Malibu Media, LLC v. Fitzpatrick, No. 1:2012cv22767 - Document 54 (S.D. Fla. 2013)
Court Description: ORDER denying 24 Motion for Summary Judgment; granting in part and denying in part 25 Motion for Summary Judgment. Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 10/17/2013. (lh)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Malibu Media, LLC v. Fitzpatrick Doc. 54 UNI TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FO R TH E SO UTH ERN D I STR I O F FLO R I CT DA M I M I D I SI N A VI O M A LI M EDI ,LLC BU A Cas N o.1: 2- - 67 e 1 CV 227 Pl i t f , a n if M A RK FI TZPA TRI , CK D e e nt f nda . / O R D ER D EN YI G D EFEN DA N T' M O TI N FO R SUM M A RY JU D G M EN T. N S O DEN Y I G PLA I TI S M O TI N FO R SUM M A RY JU D G M EN T A N D G R AN TI G N N FF' O N PLAI TI S M O T I N FO R SUM M A R Y JUD G M ENT N FF' O O N AFFI M A TI E D EFE NSES R V TH I CAU SE ca e bef r t Cour on t pa te ' c os M o i S m o e he t he ri s r s tons f Sum m a y or r J d me t( 2 ,2 1 Thi i a Bi-o rn , Co y ih Ifi g me tc s . Plitf M aiu u g n DE 4 5 . s s t-re tl p rg t n rn e n a e anif l l b M e a,LLC (é ai ' ma spo nogrphi movi whihi diti e vi apads citondi 1 lbu' ke r a c M ) es e t srbuts a i ubs rpi ba e we ie. I e ne pia t r sM a i spot nta busnes and t se non-ubs rber s d bst ntr t r cy mde cut lbu' e il i s o tm s ci a ce st iscon e M ai u r tnel m o t sBi-ore ne wo ksf una horz diti i c s ot t nt lb ou i y nior tf r nt t r or ut ied srbuton ofisfl . Thi c e a os outofs h e f t. t ims s as r e uc fors 1 Bi-oren i a co put fl s rng pr oc . l u iies a pe rt pe r newo k compos prma iy of tr r t s m er ie-ha i ot ol t tlz e -o- e t r ed i rl peronalco s mputr t s edi tlc e . To s r conentvi BiTorentaç e r'upl t di tlmae i e s o har gia ontnt ha e t a t r ç ede ' oads he gia tral s a dce tsatre tfl ta c nan ()au iu srngo aph n mei c aa tr u e t v rf ted t a d( a n rae orn i h t o tis 1 nq e ti f l a u rc h rces sd o e i h aa n 2) e y tr dmap't t I a esesofot rus r Li rt M e a Hol ngs LLC v.BiTo e Swar 277F. D.67 soa ' o he P ddr s he es. be y di di , t rr nt m, R. 2, 67 ( . Fl. l. Th c ne ti dsse e a ds v r l sr, owna aûwa , d wno dc ranpic s 4 SD. a 20l ) e o tn s ias mbld n e ea ues kn s ' nn' o la eti e e s ' oft contntt t ri vi lc he e o hei ndi dua omputr .Thetrentfl t die t t us r' co es o r ie hen r c s he e s mputrt ot r i t s r e o he s n he wa m whohavepice oft fl t us rne t ma ac e s he ie he e eds o ke omplt c ee opy.Onc t misngpice ae downl de fom e he s i e s r oa d r t ohe s nn computr ,t y ae s nce and ras e e on t us ' compu e . Bubbl Gum Pr s,LLC he t r wa e s he r eque d e s mbld he ers tr e od . v Do s18 , 01 WL 2 5 3 9( D. a 2 2 . . e -0 2 2 9 3 0 S. Fl. 01 ) 1 Dockets.Justia.com M ai al ge De e nt us d BiTorent t downl d a r diti e t e of is lbu le s f nda e t r o oa nd e srbut hr e t movi s De e ntde e t a lga i deni e rha ng us BiTore ,a e n de es e . f nda ni s he le tons es ve vi ed t r nt nd ve ni knowi wha BiTore wa bef e Pl i ifbr ng t t r nt s or antf ough t s s tagans hi The pa teshave t hi ui i t m. ri co smo e frs mma yj d me to t s l cam o die tc p rg tifig me t Ha ig r s - v d o u r u g n n he o e li f rc o y ih n rn e n . vn rv e dt emoins o po iin ( 27 28 , e le r 3 , 4 , n t er c r , ohmoins e iwe h to , p sto s DE , 1r pis DE 2 3 1 a d h e o d b t to mus be de ed bec us t r r mai a diput d is of f c ,na y,whe he De e nt t ni a e he e e ns s e s ue a t mel t r f nda d wn o d d o s ae Plitf' mo is Ho v r s mmay j d me twilb ga td f r o l a e r h rd an ifs ve . we e , u r u g n l e rn e o Pl i ifast t n ofDe e antf o e f ndan ' ffe afima i def ns sbec us De e n ha notme t ts iten fr tve e e a e f nda t s t he t e hol s wi t ta oft e de e esar a i bl hr s d ho ng ha ny hes f ns e pplca e. 1. BA C K G R O UN D 2 Fa ta Ba i o lb 'I# ige nt ai cu l ss fMa iu s n n me Cl m I Li td (l ' i a i v siains 511 t tmo tr Bif re tn t r fr PP, mie çPP' s n n etg to t ) 41 ha ni s t o rn ewo ks o o M albu. Si y- ght tm es be w e n J nuar 3 a Fe ua y 1 201 3 a I i tgai i xt ei i t e a y nd br r 2, 2, n PP nvesi tve s r rr ceved pi c ofPl ntf st e m o e fom a c e ve e i e es ai if hr e vis r omputri a BiTore s r t ta e n t r nt wa m ha n l i siaorta d t I e ne Prt PP nvetg t rcke o ntr t oocolCûP' a es 67. 241. The I a es 1 ' ddr s 205. 239. ) P ddr s belmge t Hot r Communiatons (é- wie', a Pe yl ni- ed I ene Ser c c d o wie ci tl r ' lot ) nns va abas ntr t vie Pr d rC$SP'. Pli ifis d as ovie I ' antf s ue ubpoe t Hot r rquesi t know t i ntt oft ) na o wie e tng o he de iy he Hot r s c i r who had be as i wie ubs rbe en sgned I a es 67. 