Gibson v. NCL (BAHAMAS) LTD. et al, No. 1:2011cv24343 - Document 60 (S.D. Fla. 2012)

Court Description: ORDER Granting 53 Jurisdictional Discovery and Denying Defendant Grupo Cacum's 47 Motion to Dismiss with Leave to Refile; dismissing 47 Motion, with Leave to refile no later than 9/4/2012; The parties may conduct jurisdictional discovery until 8/27/2012; See Order for complete details. Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 5/30/2012. (ral)

Download PDF
Gibson v. NCL (BAHAMAS) LTD. et al Doc. 60 U N I D STA TES DI TE STR I T C O U R T C SOUTHERN DI STRI O F FLO RI CT DA CA SE N O .11 24343- V - TZ/ M ON TON CI SEl Sl LARI 1 GI TA . BSON , Pl i if , a ntf s VS. NCL ( BAHAM AS)LTD. al, e/ . Def nda . e nt / O R DER G R AN TI JUR I I O N A L D I O V ER Y A N D DEN Y I G D EFEN D AN T NG SD CTI SC N G R UPO C AC U M ' M O TI N T O DI I W I LEAV E T O R EFI S O SM SS TH LE THI M A TTER c m e be or t Cour upon Def nda G r po Ca um S. .de C. .S S a f e he t e nt u c A V ' tGr p Ca u 'M oi nt DimisteCo lit ( 4 1 a dPlitf' Mo inf rLe v t d u o c m' to o s s h mpan , DE 7 , n an ifs to o a e o û ) Conduc J iditonalDic r ( 5311Durngacuieon Def ntNCL ( ha s Lt ' t urs ci s ovey DE . i rs enda Ba ma ) d.s s i ,h No we anE c Plitf wa ij rdwh ns eatmp e t bo r ab c le teç u g e h p t e r gi pi, an if s n u e e h te td o ad us ald h s n l l Bus't ta p r h rt azpi etu i t Me ia u ge Thed u l Bu 'wa o e a / r , o rns o t e o iln o r n he xc nj n l. ' t nge s' s wn d ndo l o r t by D ef nda s Gnz Ca ,Oper dor Ca pe a ed e nt po cum a a nopy,S. . Oper dor Bi m a S. . a A , a a o ya, A , nd XYZCo rto (s eEx u so Eniis).Plitf camst t h ij rdh r ho le wh na mo ain çh c rin t e ' an if li ha s e n u e e s ud r e n t t e pl ye oft Exc s on Enttesc m e up be nd he a w ihou w n ni r m o e he ur i ii a hi r nd, t t r ng, oughl g a d he y r bbe r i a at mptt he vehe ont t ç ungl Bus' Def nda Gnz Cac , M e c n c or ton, n n te o a r o he d l e . ' e nt po um a xi a om a i mo e t dimist Co litfrlc o pes n l u idcin.l t eatr ai , p Ca u v s o s s he mp an o a k f ro a j rs ito n h l n tve Gnzo c m e c ne dsh thecamsa ans if r e l e e( u t 1 a dj it e t r ( u tV) alosae o tn ta t li g i tt o n gi nc Co n I) n on v n u e Co n l fit tt g 1 M oton t Conduc Ju idi i D ic y i pa tofPl nif' oppostonpa r t G r Cac ' The i o t rs ctonal s over s r aitf s ii pe s o upo um s Moint Dimis ( 5 1 to o s s.DE 2. 1 Dockets.Justia.com a cli . Pl i if oppos Gr am antf es upo Ca um ' M o i on t m e is a a tonal r que t c s ton he rt nd, ddii ly, e ss J iditona dic r ' s c i l s ove y.TheCour wilgr ntPl ntf r que ta de Gr po Ca um ' M oton ur t l a ai ips e s nd ny u c s i t Dimiswi la et r fl f l wi t ec n lso of u idcina d s o r . o s s t e v o eie ol ng h o cu in j rs ito l ic vey h o L BA CK G RO UN D Z Thi ds ue a ie o to ij re Plitf