Chanel, Inc. v. 7perfecthandbags.com et al, No. 1:2012cv22057 - Document 211 (S.D. Fla. 2014)
Court Description: ORDER granting 207 FOURTH MOTION FOR ENTRY OF FINAL DEFAULT JUDGMENT AGAINSTDEFENDANTS 215-333 AND CLOSING CASE Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 1/31/2014. (sk)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Chanel, Inc. v. 7perfecthandbags.com et al Doc. 211 UNI TED STAT ES DI STR I T CO UR T C SO UTH ER N D I STR I O F FL O R I A CT D CA SE N O .1 22057- 1 SE1 S1 ON TON 2C V- TZ/ M CHAN EL,l C. N , Pl i if a ntf , V S. 7 PERTECTH AN D BA G S. M ,e al, CO / . Dee ns f nda t . OR D ER G R AN TI G PLA I FF' FO U R TH M O TI N N NTI S O FOR ENTRY OF FI NAL DEFAULT JUDGM ENT AGAI NST - DEFENDANTS 21 333 ANp CLO SI CASE 5NG TH I M ATTER i be or t Cour upon Pl i if s Four h M oton f Ent y of Fi l S s f e he t a ntf t i or r na Dea tJ me Agans Dee nt 215333 ( 2071 Pli if Cha ,I (t ful udg nt i t fnda s - DE . antf, nel nc. schane'or l' S anif)mo e f rfn ld futj d me ta an tDee d n s 21 - 3 ,t e Pm n rhiso ç itf ' v s o i a ea l u g n g is fn a t 5 3 3 h pl es p r Unn o p r td Aso ito sie tfe o S he ue 1 ' e eo ( olci ey t fn a t' fr ic r o ae s cain d niid n c d l i h rt c l tv l i e d n sll o A' e De alg dv oain o teLn h m Ac,c d fe a 1 U. C.j 1 1 l 1 ,1 21 1 a,a d l e i lto s f h n a e t o iid t 5 S. j 1 4, l 6 1 , 1 N) n . 1 2 ( ) AsDee d nsh v f i d t a pe r p e d o oh r s d fn t i a to a gv n 1 5d. fn a t a e al o p a , la r t e wie e e d hs cin, nd ie e t doc e t r e de s itd i s he um n a y vi nce ubm te n uppor ofis moton,t Cour s l g a Pli ifs t t i he t ha l r nt antf Fo t M oton f Fi lDe a tJ m e . urh i or na f ul udg nt 1Plitf sSe e t Ame d d Co lit( 1 9 fld a an tDee a t 21 - 3 icu e an if v nh n e mp an DE 8 1 i g i s fnd n s 5 3 3 n ld d e a dto a S be tDo i Na so e ae by Dee a t 1 2 a d 1 5 s e iial,S b e t d iin l u jc man me p rt d fnd n s 3 n 5 , p cfc ly u j c Do i Na sme se l r so e .o ( f n a t1 2 a d io os o pngc m ( fn a t man me n j wel y t rsc m Dee d n 3 ) n g g h p i .o De e d n e 1 .De e nt 1 - c ne- c a e. t a Dee nt l - ca -rde.om ak//vi 55) f nda 32 ha lne klc ne nd fnda 55 psta c / a ps l.o ae s be tt te Co r' Oco e 2 ,2 1 Fia De a l J d me ta d Pema e t el m r u j c o h u ts tb r 8 0 3 n l fut u g n n r n n c Ij n to Ag i s De e d n s 6 - 1 .g 2 6 e tr d o t e d c t Oco e 2 ,2 3) n u cin an t fn a t 7 2 4 DE 0 , n ee n h o ke t b r 9 01 . Pl i ifs Fou t M o i f Enty of Fi l De a t J antf rh ton or r na f ul udgmen Agans De e nt 21 333 t i t f nda s 5- r q ss t t ti Co r e tr d fut j d me t a an t t e Su j c Do i Na s e uet ha h s u t n e e a l u g n g i s h be t man me me se ley t r sc m ( fn a t1 2 a io o h p i .o ( f n a t1 5 ie tfe o n jwelr so e .o Dee d n 3 ) nd g g s o pngc m De e d n 5 ) d n iid n Sc ul t ' her t hed e i ' e o. A Dockets.Justia.com 1 . FACTUAL AND PROCEDUR AL BACK GROUND Cha l I (ç ne' i a c ai dul or nie unde t lwsoft Stt of ne, nc. t Cha 1' s omorton y ga z d ) r he a he ae Ne Yor wih is prnci lpl c of busne s i t Unied St e l at a Ni W es 57h w k t t i pa a e i s n he t ats oc ed t ne t t Sre , w Yok, w Yo k 1 01 ( v n h Ame d d Co an ( 1 9 a !4 . Ch n l s te t Ne r Ne r 0 9. Se e t n e mplit DE 8 t 1) a e i e ngage i t pr d n he omoton,diti i a s l i Unied Stt s i e sa e c i srbuton, nd a e n t a e nt rt t omm e ce o hi r f gh quaiy go t rt Cha M aks ( lrton ofAdre Hn Sibar i Suppor of lt ods mde he nel r . Decaai inne hn s ro n t Pli tf s Ei ht Ex Pare Applc ton f r Enty ofTe a n if g h t ia i o r mpor r Re ta ni Or r Pr i i r a y sr i ng de , elm na y Ij n to ,a d Or e Re tan n Tr n f r o As es Tid t t e Comtretn Op rto nu cin n d r sr ii g a se f s t e o h t ef iig eain (t-n De .)!! 4,5 g 1 1 . Cha i,a a altmesr e ntheeo ha bee t ç lhn c1' l ' DE 77- 1) nel s nd t l i elva rt s n, he owne ofa1 rg si a t t f l wi Fe a l r it r d ta m a ks r 1 iht n nd o he olo ng der ly eg se e r de r : T r mar ade k CHA N EL R e sr i gi t at on Number 0 61 1 2,69 , R e s ra i gi t t on Da e t Se e be l pt m r 3, 1 955 Cl selGoods as ls/ r (nt Cl s:1 Nec ac l l as 4) kl es CHANEL 0,260 5 6 ,3 M a 1 1 5 (n 'Cls :1 )W o n'h n b g y , 9 6 It a s 8 me s a d a s l CHANEL 0,906, 2 26 J 19711 (ntlCls :25)Coas s t,bl e , anuay 9, I ' a s r t, uis ous s 0 M a ch 1 r 3, CH AN EL 955, 074 , and s r es ca v 1 973 , (ntlCl s 1 W ac I as : 4) thes (n'Cls : )S is jc es s it, I t a s 25 ut,a k t, krs l r 1241, 264 , es e , nt, ous s t cs J 7,1 une 983 dr s s pa s bl e , uni , s t r ,c r ga ,t e- hi t ,c t , wea e s a di ns e s rs oa s r i t ,s r e ,s s a boot a ncoa s ca v s hoe nd s 2 T r mar ade k CHAN EL R egi t i s raton Numbe r 1 R egi traton s i Dat e Cl selGoods as ts/ (n 'Cls : )Sut,a kes s rs It a s 25 isj c t, kit, l 241 265 , , J 7,1 une 983 d e s , s bl es t c , r s es pant , ous , uni s s e t r ,c di , t , a nc t , w a e s ar gans coa s r i oa s s ar s s sa boot c ve , hoe nd s J R 1347, 4 09 , It a s 3 ul ie f l J y9 1 ul , 985 (n 'Cls : )A f lln o perum e y,c m e i ,a t l ti s f r os tcs nd oie r e CHANEL 1348, 842 , I ' as : l li ru r J y1 1 ul 6, 985 (nt Cl s 3)Ful lneofpe fmey, c me i sa t lti os tc nd oie res 1501898 , , (nt Cl