2 . o Fe a y 9,201 a P ddr s 205.41239 n bnzr 2 t 2 3 U nl sot r s notd t ba ound fct ar tke fom t undiputd r or evi nc . es he wie e he ckgr a s e a n r he s e ec d de e Defndan miunde sa t s peofPl ntf' al to . Deenda alege t tPl ntf i cl mi t t e t s rt nds he co ai ifs legain f nt l s ha ai if s ai ng ha ifign ta s cin ocu rdo treo c so s whih aetetme Ise o Ex iiA o teCo an .( nrn ig rn a to s c re n h e c ain , c r h i s itd n hbt f h mplit DE 2 , 1 1 Thsi ic rc.Ex i tA st o th the t lsweeifig da dprvd srgsrt nd tsfrte 4 p. 0 . i s n ore t hbi es u ta tre ie r nrn e n o ie e itai ae o h t o co i t . Thepur eofEx bi A wast pr det co i i onna i f rt t eeM albu ttesa is . pyrgh s pos hi t o ovi he pyrght nf ton o he hr i il t s ue Exhi tB s bi howst fe he r quenc ofi rngement Defndanthasr s d analbit thewasa hi ofi s ve a mies y nfi . e aie i ha t s fce e r l l a yfo hiho cmp trwh no eo tei rn e nso Ex iiA o cre .Wi u rahn ete te wa rm s me o ue e n fh nfigme t n hbt curd t t ecig i r h ho h me sofh d fneo Plitf'rj n e ta Bi re thrsd t atmaial u esaue afr tv l at nt te ees r anifs eoidrht t rn sae aa uo t l nls sr fimaiey cs To c y t sop i,eve i i Defnda ' albiwe e a ce ed as f t i woul notbe dlpostve as t hi la lt f o t t n f t e nts i r c pt ac, t d s ii o s ibiiy or i rnge toft ssngl ttegi n t tExhi tB s nfi men hi i e il ve ha bi howst tt ssm ettewasi rnged28ot rtmts ha hi a il nfi he i . 2: UTC .4 H ot ie r 44 d ha f nda s he ubs rbe sg d ha P ddr s t w r esponde t tDe e ntwa t s c i ras i ne t tI a es a 2: UTC o Feb ua y 9,201 44 n r r 2. #. Ac e st Dee d n 'l tr e Co n cinb a Un d n se T idpa t c s o f n a ts n e n t n e to y n i e t d hr - ry De e f ndant a is he was a Hot r s c i r but de e downl di or s rng dm t wie ubs rbe ni s oa ng ha i M a i s f l s. D e e nt a s de e usng t B iTor e pr oc a e n kno i w ha lbu' im f nda l o ni s i he t r nt ot ol nd ve w ng t BiTore was be or t sl ws twasfld. Def ndantadva s t t i f how hi I t r nt f e hi a ui ie e nce wo heores or s P add es c r s amet bei i a e i wha hecon e wass o mplc t d n t t nds omeoneele' il galdownl di The s s le oa ng. fr ti t t l ta ked t wr I a es . Though De e nthas i r e a s hol ry is s ha PP r c he ong P ddr s f nda ntoduc d c a l a tc eon t t c t r i no r co d e de f om t c e t ts ril he opi , he e s e r vi nce r he as ha uggesst sha ned he e.5 t hi ppe r The s ond t r i t s one wihi t physc us bl r nge of De e nts wie e s ec heo y s hat ome t n he ial a e a f nda ' r l s i e t (: -i' conne ton,us Deenda ' i er t c ntme : f' wi ) ci ed f nts nt ne onneci t do oa and s r ton o wnl d hae Pli ifsmovi s a ntf e. Ast t ss c t r t cr um sa ilevi e c sbot wa . De e o hi e ond heo y, he ic t nta denc ut h ys f ndan a hi t nd s mt -i wie lved i a 300 uni,30 s o y c f i n t t r ondomi um buidi 6 The l i had wi f, butt c ni l ng. he onneci n to 4 I addr s ae va i y a sgne underaconc ptkno n asil etm e.' ( po io o Lati M. mh , P eses r rabl s i d e w çeas i ' De st n f t e Mu y i r DE 2 - , 3l9:8 . p ro o iatvt ma c u ete I a d est b rasg dt a oh rsbsrb r Th 5 5 p. 1 ) A e id f n ciiy y a s h P d rs o e e sine o n te u cie. e las tme f s c i s i Defndants condo buidi was t nt f hour. A Ho wie s bs rbe i e e i or ubs rber n e ' l ng we p our s t r u ci r n Defnda ' buidi whos conne i t t i e ne w a no us f t e p f rhour woul l e hi çl s 'on e nts l ng e cton o he ntr t s t ed or w nt ou s d os s sea e' t asi d I a es a i woul be ta er d t anot rus . l i u e rwhy t s he sgne P ddr s nd t d rnsfre o he er t s ncla he ubpoe onl r esed na y equ t t s c i rs i ntt f t s sngl tme,des t l havi ta ke t a e s f ove sx we a he ubs rbe ' de iy or hi i e i pie PP ng r c d he ddr s or r i eks nd c ctng wiht c onne i t he omputrt tus d t a e s68 tmes e ha e he ddr s i . Defnda poi st asud on t w e knes e i t dee in m ehodsus t tac I add esesi udi t e nt nt o t y he a s s n he tcto t ed o r k P r s ncl ng he us ofi amed' I addr s ,orus s conc alng t r own addr sw ih a he '. Howev ,t sud i not e f 'P eses er e i hei es t not rs er he t y s c usveast whehe I fa ngca oc ri ca esofdie tdeeci Se Ta yos Kohno,M ihae Pitk & oncl i o t r P r mi n cu n s r c t ton. e da hi c l ae Arid Krsn muty Ch le ge a d Die t n f r Mo trn P2 FieSh rn Acwtk - o - I'y my vn ih a rh , aln s n rci s o ni ig P l a ig r l s r 1l o o r / . PrntrRe eie a DM CA Take i e c vd downN otce Uni r iy ofW as ngt Te m ialRepor,UW i , ve st hi on cl c t CSE- 06- ,DE 08- 01 2 p.1 - 20. 4, 4 6 N eihe pa t ha cai d t tDeenda ' wie mi ha be n t i rnge . M albu saest ti i mor t r ry s l me ha f nts f ght ve e he nfi r i tt ha t s e lkel t t D eenda was t i rnge ,bec e by lr mar n t viwer of M ai s co ent ae m ae. i y ha f nt he nfi r aus a ge gi he e s lbu' nt r l ( caaino Coet Peise Fed, 2 - , 1 ) De lrt f lte lsir il DE 5 2 ! 