Westchester Fire Insurance Company v. Mid-Continent Casualty Company, No. 1:2012cv21758 - Document 38 (S.D. Fla. 2013)
Court Description: ORDER denying 18 Motion for Summary Judgment. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 1/25/2013. (tkn)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Westchester Fire Insurance Company v. Mid-Continent Casualty Company Doc. 38 UNI TED STATES DI STRI COURT FOR THE CT SOUTHERN DI STRI OF FLORI CT DA M i miDi son a vii Cas Num be 1 21 CI M ORENO e r: 2- 758- VW ESTCHESTER FIk I IE NSURANCE C0. , Pl ntf , ai if VS. M I CONTI DNENT CASUALTY CO. , D e e nt f nda . O RDER DENYI M OTI FO R SUM M ARY JUDGM ENT NG ON THI CAUSE c be or t Cour uponPl ntf W e t hese r I ur nceCo.sM o i S mne f e he t ai if sc t rFie ns a ' ton f SummayJ or r udgment( E.No.1 , e onNnve r8. 2.Pli ifW e these fldt s D. 8)fld mbe 201 antf sc tr ie hi moinf r u r u g n, o tn i ta Dee d n M i co tn nt s at Co vo ae is to o s mma yj d me tc n e dng h t fn a t d- n ie Cau l . iltd t y du y ofgoo f t b f ii t r ac a s te nti a unde l ng l ui. Fort f l ng t d aih y a lng o e h etlme n n ryi aws t he olowi r as ,heCou tfndst tage neis ofmatra f c e ssr a di t r s e ons t r i ha nui s ue e i l a t xit eg r ng he ea onablnes of e s a opporuniy M i contnentha t s tl i t unde l ng a i Cons que l t Cour ny t t di d o ete n he ryi cton. e nty, he t d n e W e th se ' moin frs mmmyj d me t e is sc e trs to o u u g n. 1 FACTUAL BACK GRO UND . OnM a 1 , 0 3 J s sPild s fee mutpeij re whi o e ai gac n r t y 9 2 0 , e u l o u fr d lil nu is l p rtn o cee a e mi rtu k m a a t e a s d b Contne alM a a urng,l xe r c nuf c ur d nd ol y i nt nuf ct i nc.Ac r ng t Pildo,he co di o la t tuc sai ho ra s mbl dr d on hi whe hea tm pt t l we i a trt a s m bl ha r k' r ppe s e y oppe m n te ed o o r t fe he s e y d be omewe d i t uprg poston.Asar ul oft ac i nt Pil s f r s r l c dge n he i ht ii es t he c de , lado ufe ed eve a ij re i ldn b and ma ea dfa tr dv re r e P l d s s q e tyfldap o u t nu is ncu ig r i a g n r cu e e tb a . il o ub e u nl ie r d cs a Dockets.Justia.com la lt s ta i tContne a on J nua y 1 2006 i M im iDa Count Fl i ibiiy ui ga ns i ntl a z 2, n n - de y, orda. Durngt stme, i nt lhad aprm a y i ur nc polc of$1m ilon is d by i hi i Contne a i r ns a e iy li s ue De e ntM i contne . I addii Contne alpos es e an u br lai u anc polc fo f nda di nt n ton, i nt s sd m e l ns r e iy r m Pl ntf W e t hese wih a$5m ilon lmi.W esc se ' 'mbr l polc sood i e s t ai if sc t r t li i t the trs l ela i y t n xce s o M i contne ' prm a ypolc c i c ran da a a occ r nce . d- i nts i r iy, overng e ti m ges nd ure s l t e ui ltgai n,M i contnentpr ded ade e e f rCo i al Prort ti l n he ns ng ii to d- i ovi f ns o ntnent . i o ra , Pla op e e tda e o o cls e c e n $1milo M i - ni n ' camsa j se, ild rs ne n c n mi o s x e dig lin. d co t ts li du tr ne Al i St ve ,wasawa ea t stm et aver c i f vorofPildo ç oul ' xc d t yc a e ns r t hi i hat dit n a la ç d'e ee he c c mp n sp lc l t et ten tr o teij re a de o o cd ma e alg d Se o a y' o iy i du o h au e f h nu is n c n mi a g s l e . e mi e De sSttme t Un ip tdM ae il cs! 1 . f' ae n of d s u e tra Fa t 8 Ac r