Louis Vuitton Malletier, S.A. v. bags-watch-replicas.org et al, No. 0:2012cv62096 - Document 10 (S.D. Fla. 2012)

Court Description: ORDER granting 4 Motion for Preliminary Injunction. Signed by Judge James I. Cohn on 11/2/2012. (ams)

Download PDF

Louis Vuitton Malletier, S.A. v. bags-watch-replicas.org et al Doc. 10 UNI TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT SO UTHERN DI STRI OF FLORI CT DA CASE NO .1262096- V- HN CI CO LOUI VUI O N MALLETI S. . S U ER, A , Pl ntf, ai i VS. BAG S- ATCHW REPLI CAS. RG ,eta/, O . Def endant s. I ORDER G RANTI APPLI NG CATI FOR ENTRY O F PRELI I ON M NARY I NJUNCTI N O THI CAUSE i bef e t Cour on Pl nt s Ex Pade Appl i f Enty ofa S s or he t ai x i on or r cat Te mporr Resr ni Or ,Pr i nar Ij ci an Or Resr ni Tr sero ay tai ng der el mi y nun t on, d der tai ng an f f As et Ti t t e Coune# tng Op a i (he ' ppl a i f Pr i na Ij di ' s s ed o h t ei i er ton t ' i ton or el l nun on' A c mi ) ( 4) an pp t e Pr i nar Ij di Hearn h don No emb 2,2 2.Th DE , d on h el mi y nun on ig el v er 01 e Coud h c efl r i as ar ul evewed te Appl ai f Pr i n Ij o t enie c r y h i t or el al nundin, he tr out c on mi fl and i ot i e s he- i f l advi i t pr i se ul y sed n he em ses. By t e i t tAppiat ( 4) Pl n i L s Vui Mal i , A. Cpl n i h nsan l i DE , ait oui oon l er S. , ait c on f et f orl oui Vuion ) mo es f en r o a pr i nar ij di agai tDef nd t Th L s t p, v or ty f el t mi y nun on ns e ans e Padner ps and Uni por ed Associ i shi ncor at atons i ii on Schedul ' ' her o dentfed e ' A et ( ol v y, h M end t * pur an t 1 U. C. 1 6 and F , R.Ci P. f c l el t e Def an s ) su t o 5 S. j 11 edi ed. v. 65, or al ged vol i s o t e L am Ac ,1 U. C.ïj 111 an 11 a)and ( ) l e i at on f h anh t 5 S. 4, d 25( d. The Coud convened t hearng on Novem ber2,2012,atw hi onl counsel or he i ch y f P l nt# was pr ai i esent and avai e t pr l abl o esent evi dence suppodi t Appl i f ng he i on or cat Pr i n y Ij c i ( 4) De en t h v n t r pon t t e Appl a i f el ar nun t DE . f dan s a e o es ded o h mi on i t or c on Dockets.Justia.com Pr i n y Ij di norma an fl g i t s c e,n ha e De en t app ed el ar nun on, mi de y in n hi as or v f dan s ear i i t s matereiheri vi l ort ough copnsellBecause Pl nt; has sats n hi t t ndi dual y hr . ai i ised t he r i equr t f t isu e ofa pr i n y ij c i t Cou wi gr tPl n i emen s or he s anc el ar nun ton, he d l an ait mi l fs Appl a i f Pr i nal Ij nc i ( 4) i t or el c on mi n u t DE . on 1 . Fact Backqr ual ound The Coud bases t s Or on t f l ng f t fom Pl nt Compl nt hi der he ol owi açs r ai i Fs ai , Ap ia i f Pr i nar Ij nc i an su ori e den i ysu s i . pl t or el c on mi y n u t on, d pp t vi t ng ar bmisons 1. Pl nt# m anuf ur ai i ad es, pr ot om es, dit i es, and sel i i er at s rbut l n nt st e s c mmere,icl ng wi i t s j dii ditit lxu y goo un mulpl f er l o c n udi t n hi u cal src , u r h ds der t e M al i y r st ed tadem ar t egi er r ks. see Decl aton of Ni ay Li ar i kol vadki i Suppod of Pl ntf s n n ai i Ap ia i f Temp al Res r nig Or ILv dki De l' 1 4. pl ton or c or tai n der ' ia n c . 1 ) d 1 2. Pl nt i t ownerand/ excl ve I ai i s he # or usi i censee oft f l i tademar he ol ng r ow ks o t e Pr ial s ero t Uni St t s Pa en an Tr m a k Omc ( ol v y, n h i p Regit f he t a e t t d ade r nc ed e c l el edi t e ' i Vui Mars': h ' s oon k ' Lou ) T r ademar k Regi r i st aton Num ber 0 297, 594 , LOUI VUI ON S U 1 045, 932 , Regi r i st aton Dat e /Roj anto oods w Clssl s) a e I 18: r s!val C tunk i tavel ses, r i ng Sept ber20, bags,sat s,hatboxes and shoe em chel or uggage hand 1932 boxes used f l , bags,and pocket books. August10, I 18:I C uggage and I es' adi 7. handbags. 19 1De en t 1 ( s uion h mesc r sp ed vi emai i c eci wi t e f dan 7 I v t - er .om) e ond oui t a l n onn ton t h h TRO and suppodi document ser ng s ved upon i. Pl nt s counsel r i t t t ai x epl o he ed r esponse and i or ed Def nf m endant 17 oft upcom i hearng on Novem ber2,201 he ng i 2, an t e r r d h equi emen f ra sub s i o a f malr pon e an orobedi as d ai to mison f or es s d/ j on et l ed i t TRO . To dat Pl nt s counselhas r ved no f t com m uni i norany n he e, ai x ecei urher caton f mal es on e t t TRO fom Def ant1 ( DE 8) or r p s o he r end 7. See . T r ademar k Regi r i staton Number 1 519, 828 , 1 794, 905 , Regi r i staton Dat e /Roj avantG oods Clsst a es) I 18:tunks,val C r i tav i ses, r el ng Januar 10, bags,sat s,hatboxes and shoe y chel 1 989 boxes used f I or uggage hand , bags,and pocket book s. I 16: r C tavel goods cat ogs, al st i y,pads ofst i y, atoner atoner cal endar i s, ndexes f adi es or cl m ade f tavel s,not or r l er ebook s, envel opes;prnt I s f i ed abel or l uggage and ot tavelgoods and her r l herhol t ef ,sol as a eat deo her or d uni'wrtng paper paperbags f t ii , , or packagi hatboxes,paperor ng, car dboar boxes,phot @phs, d ogr adhesi f s atonel ,om ce ves or t i Sept ber28, r si i t nat e ofwrtng em equi t n he ur es ii 1993 pads I r papercuoer s, , eqertays, I t opener w r i t et eter s, i ng abl s, t penci pencihol s,f ai l s, l der ount n pens!bal ntpens,pen cases, l poi pencl cas I hol s, l es, ead der bal nt f pens,ni ni of l poi s or bs, bs gol i d, nkwel i ands,and l nkst s, pl ng car ayi ds. I 25:cl hi f m en and wom en; C ot ng or namel bels,shawl sashes, y t s, scar ves;f ooG ear and headgear , . 1938, 808 , Nov 1995 28, f 1 iewel wa c s, d s r s emb er I wrstwaty, t he an tap C j r or 4: ches . 3 Tr ademar k Regi r ton Re staton sta i gi r i Num ber cj st s)lRelvantGoods as e e Dat e I 1 wat C 4: ches and staps f wrst r or i wat ches. I 1 cat ogues f urng I C 6: al eat i uggage and tavelaccessores,bags,smal r i l I hergoods,and gar ent , eat m s' not ebooks,ant ogi and hol es, p amphe s r eri: t tav , lt ef r o r el n ' cal endar t ephone i es' s; el ndex , f ai pens,bal ntpens:ni ount n l poi bs, co er f rp k an des dl i v s o oc et d k ar es, and checkbook hol s. der LO UI VUI O N S U 1 990, 760 , I 18:tunks;tavel tunks' C r r i r ng , suicases;tavel bags;I t r i ng uggage; gar entbags f tavel hatboxes m or r ; f tavel shoe bags f tavel or r ; or r ; August6,1996 um br j ani al rer ej as; m cari s; r sacks;haver uck sacks;l heror eat t tl sh njba b hb ; exi oppi gs; eac ags e h andb ' nl c ess d emp y ags va W as ol , t; atache cases;t e bags,tavel t ot r sat s'cl ch bags;bref es; chel , ut i cas wal s'pocketwal s;cr tcar l , et l et edi d cases;busi ness car cas bi d es; l l and car hol s;checkbook d der hol s;key cases;change pur es; der s bref i case-ype pod ol t i os. I 24:tavelbl C r anket s I 25:shi sweat ds;pol C ds; shi o s ds; s ds h dwearj k t , hi T- hi ; ea ;ac e