Thomas, et al v. Blue Cross, et al, No. 1:2003cv21296 - Document 2131 (S.D. Fla. 2012)
Court Description: ORDER granting 2092 Defendant Blue Cross Blue Shield of Florida's Motion to Enforce Injunction and denying as moot Defendant's 2086 2092 Motions for Extension of Time. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 9/18/2012. (cbe)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Thomas, et al v. Blue Cross, et al Doc. 2131 N UNI TED STATES DI STRI COURT FOR THE CT SOUTHERN DI STRI OF FLORI CT DA M i m iD i s on a vi i M as e Fie N o.00- 334- D - O R ENO tr l 1 M M Cas Numbe 03- 296- V- ORENO e r: 21 CI M I RE:M ANAGED CARE LI GATI N TI ON RI LOVE, . ,e al, CK M D. t . Pl i if , antfs VS. BLUE CRO SS AN D BLU E SHI ELD A SSO CI O N , e al, ATI t . Def nt . enda s O R DER G M NTI G M O TI N T O EN FO R C E I N O NJU N CT I N O TH I M A TTER C= e be or t Cour upon M ova ' Re wedM oton f O r rEnf c ng S f e he t nts ne i or de or i lj n to ( E. . 0 2)fldo br r 1 2 2. eti gDe e d n BleCr s u S il nu cin D. No 2 9 ,i nFe ua v 6. 01 S tln fn a t u os Ble hed e o Fo i amo e f r no d re f ri ij n to a ans sxPlitfs Ph sca sS r ia Gr u f lrd v s o a r e n o cng nu cin g i t i an if ' y iin u g c l o p, . LLC,Napl Physc a Sur c Gr es ii ns gial oup,LLC,PSG ofSou h Fl rda, LLC, PSG ofBoca LLC, t oi , Sa t r Sur ca Ce e , nc ua y gi l nt r LLC , nd Gl di us Sur c lCe er The M ovantas e t t Pl i if a a ol gi a nt . s r s he a ntf s a e pr ee ng i vi a i oft s Cour ' or r . r oc di n ol ton hi t de s s 1.B ackground O n O c obe 27, 0, ai if fl a c pl i syl Sanct y Su gi alCe e , LL C,e t r 201 Pl ntf s ied om a nt t ed uar r c nt r t aIv.Bl Cr san ueShil fFl i ,I .CaeNo.1 c 81 HURLEY i t Sout r . & ue os dBl . edo orda nc, s 0-v- 260n he hen Di t i t of Fl i ,alegi vi a i of EY SA a pl n t r s by Bl Cr s Bl Shi l of s rc or da l ng ol tons nd a e m ue os ue e d Fl i .ThePl i if i l sx physc a gr ,f ofwhom t De e nta lge pr tc orda antfs nc ude i ii n oups our he f nda le s aci e Dockets.Justia.com tr ug p y iins oaeLo eca s mbesBCBS tldamo int e o c ij n to o t h o h h sca wh r v ls me r. F ie to o nfr e nu cin n he g ounds t tt pli if we e pr bied fom pr e tng t ac i Thi Cour r e r d t r ha he antf s r ohi t r os cu i he ton. s t efr e he mo i a M a sr t J ton, nd gitae udgeTorese e e aRe t ndRec r nt r d por a omm e ton fndi t t hem o i nda i i ng ha t ton wasi ompl t J nc ee. udge Toressaed t tt r or wasi qua e t s r t t ha he ec d nade t o uppor a fndi t tt t i ng ha he Pli if we er l sng pa te ort tt cli swe er e e cai s Ther por r commende antfs r eea i ris ha he am r elas d l m . e te d gr ntng t pa tes a ni y da di c r pe i t a l w t Cour t de e m i ow ne s p of a i he r i net y s ove y rod o lo he t o t r ne r hi c ra n oft Pl i ife ii a t s a usoft cl m s Thi Cour a e ti he a ntf nttes nd he t t he ai . s t dopt d t R & R a g a t d e he nd r n e BCBSF l ve t tl a r ne ea o ie e wed m oto BCBSF tld isr newed m oton on Febr r 1 201 i n. ie t e i ua y 6, 2, a s ri t tiha e de et te c Pl i ifwa ar l asngpary.n t m e ntm e, udgeHlre s e tng ha t d vi nc ha a h antf s e e i t I he a i J zly s a d t ac i pe ng be