ngl on f rocc sonsi t mont l a ng u t til W e the t rr quese co di y, ou a i n he hs e di p o ra , sc se e t d M i co i ntt s tl wih Pil a lcai swihi M i contne ' $1m ilon polc lm i. d- ntne o ete t lado 1 l m t n d- i nts li iy i t W esche t re n ofe e t c rbut a n ountfom islye ofcove a t t s tl me i t se ve fr d o onti e n m r t a r r ge o he ete nt f M i contnentma a$1milon ofe .Ne rhees ,M i contne ne rofe e Pil m or d- i de li f r ve t l s d- i nt ve f r d lado e t $1 000t s tl hi c am . l t d,M i contne chos t r l o t a c ofisown han 50, o e te s l i nsea d- i nt e o ey n he dvi e t co e t tt c ewasç e i e'wih t potntaloflabiiy ç uns l ha he as ç nsbl ' t he e i def i lt ç doubt' a d s e ' f nd iput d-' ul Gr a Ame ia I u a e Com pa esSui Appr hi Tra Re t a 23.I f c ,de e e et rc n ns r nc ni t oac ng il por, t n a t f ns co e c l uns l oncuded: I i ourbe ift tt r i a70% c ts le ha he e s hanc ofadef ns ve diti t sm a tr e e e r c n hi te a on t 3 tm e ou of 1 t tt pl i tf m a o a n a ve di t w e an i pa e a nd he i s t 0 ha he a n if y bt i r c, tci t s t nta amot ofc pa a i neglge wilbeas e s a i tt ubsa i l mt om r tve i nce l s s ed ga ns he pl ntf ai if Consdei pli ifsc es(ijani pae postonofla lt a i rng antf ouns l sc tci td ii ibiiy nd da ges webeivet s tlme rng oft scam i $1 000-$350, (n ma , le he ete nt a e hi li s 50, 000 i lghtoft stlmen oft wor rsc i he ete t he ke ' ompe ai le ) a lke s wih ns ton in , nd, i wie t r s c t t s tl me oft wor rsc e pe t o he e te nt he ke ' ompens to le t ne ve di t ai n in, he t r c e tr on t scli i i t r ngeofze oxposle hi am s n he a r $650, 000. I a 2 - 5 Dee ec u s l loc n u tdamo ktil h trs le i tno s v n e njt r d t 4 2 . fns o n e as o d ce c ra t a e utd n e f e e te t o s r fndi no la lt on t pa tofM i contne . Uli a ey,c i ng ibiiy he r d- i nt tm t l ouns lc i r t sc e t be e onsde ed hi as o , ç fo t emo t at . . nal rn ti g' farwihar s l o et e z r o f l l blt s j r h s p z, . a 1 o oh n 'afi t e ut f ih r eo r ' l i i y l u a i d p ndn u n wh m t ej r b l v d l lg t ft e efn i g , i - nt e t o mu ae is e e ig po o h uy ei e . n ih o h s d n s M d co i n f r ltd t e n $1 000s tlm e ofe . 50, e te nt f r Afe tilha c me d,Pil ma a a tmptt s tl wih M i co i ntf $1 tr ra d om nce lado de n te o e te t d- ntne or milon.Core pondi y,W e t hese r ie a e isde a f M i contne t s tl a li rs ngl sc tr et r t d t m nds or d- i nt o e te t s r lpoi sdu i t til Att e o t ti lsfr twe k, ud M i hae Ge n ad s d eve a nt rng he ra . he nd f he ra ' is e J ge c l nde vi e tep rista h b l v dtec s wa ç 5 - 0s i'o la ii , u i tej r b le e h a t h t e ei e h a e s ç 0 5 pl ' n iblt b t f h u y eiv d e e a t y Pil do,i éc d r s ti am ulimilo dola ve dit' Pos- i lRe t a 2-3. la t soul e ul n t- li n lr r c .' tTra por, t Ad i o al aj rrwh wa e c e d rn t ec u s o t etilidc tdt d fns c u s l dt n l u o o s x usd u ig h o re f h ra n iae o ee e o n e i y, t ts ha be n pr pa e t fnd i f vorofPildo.M i contne none hees r f s d t ha he d e e r d o i n a la d- i nt t l s eue o s tl o a i sa ng by is$15 000 tgur Cons que l t c e pr e de t ve di t e te nce ga n, t ndi t 0, i e. e nty, he as oc e d o r c wi tej r fn i i