s' tes;bels;shawl scar es. i t s; v 4 ïTr ademar k Re sta i gi r ton Re staton gi r i Num ber Dat e Cl sl IRelvantGoods as es) e I 14:goods m ade ofpr ous C eci m et s,nam el shoe or ent al y, nam s, or menal ns j r,n y, na t pi ;ewel amel y rngs,earrngs,cum i br et i i nks, acel s, char neckl ms, aces;hor ogi ol cal i r nstument staps f wat s, r or ches, wat ches and wrstw at i - ches,and cases f wat or ches. 2, 828 177, I 18:goods m ade ofI heror C eat i iatons ofI herar not mt i eat e i uded i ot cl ncl n her asses,nam el y, boxes m ade fom I her tunks, r eat ; r val i tavél bags,I ses, r i ng uggage f or tavel gar entbags f tavel r , m or r , vani cas sol em pt r t y es d y, ucksacks, Augus 4,1998 hand bags,beach bags,shoppi t ng bags,shoul bags,aqache der cases,bref i cases,and fne I her i eat goods,nam el pocketwal s, y, l et pur ses,I herk hol s, eat ey der busi nesscar caseè,cali car d l ng d cases,and cr tcar cases,and edi d um br l el as. I 25:cl hi and unde- ear c ot ng , nam el s y, weat s,shi suis, er ds, t wai coat r ncoat skit coat st s, ai s, rs, s, pul l s,touser dr over r s, esses, j k t ,s awl sol , as sf ac e s h s, t es s he or wear scar , ves,necktes,pock i et squar gl es, oves,bels,sock bat t s, h r obes,shoes,boot and sandal s, s. 5 T r ademar k Regi r i st aton Number Regi r i st aton Da e t Cl st lRel as es) evantGoods I 014:goods m ade ofpr ous C eci m et s,namel shoe om am ent al y, s, oraMenal n ,ewel , n t pis j r y namel ,rngs,bel buckl ear y i t es, rngs,cum i br et char s, i nks, acel s, m neckl aces,hor ogi i tum ent ol calns r s, staps f wat r or ches, ches,and wat wrstw at i - ches,and cases f or wat ches. I 18:goods m ade ofI heror C eat i i i ofI herar not m t ons eat at e i uded i ot cl ncl n her asses,namel, y boxes m ade fom I her tunks, r eat ; r val i tavelng bags,I ses, r i uggage f or tav ,gar entbags f tavel r el m or r , . 2 181, 753 , Aug t1 us 8, vant c ess d)bags r c s ck i as oljemp u k a s, N, 1998 hand bags,beac ng , shoppi bags,shoul bags,atache der t cases,bref i cases,and fne I her i eat goods,nam el pock wal s, y, et l et pur ses,l herkey hol s, eat der busi ness car cas calng car d es, l i d cases,cr tcar cases,and edi d um br l el as. I 25:cl hi and unde- ear C ot ng , namel,sweat s,shi suis, y er ds, t wai coat r ncoat ski coat st s, ai s, ds, s, pul l s,touser dr over r s, esses, j k s sh s, t es s h f ac et , awl sol , as es or wear scar es,necktes,pock , v i et squar gl es, oves,bels,socks,bat t h r obes,shoes,boot and sandal s, s. 6 Tr ademar k Regitaton Regitaton sr i sr i Num ber Dat e Cj st IRel as es) evantGoods I 1 jwel :n y,r s, el C 4:e r amel i b t y ng buckl earrngs,cum i es, l nks, br et char s,br acel s, m ooches, neckl aces,hor ogi i tument ol cal ns r s, wat ches,and cases f wat or ches. LO UI VUI O N S U PARI S 2 346, 373 , M ay 2,2000 I 18:Goods m ade ofI herorof C eat i iatons ofI hernoti uded i mt i eat ncl n ot cl her asses,nam el boxes of y, I herused f tavelpum oses, eat or r hatboxes f tavel tunks,val or r ; r i ses, taveli bags,tavel set f r l ng r i ng s or cont ni cosmetcs,gar ai ng i ment bags f tavel r sacks, or r , uck handbags,beach bags,shoppi ng bags derbags,bref i cases, , shoul pouches'fne I hergoods, , i eat namel pocketwal s,pur y, l et ses,key cases,car hol s,checkbook d der hol s'um br l der , el as. I 25:Cl hi and unde- ear C ot ng , nam el s y, weat s,shi sui er ds, t s, wai coat ski coat pul s, st s, ds, s, l over tou er dr s cot n j k t , r s s, es es, l hig ac e s shaw l st es,scar s, ol ves,necktes, i cl hi bels,bat ng suis, ot ng t hi t f ooG ear head wearand ; wat r cl hi namel em oof ot ng, y, r ncoat ai se I 25:Cl hi namel s C ot ng! y, weat s, er shi sweat ds,pol shi t ds, shl o ds, shi suis,wai coat r nc s, ds, t st s, ai oat skit coat pul s,touser rs, s, l over r s, 2,361, 695 es s s, t es June 27,2000 dr ves,ac ees,ha s,squar scar es j k t s wl sol , i pocket es, , neckt pockethandker efsquar f chi es or wear gl , oves,tes,bel bat ng i t s, hi sui shoes,boot and sandal t s, s s, and hat s. 7 Tr ademar k Regi r ton Regi r i sta i staton Num ber Dat e A LO UI VUI O N S U PARI S 2, 388 378, uonnn22, gus t auhu ' 8 cj e lRelvantGoods assl s) e I 18:goods m ade ofI heror C eat i iatons ofI hernoti uded i mt i eat ncl n ot cl es,nam el boxes of her ass y, I herprnci l used f tavel eat i pal y or r pum oses,tunks,val r i tavel ses, r i ng bags,tavelng set f cont ni r i s or ai ng j d e r ucksacks, c y Cosm et san j wel , r handbags, beach bags,shoppi ng bags, shoul bags,brefcases, der i pouches, i I hergoods fne eat nam el pocketwal s,pur y, l et ses,key cases,busi ness car c d ases,cr t edi car cases,and cali car cases. d l ng d Tr ademar k Re staton Regi r i gi r i staton Num ber Cl sl yRow antooods as es) j Dat e I 14:J C ewel i udi rngs,bel l ncl ng i t buckl ofpr ous m et s, es eci al eari cu# Inks,br et rngs, i acel s, char br ms, ooches,neckl aces, i te pi or ent pi and ns, nam al ns, m edalons;hor ogi and l i ol cal chr onom eti rc i r nstument and appar us,nam el s at y, wat ches, at cas and cl s; w ch es ock nut ack s ofpr ous m et s; cr er eci al candl tcks ofpr ous met s, es i eci al j r b esofpr ou me al ewel ox y eci s t s. I 18: avelbagi,tavelbags C Tr r m ade ofI her I eat ' uggage tunks , r and val es,gar i s mentbags f or tav , ani c es s d emp y r elv T- as ol t; O * 2, 107 773, ct ober1 4, 2003 r ucksacks,shoul bags, der handbags;atachet cases, bref i cases,dr rng awsti pouches,pocketwal s,pur l et ses, br j el as um ness car cases d , busi made ofI herorofi iaton eat mt i l her cr tcar cases made of e#t , edi d l herorofi iaton l her eat m t i eat ' , c l c d c s ma o I ter alnj ar a es de feah i orofI i i l her k hol s m t on eat ; ey der at made ofI herorofi iaton eat mt i l her eat . I 25:Cl hi namel C ot ng, y, unde- ear sweat s,shit T, er rs, shi suis,hosi y,bel scaNes, ds, t er t s, neck tes,shaw l wai coat i s, st s, ski r ncoat over s, ds, ai s, coat su p der , r s j s, s en s tou eo,ean pul v s, r ck j ck s wit l er fo s,a et , ner o gl oves,dr gl ess oves,tght socks, i s, ba hig s t b h r ,p j s, t n ui at obes aama s, ni dr ght esses,shods,pocket squar ,hi es' ghheel shoes,I ed owheel shoes,sandal boot and ed s, s, sl i s. pper Tr ademar k . Regi r ton Re staton sta i gi r i Num ber 3, j, 02 zaj Dat e Cl st lRel as es) evantGoods Novèm ber29, I 09:Spedacl sungl ses,and C acl es, as :::5 spect e cases . 4 3 023, 930 , Decem ber6, I 09:Spect es,sungl C acl asses,and 2005 sped acl cases e . * 3 051, 235 , Januar 24, y 2006 I 09:Spect es,sungl C acl asses,and sped acl cases e . 