Thomas, et al v. Blue Cross, et al, No. 1:2003cv21296 - Document 2133 (S.D. Fla. 2012)
Court Description: ORDER granting 2107 Motion for Preliminary Injunction Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 9/18/2012. (cbe)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Thomas, et al v. Blue Cross, et al Doc. 2133 fX UN I TED STA TES DI STRI CO U RT FO R TH E CT SO U TH ERN DI STRI OF FLO RI A CT D M im iDi son a vii M as e Fie N o.00tr l 1334- D - O REN O M M Cas N um ber 03e : 21296- I - O R EN O C V M I RE: AN A G ED CA RE LI GA TI N M TI ON RI LOV E, . . e al, CK M D,t . Pl i if , a ntf s VS. BLUE CR OSS AN D BLU E SH I ELD A SSO CI TI ,etal, A ON . De e f ndant. s ORDER GR ANTI M O TI FO R PR ELI I NG ON M NARY I NJUNCTI ON THI M ATTER c S ame be or t Cour upon M ovant Amende M oton f Pr lmi r f e he t ' s d i or e i na y lj to ( E.No.2107) fldonM ar h 23.2012.Seti Defnda Bl Cr sBl Shil nuncin D. , ie c tlng e nt ue os ue ed o Ne J re ( rz n mo e f ra o d re f ri ij ncin a an tPlitf Dr De p k f w esy Ho io ) v s o n r e n o cng nu to g is an if . e a Srni ns n. M ova a s r st Pl i ifi pr e ng wih a s a e c t ton i vi a i of i va a The nt s e t he a ntf s oc edi t t t our ac i n ol ton t sCour ' or r hi t de s. s 1.Background On J 22, 1Pl ntf D e pak Srni s n fl a s a e c ta i D e paksr ni a an, une 201 ai i f e i va a ied t t our cton, e i vs M D.v Bl Cr s Bl Shil o w Je sy,I ,i t Supe i Cour ofNe J re La . ue o s ue ed fNe r e nc. n he ror t w es y, w Di son,Bege Cot y ( D31 11 .ncl d i t compli aet nt c srngi fom vii r n mt L- 4- ) l ude n he ant r we y ount a ng r t tousi e f r nc t m i r pr s nt ton, n a tont s ve a vi a i of e J r e s a ut sa ori nt r e e e o s e e e a i i ddii o e r l ol tons N w e s y t t e nd rg lto s Hoio fldap ei n r ij n to i t sc u toe j i Pli tf fo algnga y e uain . rz n ie rlmiay nu cin n hi o r t no n anifr m l i n e Dockets.Justia.com cai r e s d i t s tl ntag ee t e e e byt Bl Pa te i t sCour . Pl i if l ms ela e n he e teme r men s nt r d he ue ri s n hi tThe antf s bs uen l a u eq ty mende is c d t ompli on M a c 1 201 Horzon now m ovesf a pr i i r ant r h 6, 2. i or elm na y ij tona or rt s c us whyt Pl ntf s dnotpeme nel wihdrw hi Ne nunci nd de o how a e he ai if houl r na ty t a s w J r e a ton. es y ci l t Amende Co pl nt t Pli ifa tmpt t c r e ou a exc pton t t fov n he d m ai , he a ntf te s o a v t n e i o he e stlme t s do h tmi o whe h cams l g dyao e t wi:' l sa n e Co lit ete n ba e nt e i ng f nt e li al e l r s ,o t 'thi me d d mp an e l a es e onl t e cai s whih eihe we e no i ude i t Lo Sete e ,or a os ddr s s y hos l m c t r r t ncl d n he ve tl m nt r e s e ntt t Ef e tveDaeoft LoveSete e , nd/ a os pos t Te mi to Daeof ubs que o he f c i t he tlm nt a or r e t he r nai n t t eLo S tlme t'Ho io s e s t e j i t ePlitf o teg o n st a al f scamsae h ve ete n . rz n e k o no n h an