Garcia v. Wells Fargo Bank Northwest Na Trustee et al, No. 1:2010cv20383 - Document 218 (S.D. Fla. 2011)
Court Description: ORDER granting 138 Motion for Partial Summary Judgment; denying 149 Motion for Summary Judgment. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 12/14/11. (tp)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Garcia v. Wells Fargo Bank Northwest Na Trustee et al Doc. 218 UNI TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT SOUTHERN DI STRI OF FLORI CT DA CASE NO.1 20383- I NG 0CV-fI NATHALY GARCI GARCI , A A a Pe s na Re es n a i f THE ESTATE s r o l pr e t tve or OF CARLOS EDUAO O FRI N EDA S ALVAREZ,DECEASED, on Be l Oft Esa ea Al Po e il haf he tt nd 1 t nta Be i ire a orSur i r , nefca is nd/ vvo s Pl i if , a ntfs W ELLS FARGO BANK NORTHW EST, . TRUSTEE, N A. af e g co o a efd i r or i n p r t i uc ay; CESSNA AI RCM FT COM PANY, af e g co po a i HON EYW ELL or i n r r ton; AEROSPACE,adi son ofHONEYW ELL vii W TERN A TI A L I C. a Del w a e ON N , a r c por ton;AVI J CENTER, or ai ON- ET LLC, aFl i Li t d Li lt c orda mie abiiy ompan SOUTHERN J y, ET CENTER,LLC,aLi t Libiiy Compa mied a lt ny, Def nda t . e ns / O R DER G M N TI G PLA I TI S M O TI N FO R N N FF' O PA RTI L SU M M AR Y JUD G M ENT A THI M ATTER come be or t Cour uponPli ifsMotonf Pa ta Summay( S s f e he t antf' i or ril r DE #1 )a dDee d n Ce s Aic a Co a y' M oi nf rSu r J g n ( /1 9 , ie 38 n f n a t sna rr h mp n s to o mma y ud me t DE /4 ) fld Augus 26, 1a Se e be 1 2011 r s c i y. r i t Pari s kar i onwheher t 201 nd ptm r 9, , e pe tvel The en,he tes ee ulng t ornott Genea Avito andRe t i tonAc l($ t 'a t Fl i Stt eofRe e he rl ain vialzai t t A' nd he orda aut GAl ) pos z lGe r lAvito a Re t lz ton Ac of1 ne a a i n nd via ia i t 994,Pub.L. No.1 298,1 St t 1 0308 a . 552 (9 4 , sa n e b Pu . No 1 5 1 2 j3e ,1 1S a. 0 ( 9 7 . 1 9 ) a me d d y b L. . 0 - 0 () 1 tt22 4 1 9 ) 2FLA.STAT.j95. ( ( . 031 2)b) Dockets.Justia.com aea alb ea afnnai ed fn e o be afo Dee d n Ce s aAic at mpa y($ sn ' . r v ia l s f tv e e s s n h l f fn a t sn rr f Co n t s a' Ce ) The Cour i f l bre ed on t mater3a pr e dswih t bene i ofor a g e .4Upon t s uly i f he t , nd oc e t he ft al r um nt c r f c n ieaino t pla i g ,nc n u cinwi teag me t st o t i temoi n a d a eul o sd rto fhe e d n si o j n to t h r u ns e f rh n h to s n h a o a a gum e ,heCour fndst tGARA a t Fl i St t t ofRe ear una ia e a t rl r nt t t i ha nd he orda a u e pos e val bl s afim ai de e esi t a fr tve f ns n he bove-t e a ton. syld c i 1 Background . Thi ca e a i es o of t Fe ua y 1 2008 c a h of a Ces na M odel65 Cia i I I s s r s ut he br r 8, rs s 0 t ton l a r r f. r we et eei vi l a r t pl - t Pli ifsde de ,who wa t coic a t The e r hr ndi dua s boa d he ane he antf ce nt s he piot t ar r tt Ca ai oft ar a tandt owneroft ar a tAta oxi a eyt rp l of he ic af,he pt n he icr f, he he icr f. ppr m t l hit f mi e i o t fi , hepio die ge t prmar ti a t a opiot a a t ed our nut s nt he lght t l t s nga d he i y rm nd he ut l , nd tempt t m a lyti t aic a tusng t s onda y ti s t