10 Tr adem ar k Regi r i st aton xum ber Regi r i st aton Da e t Cl O )IRelvantGoods a**( e I 09:Spect es,sungl C acl asses,and spec acl cases. t e I 14:Jewel ,nam el rngs,k C l y, i ey rngs ofpr ous m et ,eari i eci al rngs and earcl cu@ lnks,br et i ps, i acel s, char s,br m ooches,neckl es,te ac i pi or ent ofpr ous met , ns, nam s eci al m edalons;hor ogi and l i ol cal chr onom eti appar us and rc at i r nstument nam el wat s, y ches, wa c c es al m coc s;ewel t h as , ar l k j r y boxes ofpr ous m et ,t ral eci al hei l oys orcoat t ewih. ed her t I 18:Leat and i i i I her C her m t on eat at M x n . p odu ,n y, r el b , r ds amel tav i ags ng XP X ta el s t c ie o ba or rv i es ompr d f gs ng s M X K 3 107, 072 , FLOW ER PATTERN I uggage,tunks and sui r t cases, June 20, 2006 k sacks vani cases sol em pt r t y d y, uc , shoul bags, handbags,ataché der t cases, docum entwal s and l et bref i cases m ade ofI her eat , pouches m ade ofI her wal s, eat , l et pur ses,key cases,busi ness car d cases,cr tcar cases'um br l edi d , el as. gar tba f tav pu po es men gs or r el r s , ' I 25:Cl hi and under m ent C ot ng gar s, nam el s y, weat s,shi t shi er ds, ee- ds, bels,sca- es,necktes,shawl t i s, wai coat ski r ncoat st s, ds, ai s, over s,suspender touser coat s, r s, deni touser pul m r s, l s,dr over esses, j ck s, as f wear gl e a et s hes or , ov s, tght bat ng sui bat r i s, hi t s, h obes, paamas ngh g wn s t , j , i t o s, hors pock squar shoes,boot et es; s, slpper headgear namel hat i s; , y, s and caps;unde- ear . 11 The Loui Vuion Mar ar used i connecton wih t m anuf ur and dit i i of s o ks e n i t he ad e s rbuton g ds i t c t i ien ied abo e.( Lva i Dec.1 5;s alo Uni oo n he aegor d t i es f v See i dkn l 1 ee s t ed St es Tr at adem ar Regi r i k statons of t Loui Vuit M ar s at i he s ton k ssue atached as t Comp i Ex biA t t Liadkn Dec. ost hi t o he v i e I ) 3. Def endant t ough t I er websies oper i under t dom ai s, hr he nt net t atng he n n ames i n ie on Sch due ' her o (h l j Domai Names) ha e de t id f e l ' A* et t e subed n ', v adveri pr ot o#er f sal and/ sol atI ,handbags,wal s,I tsed, om ed, ed or e, or d, east l uggage, et k hod s,b t s rs,s es,s ares,n ki ,wac es,j r an s gl s ey ler el hi ho s, t cv ec t es th ewel y, d un as es bearng what Pl nt# has det m i t be count t i rngem ent r oductons, i ai i er ned o e#eis, nfi s, epr i an / c or e i i i s o t e L s Vuion Mar s ( e Liàdkn De .I 9 1 , d or ol abl m t on f h oui t at t k . Se v i cl N - 4* Decl aton of St ar i ephen M .Gafi i Suppod of Pl ntf s Appl i f Tem por y f gan n ai i i on or cat ar Res r ni Or IGamgan Dec . ! 2 an Comp i Ex biA t t e Ga an De . tai ng der ' ' l' 1 d ' ) ost hi t o h mg e cl2 ) 4. Alhough each Def t endant m ay not copy and i rnge each Loui Vui on nfi s t t M ar f each cat k or egol ofgoods pr eded,Pl nt# has subm i sum ci evi ot ai i oed ent denœ showi each Def ng endanthas i rnged,atl ,one ormor oft Loui Vui on Mar nfi east e he s t t ks. f e Lv i Dec.W 11 1 ) De en t ar n t n no h e t e e er be se iadkn l - 4. f dan s e o ow, r av h y v en, 2Th It ne webst s o a ig un t Su j c Do n Names I iv oon ba e ner t i per tn der he b e t mai e , ous ui - gs onl es op.om,I s i o t tus .om,an I s ton d.om wer op at al i h c ouivut nou l j tc n t e d ouivui us c t e er i at on t tme Rosal accessed t he i er hese websi t pl hi or s. However at t tm e t o ace s der es , he i Pl nt s c ai x ounselaccessed t I em etwebsies oper i undert he nt t atng hese dom ai nam es, n t websies wer no I he t e ongeronl i Accor ngl t e ar no downl ne. di y, her e oaded capt es f ur or te h I ivuqonba - ies p. m, ous i - gsonl ho x n I s i oul js.om, ouivuqon t u tc et and I s tonusd. ouivuit com websi i uded i Com posi Exhi t ' 't t Decl aton of t ncl es n t e bi ' o he A' ar i St ephen M .Gam gan i Suppod ofPl ntT s Appl i f TRO . However Pl ntl has n ai i i on or cat , ai i subm i evi oed dence dem onstatng t each oft r i hat hese Def endant has i por ed at s ncor at I one ofLoui Vui s tadem ar i i corespondi dom ai nam e wihoutLoui east s qon' r ks n t s r ng n t s Vuit s aut i i and has used m oney tans er ser ces wih Paypal vi is ton' horzaton r f vi t a t c r pon n web t a isu f c ores dig si t s e or ommer i gai i volton o 1 U. C. 1 25 d) e cal n,n i a i f 5 S. 1 ( . t Lva i De .n. at1 1 ,Ros erDe . 2 29,30 an Ex bi S, an M see i dkn cl 1 1 2* al cl? 2, d hi t Z, d s t er t ) h eo. 12 aut ied or I horz i censed t use,r oduce,or m ake c o epr ount t r oductons,and/ e#eis, epr i or c or e i t to of he L sVuion Mar s. se Lia i De . 9. ol abl mi ins t oui t a t k t e v dkn cl$ ) 5. Pl ntl r ai AED I tgatons,I ,a I ai i et ned nves i i nc. i censed prvat i tgatve i e nves i i fr ,t i im o nvestgat t sal ofcount tver ons of Pl ntfs pr i e he e e#ei si ai i oduct by Def s endant s. ( Lv i Dec. 11 ,Decar to o Er Ros eri Su See iadkn l1 0* l a in f i c al n ppod o Pl n i Ap ia in f ait ls pl to c f Temp ar Res r i ng Or IRos erDe .)1 3, mgan Dec. 1 ) or or y tani der ' al cI' 1 ' d ' Ga l14. 6. l Sept er 2 2, Erc Ros er (Ro eO , an o er o AED n emb 01 i al ' saI ' mc f Iv t at s,I . plc an or f t e pur h e o ( a wal b ig a I ton n esi i nc , a ed g on der or h c as f i ) l earn t eas e et oft Loui Vuit M ar s ati he s ton k ssue i t s acton t ough t I er websie oper i n hi i hr he nt net t atng u ert Su j Domai Na bags- çh-epl s- g;()a k h derb ig a nd he bed n me wat r i or i ey ol earn t ca i I eastone oft Loui Vui M ar at i he s oon ks ssue i t s acton t ough t I er websie n hi i hr he nt net t oper ig un t e Su j Domai Name f ouivui at n der h bed n akel s honhandbagcom;an (i a d i) i bel bearng at l t i eastone oft Loui Vui on Mar at i he s t t ks ssue i t s ad i t ough t n hi on hr he It t webst op a ig un t e Su j t Domai Name O plc l svui n eme i er tn e der h bec n ia-oui /onba or ( Ros erDec.! 4- )Ro al fn ied pa mentf t L s Vuiongs- g. See al l N 9. s er ial z y or he oui t t br anded wal pur l et chased t ough bags- at r i or vi Paypalt t Paypal hr w ch-eplcas. g a o he ac ou t Dini v h maic c n , n ula ot l om. ( . See Ros er Dec. % 4 an Compo t Exhbi A al l d si e it ata he t er t ) Ros erfnal ed pa men f t e L s Vuton- and k y h der t c d h e o. al i i z y t or h oui i br ed e ol t pur ed t ough f oui /onhandbag. chas hr akel svui com vi Paypalt t Paypalar a o he rnunt , ok h oog h t l o .( Ros erDec.