if n h r u d h t 1o hi li r ' rlas camsand t tt r i no c r e- f hi camsunde j 7. m)oft stlme ee ed li ha hee s a v out or s li r 29( he ete nt ag e m e . aitf r pondst tea h team e ofpa int c tt e ane c us ofa ton,a r e nt Pl n if es ha c r t nt te s onsiut s w a e c i nd ass h, he a e notba r by t Lov s tl e . uc t y r r ed he e e tem nt I Anal i I. yss Thelng a uageoft Cour' Fi Appr he ts nal ovalOr rcea l pr hi t Cls m e r fom i tai de l ry o bis a s mbe s r niitng lws t a i tr l s d pa tesf a cai sr e ed by t s tl m e .Thi Cour,t r or a uis gans eea e ri or ny l m elas he e te nt s t he ef e, mus ga t etigDee d n ' moinit rec n iin e it()tePlitf i a ca sme e ' t r n S tln fn a ts to f l e o dto s xs:i h anif s ls mb r l , (i Hoioni arl s dpa t undert stlme 'a (i)t cli a is i t Srnias i) rz s eea e ry he ete nt nd ii he ams t sue n he i v an , co pli a er l as d cli Bec us t Pli tf i acls m e be ,he Def nda i ar e e m a nt r e e e a ms. a e he a n if s a s m r t e nt s elas d pa t a hi cli sa e r l as d cai s t Def nda ' m oto i gr nt d a t Pli ifha ry, nd s am r e e e l m , he e nts i n s a e nd he antf s t e t da f om t da e oft s or rt w ihdr w iscl i s i D e pak Sr ni an,M D .v.Bl w n y ys r he t hi de o t a t a m n e i vas ue Cr s BleShil o w Jese l . o s u ed fNe r y, nc W. rnv s ni aca sme e ,ai d t o ou o h ca s a da cptdmo e o teLo e S iia a s ls mb rf l o pt t fte ls, n c e e n yh'm h v e Se teme tl nt Pl i if Dee k Srni an i a i s ve ca di ogi tlc ns d t pr tc m edi ne a a ntf pa i vas s n nva i r ol s i e e o ac i e ci nd s ge yi e J r e ThePl i i fcl i st thekne no hi a utt fov ca et tl orz s ur r nN w e s y. a ntf a m ha w t ng bo he e s m i H i on' iiil to f rp ei nayij n to wa fldi De e e o 2 1 Ne e tee s h d e no n ta moin o rlmi r nu cin s ie n c mb r f 01 . v rh ls , e o s t di put t the i a cl s m e be a t the di no optou oft cl s Srni a s a e t the s e ha s a s m r nd ha d t t he as . i vas n t t s ha e c edadoc e fom hi bil a r c i d $598. f pr - fe tve daecli .Heas e t xe ut um nt r s ler nd e e ve 98 or e e f c i t a ms s rs t the w oul ne ha s g d t docu e s ha he known t e e of t f/v s t l m en . ha d ver ve i ne he m nt d he xt nt he e e te t Srni a a lge i hi New Je s c i vas n le s n s rey ompli t Horzonsilowesove $ 000, f s r i e ant hat i tl r 2, 000 or e v c s pe f ronne snc t e f tveda eoft ftv Sete e . d i e he feci t he lc tlm nt #.Horz i aree e ion s las dpary unde t s te nt t r he etl me l i undiput d t tHorz i ar las d Bl pl n unde t fov s le e . ts s e ha ion s ee e ue a r he e etlm nt C. ni as s c Sri v an' ompl nti ude r l e c ai ai ncl s e eas d l ms The c u oft m ai i s be o e t cou tcom es diec l f om t l ngua oft fov r x he n s ue f r he r r ty r he a ge he e s tl m e is l . a ntf Sr ni a f eson t fr tha foft s a e e i ia i s Def nda e te nt t e f Pl i if i vas n ocus he i s l he t t m nt n t lc ; e