Malibu Media, LLC v. Pelizzo, No. 1:2012cv22768 - Document 16 (S.D. Fla. 2012)
Court Description: ORDER denying 7 Motion to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim. Responses due by 12/31/2012. Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 12/20/2012. (lbc)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Malibu Media, LLC v. Pelizzo Doc. 16 UNI TED STATES DI STRI CO URT CT SOUTHERN DI STRI OF FLORI CT DA CASE NO.1 22768- V- TZ/ M ONTON 2CI SEI S1 M ALI M EDI , BU A LLC, Pl ntf, ai if V S. LEO PELI ZZO, De enda . f nt / ORDER DENYI PLAI FF' M OTI TO DI I NG NTI S ON SM SS THI M ATTER c e be or t Co ton Def nda ' M oton t Dim ist S om s f e he ur e nts i o s s he i e i a Co an frFalr t S aeaCli g 7 .Thi i an acton underf deralcopyrghtlw mplit o iu e o tt am DE-) s s wh r i p anifM alb M e i L (plitf ' alg st a d fn a Le Peiz e en litf iiu d a LC s anif) le e h t ee d nt o lz o i (r ee nf' i o ryc edPli ifsc i t movi a diti e t m vi t d fnda ) mpr pel opi antf opyrghed es nd sxbutd he a he i t r twiho Pli ifspe mi son.De e n diput st alegai nsa movest dim is n e ne t ut antf r si f nda t s e he l to nd o s s Pl itf ssngl c an if i e- ountCom pl n on t g o ait he r undst ti i i qua ey pl d.Pl ntf ha ha t s nade t l e ai if s r s o d dt t eM oin ( 1 )a dDe e d n h sr pid( 1 ) Ha i c r f l e p n e o h t DE- 3 n fn a t a e le DE- 4 . vng aeul o y r viwedt a l a i i t Compli a t a i a ea horte t Cou wilde t e e he leg tons n he ant nd he pplc bl ut iis,he rt l ny he M o i be us t Com pl nta qua e y s a es a c a m f rcop i ti r nge e . ton ca e he ai de t l t t li o yr gh nf i m nt 1. Fact A legatonsl ual l i A. Ba ckgr und o Plitf,MalbuM e a,LLC,i t o roft c iht s di ,e chofwhih anif i di s he wne he opyrg s ubju ce a c 1 nl s ot nv s no e , t f c ua bac ound i de i d fom Pl ntf sCo pl nt U es he i e t d he a t l kgr s rve r ai if m ai ( I a dtee hb t a c mp n igi, steCo r mus a c p al a ta alg to sa tu DE- j n h x iis c o a yn t a h u t t c e t 1 fcu l le ain s r e a consr t m i t lg mos f vor bl t t Pli if SeeAme c De al s ' v nd tue he n he i ht t a a e o he a ntf. rian nt As n . Ci Cor ,605F. 1 ( t Ci. 0) gna p. 3d 283 11h r 201 . 1 Dockets.Justia.com co r a orgi l ose i y por a c wo k ofa horhi c plt wih aCopyrght ve s n i na , t nsbl nogr phi , r ut s p om e e t i Re itainNu e .( eCo l ! 9 2 . De e d n i p more l aFlrd r sd n wh , g srto mb r Se mp . 51 , 8) fn a t s u tdy o ia e i e t o a c di t l t r tSe vie Pr de Hot r Com muni tons w asas i d l e ne Pr oc c or ng o n e ne r c ovi r wie cai , s gne nt r t ot ol a d e s(t a d e s'2 .3 2 2 7. ( mpl! - , A. Bewe nJ n ay 3 2 2a d r s $P d r s' 42 8.2.0 2 Co . !89 Ex. ) t e a u l , 01 nd I ) M a 29,201 De e ntco e a diti e , vi t BiTore pr ocol t c tt nt y 2, f nda pid nd srbut d a he t r nt ot , he onsiue ee e sofe c oft fl si ntfe i Exhi t A a B t t Compl i wihout lm nt a h he im de i d n bis nd o he ant t p r sin.( mp . 