% 6 an Compost Exhbi C ata ed s opz a o maic m See . al l d i e i t t ch t er t ) Ros er fn ied p men f t e L s Vuqon- an d bel pu c s h eo. al ial z ay t or h oui i br de t r ha ed t ough r i l svui hr eplca-oui /onbags- g or vi Paypal t t a o he Paypal accoun , t ' hr t ' i opher al a nmaic . ( c s ad zl l om See Ros er Decl $ 8 an Comp i Ex bt E . al . d ost hii e 13 a t h t er t ) Ro al r eie t e L i Vuqon b an wal t k y h der and tac ed h e o. s er ec v d h ous i r ded l , e ol , e bel pur t chased vi t bags- ch-epl or f el svui a he wat r i cas. g, ak oui oonhandbag. , and com r i l svui bags. g websies,r epl oui qoncaor t espec i y,each ofwhi wer shi tvel ch e pped t hi o s a e s i t e Sou h n Ditit of Fl i ddr s n h t er src or da. ( See Ros er Dec. 5 5, 7, 9 an al l d Co si Exhbt B,D,an F a t h t er t ) mpo t e ii s d tac ed h e o. 7. Addii l Rosal accessed I er websi oper i under t tonal y, er nt net t es atng he Sube tDomai Names i ied i t e t l b o an wen t ough t e pu c si jc n denti n h abe elw, d t hr f h r ha ng pr ocess3f varous pr or i oduct m os ofw hi bor count f t of at I ,one oft s, t ch e ereis , east he Loui Vui on M ar at i s t t ks ssue i t s ac i ; (d a 5 1 44 and Co n hi ton. I t 0mpost Exhbi G i e it s . t r gh 00 t er o. Fol ng s s i o hi or er Ro al r eie if ma i h ou h et ) l owi ubmison f s d s, s er ec v d nor ton f fnal ng paym ent f each of t iems or ed vi Paypal t Def or i i zi or he t der a o endant s' r espectve Paypalaccount as f l i s, ol ows: ' ê Sub ectDomai Name j n Pa ypal Acloun t bestepl r i cawat ches. us noodbuvlnea cm aicom i l . br andappar st e. el or com weI I 5063a vahoo. com cheapl svui oui oonhandbagsr i com 2496711347* qq. epl ca. c0m 3Rosal was i tuct t notfnal hi pur es vi t I er websies so as t er ns r ed o i i s chas ze a he nt net t o a oi c ti t a to f dst t Def ans c s. See Ga v d on r i ddi nalun o he end t' o#er ( bu ng i mgan Decl1 4. .1 ) 4Al gh aIo t e web t op a ig un t e Subed Do n Name oferf s e t hou I f h si es er tn der h j mai s f or al L s Vuoon br ded i ( e Ga an Dec.% 2 an Co ost Ex biA t er t , oui i an t ems s e mg l d mp i hi t h e o) e Rosal i entonal pur er nt i l y chased non- s Vuit br Loui ton- anded m er chandi fom som e of se r t web t op a ig u ert e Su j Domai Names as par o hs iv t t e he si es ertn nd h bed n t f i n es i i ga v pr es .( e Gamgan De .$ 4. Makng pur h es o mied br nds i a t hnqu oc s Se cl ) i c as f x a s ec i e comm onl us by i y ed nvestgat s t avoi i i or o d nadvedenty tppi of t t getas t whi l i ng he ar o ch br owneri condud i t i tgaton.(d. and s ng he nves i i I ) 1 4 cheapl svui oui qonsal l . eoutetcom I oui oonpur svui sesoutet i com l onl nes. usahandbaosoutet gm ai. la l com c na es el 3.om hi whol al z c xan 7g3@ homaic i c7 t l om . cnw hol ebi com esal z. ebayl l . voutetcom goodsabc. com happychi r com natade. i nashoes. nchi com i neasybi com z. I s qonouivui bags- i onl neshop. com I s qondesi shop. ouivui gner com l s- qonhandbagsonsal com oui vui e. I svui her oui oon- mes.om c I svui m iatonhandbags. oui qoni t i com I s- tonnor r . oui vui t dstom com I svuit oui tonouteo . l net vzhctadea hot ai. r m lcom z1 9622688* 163. m * xi ao83l3a nm ai. l com veIunc1986a 163. i i com 1677576386a qc. c0m oi ntnolg86e hot lcom l i pai mai . oara37472006a hot I r mai. com 274697833* qc. c0m br ati ant rce76ga cm aicom l . annabeaut v84a vahoo. com 1786291 408a qq. c0m alsondi l i cklsza nm ai. lcom annachenl8g7a cmaicom l . I s uion tej s om ouiv t ou ltu tc t bu n sh or v o.om sies on a aho c I svui oui oonusd. com I ybelsoutet com uxur t l s. I vbagsoutet com l ooz. m onogr bagsonl com am i ne. kent f v anca hot ai. m l com wumenni i za hot lcom ezol mai. si wca l63. ki com . Davnalanna vm ai. f lcom n ebu n et y.et ie as onrde.om M hi ta c r ia s s s.om epl bag jerey c c ai bao zoo si c t ao bao ta na.n vp hopg gmaic is gg@ l om . miha h t q com c elz a q. r i -oui qonepl l svui bags. g o or I s qonouivui nevedul m .nf l io m r i oui donl epl cal svui uggageoutet com l s. r i oui oonpuoes. g epl cal svui or shopvoguebags. com annel adenni 68a nm ai. sl l com s 6 zhenoia nm aia f lcom davi dcassandr 68a nm aicom al l . f onbansuka vahoo. ashi com 5 Rosal er r ved i i ecei dentcal Paypal account i or aton fom nf m i r t he cheapl s oonsal l . m and I svui ouivui eoutetx oui qonpur sesoutet i com websi l onl nes. t es d ig hs p ch ig p oc s ( Ros erDec.5 1 1 an Comp.Ex .J and K urn i ur asn r e s. See al l 3- 4 d s t e o. hert ) 6 Rosal r ei i i Paypalaccount i or aton fom t r i l s ooner ec ved dentcal nf m i r he epl ouivui cabags. g and l svui neve#ul m .nf websi durng hi pur or oui honl io m t es i s chasi pr s. ng oces t e Ro al Dec. 3 38 an Co p. s.HH an 1t er o. se s er l5 7d m Ex d 1 h et ) 15 super iy ashi net qual f on. t wom enspur t e. ses or com r usdsza vahoo. uf com chenvaovi za om ai. nzol lcom wor ux r de.om l uy a c dl wor u uM r ea h maic l x ad ot l om dl . ( Ro al Dec. N 1 .4 an Co si Exhi t G t ou 00 t er t ) See s er lI 0. 4 d mpo t e bi hr gh s h e o. 8. Ther eaqer Pl ntf s r esent i r ewed and vi l i , ai i epr atve evi sual nspeded t y he phot aphs and web page I i ogr i ngs,i udi i ages,f t iem s bearng Pl nt s st ncl ng m or he t i ai F tademar pur r ks chased and r ved by Rosal and det m i t iem s t be nonecei er er ned he t o genun v son of Pl n l s pr cs. t ie er i s ait odu t see Liadkn Dec. ! 11. Ad ton l v i l 1 ) di al i y, Pl nt s r esent i r ewed and vi l i ai i epr / atve evi sual nspec ed t iem s bearng Pl nt s y t he t i ai r ta r demar s o e f s e t ou t e It n web t op a ig un t e Subed k #er d or al hr gh h n er et si es er tn der h j Dom ai Names and det m i t pr n er ned he oduct t be unaut i s o horzed,nongenui ver ons ne si ofPl n i pr t .t Lv i Dec. ! 1 1 ) ait ls oducs see iadkn l% I 2- 4. 9. On Aug t2 Pl n i fld i Compl n ( 1 a n tDe end t f us 4, ait i t ; e s ait DE ) gais f an s or f al tademar count tng and ifi eder r k e#eii n rngem ent f se desi i of orgi and , al gnaton i n, cyber r piacy. Al on Augus 24,2012,Pl nt# 5I is Ex Pade Appl i f Enty of so, t ai i ed t i on or r cat a Tempor y Res r ni Or ,Pr i nar Ij t a Or Res r nig Tr f ar tai ng der el mi y nunci nd der tai n anser on, o As e sTi t t e Coun ereing Op a i ( 4) On Ocober24,201 t sCoud f s t ed o h t ft i er ton DE . t 2, hi ent ed an Or G r i Pl nt s Ex Pade Appl i f a Tem por y Restai ng er der antng ai i f i on or cat ar r ni Or , Pr i na Ij ndin and Or Res r nig Tr f o As e s Tid t t der el l n u o mi der tai n anser f s t e o he Cou t f t Op at ( 5 an amo o h t ng t n ereing er i DE ) d, i on ng t er hi s, empor i r taied ary esr n l Def endant fom i rngi t Loui Vui on M ar at i s r nfi ng he s t t ks ssue. Pur suantt t Coud' o he s Odober2 201 Or er( 5) Pl n i pr per s v t e Def dans wi Pl n i s 4, 2 d DE , ait o l er ed h # y en t t ait h l 1 6 Appl i t Compl nt t Coud' Oct i on, he cat ai , he s ober 24, 2012 O r , and aI ot der I her docum ent i connecton wih t s m ater? sn i t hi t . l. l LEGAL STANDARD l or ert obai a pr i n ij to a p mus demon ta e '1 Ih e i) n d o t n el al nuncin, ady t mi s r t . ) t er s ( a s s a talI el ood o su c s on t e mer s'( ) t t i epar e ij y wi b ub t n i i i k h f c es h i , 2 ha r abl nur l e t r l s #er d it e r ifi n tgr t ( )t tt e t e ene ij you ei s t e h m t e u e f h el s o an ed; 3 ha h hr at d nur G gh h ar h e r ifwoul ifiton t e n - v t an ( t tt e en r oft e r ifwoul s v t e el e d nl c h on mo an ; d 4) ha h ty h el e d ere h pu i it e t'Schiv e r Sc n erv.Schivo, F.d 1 bl n er s ' a o x. el hidl c a 403 3 223,1 -2 ( 1h Ci. 225 6 1 t r 2 ) s e alo L vi r s & Co.v Su ie I lTr diq Ic. 51F. 98 985 ( 1 h 005 * e s e Stau s , . nr nr. a n n , s 3d 2, 1t Ci.1 95 ( pplig t e t tt a pr i nar ij c i i a L am Ac c e) r 9 ) a yn h es o el mi y nun t n anh on t as . 