8. o s e t ough m os oft uni w a s ow . D e e ntsr e r n t newor , a m ai ne wor pe d hr t he t s l 7 f nda ' out r a wo t ks n t k a agues ne wor .8 O n s up,t r er aut atca1y pa s d pr e st g tne wor a nd t t k et he out om i 1 s wor ot ct he ues t k; gue tus ca c s er n onnec t t newor butc t o he t k annota es t i t r twihouta pa s d.9 cc s he n e ne t s wor Apr l 201 a t hni a f om a ba m onior c pa i pec e D ef nda ' ne w o k f i 3, ec ci n r by t om ny ns t d e nt s t r or r as unr a e t t s c s a concude t t hi gue t n t r wa ç p nl alwig e ons elt d o hi a e nd l d ha s s ewo k s : e , l n o ) o a nyone t s ft ne. ( r HuntrE- l DE 24- .0 I i uncl r t o ur he t' Erol ' e mai, 6)1 t s ea hough, whe he by t r t p n't e tcmiin me n o n j tf rc n cin t te g e tnewo k o o e f rwe û e ' h e l ca o a t pe us o o ne to o h u s t r r p n o b b ow s ng w ihouta pas w o d.I a a fda tfl i s r i t s r n n f i vi ied n uppor ofhi m oton,D ef ntc a m st t s i enda l i o ha eC o fr d ta te r ue h d te g e ta c s f n t n a albl a d ( t i wa o e ' v û nime h t h o tr a h u s c e s u ci v ia e n t ) t s p n' c o ha ( fd vi o De e d n i S p r o Dee a tsM o in f rS mma y J d me t 2 - ,! 4 , Afia t f fn a t n u po t f fnd n ' to o u r u g n , 4 6 ) but lke t t hni a s s a e e ,D e enda ' a fdavi does not c a iy w ha t n' m e ns i he ec ci n' t t m nt f nts f i t l rf tû ope ' a . Ass h,i i uncla whehe an i e l ng neghborc d ac es Def nda ' i e ne wihout uc t s er t r nt ropi i oul c s e nts nt r t t know i hi pas w o d. ng s s r Su t i Ga i t Rec d Evi nce bsantal ps n he or de 1 TheLynks E1 0 r t rpr de optmum cove a a sgnalsr h whe i i ce r l l td, a i ys 55 ou e ovi s i r ge nd i tengt n t s ntaly ocae nd s plc da y fo mea,a dp ysc la deeto i o sr cin . ( n s sE1 5 UsrGuie DE 2 - 1 p.5 a e wa rm tl n h ia n lcr nc b tu to s Lik y 5 0 e d , 51, ) Deenda ' r e wasl aed i am ealbox i dehi be oom cl e. Thei e i walsoft condo we et e f nts outr oc t n t nsi s dr os t ntror l he r hr e i hest nkandmad ofi ult dr l. nc hi e ns aed ywal Defnda ' mai non- tnet k wa a al tmespa s dpr e e wih a ei di tpa s d t the e nts n, gues wor s t l i s wor otctd t n ght gi s wor ha s id. A gues newo k al t e wihi is sgnalr nge t ac s t i er tbutr srcs a es t ot r upple t t r lows hos t n t i a o ce s he nt ne e tit cc s o he r s ce on t newor Neihe Defndantnorhi wiec r calwhos tu t r ut . e our s he t k. t r e s f an e l e p he o er Ther t ' us rma saesir gues net r i s ouers e nual tt i he t wo k s hown a a open,uns ur wiel snewor t tyou sn ec e r es t k ha r guessc n e iy c t a asl onnec t Topr ve una horze us r fom usngyourl t r ac s ,yourgues net k t o. e nt ut i d e s r i n enet ce s t wor rq ie ta ap swo dbee trdfrltr e a c s. ( 25 1 , 1 ) Th ma a do sn tsaewh te te e urs h t as r nee o nen t c es' DE - l p. 2 . e nu l e o tt eh r h ' gues newor spaswor f toncoul bedia eds t ts e co d ac es t i er vi t gue t t t k' s d unci d s bl uch ha om one ul c s he nt net a he s newor wihoutknowi t pa s d. t k t ng he s wor 1 0 Pl ntf cli st tcl iin' saement, whih ar c ai i a em alfom t tc cin t D eenda ai if am he e m ca s tt s c e ont ned n n i r he e hni a o f nt aei d sil h asya ds o l n t ec n iee o smmayjd me t Be a s t tc niin so srain r na misbe e ra n h ud o b o sd rd n u r u g n. c u e he eh ca ' b ev to t tt gu tnet k wa ç n' coul be i r ha he es wor s l ' d ope ntoduce atti by smpl c lng t tch cin a a wine s t d ral i y ali he e ni a s t s , he sae nsma bec n iee a tes mmayj d me tsa e Se Ma u av De oe,l 3F.d 1 6,1 2 ( 1h ttme t y o sd rd t h u r u g n tg . e c b . b r 9 3 31 3 3 1t Ci.1 9 )(ttn ta aditit o r ma c n ie ah asysae n a s mmayj d me tpo ie teh asy r 9 9 saig h t src c ut y o sd r e ra ttme t t u r u g n rvd d h e ra sae n c nb le u e t a misbl e ie c a til' ttme t a e ç d c d o d si e vd n e tra.) r ' 4 The r co d i t s m at r has m a g ps The ba monior t cl c a was ne r e r n hi te ny a . by t e mii n ve de e a t r o e c d notc arf w ha he m e ntw he he wr e t tt gue tne w or was pos d nd he ef r oul l iy t a n ot ha he s t k ç n. Ther i no e ' ope ' ' es xper t s i ony a t t r nge ofD e e nts wi e e s i e ne . W ihout t e tm s o he a f nda ' r l s nt r t t s h t tmony i i uncl r whe he a neghbor c d ha a e s d t newor i t fr t uc esi ts ea t r i oul ve cc s e he t k n he is plce 1 M or ove ,net rpary hasi r a .1 ntoduce f e i e de fom De e d or nsc vi nce r f ndantsc ' omput ror e e r ihe t r e t twoul m a i mor orl s pr outr ha d ke t e es obabl t tDe e e ha f ndantha do oa d t vi os or d wnl de he de us d BiTor e .1 e t r nt 2 I. I CR O SS M O TI N S FO R SU M M A R Y O I FR I EM EN T M U ST BE D ENI N NG ED JU D G M EN T ON DI ECT R A. Summ ar Ju e St y dgm nt andar d S mmay j d me t i a p o rae