52 - 0 Ex. ) emiso Co l! 9 3 , B. On J y 27, 2,Pl i ifbr htt sa ton al gi asngl co ofc i ht ul 201 antf oug hi ci le ng i e unt opyrg i rng nt Def ntm ovest dim ist Compl i , a gui t tPl i ifha f ie t nfi eme . enda o s s he ant r ng ha antf s a ld o a qua ey sa eacl m f i rng m e prnci ly bec us t Compl i s t f t a de t l t t ai or nf i e nt i pal a e he ant e s orh n i ufk intba i f i tf ng Pli ifa t i rng r s i e f rusng t d ce ns t e s s or den iyi a ntf s he nf i er e ponsbl o i he evi a sg d I a es 24. 22. durng t r lvantpe i s i ne P ddr s 238. 207 i he ee rod. B. BiTore Pr oc t r nt ot ol Bi-bre i a mode n Epe rt pee 'fl s rng t us d f diti i daa vi t tf r nt s r s e -o- r' ie ha i ool e or srbutng t a he i enet Unlke ta to lfl tanse pr t ol t ti vea c ntals r era t ta f rof nt r . i r dii na ie r fr o oc s ha nvol e r e v nd he r ns e who etl sbewe n us r ,t BiTore tpr ocolpr desa de e r lz me hod of l q e t e e s he t r n ot ovi c ntai ed t diti i daa.BiTo r ntbr ksa i vi lfl i o s a lpi c t ti vi ua us r t n srbutng t t r e ea n ndi dua ie nt m l e es ha ndi d l e s he diti e a srbut mong t m s l s Thi f c lt t f trfl ta f r t n tadto ltl s rng he eve . s a iiaes ase e r nse s ha r ii na 5e ha i s fwaet trq ie usr t ta se whoeslsfo ac nr l e v r ( eCo l! 0 1 ) o t r ha e ur s es o rn fr l e r m e ta s r e . Se mp .51 - 3. The BiTor e pr ocolope a e a f l s The pr s be i w ih one us r t t r nt ot r t s s olow . oce s g ns t e , he 2An I add es i auni numbera om ai a l a sgned t de c conne t d t t P r ss que ut tc ly s i o vies c e o he itr e, . , c mp tr b a Itr e Sevc Pr v d r(ç P' .( c . fTo isF e e ! ) ne n teg.a o u e, y n n en t r ie o ie (S ' De lo ba is r 7 l ) ( ComplEx. . . C) 2 ' ee ' ' d'whom a st fl a l evi aBi-ore ci nt fi rt M edi H ol ngs v s ke he ie vaiabl a tf r nt le . be y a di . Bit rent tor Swar e al,277 F.R. 6 2 6 4 ( D.I . 011 .Thes e te ce tsaço rn 'fl ta m t . D. 7 , 7 S. F a 2 ) e d h n r ae d re t'ie h t t c nti a r ad ma t t I a es e ofo he us r who ar s rng t fl . I Eac pi eof o ans o p o he P ddr s s t r e s e ha i he ie d. h ec t t r ntfl i as i he ore ie s sgned auni cypt r phi has val . que r og a c h ue ( mpl1 4 1 . Tha v l e Co . 51 , 8) t au a t asa( quedi t lfnge rnt'ha e ur sapi c ofdaabel cs t uni gia i m i 't t ns e ee t ongsi a pa tc art r nt n ri ul ore fl.( mp . 5) ie Co l!1 . Ot rus r , û r ,'he do oa t t r nttl , whi h a l t m t downl d he e s or s s't n wnl d he ore le pee c lows he o oa fom ot rpe r who pos e spic oft fl . I Al oft s pe r ar pa toft s m e r he e s s s e es he ie d. l he e e s e r he a t wa m 'be a et y a e do o ng pi e oft s m efl . fi ery M e a Hol ngsv i r ' c us he r wnl adi ec s he a ie b t di s di . Swar Sharng Has Fie,8 F. S p 2 4 4, 48( M a s 201 ) (e as Co . 1) m i h l 21 u p. d 4 4 D. s . 1. S e lo mpl!1 . Afe downl di apic oft fl , each useraut atcaly becom esa s ce f t spi ce. tr oa ng e e he ie om i l our or hi e Theva iusme be soft s r c i t e ha pic wih o a he . 1 Fi l ro m r he wa m ontnue o xc nge e es t ne not r d. naly, t nc ape ha a c ult d e t e er s c um a e nough i vi pi e oft fl, t soft ar alow st peert o ndi dual ec s he ie he w e l he o r a s mbl t agg egaefl 'fi ry M edi H ol ngs 277 F. D .at674. e s e e he r t ie.' be t a di , R. Pli tf' I v siaint I e tW f Ale e lfi c r anifs n etg to o d ni he lc d n rn e Pli tf ale st tDef nt wiho Pli ifsa ho iaton, i entonal co e a a n if lge ha enda , t ut antf ut rz i nt i ly pid nd di ti e i a pi c e f hi , t wor lse i Exhi t A andB.