s fee wh l atmpi g t b ad a b st s ip t rs s u f nu is an if u frd ie te tn o o r u o ta s o t e t azp iet u i aj n l i M e c Plitf wa ap se g ro NCL' s i,h r n p r h r o iln o r n u g e n xio. an if s a sn e n S hp te Norwe an Epi She de i dt pa tcpa ei a ons ee ur i whih i uded ardeon t gi c. c de o ri i t n n hor xc son, c ncl i he C u g eBu ' a dazpl et u o t eYu aa j nge wh l t eNo we a E cwa d c e i t n l s' n i i o r f h c tn u l, ie h r gin pi s o k d n l 3 n CosaM a ,M e c Afe t s p doc d i M e c Pli ifwa ta pored, bus fom t t ya xio. tr he hi ke n xi o, antf s r ns t by , r he pe t aj n l ae .Thee P an ifwa isr ce t b a dteç un l Bus' otk he t te ir o u ge ra r , litf s n tu td o o r h ç g e 't a e r o h l zi i t .Pl ntf as e t t twhie s w ass a ng i f ontoft t ungl Bus' a em pl e, plne our ai i f s r s ha l he t ndi n r he l l e ,' n oye r pr e ai ,a orag oft Exc son Entte ,c m eu fo be nda s e es nt tve nd/ ent he ur i ii s a p r m hi nd udde y, t nl wihout wa ni r r ng, oughl gr dPl ntf i anate ptt he he ont t S ungl Bus' Pl ntf he r y abbe ai if n tm o ave r o he ç l e . ai if a d ' a d 'i he s de a w a a reva ua e t Fl i f i m e a e s lg r t pop' n r houl r nd s i c t d o orda or m di t tr e y. Pli tf fl d s ta i tDe e nt NCL a t Exctr i Enttes I Count1 Pl n if a n if ie ui gans f nda s nd he lson ii . n , aitf as e t t t CL wasneglge .l Countl , hi h i l s rs ha N i nt n l w c nc udesffee s c a m s Pl i ifaleg t t i t n ub- l i , a ntf l es ha t Exc son Enttesw e e ne i nt4 I Count 1 , Pl i ifa s t t tt Exc s on Entte a e he ur i ii r glge . n 1 1 a nt f s ers ha he ur i ii s r 2 e soh l ien td,h fcu l a k r u di d rv dfo Plitf' Co lit( 1 a teCo r Unls te' s oe te a ta b c go n s eie rm anifs mpan DE J s h u t w mus a ce alf t algai astu andconsr t i t lg mos fvor bl t t Pli if Se t c pt 1 acual le tons r e tue hem n he iht t a a e o he antf. e Ameia De tl s' v Ci aCop.6 F.d 1 8 ( lhCi. 01 ) rc n na As n . gn r , 05 3 2 3 1 t r2 0 . 3 Com pli doesnotdes rbet t ungl Bus'' The ant c i he t l e . 4 g o n sfrPlit fsn gie c cam a ansteEx uso Eniisaea f lwst)fie t The r u d o ani ' e l n c li g i th c rin tte r s ol : ald o f g o a po d asf e c rin;b)fi dt p o iea e c rinwi po re uime t()fie t po d rao a y rvie ae x u so ( al o r vd n x u so t rpe q p n; c ald o rvie e s n bl e h sf me n frp se est b adteû u geBu i ()fi dt a e u tl tan mo i ra ds p r ietesb et ae a s o a sng r o o r h d n l s' d al o d q aey ri, nt n u evs h u jc l ' e o e so t ens ei ha a1t ne s a yequi e t alow pa s ngest ha r as bl s emea t boa d xcurin o ur t d l he ce s r pm nt o l s e r o ve e ona y af ns o r teE n l Bu , () fi dt wanPlitf o d n esa do tce ta wo l bee c u tr dd rn tes bet h uu ge s' e al o r anif f a g r n bsa ls h t ud n o nee u ig h u jc ' ' e e c rin'9 fi dt a e u tl mo io, u evs, n /ris e th s bete c