nt Horzo f us son t s c hafoft saeme fom t s tlm e a e m e i bol i n oc e he e ond l he t t nt r he ete nt gr e nt n d: Upon t Efe tve Dae t ' l s d Pa tes('s l be rl s d and f e r he fci t, he ' ea e ri 1' hal eea e Re orve di c r d f om a and a lca e ofa t o ofw ha eve ki s lc orcha a t rwhe he s ha ge r ny l us s c i n t r nd, otr e rce t r a i i unde an f de alorsa e lw,whih i ude ,buti notlm ie t t Ra ke e r rsng r y e r tt a c ncl s s i t d o, he c t e l l nce a Com z Or ni a i A c ,a ir t a o he s a ut y a c m on 1 w ntue d nd pt ga z tons t ntt us nd t r t t or nd om a cams itnina o n n itnina, rsn o o bf r t eE fcieDa e ta a e we e li ,ne to l r o -ne to la iig n r eo e h fe tv t,h t r , r o c udh v b e a s re a ais o h Ree s dPa te , y r a o o , ii o to , r o l a e e n s e td g n tfte la e ris b e s n f arsng u f or i anyway rel n ated to any oft f ,act e he acts s, vent t s, ransact ons,occurrences cours i , es ofc onduc , i s pr i es re e e a i , is ons ci c t e o ot rm ate s t bus ne s actc , pr s nt t ons om s i , r ums anc s r he tr rf r n e i teAcin o a d e s d i t i Ag e me t wheh ra y s hcam wa o eee c d n h t , r d r s e n hs r e n , te n uc li s r o co d ha be n as e t d by a Re e i Pa t on is o n be l or on be l of o he ul ve e s r e ny l as ng r y t w ha f ha f t r Pes n a t t eb sn s p a tc s h t r t es b e tj7. i icud s wih u l tto ro s s o h u i e s r cie t a ae h u j c Th s n l e , to ti ain mi a t R e e ed Pa tesonl a a pe tofa f e f s r i e cl i s s it d by a cl s s o l as ri y, ny s c ny e or e v c a m ubm te ny a s me rt aBl Pln. mbe o ue a Se to 1 1a (mp a i a d d .Th s Plitf f c s so t ed t o whc Dr S i ia a wa cin 3.() e h ss d e ) u , anif o u e n h ae n ih . rnv sn s de edpa nt a Def nda f us onhow t ' our e of ni yme s nd e nt oc es he ' s s conduc 'behi t ale dpa m e c t' nd he l ge y nt de al a e vi t ly i ntc lt t f c ua pr c t s be nd t fove a l ga i . ni s r rua l de i a o he a t l edi a e hi he le tons Spe f c ly, . i vas n i hi co pl nts a e t tt a e d c pl i o y a i s cii a l Dr Srni a n s m ai t t s ha he m nde om a nt nl pple t c ai sm a s e o lm de ubs quent o t e f c i da e oft ftv Se tem e . orzon,o t ot rhand, t he f e tve t he / : tl nt H i n he he s a est tt br d l ngua ofr e e i l sc t t ha he oa a ge el as nc ude onduc a i i outoft s m ecour esofc t r s ng he a s onduc t a t tal ge i t fov s tlm e . di Dr Srni s sc s ha le d n he e ete ntRea ng . i va an' ompl i , saleg i do,nf c , ant hi l atons i a t r ae t sm iar c elt o i l onduc a t Lov a lga i .He ma s s cii a gum e s r ga di a t s he e le tons ke pe fc r nt e r ng c pia yt dely,de o di nihpa nt. e mpl,i !76oft compli healg ons rc o a ny, r mi s yme s For xa e n he ant le ed t tH o i on e ha r z ngag i ' e i lunde pa m e ofoutof ne wor us , t a y and r as bl ed n ' r a s r y nt - - t k ual cus om r e ona e (' 'a ' UCR' mount g c as pr s e