( s rbut d, n e em al as on he ks itd n bis Compl! ) . 29. Defnda tpur t y di s vi t BiTore pr oc o va i daesbewe n J nua y 23, e n poredl d o a he t r nt ot ol n rous t t e a r 201 andM a 5,201 a t 2 y 2, lhough t al ge i rng nti notnec s a iylm iedt t ttme he le d nfi eme s e s rl i t o ha i pe i r od. To dee m i who aleg y i rng isc i s Pl ntf r t i d i si orTo a tr ne l edl nfi ed t opyrght, ai if e ane nve tgat bis Fisrv ahse o e, P Li td($ P'.Ac o dn t ad ca ai ns b te b M r e e i i mply r 1 P mie çP ' c r ig o e lrto u mitd y I ) . Fis r De e e e , f ndan ' I a e swasd s r d usng SNTERNATI ts P ddr s icove e i C I ONAL I PTRACKER v1 2. . 1 a r lt d t hnol y't te bls(he s nnni ofpe -t pe rne wor f rt pr e of nd ea e ec og 'ha na e t c ng t er o- e t ks o he es nce i rngi ta aci .' ( e e De l!1 ) Th tb e c nan di Ex i t A a dB s tfrh nfi ng r ns tons ' Fisr c. 4. e a ls o tie n hbis n 3 e ot t eS t ae '(n tme )wh nade ieu i I a d e s2 238. 207 connect d wih t h t d ts' a d i s e hi vc sng P d r s 4 22. e t he . i ve tga orss r e s nd ta m it af lc , o po to t ee t o adgtl da g ie n si t ' e v r t r ns ted ul opy r rin h rol f iia me i t l a l ie tfe b teUniu Ha hNl est a c reaet gh c p rg td wo k a is e '' d n iid y h q e s z r h t o rlt o te o y ihe r s t su l 4 mb . ( is rDe l:1 ; mp . 6) Ba e o te eh s v le a dasd - y sd v e n o t e F ee c. 9 Co l!1 . s d n h s a h au s n ieb -ie iwig f h downl dedwor a orgi wor , t i si t rconcud t te h pi eofda a oa ks nd i nal ks he nve tga o l ed ha ac ec t r c i d fom I a e s24. 22. wa pa tofafl c ani a c ofam ovi pr e t e e ve r P ddr s 238. 207 s r ie ont i ng opy e ot ced by a c opyrghtati s he e ( mp . 2 . i s ue r . Co l: 0) Usng t I addr s t ust da ea tme oft de e t d a doc e t i rngi i he P esd pl he t nd i he t c e nd um n ed nfi ng a tviy,' hel c us iss bs i r1 t i ntf t na , a r s , li a es ,e al c i t 't SP an e t u crbe og o de iy he me dd e s bilng ddr s m i 3Not bl , t e s t r t si tf as pe t i rngeronl b I a es , a do a y hes ofwa e ool den iy us ced nfi y y P ddr s nd notpr dei ntf ng i o m ai s a na , sr e a es e ,t lphonenumber , e al ovi de iyi nf r ton uch s mes te t ddr s s ee s or m i a e s .Appa e l Pli tf us d t I a r sast ba i f ras ddr s es r nty, a n if e he P dd es he ss o ubpoe c na ompeli lng De e ntsI t pr det i ntf ng i or ai n vi aPur BilofDi c r pr e ng f nda ' SP o ovi he de iyi nf m to a e l s ove y oc edi i F o iasaec u t ( p' a 2. I r py De e d n c ne dst a t su eo Flrda n lrd tt o r. Op n t ) n e l, fn a t o tn h thi s f o i dic r Gl r d t ba f obt ni pr ti i or ai ' ( pya 5) W i o tctn a y s ove y towe e he r or ai ng e-ral nf m ton ' Re l t . t u iig n h . a hort De e nts ut iy, f nda uggesst td helgaiy ofusnga sae c t ii t obt n dic r t ha t e lt t i t t our dec son o ai s ove y f racam o e whc Fe e a c u t h v e cu iej rs ito i aq sint a me i o li v r ih d rl o rs a e x lsv u idcin s ueto h t rt s a tona lga a yss' 1 Si De e ntsa g e on t spoi e t r , s doe t ddii l e l nal i . d. nce f nda ' r um nt hi nt nds he e o s he ' Cour ' a l i ofi. ts na ys s t 4Alhough Pl ntf Opposto bre ct sExhi tA f t pr ii t t t ai ifs ii n if ie bi or he oposton hat he i si a o r c de 398i t nc ofadeviewih I addr s 2 .238. 