fv ro Pi a owi n c mp rtv f ut Th c u t ne e afn l t h u y idng n a o f l d t o o aaie a l. e o r e trd i a h l h j d me t g is Co t na o Se tmb r8 2 0f r$19 0,7 , 28 ,0 of ih u g n a an t ni tl n pe e , 01 o , 9 1 3 $ 50 0 whc ne c n tttdc ssa r e t Pia o sa tr e .I t ee d,h j d me t e u td i a e c s o si e o t wad d o l d ' to n ys n h n t e u g n r s le n n x e s u l e ur ov rt prm a y polcyag ns Contne a a W e t se i t nmountof xpos e e he i r i ai t i nt l nd sche tr n he $705, 73. 1 W e t hese ha now br sc t r s oughtt ss tag ns M i contne al gi t tM i contne hi ui ai t di nt le ng ha di nt a t d i ba f t by r f i t s tl Pil do' cli W esc t tl t sm o i f c e n d aih e usng o ete la s a m. t heser ied hi ton or - 3- sl r u g n r q etn t sCo tofnda amatro lw t a M i- ni n f i dt l mmayj d me t e u sig hi ur t i s te f a h t d co t t al o ne e e r ieisd y ofgood f ih t s tl wih Pildo whe pr e e wih ar as bl opporuniy xe c s t ut a t o e te t la n es nt d t e ona e t t t do s o o. I . LEG A L STAN D AR D I A c u t h l g a ts mmayj d me ti dh mo a ts o t th r i n g n i o r s al r n u r u g n f t e v n h ws ha te e s o e une t d s uea t a ymaeil a ta dt mo a ti e t ldt j g n a ama tro lw. Fe . ip t s o n tra fc n he v n s n i e o ud me t s te f a ' d R. t ' Ci . 5 () Co s q e ty t emo a tde r t ei iil e p nsblt o if r n ted src v P. 6 a . n e u n l,h v n G as h nta r s o i i y f n o mi g h itit b i co toft ba i f ism o i and i ntf ng t epori ofthepla ngs de ii , ur he s s or t ton, de iyi hos tons t e di , postons ans r t i e r t i , a isonson fl,t t rwih t afi vis i a 'whih i we s o nt rogaores and dm s i ie oge he t he fda t , f nyp c t bele de onsr t t abs nceofagenui is ofmatra f t' Se Cel e Cor v ives m tae he e ne s ue e i l ac . e otx p. . ' Car t 4 7U. 31 , 23( 98 ) tet 7 S. 7 3 1 6 . , 1 1 DI 1 . SCU SSI N O l t ep e e tmo in W e thetrag e t a ii e tte t s mmayj d me tha n h rs n to , sc se r u s h tt s n ild o u r u g n t t M i contne vi a e isdut ofgood f t i f ii t s tl t c e wih Pildo.I d- i nt olt d t y aih n alng o e te he as t la n pa tc a ,i m ant i t t ei no ge neis ofma e i f c t M i contne had a riul r t i ans hat her s nui s ue t ral a t hat di nt r as nabl opporuniy t s tl t c e a s dha done s asi s d haveknown t t e o e t t o ete he as nd houl ve o t houl ha t ti lwoul lkey r s ti a exc s ve diti f vorofPildo. he ra d i l e ul n n e s r c n a la Unde Fl i l w, i ur rhasadut whe ha i c am sagans isi ur d t tus r orda a an ns e y n ndlng l i i t t ns e o ç e t s deg eeofc r a dii nc a a pe s ofor na y c r a pr de s d e cs he ame r a e nd lge e s r on di r a e nd u nce houl xer ie i t m a ge tofhi own busne s' M ac a v.Gov'Emps I s Co. 953 So. 451 n he na men s i s. ' ol t . n. , 2d , 45 5 ( a 2 0 )( u t Bo tnOl Coo yI s Co v Gu ir e , 8 S 2 7 3 7 5( a 4- 5 Fl. 0 6 q oi ng so d ln n . . , te rz 3 6 o. d 8 , 8 Fl. 1 0).TheSuprmeCour ofFl i ha f t relbortdont sdut notngt t 98 ) e t orda s urhe a ae hi y, i ha - 4- whe t i ur d hass r nde e t t i ur ralcontolo rt ha i oft n he ns e ur e r d o he ns e 1 r ve he ndlng he cam ,i udi a 1de sonswih r ga d t ltga i a s tl men ,t nt li ncl ng 1 cii t e r o ii ton nd e te t he he i ur rm us a s