s 6 Keyc i I ' as : ) l hans (n'Cls :1 Co t j wer I t a s 4) sume e ly l Aug t30 (nt Cl s:1 )Gitwr ppi pa r us I ' as 6 f a ng pe l , u t cl f j 1 988 ( as : )Bl e ,s , ls s 25 ous s hoes bet, s a v sj c es me 'te c r e ,a k t, ns is (nt Cls 26)Br he ,butonsf l ' a s: l ooc s t or cl t ng o hi CHANEL 151 757 , 0, 1 Novembe 1 j t cj r , , j 1 988 A ugus 20, t 65 25 4, 2 1 991 , (n as :9 sunglses s ) as , (nt1Cls :9)Sungl s l as ases (ntlCls :1 Leahergoods I ' a s 8) t ; CHANEL 1 733, 051 , name y,ha l ndbags walet, r velba , , l s ta gs Nove be l l ge, i s a c edi ca d m r 7, ugga busne s nd r t r 1 2 99 ca e ,c nge pur e ,t e ba , s s ha s s ot gs cos ei bagss d empt a m tc ol y, nd ga ntba f ta l nne gs or r ve (ntlCl s 1 Leahe goods l ' as : 8) t r ; 1 822 ,734, N nn e y,ha m l ndbags wa lt , r ve bags , le s ta l , ove be 24, m r 1 992 l age busnes ca d c es c nge ugg , i s r as , ha pur e ,t e bags a c m e i bags s s ot , nd os tc s d e pt ol m y 3 T r e r ad ma k Regi t at o sr in Numbe r Re sr in gi t at o Da e t Cl s ts/ o a se lGo ds Jl 2 2,559, 2 77 l l r A prl9, i 2002 (nt Cls :1 - i pice ; mey, W ' a s 4) ' me e s na l a c s a Pa t The eof t he , nd r s r X 30594 ,2,3 Deegj 1,(n,Cls:8-Hadas ca jr 3 It as1) nbg mb ; e l (nt Cl s 9 Eye a sfa , I ' as : ) gls r mes l s as e ungl s s r 3025,36 , 9 De e0(jr1 , (nt Cls : )Gl ve ,s mwea c2 ; 3 l , a s 25 o s wi r mbe l (nt Cl s: )Hai a eso i l ' as 26 r cc s res l na y ba r te mel r e ts CH AN EL 3 1 1 33,39 , A ugus 22, t 2006 , (n lCls 1 J welya wac s lt a s: 4) e r nd the (ntlCls :9)Skigoggls e gls l ' as e , ye a s fames m obie phone sr ps r , l ta , sm g a s ,s l s pa t , as f t l s es ung a s r s c es or s cac e a s ms e pe t l s nd ungl s s (ntlCls 20)M i s namey l ' a s: nor, l pe s na com pac sa ha he d ro l t nd nd- l m ir s r or Augus 29 t CH AN EL 3, 3 695 1 4, (ntlCls :25)Skiboot,s vior, I ' as s un s s 2006 , s pe r ,s e t nds s i w e r us nde s w a ba , w m a , socki a s ks t ngs nd oc (ntlCls :26)Hara ce s is I ' as i c sore nnme yba r tesa pony-ai hol r l rel nd t l de s (n 'Cls : 8 Ba ss e ilya o td l t a s 2 ) g p cal d pe l f s t equi or pors pment bas t ls , ke ba l, kies s s s pols t l sr ke s t , ki, ki l, emi ac t , t nni ba l,t sr c tco r ,gol e s ls enni a ke ve s f cl ,gol bags s ubs f , now boa ds r CHA N EL 3 890,59 1 , D e m be 1 ce r 4, 201 0 4 (ntlCl s 9)Ca e f t e I ' as : s s or elphones , (ntlCl s 1 Te aytto I as : 6) mporr atos (ntlCl s 1 Keyc es l ' as : 8) as T r ademar k R e s ra i gi t t on Number R e s ra i gi t t on Dat e Cl selGoods as ts/ (n 'Cls : )Pr tci ec v r f r It a s 9 oe tv o e s o l 4 07 269 4, , pora ee e toni de ce ,ha tbl l c r c vi s ndhe d l D di t lde ce , r ona c put r gia vi s pe s l om e s ec2011 20, a c lphones e be m r nd el (ntlCls :1 Tempor yttoos I ' a s 6) ar at (ntlCls :1 Ke c es I ' a s 8) y as (h f n lM aks' whc a erg see o tePrn ia Re itro teUntd S ae Pae t te d e r ' ih r e itrd n h icp l g se f h ie tts tn cha ) a Tr dema k Ofi and a e us d i c nd a r fce r e n onne i wih t m a a t e a diti i ofhi h cton t he nuf c ur nd srbuton g quaiy goods i t c e res i ntfe a lt n he atgoi de iid bove.( hn Dec.! 4;s e alo Unie Stt Ha l e s td aes Trde r Regitai of t Cha M aks a is (f nelTr de r Regitai ' a mak srtons he nel r t sue scha a mak srtons' ) atc e a Co o i Ex i tA t teHn nDe l ( 1 7 2 ) ta h d s mp st hbi o h h c. DE 7 - 1 e A s s tf r h m or f l i Pl i if s Ei h Ex Par e A pplc t o f Ent y ofTe por r e ot e uly n a ntf ' ght t i a i n or r m ay Retan n Or e , ei nay lj n to ,a d Or e Retann t Trnse o AsesTidt srii g d r Prlmi r n u cin n d r sri ig he a fr f s t e o t e Co n efii g Opeain g 1 7 2 a d t e De lr to s o Cha e' rp e e tt h u tretn rto DE 7 ), n h ca ai n f n ls e r sn ai ve Adre inne Hnhn Sibaro fl i s s r ied n uppor of Pl ntf' Ei h Applc i f Te t ai ifs ght iaton or mpor l a. y Re tanng Or e ( 1 7 1, Dee a t ae p o tn s lig o frn fr s l a d sr ii d r DE 7 -1 fnd ns r r mo ig, eln , fei g o ae n diti tng g srbu i oods be rng c e f is of Pli if s ta ma ks wihi t s J cal Ditit a i ount re t antf r de r t n hi udi i src t ough va i f l i e a tve c m e c alI e etwebs t a c m e ci le- t r s i diec hr rous uly nt r c i om r i nt m ies nd om r a s o e n r t c rve i ofCha ' rght.( we pageprnt sfom ea hoft Def nt'we ies onta nton nels i s3 See b i out r c he enda s bst 2 Pl i if s Ei h Ex Par e A pplca i n f r Te po a y Re tai ng Or , Pr i i r a ntf ght t i to o m rr s r ni der elm na y Ijmci and Or r Resr i ng Tr nse ofAses Ti t t Co ef tng Opeai , n t ton, de tani a fr st ed o he untreii rtons t t wih s ogeher t uppori exhi t and decartons a e i or aed heri by rfr nc (he tng bis l ai r nc por t en ee e e t t g hApplcainf rTe ayResr i ngOr r'.