wh n ûh p e d n s d po iins a s r t u r u g n s p r p it e s e la i g , e sto , n we s o t i er oga or e ,a ad i s ons o f l ,t t r w ih t a fdavis i a s nt r t i s nd m s i n ie oge he t he f i t , f ny, how t tt r i no ha he e s g n ie is a t a y maeilfc a t a te mo ig p ry i e tte t aj d me ta a e un sue s o n tra a t nd h t h vn a t s n i d o u g n s l ma trofl w. Ander on v Ll d / fobb I ,477 U. 242,247 ( 98 . Onc t movi te a ' ' s . r.p y, nc. S. 1 6) e he ng pa t de ons r t s t a e e of a ge ne i s ofm a e i f t t non- ovi pa t m us ry m t a e he bs nc nui s ue t ral ac , he m ng ry t S ome f wa d wih tpe fc f t s l c or r t s cii ac s howi t tt r i a genui i s f rtil'' M at s t ng ha he e s ne s ue o ra .' su hia Elc. ndu .Co.v Ze t Radi Cor s475U. 574,587(1 ( tngFed.R. v.P.56( ) e I s . nih o p. S. 986) quoi Ci e). The Cour mus vi w t r c d and al f t i e e est r r i t lg m os f vor bl t t e he e or l acual nf r nc he efom n he i ht t a a e t t nono he movi pa t a de i whe he Sihe evi ncepr s nt as fce diag ee tt ng ry nd c de t r tt de e e s ufi int s r men o rq ies b s int aj r o wh t e i i s o esd dt to ep ry mus p e i a amatr e ur u miso o u y r eh r t s o n -ie ha n a t t rval s te 1 Pli ifa t edt fl anafi tofa e r i wiel si e ne col e i t , how e r f t r as 1 antf tempt o ie fdavi n xpe t n r es ntr t m ctviy ve , or he e ons s touti t con e r neousy is d Or Sti ngt Afi tofEr t Rubi s e de wilno be e n he t mpo a l s ue der rki he fdavi neso , uch vi nce l t c i r d. onsde e 1 Plitf r quesedcopisofDefnda ' had drv i dic er i or rt f e ialy anayz t butt 2 an if e t e e nts r ies n s ov y n de o or nsc l l e hem he pa teswer una et ag e t t m a ri e bl o r e o he nnerand s copeofPli ifsi tga i De e antf' nvesi ton. f ndantshad drvesandot r ' r i he c ompu e e pme wer neve t nedoverno weet y s t r qui nt e r ur r r he ubpoena o oher s c ed r t wie ompeledby c tor . l our der o 1w.'Ale v T s n Fo d ,I c, 21F.d 6 2 6 6( 1h Ci. 99 )( u tn An e s n 4 7 f a ' ln . y o o s n . 1 3 4 , 4 1 t r 1 7 q o ig d r o , 7 ' U. a 2515 ) S. t -2). l o p ig amoin frs mmayj dg n , h n n- vn p ry ma n trl s ll n p osn t o u r u me t t e o mo ig a t y o ey oey o on t pl a ngs but m us s he e di , t how by afi vis de ii , a w e s t i e fda t , postons ns r o nt noga or e , a t i s nd a i s ons t t s ii f c s e s dem ons r tng a ge ne i s f ti l See Fe R.Ci P. dm s i ha pec fc a t xi t ta i nui s ue or r a . d. v. 56( ,() s ealo Ceotx Cor v Catet 477 U. 31 324 ( 986) A mee i cntla'of c) e ; e s l e p. . r t, S. 7, 1 . r ç i il' s e de e s vi nc uppor i t oppos ng pa t s pos to w il no s f c i t ad, t e m us be a tng he i ry' ii n l t uf i e; ns e her t s fiin s wi ta t ej r c ul r a o a l fndf rt a p ry An e s n 4 7U.. t2 2; u fce t ho ng h t h u y o d e s n b y i o h t a t. d r o , 7 S a 5 s ealo Wale v. b 911F. 1 1577( 1hCi.1 . e s k r Dar y, 2d 573, 1 t r 990) #. The Re r Evdenc Doe Not Su co d i e s ppor t Enty o S mma y J d me t a t t he r f u r ug n s o If ige n f rEih rpl y n kn me t o t e r By fln c o smoinsf rs mma yj g n , h p risa reta t e ei n is eo iig r s- to o u r ud me t t e a t g e h t h r s o su f e m a era f c a t s e i s s a e que tons of 1 w f t Co ts de e na i n. H owe r t i l a t nd he ol s ue r si a or he ur ' t nni to ve , lcr s - to f rs mmayj d me twi n t i t e ev s wa rn t c u ti g a tn t lo smoins o u r u g n l o , n h ms le , ra t he o r n rni g g l s mmayj d me tu ls o e o t ep risi e t ldt j g n a amatro 1w o fcs u r u g n n e s n f h a t s ni e o ud me t s e t te f a n a t t ta enotgenui y diput ... Unie St e v Oake 7 F. 1 1 ( 1h Ci. ha r nel s ed. ' ' td ats . ly, 44 2d 553, 555 1 t r 1 4) Hee,at n e de ir rc d ha lf t f ment q si i t c euna weed 98 . r hi vi ntay e or s e the unda al ueton n he as ns r a net rsde a m o ng pa t ha s nd ihe i , s vi ry, s hown a a e ofma e i li s off c f ti . n bs nce t ra s ue a t or ral 1. Pli ifsM oton f rSum ma y J a ntf' i o r udgm e M us BeDe ed nt t ni Fo Plitf t p e al n ismo inf rs mma yj dg n i mu ts o t t h r i n r anif o r v i o t to o u r u me t t s h w ha t ee s o diput t tDef nda downl ded a s r is movis l Pli ifs prnci e de e t t s e ha e nt oa nd ha ed t e .' antf i pal vi nc ha De e nt i rnged is c i ht i t t Def nda ' l na f nda nfi t opyrg s ha e nts SP med De e nt a beng t f nda s i he 1 Topealni drccpjgtnr gmetli Pani mut rv ta()io e a aicpr h o 3 rvio t i toy hifi e ncam litf spoehtl twnd vl oyi t n s e n f d g ismo isa d( Dee d n c pe te Fes Pu ln l c v Rua Te. ' v'. .n .4 9U.. 4 , 61 t ve n 2) fn a t o ld h m. it b 's n . . r l lsc J Co lc, 9 S 3 0 3 r ( 9 ) Onl tes c n ee n i ds td 1 91. y h e o d lme t s ipue . 6 s c i r who was a sg d I a es 67. 241. a 2: UTC on Fe ua y 9, 201 ubs rbe s i ne P ddr s 205. 