m a t horz a sabii er Att t o nua l rm he r r f i he ec r rm yse nd he i ont l t lz . ha tme,hea r r f i e ael pic downt anos i t ic a tmm di t y thed o e down att Thear r f uli a eyc as tiude. ic a t tm t l r hed nos e down i o t g ot i t nty kilng a 1tzeepas e r . nt he r md, nsa l li 1 lr s nge s Pli tf ha br a n if s ought s t a ns ui gai tCes na f neglgenc a f src la lt a t s or i e nd or tit i biiy s he ma u a tr rd sg ra ds le o t es b e t ica t n is u c mp n n pat, le igfiu e n fcu e, e ine, n elr f h u j c arr fa d t s b o o e t rs algn alrs a ac u eo tec ah. ( r Am. mp .! 38& 4 DE # 0 1. pe i c l , anifcams s a s f h rs s Thid Co l ! 4, 7 - ) S cf al Plitf li i y t a t ed s 7Acu trCo to Un t s a h 7ACU' , pa t nt earr f t a wa'su esa d h th ah t ao nr l i (t s d ' a r o h ic at h t l s r n ) n o r or of t pot nta f r na y, m a f tone a f l d t wa n t piot of t pe at s he e il or u wa lunci d nd aie o r he l he 3Pl ntf fld ac oldat rpl a rs e( #1 onOcobe 1 2011, nd ai if ie ons i ed e y nd e pons DE 58) t r 2, a Dee ntfl arpl ( #1 onOcobe 21 2011 fnda ied e y DE 65) t r , . 4On Dec mbe 7,2011 t Cou thed a he rng o t c os - o i f s e r , he r l a i n he r sm tons or umm a y r j udgme tont a ia lt ofGARA a FlrdaStt eofRe e. n he pplc biiy nd o i aut pos 5 Fl i ha a e t docrne ofsrc la lt whih e e t s le sofapr t orda s dopt d he ti tit i biiy, c xtnds o el r oduc , We tv Catr la Tr t Co.336So.2d80,87( a.1 ; eeeg.M obly v S.Fl s . epilr acor , F1 976) s . , e . a. Be e a Cop.5 0S 2 29 2 ( a Dit CtAp 1 8 ) r ve d nid, 0 S 2 1 1 v r ge r , 0 o. d 2, 93 F1. s. . p. 9 6 , e iw e e 5 9 o. d 1 7 ( a 1 8 )(oi gt a rti r aela l f rd f cso e wh c iha n c n r l. F1. 9 7 n tn h t eal s r ibe o e e t v r ih t s o o to) e 2 ma f toni acua or I i unco ese t t i 2006,Ce s s d t pa tc a das 7ACU t lunc i ng t t . t s nt t d ha , n s na ol he riul r h o t ar r tsm ant na pr vi r Sou he n J tCen e ,whot n i t l t das 7ACU i t he ic af' i e nce o de , t r e tr he nsaled he h n he arrf.P1' Sae n o Fa t !6 DE#1 , t ; f' S ae n o F cs 1 , #1 , t ) ica t( . ttme t f cs , s 38 a 3 De .s ttme t f a t ! 1 DE 48 a 5 . Ces na' p i a y de e ei t tt c as oc ure nota ar s tofam e ha c f iur , s s rm r f ns s ha he r h c r d s e ul c nial al e bu a ars tofpio er .De .Ans,DE #77)Cesnaalorie afr tvedefns st tt t s e ul lt ror ( fs . . s s as s fimai e e ha he s i i b re b GARA a dt F o iaSttt o Re s .De .sAf. f ! 21& 2 DE / 7 . ut s ard y n he lrd aue f po e ( f' f De . ! 2, / ) 7 Bef r t Cour now a ec os - o i ont a i biiyofGARA a heFl i St t e o e he t r r sm tons he pplca lt ndt orda aut ofRepos t t i t ntc e. e o he nsa as I .Le St I gal andar d S mmay u g n i a p o it wh r t ep e dn sa ds p ri tras sa ls h t u r j d me ts p rprae ee h la ig n u po t ngmaeil etbihta teei n g n i eis ea t a ymaeil a t n t a temo igp ryi e tte t u g n a h r s o e u n su s o n tra fc a d h th vn a t s nild oj d me t s amatroflw.SeeFED. CI P. Cel e Cor v Catet,477U. 31 322( 98 .s te a R. V. 56; otx p. . r t S. 7, 1 6) % one o t p icpa p r o e o te s mmayj d me tr l i t io ae a d ds o e o fcu l f he rn i l u p s s f h u r u g n ue s o s lt n ip s f a t al y uns uppored cai orde e es' Cel e 477 U. a 323 t l ms f ns . otx, ' S. t -24. The m ovi pa t be r t bur n ofpoi i t t pa toft r c d t t s ng ry a s he de ntng o he r he e or ha howst he a e e o a g ne i s ofm a e i lf c . See Adi ke v S. K r s drCo. 398 U . 