non- nt a ( t tt e r oft r i woul s nr t publc i ers. Sc av e he mova ; nd 4) ha he nty he elef d e e he i nt e t' hi o x. ' r lS hide v Sc iv , 3F.d 1 2 ,1 2 - 6 ( 1h Ci. 0 5 ; e a s Le i r u sd Co e c n lr . ha o 40 3 2 3 2 5 2 1 t r 2 0 ) s e lo v Sta s : . v S n ie 1 tl T a n I c,51 F.3 98 98 ( 1h Ci. 1 9 ) (p yn t e ts t a . u rs n ' r dig n . . d 2, 5 1 t r 9 5 a plig h e t o prl n r ij n to i aLa h m Ac c s) ei ay nu cin n n a t a e . mi 11 1. AN A LY SI S r t i ton o e i na y The deca ai lr tons Pli if s it d i s antf ubm te n uppo t of is Applcai f r Pr lmi r Ij n to s p o th f lwi c ncu inso lw: nu cin u p r t e ol ng o lso f a o Pl i ifha a ve y sr ng pr biiy ofpr ng a ti lt tc ume sa e lkel antf s r to oba lt ovi t ra ha ons r r i y t be c us d by De e nt a rie t pr m oton,s e ofe f s e,a / diti i o onf e f nda s' dve ts men , o i al, f r or al nd or srbuton o j wer s h a b a ees n c lc s p n a t, e ri g a d rn ,wac e , cohn f e ly, uc s rc lt, e ka e , e d n s arn s n igs th s l tig ac es ore na y,c ti ,ke hol r ,a gitboxe bea i c e f is r pr tons c s is, mel uflnks y de s nd f s rng ount re t, e oduc i , and orcol a e i t tons oft Tif ny M a ks a t tt pr t De e nt a e s lng / or bl mia i he fa r , nd ha he oduc s f nda s r eli a pr nd omotng a e c es of Pl ntf s pr t t t be r co e of t Tif ny M a ks on i r opi ai if oduc s ha a pis he fa r j wer , uc a b a ees n c lc s p nd n s e ni g a d rn s wac e , lt n a c s o is e ly s h s r c lt, e k a e , e a t , a n s n ig , th s cohig c e s re , na y,c fi ,ke hol r ,a gitboxe mel uflnks y de s nd f s. 1Aso t ed t o p ei n r ijmcinh a igc n uce o Oco e 1 , 01 te 3 f h ae f r l ay nt to e rn o d td n tb r 5 2 2,h mi r drcino t Su j c Do i Na st t es r i gst, e ie t f he be t man me o h ev n ie o htp:/e vi notc com/if /nde ht l ha notbe fnalze Alhough e h De e nt t /s r nc ie. tfpp3 i x. m , s en i i d. t ac f nda hasr eved notc oft Cour ' Oc obe 2,201 Or ra t Oc obe 1 201 he rng vi ec i i e he ts t r 2 de nd he t r 5, 2 a i a t e e toni no ii ai m ehodsa horz d byt Cour. he l c r c tfc ton t ut i e he t 1 0 B. Be us of t i rnge e of t Tif ny M a ks Pl ntf i lke y t s f r ca e he nf i m nt he f a r , ai i f s i l o ufe i d ae a d irp rbe ij r i ap ei n r ij n to i n tg a td l ce ry a p a s mme it n re a a l nu y f r lmia y nu cin s o rne . t la l p e r fom t f l ng s ii f c s as s t f t i Pl ntf s Compl nt Applc ton f r he olowi pec fc a t , e orh n ai if ai , i a i or Prl n r Ij n to a d a c mp n ig d ca ain o fl,t a i dit a d ir p rbl ei a y nu cin, n c o a yn e lrto s n ie h t mme ae n re aa e mi ls ,d ma e a d ij r wilr s l t Plitf a d t c n u r b c u e i i mo elk l tu o s a g , n n u y l e ut o anif n o o s mes e a s t s r iey r e t no t t han t ha : De e nt own or c r ntr t we ie busnes es whi a rie, f nda s ontoll e ne bst i s ch dve ts p o t, fe f rsl , n s l a la t e ly s c a b a ees n c lc s p n a t,e ni g r moe o fr o ae a d el t e s j wer , u h s rc lt, e ka e , e d n s a n s , a rngs wac s cot ng ac es ores nnme y,c fi ,ke hol s a gitboxesbe i nd i , the , l hi c s i, l uf nks y der , nd f arng c e f i a i rngi ta m a ksi vi a i ofPli ifsrg s ount ret nd nfi ng r de r n olton a ntf i ht ; 2. Ther i good c e t be ive t t mor count f i a i rngi e s aus o le ha e eret nd nfi ng pr ct b rng Pli ipsta m a kswila ari t m a keplce t tc ume sa e lkel odu s ea i a ntf r de r l ppe n he r t a ; ha ons r r i y t bem ild,c us d,a dia ntd by t qua iy oft s pr t and t tPl i ifm a o se onf e nd s ppoi e he lt he e oducs; ha