11 1. ANALYSI S The decl atons Pl nt; subm i i suppod of is Appl i f Pr i i ar i ai i oed n t i on or el nal cat m Ij di su ort ef lwig c cu onso Iw: nun on pp t h ol n on lsi fa o A. Pl nt; has a ver s r pr ai i y tong obabit ofpr ng atti t consumer ar ly i ovi ral hat s e lk y t be conf ed by Def iel o us endant advedi ent pr oton,sal o#er f sal s' sem , om i e, or e, and/ diti i of handbags, wal s, I or s rbuton l et uggage, key hol s, bel shi shoes, der t s, ds, s ares, ne ki , wat es, jwel and s gls es be i c t t cv ct es ch e r y, un a s ar ng oune#ei s, r odud i epr ons, and/ col abl i iatons of t Loui Vuit M ar and t t or or e m t i he s ton ks, hat he pr odud s Def endant ar selng and pr otng ar copi of Pl ntfs pr s e l i om i e es ai i oduds t hat 7 o t e da e o pr i n y ij nci h i c duced on Nov er2:201 t e As f h t f el ar n u ton ear on t mi ng emb 2, h r die t e rci on of t e Su j h b ed Domai Names t t e s vl n o h er ng st i e, hhp:/ /se- i nnnotce. /vpp3/ndex- m l has not been snal i com l i ht , i zed. Alhough aI t l Def endant have r ied notce of t Cour' Oct s eœ v i he ts ober 24, 2012 Or and t der he Novem ber 2,2012 hearng vi t el r c notfcaton m et i a he ectoni ii i hods aut i by t horzed he Cour. t 17 bear copi of t Loui Vui on M ar on handbags,wal s, I es he s t t ks l et uggage, k hol s, ey der bel s rs s es, c v n k i wa c s,e l, s gls es. t hi , ho s ares, ec t s, t es, t he j wel and un a s B. Because oft i rngem entoft Loui Vui on M ar Pl nt# i I y t he nfi he s t t ks, ai i s i kel o su i dit an ir ar e ij yia pr i nar ij ndi i no gr t I cear #er mme a e d rep abl nur f el mi y n u on s t aned.t l l y appear fom t f l ng specii f s r he ol owi fc ads,as s f i Pl nt s Com pl nt Appl i et odh n ai x ai , i on cat f Tem por or al Restai ng Or , and accom panyi decl atons on 5I t r ni der ng ar i e, hat i dit an i ep abl Is dama and ij y wi r ul t Pl n i an t mme a e d r ar e o s, r ge, nur l es t o ait l # d o consum er because i i m or I y tue t nott : s ts e i kel r han hat 1. Def endant own or contol I er websi busi s r nt net t e nesses w hi ch advedi pr ot o#er f sal and sel at I se, om e, or e, l , east handbags,wal s, I l et uggage, key h der b t , s ds, sh s, s ares ne k i , wa c es,j wely an s gl s ol s, el hi s oe c v , c t es t h e r , d un as es bearng count tand i rngi tadem ar i vi aton ofPl ntfs rght i e#ei nfi ng r ks n ol i ai i i s; 2. Ther i good cause t bel t m or count tand i rngi es o i eve hat e e#ei nfi ng pr oduds bearng Pl ntFs tademar w i appear i t m ar et ace;t consum er i ai i r ks l l n he k pl hat s ar l el t be m i ed,conf ei yo k sl used,and di sappoi ed by t qual y oft nt he i t hese pr oduds;and t Pl nt# may su#erl ofsal f i genui pr hat ai i oss es or t s ne oduds; C. The bal ance of pot i har t Def ental m o endant i r r ni t rtade i s n estai ng hei r n c t ei an ifigig br ded go i a pr i n y ij ton i is ed i f oune# t d n rn n an ods f el ar nunc i s s u s ar mi ouG ei ghed by t pot i har t Pl ntl, is r aton and goodwil as a he ental m o ai i t eput i l manuf ur and di rbut ofqual y pr ad er sti or i oduds,i such r i i noti t f el s ef ssued;and D. Th p i i er tf or is c o t e pr i nal ij di i or rt e ubl nt es av s s uan e f h el c mi n un on n de o pr ec Pl nt s tadem ar i er t and pr ectt publ fom bei defauded by t ot t ai x r k nt es s ot he i r c ng r he pal i o# ofcount f tgoods as genui goods ofPl nt#. m ng erei ne ai i 18 E. Un 1 U. C.j 11 7( ,Pl n i ma be en ied t r ov ,as an der 5 S. 1 a) ait ; y t l o ec er t equi e r t abl emedy,t iegalpr is gai t ough Def he l l oft ned hr endant diti i and sal of s' s rbuton es handbags, wal s, I l et uggage, key hol s, bels, shi shoes, scar der t ds, ves, necktes, i wat es j r an s gl s be ig c t ei an ifi emen s o t e L s ch , ewel y, d un as es arn oune# t d n r s ng t f h oui Vui Mars. Re ok Itl Ld.v Mar at h Ener .I . 970 F.d 55 55 ( t qon k See eb n ' t . n ec t s. nc , . 2 2, 9 9 h Ci.1 2)( tn Ful Br sh Pr du t Co.v.Ful Br sh Co. 299 F.d 77 77 r 99 quo ig l u er o cs l n er , 2 2, 7 ( t Ci.1 62 CAn ac n ig o pr i u derj 111 a)i n s non mous wi an 7h r 9 ) cou tn f ofs n t 7( s ot y y t h a d o mon ar dama :' n ac oun i f pr f s ...i an equi e r y war f et y ges I al c t or o i ng t s t abl emed s j tt t e prn pl o e t . ubec o h ici es f qui ' y/ Requestng equiabl r i 'nvokes t di rctcoud' i ent equiabl i t e el ' ef i he sti s nher t e power t or pr i i y r i ,i udi an asset feeze, i or t assur t s o der el nar el ncl ng m ef r n der o e he avai l y ofper anentr i . LeviStauss & Co.v.Sunrse l 'Tr nn I ,51 F. l i abit m el ' ef ' r i ntl adi nc. 3d 9 98 ( 1 h Ci.1 95)( t Fe alTr de Comm ison v.Uni St t Oi an 82, 7 1 t r 9 cing der a i si t e aes I d GasCor , 48 F. 1 1 3 ( t Ci.1 4). p.7 2d 431, 433- 4 11h r 98 ) G. l I oft i enty deceptve nat e oft count f tng busi n i ght he nher l i ur he ereii ness, and Def endant bl ant vi aton of t f al tadem ar I s' at ol i he eder r k aws, Pl nt has good ai f r eason t bel o i Def eve endant w i hi or tansf t r is l de l r er hei l goqen asset beyond t l s he j iditon o t i Coud une st s as e sar r taied. ur c i f hs s ls ho e s t e esr n I V. CONCLUSI ON Fort f egoi r he or ng easons,i i ts ORDERED AND ADJUDGED t hat Pl nt s Appl i f Pr i i ai i f i on or el nal cat m Ij nci i h eb GRANTED I 4 asf lws n u t s er y on DE ) ol : o 1 9 () 1 Ea Def dan ,i omœ r di t r empl ee a t ,s bsdi i , ch en t t s s, r o s, ec oy s, gen s u i ar es di rbut s,and al per sti or l sons i ac i conced orpadi paton wih any Def n tve ci i t endan havi t ng n tc o t i Or ar h eb r s r n a enoi d: o ie f hs der e er y e taied nd j ne a. Fr m anuf t i i podi advedi ng, pr otng,olerng t om ac urng, m ng, si om i i o sel,seli dit i i or tansf rng any pr l lng, s rbutng, r eri oduct bearng t s i he Loui Vuit Mar or any conf ngl si i tademar ot s ton ks, usi