eadut t e r s s h c r a m a s h dec sonsi ns e t s um y o xe cie uc ontol nd ke uc ii n good f ih a wih duer ga d f t i e e t oft i ur d. Thi g f t a t nd t e r or he nt r ss he ns e s ood aih dut oblga e t i tr rt a s t i ur d ofs tlm e o y i t s he nsle o dvie he ns e e te nt pporunii , t t tes o ad s a t t pr bl ou c eoft ltga i t wa n oft pos i lt ofa vie s o he oba e t om he ii ton, o r he sbiiy n e e s u g n , n t a vs teisze o a yse sh mih tk t a od xc s j d me t a d o d ie h n t d f n tp e g t a e o v i r s m e The i ur mus i tga et f c s gi f i co i r ton t a n . ns er t nvesi t he a t, ve ar nsde a i o s tl ntofert ti notunr as e teme f ha s e onabl unde t f c s a s tl i pos i e, e r he a t , nd e te, f sbl whe e ar a ona y pnz ntpe s f c d wih t pr pe tofpa ngt t t l r e s bl de r on, a e t he os c yi he o a r ove y,woul do s ec r d o. Gute r z,38 So. a 785. ir e 6 2d t Fl i a s r ogniesat r pa t rghtt m ant i a a ton ag ns t i ur rt r orda lo ec z hid- ry i o i an n c i ai t he ns e mde tec mmo lw t r c v rt a n o a e e s u g n b s do t is rrsb e c o i h o n a o e o e he mou t f n xc s j d me t a e n he n u e ' ra h f t s good f t oblga i M ac a,953 So. a 455. Thees e e oft st pe ofa ton i ç o aih i ton. ol 2d t s nc hi y ci s t t rme yast aini whc a is rdi e p e t a e c s j d me tb c u eo tei u e ' e d iu to n ih n n u e s x osd o n x e s u g n e a s f h ns rrs f iur t pr ryorpr a l e o ope l ompty de e t c am .'Cunni l f nd he l i ' ngham v St . andar Gaur l .Co ,630 d . ns . So.2d 1 1 ( a.1 ) I i t rf ewel-etedt tt ne e si urri e ildt 79, 81 Fl 994 . t s heeor ls tl ha t xc s ns e s ntte o a mai ai ac mon lw ba f t a ton a i taprm a y i lr .' Vi l I .Co.v Cont nt n om a d aih ci gans i r nszer' giant ns . 1 Cas Co.33So. 73 737( a. s.Ct App.2010) . , 3d 4, Fl Dit . . 1T) g a a n o wh tc n tttsb d fi i wh te u d ral h cru tn e a % he r v me f a o siue a at s eh r n e lt e ic msa c s n ( h i ur rf ie t s tl acli a i ta i ur d whe i ha ar s bl opporuniyt do s ' ns e a ld o e te am gans n ns e n t d ea ona e t t o o. ' Co rr sv US. c I s Co, 2 So 2 1 , ( a Dit CtAp 2 0 ) Ac o dngy nte a . Se . n . .9 7 . d 6 20 Fl. s. . p. 0 6 . c r i l , Fo i ac u t h v t e eal r s r ed t q e to o ba fihf rtej r . Be g sv lrd o rs a e t n rly e ev ll he u sin f d at o h u y' r e . g ' Ihnt I s Co,8 6 S 2 6 5 6 2( a 2 0 ) s eas Guir e , 8 So 2 a 7 5(-h n i n . . 9 o. d 6 , 7 F1. 0 4 ; e lo t rz 3 6 . d t 8 t 'e y e t f qu ton off iur t a i good f t wihdu r ga d f t i er ssoft i ur d i f t esi al e o ct n aih t e e r or he nt e t he ns e s or he - 5- W esc se now a guest tM i contne ' r f a t s tl wih Pildo co tt e t he tr r ha di nts e us l o e te t la nsiut d ba f ih asM i contne ha ar as d at di nt d e onabl opport t t r c a s tl mentknowi t a e tmiy o ea h e te ng hat n e es ve ditwasapos i lt Specfcal W e t hese poi st M i contne ' a r nes xc s r c sbiiy. ii ly, sc t r nt o d- i nts wa e s ta P l d scam iv le ç aa to hc'n u is l d e d fn ec u s l d t dt a t i h t il o' li n ov d t tsr p i'ij re . n e d, ee s o n e a mit h t hs a c e was f t m os pa tan t lornot ng'c e.Addii ly,W esc se sr s t f c t ta , or he t r, t al hi ' as tona l the tr tes es he a t ha