ma he t c epr de s whoot wiewoul hav ) s whihj lo esurd ny alh ar ovi r , her s d e rman d o to n t r t j i Ho io ' newo k o pr vd r a d a c ptHo io sd e l e ie u f ewo k o on rz ns t r f o ie s n c e rz n' e py d so ne c n rc r i u sme t ae . Smi ryi !8 ' rz nh sfie t d s ls ta i ic u td o ta t emb re n rts' i l l n 8: ' io a ald o ico e h tt ' a Ho us sispa e t yments he e t de di i s and dely pa c m s o ny, m nih, a ymentf rc r d,m e c l ne es a y o ove e dialy c s r s r ies'Fi ly,i ! 1 ' rzon,i ta ofpa ngpli iff rcoveed, ial ne say e vc . nal n 03:' i nse d ' Ho yi antf o r medc ly ces r s r i esi a or nc w ih s a r c ng pr c i e ,has e ge i a s he e t s t m a i a l e v c n cc da e t t nda d odi a tc s nga d n c m o ys e tc ly de di i s a de a pa m e st pl n if ' ny, m nih, nd l y y nt o ai t f . ' The no i e ofs t l m e tpa ge s ntt a1 po e i lc a sm e be s a l s m a i est tc e te n cka e o l t nta l s m r pty um r z he ftv: cas p e: The Com pl i i t A c i a l ge ,a ong o he t ngs t tbe wee a nt n he ton le s m t r hi , ha t n 1 a t pr en , heBl Pa te , m ong ot r , ngage i a c pi a y t i pr pery 999 nd he es t t ue r i s a he s e d n ons r c o m o l de del y,a orr duc pa m e st ny, a nd/ e e y nt o ph i a ,phys c a g oups a phys ci n or ni a i by e gi ys ci ns i in r , nd i a ga z tons nga ng i s ve a t s ofa l ge y i pr rco uc ,i l ng butnotlm ie t n e r l ype le dl m ope nd t nc udi i t d o: *M ir pr e i a orf lng t dic os t us ofedist uniae al S se es ntng nd/ aii o s l e he e t o l tr ly t bundl ' e, ' S o o e'a do rj c camsf rme ial n c s ayc v r ds r ie ; t wnc d , n /r ee t li o dc l e e s r o ee e vc s d ' y .Falngt pa frç di lyne sa f' e vc si a c da ewihme rpl ii o y o d cal ce sr s r ie n c or nc t mbe an me docume s nt ; *Faii a orr us ng t r c lng nd/ ef i o e ogni e CPT* m odi i r ; z fe s *Conce lng a orm i r pr s ntng t us of i pr r gui i a c ie i t a i nd/ s e e e i he e m ope delnes nd r t r a o den del y,a orr duc pa m e f r m e c ly ne es a y co r d s r i e ; y, a nd/ e e y nt o di a l c s r ve e e v c s *M i r pr s ntng a orr f i t di c os a i a e f s he e. s e e e i nd/ e usng o s l e pplc bl ee c dul .Fa lng t pa c a m s f rm e ca l ne s ar c r d s v c w ihi t r quied ii o y l i o di ly ce s y ove e er i es t n he e r s a ut r a / c r c ua tm e pe i . t t o y nd or ont a t l i rods The Compli i t Ac i c am st tt c a nt n he ton l i ha he onduc des i d a t crbe bove vi aed t f de al ol t he e r saut e il t Ra kee rI l nce a Co z Or aniatonsAc,18U. C.j1 , tt e ntted he c te ntue d nd m pt g z i t S. 961 etseq. D. 1 E. 385- a 3. 