y m l r ar ks, her t t han hose ac ual m anuf ur ordi rbut by Pl nt#;and t l y ad ed sti ed ai i b Fr s r ig,c nc al j,desr ig,s l o#,tan f rn or . om ecet o e i n n toyn elng i r serig, ot e- ie diposng o : () an pr du no manuac u ed or h s s i f I y o ds, t f tr diti t b Pl ni b i te L s Vuio Mars,or an srbued y ait ear h oui t n k #, ng t y c f igl sl l tademars;or(i an evi c r at t te onusn y mi r ar k i y den e el i o h ) nq manuf adur i podaton, sal oler f sal di rbuton, pr e, m i e, or e, sti l tansf of any pr r er oduc s bearng t Loui Vuit M ar or any t i he s ton ks, conf ngl si i tadem ar usi y m l r ar ks. ( 2) Eac De en t i omc s,di t s,empl e agen s s bsdi i , h f dan , t s er r or ec oy es, t , u i ar es di rbut s,and aI per sti or I sons i ac i conc orpadi paton wih any Def n tve ed ci i t endanthavi ng notce oft s Or shal i m edi el di i hi der lm at y scontnue,untlf t O r fom t s Cour,t i i urher der r hi t he use of t Loui Vuit M ar s or any conf ngl si i tadem ar on or i he s ton k usi y m l r ar ks, n connecton wih aI I er websies ow ned and oper ed, or contol by t i t I nt net t at rl ed hem icu n t e It ne webst op a ig un t Sube Domai Names; n ldig h ner t i es ertn der he j d n () 3 Eac De en t i o er di t s,empl e agen s s bsdi i , h f dan , t mc s, r or s ec oy es, t , u i ar es di rbut s,and aI per sti or I sons i ac i concer orpadi paton wih any Def n tve t ci i t endanthavi ng notce oft s O r shal i m edi el di i hi der lm at y scontnue,un i f i tl udherO r fom t s Coud,t der r hi he use of t Loui Vui on M ar or any conf ngl si i tadem ar wihi dom ai he s t t ks, usi y m l r ar ks t n n nam e ext ons,m et ags orot m ar er wihi websi sour code,fom us on ensi at her k s tn t e ce r e a web ge (n udi a t e t l ofan web pag ,an a ediig l s t ot er ny pa icl ng s h ie t y e) y dv sn i o h nk websi fom sear engi dat t r es, ch nes' abases orcache m em or and any ot f m ofuse y, her or ofsuch t m s whi i vi bl t a com put userorser es t died com put sear er ch s si e o er v o r er ches 20 t websies r st ed by,owned,oroper ed by each Def o t egi er at endant i udi t I er , ncl ng he nt net web t oper i un t Sube Domai Names si es at ng der he j d n , ' ( 4) Eac Def ndan s l no tan f o er p oft Subec Domai h e t hal t r ser wn shi he j t n Names durng l pendency oft s Adi oruntl udherO r oft Coud; i he hi on, if der he ( 5) Th domai n e n ame Regitar f t Subed Domai Names ar di t d, s r s or he j n e r e ec t t ext not aleady done,t tanser t Pl ntf s counsel f deposi wih t s o he ent r o r f o ai i , or t t hi Cour, t domai n c fc t f t e Subec Domai Name , n ame edi aes or h i jt n s' ( 6) The domai n n ame Regitar f t Subec Domai Na sh lt t e s r s or he j t n mes al o h , ex entnotàleady done,i medi el assit i changi t Regi r of r d f t t r m at y s n ng he star ecor or he Subec Domai Names ex ep ig anys h do n n jt n , c tn uc mai ameswhi su Regitar h e ch ch s r s av been notfed i w rtng by Pl nt# have been orwilbe di i ii n ii ai i l sm ssed fom t s acton,t a r hi i o hol n ac ou twi a Re sr ofPl n i c si (he M w Regita/) To t dig c n t h gitar ait /s hoo ng t Ne s r '. he ex entt Regitar do notassi i changi t Regi r s ofRecor f t domai t he sr s st n ng he star d or he ns un t ei r p t e c tolwi n on ( )bu ne s da o r eito t s Or ,t e der h r es ec i on r t v hi e 1 si s y f ec p f hi der h t l eldomai ( opev n TLD)Regiti ( t ei admi s r or ) f t e Subec Domai s r or h r es nitat s or h j t n Names wi n fv ( bu ies da s o r eitoft s Or er s l ch ge oras iti , t ie 5) sn s y f ec p hi d , hal an hi , ss n c angi t e Regitarofr or f t e Subec Domai Name e c tng an s h h ng, h sr ec d or h jt n s, x ep i y uc dom ai nam es whi such Regiti have been notfed i w rtng by Pl ntf have n ch s res ii n ii ai i been orwi be di i l l sm ssed fom t s acton,t a hol ng accountw ih t New Regi r . r hi i o di t he star As a m aoer of I ,t s Or shal no I aw hi der l onger appl t any Def y o endant or associ ed at dom ai name di i n sm ssed fom t s adi Upon t change oft Regi r ofr d f r hi on. he he star ecor or t e Subed Domai Names t e New Regitarwi mait n ac es t t e Sube t h j n ,h s r l n ai c s o h l jc Dom ai Names i tustf t Coud durng t pendenc oft s ac i Addii l t n n r or he i he y hi ton. tonal he y, 21 New Regi r shal i m edi el i iut a t por y 302 domai nam e r r i star lm at y nstt e em ar n ediecton whih wi auoma ial r diec an vsi t t Subed Domai Names t t c l t tc l e r t y i t o he l y or j n o he fll hll) tllhi ( t r Uni m f or Res ur e o c Lo t caor CURL' ' ) h/p:/ i /se- nonotce. /vpp3lndex- lwher i com l i he eon copi of t Com pl nt and aI es he ai I ot document on fl i t s ac i ar di ayed.Aler i y,t New Regi r her s i n hi ton e spl e t natvel he star ma up t t e Domai Name Sy t (DNS' da a imait n f t e Su j Do n y da e h n sem * ' t t n ais or h bed mai ) Nam es, w hi I t dom ai nam es t t I addr ch i he nk n o he P esses wher t r associ ed e hei at websies ar host t NSI. EDI t e ed, o M ATEM PLE. NET and NSZ. EDI M ATEM PLE. NET, whi wilcause t dom ai nam es t r ve t t websie w her copi of t ch l he n o esol o he t e es he Com pl nt t s Or ,and aI ot document on fl i t s adi ar di ayed. ai , hi der I her s i n hi e on e spl Aqer t e Ne Re s r h e ded t s c ng t e Su j tDo n Na s l pl e h w gitar as fe hi ha e, h bec mai mes halbe ac d on Lock s at pr t us, eventng t m odi i or del i of t dom ai by t New i he scaton eton he ns he Regi r orDef star endant s; () 7 Upon Pl ni r es,t e pr ac prt ton s vc f an Su j ait equ t h i y oeci erie or y bed fs v Dom ai Nam es f whi t Regi r us such prvacy pr ec i ser ce t conceal n or ch he stant es i ot ton vi o t Regitants i i and cont i or i ar or ed,t t ext notaleady he s r ' dentt y act nf maton e der o he ent r done, t di ose t Pl nt; t tue i ii and cont i or i of t e o scl o ai i he r denttes ad nf maton hos Regi r s' stant , () 8 Pl ni ma ener an c tnu t ent ,te Su jc Domai Na it ait y t , d oni e o er h be t # n mes no Googl s W ebm as erTool and cancelany r r ton oft dom ai t have been e' t s ediec i he ns hat ent ed t e by Def er her endant whi r r taë c t t count toper i t a new s ch ediect r o he e#ei atons o dom ai nam e orwebsi and t eby evade t pr si oft s O r ; n t e her he ovi ons hi der 22 ( 9) Eac Deen ts lpr ere,an c tn t pr er e,c is o aI h f dan hal es v d on iue o es v ope f I c ompuer5Is r at t t e u e o an o t e Subec Domai Namesand s lak aI t e el i o h s f y f h ng j t n halt e I seps n es ar t r ti e c t ec s y o e r ev ompu erfes r a ig t t us o t e Su j tDo n t i eltn o he e f h bec mai l Names t may have been del ed bef e t enty oft s Or ; hat et or he r hi der ( 0 Upon r eito no ie o t s Or ,Pa ,I .CPa I)and i r a ed 1) ec p f tc f hi der ypal nc yPa' ' t elt s com pani and am l es shal,t t ex ent not aleady done,i m edi el feeze al es i at l o he t r m at y r I f unds,as opposed t ongoi accountadi t i orwhi her o ng vi n y, ch eaqerar tansm i i o e r qed nt t Paypalaccount r at t t Paypal he s el ed o he accountr pi s: eci ent pi j y h maic ngul@ ot l om . o sh zoog h t l om k op @ omaic . c it er al @ gmaic m hr oph ad zl s lo . g oodbu l gmaic mD yi ne@ lo . wel @ y o.omu l so63 aho c 2 711 47@ q c0 496 3 q. m1 u ahan gs t t g l om? s dba oul @ maic e . xi gN g h t l omn an 3@ omaic . y q r e@ h maic zh tad ot l omD . z1 2268 1 c mD 96 8@ 63.0 xi aot3l @ gmaic mD 3 lo , y i g1 6@ 1 c eIun 98 63.omD j 1 757 86 qq.0m1 67 63 @ c oi aitn g8 h t l l n igl 6@ o maicomD p . gara3 47 6@ homaic r 7 200 t I omD . 