1 1 bs nc f enui s ue t ra a t c s . H es , S. 44, 57 ( 970 ;Ale v T on Food ,I ,1 F. 642,646 ( 1h Ci.1 .Oncet movi pa t 1 ) ln . ys s nc. 21 3d 1 t r 997) he ng ry e t bls t a e eofage neis ofma e ilf c ,hebur n s fst t no ovi pa t sa ihes he bs nc nui s ue t ra a t t de hit o he nm ng ry t go be o yond t pl di a desgnae S pe i f c ss he ea ngs nd i t û c sc a t howi t tt r i age ne is f s ng ha he e s nui s ue or til' Ceotx, 7 U. a 3 4; e as Ch n lI c v Ia i Acie a o a,I c, 31F.d ra. l e 4 7 S. t 2 s e lo a e, n . . tl ' an tv we r fFl. n .9 2 1 2,1 ( 1hCi. 991 ( di t thenonmovi parymus ( mef wadwihsgniia , 47 477 1 t r 1 ) hol ng ha t ng t tt co or r t i fc nt pr tvee de edemonsrtngt e se eofati eis offc.'. obai vi nc tai he xitnc rabl sue a t' ) i u r j d me tma b ia p o raee nwh r tep risa r eo teb scf cs d mmay u g n y e n p r p it ve e e h a t ge n h a i a t, s e 3 but s gr a dia ee bout hef c ua i e e st ts dbedr wnfom t s f ct .'W ar orTom bi t a t l nf r nce ha houl a r he e a s ' ri gbee Tr p. ,nc v. vNanFu 695F. 1 1 (11hCi.1 ) Onamotonf s ans Co.I . M/ ng, 2d 294, 296 t r 983 . i or ummay r j d me ttec u t t iw tee d n ea drs lealn ee e i t lg t s f v rbet u g n ,h o r mus ve h vie c n e ov li frnc s n he ih mo t a o a l o t nonmovi pa t Se Ande s v Lf ry fobb I ., 477U. 242, ( 986) Howe r a he ng ry. e r on . :e / y, nc S. 255 1 . ve , me e s ntlaofe de i s r ci il vi nce n uppo toft no ovi pa t sposton i i ufi intt de ea a r he nm ng ry' ii s ns fce o f t moin frs mmayj dg n .Se i. t 2.l t ee d n eo fr db t eno mo i gp ryi to o u r u me t e d a 25 f h vie c fee y h n v n at s meeyc l rbeo i n tsg i n l p o t ,ummayj d me ti p o r Se i a 2 9 5 rl o o a l r s o in t ty rbai s ka ve r u g n s r pe. e d. t 4 - 0. 1 1 A nal i 1. ys s Th o l is e b f r t eCo r o tec o smo in f rpata s mmayj dg n ae e ny su s to e h u t n h r s- to s o ril u r u me t r whehe GARA a t Fl i St t eofRe eba acai whe et Pl i ifal ge t ca e t r nd he orda aut pos r l m r he antf le s he us oft c a h t be a pa tt twa s d by t De e ntf we t n t ye r prort t c a h. he r s o r ha s ol he f nda e r ha wo a s i o he r s Pl ntf a guest tnet rsaut a isbe a eGARA doesnots el s le s a t de i r ai if r ha ihe t t e pple c us hi d el r , nd he lve y oft das 7 ACU oc r d wihi t t l yea lm iai 'perod oft Fl i St t t of he h cure t n he weve- r i ttons i he orda a u e Re e.DE #1 a 6) Dee nta ue t tt pr tci ofGARA andt Fl i Stt eof pos ( 38, t . fnda g s ha he oe tons he orda aut Re edo a y be aus i di notm a a t et das 7 A CU,a t s eoft das 7ACU pos ppl c e t d nuf c ur he h nd he al he h wa i i alt t manuf cur roft ar a Fort f l ng r as ,t Cour fndst t s ncdent o he at e he ipl ne. he olowi e ons he t i ha ne t rGARA nort Fl rdaSt t t ofRe e ba Pli ifscli . ihe he o i a u e pos r a ntf am A .G, 4AA GARA i Si e s çnt nded t çi t e es i pr uc la lt coss whie a t s me tme o lmi xc sve od t ibiiy t , l t he n i af r igfite t n t p ro ij rdi g n rl vainarrf a cd n s'H. RE . 