rint e s r ta ie o e x uso , al o d q aey ntr s p r ie a do n p c te u jc x uso o n ue h tt mply d ( e 2 NCL' a r ntage t ora nt by esoppe . l Coun I Pl i ifm ant i t tN CL a t S ppa e n s ge s t l n t V, antf i ans ha nd he Exc rinEniise a e i aj itv n u e n l ,n Co n V, anifa esta NCLma e u so tte ng g d n on e t r .Fial i u t Pli tf v r h t y d ne i ntm ir pr s nt to t he . glge s e e e a i ns o r Gnz Cac ,a M e c n c po a i n,m ove t di m i s a1 cl i s aga ns i f l c of po um xi a or r to s o s s 1 am i t t or a k p ro a j rs ito a manan t a i d e n th v rq iiemii m c na t wi F o ia es n l u idcin nd itis h t t o s o a e e u st n mu o tcs t lrd h t be ha e i o c the e. Gr po Ca um s o uld nt our r u c ubmit d a afi vi fom isl lr pr e a i te n tda t r t ega e es nt tve a tsi t is l c of co a t wih Fl i . I t at r tve,Gr po Ca um c e t t te tng o t a k nt c s t orda n he le na i u c ontnds ha Plitf sn gie c a dj it nu ecams h udb ds s f r alr t saeacam.Plitf an if e lg n e n on ve tr li s o l e imis o f i e o tt li an if u oppos Gr po Ca um' M oi on t meisa as r ssni t da of j iditonal es u c s ton he rt nd lo eque t ney ys urs ci ds o ey Gn p Ca u a est a Plitf sr q s f r u idcina d s o eyi n t n mo e ic v r . z o c m v r h t anif e uet o j rs ito l ic v r s ohig r t n a fs ng e ha i hi xpedii n. to 1 1 DI 1 . SCU SSI N O 4 Le a St n a df rPe s na Ju idcin . g l a d r o r o l rs ito a Fe a Rul ofCi lPr edu e1 b)2)pr de t tadef ntma movet dimisa derl e vi oc r 2( ( ovi s ha enda y o s s c mp an f rlc o pes n lurs ito I o d rt d tr n wh t e t i Co r ha pes n l o lit o a k f ro a j idcin. n r e o eemie eh r hs u t s ro a j rs ito o e a n n e ie td fnd n ,te Co r mu tu d ra e a t - a ta lss u idcin v r o r sd n ee a t h u t s n e tk wo p r nay i. Wi s l .v Babbiba Be Cons.SL 598F. 802, ( 1hCi. ) Fis,heCou t ndoor, nc . t y ach t, U, 3d 807 1 t r2010 . rtt r r ao a l sf me n frp se g r t p riiaei al s e to tes be t h r e c rin ;g fi dt e s n be ae a s o a sn es o atcp t n lap c fh u jc s oe x u so s () al o e pr ul t e or e,a orf lw ade t polci a pr edu esf i pe ton a moniorng oft e son om gae, nf c nd/ olo quae i es nd oc r or ns c i nd t i he xcuri t e s r p o re up n wa u e ()fi dt e s r ta po el tan da dspevsdp ro so eae te o n ue rpe q ime t s sd;h al o n ue h t rp ry rie n u r ie es n p rtd h e e c rin'ifie t e s r ta ih dpo e p lce a dprc d rsi plc t e szepasn es icu n x u so , ) ald o n ue h tt a rp r oiis n o e u e n ae o n t se g r,n ldig ( r Panifh drao a ysf me n frb adn tetu geBu ' U) daso ee c so ta wa n t litf, a e s n bl ae a s o o r ig h t n l s' ha h r x urin h t s o l , ' c mpee t o e ae ; k f i dt i lme t meh d o o e ai nwhih wa r a o a ea d s f a d wo l o tn l p r t d ( ) a l o mp e n a t o f p r to y e c s e s n bl n a e n u d p e e ttece to o ad n eo sc n iina duiz do alwe n gi n meh