UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. Secretary Department of Corrections et al, No. 1:2012cv22958 - Document 77 (S.D. Fla. 2013)
Court Description: ORDER denying 59 Motion to Intervene. Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 9/6/2013. (cqs)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. Secretary Department of Corrections et al Doc. 77 UN ITED STA TE S D ISTR ICT C O U R T SO U TH ERN D I STR I T O F FLO R I C DA CA SE N O .1 22958- V - TZ/ M ON TO N 2Cl SEI S1 UN I TED STATES O F A M ERI , CA Pl ntf, ai if VS . SECRETA RY,FLOR I A DEPA RTM EN T O F D CO RRECTI N S, al, O et . Dee f ndan s t. / O R D ER DEN YI G M O TI N T O I TER V EN E N O N THI M ATTER i b f r t eCo r o t eM oint ltr e ( 5 1 fldb S s eo e h u t n h t o ne v ne DE- 9 ,ie y o Re nal Ros a ot rM usi prs ner cu r ntyi a ce a e i t Fl i Depa t e o gi d e nd he lm i o s r e l nc r r t d n he orda rm nt f Co rcin .Th UntdSttsh sfldars n e( 6 J Dee d nsh vefldo o iin re to s e ie ae a ie epo s DE-6 , fn a t a ie pp sto g 65, n M o a t fldarpy ( 6 1 Th Untd Sae b o g t h sa to algn ta DE- j a d v n s ie e l DE- 9 . e ie tts r u h t i ci n le ig h t De e nt a ei vi a i oft Re i ousLa Us a l tt to lz d Pe s Actof2000 f nda s r n olton he lgi nd e nd nsiu i nai e r ons ( , PAI bec us t ydono s l kos rme l t t eprs r whos rlgi beif RIUI I a e he t e' ve he as o hos iones e ei ous les rquiekos rme s TheMusi prs r'( e r he al. lm iones Mova s prpos dc anti aputtvecl s nt) o e ompli s ai as a ton s e ng ha alor i t ale i kos rm e s f M usi pr s sw ho obs r e hal c i e ki l , n he t nmtve, he al or lm i oner ev al dit r lws Be aus t m o i n i u i ey a t Gove me wila quae yr pr s ntt e a y a . c e he to s ntm l nd he m nt l de tl e e e he i ee t ofa ntrss nyonewhos ksakos rmea a ar ul ofar i ousbelet i i de ed. ee he l s es t elgi i l t s ni l sa tonwa fldpurua t 42U. C.j2000c 2( whi gi t De rme ' ci rhi s ie s nto S. c- 9, ch ves he pa t nt o J siet ea t o iyt e f rec mp in ewih j2 0 c - b ete a a to frij n t e f u tc h u h rt o n o c o la c t 0 0 c 1 y i r n ci n o nu ci h v r le orde a a or r le on be foft Unie Stt swho ha an oblgaor i e es i e if clr t y ei f hal he t d a e s i t y nt r t n pr ec i t r lgi lbe t ofa lprs r . ot tng he e i ous i ry l i one s Dockets.Justia.com TH E M O TIO N TO INT ERV EN E M ova t s e t i ewe pur ua t Fede a Rul ofCi lPr dur 24.Rul 24 sa e n s e k o ntl ne s nt o rl e vi oce e e tt s i pe tne pa t n ri nt r : ()l e ve i ofRi . tmel moi t c tmus pemi a a ntr nton ghtOn i y ton,he our t r t nyonet i ev o ntrene who: ( )camsa itrs r ltn t teprp ryo ta a to t a i tes b e to 2 li n n ee t eaig o h o e t r rns ci n h t s h u j c f t a ton,a i s st t t tdiposng oft a i n ma asapr tc ma tr he c i nd s o iuaed ha s i he cto y aci al te i paro i m i r mpedet mova ' a lt t pr e isi e e t unls e si pa te he nts biiy o otct t nt r s , e s xitng ri s ade t l r pr e t ti e e t qua e y e es nt ha nt r s . ( PemisveI e v nton. b) r si ntr e i ( )I Ge r .Ontmeymoton,t c t per ta 1 n neal i l i he our may mi nyonet i e v newho: o ntr e # + + ( hasacai ordee et ts r swiht mai a tonac