207 diti utngt nt nve tg t r e or d nsa es c t P es 4 22. srb i we y dif e c i e fl ,t te bi i f c i ntfesonl 1 fl a doe notpr dean I fer nt opyrght d ims ha xhi t n a t de i y 4 ims nd s ovi P a e s A s plme a exhi t( 1 3)a co nyi Pl ntf soppostonbre i c ts ddrs . up e ntl bi DE- 3- c mpa ng ai if ii if ndiae t ti rngeme oft s fl oc uredafe t sc ewa fl d. Exhi tB i m or ha nfi nt he e ims c r tr hi as s ie bi s e compr he i a not st tI a es ,butneihe t texhi tnort i tgaor s e nsve nd e ha P ddr s t r ha bi he nvesi t ' de l r ton i ntfes398i t nc .TheCour e c a ai de ii nsa es t xpec sco elt m a s et tis t uns o ke ur ha t r pr enttonst t Cou ta e a c a ean s e es ai o he r r c ur t d uppored b t r c d. t y he e or a e sa phonenumbe oft s c i rusng t tI a ddr s nd r he ubs rbe i ha P dd r sa t r e nttmet) ( e e es t he elva i s. Fis r De l!22. Neih t Compl ntnort i tgaorsde aai s ci eshow Pl i if c. ) ter he ai he nvesi t ' clrton pe t i antf i ntfe M r Pei z asa i rnge conne t d a t r e ntt de iid . lz o n nfi r c e t he elva i m e wih I a e s s t P ddr s 24. 2 207,howe r 238.2. ve . I. l Lega Stndar M otonToDimisPuruantt Rul 12( ( l a d: i s s s o e b)6) Thepur eofam o i t dimisfl pur ua t Fe r lRul ofCi pos ton o s s ied s nt o de a e vi Pr ed e l oc m 1 ( )6 i t ts t ef ca s f inc o ac mp an Therul per isdi mis ofa compl i 2 b ( ) s o e t h a il u fce y f o lit e m t s s al ant . t tf l t sa eacli upon whih r i ca begr nt d. I s d be r a aongsde Fe r l ha ais o tt am c elef n a e t houl ed l i de a Rueo Ci iPr c due8 a( ) whihr q rsad h l a dpli sae n o t cam s o n l f vl o e r ()2 , c e uie t o' n an ttme t f he li h wig s t t tt pl de i e il d t r i .' Alhoughacompl nt halnge byaRul 1 b)6)moton ha he ea r s ntte o elef ' t ai c le d e 2( ( i t dim isdoe notnee de al f c ua ale tons apli ifi siloblga e t p o det o s s s d t ied a t l lga i , antf s tl i t d o r vi he dr l ounds' orhi e ilm e t r i , a aç or ai r cia i oft elm e sofaca e of g 'f s ntte nt o elef nd s mul c e tton he e nt f us a ton wilno do. BelAtantc Cor . v T mby, 5 U. 5 4 5 5( 0 ) ci l t ' l l i ' p . wo l 5 0 S. 4 , 5 2 07 . Onc a c tçi ntfespl a ngst t be us t y a e no mor t n co l i , are e our d ii e di ha , ca e he r de e ha ncusons note ild t t as umpton oft t 'i m us deer newhe he t we lpl f t tsaea ntte o he s i nzh,'t t t mi t r he l- ed ac s ttt cl m t r i t ti plusbl on isf ce ' As r .p v I b l 1 S. . 9 7 1 4 ( 0 ) A ai o elef ha s a i e t a - ' hc o . q a , 29 Ct 1 3 , 9 9 20 9 . c mpli t a o ys r i a1 ( )6 mo int d s s i ic nan f cu l l gainst a ae o an c n nl u vve 2 b ( ) to o imis f t o ti s a ta al t h t r e o t nough t r ie arghtt r le a t e o a s i o e if bovet s cultvel ve , on t as um pton t ta1 t he pe a i e l he s i ha l he (a t )algai i t c antaetue' Twombl,55 U S.at555. However a wel- ed fcual le tons n he ompli r r .' y 0 , lpl . c mp an s r i e amo int ds s S v ni isrk sas v yj d et t cu l r o o te e o lit u v v s to o imis t e f t ti e a v u g ha a ta p o f f h s e f t i i o e, nd dha ar co r i ve y r m ot and unlkey. '' Twom bl 550 U . a acs s mpr babl a t t e vey s r e e i l ' y, S. t 556. 