( 1 ) t ht Ei i to o mporr tani de ' DE 77. ) 3 Pl i ifs St t me s of Fac s r r ng is rg s a Def nda s i rng ng a tvii a e antf a e nt t ega di t i ht nd e nt ' nfi i c i tes r o tie i t e Se e t Ame d d Co liti P rg a hs6 - 7 g 1 9 a d i Plitf u l d n h v nh n n e mp an n a a rp 2 8 DE 8 1 n n an ifs 5 and e-t es s sor howi e ch Def nda s a ts m e s a ofer t s l c e f i Cha l ng a e nt ' dverie nt nd f s o e l ount ret ne brnded pr t at he asCompost Exhi tB t t Hn Dec.g 1 3 t ough DE a oducs tac d ie bi o he hn l DE 77- hr 1 7 9 ( ra tr ç fn ns W e stsa d E- tr s'. Ass c Dee da t aet e a tv , 7 - ) hee fe, s e da t ' b ie n So e ' ) De ) u h, fn ns r h cie c cous and dom i ntf e be nd t pr oton,a ts m e ,diti i ofe i f ons i , na or es hi he om i dverie nt srbuton, f rng or s l a s l ofha ae, nd a e ndba ,wa lt,s ,boot,bet ,s r es s a s s wa c ,ca e f gs le s hoes s ls ca v , ungls e , t hes s s or te elphone ,pr t c i c r f pora e el toni devi s i l ng celphones c me is s o e tve ove s or tbl ecr c ce , ncudi l , os tc , a d c sl j wer i cudn n c lc s b a ees e ni g a d rng u i ta e r swh c n o tz e ly, n l ig e k a e , r c lt, a n s n i s sng rd mak ih me aee a tc piso t Cha e M aks(h d u tretGo d ' .( e nh Ame e Co an z x c o e f he n l r t e t n efi o s' S ve t co ) nd d mplit ! 7 5 ,717 ,7 - 8 9 - 4 s e as Ham De l ! 9 1 ,a d Dee a t'W e ie a d E! , 6 - 3 5 7 , 3 9 ; e lo l c. ! - 3 n fnd n s bsts n St es Deca aton of Erc Ros lr i Suppo tof Pl ntf s Ei h Ex Pare Applc ton f or ; lr i i ae n r ai if ght t i a i or Te ay Resr i ng Or r ( r fe ,dRos e De .' ( 1 1 t ough DE 1 - 91 mporr tani de heea tr t alr c1' DE 77- 2 hr ) 77 1 ; De l r ton of Kat ee Bur i Suppor of Pl ntf Ei h fx Par e Applcai n f r caai hl n ns n t ai ips ght t i to o Te ay Retai ng Or ( e fe, S ' De .' g 1 20 t o h DE 177241 mporr sr ni der hera tr f ns c1' DE 77- hr ug Bul ) - ; D e a a i of St phe M .G a tga i Suppor of Pl i if s Ei h Ex Par e A pplc ton f cl r ton e n fi n n t a ntf ght t i a i or Te o m' Re tanig Or e ( ee fe ,t fi a De l' ! 2 3 ( 1 7 2 t rug 1 7 2 2 mp r y sri n d r h r atr % fg n c .) ! , DE 7 - 5 h o h 7 - 8 ; Ga ' s e alo a c r outi ng t Regita a Adm i sr tve a Con a t i or ton i ntte e s ha t lni he sr nt nd nitai nd t c nf ma i de ii d o teW HOI d man rg sr to r c r sf rt Gr u VIIS b e tDo i Na satc e nh S o i e itai n e o d o he o p I u j c man me ta h d a Co o i Ex i t t t Gatg n De 1) s mp st hbiA o he f a c. e i Pli if rti Erc Ros e (é ae' ,a ofier ofAED l tgai ,I . a antf eaned i alr i lr' n fc Ros ) nvesi tons nc, lce e prvae i siatve fr a Kahlen Bur $ 's' a pa t rofAres Cli i ns d i t nve tg i im, nd t e ns(ç n ' Bul ) rne i ams Se vi es a lc ed prva e i tga i tr ,t i tga e t s pe t d s es of c m t f i r c , i ens i t nves i tve i m o nves i t he us c e al ot er e t Cha lbrnde pr t by t Deenda s ( Gafga De l ! 4;Ros l Dec.! 3;Bur ne a d oducs he f nt. See fi n c. aer l ns Ei h Applc ton frTemporr Re tai ng Or ( 1 and ae i oportd heen by ght iai o ay sr ni der DE 771 r nc ae ri r er ef ence. 6 De l ! 3.Ro ae a c se c mme ca Itr e we stso eai u d rc ran Gr u Vl1 c. ) s lr c e s d o r il n en t b i p r t n e eti o p 1 e ng S be tDo i Na s a dwe ttr ug t p r h sn pr c s4f rvaiu p o ucs mo to u j c man me , n n h o h he u c a ig o e s o ro s r d t, s f whihbo eco efiso ,a lat o oft Cha lM rksa is i t sa ton.( Roslr c r untret f t e s, ne he ne t sue n hi ci See ae De l ! 4 . Folwi s b sin o h so d r,Ro ae rc ie i o to fr fn l ig c. 1) lo ng u miso f i r es s lr e ev d nfnnain o iai n z pa ntf e c oft ie sor r d vi Pa la orba ta f t De e nt r peci yme or a h he t m de e a ypa nd/ nk r nser o f nda s' es tve Pa pa a d o ba ka c u t.f ) y l n /r n c o n s (#. Addii l Bum s a es e t f l i e a i co mer i e-t r s i ntfe on tonaly, , cc s d he uly nt r ctve m cal so e de i d Sc dul G ' he eo,a wentt ough t pur hasng pr es f va i pr he e W ' r t nd hr he c i oc s or rous oduct,m os of s t whih boe c e fisof a l s,oneoft Cha M aksa is i t saci ( eBur c r ountret , t eat he nel r t sue n hi ton. Se ns De l ! 4 a d Co Ex.A te eo. Fo lwig s b s in o he o d r,Bu n rc ie c. n mp. h rt ) lo n u miso f r r es r s e ev d i fr to f rfn lzn p y n f re c o t eie o d r dv aPa pa.1 n omai n o i aii g a me t o a h f h tms r e e i y l (d) Cha ' r pr e a i Adre nels e es nt tve i nne Hal Siba r a c s t c me ci I e ne m s ro, c es ed he om r al ntr t we sts b g d to .o dyta e 8c m,n c dita ec m,me j welr so e .o a d b ie a s oc mec m, i r d 8 .o ie yrd .o nse ley tr sc m, n hothopta c ,a ca ur d t ç ym e 'pa pr di t bn ta f ri or ton f s r de.om nd pt e he s pa nt' ges ovi ng he nk r nse nf ma i or fn l ig p y ns f rplc a e i e tf n te b n a c u t f re c we ie ( e Ha n iai n a me t o t h s s d niyig h a k c o n s o a h bst . Se h z r De l! 1 a dCo Ex. t eeo. c. 2 n mp. D h rt ) M s Ha Siba r r vi we a viualy i pec e De e . hn s ro e e d nd s l ns t d f ndant'W e ie a E- or , s bst s nd st es a wela pit esofie s be rng t Cha lM a ks ofe e f r s l by De enda svi t r s l s c ur tm a i he ne r f r d o ae f nt a hei Itr e we ie a d e so e o e aig u de t e Gr u VIIS b e tDo i Nn sa d Enen t bsts n -t rs p rtn n r h o p I u j c man me n St e ,a lkewiedeemi dt pr ct we enotge neCha lgoods ( eHn De .! ors nd i s tr ne he odu s r nui ne . Se bn cl 1 . 