d o o rt n'l fi dt rv n h rain f a g ru o dt n tl e r l d e l t to s f peai , ) al o o i o ge o ( e p o laea e oc a po raesft rls ( fie t p o el po d ac mplt a da c rt d srpin r mug t nd nfre p rp it aey ue ;m) ald o r p ry rvie o ee n c uae e cito o al s e t o tesbe t h r e c rin t NCLwhihik e NCLwo l u et p o ieifr t nt f lap cs fh u j c s o e x u so s o c t nw ud s o r vd n omai o o pasn esi NCL' leaue we st, ndo b adtev se;n fie t v rf ta t e c rinwa t ae se g r n S i rtr, b ie a n o r h e sl() ald o eiy h the x u so s i f, t s r l be l e sd a disrdi a ()fie t iq iewh te pasn es icu igPlit fh da yse il ei l,i ne , n nu e ' nd o ald o n ur eh r se g r,n ldn ani , a n p ca a c ' f n e sa dc n iin . DE 1a !5 1 e d n o dto s g t 0. 3 mu t eemiewh t e t eFlrd lnga m sau epr vd saba i f r ro a j rs ito .1 5 s d tr n eh r h o ia o -r ttt o ie ss o pes n lu id ci n d. (l eplitf b asteb r e of sa ls n ap i f cec s o j rs cino e temo a t i- an if e r h u d n e tb ihig rma a i a e f u idito v r h v n , -h non- esdentde e nt' 1 a 81 $ pr m a f i c s i es a i he i t pl ntf pr s t r i f nda . d. t 0. i i ac e a e s t bls d f he ai i f e en s ' A a fd vt o d p sto tsi n s fiin t d fa amoin f r u me ta amatroflw.6 fi a is r e o i n e tmo y u fce t o e e t to o j dg n s te a ' i ' 1 S her, shee,heDe e nts t afda ts t t c rr t bur nta tonal s fs d.t e a r t fnda ubmis fi vit)o he ontay,he de r dii ly hi' W t b c t teplitf t p o uc e d n es p o t gj rs ito .' Mee e r l M ee v Su a k o h an if o r d e vie c u p ri u idcing ' ir x e. ir . n n l I en.Hotl,Lt 288F. 1 1 ( 1hCi.2002) W heet e de eprs nt byt ntr es d, 3d 264, 269 1 t r . r he vi nc e e ed he pa te afi vis a de ii t tmony c lc s t c tm us c t' a 1r s na e ris' fda t nd poston esi onfi t, he our t ons l l ea o bl ue if rn e i fvo o t en n mo a t litf. #. l it elnga sauep o i e j rs it n n ee c sn a r f h o - v n pan if f Ony fh o -nn tt t r v d s u id ci o d e ac u t r c e t t esc n se a dd tr newh t e t ee ecs o j rs ito c mp rs o s o rp o e d o h e o d tp n eemi eh r h x r ie fu id cin o o t wihduepr es .PVC Wi s, F. a 808( tn I e ne Sol i Cor v. s l557 t oc s ndoor 598 3d t ciig ntr t utons p. Marhal, F. 1 1 96( t Ci. 3d 293, 295- 11h r 2009). ) B.Jurs c i lD i c e i di tona s ov v Hee Plitf r q e tdj rs ito l ic v r i r s o s t GnzoCa u sMo int r, anif e u se u idcina d s o ey n e p n e o p c m' to o Dimisf rlc o p ro a j rs cin ( 5 DE 5 1 Therg t ojzidcin l ic v r i a s s o a k f e s n lu idito . DE 2, 3 . ih t t s ito a ds o ey s r quaiid one Se Eatn v Dor he trDe .I . 