5 11 1. Di c s on s us i A. The Co pl n Sufki ntyAle aPl usbl Li B m ait t e l lges a i e nk ewee De e nt t n f nda a t I Addr sAs oc ae W ihl rng m e nd he P es s i td t nfi e nt To esa ih co i i rnge e , Pl ntf mus pr ()ownes pofavai t bls pyrght nfi m nt ai if t ove 1 rhi ld co iht a ( c yi ofc tt ntee nt oft wor t ta eorgi l Fei pyrg , nd 2) op ng onsiue lme s he k ha r i na st . Publc i s I . v.Rur Te . r Co. 499 U. 340 iaton , nc al l Se v , S. , 361( 991; 1 ) Mcca kilv Ra 279Fed. s l . y, . Ap x. 3 91 ( lhci. 0 ) Batma v M nemoni ,l ., 79F.d 1 2,1 ( 1hCi. p 91 , 6 1 t r 2 08; e n cs nc 3 53 540 1 t r . 1 9 ) T a Fo e Wiee s I c v T c n pa kCo Lt ,281F. D. 688( D.Fl 201 9 6 ; r c n r ls, n . . e h o r ., d. R. 683, S. a, 2) . Defnda doe notcontnd t tt Compl i f ist a lget ee e nt s e ha he ant al o le hes l emen s Rahe ,Deenda t . t r f nt ar guest tt alegai a et s c a i a concus yt a quat y a lgeapl usbl ha he l tons r oo pe ul tve nd l or o de el le a i e c rg i rnge e cli a ns a i vi pe s , s cfc ly De e nt Def nda opy i ht nfi m nt a m gai t n ndi dual r on pe i a l f nda . e nt t ke is wih pa a a 23- oft Co ait i pa tc a : a s s ue t r gr phs 24 he mpl n , n ri ulr As t s c i oft l e ne s r c beng us d t diti e Pli ifs he ubs rber he nt r t e vie i e o srbut antf c i e m ovi ,Def nti t mo lk y i rnge . Cons que l opyrght d es enda s he st iel nfi r e nty, Pl n ifhe e a lge De e nti t i rnge . . . . De e aitf r by le s f nda s he nfi r f ndanti t onl s he y pe s who ca be i ntfe a t i rnge att stme.', r on n de ii d s he nfi r hi i Co .5232 (mp a e a d d . mpl! -4 e h s s d e ) De e nta guest tt s a lga i a ei ufi intbe aus t y do note an how f nda r ha he e le tons r ns fce c e he xpli hi c s ondom i um u twa as oca e wih t I a e sa i s . M or s ci ly, e nt ni ni s s it d t he P ddr s t s ue e pe sca l Defnda con e t tt al to ar i a i ebe us t Com pli doesnots c f t tm es t nds ha he lega ins e mplusbl ca e he a nt pe iy he i a da e t tDef nda w a as i d t i rng ng I add es . Pli ifha smpl aleg t t nd t s ha e nt s sgne he nfi i P r s a ntf s i y l ed ha ac omput rusng t I a es a sgne t De e e i he P ddr s s i d o f ndan pa tcpaed i t a lgedi rngi t rii t n he le nfi ng a i t Alhought Compli c dbeceae ( g.by defni t r ssuch asis crber,'' ctviy. t he ant oul l rr e , i ng e m dubs i . a s ii ly des rbi t lr bet e t I addr s a t i vi ualD nd pecfcal c i ng he il we n he P k e s nd he ndi d 6 eenda ) i f nt,t r e e esExhi tA i i tf ng t I a ef r nc bi n den iyi he P dd r sa is a beongi t De e nt s h t ti es t s ue s l ng o f nda , uc ha t ma bef il r a t r f r ncet da e a t y a ry e d o e e e he t s nd i mesco ane i t i si t ' l s it d nti d n he nve tga ors og ubm te a Ex ii A.( eCo . 8( ss t o' i Ex i iA, Def ndantsI addressi s hb t Se mpl$ û e f lh n h bt W t e ' P s 24. 22. .'. 238. 