31) 4Ros l ri e tona l di notf na i e hi pur ha esf om t l e ne w e ies o r tng unde a e nt n i ly d i lz s c s r he nt r t bs t pe a i r t ermanngS b e t manNa ss a t a oi c nrb tn f d t Dee a t' o fr . h e ii u j c Do i me o s o v d o tiu ig un s o fnd ns c fes 7 On M a 23,201 Pl ntf fl d isEx Par eM oton f Le vet Fie Se t Ame y 3, ai if ie t t i or a o l ven h nded Co an a an t De e d n s 21 - 3 ( 1 0 smutn o l wi is Eih h Ex Pa t mplit g is fn a t 5 3 3 DE 7 ) i la e usy t t g t h re Ap iai n fr En r o Te o a y Re tanig Or r P ei n r Ij n to , a d Or e plc to o ty f mp r r sri n de, r l a y n u cin n d r mi Re tann Trn fro As es Tid t te Co ne fiig Op r t n.( 1 . On M a 3 s sr iig a se f s t e o h u tretn eai DE 712 o y 0 2 3 Plitf fld isNoieo S rkngDo k tEnr 1 ( 1 4)d t t Co r' Or e 01 , an if ie t tc f tii c e ty 71 DE 7 ue o he u ts d r G r ntng Pl ntf s M oton t A m e t Cour ' Or r G r ntng Sec a i ai if i o nd he t s de a i ond M oton f A le na e i or t r t Sevc o Pr c s ( 1 5 ,ha r q rdPlitf t s c r la ef ratr t s r iea t a y r ie f o e s DE 6 j t t e uie an if o e u e e v o lenae e vc s o n a tona de e nt bef e m a ng a i tonsf t mpor r r tai ng o de s a ns t e ddii l f nda s or ki pplcai or e a y esr ni r r gai t hos de e nt .On J 4,201 Pli iffl d isEx Pare M o i i Furhe Suppo tofPli tf s f nda s une 3, antf ie t t ton n t r r a n if M oton t A m e t Cour ' Or r Gr ntng Se i o nd he ts de a i cond M o i f A le t Ser c a ton or t nm e vi e nd Me a morndum ofLa i Suppor Therof( 1 ,whih t Co tgrntd ont tsmeda w n t e DE 75j c he ur a e ha a y. ( 1 61On J n 5 2 3 Plitf fldisEihh Ap iain f rTRO.( 1 7)OnAu u t DE 7 . u e , 01 , anif ie t g t pl to o c DE 7 . gs 8 2 35ti Co r g a td Plitf' Eih h Ap iain f rTRO g 1 0 , nds b e u n l , 01 , h s u t rn e anifs g t pl to o c DE 9 1 a u s q e ty c n re t etmp rr r sr ii go d rit aPrlmiayIj cino Au u t1 , 01 .( o ve td h e o ay e tan n r e no ei n r nun to n g s 9 2 3 DE 1 5)TheTe rr Re tanig Or e a d Pr l n r lj n to rq ie ,i trai ,P y l 9. mpo ay sri n d r n ei ay n u ci n e u rd ne la a pa mi t fe ze a la ount and t di r t a hol ng ac ount f t tus of t Cour a 1f nds o r e l cc s o ve t o di c or he r t he t 1 u c r nty i or whi h dzi t pende ure l n, c lrng he ncy of t Or r c e i t De e nt Pa l he de om n o, f nda s' ypa a ount.Pa cc s ypalc ompled wih t r r m e soft Cour' Or r a r tane t f i t he equie nt he ts de s nd esr i d he unds r aedt Dee elt o fndant,i udi a i ntfe amountof$90, 35. Se Deca ai ofStphe s ncl ng n de iid 937. ( e lr ton e n Gafi n i Su fga n ppor of Pl i if s Fourh M oton f r Ent y of Fi D ef t J dgm e t a ntf ' t i o r nal aul u nt ( rafe ,t fga De .n Suppor ofFourhFDJ' 6. hee tr çGafi n cli t t '! ) 5 Addii l , on A ugus 8, 201 t Co t e e ed a O r r Gr ntng Pl i if s Ex Par e tonaly t 3, he ur nt r n de a i a ntf ' t M oi frLea t Fie Pl ntf' Se nt Ame d Compli ( 188 ,a t Clr of ton o ve o l ai ifs ve h nde ant DE 1 nd he ek Co r e trd Plitf' S v nhAme d d Co litf rDn g sa d Ij n tveReifo te u t n ee anifs e e t n e mp an o ma e n nu ci le n h do tt tsmeday.( 1 1 cke ha a DE 89. 8 Puz ua t t Cour' Or r Cour ' Or Gr ntng Pl ntf Ex Pare M oton i s nt o he ts de ts der a i ai ips t i n Fu t r Suppor ofPli ifs M oto t Am e t Cou ts Or rGr i Sec M o i f rhe t antf ' in o nd he r ' de antng ond ton or Alen t Sevc ( 1 6 ,Pli tf s r e e c Dee d n wi a c p o terr s e t tr ae r ie DE 7 1 anif ev d a h fn a t t o y f h i e p ci h ve Summons a c e oft Co pl nt Fis ,Sec , nd opis he m ai , r t ond,Thid,Fourh,Fit Si h,a Se nt r t fh, xt nd ve h Ame d Compli s vi emal a or vi publcain s r ie on Augus 20,201 ( e nde ant a - i nd/ a i to e vc t 3. Se Gafi n De .i Suppo tof Fourh FDJ ! 7. Plitf fl t Pr s of Se vce as t fga cl n r t ) anif ied he oof ri o Def nt onAugus 23,201 ( 1 DE 1 1 enda s t 3. DE 97; 98. Pl ntf tld isRe s f Clr sEntyofDeful on Se emberl 201 ( 201. ai if ie t que t or ek' r at pt 7, 3. DE 1 On Se e r1 201 t Clr ofCou tpurua t Rul 55( oft FedealRulsofCi l ptmbe 8, 3,he ek r, s nt o e a) he r e vi Pr ed e,e e e de a ta i tDef nda s f r f itr t a ar pl a orot r s de e oc ur nt r d f ul gans e nt o a lle o ppe , e d, he wie f nd t sa to g 2 2)To d t,Dee d n sh v n ts u h t v c t te d futo oh r s hi cin. DE 0 . ae fn a t a e o o g t o a ae h ea l r te wie a a and def t s aci n.Pli ifnow m o t Cour t gr ntDe a t Fi lJ ppe r end hi to a ntf ves he to a f ul na udgm e t n a i tDe e nt. gans f nda s l. l LKGAL- I NDAR/ SIW Fe ea Ru eo Cii P o e u e 5 ( ()a t rz sa c r t e trad futj d me t d r l l f vl r c d r 5b)2 uho ie ou t o ne e a l u g n a ns a pr ry s r d de e nt who,lke Def ndant he e,f l t fl a tm e y r s gai t ope l e ve f nda , i e s r aied o ie i l e ponsve i pladi By s h a def ul,alofPl ntf welpld a l ato i t Compli a e de med e ng. uc a t 1 ai ips l- e leg i ns n he ant r e a ted.Se Buc dmit e hanan v Bowman,8 F. 359,361( 11 Ci.1 7) Pet dEx es I .v . 20 2d 1 11 r 98 ; me prs, nc . Mepot.om,33 F.Supp.2d 1 3, 1 7 ( D.Fl. 2004) I t a te fcs i t d sc 6 21 21 S. a . f he dmitd a t n he Co pl ntesa ih la lt t n t Cour mus de e mi a pr i e damag .W her a1 t m ai tbls ibiiy, he he t t t r ne p oprat es e 1 he e s ntale de e i on r cor a e de i r he r ng on dnm age i notr qui e Se SEC v s e i vi nc s e d, n vi nta y a i ss e r d. e . Smyt 420 F. 1 h, 3d 225, 1 n.1 (11h Ci.2005) (' e 55( ( s ks of e de ir 232 3 t r ' Rul b)2) pea vi ntay he rngs i a pe s i t ai n nui s ve one . . . W e ha hel t t no s ve d ha uch hea i i r qui e whe e a1 rng s e r d r 1 9 e sn ile ie c i ara o r c r ' (iain o te ) s e as Peme Ex e s 3 6 F. se ta vd n e s le dy f e o d.) ctto s mi d ; e lo t d pr s , 3 ' t S p .2 a 1 2 (ne ig d f ut u g n,pema e tij ci n a d sau o y d ma e i a u p d t 2 3 e trn e a lj d me t r n n nun to n ttt r a g s n La m Ac ca e wihouta he rng) I t s c e,a heai on dn s i unne sa y a nhn t s t ai . n hi as rng mage s ce sr s Pl ntf s e sa ut y da ai if e ks tt or mage a has s s nd ubmit d de al d deda ai wih ac ompanyi te t ie r tons t c ng doc e a y e de e i s um nt r vi nc n uppo tofisda a s r ue t r t m ge eq s . 