1 3 fo dn ar rame to es ns nu e n e e a a ito ica t c ie t. R. PNO. 0 ' 525() ( 994) re i ed i 1 U. C. A. 638,av l l at 1 W L 235994,a *1. 1 1 , prnt n 994 S. C. N.1 aiabe 994 t Spec fca l G A RA ba ss t a ns ge r la a i n aic af a com ponen pa tm anuf c ur r ii ly, r uis gai t ne a vi t o r r t nd t r at es a df r e t o ij r i a cd n so c ni g1 y a so mo ea tr l r o t ar rf t isfrt n o d ah rnu y n c ie t c u n 8 e r r r fe dei y fhe ic a to t is ve 4 owne o t a aica tde lr. r r o n rrf ae GARA j2() a. He e De e nt go ousydiput sa co e i ha idesg dormmmf cur heda h r , f nda vi r l s e ny nt ntont t t i ne a t edt s 7 A CU ,ye s e t cl i c r unde GA RA as t m an a t e of t a r a t t m e e y t e ks o a m ove r he uf c ur r he ipl ne ha rl f nihe a upgrde patt amai e nc fciiy.( #1 a 16 .Spe ii al Dee nt ur s d n a d r o ntna e a lt DE 48, t ) ctc ly, fnda a gue GAI ba s t s s tbec us t s e oft da h 7 ACU wa i dent lt isr e a r s G r hi ui a e he al he s s nci a o t ol s ma a e of t ar a a De e nuf dur r he iplne s f ndan ha a ongoi dut a m a a e t pr de t d n ng y s nuf dur r o ovi r pl c m e pa t. d.I s e a e nt rs 1 n uppor oft sa gumen , f nda r le on Congr s i t nti ena tng t hi r t De e nt ei s es ' n e n c i GARA t pr debr pr t c i f m a a t e s a GAIA' de a ai t ti çs rede o ovi oad o e ton or nuf c ur r , nd t S clr ton ha t tupe s s a St t l w t t e e t ts h 1w pe t aci la ton .... l The Cour i unpe s ded ny ae a o he xt nt ha uc a nnis vi c i 'd ' ts r ua byDe enda ' r tonae. f nts ai l l i unque to bl t tone oft pur esofGARA i t pr de br pr e tonst ts si na e ha he pos s o ovi oad ot c i o ma a t e s M or sgni nt howe r i how GARA ba a es t s i ta pum os wih nuf cur r . e i ûca , ve , s l nc hi niil e t t e e vng vitms' rg t brng s t f c pe a i i ce t n pa tc a l c i sri pr ci i ht o i ui or om ns ton n rai ri ulry ompeli lng cr u tnc s' H. RE .NO.1 3 5 41 ( 9 4 (een fe J iir Co te No e j ic msa e . R. P ' 0 -251) 1 9 ) h ri a tr udcay mmi e ts, t rprntd i 1 U . C. A. .1 e i e n 994 S. C. N 644, l l at1 W L 42271 a # De e ntsar avaiab e 994 9, t 5. f nda ' gume nt t tisr e a t aipl m a a t e i ult si fom labiiy f rt s eofar pl e e pa t ha t ol s he r ane nuf c ur r ns a e t r i lt o he al e ac m nt r ta alg dymaf n to e a dc u e ij r i ia p st t t et tlt o t elg sai eitn h t l e l lu cin d n a s d nu y s n p o ie o h oai f h e iltv n e t e y ofGARA asevi nc byt J cir Co mit eN ot : de ed he udi a y m te es Thi lmia i a i swih r pe tt cvi a tonsa i i ou ofça i nt , and i s i tton pple t es c o i l c i rsng t dccde s' ' t i lm ie t cvi a i br s i td o i l ctons ought a i t a man a t e ti is c pa iy a a gans uf c ur r tn t a ct s manuf c ur r'Thel t lm ia i i i t ndedt i ur t tpa teswhoha n t a t e .' ater i tton s n e o ns e ha ri ppe o bema acur r ofa aic af oraco pone pa t r noti nuf t e s n r r t m nt r a e mmuni