antf y s frl sofs l sf isgenui pr t ; ufe os a e or t ne oduc s C. The balnce o pot nta ha m t Def nt i r tani t i tade i a f e il r o enda s n esr i ng he r r n c t efi a d i fi gn b a e g o si ap ei n r ij n to i is e i fro t ih d o mtret n nrn ig rnd d o d f rlmiay n u ci n s su d s a u weg e byt potnta ham t Pl ntflisrputtona goodwila amanufcurrandditi orof he e il r o ai it t e ai nd l s at e srbut qua iy pr t ,i s h r i i no is d; lt oduc s f uc elef s t sue and D. Th p bi itr s fv r is a c o t p ei n r ij n to i ode t e u lc n ee t a o s s u n e f he rlmiay nu cin n r r o pr ec Pli ifs ta m a k i e e t and pr e t t publc fom bei de r uded by t ot t antf r de r nt r ss ot c he i r ng fa he pa mi of ofco e f i g l ng f unt re t oodsasge negoodsofPl ntf. nui ai if E. Unde 1 U. C.j 111 ( ,Pli ifmay b e ild t r ove,a a equia e r 5 S. 7a) antf e ntte o ec r s n tbl rme y teilg l o isg i d tr u h Dee d ns d srb to a d s lso j wer ,s ha e d , h le a pr ft ane h o g fn a t' itiui n n ae f e ly uc s 11 l br cee s ne kl e , penda s e ni a lt , c ac s nt , a ngs a rngs wathes cl hi ac es ore , name y, nd i , c , ot ng c s i s cuflnks key hol r ,and g f boxe be rng cou e f is a i rnge e s of t Tif ny fi , de s it s ai nt r et nd nfi m nt he fa M aks.Se Re r e ebok 1 ' Lt v.Mar e h Entr . I . 970 F. 552,559 ( h Ci.1 ntl d. , natc e s, nc, 2d 9t r 992) (uotngFule Br hPr ct Co.v.Fule Br s Co. 299F. 77 777( t Ci.1 (( q i lr us odu s lr u h , 2d 2, 7h r 962) ( An 7() s ynonymouswih a awar ofmonear da ge t n d t y ma s: a co tng ofpr isunde j 111 a i nots c uni oft r $ana c u tn f rp o is. .sa e utb erme ys j c t t p i cplso e u t '). gl c o n ig o r ft . i n q ia l e d ube t o he rn i e f q iy.') ' F. Req si e t bl r i tivoke t dititcour' i r ntequiabl powe s ue tng quia e elef in s he src ts nhe e t e r t or r pr lm i r r lef i l ng a as e fe ze,i o de t a s e t a ia lt of o de e i na y e i , nc udi n s t r e n r r o s ur he va lbiiy pema n rle . fe Staus d Co.v Sunrs I 1Tr ng I . 51F. 982,987 ( 1h Ci. r ne t eif' vi r s r ' . ie nt adi nc, 3d 1t r 1 ( tng Fe r Tr Commison v.Unied St e Oi and GasCor ,748 F. 1 , 995) cii de al ade si t ats l p. 2d 431 1 34( 1hCi.1 ) 433- 1 t r 984). G. I lgh of t i r nty de ptve naur of t c e f ii busnes and n i t he nhe e l ce i t e he ountr etng i s, De e nt 'blt ntvi a i oft f der ltade r l ws Pl ntf ha good r s n t beive f nda s a a olton he e a r ma k a , ai if s ea o o le De e d n swil i eo ta se t erilg te a s t b y n t ej rs ito o t sCo r u ls fn a t l h d r rn fr h i l- otn s es e o d h u idci n f hi u t n e s t eas e sa er sr ne hos s t r e tai d. I . V CONCLUSI ON Fort f e ng r a ons i i he or goi e s , t s ORDERED AND ADJUDGED t tPlitf sAp iai nf rPr l n r Ij n to i ha an if pl to o ei ay nu cin s c mi h rb GI NTED ( 5 a f l : ee y U DE- ) s ol ows Ea h Def ndan , is ofier , die t s empl yees ag s s i a i , c e t t fc s r c or , o , ent, ubsdires diti or ,a a lpe s i a tve c e torpa tci ton wih a De e srbut s nd l r ons n c i onc r ri pa i t ny f ndan ha ng notce t vi i oft sOr raehee r sri da enoi d: hi de r rby etane nd j ne a. Fr ma a t i i om nuf curng, mpori a tsng,pr tng, dverii omotngsofe i t s l i f rng o el, s li diti i or ta f ni a pr t be rng t Tif ny e lng, srbutng, r ns e ng ny oduc s a i he fa 12 M a ks or a co usngl smia ta m a ks ot r t t e a t ly r , ny nf i y i lr r de r , he han hos c ua l ma a t e orditi e by Pl ntf;a nuf cur d srbut d ai if nd Fr om s r tng, c eai desr ng, s li of, ta f rng, or ec e i onc lng, toyi