11 1. A. LI BI TY A LI T r m ar l r nge e ade k nf i m nt Th alg t n i Plitf s S v nh Ame e Co an ,i c nu cin wi r c r e le ai s n an if e e t o nd d mplit n o j n to t e o d h e ie c ,s p o ta fn i o la ii a an tDee d ns f rta e r i fig me t 'T1 vd n e u p r idng f iblt g i s fn a t o r d mak nrn e n . ' o y g p e alo a ta e r ifi e n cam a p an ifmu td mo tae t a ( )i mak hm r v i n r d mak n rng me t li litf s e nsr t h t 1 t r s s prort ( de e ntus d ismaki c i iy; 2) f nda e t r n omme c ( t c e ) a ( dee ntsmaki r e wihout onsnt; nd 3) fnda ' r s lkel t c us cons rco uson. Pet d Ex es,336 F.Supp.2d a 1 1 (ii I 1 i y o a e ume nf i ' me pr s ' t 217- 8 ctng nt Co meisExc I v Ga di He t & Beaut l . 303 F. 1 ( 1h Ci.2002)a s tc k, nc. . par s a1h y nc, 3d 243 1 t r nd Fr hlng Entn,I .v 1 1Selc Gr p,I . 1 F. 1 ( 1h Ci.1999).Pli ifha e i e nc . nt e t ou nc, 92 3d 330 1 t r ) antf s etbls ea h oft s ee nt bec us ( ) Pli ifs ownes p a rgitain of t sa ihed c he e lme s a e: 1 antf rhi nd e sr to he ta e r sa is ep e e eDee d n s i rn i c n u t( v nh Ame d d Co lit!6 rd mak t su rc d fn a t' nfigng o d c Se e t n e mp an 2; Ha nDe l!4 ; 2 De e d n sa v rie ,o fr df rsl a do s l g o sb a igPlitf s h c . ) ( ) fn a t d e tsd fee o ae n /r od o d e rn anif mak i i esaec mmec wi o tPlitf' c n e t( e e t Ame d d Co lit!71 s e r s n ntrtt o re t u anif o s n S v n h h s n e mp an ;e as Ha nDe l! 9 1 a d Co o i Ex i i C atc e te eo ( 1 7 1 1 RoslrDe l! lo h c . ! - 3 n mp st h bt ta h d h rt DE 7 - 0 ; ae c.( e 4 and Compost Exhi tA t r t Bur De . Compost Exli tA t r t s ege r l ie bi he eo; ns cl and ie lbi he eo; e ne al y Dee nt'W e ie a E- or atc asCo fnda s bsts nd st es ta hed mpost Exhi tB t t HahnDe l) a ( ie bi o he c.; nd 3) t ma ksus d on t goodsDe e nt a rie ofer d f rs l a / s d a e s smia t he r e he f nda s dve ts d, f e o ae nd or ol r o i l r o Plitf smak t tc n u rc nf so i lk l ( v nh Ame d d Co lit! 5 ,71 7 , an if r s ha o s me o u i n s iey. Se e t n e mp an ! 9 , 2 10 7 ) s eas Ha n De l ! 9 1 a d Co st ExhbtC atc e t t eHam De l;Ro ae 9 ; e lo h c. ! - 3 n mpo i e ii t h d o h l c. s lr a De l ! 4 a d Co st Ex i tA te eo;Bu n De l ! 4 a d Co ost ExhbtA t eeo c. n mpo ie hbi h rt r s c. n mp ie ii h rt ; s ege r l De e nt W e ie a E- or satac as Co post Exhi tB t t Hahn e ne al y f nda s' bst s nd st e t hed m ie bi o he Dec. l) B. Fal e D e i i ofO r gi s s gnat on i n Plitf alg sf led sg ai no o ii un e j4 ()o teLa h m Ad,1 U. C. anif le e as e in to f rgn d r 3 a f h n a 5 S. j 1 2 () Th ts cin p o ie a f lo : 1 5 a. a e to r vd s s o lws Any pe s who,on ori cor c i wih a goodsors r i e ,orany c ane r on n me ton t ny e vc s ont i r f goods us i c or , es n omm e c a wor t r ,name,s r e ny d, e m ymbol o de c or a , r vie, ny co bi ton t r of or a f l e des g t o of or gi f l e or m i l a ng m na i he e , ny a s i na i n i n, a s s e di des rpton off t o f leorm iladi r pr s nt i off c ,whihci i ac , r a s se ng e e e aton a t c ( i lkel t c us conf i ort ca emit ,ort de ei ast t A) s i y o a e uson, o us sake o c ve o he a f laton,co c i or a s i i of s h pe s w ih a herpe s f ii i nne ton, s oc aton uc r on t not r on, or a t t o i n,s s o he r gi pons s p,or a o lof hi or he goods s r c s or hi ppr va s r , e vi es orc m e ci a tvii by a he per on, om r al c i tes not r s or ( i c B) n ommeca ad rii or pr i mirpr ens t natr ril ve tsng omoton, se es t he tze, c r c e itcs quaii s or ge a c orgi of hi or he or anot r ha a t rsi , lte , ogr phi i n s r he pe s sgoods s r i es o c r on' , e v c , r omm e c a a tvii s s l be la e i a c vi r i l c i te , hal i bl n i l a i by any pe s w ho be i ve t t he or s i or i lkel t be cton r on le s ha he s s i y o da a d by s h a t m ge uc c . 1 U. C. 1 25a () 5 S. j 1 () 1. The s m e s t of f t alwig Plitf t prv i u d r j 1 1 ( )a wilr s l i n e ac s lo n an if o e al n e 1 4 1() l eut n rc v r u d r j 1 25 S e Bab i Elc . 3 F.d a 1 81 ( 1h Ci.1 9 )(iig Ma a h n eo ey n e 1 .e bt e s, 8 3 t 1 1 t r 9 4 ctn rto Mf Co v En ri Pr d .Cop. 7 7 F.d 21 ,21 ( t Ci.1 8 );s e as Cl io I c v g. . . e lt o s r , 6 2 4 7 5h r 9 5 ) e lo ar l n . . e Sa - y I . I ,21 U. P. ve Wa ndus, nc. 0 S. Q.459,469 7 ( D.Fl 980) d-hi i be aus Seci - 0 S. a.1 . t- s s c e ton l 11 a i br rt n Se ton 111 i t i c r flea rii orde ci i whehe or 25() s oade ha ci 4 n hat t ove s as dve tsng s rpton t r no i i vesta maki rnge nt'BabbiElc . 