dfom la lt ze r i biiy te ma b s b e to i s meoh rc p ct h y y e u j c t n o te a a i y. J c a y C om m it e N o es a # N eihe t t ofGA R A nort J ci r Com m it N ot udi i r te t , t 6. t r he ext he udi a y tee es m a me i ofas i e e i f aiplnem a a tle swhot ns l r pl c ment rs The ke nton pecal xc pton or r a nuf c tr r he e l e a e pa t. 5 pr sonsofGARA a islgil i hit yc im t t k Spr e tonsbegi a endwih ovii nd t e satve sor onfr ha GA1A' ot c i n nd t t De e he f ndan ' r ea amanuf cur r TheCour doe no fnd t r t bea s ts ol s a t e. t s t i he e o ny uppor i t t xt t n he e o GARA o i t J iir Co te Noe t j tf t e e tnso o t a p oe to t t e f r n he udcay mmite ts o usiy h x e in f h t r tcin o h Def nda whe i a t i o he ca ctes See alo Smih v Ce s a Aic atCo ,Ca eNo e nt n t c s n t r pa ii . s t s n r rj . s . . 6:0 CV- 4 ORL- KRS,2 1W L 51 8 31 t* ( . Fl.S p .21 2 1.Id e ,t e 1 - 27 31 01 7 3 ,a 2 M D. a e t , 01 ) n e d h J d cayCo te Noe a vo aej s teo po i . u iir mmi e ts d c t u t h p st t e W ih r a d t t pr mpton is ,De e t eg r o he ee i s ue f ndan a guest tPl i ifca ts De e nt tr ha antf nno ue f nda a as lt unde Fl i ssrd la lt lwsbe a eGAIA t upe s desa St t lw t t e e s e lr r orda' ti ibiiy a c us A d re s ny ae a o he xtnt t ts h lw pemisacvi a ton de ci i s e ton ()'( #1 a 4) Aspr ousy ha uc a r t i l ci s rbed n ubs ci a . DE 65, t . ' evi l d su s d te lmiain st o t i s b e to () tn u e t a his wh h pp n t b ic se , h i tto s e u n u s cin a s s r h tpa e o a e o e i manuf t e sofa a r r to a c acur r n ic af r omponen pa tar noti uni d fom labiiy t y ma be t r e mm ze r i lt he y s be tt i s meoh rc p ct . J dcayCo te Noe , t* . u te mo e t J dcay u j c o n o te a a iy' u iir mmite t s a 6 F rh r r , he u iir ' Comm it eNo esi c t t twher t sa ut ofr ei i pplca e ie, hetm e r m eha te t ndia e ha e he tt e epos s na i bl . .t i fn s note r ort de e n i notbeng s i isc pa iy asam a acur r sst t 1 w wil xpied he f nda t s i ued n t a ct nuf t e - s a e a l co i t go l f l unf te e by Fe r i ere e .'I Thus GARA doe no pr bi ntnue o ve. uly, et r d n de al nt f r nce' d , s t ohi t Pli iffom brngi a src la lt aci n a i tDe e ntf isr easas le ofapr t antf r i ng tit ibiiy to gans f nda or t ol e lr oduc ta alg dymaf n to e a c u e ij r . h t le e l lu cin d nd a s d nu y B. o laSt t eo po e Fl rd aut fRe s Fl i ' Stt eofRe epr cl spr tla lt aci nsbr orda s a ut pos e ude oduc ibiiy to oughtf a oc ure a or n c r nce t la t 2y asa tr eie yo ap o uc. L S AT j9 .31( )b . fn a t r u sha Flrd ' e s 1 e r fe d l r f r d tF A. T . 50 2 ( )De e d n ag e t t o ia s v St t e ofRe eba st ss tbe a et a r anewasdelve e mor t 1 ye r prort t aut pos r hi ui c us he ipl i rd e han 2 a s i o he i i nt ( #1 a 5) Conrr t Dee n ' agume ,i i ir e ntwhe t arrh was ncde . DE 65, t . tay o fnda ts r nt t s relva n he ica d l ee b c u ePlitf alg st ed s 7ACU t b t ep o u t a c usdteij r . i i ei r d e a s an if le e h a h v o e h r d d h t a e h nu y As t s 6 undiputd t tt das 7ACU wa dei e wihi t ye r oft i i nt t Cour fndst t s e ha he h s lver