B) lm fns ha ha e t he n ci ommon ques i ofl or f t ton aw ac . M ova ss ekt i e v neund Rul 24()2 or i t atr tve, rRul 24( ( )B) nt e o ntr e er e a() ,n he lenai unde e b)1( . A . Int erventon ofR i i ght De e nt a guet tM ova ss d notbepe m it t it r f nda s r ha nt houl r ted o n e venebec us t ydo no a e he t m e tt r quie nt ne es a y f i er nton a ofrght l or rt i e ve a ofrg e he e r me s c s r or nt ve i s i . n de o nt r ne s iht M ova smus s w:( )t i a iai t i evenei tmey;( t yha a i ees r ai nt t ho 1 her pplc ton o ntr s i l 2) he ve n ntr t eltng t tep o e t o ta s cinwhc i t s be t ftea to ( )t yaes st ae ta o h r p ry r rn a to ih s he u j c o h cin;3 he r o iu td h t dipos ton oft a ton,asa pr ctca m a t r m ay i pede o i pai t i a lt t pr e tt t s ii he c i a i l te , m r m r he r biiy o ot c ha i ees;a ( M ova s i ees i r prs nt i de t yb t e si pari t t s t ntr t nd 4) nt' ntr t s e e e ed na quael y he xitng tes o he ui. Chie v Thor gh,865F. 11 1 3( 1h Ci.1 9) fnda saguet tM ova s ls . nbur 2d 97, 21 1 t r 98 .Dee nt r ha nt' moin i no t l,h M o a t'ne e t d n t eaet t s b e to ti a to , e ilo t s t i y te v ns itrss o o r lt o he u j c f h s cin d n a f o me i tr e to wil o p eu ieteM o a s a dPli t tt eGo e n, l a e u tl nev n in l n t rj dc h v nt, n ani l h v mme twil d q aey f r pr e whatve i e e tt M ova t ha Ass outbel M ova sc e es nt e r ntr s he n s ve. et ow, nt nnnotm e ta1oft e 1 he r qui e e s f i t r nt o e r m nt or n e ve i n. TheGove nme Wil quatl Re e e M o s r nt l Ade ey pr s nt vant M ova ss k ahallo kos rm e lf ra1M usi prs r who desr one.The nt ee a r he a o 1 lm ione s ie Gove n e ' c r m nts ompl n s e r i f al prs swhos r lgi be if r quieakos r ait e ks elef or l ioner e e i ous le s e r he m e l Ther i s a. elef oughtby t Go nme i notlmiedt r le f J wih prs r onl he ver nt s i t o ei f or e s ione s y. W hiet compl ntcl ryr i son t e re sofJ wih prs ne st de onsr t t l he ai ea l ele he xpe ince e s i o r o m ta e he De e n s'c i d de a ofkos rm e l,i c e ry s e r leff a1prs r whos f nda t ontnue nil he a s t l a l e ks e i or l ione s e r i ousbe if r quieakos rm e l TheGove nm e hasr ie a e t si isRe pons t t elgi le s e r he a . r nt et r t d hi n t s e o he M otont I evene( 66a 3J wher nt Go r ntsae tt t e e t tMusi i o ntr DE- t , ei he venme tts do he xtnt ha lm pr s r - orpr s r ofa ot r f ih - have a s nce e r lgi usbas s f c u i a kos r i one s i one s ny he a t i r ei o i or ons m ng he dit t rcli f rs h aditi r pr e e by t Unie Stt si t sltga i ' M o eove , e, hei am o uc e s e es nt d he t d a e n hi ii ton. ' r r t alg to si teGo e n n ' c mplit( Ia ! 2& 1 , ry rf rr l t u d rc rs he le ain n h v r me ts o an DE- t ! 