e lng f r nseri ot wiediposng of ()a pr t,notma acur orditi e her s s i : i ny oducs nuf t ed srbutd by Pl i if bemi t Tif ny M a ks o any c usngl smia antf, ng he fa r , r onf i y i lr ta maks or(i any e denc r ltng t t ma a t e i tton, rde r ; i) vi e eai o he nufcur , mporai s l ,ofe f s l diti ton,orta f r of a pr t be rng t a e f r or ae, srbu i r nse ny oduc s a i he Tif ny M a ks ora conf i y sm ia ta m a ks fa r , ny usngl i lr r de r . ( 2) Ea h Dee nt is ofi r, die t s e oye , age t, s i ais c fnda , t fces rcor, mpl es n s ubsdire , diti or ,a al pe s i a tve c e to pari i ton wih a Def nda ha ng no i srbut s nd 1 r ons n c i onc r r tcpa i t ny e nt vi tce oft s Or r s l i e ael hi de ha l mm dit y,untlf t Or r of t s Cour,dicontnue t us of t i urher de hi t s i he e he Tif ny M a ks or a c usngl sm ia ta fa r ny onf i y i lr r dema ks,o or i c r n n onne ton wih a1 l e ne ci t l nt r t websts owned a ope aed,or c r ld by t m i l ng t I e netwebst o r tng ie nd rt ontole he ncudi he nt r ies pe a i u d rteSu j c Do i Na s n e h be t man me ; () 3 Ea h Dee d n , is o fc r, die t r, e l y e , a n s s sdire , c fn a t t f es rco s mp o e s ge t, ub i ais diti or a a 1pe s i a tve c srbut s, nd 1 r ons n c i once torpa tci ton wih a De e ntha ng notc r ri pa i t ny f nda vi ie oft s Or s li e a el untlf t Or r of t s Cour,dic i t us of t hi der hal mm dit y, i urher de hi t s ontnue he e he Tif ny M ar ,ora c u i y smia tade kswihi dom an na e e ensons mett gs fa ks ny onf sngl i lr r mar tn i m xt i , a a o ohe mak r wihn we st s t c c d ,fo us o a we p g (n ldnga tttteo r t r r e s t i b ie ol e o e r m e n ny b a e icu i s h il f r a we pag ,a a rii lnkst ohe we ie ,fom s a c e ne 'datbas sorc che ny b e) ny dve tsng i o t r bsts r e r h ngi s a e a me or a a o he f m ofus ofs ht r swhih i vi i et a c m y, nd ny t r or e uc e m c s sbl o ompu e us rors r e t tr e evs o r td a h f nt diec c pu e s a che t we ies r git e by,owned,or ope a e by e c De enda , r t om t r e r s o bst e ser d i cu i t eI tn e we stso e ai u d rteS b e tDo i Na s n ldng h ne zt b i p r t n e h u j c man me ; e ng () 4 Ea hDe e d n s al tta fro rhp o teS b e tDo i Na sd ng c fn a t h lno rnse wnes i f h u j c man me mi t pe nc oft sAc i oruntlf t rOr roft Cour; he nde y hi ton, i urhe de he t 13 ( 5) Th d mann meRe itasf rt S b e tDo i Na ss ali daey t eo i a gsrr o he u j c man me h l mme itl ,o t e tn no ara y d n ,a ss i c a ig t e Re ita o r c r f rt e S be tDo i he x e t t le d o e s it n h ngn h g srr f e o d o h u j c man Na s,exc ptng a s domai na e whi h s h Re sr r ha be notfe i wrtng me e i ny uch n m s c uc gita s ve en iid n ii by Pl ntf ha be orwilbedim is fo t sa ton,t ahol ng a ountwih aRe sr ai if ve en l s s ed r m hi c i o di cc t gitar of Pli ifs c i (he i w Re srr'.To t e e t Re sr r do not a ss i antf hoosng t ç Ne gita' ) he xtnt he gitas sit n cha ngt Regita sofRe d f t domansundert i r peci c r wihi one( ) ngi he srr cor or he i her es tve ontol t n 1 b sn s d y o rc it o t i Or e, t tp-e e d man ( u i e s a f e ep f hs d r he o lv l o i TLD) Re itis ( r ter g sre o h i a mi srtr) frt e S be tDo i Na s wi i fv ( )b ie sd y o rc ito ti d nitao s o h u j c man me , t n ie 5 usn s a s f e ep f h s h Or e , h l, h n eo a ss i c a gng t eRe ita of e o df r h S b e tDo i Na s d r s al c a g r s it n h n i ,h gsrr r c r o t e u j c man me , e e i any s xc ptng uch domai na n mes whi h s h Re sre ha be n notfe i wrtng by c uc gitis ve e iid n ii Pl ntf ha be n or wilbe