d t n wo a s he ncde , he t i ha t Fl i St t eofRe edoe notba t ss t he orda aut pos s r hi ui. I .C o us on V ncl i Uponca e ulc i r ton oft pl a ngsa t Pa te a g nt , heCo tfndst t r f onsde ai he e di nd he ris' r ume s t ur i ha GARA i i pplca ewhe eDef nda i s di t ca c t ofas le , r hert n i t capaciy s na i bl r e nt s ue n he pa iy el r at ha n he t ofam a uf dur . Cour f t fndst tFl rda' Stt eofRe ei i pplc bl whe e a n a er The t urher i ha o i s aut pos s na i a e r c mp n n p alg dt b t ec us o ij r s eie e t nt el - e ri tton ' e id o o e t m l e o e h a e fn u ywa d l rdwi h z y a l ai s p ro , e v hi mi r a dl s oft dei r dae oft aiplne. eg r e s he lve y t he r a Ac r ngy, co di l uponc i r tonof her c da onsde a i t e or ndbei ot r s a s d,ti O RDERED, ng he wie dvie i s ADJUDGED, DECREED t tPli ifsM oi frPa ilSummay( #138)be, ndt and ha antf ton o rta r DE a he s mei he e GRANTED, a s r by, l i f t rO RDERED,ADJUDGED,and DECREED t Def ndan Ces na Aic a t t s urhe hat e t s rrf Compa sM otonf SummayJ ny' i or r udgme ( #149)be a t s mei hee DENI nt DE , nd he a s rby, ED. DO NE a ORDERED i c mbe sa t J m e La e eKi Fede al usi eBuidi nd n ha r t he a s wr nc ng r J tc l ng a Unie Stt Courho e, im i Fl i ,t s 1 h da ofDe e be , nd td aes t us M a , orda hi 4t y c m r 2011 . ? vA M ES LA W N CE K I G N UN I TED STA TES DI STRI J D G E CT U SOU TH ERN D I STRI O F FLO RI CT DA 7 CC: Co ns l o Pl i t s u ef r ant Aaron Sam uelPodhurs t Pod s Orec J efbe g e a hurt s k os s r t l CiyNa i Ba Buidi t tonal nk l ng 25 W Fl e Ste t agl r r e Suie 800 t M im i FL 331 1 n , 30- 780 305- 835 2800 Fa 305- 238 x: 358- 2 Emala o h rt o h rt o i: p d u s@p d u s. m c Le P Val vi a di a PodhurtOr e k, A. s s c P. 25W es Fl glrStee t a e r t Suie 800 t M i i FL 331 am , 30 3 0578 94209 Emal ladva d urtc m i:v l ii@po h s.o A l xande R undl t e r e Podhur tOr e k, A . s s c P. CiyNai lBnnkBuidi t tona l ng 25 W Flgl rSte t a e re Suie 8 t 00 M i m i FL 331 0- 78 a , 3 1 0 305- 2800 358Fa 305- 2382 x: 358- Emal at lt p d u s.o i: rmde@ o h rtc m R i ar M . ar i z c i c do M tne - d Pod s O r e k,P. . hur t s c A CiyNai na Ba Buidi t to l nk l ng 25 W Flgl Ste t a er r e Suie 8 t 00 M i m i FL 331 1 a , 30- 780 305- 358 2800 Fa 305- 2382 x: 358- Emalr i o h rtc m i:mcd@p d u s.o Co n efo Dee d ntCes u sl r f n a sna H enry M orri K nobl son ock W is El e M os lon s r kowiz Edel a & Di ke LLP t m n c r 1 Sout s Se ond Stee 00 hea t c r t Suie 3800 t M i m i FL 331 - 26 a , 31 21 8 305- 4400 374Fa 57 0261 x: 9- Emal h A . o lc wis n le .o i: a u bo k@ lo esrc m St phe Fr e Coxhead e n as r W is n Ele M os lo s r kowizEdel & Dike LLP t man c r 1 Sout a tSe ond Ste t 00 he s c re Suie 38 t 00 M i m i FL 331 a , 31 305- 4 374- 400 Fa 305- 0261 x: 579- Emal se .o h a @wis n le .o i: tvec x e d lo esrc m Chrit phe Da d Br s o r vi own W is n Ele lo s r 1 SE 2nd St e t 00 re Suie 38 t 00 M i m i FL 331 a , 31 305- 4 374- 400 Fa 305- 0261 x: 579- Emal c so h rb o @wis n le.o i: bitp e .r u lo es rc m 9
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
