WALSH CONSTRUCTION COMPANY et al, No. 1:2016cv00845 - Document 54 (Fed. Cl. 2018)

Court Description: REPORTED OPINION. The Clerk is directed to enter judgment. Signed by Senior Judge Susan G. Braden. (Attachments: # 1 Memorandum Opinion And Order On Evidentiary Issues)(dg) Service on parties made.

Download PDF

WALSH CONSTRUCTION COMPANY et al Doc. 54 Att. 1 In the United States Court of Federal Claims No. 16-845 C Filed: October 3, 2018 **************************************** * WALSH CONSTRUCTION CO., et al., * * Plaintiffs, * * v. * * THE UNITED STATES, * * Defendant. * * **************************************** Federal Rules of Evidence; Rule 26 of the Rules of the United States Court of Federal Claims (General provisions regarding discovery). MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER ON EVIDENTIARY ISSUES From March 19-20, 22, and April 4, 2018, the court convened a trial in the above-captioned case. The exhibits identified herein, together with the parties’ Joint Stipulations of Fact (Jt. Stip. ¶¶ 1–21) and the testimony adduced at the trial (TR 1–1143), comprise the record regarding the court’s Memorandum Opinion And Final Order. I. DOCUMENTS PROFFERED BY PLAINTIFFS THAT THE COURT RULES ARE ADMITTED INTO EVIDENCE. PX 1 PX 9 PX 17 PX 25 PX 33 PX 41 PX 49 PX 57 PX 65 PX 73 PX 81 PX 89 PX 97 PX 105 PX 113 PX 121 PX 2 PX 10 PX 18 PX 26 PX 34 PX 42 PX 50 PX 58 PX 66 PX 74 PX 82 PX 90 PX 98 PX 106 PX 114 PX 122 PX 3 PX 11 PX 19 PX 27 PX 35 PX 43 PX 51 PX 59 PX 67 PX 75 PX 83 PX 91 PX 99 PX 107 PX 115 PX 123 PX 4 PX 12 PX 20 PX 28 PX 36 PX 44 PX 52 PX 60 PX 68 PX 76 PX 84 PX 92 PX 100 PX 108 PX 116 PX 124 PX 5 PX 13 PX 21 PX 29 PX 37 PX 45 PX 53 PX 61 PX 69 PX 77 PX 85 PX 93 PX 101 PX 109 PX 117 PX 125 PX 6 PX 14 PX 22 PX 30 PX 38 PX 46 PX 54 PX 62 PX 70 PX 78 PX 86 PX 94 PX 102 PX 110 PX 118 PX 126 PX 7 PX 15 PX 23 PX 31 PX 39 PX 47 PX 55 PX 63 PX 71 PX 79 PX 87 PX 95 PX 103 PX 111 PX 119 PX 127 PX 8 PX 16 PX 24 PX 32 PX 40 PX 48 PX 56 PX 64 PX 72 PX 80 PX 88 PX 96 PX 104 PX 112 PX 120 PX 128 Dockets.Justia.com PX 129 PX 137 PX 145 PX 153 PX 161 PX 169 PX 177 PX 185 PX 193 PX 201 PX 209 PX 217 PX 225 PX 233 PX 241 PX 249 PX 257 PX 265 PX 273 II. PX 130 PX 138 PX 146 PX 154 PX 162 PX 170 PX 178 PX 186 PX 194 PX 202 PX 210 PX 218 PX 226 PX 234 PX 242 PX 250 PX 258 PX 266 PX 274 PX 131 PX 139 PX 147 PX 155 PX 163 PX 171 PX 179 PX 187 PX 195 PX 203 PX 211 PX 219 PX 227 PX 235 PX 243 PX 251 PX 259 PX 267 PX 275 PX 132 PX 140 PX 148 PX 156 PX 164 PX 172 PX 180 PX 188 PX 196 PX 204 PX 212 PX 220 PX 228 PX 236 PX 244 PX 252 PX 260 PX 268 PX 133 PX 141 PX 149 PX 157 PX 165 PX 173 PX 181 PX 