j r rwh wa ds se d rn t tiln c tdh ri l to t fn frP l d , swel s u o o s imis d u ig he ra idiae e nci in o id o il o a la na a tep e ii u g ' sae n t tep rist t h c s c udr s l i amut- lind la h r sdngj d es ttme t o h a t ha t e a e o l e u tn e limi o olr l v r iti tej r b l v dPi a o.Un e te ecru tn e , e th se n tst a M i edc f h u y ei e l d e l d r h s ic msa c s W sc e tr oe h t dContnentne rofeedmor t $1 000de pieisownc e' rcomme tonofa i ve fr e han 50, st t ouns ls e ndai s te ntr ngeup t $350, t tW e these r pe e yr se a s tlm e andeve etl me a o 000, ha sc t r e atdl eque td ete nt n madea ofe t co rbut a t Pildo ofe edt s tewihi M i contne ' $1m ilon n f r o nti e, nd hat la f r o etl t n d- i nts li polc lm i durng ti ll Fi ly,W esc se co e t tPil do wa wilng t ac e a i y i t i ra . na l t he tr nt nds ha la s li o c pt s tlm e ofe f l s t n t $1m ilon polc lm i. W esche trt r or a gue t tM i e te nt f r or e s ha he li iy i t t se he ef e r s ha dContne ' be vi rc tt e bad f t i nts ha o onsiut d aih. I r s ns M i co i nta s rst t de pie t pos i lt ofan e es ve di t t n e po e, d- ntne s e t ha , s t he sbiiy xc s r c, he aval ee de eprort ti li cae boh t tt ca ewm de e i ea t tan a r e iabl vi nc i o ra ndi td t ha he s s f nsbl nd ha dve s d- i nt pe fc l e i he dvi e ovi d t r ul w a nota pr biiy. M i contne s ciialy r leson t a c pr de by is es t s oba lt c elt tt r wasa70% c nc ofa ve diti isf vori t unde l ng a ton wih t ouns ha he e ha e r c n t a n he ryi c i t he e pe tto o s b tn ilc mp rtv n gie c i t ee n t tt ej r f t f rPi a o. x cain f u sa ta o aaie e lg n e n h ve tha h u y omd o l d l Furhem or ,M i contne hihlght t moc ti t tde e ecouns lc uct whe ei t r e d- i nt g i s he k ral ha f ns e ond ed r n Thoughdipu e by M i contne ,W esc se alo cl mst tPildo maderpe t eforst s tl s td d- i nt t he tr s ai ha la e aed f t o cte wih Mi contnen f $1milon prort til t d- i t or li i o ra . 6- - tno t fs v n e nj r r f u dn la ii o tepat fM i co tn n.l tuse h sz s e u o e e te u o s o n o iblt n h r o d- n ie t t h mp a ie y t t ha ngt ke t slgala cei o c i r ton,tdi i f c m ak ar as ha , vi a n hi e dvi nt onsde a i i d n a t e e onabl efor t e f to s tl t ca eby m a ng t $1 000 ofe wihi t r co mende r nge. Though i was e te he s ki he 50, f r t n he e m da t pr r d t ofe a hi rn ot wihi t s tl me r nge M i contne a m a l d es epa e o f r ghe m mt t n he e te nt a , di nt dn nty eni t tPildo e rde ha la ve monsr t d awilng st s tl hi cai f rls t n $1m ilon, uc l s ta e li nes o e te s l m o e s ha li m h es t thewoul ha a e edt $35 000a t hi e oft s tlm e r ng Ba e on ha d ve cc pt he 0, t he gh nd he e te nt a e. s d t ecr hes icumsa s M i con i tmai ai t tt r i age ne is ofma e i lf c a t t nce , d- tnen nt ns ha he e s nui s ue t ra a t s o whe he i f fle isdut ofgood f t t r t ulild t y aih. Bec us W esc se ha f ied t de onsr t t a enc ofa g ne is ofm aera a e t he tr s al o m tae he bs e enui s ue t il f tr ar ng whe he M i contne vi a e isdu y ofg f t t Cour de est moton ac eg di t r di nt olt d t t ood aih, he t ni he i frs mmayj d me t F o teo te,h Fo iaS p e Co r h sn tdta teis eo o u r u g n . r m h u st te lrd u rme u