dim is fom t s a ton,t a hol ng a ountwih t Ne ai if ve e l s sed r hi c i o di cc t he w Reg sr r As a m at rofl t s Or r s lno l r a y t a De enda oras ocit ita . te aws hi de hal onge ppl o ny f nt s aed domai na e dimi s d fom t s a ton.Upo t c nge of t Re sr r of r c d f t n m s se r hi c i n he ha he gita e or or he S be t manNa s t eNe Re ita wil iti a c s t teS b e tDo i Na si u jc Do i me ,h w gsrr lman an c e s o h u j c man me n tus f t Cour durng t pe ncy oft s ac i Addii ly,t Ne Re sr r s l r t or he t i he nde hi ton. tona l he w gita ha l i e ae y i tt e a t mm di tl nsiut empor r 302 dom an na e r die ton whi h wil a o a ialy ay i m e rci c l ut m tc l rdr c a y viio t t e Su jc Do i Na st t f lwig Un f r Re o re Lo ao e ie t n str o h b e t man me o he ol n io m s u c c tr o (S ' htp:/evi noie. m/if i ht whee c es oft Compli a al < URL' t /sr ng tc co tfpp3/ndex. ml ron opi ) he ant nd 1 ot rdoc e son tl i t sa ton a e diplyed. t nai l t Ne Re sr rma updae he um nt se n hi ci r s a Aler tvey, he w gita y t teDo i Na Sy tm (i ' d t i manan f rte S be tDo i Na s whc l h man me se ç ' aa t iti s o h u j c man me , ih i DNS ) nk t dom ai na e t t I a r s es w he e t r as oci t d w e ie a e hos e t he n m s o he P dd e s r hei s a e bs t s r t d, o N SIM EDI . ATEM PLE. NET and N SZ. EDI M ATEM PLE. NET, whih w il c us t domai c l a e he n na a s t r s ve t t we ie whe e c pi o t Compli , t s Or r a a 1 ohe n e o e ol o he bst r o es f he a nt hi de , nd l t r 14 doc e s on fl i t sa ton a e dipl ye Afe t Ne Re sr rha e f ctd t sc nge, um nt ie n hi c i r s a d. tr he w gita s fe e hi ha t e S j c Do i Na s s l b plc d o Lo k saus p e e tn t mo iiain o h ube t man me hal e a e n c tt , r v n ig he d fc to r dee i oft domai by t New Regita orDefnda s lton he ns he sr r e nt ; () 6 Upo Pli tf sr q et t e p ia y p o e to s r ie fra y Su j c Do i n anif e u s, h rv c r tcin e vc o n be t man Na mesf whi t Re sr ntus ss h prva y pr eci s r i e t conc lt Re sr nts or ch he gita e uc i c ot ton e v c o ea he gita ' i iy a c ac i onna i a e or r t t e e not ar dy do , t dic os t dentt nd ont t nf ton r de ed, o he xtnt lea ne o s l e o Pl ntf t tuei nttesand c ac i o m a i oft eRe sr nt ; ai if he r de ii ont t nf r ton hos gita s Plitf ma e tr n c n iue t e tr t S b e t Do i Na s it an if y n e ,a d o tn o ne , he u j c man me no Googl s W e e' bmase Tool a c e any r dieci n oft dom ans t tha bee e er d tr s nd anc l e r to he i ha ve n nt e t r by De enda swhi h r r c ta fc t t c e f i ope ai t anew domai na eor he e f nt c edie t r fi o he ountr et r tons o n m we iea t r by e det pr so oft sOr r bst nd he e va he ovii ns hi de ; () 8 Ea h Dee nts l pr e v a c tn t prs r c e ofal c c fnda hal esr e, nd oniue o e eve, opis l omput er flsr ltn t teu eo a yo t eS b e tDo i Na sa d s al a ea1 tp ne e sr t ie eaig o h s f n f h u j c man me n h l tk 1se s c say o rtiv c mpu e flsr ltn t t e us o te S b e tDo i Na st a ma h v b e ere e o t r ie eaig o h e f h u j c man me h t y a e e n de eedbef et e r oft sOr r lt or he nty hi de ; ( 9) Upon rceptofnotc oft s Or r Pa l I e i ie hi de , ypa, nc.C( yPa1' and is rltd Pa ' ) t eae compa e a a fla e s l,t t e e no ale done,i e ael fe ze al f ,a ni s nd fii t s ha l o he xt nt t r ady mm di t y r e l unds s op ed t o ng a ount a tviy,i o whi h he ea tr a e tans itd i o t Pa pal pos o ngoi cc ci t n r c r fe r r m te nt he y a co t r a e t t Pa c un s elt d o he ypala ountr i e s cc ecpi nt : tfa c das e m a lc if n ana al i.om