or hi . t ye he ton ndi f e m 111 A nal s . ysi The l ngua of t Cour ' Fi lA ppr l Or r cl ary pr hi t c a s m e be s f om a ge he ts na ova de e l o bis l s m r r i ta i lws t a i tr e s d pa tesf an cli sr e ed by t s tlm e .Thi Cour niitng a uis gans ela e ri or y am elas he e te nt s q t r or mus grntt s tlngdee ntsmotoni t eeco tonse s:()t Pli if ae heef e, t a he eti fnda ' i f hr ndii xit I he antfs r ca sme es (i BCBS i arla e p ryu d rtestlme t a (i) h camsa is ei ls mb r' i) , F s ee s d at n e h ete n ; nd i t e li t su n i t Sancuar Sur c Ce e c he t y gial nt r ompl i a er e ed cai s ant r elas l m . TheFi A ppr nal oval de Or rpenna nty c r ii as t l m e cl s c m pos oft f l ng ne l e tfed e te nt a s o ed he olowi cls m e r ' a s mbe s . Any a a1 Physc a ,Physcin Gr ps and Phys can Or ni tons who pr de nd 1 ii ns ia ou , ii ga za i ovi d C o r d Se v c s t a Pl n M e be o s r c t a i vi le ole i orc r d ve e r i e o ny a m r r e vi es o ny ndi dua nz l d n ove e by a Pl n of e e o a i s e ed b a Pe s nn e asa de e nti t Com pl i or a f r d r dm ni t r y ny r on m d f nda n he a nt bya ot rprmaylce e oft gntte lorbyan oft i r peci c rntorf mer ny he i r i ns e he e iis y her es tve ure or s i a i orA f ii t s i e h c e fom M ay 22,1 t ough M a 31, ubsdi res fla e , n ac as r 999 hr y 2007 ... Fi lAppr lOr rat!2.TheFi Appr lOr rdefnesrlasdcl msas na ova de nal ova de i ee e ai : a ya alc us so a to j d me t, in ,id b e n s , o t,d ma e , biain , n nd 1 a e f cin,u g n s le s n e td e s c ss a g s o lg to s a t e 'f es l s , l m s la ltesa de ndsofwha e rki s ceorc r c e tonz ys e , os es cai ,ibiii nd ma t ve nd, our ha a t r whehe a ii unde a f de a orsae lw,whi h ...ncudes buti no lmie t t t r rsng r ny e r l t t a c i l , s t i t d o, he Ra t r I l nce a Co r pt Or ani tons Act a ir s and ot r saut r a ckeee nfue d nd r u g zai , nttu t he t t o y nd c ommon 1 w c am s i e i lornon-nt to l...mi i on orbe or t Efeci a l i , nt ntona i en i na sng f e he f tve Da e t ta e, r orco dha be nas e tda ns a oft Relas Pa te byr s t ,ha r we e ul ve e s re gai t ny he e ed ri s ea on o ,a ii outof ori a wa r l td t a o t f c s a t ,e n s ta a tons f rsng , n ny y e ae o ny f he a t , c s ve t , r ns c i , oc ure es c s s of c c r nc , our e onduc , busne s pr ctce , r pr s nt i , omisons t i s a i s e e e atons si , cr um sa es orot rm a tr r f r nc d i t Ac i o a es e i t Se te nt ic t nc he te s e e e e n he ton, r ddr s d n he tl me Agr eme , t ra s hCl m wasorcoul havebe n a s redbya Re e sngPa t e nt whehe ny uc ai d e s et ny l a i ry on isown be l oron be fofo he Pe s ,ort t busnes pr c i st ta et t haf hal t r r ons o he i s a tce ha r he s be t fSe to 7o t Set me t re n . i i ld s wih u l tto a da u j c o cin f he tl n Ag e me t Th s ncu e , to t i ain n s e mi t Ree s dP riso y a ya pe to a yf ef rs r iecam l o la e a t nl, n s c f n e o e vc li . e l Se Fi lAppr Or r!5 e na oval de 1. PSG Pli if Ar Cl s M e be s The a ntfs e a s m r Th mao d s uei t i moini wh te o n t h sxszgc l r u aeca s mb r e j r ip t n h s to s eh r r o t e i l ia g o ps r ls me es r asdetne i t s tlm e a e nt Re e i pa te