692F. 727,729- (11h Ci.1 .E-he lfe . e o . c se v, nc, 2d 31 t r 982) sl d cso t alw j rs ito a ds o ey i v r mu hap o u toft tmi ga d n tr o a y e iin o lo u id ci n l ic v r s ey c r d c he i n n au e f n j rs ito l ic v r rq e t'Mo h rDo 1v S ihMo a dBi Ra hdAl a tu 6 2 u id cina d s o ey e u s. t e e . hek h mme n s i M ko m, 3 ' F. zd 11 11 ( D. a. )(oleci ca e ) l Po ne v. s xI su Co. 1 F. supp. 30, 46 S. Fl 2007 c l tng s s. n s r Ese n r. , 78 3d 5A fd rl src c u tnFlrdama e ecs p ro a j rs ito o e ano r sd n d fn a tote : e ea ditit o r i o i y x rie es n luidcin v r ne ie t ee d n t h ç smee tn ta aFoiac u t y .'Frs rv S t, 9 F.d8 2, 4 ( lhCi. 01 ) a xe th t lrd o r ma ll a e . mi 5 4 3 4 8 6 1 t r2 0 ' h 6 eBo ev Or n eCny Bd o y Co ' ,1 2F.d6 3 6 6( lhCi.198 ( jd me ta a Se gl . a g f. fcnt mm r 6 3 5 , 5 1 t r 9 ) A u g n s s ma troflw i onl a oprat i t fct a i e e sçpoi s ove hel ngl i f voroft m ova ..hat te a s y ppr i e f he a s nd nfr nce t nt o m mi y n a he nt .t rao a l p o l c ul n t riea ac nrr v r c.) e s n be e pe o d o arv t o tay edit'. ' 4 1 1 4, 7( 1hCi.1 ,heElve hCic tatr t dititco tsde sont de 209, 21 n. 1 t r 999)t e nt r ui flmed he src ur' cii o ny j rs ito a dic v r wh r plitfs frtalde t t ds o e y i t i o p sto t u idcin l s o ey e e anif is l d o he ic v r n her p o i n o u i de e nt 'moton t dim is whi h wa fl tve m o hs a trt m oton t d s is a f nda s i o s s, c s ied s nt fe he i o im s , nd pl i if f l t s ciy w ha t y t a ntf s aied o pe f t he houghtc d o s d be di c r By c r t i Eat oul r houl s ove ed. ontas , n on, t eElv n h Cic i r v re ted src c ur' d s s a f rlc o s b e tmatrj rs ito h e e t rut e es d h itit o ts imis l o a k f u j c te u idci n whe e pli tf ha s l s poe duc t um,i ntf ng s c fc ma e i l t twe t t r a n if d ewed ub nas es ec de iyi pe ii t ra s ha nt o he h a t fpanifsa s rin , u pan ifh dn ty t e eve tej rs ito l ic v r . e r o litf se t s b t litf a o e rc i d h u idcina d s o ey o l h i sa t a e Pli t f e u se u idito a ds o eyi e o p iinp peswhc nt e n tn c s , ani rq e tdj rs cin l ic v r nh r p osto a r, ih f we e fl t a a hal we ks afe Gr po Ca um m ove t dim is f l c of pe s l r ied wo nd f e tr u c d o s s or a k r ona j rs ito .Alh u h Plitf frta k df r u idcina d s o eyfvemo t satrs efld u idci n t o g an if is s e o j rs ito l ic v r i n h fe h ie he Co ant t r c d doe notr tec whehe Gnz Ca um i or e Pli if pror omovi r mpli ,he e or s el t t r po c nf m d antf , i t ng t ds s,h ti itn e t dip t pes n lu idcin.Th s Plitf ma no h v h d a y o imis ta t n e d d o s u e ro a j rs ito u , an if y t a e a n ra o t r q eto b gn j rs ito a ds o e y p irt Grpo Ca u fln ismo in t e s n o e u s r e i u idcin l ic v r ro o u c m iig t to o di m i s; Addii ly,i he r s s. tona l n r eque t Pl ntf i ntt e t e de e s ho s t obt i durng s , ai i f de ii s he vi nc he pe o a n i j rs ito l ic v r .DE 5 a 1 1 Th ,h Co r fn sn b sst d n P an ifsrq e to u id cina d s o ey ( 2 t 8 . us te u ti d o a i o e y litf e u s f r j rs ito l ic veyd t d ly u id cina d s o r ue o ea . M or eove , Pl i if ha aleg e r a ntf s l ed nough i he