38F.d a 11 1(ii Siv r t Entr , t t nvol rde r nfi me . ' t e s, 3 t 8 ctng le sar es. I .v Ada 537F.Supp. ( D. Y.1 2). wihta maki rnge ntcams t t t nc . y, 236 S. N. 98 ) As t rde r nfi me li ,he es 11 f rla ii f rf led sg to o o ii u d rj43a i as ç te tepu lci lk l t b o iblt o as e inain f rgn n e y () s lo t h r h bi s iey o e whe de i d orc u e by t smia iy oft m a ksa is .'Fwt Pe os l v. Taco Cabana, ceve onf s d he i lrt he r t s ue' ? s , nc . I c, 0 U. 76 78 , 1 2 S.Ct 2 5 , 7 3( 9 2 . As d s u s d a o e Plitf h s n .5 5 S. 3, 0 1 . 7 3 6 19 ) ic se b v , an if a s fce l s wn t r i a sr lke i ufi inty ho he e s tong i lhood of c u i t ta ie be a e oft us by onf son ha rs s c us he e Dee da t ofte Ch n lMa k .Th s Plitf i e tte t d ful j d me ton is fle f n ns h a e r s u , an if s n ild o e a t u g n t as de i to ofo i n cl i . s gna i n r gi a m C. C ybe s t i r qua tng The Antc rqua t Co ume Pr e ton Ac (W CPA', 1 U. C.j 11 ( , iybe s ti ng ns r otci t; ' 5 S. ) 25d) i mpos s la lt upon a peron f t ba f ih i e t pr i fo a pr t t ma k by e i biiy s or he d at ntnt o oft r m o eced r r i t rng o us ng a dom a n na e t t i i ntca o c usngl sm ia ,or diutve of t t eg s e i r i i m ha s de i l r onf i y i l r l i , ha mak.Pet dEx e s 336 F.Supp.2d a 1 1 Topr i unde 1 U. C.j1125( ,Pli if z me pr s , t 2 8. eval r 5 S. d) antf mus d mo taet a ç 1 ismak i d sicie o fmo sa e tte t p oe t n;( )t e t e nsrt h t ç ) t r s itn tv r a u nd n ild o r tci 2 h ( o Dee ntsdomannamei i ntc orc u i y smiart t Pli ifsmak;a ()t fnda ' i s de ial onf sngl i l o he antf r nd 3 he De e ntr se ed orus t do an nn e wih aba f ih i e t pr k. Bav o Pal , f nda egit r ed he m i m t d at nt nt o ot ' ar ' ace S. v Vac i Tour,I . 203 Fed.App' 25 25 ( 1h Ci.2006) n t sca e t wel A. . aton s nc, x. 2, 6 1 t r .I hi s , he lpld al gai demonsr t Pl i ifs M a ks a e ditnci a f m ous t t t i rngi e le tons tae antf r r si tve nd n , ha he nfi ng doman nn i mesa econf i y sm ia ,a t tDe e nt r git r d t c r quatng do an r usngl i l r nd ha f nda s e se e he ybe s ti m i na mes wih t ba f ih i e t pr t he d-a t nt nt o oft fom t m . As s h, Def ndan s a e la e f r he uc e t r i bl or c bes uatngt r15U. C.j 11 d) y rq ti mde S. 25( . D. C om m on Law U nf r Com pet ton ai ii W he he a de e n ' us oft pli ifsta t r f nda ts e he a ntf r dema ksc e t a lke i r r a ed i lhood ofc u i onf son be wee pl ntf and de e nts pr t i as t de e mi ng f t r i t a l i of t n ai ips f nda ' oduc s s lo he t r ni ac o n he na yss unf i c pe ii unde t com m o 1 ofFl i Rol x Wat h U S. ,I v.For e t r N o. a r om tton r he n aw or da. e c A. nc. r se , 12 8 -8 81- v Pane 1 8 W L 1 6 8 a * ( D. a De . 98 )(-h a p o raets f r 3 3 -Ci- i , 9 6 5 6 , t 3 S. Fl. c 9,1 7 tf e p r p it et o t' de e mi ng whehe t r i a lke i t r ni t r he e s i lhood ofc uson,a t tade k i rnge e , f s onf i nd hus r mar nf i m nt al e de i ton of o i n,a unf i c m pe ii unde t c mon 1 w ofFl i i s tf t i sgnai rgi nd ar o tton r he om a orda, s e orh n JohnH Haran4 I .v.Cl k Che k ,I . 71lF.d 966,97 ( 1h Ci.1 ))Pli ifha l nc ar e c' nc, s 2 2 1 t r 983.' antf s e t bls t e i a lkelhood ofc uso r r ng De e nt 'us oft Cha lM a kso sa ihed her s i i onf i n ega di f nda s e he ne r n t i countrei a i rngi pr her e f t nd nfi ng oducs Ac or ngl Pl i ifhas s e d on t m e is of t. c di y, antf ucc ede he rt is c m on 1 w unf i c pe ii cl i . t om a a r om tton a m I V. I NJUN C TI E R ELI V EF Plitf i e tte t t er q e tdij n tv rle p ts n t 1 U. C.j1 1 a d 1 anif s n ild o h e u se n u cie eif t ua t o 5 S. r 16 n 7 U. C.j 5 2. A panifs e i a p r n ntij ncin mus d mo srt ta ( ) i h s S. 0 li tf e kng ema e nu to t e n tae h t 1 t a s fee a irp r beij r ;( )rme isa lw, u h a mo ea yd ma e , r i a e u t t u frd n re a a l n u y 2 e d e t a s c s n tr a g s a e n d q ae o c mp n ae f r t a ij r ; ( ) c n iei t b ln e o had hi b t e plitf a d o e s t o h t n u y 3 o sd rng he aa c f r s p ewe n an if n defnda t a rme i e t i warntd; a ( t tt publc i ee twoul no be e n , e dy n quiy s ra e nd 4) ha he i ntrs d t d se v d b ap r n ntij n to Se e y I c v M e c c a ge LLC, 4 U..3 8 3 is r e y e ma e nu cin. e Ba , n . . r Ex h n , 5 7 S 8 , 91 ( 2006) . He e t welpld ale tons a r or e de r , he l- e l gai nd ec d vi nce de onsr t t Pl ntf ha m ta e hat ai if s de l veoped goodwilamong t c umi publcwhih woul be unde m i i De e nt a e l he ons ng i c d r ned f f nda s r no pr bie fom f t ri rnge e .De e ant comt re tpr t ohi t d r urhe nfi m nt f nd s' t e f i oducswilc e t ir pa a e t l r ae re r bl ha m a c u i pa tc a l bec us t c eret pr t be r i ntc l ma ki as r nd onf son, ri ulry a e he ount f i oduc s a de i a r ngs Pl i if s genui m e cha s a a e not m a ac ur t Cha l s qua iy s a a ntf ne r ndi e, nd r nuf t ed o ne ' lt t ndar . ds Furhe m or ,D e e nt wil uly i rng t Chane M a ks a c i t r e f nda s lf l nf i ed he l r nd ontnued t do s eve a t r o o n fe s r i e of t Co pl nt i t s m a t r upon t m . Suc w il ul c e vc he m ai s n hi te he h lf onduc de onsr es a t m tat lke i i lhood t tDef nda s woul c i t ha m Pl ntf st a m a ks i t Co tde i t ha e nt d ontnue o r ai i f r de r f he ur clned o 13 is e a ij n to Peme Ex e s 3 6 F.u p.2d 1 2223 (ne ig p r n n ij n to su n n u cin. t d pr s , 3 s p 2 - e trn e ma e t nu cin u d r1 U.. j 1 1 t p e n f rhe i rn e n o