w u ou on 1 991 m a lc i. om i xhe hua 88 m alc ns n n i.om s1 r e l ive 925'wer a c hoo.n f voram e hot a lc a ' s m i. om a i ad i c dm n m n.om oks on m a c .n hoovom c 15 c i hot a lc n da m i.om l nf ' l ooki orewer mai.om lc * m9 80303 a com .n hoo. c ' ohns on0823 ho m a lcom t i. zhumei 966 x lc 1 mai.om ta ta i n i n9696 ma lc i.om 1lnd18 ii 9 mai. lcom e h m a lc a i. om da i ze n n m alc i.om l i 601 y a lc u n m i.om 4618 7431 6 . com e hunf n 1 s e 68 . com s 10224 hot a lc hi a m i.om l i i nkua ahoo. om a a i c ' e l des na ta i m a lc wer i usr la i.om t ews o' k m a lc i. om iove f s ons l m a hi ho i sor m ai.om n t e lc s rc 936 m ai.om t i ker lc o e n wi ni ndows ho m alc t i.om 1 920568956 . m co kaerna e t i heln m a lc i.om c' z ma lc i.om a wela alf n si o whih a eta s te it ()a y oh rr ltd a c u t o te sme s l s 1 u d n r c r r n mi d no i n t e eae c o n s f h a t c t rs,(i a ot r ac ot s whih ta fr f usomet) i) ny he c mt c r nse unds it t sme fnancali tt i no he a i i nsiuton a c u ts,a d o a o t e ohe Pa pa a c u t s be tt t i Or e ;a d (i a y oh r c o nt) n /r ny f h t r y l c o n s u jc o hs d r n i) n t e i Pa pa a c u t te t o us db a yo t eS be tDo i Na si e tfe o S h d e$ ' y l c o n s id o r e y n f h u j c man me d niid n c e ul $ A' he e o; rt (0) Upon r c pt of notc of t s Orer Pa l an is rl e c 1 e ei ie hi d , ypa d t eatd ompa es a ni nd a fla e s l, t t e e no ar dy done i e ael fe ze a l f , a o fiit s ha l o he xtnt t lea , mm di t y r e 1 unds s ppos d t e o ongoi ac ounta tviy,i or whi h he e fe a e ta mit d i o Pa ng c ci t n c r a tr r r ns te nt ypala ount lnked t cc s i os 16 a s cit d wih, ort ttans i fm ds i o D e e nt 'i iid ba a count,4i l ng but s o ae t s l nc udi ha r m t t nt f nda s dentfe nk c notlm ie t t i t d o he; Bank N am e A cc ountN am e Bank A c ountN um be c r HSBC Hon kon Br nch a I tila Co me c a Ba ndusra nd m r i l nk ofChi na M a wa I ti Li ie ndusral m t d ********5838 De Ja hun n ic *************** 3649 Ba ofChi Puta Br nch nk na i n a I ti la Comm e c a Ban ndusra nd ril k ofChi na M i n Ja nFe in ##**## #*# #### ##1 l - - 96 YuFe Luo i #***# *********3550 * Ba ofChi Puta Br h nk na in anc Li Gui i n n ***************3035 Ba ofChi nk na HuiDu ***************81 32 ChnaMe c a t Ba k( ng i rh n s n Ho Kon Br nc a h) Cha e Shi ofn ***#**#** *** 4801 Ba ofChi nk na Zho zuiShe n n *#* **** **** ***3 58 *- 0 Ba ofChi Puta Br nc nk na in a h Xi we Che a i n *** **** **** ****8767 Sub Br h - anc Ze Gon on n #***** *********8683 Ba ofChi nk na Li e W a m i n *******#***#**#1 4 31 Ba ko Chn , u u M ain n f ia F zho ja g and a ot r lt d a coun soft s m ec t e s ny her ea e c t he a usom r ; ( 1 Pa s laloi ditl t t e en no ara done,di r t ahol ng 1) ypal hal s mme aey, o he xt t t le dy ve t o di a co tf t tus oft Cour a1f c un or he r t he t 1 undsi a1 Pa la co sr lt t t Pay la ount n l ypa c unt ea ed o he pa cc r i et. ec pi n s' tfa ca as l m a lc if n nad ae i.om w u ou on 1 991 m a lc i .om i he ngs nghuan 88 m a lco i. m sl r e 1 ive 925'we r a c hoo.n fvoj me h t i.o a ra s omal m c ad i a n. m m n dmi co oks gong ya c . n m hoo.om c 1 The f l a ount numbe s have be r da t d t a d dicos e of prva e fna i l 4 ul cc r en e c e o voi s l ur i t i nc a i o mai i c inc wihFe R.Ci P.5. a( ; nfr ton,n ompla e t d. v. 2()4) howeve,t f la coun numbesae r he ul c t r r i ntfe o Pl i ifsN o i ofFii Re e e eLit fld unders l whih s l bedicl ed de ii d n antf tce lng f r nc s, ie ea , c ha l s os t Pa lt efe t t