239 t 44 br r 2. Si y i ntf ng t t a de e nts I a e s was us d t c mpl de iyi ha f nda ' P ddr s e o omm i a i rnge nt i not t n nfi me s dipostve of t def nda a t ly ha ng bee t i vi l who c s ii he e nt c ua l vi n he ndi dua omm it t ted he i rnge nt SeeBubbl Gum Pr . LLC v Doe 180,201 W L 2953309( D.Fl 201 . nfi me . e ods, . s 2 S. a. 2) Pl ntf ha no pr ed an r lort si ai if s t oduc y ea e tmoni evi nc t tDef nda hi s fdownl ded al de e ha e nt m el oa or r diti ed t copyrght wo ks 1 Plitf moin fr s mma yj d me tmu tb e srbut he i ed r . 4 anifs to o u r ug n s e denid be aus t r r ns a diput d is of m a e i f c ,na ey, wheher Def nda e c e he e emai s e s ue t ral a t m l t e nt downl dedorr srbut d Pl i ifsm o est r by i rngng isco i . oa editi e antf vi he e nfi i t pyrght De e f ndantsM oton f Summ a y J ' i or r udgme M us Alo BeDe e nt t s ni d Si lry,f Def nda t pr va lon hi m o i n, mus s mia l or e nt o e i s to he t how t r i no dipu e i s he e s s t d s ue off ctt a he di notdownl orditi t Pl ntf s wor .s Def nda ha notm a t s a ht d oad srbu e ai if ks' e nt s de hi s howi On s t p D e e ng. eu f ndan ' r e a om a i aly r r us r on t gues ne w or t i t s out r ut tc l equies e s he t t k o nput apa s d i or rt us t gues ne wo k i e ne . Def nthastle t oresa t how a s wor n de o e he t t r nt r t enda lr e he i s o neg coul ha c ihbor d ve onnecedt hi g s newor - ( )t r e wa s tu t alow t guet t o s uet t k 1 he outr s e p o l he s newor t bea c s t t i enwtwihoutapa s d;( t r e wasi cke 'me ni t k o c esed o he nt t swor 2) he outr û d,' a ng ha 1 Pl ntf a gue t t ga i isr levi nc s d bes a edby a i er et tDefndantdi i f t 4 ai if r s hat he p n t ea de e houl upplnt n nf enc ha e d n ac c ommi i rngementbec e i Defnda we e i ent he woul ha i r uce hi c t nfi aus f e nt r nnoc , d ve ntod d s omputrhad drve a e r i s t c lao ye ie c . Panifh sno p o ie a ylg la t rt t j siyt a s c a ifrn ei warne x up tr vd n e litf a t r vd d n e a uhoi o utf h t u h n n ee c s ra td y hee. Defndantwasnotc r e ompeled by a cou or rt pr e hi compuerequi ntno hasPl ntf ale l rt de o oduc s t pme r ai if lged t Defnda s lae evi e. M o e ,t r c devi nces sst tDeendan wasame bl t ha ng hat e nt poiitd denc r over he e or de ugge t ha f t na e o vi hi c putrequi entr viw e butt tt pa tes we e una e t r h a agrem e a t how t lm i t s om e pm e e d, ha he ri r bl o eac n e nt s o o i t he i r si i o Deenda ' dat t twaset rprvie d orir eva . Unde t cic t es s h an i eenc ntu on nt f nts a ha ihe i lge rel nt r he r umsanc , uc nfr e i n twarne a s mmayj d me th we e,h fc o d fn a tsn n po u t nmavb rlv n a til s o ra td t u r u g n; o v rte at f ee d n' o - rd ci . e ee a t tra. o 1 Pli ifc csDe e tt t tans ton a 2: UTC onFe uay 9, 201 vi iss 5 antf onne t f ndan o he r aci t 44 br r 2 a t ubpoenat Hot r o wie. Bu teifign atvte ta o c re a 2:4UTC o l iv le o eo tetrette a is e E 5 Ex. p. th nrn ig ciiis h t c urd t 4 ny n ov d n f h he i s tsu . DE , B, l 5.Tocn etPanifoteifig me t fteohe t tte, anifue asaitcln l it th wsa ) on c litft h nrn e n o h t rwo ilsPlitf ss tt ia aaysshaso s l o l sc ncet tHowiea sgne t s I addr st mo t onei vi i Fl l who % r es ha ha t r s i d he amc P es o re han ndi dual n orda d wnoa t a dr dsrb tdtemo e a ise ( 2 , . -8 .DE 3 , 2 .Th i l aino ti a lss o l d d n e itiue h vis t su . DE 8 p 6 1 ( 4 p. ) e mpi to f hs nay i , c i t tDef da wast s c i ra sgne t addr st e ietmet tl c s ha en nt he ubs rbe s i d he es he ntr i ha PP onduced isi tgai a t t t t nvesi ton nd ha Defnda i rnge t copyrght on alt e m ovis Ha Pl n ifss bpoe notbe n lm iedt onl a sngl e nt nfi d he i s l hr e e . d aitf ' u na e i t o y i e m i eofasngl da durngt ssxw e tme fame,i m a hav be n cl r rwheherDefndanthi s l wa t nut i e y i hi i ek i r t y e e ea e t e m ef s he s bs i rasi d I addr s67. 24l. f r lvanttm er m e.W hehe ornotDe e ntwast s bs i r u crbe sgne P es 205. 239 or ee i fa t r f nda he u crbe a sg I a e s67. 241. bewe J uay 3 a Febr y l 201 r mansadiputd is off t s ined P ddr s 205. 