f d r l - r tce ta e r s. n e 5 SC. 1 6 o rve t u t r nfi g me t f e eal p o e td rd mak ) y V. A. D A M A G ES St t or Dam agesf t U s ofC ount r e tM ar a ut y or he e efi ks l a ca e i vi t us o c n s nvol ng he e f ount r e t m a ks i c e f i r n onnec i w ih a s l ,of e i f ton t a e f rng or s l, rdsrb to ofg o s 1 U. C. 1 1 ()p o i e ta apanifma ee ta a r o ae o itiu in o d , 5 S. j 1 7 c r v d s h t litf y lc n wad f sau o y d ma e a a t b f r tna j g n i rn e e i te s m o n tls t a ttt r a g s t ny i e o e i l ud me t s e d rd n h u f o e s h n me $1000. a notmor t n $200, 00 pe countrei m a k pert ofgood. I a ton,i , 00 nd e ha 000. r ef t r ype n ddii f t Cour fnds t t De e nts c e f tng a tons we e wilul i may i pos da a s he ti ha f nda ' ount reii c i r lf , t m e m ge a ve t ma mum lmi up t $ 000, 00 pe mak pe t of good. 1 U. C.j bo he xi i t o 2, 000. r r r ype 5 S. 111 c( .A sat or da geawa di a opraei ac ewheet dee nthasdef t 7()2) t ut y ma r s ppr it n as r he fnda auled. Se Pet d Ex es,336 F. e me pr s supp 2d a 1 9t 21 22. Purua t 1 U. C.j 111 c) Pl ntf s nt o 5 S. 7( , ai if e e t t r cove a aw a d of s a ut y da a s as t Count I of t Se nt Am e d lc s o e r n r t t or m ge o he ve h nde Com pl i . a nt TheCour haswi dicrtont s ta n t de s ei o e n mountofsaut ydn ges f at1 9( tng tt or ma . #. 21 cii Cabl/ eHome Commc' Cor n p.v.Newor Pr l . 902 F. 829, 85 ( t Ci. 1 ) t k od, nc, 2d 2 11h r 990 (oncl ng t tt c tsdic ein i sti t n c udi ha he our' sr to n etng he mountof c ihtda ges i l de, opyrg ma s ç wi c tai donl byt s cfe ma maa mi mal) onsr ne y he pe iid xi nd ni ' .Congr se ce asaut yda ges es na td tt or ma r medy i ta m a k c e f ii ca e ,be us e de e of a de enda ' pr is i s h e n r de r ount retng s s ca e vi nc f nts oft n uc c es i al t i sbl t a c ran. Se eg. S.REP.NO. 1 1 pt V( ( 995) as s mos mposi e o s e ti e ., 04- 77, . 7) 1 ( s usi pur es ofLa m Ac saut y da es) Thi c s i no e e i Si e dic sng pos nha t tt or mag .. s a e s xc pton. nc Def nt ha r us t pa tc pa e i t s ltga i Pl i ifha bee de i d oft a lt enda s ve ef ed o r i i t n hi ii ton, a ntf s n pr ve he biiy t obt n di c r f om t m . o ai s ove y r he 1 4 l t s ca e Pl i if i entte t a sat or a r of $6, 00 pe Cha l M a k n hi s , antf s ild o t ut y wa d 000. r ne r c u tretd ( 0 p rt p o g o s d ( 5 -h nd g ,walt,s e ,b o s b ls s a v s o n efie 2 ) e y e f o ds ol 1 a ba s les ho s o t, et, c r e , Sm gls es Wa c , c es f r t l phone , pr e tve cove s f pora e eecr c de c , l a s , t hes as o e e s ot c i r or tbl l toni vi es icu n c l p on s c s t s a d c t mej wer ,icu i n c a e ,b a ees e rig n ldig el h e , o mei , n osu e ly n ldng e klc s r c lt, arn s c a rngs.Thust Cour s la r $1800, 00i saut ydamage purua t 1 U. C. nd i ) he t hal wa d , 000. n tt or s s nt o 5 S. j 11l . 76 B. St ut y D am age f Cybe s at or s or r quat i t ng Pl ntf a s s ksdn a f rvi ai oft Antc r quatng Cons e Pr e i ai if lo ee m ges o ol ton he iybe s ti um r otcton Upon a fndi oflabiiy fr c rquatng purua t 1 U. C.j 11 d)1,dhe i ng i lt o ybes ti s nt o 5 S. 25( () t t p anifma ee t a a y tmeb fr fn l ud me ti rn e e b t etilc u tt rc v r litf y lc , t n i eo e i a j g n s e d rd y h ra o r, o e o e, i t a ofa t lda es a pr ks a a r ofsa ut y da nse d c ua mag nd ot , n wa d tt or mage i t a o tofnotl s s n he m un es ta $10 0 a d n tmo e ta $1 00 0 p rd man n me a t e c u tc n iesj s. 1 h n ,0 n o r h n 0 ,0 e o i a , s h o r o sd r u t' 5 ' U. C.j 11 d . S. 17() He e,Pl i if s ks sa ut r da a i t a o t of $1 000. f e c of t r antf ee tt o y m ges n he m un 0, 00 or a h he t n y f r ( 4 d man n me voltn t p ovso s o 1 U. C.l 25d ( ) fr a ttl we t-ou 2 ) o i a s i aig he r iin f 5 S. 1 ( )1 o oa a r o $ 4 0 0.0 De e d n s r gsrto o t e l rn i S b e tDo i Na s i i wad f 2 0,0 0 . fn a t' e itain f h nfigng u j c man me ? s n b d fiha dv oae 1 U. C.j 1 2 ( ) ( e nh Ame e Co lit! 8 ,1 7) l viw a at n i lts 5 S. 1 5 d . S ve t nd d mp an ! 0 0 . n e of De e nt i en i l wr ul c f nda s' nt tona, ongf onduc , t Cour fnds t t Pl i ifs r s i t he t i ha antf eque t s r a ona e.See Tave na Opa Tr mar Cor v I mai,Ca e N o.08e s bl r ade k p. . s l s 20776- V,201 W L C1 0 1 83838 a *3 ( D.Fl.M a 6,201 (wadi $1 000. i saut y da ge f do i 4, t S. a y 0) a r ng 0, 00 n tt or ma s or man na a is ) Thus t Cour s l a r Pl ntf $ 000. i saut ydn spurua me t sue . ,he t hal wad ai if 240, 00 n tt or mage s nt t 1 U. C.j 111 d) o 5 S. 7( . 