27 46978 q c 1 33@ q.0m br t tie76 gmaic an a r g@ c l omn . ann au y 4@yah c abe t 8 oo.omD 1 6291 8@ qq.0mD 78 40 c als di l gmaic l on ck sz@ i l omD . 23 ann enl 7@ gmaic ach 8g l omD . busn s onor ies h @yah c oo.oml k tf @ h maic enyang ot l om; . wumen j zol @ h t l o gi z omaic mD e . skwc l c jj @ 63.om/ pa pal g@ y l oml y f an maic . ai obao o8@ sn cn/ t aoba zo ia. vp hopg @ gmaic ml is gg lo . mih h t qq.om; c aelz@ c an ad ni 68 gmaicomL gel en sl @ l . z engf gmaic h j@ l om; . d i a s dr 68@ gmaic avdc s an al l omn . f hi ags @ y o.o as onb uk aho c m/ rfs uu dsz@ y oo.omD ah c c eny oyn z@ gmaic mn h a izol lo . wor u rde@ homaic l xuy a dl t l oml . aswela alf nd i orwhih ar tan m ied it ()a o h r a e ac ou s o t l s Iu s n c e r s o no i ny t er elt d c nt f he s ame c somers ,(i an o herac ou t whc tanserf nds it t e s u t t) i y t ) c n s ih r f u n o h ame fn ci ian al isi t a c ts, d/ an ofheoh Paypal cc nss jd t t sOr ' d n tui c ount)an or y t ter t on a ou t ube o hi deran , (i an o h Pa i) y t er ypalar nu t t t orus d by an oft e Su j Domai Na i r ns i o ed e y h bed n mes i ii on Schedul ' ' et dentfed e A'her o; ( ) Pa 11 ypals al alo i dit y, o t e exen n tal dy done,dier t a h l s mme a el t h t t o r ea v to hol ng accountf t tustoft Cour aIf di or he r he t I unds i al Paypalaccount r at t t n I s el ed o he Paypal accountr pi s: eci ent pi j y@ h maic ngul ot l om . ok h zoog h maic s op @ ot l om . c it er zl gmaic hr oph adal @ s l om . goo uyi g l o db l ne@ maic mo . wel 63@ y o.omn l so aho c 24 249 13 @ qq.0m1 671 47 c u ahan ags te@ gmaic s db oult l omo . xi g77g homaic an 3@ t l omn . y qr e@ h maic mn zh tad ot l o . z162268 1 c 9 8@ 63.0m: xi 83l @ gmaic ao 3 l omD . y i g1 86@ 1 c eIun 9 j 63.omL 1 757 6@ qq.0m1 67 638 c oi aitn g8 h t l oml l nigl 6@ omaic p . gara 4720 homaic r37 06@ t I omD . 27 46978 q c 33@ q.0m1 banar e76g gmaic r tti c @ l omD . ann auy 4@ y oo.omD abe t8 ah c 1 6291 @ qq.0mD 78 408 c al on c s gmaic ls dikl z@ i l omo . ann henl 7@ gmaic ac 8g l omn . b ies ho @ y oo.omD usn s nor ah c k tf enyang@ h maic ot l omo . wumen j z@ h maic gi ezol ot l omn . skwc l c jj @ 63.omD p ypal @ ymaic a f png l om? . at aob oo8@ sn c i aob aoz ia.n; vi ho g@ gmaic ps pgg l om/ . miha h t qq.omn c elz @ c ang ad sl 8@ gmaic el enni 6 l omD . zh gf gmaic en j@ l omD . da dc s dr 68@ g l omu vi as an al maic . fshon gsu @ y oo.olD a i ba k ah c r f s z@ y o. mn u u ds aho co ch y yizol gmaic en ao n z@ l omD . wor u uY r l x ade@ h maic dl ot l omD . an an ot err at ac ou t o t e s cu t mers s j t t s Or er d y h el ed c n s f h ame s o t ) ubed o hi d ; ( 2) Pay s lf 1 pal hal udher t t e e t tn tal dy don wi n f e bu ies , o h x en o r ea e, t i hi v sn s d s o r ei n t s Or ,pr vie Pl n i c s wi aIdat whih de ai ( an ay f ec vig hi der o d ait oun el t I a c t l i fs h s ) a c t o t e t alf nd r s r n d a i t t e Pay a c ts whih t e c oun i f h ot u s e taie nd den i h ng ses pal c oun t ) c h r taied f ds ar r a e t o,an (i t e ac ou tta adi s r a e t aI f ds es r n un e elt d o d i h c n r ns on elt d o I un ) 25 tan mi it te Pa r s oed no h ypal c nt)whih ha e be r taied.Su h rsr nig o a cou ts c v en esr n c e tai n f t f he unds and t di osur oft r at fnanci i tt i accounti or aton shal he scl e he el ed i al ns iuton nf m i l be made wihout notce t t account owner or t fnanci i iutons untlf t i o he s he i al nst i t i udher or of t s Cour. Paypalshal r ve and m ai ai t s O r and is cont s as der hi t l ecei nt n hi der t ent confdentaluntlf t or oft s Coud; i i i urher der hi ( 3 Pl n i sh l n ai R b i t e a 1 ) ait almait n s ond n h moun o TenTh s Dol sand # tf ou and l ar Zer Cen s ( 0,00. ) a pa men o d o t $1 0 00 , s y t f amag t whc Def n s may b en ied es o ih enda t e tl t f a wr gf lij nci orr taitdur g t pen en y o t s aci ,oru tl udh or on u n u ton esr n i he d c f hi ton n n if er Or o t Cou t I t e Cours dicet t e bon may be su j tt ic eas der f he r. n h r sr i h on, d bec o n r e s oul an ap ia i b made i t e it e to j s ie; h d pl ton e c n h n er s f u t c ( 4) Thi Pr i nal Ij di s al emai i e d dur t e pen c o 1 s el mi nun on h lr n n le i h ng den y f t s acton,oruntl hi i isuch f t dat as setby t Cour orstpul ed t by t padi urher e he t i at o he es. DO NE A ND O RDERED i cham ber i Fod Lauder e,Fl i t s 2nd day of n sn dal orda, hi Novem ber 201 , 2. @ JAM ES .CO HN UNI TE STATES DI STRI J CT c c: AI CounselofRecor I d 26 GE SCHEDULE :A' ' ' DEFENDA NTS BY NUM BER AND SUBJEGT DO MA I NAM ES N Def endantNum ber Def endantISubk tDom ai Nam el j ec n s) Def endant1 bags- at r i or w ch-epl cas. g bags- ch-epl bi wat r i cas. z bags wat r i net - ch-epl cas. Def endant2 bestepl r i cawat chesa us Def endant3 br andappar st e. el or com Def endant4 cheapl svui oui oonhandbagsr i com epl ca. Def endant5 cheapl svui oui oonsal l . m eoutetx I svui oui oonpur esoutet i com s l onl nes. Def endant6 chi hol elz3. naw esal com Def endant7 cn hol ebi com w esal z. cnw hol ebi net esal z. Def endant8 ebayl l . voutetcom Def endant9 f oui tonhandbag. akel svuit com Def endant10 goodsabc.om c Def endant11 happychi r com natade. chi r natadeok. com Def endant1 2 i nashoes. nchi com Def endant13 i neasybi com z. i neasybi net z, Def endant1 4 I svui bags- i oui qononlneshop. com Def endant15 I s qondesi shop. ouivui gner com Def endant16 I s- oonhandbagsonsal com oui vui e. Def endant17 I s ton- mes. ouivui her t com Def endant18 I svui m i i oui ooni t onhandbags. at com Def endant19 I s- tonnor tom . oui vuit ds r com Def endant20 l svuit oui tonouteo . l net 27 Def endantNumber Def endantISub ec Domai Na s) j t n mel De en t21 f dan Iuivuion t j t om o s o ou l us . et c Def endant22 I svui oui qonusd. com Def endant23 I ybelsoutet com uxur t l s. Def endant24 I vbagsoutet com l ooz. Def endant25 m