239 t en an r nd uar 2, 2, e i s e sue ac. ispa s d faur wa e er lyoveromea i c dbeus dt a es t i ene;or( t swor e t e s xt nal c nd t oul e o cc s he ntr t 3) t i rnge knew t paswor whihma ha be n ç dmi 'adeaul pa s d.6 g 27, he nfi r he s d, c y ve e û n', f t swor l DE a p.4) Thes c andt r t ore aes c ai a u uppore byanyrcor e de e. I . e ond hid he is r pe ultve nd ns td e d vi nc t i uncla whehert trti e n pos i e. De e s er t he i s s ve sbl f ndan sa e i an a tdavi t the c imed t tt s n fi t ha onfr t gue tnewor wa ' n. ( 24- !4j Ho ver Defndants c r trzain oft he s t k s ç ' DE 6, . we , e ope ' ' haacei to he newor asto n' s f r fom t s m e a g t a t t c c a s net rr ol swhehe t k çpe ' uf e s r he n mbi uiy s he e hnii n'; ihe es ve t r t gue tne w o k w as or e n c d have bee c i ur d t a l a gue tt us t i e ne he s t r , ve oul n onf g e o low s o e he nt r t wihouta pa s or G i n t t Def nda ' deni i no c r a e by c us ve e de e, t s w d. ve ha e nt s al s t or obor t d oncl i vi nc hi moin frs mmayj dg n mu tb d nid. s to o u r u me t s e e e 11 1. SU M M A RY JUD G M EN T I G R AN TED A S TO D EFEN DA N T ' TH I D ,FI S S R FTH , SI XTH , SEV EN TH , EI H TH , N I G NTH , TW ELFTH , TH I TEEN TH , R FO UR TEEN TH , AN D FI 7 FTEEN TH A FFI M ATI E DE FEN SE S1 R V Plitf as s e ss mma yj d me t nt leo De e d n ' ffe na fr tv anif lo e k u r u g n o wev f fn a ts ite fimaie d fn e .t apanif moin f rs mmayj d me t te d fn a tb a st iiilb r e ee ss l on litf s to o u r u g n, h ee d n e r he nta u d n o s o n t a t ea fr tv d fn ei a p ia ln O hc o F lW S pe vso v Pau,9 5 f h wig h t h f maie ee s s p lc be' f e f / u r iin . l 8 ' r F.Supp.1 1 ( D.Fl 1 (ii Bl Cr sand Bl Shil v Weiz,91 F. 1 44, 465, 470 S. a.997) ctng ue os ue ed . t 3 2d 5 1 5 ( 1h Ci.1 9 ),a d i i t o ny u n s c a s o ng gh t te b r e s its t (J 5 2 1 t r 9 0 ) n t s t l l po u h h wi t a) h u d n hfgj o a r pli ifr gadi t taf tvedefns ,'Paul 985 F.Supp.a 1 (ii Wet 91 F. antf e r ng ha fnnai e e' , t 470 ctng iz, 3 2d a 1 5 n 1 ) Prcial,ti me n ta ith n n mo ig p ry ma n t(i y d p n t 5 2 .3 . a t ly h s a s h t l l e o - vn a t y o smpll e e d c g 1 6 admi ' s he f t s wor or he ys l 500 out , Pli ifco e t E antf nt nds hat f n' i t deaul pa s d f t Lynks mode E1 r er notDef nts enda ' Ly k y El 5 rue.( 3 , . 1 n s s 5 0 o tr DE 4 p 4 1 7 Defndantsf rh a fr ai deens , f l et mii t damages i obvit by Pli ifsrpr s nt i e ' ou t fim tve f e aiur o tgae ,s aed antf' e e e aton ta io l se ssauo yd ma e .g 2 , 11 Dee d n sae ta i Plitf wi drwsiscam frama h tt ny e k tttr a g s DE 5 p. 2 . fn a t tts h t f anif t a t li o c l h da a s he wil wihd a hi f t a fr tve deens Plitf r pr s ntton wil be c tu a is m ge , l t r w s ourh fimai f e. an ifs e e e a i l onsr ed s t wihdr t awalofcai i a ua damages a ac r ngl D e e ts f t a fr ai deens i srcke I l m ng ct l nd co di y, f ndan ' ourh fim tve f e s ti n. n Dee d n 'tnhafnn tv d fn eh c ne d ta Panifi n t nildt ij n tv rle b c us Plitf s fn a ts e t fi aie ee s e o tn s h t litf s o e t e o nu cie eif e a e anif t alg d ij re aen i e i dit n rirp rbe S c asae n i meey ad na a dn ta a maie l e nu is r et r mme ae o re aa l. u h ttme t s rl e il n o n mr tv e h d e e. I i t r f r src efns t s he e o e tiken. De e ntha vol t iy wihd a hi ee nt afim ai deens -l k of f nda s unarl t r wn s lve h fr tve f e ac o i nalt rgi iy. 8 u o te mee alg to o d fn e i h s Ans r t c u tr ( mo in f r s mmay pn h r le ains r ee s s n i we o o n e a to o u r j d me t. Ke b n Na. s' v Wi o gh y, 01 W L 3 2 8 , t* ( . Fa 2 0 ( ing u g nl' y a k tAs n . l u b 2 0 ' l 21 0 6 a 3 M D.I. 01 ) ct i Matus t Elc I .Co.Lt ,475U. a 587 .Hee,Dee ntsafimai defns sf l s hia e . ndus d. S. t ) r fnda ' fr tve e e ai be us Def nthasno s ca e enda t hown t ta ofhi pr f e de e esa e s ha ny s ofer d f ns r uppore by t r c d td he e or e de e a a e, he ef e a i abl vi nc nd r t r or , pplc e. A. DeMi mi NonCu atLe (1) ni s r x 11 De e f ndantar guest tunde t docrne ofde mi mi no cu at1x e n i he i f und ha r he ti ni s n r e ve f s o t ha downl d orr srbu e Pl i ifswor , si rnge o ve oade editi t d antf ks hi nfi mentwass i ubsan i ast o ns t tal o b n n a to a l . Su r j g n i wa rn e b c u e Dee d n h sn tp o u e a y e o -cin b e mmay ud me t s ra td e a s fn a t a o r d c d n e de e t t hi a l ge us w as qua ia i y a qua ia i y de m i m i See Pe e vi nc ha s le d e lt tvel nd ntt tvel ni s. tr Letr s an As o s v Wo l I s.o ce t lg Ene s,5 3F.d 1 7,1 0 - 0 ( 1hCi. te e e d s c . . rd n t fs in oo y tr . 3 3 28 3 6 7 1 t r 2008)(mpha ii t tdemi mi us camsmus addrs boht qualttveandqua iai e szng ha ni s e li t e s t he iai ntttve di nsonsoft us) Ther c d e de rga di t quantt oft al d i rnge nt me i he e . e or vi nce e r ng he iy he lege nfi me i s an . The e i s s c t r s ome e de e t s vi nc o ugge t t t Def nda m a ha diti e c e of s ha e nt y ve srbut d opis Pl ntf s w or 68 tm es but i i unc e r how m uc of a of Pl i if s w or w e e ai if ks i , t s la h ny a ntf ' ks r diti t d. Ther i no e de e oft quaia i sgnii nc ofwha wa diti t d i t srbu e es vi nc he lt tve i fca e t s srbu e n he r co d a as s h t r i no x a t n e ur t C m po t nce of t pori n co e ' or e r nd uc he e s v y o a as e he t i ra he to pi d' diti t d. I As s h,De e srbu e d uc f ndantha no s s t hown t thi a fnna i de e e i vi bl a ha s fi tve f ns