t a o e h t h su f b dfihi ç e eal rs r edl. .o t ej r . S eBege , 9 S 2 a 6 2 Th u hc u t a at s l n r l e e v l . fr h u y' e r s 8 6 o. d t 7 . o g o rs g y ' h v a t srs le tematra tes mmayj d me t tg ,h c s 1w of rdb a e t i e ov d h te t h u r u g n sa e te a e a fee y me W esc se doe nots s t taf t ly diputd st ton s h ast pr s nto t he t r s ugge t ha acua l s e iua i uc he e e ne c tt esba f t onsiut d aih. l ee a t ba f ih a l i l ksa alt r l va cr t t e t dee mi t nd d, s he d at nayss oo t l he e e nt icunsanc s o t r ne he r as bl s oft opporuniyt s tl,s e Cont e as 927 So. a 20,t f c soft sca e e ona ene s he t t o e te e rr , 2d t he a t hi s pr bi t Cour a t ssa fom fndi t tM i contne aced i ba f ih.Thoug M i ohi t he t t hi t ge r i ng ha d- i nt t n d at h dContne kne t tam ulimilo dola ve ditf Pil do wasapos bii t r wa no i nt w ha t- li n lr r c or la si lt he e s y, defnii e denc t ts h ar s twa lkey.Thesa e i tve vi e ha uc e ul s i l tt ment fom M i contne ' couns sr di nts el a wela t etil u g a k o e g do l ap tn il o a e e sv r itnt ee e th th s l s h ra j d e c n wld e ny oe ta f r n xc s edc i h v n ta te j r b le e Pild At h s met , ee ec u s l d ie M i- ni e t h thec s u y eiv d la o. t e a i d fns o n e a v s d d co tn n t a t a e me wa ç f nsbl 'wih a6 A c s ' e i e' t : de 700 hanc ofade e eve dit' Gr a Ame i a I tr nc e f ns r c . e t ' rc n nsla e Co ni sSui Appr c ngTralRe t a 23,24.Addii ly,c mpa e t oa hi i por, t tona l ouns lsmock ti r s t d e' ral e ule i t emao i o j r r fn i f rM i- n ie t Asar s l, o nslrc mme e a n h j rt f u o s i dng o d co tn n . y e ut c u e e o nd d s tlmentr ngeof$1 000 t $350, t whih M i contne a r t e te a 50, o 000 o c d- i nt dhe ed, hough on t 1 he ow e Asco t ha a kno e d,tg ni urnc compa srla eona ceofc e i a nd. urs ve c wldge dal ns a e ny' einc dvi ouns l s f c o t bec i r d i ba f t ca es' ar y v Aut owne sI s Co. No.8: c 595a tr o onsde e n d aih s . 'Ke ne . or n. , 06- v- T- 4 2 TGW , 0 9U. DitLEXI 1 8 8 a *1 ( . Fl. v 5 2 0 )(iigCo tnStts 2 0 S. s. S 0 91 , t 3 M D. a No . , 0 9 ctn to a e M utIs.Co.v Tr vehan,390 So. 724,728( a DitCtApp.1980 Thus gi nt s .n . e t 2d F1. s. . :. , ve hi lgala cea t r ulsoft pr ti r s a ch, he er i a ge ne diput o rt e dvi nd he es t he e-ral e e r t r ema ns nui s e ve he r a ona e soft o runiy t s tl pr s nt i t sca e e pe a l snc t pa tes e s blnes he ppo t t o e te e e ed n hi s , s cily i e he ri c es whehe Pil woul ha e c i r d a ofe ofl st $1milon. Though ont t t r lado d ve ven onsde e n f r es han li M i contne m a ha i f c aced i ba f t i o i nott s tl wih Pil do,t ti a d- i nt y ve n a t t n d aih n ptng o e te t la ha s matrf r h j r t d cd i lg to tecru tn e . te o t e u y o e ie n ih f h ic msa c s I . C O N CL U SI N V O Fo t a r he bover s ,i i ea ons t s ADJUDGED t tW ethese' M otonf SlmmayJ ha sc trs i or l r udgme ( E.No.1 ,ie on nt D. 8) fld Nove r8.2012,i DENI mbe s ED. z-...- s D N A DO DR DiCabraMi ,li,iJ'aoJna,03 O E N R E E n hm e t a Fod ts dyfaur 21. s mi rah y FE CO A . NO UN I TED STA TES DI STRI J D GE CT U Copi pr de t es ovi d o: Couns ofRe or el c d - 8-
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