t r le or r d he e n. o ypa o f c ua e he ei f de e r i c i hot a lcom n da m i. l n f 'w er ooki or e ly m a lc i .om * m 9 80303 a c . n hoo.om c ' ohns on08 23 hot a lc m i .om z hum e 19 i 66 m a lc i. om ta i n9696 m ai. m i nta lco 11nd1 ii 89 m a lc i. om e ah m ai.om lc da i z n n e m a lc i. om l i 601 mai.om u n lc 4618 7431 6 .om c es en: 68 hunf 1 .om c s 10224 hot a lc hi a m i.om 1 i nkua ahoo. om ai a i c j wer d s na srla mal o e ly e i u tai i. m c t ews o' k ma lco i. m iovem f s ons l a hi ho i so e mai. m n tr lco sr c r ti ke 936 m a lc i. om o eni wi n ndows hot lcom mai. 1 20568956 9 .om c kaerna e t i heln m a lc i.om c' z ma lco i. m and a ot r l e a ount oft sme c t rs,andoralPa la ount lnke t ny her eatd cc s he a usomet) / l ypa cc s i d o, as oc aed wih,ort tta m i f ndsi o De e s it t ha r ns t u nt f ndant i ntfe ba acc st t s' de ii d nk ount o he: Bank N am e A c ountN am e c B ank A c countN um ber HSBC Hon kon Br h anc I ti a Co mer a Bal ndusral nd m ci l rk ofChi na M a waI ti lLi t ndusra mied ********58 38 De Ja n n ichu *************** 3649 Bal ofChi Puta Br nc r k na i n a h l ti la Co m e c a Bank ndusra nd m r i l ofChi na M i n Ja nFe i n ##*#** ### **#*- 1 - *# 961 Y uFeiLuo ***# ****+****35 ** 50 Ba ofChi Puta Br nc nk na i n a h Li G ui i n n ##*************3035 Ba ofChi nk na H uiD u ***# **##*****81 2 ## 3 Chi M ec nt Ba ( na rha s nk Hong Ko gBr n h n a c) Cha fn S i oe h * * * * ** * 8 # * * # * 4 01 18 Ba N a e nk m A c untN am e co Bank A cc ountN um ber Ba ofChi nk na Zho zuiShe n n **** **** **** *** 58 - 3- 0 Ba k ofChi Puta Br h n na i n anc Xi iChe awe n Ba ko Chn , zho M ain n f ia Fu u ja g . **** ***********8767 Sub- a Br nch Ze Gon on n ***### *********8683 Ba ofChi nk na Li e W a m i n ***************1 4 31 an a o he r l t ac ount of t s m e c t e s as we l a any o he a oun s whih d ny t r e aed c s he a usom r l s t r cc t c ta se fnd it t e smefna ca isiui n a c u ts a a y o te oh rPa pa a c u t r n f r u s n o h a i n il n t to c o n t) s n f h te y l c o ns t s be t ot i Or e ; u jc t hs d r ( 2) Pa s l f t r wihi tve da ofr ei ng t sOr r t t e entnot 1 ypal hal urhe, t n l ys ec vi hi de , o he xt ar dy done,pr de Pl ntf s c lea ovi ai if ouns lwih al da a whi de a l a a ountng oft t al e t l t ch t is n cc i he ot f n sfo e a ie tfe t ePa pa a c u ts wh c te fo e f d a er ltd to. S c u d r z n nd d n iis h y l c o n t) ih h r z n un s r eae o u h fe zi oft f r e ng he unds a t dicl u e oft r l t d fnanc a i tt i n a counti or ai nd he s os r he e a e i i l nsiuto c nf m ton s l bem a wihoutnotc t t a ountowne sort fna i i tt i untlf t ror ha l de t ie o he cc r he i ncal nsiutons i urhe der oft sCour. Pa hi t ypals lr c ve a m ant n t sOr ra isc e sasc hal e ei nd i ai hi de nd t ont nt onûde i lun i nta tl f t ror roft sCour; urhe de hi t ( 3 Pu s a tt 1 U. C.j 1 1 ( )5 ( ,Plitf s alman an is p e iu l 1) ru n o 5 S. 1 6 d ( )D) anif h l iti t r vo sy po tdbo i t ea u to Te Th u a dDolr a dZe oCe t ( 00 0.0 , sp y n of se nd n h mo n f n o s n l s n r n s $1 ,0 0 ) a a me t a d ma e t wh c De e a t ma bee tt d f rawr n f ij n to o r sr it d rn t e a g s o ih fnd n s y nil o e o gul n u cin r e tan , u i g h pe ndenc oft s a ton,oruntlf t rOr eroft Cour.I t Cour' dic ei n,t bond y hi c i i urhe d he t n he ts s r to he ma bes be tt ice s s o da a plc to b ma ei t ei tr s o j tc ; y u jc o n r a e h ul n p iai n e d n h nee t f usie (4 Thi Ore s al p l t teSu j c Do i Nn s t a s cae we sts a d 1) s d r h l a