s a e nd Plitf i e tte t s mmayj g n . anif s n ild o u r ud me t #. I n c nt n n e n t' n o e I#ig me t J) ; Def nda alo cli t ti he i f nd la e f ri rnge e t tda a s s d be e nt s a ms ha f s ou ibl o nfi m nt ha m ge houl waved or ei i t d bec us hi conduc wasnotwilula t the a t d i good f ih. The i lm na e a e s t lf nd ha ce n at S mz e i r nge ' def ns i not a t' de ens but a lm ia i on dn a l oc nt nf i r' e e s i l ue f e i t ton m ges t t i onl ha s y 9 a iabl i t i rngerpr st the wasunawa e t tt wor ha be n c pplc e f he nfi ove ha r ha he ks d e opyrg ed. I iht n s h a c s t Cour ha dic ei n t l r mi mum saut y da a fo $750. t uc a e he t s s r to o owe ni t t or m ges r m 00 o $ 0 .0pe wo k.1 U. C. 5 4 0( ) 2 00 < r 7 S. j 0 ( 2 . W he e t i rng wor co an no i e of c i ht a de e nts c am ofimoc t r he nfi ed ks nt i tc opyrg , f nda ' l i r en ifig me tc ni sn e ie tay weg t 1 U. C.j 4 l c M a e ik Re o dn Co v n rn e n a e o vd n ir i h . 7 S. 0 ; / v rc c r ig . . Har r 598F. 1 199( h Ci.201 ( di t i enti rnge dee ef ecos d i pe , 3d 99, 5t r 0) hol ng he nnoc nfi r fns or l e n ilga downl i c s swhe et publcl a ia e s ur em a e i l a c le l oad ng a e r he i y va lbl o c t ra , ompa dic,f aur d d s et e c i notce. opyrght i ) Her,i i undipue t t oft t e tte a is had c iht e t s s td hat wo he hre ils t sue opyrg ma ks diecl on t wor . As t t t r wor i i undiput t tPli ifs we ie,t r r ty he ks o he hid k, t s s ed ha antf bst he prm a y me ns by whi h Pl ntf' co e i l tma ey diti e cai i r a c ai ifs nt nt s egii t l srbut d, l med t t al of is ha l t wokswe e c p rg td. As s c s mmay j g n mu tb g a td t Plitf o t e r r o y i he u h, u r ud me t s e rn e o an if n h de e e f ns . luePr es( l oc s ZY Def nda a guest td pr s lmist i e nt r ha ue oce s i t he mposton ofsaut y da a a f e t ii t t or m ges nd e s o no m o e t n 1 tm est a ountofac ualda age . D e e ntha notc t d a au hort f t r ha 0 i he m t m s f nda s ie ny t iy or t pr ii t tdue pr e sr quie da ag t beca d a hepr es To t c r y, he oposton ha oc s e r s m es o ppe s opos . he ontar t Fis Cicui r ce l uphe d sa ut y da a s of $675, on a due pr s c le he rt r t e nty l tt or m ge 000 oce s ha lnge whe e t D ef ntw a la e f il ly dow nl ng 30 s r he enda s i bl or lega l oadi ongs f hi ow n non- om m e c al or s c ri us So y BM G M u i Ent 'v.Te e. n sc m t nenbaum,71 F. 67 ( s Ci.2013 .TheCou te ai d 9 3d 1t r ) r xpl ne t ts a ut y da age ne notne es a iy be pr ha t t or m s ed c s rl opor i t t a t da a bec us s a ut y tona e o c ual m ges a e t t or da gesalo s r a detrentf nc i I a 71 The s ma s e ve er u ton. d t . nme r s ng i a i a e he e and ea oni s pplc bl r P an ifi smial e tte t s mmayj d me t nt ed fn e litf s i lry n ild o u r u g n o h ee s . Joi r%1) nde 1 10 Plitf smo in f rs mma yj dg n i as ga td a t t d fn e o fiu et an if to o u r u me t s lo r ne s o he e e s f al r o j i a i ds n a l p ry Rue 1 a r q r sta apat be aj i d i isa e ewo l on n n ipe s b e a t. l 9() e uie h t ry one f t bsnc u d pr ve tt e si pa te fom obt i ng compl e r i ort a e pa tesnon-ncuson i e n he xitng ri s r ani et elef he bs nt ri i l i n t e c s wo l p eu ie t a p ry s rg t. Un e Rul 1 ( )t e Co r h s d s rto t h a e u d rj dc h t a t' ih s d r e 9 b h u t a ic ein o dim is a aci n o t gr s s n to n he ounds t ta pa t i i s ns bl De e ha ry s ndipe a e. f ndanti no es Rul 1 s g r e 9' rto ae a d ise d ag e t a j id r i rq rd b c u e o te u i u n tr o te ain l n n ta r u s h t on e s e uie e a s f h n q e au e f h BiTore pr t ol De e nti core t i sa i t t BiTore nec s rl r quies mor t r nt o oc . f nda s r c n t tng ha t r nt es a iy e r e t n o pa tci nt Hi a guments emst be t ts e ot rBiTore us ri i s ns bl ha ne ri pa . s r e o ha om he t r nt e s ndipe a e be a s t a u e a d Dee a taej i tt rf ao s I i welstld h we r ta j it c u e h t s r n fnd n r o n o te s r . t s l-ete , o ve, h t on trfas saenoti s nsbl pa test aca e Hepih v.Walac 430 F. 792,81 (t o te or r ndipe a e ri o s . r c l e, 2d 7 5h Ci.1 (ç e 1 ...wa notme ntt uns tet wel- tbls d a hort t t efe t r 970) ç Ru1 9 s a o etl he lesa ihe ut iy o he fc t a j i ttrfa o so c c n piao sa en tp ro who ea s n efo ac s wi r s l i h t o n o te s r r o o s rt r r o e s ns s b e c r m a e l e ut n l dimis f non-oi de*1.B Dee ntofe sno ot r agumentf why a he pa t i s sal or l n 15 1 * . fnda fr he r or not r ry s i ipe s be t t a to a t eeo e Plitf i e tte t s mma y j d me t o nds n a l o he cin nd h rf r an if s n ild o u r u g n n Dee d n ' no j id rd fns . fn a ts n-on e ee el g E. Lie s % 11 , Un lan Han s r. Eso pe ( 1$ Wa v r I F , c ne 1 ) ce d . R tp l X11 J r ie 47 . ) Fof iu e4 / retr . , .) N Dee ntseg h(ie e,c e ,a a quis e