5 t Co r c l w go m st i e pr t to ofs tl m e ag e m ent M unr v U S. nt a t a ve he nt r e a i n e te nt r e s. oe . Foodse v. r , 985So. 65 655( a.1 tDCA 2008) Si lry,ar e eofcai i astlme a ee nt 2d 4, Fl s . mia l elas l ms n e te nt gr me c tt t sac r c . e eg. P ' M Er ct s I . M i e e Cor ,867 So. 1 2,1 -54 onsiu e onta t Se , . , r e or , nc v. ddls x p. 2d 25 253 ( a. hDCA 2004) I i eprtngac rc,aFl i co ti tgui d trtbyt lnguag of F1 4t .n ntr ei onta t orda ur s ç de is he a e t c r ctis l a wher t con r c i c e randuna bi he onta te f nd e he ta t s l a m guoust r i nor s t gof rhe . he e s ea on o ' t r' u ' f . r o ab Cop. fAm. . Ko , 2 S 2 31 , 3( a 5hDCA 2 0 ) ç an u g i ad c me t v Mc wn 8 9 o.d 1 31 F1. t 0 2 .da g a e n o u n t i am bi s guousw he i i unc r a n i m ea ng a m a be f ry unde sood i m or w a t one n t s e ti n ni nd y ail rt n e ys han a i s c ptbl ofi e pr t ton i oppost wa . Bar t v D e tn O wne . As n I ,856 nd s us e i e nt r e a i n ie ys' ' ne t . s i y rç s', nc. So. 1 1 ( a 1 tDCA 2003 .' he et tr aeuna guoust pa te 'ne mus 2d 090, 092 Fl. s ) W r he ems r mbi ,he ris itnt t bedic r dfom t f c soft doc nt'Do v. k ,I ,8 So. 595,601( a. s ene r he our onwr he ume . ws Nie nc. 46 2d ' F1 4t DCA 2003) h . W ih t ts m a y a Fl i l w i m i t sco tm us a yz w he he t Pl ntf s t ha um r nd orda a n nd, hi ur t nal e t r he ai i f c pl nts r s t ' a e oper tve nuc e of f t'a t fov s tl e ,t t i ,whe e t om ai ha e he ' m s ai l us ac ' s he e e tem nt ha s r he ' i a y rghta dut ' r t s m e. ' m r i nd y'a e he n Thom asv Bl Cr s andBl Shi l s' 333 Fe A ppx. pr . ue os ue e dAs n, d. 41 41 ( 1h Ci.2009)Thos rght a dute wer ' ue Cr s conrcua duyt pa is 4, 8 1 t r . e i s nd is e ' Bl os' ta t l t o y t dodor f rmedialynec s a yc r gi t iscle s a t doc or ' nta t rg t r c ve so c l e s r a e ven o t int , nd he t s co r c ual i ht o e ei t m one ' I A c or ng t t pl i m e ni of t s te e a e e ,t e cl i s a e he y. d ' c di o he a n a ng he etl m nt gr em nt hos a m r r la e whih'na ywa eae)oa yo tefcsa t, v n sta s cinso c re c sc u ss ee s d c ' n yr lt lt n fh a t,cs e e t,rn a to , c u rn e ,o re i ofc onduc , i s pr c i s r pr s nttons omisons cr sanc orot rm a tr r fr nc d tbusne s a tce ,e e e a i , s i , icum t es he te s ee e e t Acin. S tlme t Ag e me t j 1 1a .Th s t i c u tmu td tr n wh te Dr he to ' ete n r e n , 3.() u h s o r s eemie eh r . ' Srni a scl m sf lwihi r e s d c ai sby t pl i unn bi i vas n' ai al t n el a e l m he a n m guousm e ni oft doc e . a ng he um nt G i n t ne ry i ntc l ngua us d i Pl ntf sc pl ntr ga di a s he et de de a ve he a l de i al a ge e n ai if om ai e r ng c m o ny, l y, a r uc pa nd ed e yment f m e cal ne es a y s r i s t s Cour m us fnd t tt cli s a e s or di ly c s r e vce , hi t t i ha he am r r e s dcams Ree e camsi l t et t'rse o of'hes me' oureofc ela e li . las d li ncude hos ha ' ig) ut t a ' s a c onduc. t' ' Thef c sasa lge by Srni s n a et tHorz e at le d i va a r ha ion ngag i pa nts m e t den di i s ed n yme che s o y, m nih a d a pa e s a e ged i s i unde pa en not i a or nc w ih s a r c ng nd el y ym nt nd nga n ad r ym t n cc da e t t nda d odi pr c