p y o h b e t man me ,he so itd b i , n e a o he do an na pr pery br ny t r m i mes o l oughtt t Cour' at nton a ve ii by s n afi vi o he ts te i nd rfed wor fda t whi h ve iis s h ne dom an nn c rfe uc w i mes a e beng us by De enda s f t pum os of r i ed f nt or he e 19 c e f ii t Tif ny M aks a is i t s a ton a orunf il c ount retng he f a r t sue n hi c i nd/ a ry ompei wih Pl n if tng t aitf on t W ord W i W e ori c meci wih s r h e ne r s t page ;a he l de b n or ton t ea c ngi e uls s nd ( 5 Th sPrlmiay Ij n to s l r man i efc d rn t pe d n y o ti 1) i ei n r n u ci n hal e i n fe t u ig he n e c f h s a i oruntls h f rhe dat ass tby t Cour orsi a e t by t pari . cton, i uc u t r e e he t tpul t d o he tes DONE AND ORDERED i c mb r i MimiFoia tiz o ay of n ha es n a , lrd ,hs3 - PAT I A .S TZ CI UNI TED STATES DI STRI J CT UDGE c c: A1 Couns lofRe or 1 e c d 20 , 2. 201 SCH EDULE dA' d ' DEFENDAN TS BY NUM BER ANp SUBJECT DO M AI NAM ES N De e f ndant Num ber De e f ndantNam e 1 g j wer ma c m zse ly x.o 2 3 3 4 4 9 ta c 98 r de.om a xuesne . t tfanybi c if z.om ba . om votc ecif ny.om tf a c 5 5 c dire ly o e ae .o a ej wer wh l slrc m mo ee lyc m d jwer .o 6 7 8 8 8 9 9 1 0 1 0 11 1 2 1 3 c nas upple s.om hi hoes ir c c nawhols l 688.om hi e ael c e col c c y.om ove c ri rco r a te . m tfa if nygood. com ûrt hea ae.om sc ps l c f le i mal. m ulr plca lco goodsa c . om whols l ta 3a. m e a er de co goods a c a a.om hei doudou. t ne i a hi nf s onzol c m z.o 1 4 1 5 j welr f r rsc m e l y o gil.o e jwer - s.o e ly ltc m 1 5 whols l if l tc e aetfany- s .om 1 6 1 6 j y sb rtsc m o a - a aa .o rpl a -o a .o e i sj y sc m c 1 7 l8 1 9 20 21 22 m a le i a. lr plc com nvrenguicom . s s hoe buyc nmc m hi o s s iyta .om hoe ct r dec s hop4ne kl cec c a .om s hop4tf a c if ny.om 21 22 22 tf any if andc ani co oe ng. m tfa ndc a eltc if nya obr c e .om 23 24 syl tel.om t eis fc tfanyc na s l .om if a da a ee 25 2 6 2 7 2 8 tfa y o e ly u.o if n c j wer a c m tfa y e lyo teuo g ifn j wer ult .r wh ls lj wer z zc m o e aee ly ol .o wh e aeifn j welr .o ols ltfa ye l yc m e 22 SCHEDULE GB' ' DEFENDANT PARTNERSH I OR UNI PS NCORPO M TED ASSO CI ONS ATI BY SUBJECT DOM AI NAM E AND ASSOCI N ATED E- AI ADDRESSES M L De e f ndant Num ber De e f ndantNam e 1 g se ly xc m z jwerma .o 2 9 ta ec m 98rd .o 3 3 a ue. t x sne tfa y zc m if n bi.o 4 b v tc m a o .o 4 e tfa y.o cifn c m 5 c dire ly olslrc m a ej wer wh e ae .o 5 mo ee ly.o d j wer c m 6 c n s eu p ir .o hia ho s p le sc m 7 c na oe ae 6 8.o hi wh ls ll 8 c m 8 ec l.o c oyc m 8 o ec rirc m v r a t .o e 8 tfa g o c m ifny o d.o 9 irthe ps l.o sc a aec m 9 f l e ia l.o ul pl mal m r c c 1 0 g o ac m o ds .o E- ai Addr s e M l ess wy s @yho c m.n mjy a o.o c sac a @h t i.o erhaa omalc m p 1 3 l 6c m t2 @ 2 .o z a g i o a o.o c h n qng k@yho c m.n h nil a o c m.n o ci h o.o c n@y a u s x e.e x e @a u sn t i f @e 6.n no 3 c sl s a o .o ae @b v tc m j e 6 @ 1 3c m o 5 7 6 .o s ls cifn c m ae @e tfa y.o j e 6 @ 1 3.o o5 7 6 cm b v t h t i.o a o@ omal m c Ca el wer Wh ls l@g i.o dire ly o e ae malc m mo ee ly l 6.o d j wer @ z c m mo ee ly malc m d j wer @g i.o s efn a o c m.n ho sc @y h o.o c s e fn omal o ho sc @h t i. m c aln rd hrc m l @ta e .o e b in n we @h t i.o ra a s r o mal m c c ia tr u lt t i.o hn sao te@homal m c to it g i.o c gf@ malc m odewat omal o r r n@h t i. m c Ov rat r mal o ec ri @g i. m e c t o k @h t i.o c s y o mal m c to k @h t i.o c s y o malc m tfa yg o 8 @g i.o ifn o dl 37 mal m c s r ie frth a aec m e vc @ isc e psl .o z a x f t @ l 3.om h ngshgh 6 c i h n j g k h @ l 3.o ua gd g g r 6 c m S r ie ule ia l.o e vc @f l plc malc m r Go ds @ h t i.o o a omalc m Go d a a o c o s @y h o.n my ic u ta @h t i.o dso nb g omalc m 23 D e e nt f nda Num be De e r f ndantNam e 1 0 wh lslta e ac m oe aer d 3 .o 1 1 g od a ac m o s a .o 1 2 h i u o .e edo d un t 1 3 ifs in ol cm naho z z.o 1 4 j welr f r il.o e ley o grsc m 1 5 jwer - s.o e ly ltc m 1 5 wh lsltfa y ltc m oeaeifn - s.o 1 6 j ya - aaa .o o sb rtsc m 1 6 rpia -oy sc m e lc sj a .o E- ai Addre s s M l se d man iwo l c m o i@dy rd.o g o a al y ho c m.n o dsa @ a o.o c g o s a @h t i.o o d a al omal m c g od a al h t i.o c o s a @ omal m.n c 25 2 49 q .0 43 9 @ qc m sl s ed ud une ae @h i o o . t hi u o edo d u@homalc m t i.o h io d ue ly@homalc m ed u o jwer t i.o h io d .e@d mans y r xyc m ed u oun t o i b p o .o b spie rn @g i.o etrcb a d mal m c o ln c a f s in@g i.o ni e he p a ho mal m c 7 23 8 9 qc m 27 6 9 @q .0 co to g i.o r wn c @ mal m c x ol @ h t i.o xql 7 omalc m b sso e l malc m e ttrs @g i.o jwer - s@h t i.o e ly lt omalc m b sso e l g i.o e ttr s @ mal m c jwer-s@h t i.om e ly lt omal c z y 0 @ 1 3.om g wb 08 6 c j yab rts o g i.o o s a aa c m@ mal m c rplc so a @ g i.o e iaj y s mal m c sr c @rpl a -o a .o evio e i sj y sc m c z y 0 8 1 3c m g wb 0 @ 6 .o srie lrpiac m evc @male lc .o svc @d sj esec m e ie ein re .o srie eln re .o evc @d sg esec m 1 7 male lc .o l piac m r 1 8 n r n u .o veg i m c 1 9 s o s u c i .o h e b y hnac m 2 0 21 s o s i rd .o h e ct a ec m yt s o 4 e k a ec m h p n c lc .o d sg e s t i.om e in ro@homal c loh n l 3.o e -a @ 6 c m s yu kl@g i.o k lc y malc m a i a u p ir malc m d d s p le@g i.o s o s u c n @ ya o c m .n h e b y hia h o.o c s o s uy hia t i.o h e b c n @homalc m u brco hn el o a lc m r lt igsl@h tmi.o u b n lt n u a O o .o c r a cohig s @y oc m.n 2 7 2 0 0 q cm 8 0 4 7 @ q.0 s e ct ta @g i.o ho s iyrde malc m 1 3 5 v p1 1 2 q.o 2 4 6 1 1 2 @q c m s o s iyt d @h t i.o h e ct r e omal m a c s o s i r d @ya o c h e ct a e h o.n yt c n c lc @ ma - r lta i .o c e ka e x moa - dngc m r 24 Def endant Num ber Def ndantNam e e 2 2 2 2 2 2 23 24 25 26 2 7 28 E- ai Addr s e M l ess r 3 8 8 01 @ 1 6.0 z1 3 3 3 61 2 c m isy e@h t i.o n tlr omalc m so 4ifn c m h p tfa y.o whoeaeg s omal o lslrz @h t i. m c b sg s - t i.o e t z @lo mal m l c isye@homal o ntlr t i. m c tfa y n c e ri g.o ifn a d o arn c m S lo o k fs o mal o el n c o f@h t i. m l c whoeaeg @h t i.o lslrzs omal m c tfa a d o r c lt o ifny n c b a ee. m c tfa y o ko f@homalc m ifn u c fs t i.o syetef malc m tlisl@g i.o syli ef t i.o t et l@homal m s c syetefc m tlisl.o syetef o mal o tli l@fx i. m s c tfa c n da aec m ifny a a s l.o tfa y a a a ae mal op ifn c n d s l@g i. l c j wer de in u tai@h t i.o e ly sg a sr l o malc m a j wer d sg a srla mal o e ly e in u tai@g i. m c 2 7 9 75 @q c 1 4 3 8 4 q.01 4 tfa y oe ly u.o ifn c jwera c m tfa y oe ry u omal o ifn cjwela @h t i. m c tfa y e ly u lt s omal o ifn j wer o teu @h t i. m c tfrye ly ults @h t i.o if j wer o teu a omalc m tfa y e ly ult .r ifn j wer o teuo g 31 6 2 @q c m 41 71 7 q.o b c p c u @ l 3c m a k a k s 6 .o ge tcc m@h t i.o rau .o omalc m wh ls lj wer z z.o oe aee ly ol c m j n y la yl 8 @g i.o e n ce r g 7 malc m whoe ae h a j wer us h t i.o lslc e pe ly. @ o mal m c d8 0 a 3 85 0 a 3 d 0 a 6 d ap o e t d1 c a 3 4 e 9 5 7 9 31 f 3 .r tc@ whoe aeif y e le c m wh ig ad.o ls ltfr j wela.o osu r c m 25
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