189 PX 197 PX 205 PX 213 PX 221 PX 229 PX 237 PX 245 PX 253 PX 261 PX 269 PX 134 PX 142 PX 150 PX 158 PX 166 PX 174 PX 182 PX 190 PX 198 PX 206 PX 214 PX 222 PX 230 PX 238 PX 246 PX 254 PX 262 PX 270 PX 135 PX 143 PX 151 PX 159 PX 167 PX 175 PX 183 PX 191 PX 199 PX 207 PX 215 PX 223 PX 231 PX 239 PX 247 PX 255 PX 263 PX 271 PX 136 PX 144 PX 152 PX 160 PX 168 PX 176 PX 184 PX 192 PX 200 PX 208 PX 216 PX 224 PX 232 PX 240 PX 248 PX 256 PX 264 PX 272 DOCUMENTS PROFFERED BY THE GOVERNMENT THAT THE COURT RULES ARE ADMITTED INTO EVIDENCE. DX 1 DX 9 DX 17 DX 25 DX 33 DX 41 DX 49 DX 57 DX 65 DX 73 DX 81 DX 89 DX 97 DX 105 DX 113 DX 121 DX 129 DX 137 DX 145 DX 153 DX 161 DX 169 DX 2 DX 10 DX 18 DX 26 DX 34 DX 42 DX 50 DX 58 DX 66 DX 74 DX 82 DX 90 DX 98 DX 106 DX 114 DX 122 DX 130 DX 138 DX 146 DX 154 DX 162 DX 170 DX 3 DX 11 DX 19 DX 27 DX 35 DX 43 DX 51 DX 59 DX 67 DX 75 DX 83 DX 91 DX 99 DX 107 DX 115 DX 123 DX 131 DX 139 DX 147 DX 155 DX 163 DX 171 DX 4 DX 12 DX 20 DX 28 DX 36 DX 44 DX 52 DX 60 DX 68 DX 76 DX 84 DX 92 DX 100 DX 108 DX 116 DX 124 DX 132 DX 140 DX 148 DX 156 DX 164 DX 172 2 DX 5 DX 13 DX 21 DX 29 DX 37 DX 45 DX 53 DX 61 DX 69 DX 77 DX 85 DX 93 DX 101 DX 109 DX 117 DX 125 DX 133 DX 141 DX 149 DX 157 DX 165 DX 173 DX 6 DX 14 DX 22 DX 30 DX 38 DX 46 DX 54 DX 62 DX 70 DX 78 DX 86 DX 94 DX 102 DX 110 DX 118 DX 126 DX 134 DX 142 DX 150 DX 158 DX 166 DX 174 DX 7 DX 15 DX 23 DX 31 DX 39 DX 47 DX 55 DX 63 DX 71 DX 79 DX 87 DX 95 DX 103 DX 111 DX 119 DX 127 DX 135 DX 143 DX 151 DX 159 DX 167 DX 175 DX 8 DX 16 DX 24 DX 32 DX 40 DX 48 DX 56 DX 64 DX 72 DX 80 DX 88 DX 96 DX 104 DX 112 DX 120 DX 128 DX 136 DX 144 DX 152 DX 160 DX 168 DX 176 DX 177 III. DOCUMENTS PROFFERED JOINTLY BY THE PARTIES THAT THE COURT RULES ARE ADMITTED INTO EVIDENCE. JX 1 JX 9 JX 17 JX 25 JX 33 JX 41 JX 49 JX 57 JX 65 IV. JX 2 JX 10 JX 18 JX 26 JX 34 JX 42 JX 50 JX 58 JX 66 JX 3 JX 11 JX 19 JX 27 JX 35 JX 43 JX 51 JX 59 JX 67 JX 4 JX 12 JX 20 JX 28 JX 36 JX 44 JX 52 JX 60 JX 68 JX 5 JX 13 JX 21 JX 29 JX 37 JX 45 JX 53 JX 61 JX 69 JX 6 JX 14 JX 22 JX 30 JX 38 JX 46 JX 54 JX 62 JX 70 JX 7 JX 15 JX 23 JX 31 JX 39 JX 47 JX 55 JX 63 JX 8 JX 16 JX 24 JX 32 JX 40 JX 48 JX 56 JX 64 DEMONSTRATIVES PROFFERED BY THE GOVERNMENT THAT THE COURT RULES ARE ADMITTED INTO EVIDENCE. DDX 1 V. DX 178 DDX 2 DDX 3 CONCLUSION. To the extent the court cited exhibits to which the parties objected, those objections are overruled. To the extent the court has not cited documents to which the parties object, those objections are moot. IT IS SO ORDERED. s/ Susan G. Braden SUSAN G. BRADEN Senior Judge 3

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.