i s Fr t orgi lc pl i t t a e d com pl ntt Pl i ifr m ove r e e es a tce . om he i na om a nt o he m nde ai he a ntf e d ef r nc t c put s t m s s a l ni us i f r he anc oft s he e buts ilr e r d t . The o om er ys e uch s nge x ed n u t r e he c m tl ef r e o f c sa aleg i t fov s tlm e we et tt Bl Pari sf ie t dic os t us ofe t a t s l ed n he e e te nt r ha he ue te al d o s l e he e dis t rj c cams frme ial ne e sr c v r d s r ie a / rt d n ,di nih a d rd c o ee t li o dc l c say o ee e vc s ndo o e y mi s n e u e y pa e st phys ci ns Thi co z s ofc ym nt o i a . s lr e onduc i ne ry i ntc l t s a l de i a . The El ve h Cic tha gi n cl a g da on t i e r t ton oft fov s tl e e nt r ui s ve e r ui nce he nt m e a i he e e tem nt a e m e .t nde t s tl m e ag ee en e er d i t c as a ton,t r l va i r f r gr e nt s u r he e te nt r m t nt e n he l s c i he e e nt nquiy o de e m i ng w he he a c a m i r e e i not he he t a t gi ng rs t t c pl i oc ur e t r ni t r l i s el as d s w t r he c s vi i e o he om a nt c r d a t rt c a s a ton w asfl d o t s t l m e ta ee e w a e e ed, whe he t y oc ur e fe he l s c i ie r he el e n gr m nt s nt r but t r he c r d a t rt efec i da e oft s tl m en a e m e . Thom as v Bl Cr s and Bl Shi dAs ' fe he f tve t he e te t gr e nt' ' . ue o s ue el s n, e al,594F. 81 822( 1hCi. 0)( bus) ctc l t Elve hCic tf eson t . 3d 4, 1 t r201 Kol z .Spe ii aly,he e nt rui ocus t Sa t gi ng r s t ' he co pl nt no t i vi ltea m entofpl i if .I l Kol s a he t c s vi i e o' t m ai , t he ndi dua r t a ntf s d n bu z, cls me a s mber doc or br ht cli i Ilnoi sae co t al gi t tous i t re e e and t oug a ms n li s t t ur le ng ori n e f r nc de a ai by a s tlngdef nda .Kol za lged t tt de e nthe lh i ur ec pa f m ton e ti e nt bus le ha he f nda a t ns anc om ny i e f r dwihhi pa int bym o f l r usngt pa f m e c l ne s my pr e es I a nt re e t s te s ng uly ef i o y or dialy ce s oc dur . d t 8 2.l rvesn t c u ts d na o a mo in t e f r e ij nci n t e Elv n h Cic t 2 n e ri g he o r' e il f to o n o c nu to , h e e t rui hi i ht d t br a h oft r l s lng ge:t- ca m r las e e t ç ny a a lca e ghlg e he e dt he eea e a ua û-he li ee e xt nds o a nd 1 us s l o aci .. whae rki s c orc r c e 't ta er lt d t m a tr a e s d i t c a s f ton .of t ve nd, our e ha a tr ha r e ae o te s ddr s e n he l s ac i n,nc udi ç ntt us a o he s a ut yand c m o 1 w cl i s it ntona or to i l ng a ir t nd t r t t or om n a a m , n e i l non-nt nto l i e i na ... t t a e w e e,or c d ha be n as e t d a i ta oft Rel as Pa tes ''f Se alo ha r , r oul ve e s r e ga ns ny he e ed r i . ' #. e s Docor Healh,nc,v Aena,tal,605F.d 11 11 ( 1hCi. 0)(çt herla elng ge ts tI .. t e . 