4 p a e o ei l n es o e e t tt Gove ha he nune i s eki t haveDe e nt pr vi kos rm e l t prs r ofa 1f ihs nt s e ng o f nda s o de he a s o ione s l at who ha a r i o bas sf cons i kos rf ve elgi us i or um ng he ood. Thus whie t G ove n e doe no , l he r m nt s t s k e cty t s mer i a M ovant,t Gove n e s e br err left n M ova sa ee xa l he a elef s s he r m nt e ks oad e i ha nt nd t tb oa r le enc ha r d e if ompas est r i fs s he ele oughtb M ova s Ac di y,t M o nt 'i e ess y nt . cor ngl he va s nt r t a ea qua eyr pr s nt d byt Gove n nt r de t l e e e e he r me . TheM oto t I e v IW. Untmel i n o ntr ene ' & i y I M ovan s a s tt tt rm oton i tm el A cou tc i r f f t s i det r i ng t s er ha hei i s i y. r ons de s our ac or n e m ni tmei s :( )t l hoftmedzi whiht wo d- itr e rkne orr as bl i lne s 1 he engt i trng c he ul be ne v no w e ona y s dhaveknown ofhi i ee ti t caebeor hepeii frl vet i er e ( t houl s ntrs n he s f e ttoned o ea o nt v ne;2) he e tn o p eu iet tee itn p risa ar s l o t ewo l beitr e o ' fiu et a py xe t f rj dc o h x sig a t s e ut f h ud- n e v n rs alr o p l e a s o a h k w o r a o a l s o l h v k o o hi itr s; 3 t e tn o prj d c t s o n s e ne r e s n by h ud a e n wn f s nee t ( ) he x e t f eu ie o t woul beitr nori hi peii i de e a ( t exitnceofunus lcr umsa e he d- neve f s tton s nid; nd 4) he se ua ic tnc s m iiatng eihe f rora i ta deer i ton t tt a ia i i tm ey. Unie St e v lt i t r o gans t m na i ha he pplc ton s i l t d ats . Jfes nCo ny, 2 F.d 1 1 1 1 ( 1hCi.1 8 ) e efco sweg a ans fn ig efr o u t 7 0 2 51 , 3 6 1 t r 9 3 .Th s a tr ih g i t i dn t tt M ova s m o i w astm e y. ha he nt ' ton i l Thi a ton wa fl d on Aug t1 201 On Augus 1 201 a onlne ne st s ci s ie us 4, 2. t 6, 2, n i ws ie posed a a tce a t n ril boutt s t e Ex.2 t De e he ui.Se o f ndan s'Re pons Furhe , Goog es a c t s e. t r a l e rh i c est tt e w a s gnii ntpr s c r ge oft s ti t da f l i t flng of ndi at ha her s i fca es ove a he ui n he ys olow ng he ii t c he ompli . On J r 1 201 M ovant e l d c a nt anua y 5, 3, s maie ouns li t sm at rabouti e ve i e n hi te nt r nton. M ova s cou e sa e i t i r pl t the la ne oft c s i l t 201 Howe r t nt ' ns l t t s n her e y ha e r d he a e n a e 2. ve , he m oton wasnottl d un i M a 30, i i e tl y 2013, or t ni m ont a t rt c pl i w a fl m e han ne hs f e he om a nt s ied. M ova sas e t ha t y co d notha ûl muc e ri rbe us t y fr tha t e us t i nt s r t t he ul ve ed h a le ca e he is d o xha t her a nita i r m e es Howe r ac or ng t t rr pl M ova sdi note n be nt dmi sr tve e di . ve , c di o hei e y, nt d ve gi he ad i sr i c a m spr s ,a pr s t tt y s a e r quiesm or t n t o m ont t m ni tatve l i oce s oce s ha he t t e r e ha w hs o co pl e untls tm ea trM a c 1 201 ne l s n mont afe t sc eha be m et, i ome i fe r h 3, 3, ary eve hs tr hi as d en fld. M ova sdo no e an t i dely i sa tng t a nita i cai spr s o i ie nt t xpli her a n tri he dmi sr tve l m oce s r n l a ni oft s tz e r ng he ui. z ova t as poi t t St y e e e by t Cour on J nua y 23, 3, ch sa d M n s lo nt o he a nt r d he t a r 201 whi t ye t s m a t rf om J nua y 23,201 untlA pr l1 201 asr as f t tm i oft i m oton. hi te r a r 3 i i 9, 3, e on or he i ng he r i H oweve ,t e s e e oft St y doesnotexpl i why M ova sw a t d untlM ar h t begi r he xi t nc he a an nt ie i c o n t greva epr s orwhy M ovant di nots e t i e v ne i t tvem ont prort t he i nc oce s s d e k o nt r e n he s hs i o he St y. a 4 Mo a t a s r ta n p eu iewil eutfo itr e to De e d n s h we e , v ns se