i t s tl ntf li o t c a s sof i d n he e te nt gr eme . l asng ris n he eleme al nt he l s e çphysc a , ç s ii ns' l i i Gr ups' a t ' physcan o , nd s ii n Or ni tons. Pl i if m ant i t tt i ' physc a ga za i ' antfs i an ha her ' c o aesr t esdonott i oa oft ecaego i . c di t t desg to aspr de om r t tucur k nt ny hes t res Ac or ng o he i nai ns ovi d byt Pl i if ,Sa t r Sur c lCe e , he antfs nc ua y gi a nt r LLC a Gldi usStr i a Ce er LLC a elc ns d nd a ol zg c l nt , r ie e a mbul t y s gia c nt r ,orû c lt Pl ntfs'Ther toft Pli if a e r f re t a t aor ur c l e e s ç iiy ai if . Fa ' es he antf s r e e r d o s he PSG Pl i if a ar no physcin owne c antfs nd e n- i a d ompani . ca eoft ecor aesr ct e ,t es Be us hes por t tu ur s he Pl i if sa e t tnone of t e iis r c ved no i of t fov Se te e .Addii ly, antfs tt ha he ntte e ei tce he e tlm nt tona l Pli if saet tt e oft goups( pl Physca Sur ca Gr PSG ofBoc a PSG antfs tt ha hre he r Na es iins gi l oup, a, nd o SouhFl i )weeor nie afe t efeci daeoft s tlme a e me a t rf e f t orda r ga z d tr he f tve t he ete nt gre nt nd heeor t ercamsc n o beb re b te p r n n ij n to BCBS c u tr t a t e a1o te h i li a n t ar d y h ema e t n u cin. F o n es h t h l f h Pli if f l wihi t pl n m e ni of' i i Gr ps' antfs al t n he ai a ng ' Physcan ou . ' Conta l gove nst i e r t tonofs tl nta e m e s M u oev U S. r ctaw r he nt m e ai e teme gr e nt . nr . Foodse , nz 985 So. 654,655( a.1tDCA 2008 .Si lry,arl s ofcli i as tlme agre nt 2d Fl s ) mial eea e ams n ete nt e me c tt esaco r c . ,e. ,Iï M Er cor , nc v M i e e Cor , S0. 1 onsiut nta t See g. ' ' e t s I . . ddl s x p.867 2d 252,1 3-54 25 ( a.4t DCA 200 .I i eprtng a c r t acour i f ded frtb t lnguag oft F1 h 4) n ntr ei ontac, t st gui is y he a e he c r c is fa whe et c r c i cl ara una bi ont a t t el nd r he ont a t s e nd m guoust ei no r a on t g f r he . fab. her s e s o o ' t r' u ' Cop.o r fAm. . Ko ,8 S 2 31 , 3( a 5hDCA 20 2 .t n u g i ad c me ti v Mc wn 29 o.d 1 31 F1. t 0 )C g ae n o u n s La n g mbiuouswhe i i unce t ni mea nga ma bef ryunde soodi mor wa t nonea n ts rai n ni nd y ail rt n e ys ha nd i s c ptbl ofi e pr a i i oppos t w a . Bar tv D e tn ( wc .As n,I . 856 So. s us e i e nt r et ton n ie ys ' net . s i y Xf r s' nc , ' ç 2d 1 1 ( a 1tDCA 2003) ' heet tnnsaeunambi 090, 092 Fl. s .' r he e W r guous t pa te 'ntntmus be , he ris i e t dic r fom t f c ne soft doctme . Dowsv Ni ,nc,8 So. 595, ( a. h sened r he our or r he l nt' ' . ke I . 46 2d 601 F1 4t DCA 2003 . ) Thes tl men a e m e defne aSphyscin'asa e te t gr e nt i s l i a ' nyonewho i ' y lc ns d by asae s ' dul ie e tt lc ns ng boa d as a M e c D oc or o a a D oc or of Os eo t and s l i l bo h ie i r di al t r s t t pa hy hal nc ude t Pa tci tngPhysc a a Non- ri pa i Physcins'A C ri pa i ii ns nd pa tci tng i a . t i anGr 'sde i as'wo ' physci oup'i fned ' t orm o e Phys c ans a t e c a m i by orta ough t m w ho pr c i e undera sngl t xpa r r ii nd hos l i ng l r he a tc i e a ye i ntfca i numbe . de ii ton r' ' To s w t te c pa t i aphys cangr ho ha a h ry s i i oup,BCBSF a tc se bisofc am ss m itd ta he xhi t l i ub te t