207 ') ) Def nda alo c e nt s ompli t tt i tga ans ha he nvesi t or sde a a i doesnotsa et ta I ' clr ton t t ha ny SP wa c nt td nort tt pr e e f i ntf i a I s o ace ha he oc dur or de iy ng n P addr s d crbe t r n wa a t ly e s es i d he ei s c ual f lowe i t sca e. Pli ifr pondsb a g ng t tt r i no r o l d n hi s a ntf es y r ui ha he e s e r m e t tapl i if quie nt ha antf s ciialy al get tade e nts1 i ntfedhi pe fc l le ha f nda ' SP de ii m ast s c i ra sgne t r lva I he ubs rbe s i d he ee nt P a e s AsDef ntpr vi sno a hort t t ddr s . enda o de ut iy o h e c r r t Cour a e .s ontay, he t gr es De e ntsFa t lDiput Ar N o Cog za f nda ' c ua s es e t ni bl e a Thi St e t s ag Def nda as c e t tt physc la e slsed i t Compli i a700- t e nt lo ont nds ha he i a ddr s it n he ant s uni buidi wih a c l ng t ondomi um as oc ai t tha esal co muni a i wih a pay e st ni s i ton ha ndl l m c tons t nd m nt o I e e Se vi ePr de son be l ofi i dualu nt m t r c ovi r haf ndvi ni owne s.Def nda a s cli st tt I t r e nt lo am ha he P a e sas i nedt hi uni doe n m ac t onedi ddr s sg o s t s ot t h he s ove e byt i tgaor M or ove , c r d he nvesi t . e r Pli tf pr desevi nc t thewa outi ofFl rdaf a lbuttveda oft ive tga or a n if ovi de e ha s sde o i or l s ys he n si t y pe i d, n t a lged i rngi aci t t pl ro whe he le nfi ng tviy ook a e. Suc evi em i pa t wa f a c h denc ght ve he y or n e rys mmayj d me t to b tic n o f nnt eb ssf rd s salatt ssage6 a l u r u g n moin, u t a n t o h a i o imis hi t . 5 Defnda ' a gum e sc e ni t e a qua y ofPl itf i si tonm a be e nts r nt onc r ng h de c an ifs nve tgai y r l ntt alt rRul 11m oton, de ndi on t c r um sanc s eeva o a e e i pe ng he ic t e , a t a eprncpaly a gum r s hey r i i l e ancesu wh t e Pli tf ( rPli t fsc t e')i uiywa r a o bl undert nsa o t eh r anifs o ani oms ls nq r s e s na e t b f cr ums ic t he . 6l s n uppor ofhi M oto , Def nda post t tt s m eas oc ae wih beng t s in e nt is ha he ha s it d t i na med de e nti a a ton al gi unl uld f nda n n ci le ng awf ownl ng ofpor a l a i a nt oadi nogr phy e ves nnoc e peopl who wih t a d emba r s ntvul r et c e s o voi ras me ne abl o i opyrghthol r am i t c r et m i de s i ng o oe c he nos tlme t.( t a 3( in Di tl n Inc.v.D oes1-76, 279 F. D .239 t ete ns Mo . t ct g gi Si, i a R. , 242 ( D. Y. S. N. 7 W hie t Cour a no edge t pot l he t ck wl s he en i ly e ba r s i pr di ame pos dby t s tal m ra sng e c nt e hi a ton,i mus de Def nda ' M oton b ci t t ny e nts i e a e t ki t a lga i i t lghtm os c us , a ng he le tons n he i t f vor bl t Pl n if t Compli a qua ey sa e ac am a a e o aitf, he ant de t l t t s l i ofc i i rng m e opyrght nfi e nt . Ac di y,i i cor ngl t s ORDERED THAT ()Dee a tsM oinToDimist Co an ( 1 fnd n ' t o s s he mplit DE 7 i DENI a d )s ED; n ()Dee a tS al l a Ans rt t eCo an b Decem ber 31,2012. 2 fnd n h l Fie n we o h mplit y - DONE a ORDERED i M im i Fl i t s20 h da ofDe m be nd n a , orda hi t y ce r , 201 2 ' w z @ ' PATRI A A.SEI CI TZ UNI TED STATES DI STRI J CT UDGE cc: Couns lofRe or e c d 2 2d) Totee e tt tDee d n s e sas e il r cedur orr et pr ectt pri cy of 01 ) . h xtn ha fn a t e k p ca p o s uch e ul o ot he va ef nda sorot wi edic a s h co e nt her s s our ge uc poltcalbr nches ofgover ent e con,s h ar m e sa ebes die t d t t r i uc gu nt r t r c e o he ii a nm . 8
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