e,nit ( l nha ) t re nt fnda ' iht lc ns ons nt nd c e c nc ) nh uncea nds,hite h ( so p l,fu te t ( i e) a d ffe nh (o fi r )d fns sa1e s nil am t j siy e tp e) o re n h wav r, n ite t f ret e e e e l se tal i o u tf u y 1 % I Bonne v Ci o ih r , 61F.d 1 0 ,1 0 ( 1hCi.98 )(nb n ) t Elv nhCic ta o tda n r . t fprc a d 6 y 2 2 6 2 9 1 t r1 1 e a c,he e e t rui d pe s bi ngpr ede al de si oft f r Fi Cic tha ndi ec nt l ci ons he o mer ûh r ui ndeddown prort Ocobe l 1 1 i o t r , 98 . Th n nj n e d fn ei teBiTorn c ne tfi u d raRue l a ay i a wel AsJ d eBa s n e o -oid r ee s n h t re t o tx al n e s l 9 n lss s l. u g ylo n td i Maiu Me i,LLC v J h Doe 1 2 3 WL 3 6 * ( D.Pa 201) t p e ala an te c oe n lb da . on , 01 0 48 9 E. . 3, $ rv i g is a h To (ee a t, lb ne d t p o eta e c E ee a t d wno d disc p rg tdmaeil to t uh rzto . d fnd n)Maiu e s o r v h t a h d fnd n) o la e t o y ihe tra wih u a to iain Th Co rwil a et a j dc t te ematr a dt i c odc mpeer l f' eh ro n th oh rme es e ut lbe bl o du iae h s tes n o d c r o lt ei wh te r o te te mb r a e oft s nns who algedl alo i rnge M albu' wor ,a epr e ornot' he wa , le y s nfi d i s ks r es nt .' 11 De e nts aleg i rnge e on t ba i of Pli tf s co uc i t e o c m e of is f nda ' l ed nfi m nt he ss a n if nd t n he nf r e nt t c i . De e opyrght f ndants pl a ng wih r r t al oft s de ens s i i ntc . De e nt ' e di t ega d o l he e f e s de ial f nda camst tPlitf scamsa' bar d b c u et an ifa t o ie us g fiswo k lvaBi li ha an if li l re e a s l itf uh rz d e o t r s i t e pl Tor e , i udi Pl i if s a o Pl i if s age s ri i ton i t a l ge B iTo r t r nt ncl ng a ntf nd/ r a nt f nt 'pa tc pa i n he le d t r en S r ' ( 1 , 4 , 5 ! 51 ! 5 1 S mmayj d me tmu tbeg a td frPlitf a t wam. DE 0 ! 5 ! 0, , 2 . u r u g n s r ne o anif s o ' t e def ns s hes e e. Defnda ' al a i t tPl i if is l i tal s ede t t r e wih c e of is e nts leg ton ha antf te f nii ly e d he o r nt t opi s t wor i al e f tt e na e woul be i r nge s i uns ks n z f or o ns r d- nf i r s uppored by t r cor D e pie de i t he e d. s t pos ng Pli ifs c or t r pr s nttve, pr antf op a e e e e a i opoundi a r ue t f a ison, t s t of ng eq s or dm s i wo es i erogaores a t r que t f pr nt r t i nd wo e s s or oducto De e i n, f ndanthas notpr oduc d any e de e t t e vi nc ha Pl i if r l s d is c ent vi BiTor e . l of r as D e enda alege t t by M albu' a ntf e ea e t ont a t r nt ns a f nt l s ha i s i si a or r cevi pi c ofiswor i a t r nts r i f t a oft i i tga i nve tg t s e i ng e es t k n or e wa m n urher nce he r nvesi ton, Pli ifha ( )lc nsd t us ofisc i ,( c rbutd t t i rnge tofisown antf s 1 ie e he e t opyrght 2) onti e o he nfi men t co iht ( s d beeq t y et d fom cli ngi rnge nt ( haswai d acam pyrg , 3) houl uiabl soppe r ami nfi me , 4) ve li t i rnge nt or ()ha f reied t c i alt t r t s agume saeuna lng. o nfi me , , 5 s of t he opyrght 1 ogehe, he e r nt r vaii Pl ntf a guest tDef ndanthasnotm e t elm e sofa oft e fvel ga t i under ai if r ha e t he e nt ny hes i e l heores t es mmayj dg n sa d r . De e d n h sno tk n te o p ru t i i o p iin t h u r u me t tn a d fn a t a t a e h p o tni n t p osto o y s ex a n how t r c d e denc r l tng t M albu' i tga or s t ctc s pl i he e or vi e e a i o i s nves i t ' a i s uppor s a oft e t ny hes t e re a da s c s mmayj dg n mu t eg a tdt Plitf o te ed fns s h o is n s u h, u r u me t s b r ne o anif n h s ee e . F I aldiy ( 1 nv i t XI) a e o a nt f e ' hh Fial, s mmay j dg n m us be gr nt d t Pli if on D ef ndants Tw el n ly u r u me t t A fi tve D e e e i ldiy of co i . De enda sa e t t ( Mal s wor a e fnna i f ns , nva i t pyrght f nt tts ha f i bu' ks r obs e , t y ma not be e il d t c c ne he y ntte o opyr ght Though M a i s w or ar po ogr phi i . lbu' ks e m a c, 1 2 De e ntha notbr f nda s oughtf t a e de e t tt y a e obs e . As s h,Pl ntf m us be orh ny vi nc ha he r c ne uc ai if t g a tds mma yj d me t nDee a tst lt a fnn t d fns . rn e u r u g n o fnd n ' wefh fi ai ee e ve l V. C O N CLU SI N O Fort f egoi r s ns i i he or ng em o , t s O RDERED TH AT ( )Dee d n ' M o inf rS mmayJ d me t( 2 )i DENI 1 fn a ts to o u r u g n DE 4 s ED. ( )Plitf sM oin frS mmayJ d me tg 25 i GRANTED I PART AND 2 anif to o u r u g n DE ) s N DEN I I PAR T a i s tou a ve ED N s s e t bo . ( Thepa tess ltl t rJ ntPr ra StpultonbyNove r4, 3) ri hal ie hei oi etil i ai mbe 2013i n a c r n ewihteOr e S ti Tra Dae( 1 1 c oda c t h d r et ng il t DE 2 . & D NEA O E E iMimiFoiati/Y dyo O tbr 0 3 O ND RD R D n a ,lr ,hs d a f coe2 1. e * PATRI A A .SEI CI TZ UN I TED STA TES D I STRI J D G E CT U CC: Honor eAndr aM .Si ont n abl e m o A1 c 1 ouns lofr c d e e or 13
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