BCBSFf e vi spr de bym uli ephysca unde sngl txpa ri ntfc tonnumbe o ors r ce ovi d tpl i ins ra i e a ye de ii a i r be or t efeci dae oft s tlm e .The pa tesf whih BCBSF s f e he f tve t he e te nt ri or c ubmis s h e d nc t uc vi e e i l a1 oft PsG pl ntf s t t s Physci nsSur c Gr nc ude 1 he ai if , ha i , ia gi al oup, LLC, a esPhysci nsSur c l N pl ia gi a Gr oup,LLC,PSG ofSout Fl i ,LLC, h orda PSG ofBoca LLC. Pl ntfsc e t tt PSG , The ai if ount r ha he Pl i if ar non- ii nowne a t tt PSG Pl i if ha ne e pl dphyscins By antfs e physc a d nd ha he antfs ve ver m oye ia . t t r soft s tl m e a e e , hi Cou tfndst tt e f e ii s a e phys c an g oups he e m he e te nt gr em nt t s r i ha hes our ntte r ii r a e ea i ndr l s ngpa te . c pa ess ri s The om ni ubm it c a m st BCBSF a t woul be 'hos c a m i ted l i o nd hus d ' e l i ng t byort ough' hr ' i a u er sngl u pay ri ntfcai nu be . hehert e iiscls iy physcins nd a i et e de ii ton m r W t he ntte a sf t physcinswho a epr di s r iesa conta or hasnobe i ont pli m e ni oft he ia r ovi ng e vc s r ct s arng he an a ng he l uag i t s tl nta e m e , c mus be i e pr t d asacontac . ang e n he e teme gr e nt whi h t nt r e e r t BCBSF alo pr s nt e denc ofc am s or r by physcins f t t n s e e s vi e li de ed i a or he wo mbul t y aor f c lt Pl i tf s Howe ,t l ngua i a iiy a n if . ver he a ge mpora l s fs t cl i s f r s r c ' de e 'by tnty hit, o a m o e vi es ' r d' or ph ii r t rt n s itdbyphysca .BCBSF as e t bye de et tSancua ySur c l yscans a he ha ubm te i ins s rs vi nc ha t r gi a Ce e i owne b a sngl s r hol ri Dr ArhurHa l M . and t ther cevednotc of nt r s d y i e ha e de n . t nda , D. ha e i ie t c a s a di not opt out m a ng Sa t r Sur ca Ce e a r l asng pa t . H ow ever, he l s nd d - , ki nc ua y gi l nt r e e i ry Sa ndua ySur c Ce e , r gial nt r LLC di not ves r i e b muli ephyscins it d ha e v c s y tpl i a ubm tedunde sngl ra i e txpa ri ntfcai n a t doe no f l w ihi t defnii ofphysc a g ou unde t a ye de ii to nd hus s t al t n he i ton iin r p r he s tlm e ta ee e .Gl di usSur i a Ce e a s di no ha muli ephysc a s itng ele n gr m nt a ol g c l ntr lo d t ve tpl ii ns ubm ti c am st rasngl a ye i ntsc tonnumberNe dhels , a em or hano physc a l i mde i et xpa r de i a i . ve e s bec us et ne ii n ' de e 's r c st tr s t d i hund edsofcai sunde t ra pi sbef r t e f c i da e ' r d' e vi e ha e ule n or r lm r hei us ce o e he fe tve t w ihoutoptng o of t s tl m e a ee e ,BCBSF a s r s t t t y a e a phys c a gr t i ut he e te nt gr m nt s e t ha he r i i n oup. A ddii ly,fve phys ci ns ha ow ne s p i e es s i G l ol .Thi Co t fnds t t tona l i ia ve r hi nt r t n adi us s ur i hat he owne s p i e e t ca r hi nt r s s nnotc onve t hes e ii si t physci n gr ps By t pl n m e ni oft r t e ntte n o i a ou . he ai a ng he l ngua i t s tl e a ee e , he c pa esw oul ha ha t s a ge n he e tem nt gr m nt t om ni d ve d o ubm i c a m sby or hr t li t ough physcinsunde asngl t xpa i ntfc tonnum be .Thet a bult yf ciiyPli if a e ia r i e a yer de ii a i r wo m a or a lt a ntfs r t notr e i pa te .As t t a bul t y f iiy Pl ntf s BCBSF' m oton i de e hus el as