Com pl i t nudge her r ques f n r a nt o e t or j rs it n l ic v r o tieo t ram o afs n e p di o , u j t aey P an if le e u idci a d so ey u sd fhe e l f ihig x e t n b tus b r l. litf alg s o i t t t Exc s on Entt e and N CL' c ha he ur i ii s onduc ongoi bus nes i t t N CL m ar t a s ls t ng i s n ha ke s nd e l e ur i ,ncl ngt e ur i a i s i t sc e,ha t Exc sonEntte die tym a ke e xc sons i udi he xc son t s ue n hi as t t he ur i ii s r c l r t d 1 litf saesi he pape st tt parisr ce l confredon M a 2,201 puruan t Fe R.Ci P. r ha he te e nty er y P an if tt n r 2, s t o d. v. 2 .DE 5 a 1 , 7. 6 ( 2 t 8 1. ) 8 an ifpld t tt Exc so Enttesa ef egncor ai andN CL i af egncor ai wkj js Plitf e ha he ur in ii r or i por tons s or i por ton jt picp l lc o b sn s i M imiFlrd .DE 1a l1 , 1 ) rn ia pa e f u ie s n a , o ia ( t r3 7, 1. , 5 t i e ur i nst o hN CL, ha NCL pr o e e ur i f t Exc so En ii i N CL' her xc so hr ug t t om t d xc sons or he ur i n ttes n S ltr t e, iswe ie, nd onboa disc uies ps a t ttc t f t e ur i we e s d ie aur on t bst a r t r s hi , nd ha ikes or he xc sons r ol onNCL' we ie, c i admi se e i Fl rda. aitf f t aleg t tNCL wa a a nt S bst whih s nit r d n o i Pl n if urher l es ha s n ge oft Exc son Enttesa t tt Exc son En ii ar bele d t ha ag ee t i mniy he ur i ii nd ha he ur i ttes e ive o ve r d o nde f NCL f camsma i t Compli . ( 1a ! 1 1 391. Pl ntf saleg tonsc ttt or li de n he ant DE t ! 3- 5, . 9 ai if l ai onsiue 1 mo et a me es e uaint a t sCo rma h v j rs ito o e Gr p Ca u Th , anif r h n r p c lt h thi u t y a e u idcin v r u o c m. usPlitf o i e il d t J iditona dic r s ntte o ' s c i l s ove y. ur Pownal v Cunar Li Li t Co.2007U. Dit LEXI 99382 ( D.Fl.Aug t3, l. d ne mied , S. s. S S. a us 2 0 )i isr cie Th r ,t e c u tg a tdj rs cin ld s o ey wih r s e tt t e tu 0 7 s n tu tv . ee h o r rn e u idito a ic v r t e p c o h o r ope a o , W ae .The bas ont dic r i or ai a r yi onSt sv.Wyndham r t r Fun tr n, ed he s ove ed nf m ton, nd el ng ubb NasauRes tand Cr t Pal eCasno, F. 1357,1 ( 1h Ci. s or ysal ac i 447 3d 361 1 t r 2006) t c tf ,he our ound ta e e to g Fu W ae ddn th v ap e e c o a a e ti Flrd , e ea j rs ito a h t v n h u h n tr i o a e r s n e r n g n n o i a g n rl u idcin l r quie e swe e s tsi d be aus Fun W a e ' t ont c swih Fl rda a e a l r pa tofwha e r m nt r aife c e t rs t a t t o i r a ge r c t e a lsg l osl i t u pa k g st c ies i p se g r . Th c u t tdta Fu W ae h s n b e i t elt o r c a e o nzs -hp a s n e s' e o r noe h t n tr a t s ' ongoi busnes r l tons pswiht Fl i - edc uielnesa ge aedsgnii a i om e ng i s e ai hi t he orda bas r s i nd ner t i fc nt nc f om t c ui e lnes Thecoul i ntfe Fun W a er snum e ousco a t w ih Fl i s c fca l r he r s i . ' de ii d t t ' r nt c s t or da, pe i ly t tt t uro r t r e ve wieta f r fom Fl i fom c u s lnes