3 46, 52 1 t r 201 &@) ee s a ua i cea ;tco e sonl ca mst tcoul ha be a s re t edon ora i i fom t f cual s l r i nc m y li ha d ve en s e td bas rsng r he a t algai oft L le tons he shaneqCompli .) ant'. ' Con r r t t Pl i ifsas e ton, he c t oul not gr ntng H or z i ul ton fom t a y o he a ntf s r i t our w d be a i i on ns a i r l w s t i pe pet t I t a s a r lng w oul f us on t c t de e m i ton t tt e a uis n r uiy. ns e d, uch u i d oc he our ' t r na i ha hes s a l ga i s e f om t s m e nuc eusoff c a t e di c r ed b t s tlng de e nt i ftv le tons t m r he n l a t s hos s ha g y he e t i f nda s n l c t tocc r d be or t e f tveda eoft s tlm e .Ast cr ui c tsaed i Kol s , he ha ure f e he feci t he e te nt he ic t our t t n bu z t o l d t tedsrc c u t h u dc n ie t eh r( ea to s o c r da trteefcied t n y ae h itit o r s o l o sd r d t e t cin ) c ure fe h fe tv ae wh h oft s tl nta ee nt' Tha nuc e of f ti t s he e t de di i s a d a he eteme gr me .' t l us ac s he c m o ny, m nih, nd ely pa e st ough t em e hodsa de c i i t ftv com pl i . r Sr ni s n i f e t a end ym nt hr hos t s s rbed n he ? c a nt D . i va a s r e o m hi co ant i al w e byt N e J r e saec tt two d cea l andune voc lys to s mpli ,f lo d he w e s y t t our,ha ul l ry qui a l e ut hi c a m sw iho m e i ng a hi a s li t ut ntoni nyt ng boutt s m e nucl us off c of c he a e a t onduc t oc r t hat cured be or 1 butonl a f e 999 y boutca mst twe enotpa toft s tlm e ag e m e . Spe fca l Dr li ha r r he e te nt r e nt cii ly, . Srni s n c n o y r que t y e f tea m e pr de a t rt e f c i da eoft s tl m e t i va a a nl e s pa m nt or r t nt ovi d fe he f e tve t he e te n a r em e . pa tes s t l m en c ea l co e pl t sasa end oft pe i ofM a of2011a g e nt The r i ' e te t l ry nt m a e n he rod y nd t onl c am sf te t e a trt tda e s d bea l d. hus y l i or r am nt fe ha t houl lowe 1 1 C oncl i 1. us on THE CO URT has c i r t m oto a t pe tne por i oft r co d.Fort r s ons de ed he i n nd he r i nt tons he e r he ea ons gi n above i i ve ,t s AD JUD G ED t tt m oton i G RAN TED . Furhe ha he i s t nnor i i e, t s ADJUDGED t tPl nifDr Dee kSrni s nha t nt ( da fom t daeoft ha aitf . pa i va a s we y 20) ys r he t he Cour' Or rt w ihdr w oram e a loft c ai st ta e as e t d i D e pak Sr ni as ,M D . t de o t a s nd 1 he l m ha r s r e n e i v an v Bl eCr s Bl eShedo w J re , n .ftecamsaen t t rwna do d s se ,h . u o s u il fNe es y I cj h li r o wi a n /r imis d te hd Cour w ilor rt pl i ifbe de m e i c em ptoft c t a w hi h poi a he r ng wilbe t l de he a ntf e d n ont he our , t c nt a i l s he e t de e m i t a opra er medybe or e r ofatna or ofcontm pt I i f rhe c duld o t r ne he ppr it e f e nty i l der e .t s u t r ADJUDGED t tPa te Joi Moton f Ne Brei Sc dul ( E.No.2098)i ha ris' nt i or w ifng he e D. s D EN I A S M O OT. ED W D N A DO D RDiCabraMi i li,i vdyfet br 02 O E N R E E n hme t a , od ts aoSpme21. s m F rahY e , FEDE CH I EF Copi spr de t e ovi d o: Counselofr d ecor . OREN O I TED STATES DI STRI CTJUD GE
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