ng ri s o he m a or ac lt ai if , S i s ni d. 2. Subm it d Cl i sAr Relas Cli s The te am e e ed am BCBSF alo as e t t tt is s r ied i t c s s rs ha he s ue a s n he ompli r lt t r di a a dr si ant ea e o a c l nd a tc r duc i ofa ount pa d o c ai ss i td b t Pl i if . A c or ng t t Pl i if , he e tons m s i n l m ubm te y he a ntf s c di o he a ntf s t c a m s s i t d by t PSG Pl i if cn tbe r l a e c ai sbe us t Pl i i f w e eno i l i ubm t e he a ntf s nno ee s d l m ca e he a ntf s r t n e s e e a t tm e o t s tl m e a t y a e no ba e upon t s m e c xi t nc t he i f he e te nt nd he r t s d he n onduc a t t s he setl ent tem . The s tl me a e ntsa e t tupont efe tve dae, he e te nt gr eme t t s ha he f c i t t ' la e Pa tes('s lberl s d a f eve dic r ed fom a a alc ussof ' e s d ri 1' hal eea e nd or r s ha g r ny nd 1 a e Re a ton ofwha e rki s lc orc r c e whehe a ii unde a f der lorsa elw, ci t ve nd, otr e ha a t r t r rsng r ny e a tt a whi h i l ,buti notlmie t t Ra ke ee l l nc d a Com z Or ani to c ncudes s i t d o, he c t r ntue e nd pt g zai ns Ac ,a ir tand o he saut y a c mon lw c am s i e i ornon-nt nto , t nttus t r t t or nd om a l i , nt ntonal i e i nal a i i on orbe or t Efec i Da e t ta e, e eorc d ha be n a s t d a i tof rs ng f e he f tve t , ha r w r oul ve e s ere ga ns t Reea e Pa tes by r s of a ii outof o i a he l s d ri , ea on , rsng , r n nywa r a e t a oft f c s y elt d o ny he a t, a t , e nt , tans tons oc ur enc , cotr e of c c s ve s r ac i , c r es ts s onduc , bus ne s pr c i es t i s a tc , r pr s nt tons om i s ons c r um sanc or ot r m a t s r er nce i t A c i n,or e e e a i , s i , i c t es he ter ef e d n he to a es e i t sAg e m e , t ra s hcli waso c dha bee as e tdb a ddr s d n hi r e ntwhe he ny uc am r oul ve n s re y ny Re e sng Pa t onisown be fo on behafofot rPer o ast t busnes pr c ies la i ry t hal r l he s ns o he i s a tc t a a et es be tj 7 Th sicud s wi o tlmiain a t Ree sd Pate o l, n h t r h u j c . i n l e , t u i tto s o la e ris ny a y h a pe tofa f f s r ce c ai ss s c ny ee or e vi l m ubm it d by a c as m e be t a Bl Pl n. te ny l s m r o ue a S ci n 1 1a . us camswi b e j ie i te rlt t ' n a p c o a y fef rs r ie e to 3.() Th , li l e n on d f h y eae o ' y s e t f n e o e vc l a cams'a d aie o to 'o re o c n u t(r b ie sp a t e 't a o c re b fr t e li ' n rs u f ' u s s f o d c o) usn s rci s' h t c u rd e oe h c c efe i da e oft s tl e a e m e .The Pl i if as e ti t rc pl ntt tD e e nt f ctve t he e tem nt gr e nt a ntf s s r n hei om ai ha f nda de ed ordr s i aly r duce pa e s t t m .The a l ga i i t com pl i a e bas o t ni a tc l e d ym nt o he le tons n he a nt r ed n he s me busnes pr c i s u ryi t Shane c a i s a tce nde l ng he ompl i , a BCBSF de ed t i c am s a ant s ni her l i s ' xpei ntli si t y, notme c lynec s r 'Co ai a ! TheElvenhCic t ' rme a,nvetgaor or e dial esay. mpl nt t 20. ' e t rui hass a e t tc ai s a e r l a e c a m swhe t Pl i ifs c pl i s e t ' am e ope a i t t d ha l m r e e s d l i n he a ntf om a nt har s he ' s r tve nucl us of f t' a t fove s tl m e , t t i , wher t ' i my r g a dut ' a e t e ac ' s he e te nt