ST. BERNARD PARISH GOVERNMENT v. USA, No. 1:2005cv01119 - Document 318 (Fed. Cl. 2016)

Court Description: REPORTED OPINION AND FINAL ORDER REGARDING EVIDENTIARY ISSUES. Signed by Judge Susan G. Braden. (ej) Copy to parties.

Download PDF

ST. BERNARD PARISH GOVERNMENT v. USA Doc. 318 In the United States Court of Federal Claims No. 05-1119 L Filed: May 4, 2016 **************************************** * ST. BERNARD PARISH GOVERNMENT * AND OTHER OWNERS OF REAL * PROPERTY IN ST. BERNARD PARISH * OR THE LOWER NINTH WARD OF THE * CITY OF NEW ORLEANS, * * Plaintiffs, * v. * * THE UNITED STATES, * * Defendant. * * **************************************** Federal Rules of Evidence; Rule 26 of the Rules of the United States Court of Federal Claims (“RCFC”) (General provisions governing discovery). MEMORANDUM OPINION AND FINAL ORDER ON EVIDENTIARY ISSUES From November 18, 2013 to November 20, 2013, the court convened an evidentiary hearing in Washington, D.C. on Just Compensation due the owners of eleven Trial Properties. The exhibits identified herein, together with ECF and the testimony adduced at that hearing (DTR 1– 801), comprise the record regarding the court’s Memorandum Opinion And Partial Summary Judgment For Just Compensation entered today in this case. I. DOCUMENTS PROFFERED BY PLAINTIFFS THAT THE COURT RULES ARE ADMITTED INTO EVIDENCE. SPX0471 SPX0692 SPX1200- SPX1300 SPX1301 SPX1302 SPX1303 SPX1307 SPX1314 SPX1321 SPX1400 SPX1407 SPX1504 SPX1513 SPX1603 SPX1613 SPX1623 SPX1802 SPX1903 SPX2003 SPX1308 SPX1315 SPX1322 SPX1401 SPX1408 SPX1505 SPX1514 SPX1604 SPX1615 SPX1624 SPX1803 SPX1904 SPX2004 SPX1309 SPX1316 SPX1323 SPX1402 SPX1409 SPX1506 SPX1515 SPX1605 SPX1617 SPX1625 SPX1805 SPX1905 SPX2100 SPX1310 SPX1317 SPX1324 SPX1403 SPX1500 SPX1507 SPX1516 SPX1606 SPX1618 SPX1627 SPX1806 SPX1906 SPX2101 (Page 30 only) SPX1304 SPX1311 SPX1318 SPX1325 SPX1404 SPX1501 SPX1508 SPX1517 SPX1607 SPX1619 SPX1628 SPX1900 SPX1908 SPX1305 SPX1312 SPX1319 SPX1326 SPX1405 SPX1502 SPX1509 SPX1518 SPX1611 SPX1620 SPX1800 SPX1901 SPX1909 SPX1306 SPX1313 SPX1320 SPX1327 SPX1406 SPX1503 SPX1510 SPX1601 SPX1612 SPX1622 SPX1801 SPX1902 SPX2002 Dockets.Justia.com SPX2102 SPX2109 SPX2116 SPX2123 SPX2130 SPX2142 SPX2206 SPX2213 SPX2220 SPX2227 SPX2234 SPX2402 SPX2509 SPX2518 SPX2535 SPX2542 SPX2549 SPX2600 SPX3009 ECF245 SPX2103 SPX2110 SPX2117 SPX2124 SPX2131 SPX2200 SPX2207 SPX2214 SPX2221 SPX2228 SPX2235 SPX2500 SPX2510 SPX2519 SPX2536 SPX2543 SPX2550 SPX2601 SPX3010 SPX2104 SPX2111 SPX2118 SPX2125 SPX2132 SPX2201 SPX2208 SPX2215 SPX2222 SPX2229 SPX2236 SPX2502 SPX2511 SPX2520 SPX2537 SPX2544 SPX2551 SPX2602 SPX3011 SPX2105 SPX2112 SPX2119 SPX2126 SPX2133 SPX2202 SPX2209 SPX2216 SPX2223 SPX2230 SPX2301 SPX2505 SPX2512 SPX2521 SPX2538 SPX2545 SPX2552 SPX3005 ECF240 SPX2106 SPX2113 SPX2120 SPX2127 SPX2134 SPX2203 SPX2210 SPX2217 SPX2224 SPX2231 SPX2302 SPX2506 SPX2515 SPX2522 SPX2539 SPX2546 SPX2553 SPX3006 ECF241 SPX2107 SPX2114 SPX2121 SPX2128 SPX2135 SPX2204 SPX2211 SPX2218 SPX2225 SPX2232 SPX2400 SPX2507 SPX2516 SPX2533 SPX2540 SPX2547 SPX2554 SPX3007 ECF242 SPX2108 SPX2115 SPX2122 SPX2129 SPX2137 SPX2205 SPX2212 SPX2219 SPX2226 SPX2233 SPX2401 SPX2508 SPX2517 SPX2534 SPX2541 SPX2548 SPX2555 SPX3008 ECF243 To the extent the court has cited exhibits to which the Government objects, those objections are overruled. To the extent the court has not cited documents to which the Government objects, those objections are moot. II. DOCUMENTS PROFFERED BY THE GOVERNMENT THAT THE COURT RULES ARE ADMITTED INTO EVIDENCE. DVX063 DVX070 DVX077 DVX084 DVX091 DVX098 DVX105 DVX112 DVX119 DVX126 DVX133 DVX165 DVX188 DVX064 DVX071 DVX078 DVX085 DVX092 DVX099 DVX106 DVX113 DVX120 DVX127 DVX136 DVX166 DVX189 DVX065 DVX072 DVX079 DVX086 DVX093 DVX100 DVX107 DVX114 DVX121 DVX128 DVX144 DVX167 DVX066 DVX073 DVX080 DVX087 DVX094 DVX101 DVX108 DVX115 DVX122 DVX129 DVX151 DVX168 DVX067 DVX074 DVX081 DVX088 DVX095 DVX102 DVX109 DVX116 DVX123 DVX130 DVX152 DVX169 DVX068 DVX075 DVX082 DVX089 DVX096 DVX103 DVX110 DVX117 DVX124 DVX131 DVX153 DVX170 IT IS SO ORDERED. s/ Susan G. Braden SUSAN G. BRADEN Judge 2 DVX069 DVX076 DVX083 DVX090 DVX097 DVX104 DVX111 DVX118 DVX125 DVX132 DVX163 DVX171

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.