e ge i t l phone ha he o pe aor ec i d r r ns e s r orda r r ie i , nga d n e e c ls e mais and c r pondenc wih c uie lnest ts loutofFl i wasam e roft a l, - l, ores e t r s i ha ai orda, mbe he FlrdaCai anCnzs Asocai ( mandaedbyt t o rtrsi urnc polc ,a o i rbbe ie s iton as t he our peao ' ns a e iy) nd lsedt cr s lneasi ur dson ispolc whih wa pur s d fom aFl rda bas i ur nce it he uie i ns e t i y, c s cha e r o i - ed ns a 9 aitf alo pl t tt r i ac r tbet e t Exc so Enttesa NCL (f tw pr e i of Pl n if s ed ha he e s ontac we n he ur in ii nd (or j otcton NCLp se g r'a dta ic ntisafrm slcinca s .DE 1a ! 1 ) Be a s t c nrc i n t r o te asn es' n h tt o an o u eeto lu e ( t 5. c u e he o ta ts o pat fh r cor pr en l beor t Cour,t Co twilnots ult ont sgnii a eoft c r tw ihr s ctt e d es ty f e he t he ur l pec ae he i tc nc he ontac t e pe o j rs cin lsu s Ho v rb c uePanif ssfkinl alg dta tec nrc ma b r lv n fr u idito a is e . we e , e a s litfha u t e ty l e h th o tat y e ee a t o e d tr nn uidcin imu t ep o u e d rn jrs it n l so ey. eemiigjrs it ,t s b r d c d u ig u idci a dic v r o o 6 Com pany. 1 1 CO NC LU SI N 1. O W i u j rs ito a d s o r , an ifcnn t e uet esae n sma ei t ea td vt t tu idcin l ic vey Plitf a o rf t h ttme t d n h f a i ho i s itdbyGr poCac ' l l e es a i c e ni t c por ton' lc of t c swih ubm te u um s ega r pr enttve onc r ng he or a i s a k con a t t Fl i ( 47 1 . Addii l be a e t r or doe notrve t tPl nifdea d i orda. DE - 1 tonaly, c us he ec d s e al ha aitf lye n rq etn u idcin l s o eya ds eh s le e e o g oe t l h roi,h Co r wi ga t e u sigj rs ito a dic v r n h a alg d n u ht ni e e t tte u t l rn t l nn t d y o j rs ito ld so e y sa a1ohe ds o ey a an tGr p Ca u a d d n iey a s f u idcina ic v r , ty 1 t r ic v r g is u o c m, n e y Gr po Ca um ' M oton t D i m i sw ih l ve t r fl . A c or ngl upon r vi w ,i i u c s i o s s t ea o e ie c di y, e e ts ORD ERED TH A T ()Dee ntGr poCacz sM otont Dimisi DENI W I LEAVE TO REFI 1 fnda u lm' i o s s s ED TH LE noltr h nSe e r4 20 2.( 4 1 ae t a ptmbe , 1 DE 7 . ( Pli ifsM oto f 2) antf in orLea oConduc urs ci l s oveyi GRANTED.DE531 vet tl iditona Dic r s ( . ()Th p risma c n u tu idcin l ic v r u tl g t2 , 01 . 3 e at e y o d c j rs ito a d s o ey ni Au us 7 2 2 ( )Almeisds o eya an tGr poCa u i sa e d rn u id cina d s o ey.I 4 l rt ic v r g is u c m s ty d u i gj rs ito l ic v r f Gr p Ca u flsa oh rM oi nt Dimisf rlc o p ro a j rs ito ds o eywil lo u o c m ie n te to o s s o a k f es n lu id cin, ic v r las be s a d a i tGnl Ca um pe ng r ol i oft tm oton. t ye ga ns po c ndi es uton ha i 3 DONEa dORDERED i MimiFlrd o ti S% o Ma , 01 n n a , o ia n hs f y2 2 INI S J TED TXTESDlrll rJ srtc' UDGE c c: Honor bl A ndr a M .Si ont a e e m on Al c l ouns lofr or e ec d 7

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.