ha s e he ' m pr i ht nd y' r he s me. a Thoma v. u Cr sandBl Shil s', Fe Appx. 4, 8( 1hCi. s Ble os ue edAs n 333 d. 41 41 1 t r2009)Thos . e rght a du i we e ' ue Cr s c r c uald yt pa isdoc or f m e c lyne e s r ca e i s nd tes r ' Bl os ' onta t ut o y t t s or di a l c s a y r gi t isci nt,a t docor ' onta t lrgh t r c vet m one 'I Seealo Docor ven o t le s nd he t s c r cua i t o e ei he y.' d s t s He t,n .v Aen e a. 6 5F.d 1 4 , 1 2( 1hCi. 01 ) tt h rla elng a ei ce r al I c, . ta, t 1, 0 3 1 6 1 5 1 t r 2 0 (t ) e ee s a u g s la ; h ( ic t once nsonl cli st tc dha be na s redS s donora ii fom t f t a lga i r y am ha oul ve e s e t ba e rsng r he acual le tons oft L he shane 1 Co ai .) mpl nt' .The stlme a r e nti l s br d r e e lnguag t t ' ete nt g e me ncude oa elas a e ha t nc ude ,w ihout lm ia i .. a a pe tofa f e f s r i c ai s s it d by a cl s d l s t i i t t on . ny s c ny e or e v ce l m ubm t e ny a s m e bert a Bl Pl ' Eve t m o ue an.' n houg t Pl i if as phys ci n gr ups w e e f m e a t r t h he a ntf s ia o r or d f e he efci ed t o tes tlme ta re n ,h y d n to j c ta t i ii u l y iinswee fe tv ae f h et n g e me t te o o be t h t he ndv d a ph sca e r pr ci i physc a , e i dno i oft s tl me ,a t wer i vi lycl sm e r , a tcng ii ns r ceve tce he e te nt nd hus e ndi dua l as mbe s bef r t e f c i da e oft s tl m e .ThePSG Pl ntf sr i e f e f rs r cecl i ss it d o e he f e tve t he e te nt ai i f a s e o e vi a m ubm te by c a smembe st ar e s d pary.Ass h, hos c am sar r e ed c am sand t moton t ls r o ela e t uc t e l i e elas l i he i o e freij n to a an t h s f u e tte i ga td no c nu cin g is t o e o r niis s r ne . 111 C oncl i . us on THE COU RT hascons de e t m oton a t pe tne po tons oft r or Fort r a ons i r d he i nd he ri nt r i he ec d. he e s gi n a ve bove, ti i s A DJU D G ED t t t m oton i GR AN TED I PA RT a D EN I ha he i s N nd ED I PA RT. N Furhe m or ,i i t r e ts A DJUD G ED t tPl ntf sPhys c a Su gi alG r ha ai i f i i ns r c oup,LLC, a es Phys c a Sur ca N pl i i ns gi l Gr p, ou LLC, ofSo hFl i LLC,andPSG ofBoca LLC ha t nt ( da fom t PSG ut orda, , ve we y 20) ys r he dat oft Cou t Or rt wihdr w a l t cl mst a ea s td i Sanct ysur c Ce er e he r' de o t a l of he ai hat r s ere n s uar gial nt , LLC, t lv . u Cr s a dBleS edo o i a I c, s No. 0 c - 1 6 e a . xBl e o s n u hil fFlrd , n .Ca e 1 -v 8 2 0 HUR1EY a ans , gi t Bl Cr sa Bl Shi l ofFl i ,I . I t cl m sa enotwihd a a ordimis d,t ue os nd ue ed orda nc f he ai r t r wn nd/ s s e he Cou twilor rt s f pl i if bede m e i c e ptoft cour,a whi h poi ahe rng r l de he e our antfs e d n ontm he t t c nt a i wilbes dul t detr i t a oprat r m e be or e r ofafnalor rofcontmpt l l che ed o e m ne he ppr i e e dy f e nty i de e .t i f r he s ut r ADJUDGED t Bl Cr sBleShil sM otonsf hat ue os u ed' i orExt i ofTi ( E. 2086, enson me D. No. 211 a eDENI ASM OOT. 3) r ED D ON E AN D ORD ERED i Cha be sa M i m i Fl i , hi n m r t a , orda t s da ofSe em be ,201 y pt r 2. FED CHI EF Copi pr ded t es ovi o: Cot e ofr co d ms l e r O . O O I TED STA TESD I STRI J D GE CT U
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