6 I de e m i ng t a oprat dam age aw a d, t Cour al o c i r d t de o ta e s r he n t r ni he ppr i e t s ons de e he m nsr t d w ilul s ofD ef nda s i rnge e . lf nes e nt ' nf i m nt 7 eI fi igSu jc Do i Nn sa eie tfe o S h d l $ ' e eo Th n rngn be t man me r d niid n c e ue i h rt . B' 15 Vl . C O N CLU SI N O Fo t r s ns sa e a r he ea o t t d bove, ti he eby i s r O RDERED TH AT Plitf sF u t Mo in f rEnr o Fia De a l J g n g 2 7 i GRANTED. an if o rh to o ty f n l fut ud me t DE 0 1 s The Cour s l c t hal oncure l e e Fi De a t J r nty nt r nal f ul udgme a i t De enda s i ntfed on nt gans f nt de ii Sc dul t ' he e o. he e $ ' r t A D ONE AN D O RDERED i M i i Fl i ,t s M d yo n am , orda hi J/ a f - , 201 4. PATRI A A . TZ CI SEI UNI TED STA TES DI STRI J CT UDGE c c: Al Couns lofRec d l e or 16 SCH ED U LE $A ' $ ' D EFEN DA N TS BY N U M BER A ND GROUP Vl lSUBJECT DOM AI NAM ES AND EI N STORES Dee nt Dee n / b e tDoma nNa e fnda fnda tsu j c i m N um be r and E - ore st 12 3 me j welr so e .o nse ley t rsc m 1 55 21 5 216 21 7 218 21 9 i gogos hoppi co ng. m c nel l ta e ho c ha oute s l s p.om 4yo t e. usyl com 93ba c b. om a a 4u.om a bags c ba dot om e.om gs c c 20 2 bi u c a e.r j x h n lo g o 221 222 223 224 224 224 224 225 225 225 226 227 228 229 229 229 230 231 232 232 233 234 234 235 236 237 di . om y7l c bi anglu. s i com c ne ba ukm a lco ha l gs l. m c hane cas i l pbag.om l l scta c c ne c . ha l om com c haneha l ndba zol c gs 3.om c a ha l ale .om he pc ne w l tc c ne s . g ha l ac or chanel acs s pascher. org l s cs ha . om es a c nelc c pbr ndsor a ec hea a f s l .om c apc nel al or he ha bags e. g c pc na ho ng. om hea hi s ppi c c pg a r de. t hea r ndta ne ya m as co l hop. m ya ta ne nna r de. t c a a he pm xzol com 3. ouya r m alzol3. om tade l c di r de c yta 88.om ni edi r . om c ytade c ec s go- hoppi c ng.om ef t c o o88.om f us ng. om oc hopi c e r de g. om t a ba c e obr ur ands c .c he l ha l gs 3. om loc ne ba zol c De e n De e nts j c Do i Na f nda t fnda / ub e t man me N um ber 238 239 240 241 242 242 243 244 245 246 247 248 248 249 25 0 25 0 250 25 0 25 0 250 250 250 251 252 253 253 254 255 255 255 and E- or st e hotho r de. om s pt a c ki pumpscom ki . l s it e t s . m ouivutonr dbotom hoesco l oui com vl s. m a ke r bagscom . buyzs com hop. m uc g.om hba c myc neba .om ha l gsc ve y-r co r tade. m pur t es. s yl com s e t gsne elc ba . t s di pl ycn. om hoes s a c whol s l r xpor . om e aee tc s of e zoo8. om ol f r c fanc m a que. om r e- r c t bolos hane .nf he s c li o t bor e hane .nf he s c li o t l s tonbol os c he ouivuit s . om uhr a ke . om enm r nl c vuit nbor eonlne c to s i . om bo i f anc com utques r e. s cs nel i s or a cha boutque . g t a 778.om r de c ukc ne ba - t e .om ha l gs ou l tc ta s asde8. m r de e i co vi pvog i e c uelf . om whol a e m ake . om es l s ups c f hi e e 36s. om as onc nt r c m als ock. z l t bi malsock.o lt c 25 5 whoe aej r n s o sc m lsl-o da sh e .o 256 256 e gg. o bba c e bbaggsc .om 25 6 j sia ba .o e sc s gc m 257 258 25 9 ess i zgr com ental oup. d i a rcom w nf i . nns e. t al ne 18 De e a Dee n / b e tDo i Na fnd nt fnda tsu j c man me N um ber 260 261 261 262 262 262 262 262 263 264 265 266 267 268 269 270 271 272 273 274 275 276 277 278 279 280 281 28 2 28 3 28 4 285 28 6 287 288 289 290 291 and E- or st e s il a tc tlc r . om be te ia gs i c sr plc ba onlne.om r plc bag al com e i a ons e. cha l . ne zuscom cha 4uscom nel . c ne l om . om ha lc c xcha ba . om nel gs c xcha l s . ne pur escom c ompr r s c a bolos hane . lcom ha ba c c nd gs hn.om ha ndba -sor .om gs- t ec s a pec ne . m c r ha lco qs vbzol xc o c a t el he ps or 68 wi n201 0 s a ke 51 tl r 9 kulde i hk353 r yba a nzol1 t a1 ongf 23 xi 2005 xi gr a s l e t el vigi a u r ni f yy bo ne e y w ba maz n he 1 2011 ove l kday uc f li a hi a lnf s on ho s us ne s ne b i s a i s onis sc t uka t ger i cheer s good w i h s g uc oodl kzoll dongl ngzol a o rngaao8 i lke e nti i l ga lve s r e lr upe s le sl8 - - - 19 De e n De e nts j c Do i Na f nda t fnda / ub e t man me Num be r 292 293 294 295 296 297 298 299 300 301 302 303 and E- or st e f hi as on888 he o r num b pa l s le ypa - e l r whol a e i es l 7s a s tr lkks yl 961 l t e 88 fags pzol1 l hi yu= 5588558 vi ky- pl c a e c pa om ny hui ngl hua 88 34 0 yja i s e iixng h ng 305 xi ongm a 8 osl 36 0 bejn iig 307 308 309 31 0 311 31 2 31 3 31 4 315 31 6 31 7 31 8 31 9 320 321 322 323 324 325 3 26 327 328 xue 988 hui l l dog ove y a g uc mi oodl k kat hunsl ious 8 yahoo g e t r a sl r ad e m o iove yhome l m o guabaobe ude i i r hengde ens yi denni zol s o s rs um i e ls 988 ihi bi n1 nbi 25 m ebi i n668998 e dhar dy xi yi ha a z n698 yi nwanl be i ma 1 1 6889 gr a de e t al lngf i engl g vi 88 vi m aot ou 20 De e a De e n / ub e tDo i Na f nd nt f nda ts j c man me N um be r 329 a E- or nd st e z1e 1 2255188 30 3 e j y a s 88 no b g 8 331 332 333 gongxi a ai f c ool guolc ngzol i he o ga ha r n88 os ng e 21 SCHEDULE çB' i ' I NFRI NG SUBJECT DO M AI NAM ES NGI N Def ndant e N um ber D om a n Nam e i 215 c nel l tals c ha oute s e hop.om 20 2 bj u c n lo g io x ha e.r 223 224 224 224 224 225 225 225 227 237 244 250 250 250 252 26 2 26 2 26 2 26 2 262 263 266 c nel gs al.om ha ba ukm lc c ne c a s cl pba c ha l l s i ta g.om c hane com . m l co c hanehand gs 3.om l ba zol c c pc newa ltc hea ha l le .om c ne s c. r ha l a o g c hane s cs c ror l a pas he . g l s cs hane . om es a c lc c a ha bags e. g he pc nel al or he l ha l gs 3. loc ne ba zol com m yc hanebagscom l . t bol os ha li o he s c ne .nf t bor ec ne .nf he s ha li o s c c nel i . g a s ha boutquesor ukc nebagsoute .om ha l - ltc c nezusc ha l .om c nel .om ha 4usc c nelco .om ha l m c xc nel gs c ha ba . om xcha pur e . om nel s s c com pr r s c ne . om a bolos ha lc s a pec c r hane . lcom
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