th t o rj dc lr s l r m nev nin. fn a t, o v r ag eta itr e to wil e uti p eudc b c us i wi c mpl aeter s lto o t e r u h t n ev n in l rs l n rj ie e a e t l o i t h e ouin f h l c pe dn p ei n r ij n to mo in Th p ei n r ij ci nmo inh sb e f l b ifd n ig r l ay n u ci n to . e r l ay nun to to a e n u l ree mi mi y and t Cou the dan e de i yhea i on J 4 a 5, 3. Att tm eoft he rng, he r l vi ntar rng une nd 201 he i he a i M o a t'moi nwa n ty t ie ha i b e fldj s d ysb f r t eh aig.M o a t' v ns to s o e rp , vng e n e u t a eo e h e rn v ns pr pos d compl i r s ss r lt oresofr c r notaddr s ed by t Gover nts o e ant aie eve a he i e ove y es he nme ' c mplita dn t d rse a t ep ei nayij n to h aig.Th , lo ngitr e to o an n o a d e s d t h rlmi r nu cin e rn us alwi n ev n in woul f t rde a ar s uton oft sm at n3 M ov nt'i e e t ,howe r wilnotbe d urhe l y e ol i hi te a s ntr ss ve , l p eu ie b c u et ya efe t fl as p r t s ia db c u e a s to ta o ,h i rj d c d e a s he r r e o ie e aae ut n e a s , s e u b ve t er i e e t a ea nt r s s r dequa e y r pr s nt d by t G ove m e . tl e e e e he nz nt Fi ly,M ova sha notpr s nt d an e de ofunus lcic s a s W hie na l nt ve e e e y vi nce ua r um t nce . l M ovan s s t ugges t tt i pr ors tc ea esunus lc r m s a sw ei ng i f vorof t ha he r i ui r t ua icu t nce ghi n a i e ve i t y ha note aned why t prors tc e t su ualcic sa esf orng ntr nton, he ve xpli he i ui r a e nus r um t nc av i i e ve i W ei ng al oft f c o s t Cour fndst tM ova s m oton i untm el nt r nton. ghi l he a t r , he ti ha nt ' i s i y. B. Perm i ve I erventon ssi nt i I t a tr i e,M ovant s e pe mi svei e ve i Howe r c oft n he le natv s e k r s i nt r nton. ve , me he c i r tonsf pe m isvei e ve i i whehert a i ton i tm el St l t v onsde a i or r s i nt r nton s t he pplcai s i y. alworh . M on ant Co.558F. 257, (t Ci.1 7)4 Ass touta s o , 2d 263 5h r 97 . e bove, ova s motoni not M nt' i s 3 ova s pr pos cai i udear que tf c a sce tfc ton unde Fe r Rul of M nt ' o ed l ms ncl e s or l s rii a i r de al e Ci lPr e e 23. Rul 23 cl sc rii ton wilr i eis st twilf t rdely t vi oc dur e as e tfcai l a s s ue ha l urhe a he de e m i ton oft s c e. t r na i hi as 4n Bonnerv. Ci o ih r , 61F.d 1 6 1 9( 1hCi.1 81 (nb n ) t e I t fprc a d 6 2 20 , 20 1 t r 9 ) e a c ,h y El ve h Cic ta ed a bi ngpr e ntt de ii nsoft f m e Fit Cic tha d e nt r ui dopt s ndi ec de he c so he or r fh r ui nde down pr ort O c ober 1 1 . i o t , 981 tmey.Eve i i wer,t Cour hasdicetonunde Rul 24( t den i evento i l n f t e he t sr i r e b) o y ntr in. Cons nty,hemotont i eve purua t Rul 24( i de e Fort r a ons eque l t i o ntr ne s nt o e b) s nid. he e s di c s a s us ed bove, he Cour w ile r i e is di c e i a d t m o i n t i e ve t t l xe c s t s r ton nd eny he t o o nt r ne. Acc di y,i i or ngl t s ORDERED t t h M oi nt ltr e ( 5 qi DE ED. ha t e to o n ev ne DE- 9 s NI DO N E a O RDERED i M i i Fl i ,t s nd n am , or da hi e- L d yo s pe e 2013, a f etmbr , . PATR I A A .SEI CI TZ UN I TED STA TES D I STRI J D GE CT U CC* A1 Couns lofRec d 1 e or
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