onogr bagsonlne. am i com Def endant26 net ebuy. net Def endant27 newf ontade. ashi r com De en t28 f dan r l abag jer e s.o epi c s sy cm Def endant29 Def endant30 r i l svui bags. g epl oui ooncaor r i l svui epl oui oonbags. g caor I svui neve#ul m .nf oui oonl io m r i ouivui uggageoutet x m epl cal s /onl l s. r i oui oonl epl casl svui uggageoutetcom l. Def endant31 r i oui oonpur or epl cal svui sesa g Def endant32 shopvoguebags. com Def dan 33 en t su qual a i n t per i shon.e Y Def endant34 womenspur or com sest e. De en n 35 f da t wor ux r e.om l uy ad c dl 28 SCHEDULE 'B' ' ' DEFENDA NT PA RTNERSHI O R UNI PS NCORPORATED ASSOCI O NS ATI BY SUBJECT DOMAI NAM E AND ASSOCI N ATED E- L ADDRESSES MAI No. Dom ai Nam e n E- ai Addr M l esses b - t h-epiasor agswa c r l a g c 1 b swac -epl asbz ag - th r i .i c b wat r i net ags ch-eplcas. pi j y h t l o ngul@ o maic m . b s thes o gmaic ag wac c m@ l om . goo 111 1 c d11 @ 63.om - go yl e@ gm ic odbu i n l om . al awath @ gmaicom i bab c es l . u s c tepl wat es c seN jeg uesr ia ch us ' j anon l 3.om qi l g@ 6 c weI 063 y l @ ahoo.o 5 cm brnd a appar sor elt e vis es lt n homaic p ho cohig@ t l om . cm o l Mis s lt n gmaicom p hoe co hig@ c eapplza@ h maic h a ot l om . 2496 3 q * m 711 47@ q. elxur- s ou t h maic u ydic n@ ot l om . cheapl svui oui oonhandbagsr i . epl com el y dic t y o uxur s oun@ ahoo.o cm r l aouiv oonh dbag zol h t l om epi l s ui an s z@ omaic c . elxul- i u t u vpc s omeoeNi o6@ ho maic œ t l om . c eapous oon al t h l ivui s eou l et u ah ag ou lt gmaic m s andb s t @ e lo . xm t tad l g l c r emal maicom @ l s ui pures t o i ouiv qon s ou l nl et nes I s uionou lG eb j h t l o ouiv t t t e st o maic m eg . c om 82a 85@ q c 282 q.om xan g3@ h maic i gN ot l om . chn ols el c m iawh e al z3 o c jacs @ homaic ai os g ah l om o8 ol t . ca c cj y oocn j dan oe el oo. or sh s l @ya cn c whol al z n es ebi yz q r h tade@ homaic t l om . c om es ebi@ ot l cnw hoj al z h maicom c wh e al i n ols ebz 39 020 q 0m 823 9@ q. ne t domai diworccom n@ y l d z162268 1 * m 9 8@ 63. Eb ba ho gmaicom ay gs p@ l . eba loul .om yv t c et s vc ltoe@ gmaic eriemal r s l om . j h5p 4 7d *a@t u 4 a25 0i r *bb 2d3 02e v S99 5*4. 2 besr ia th tepl wac es c . . 3 . . 4 5 - . . . 6 . . 7 . . . . 8 prvat i ewhoi net s. 9 f el s ui and g. m ak ouiv qonh ba co ok h og@ ho maic s opzo t l om . s viezu @ homaic er c ol t l om . wang en o ho maic f gll z@ t l om . 29 No. Dom ai Nam e n 1 go ab c 0 ods c.om E- aI Addr M l esses xao @ gmaic m i 83l3 lo . nie- @ homaic k t l om . cn h gwei y oo.om.n en @ ah c c y i ng1 6@ 1 c eIu 98 63.om j c ta @ h maicom eordel ot l c ta @ y oo.om eordel ah c ichn r e@ h maic n iatad ot l om . shu xi tad y o.n n ngr e@ aho c domai@ diwor c n y l om d. 1 576 6@ qq.0m 677 38 c aie-eel 6@ homaic l l g8 c t l om . j j c c ah aj eaj esag y oo cn domai@ diwor c n y l om d. oi ni g8 h maic l t pai ngl 6@ ot l om . jeas bi@ h maic n y z ot l om . ieas biol gmaic n yz @ l om . i s bi@ ya c nea y z hoo.n ay zhion l c u y g@ 63.om domai@ diwor com n y l d. gara37 06@ homaic r 4720 t I om . de gn ba sh @ g l om si er gs op maic . wer l c ee@ 63.om 27 46978 q c 33@ q.0m cu t s vie@ mrbran.om somerer c - y tc I ao g3 1 6.om i yan 65@ 2 c sh brnatie7 gmaic a t r 6g@ c l om . I cu t onl gmaic v. s omer i ne@ l om . s e89 1 c dat @ 63.om ann eauy @ y oo.o ab tM ah c m a g j qqcom yo x gg 1 6291 @ qq.0m 78 408 c elxuydicou t h t l om u r- s n@ omaic . el y dic t uxur s oun@yah c oo.om r i l s ui han gs z@ homaix m epl ouiv qon dba zol o t l . elxu vp so u l-icu tmeoeNi - 8 h maix m œ hl @ ot l . als dikl z@ gmaic l on c s i l om . c t s O ssa @ gmaico usomereNi l v l m . dh dbb l c vn @ 63.om ann h 8 @ gmaic ac enl g7 l om . - h ap yc narde.om p hi ta c 1 1 c nardeokc m hi ta .o 1 ichn h 2 n ias oes c om . . i nea y z.om s bi c 1 3 . i n s bi n ea y z.et 1 I s ui - gs onl es c m 4 ouiv oon ba - i hop.o n 1 I s ui desgner op.om 5 ouiv oon i sh c 1 I i- i 6 ous vuoonha ag on l c ndb s u e.om 1 I ivuqo h mes 7 ous i n-er c om . 18 I svui m iatonhandbags. oui qoni t i com 1 I s v ton ds r m.om 9 oui- ui nor to c t 20 I ivuton t t n t ous i ou l z. e t e . - 30 No. Dom ai Nam e n Ee ai Addr l e sses bu ies hon @ y o.o sn s or aho c m s c -c t -@ h t l om ewie . 5cje7d enerl omaic e6u obm1 u@ t du 4S99a *4. mi 02c v 255 p 21 I iv ton t j tcom ous ui oul us t et . rvat i ewhoi net s. 22 l ouiv tonu d.om s ui s c t k Y an h maic en g@ ot l om o l s ui s homaicom ouiv qonu d@ t l 48 68 qq. m 9770 @ * wumen j z@ homaic gi ezol t l om . Ixulbel oul s yah c uder t t @ oo.om s et se or rie4y @ h maic vc ou ot l om . ho hoz o@ l c ok tol z6.om skwc@ l c jj 63.om I ee3 I om . j 36 vbags600@gmaic oul ool g l om t et @ maic . o ereasr e@ l c v s tad z6.om p pf ay al ang@ y l om maic . su c n ad@ gmaic perhiac l om . fa 20 44@ 1 c rnk 060 26.om ai ob ozoo sn c t aoba 8@ ia.n a n ebu zoo gmaic et y 8@ l om . n ebu ne@ y oo.om.n et y t ah c c . 23 Ix y toult com u urbel t s s e . 24 Iba oul oozcom v gs t et . 25 m on gr ags l e.om o amb oni c n 2 nee y.et 6 tbu n qqs é-@homal om so3 7 t ic . 27 28 n as onrde.om ewf hi ta c . vp hop @ gmaic is ggg l om . mii lonmer an@ homaicom l ch t t l domai@ diwor co n y l m d. miha h t q c c elz@ q.om c n twn l @ h maicom hiao l ot l . r ia s s s.om epl bag jvrey c c . domai@ë- or c n l om d. r ia l svui bags. g epl oui oonc or chit rsade ad zl oph l om . angel er al @ gmaic - nns 68@ gmaic il l om . l c somer i @ gmaic v.u t onl ne l om . rpl a-ous i e i l ivuoonba . g c gsor l onl u tme@ gmaic v. i so r nec l om . edsanon h maic t t z4@ ot l om . I ivuqonn edul i o ous i -ev l nf mm tj s e76o@ homaic ammy u t l om . j g c a c h mal om açeg ot ic . l s om Zh gf gmaic m 3 r i oui oonl 0 eplcal svui uggageoutet c en j@ lo . r i sl iv epl ous O I oz eng i h 666@ gmaic a l om . ui u geoultx m wortade@ l com qonlgga t . e kr 63 31 r i l svui d i as an al gmaic avdc s dr 68@ l om . epl oui qonpur or o ses g l. somer ie@ gmaic vcu t onl n l om . j ane eln l c o v y @ 63.om 2 9 . . . . 31 No. 32 3 3 Dom ai Nam e n s v eb .om hop ogu agsc s er al/a hi n t up qu i s on.e t 3 womens resor com 4 pus t e . 3 5 wor u y r c l xu ade.om dl E- ai Addr M l esses fshon gs @ y oo.om a i ba uk ah c s v eba s e@ gmaicom hop ogu gs al l s opv gu s y oo.om h o euk @ ah c rfs @ yah c uu dsz oo.om if su qual/as on.et no@ per i hi n t s qual as on. t c nadpr ac c uper i hi ne@ o t i y.om M v c y yi z@ gmaic hen ao nzol l om . womens resor@ h majc pus t e ot j om . wordl uy rde@ h t l o l ux a omaic m . c or n s@ homaic opy i al t l om gi . ang i jn h t l om el ig@ omaic ang . . 32

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.