Craigslist, Inc. v. Doe et al, No. 3:2009cv04737 - Document 57 (N.D. Cal. 2011)

Court Description: ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFF CRAIGSLIST, INC.'S MOTION FOR DEFAULT JUDGMENT AGAINST DEFENDANTS CHRISTOPHER MEYER, SEAN MEYER AND XLR PUBLICATION, INC.; VACATING HEARING. Granting 51 Motion for Default Judgment. Signed by Judge Maxine M. Chesney. (mmclc2, COURT STAFF) (Filed on 2/11/2011)

Download PDF
Craigslist, Inc. v. Doe et al Doc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ockets.Justia.com $=!9*1 C9<:)$"1 !:! "%1 $=$"<!"1% 5 %10-5$ $&$ 3 $!" $&$ !"< B 98* /!1 0"%3 >"/ Accordingly, the hearing scheduled for February 18, 2011 is hereby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which redirects to and @@@ -2!:$" 9% /0)3 !"< @@@ -2!%9-$ )!" /0) /\ /\ I $" 9%3 !"< 015$ "1$ !/1 2$ @$8% 1$% @@@ /*!<:$" 9% /0)3 Buxbaum Decl. ¶ 6. I ; 45$ $" 9% %0=1@! $ /\ $"!8*$% 15$ !910)!1$< -0%1 ": 0= !<% 0" / ! :%* %1 ' $ 3 -0%1 ": @ 15091 $!/5 !< 8$ ": $"1$ $< )!"9!**&(3 "/*9< ": / /9)2$"1 ": / ! :%* %1 %$/9 1& )$!%9 $% 10 <0 %0 1$ 2$ % 0"% 0= 15$ $" 9% %0=1@! $ "/*9<$ 15$ E ! :%* %1 !**0@% 9%$ % 10 9%$ %$-! !1$*& -9 /5!%$< %$/9 1& )$!%9 $ I I 4 # 45$ "1 &F =$!19 $ 15!1 4 # / $< 1% 10 8&-!%% 15$ / ! :%* %1 $=$"<!"1%D $" 9% =$!19 $ 15!1 / $!1$% / ! :%* %1 -50"$ 2$ = $< !//09"1% 0 !*%0 "/*9<$% 15$ I 0 !"< 4 # $!10 45 09:5 15$ @$8% 1$% @@@ -2!:$" 9% /0) !"< @@@ -2!%9-$ )!" /0)3 $=$"<!"1% %$** -50"$ 2$ = $< !//09"1% Sargent Decl. Ex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in the amount of $750 per component or device @$8% 1$ 45$ 09 1 !*%0 = "<% 15!1 !" !@! < 0= %1!1910 & <!)!:$% !1 15$ )!G )9) $"< 0= 15$ /\ !":$ % @! !"1$< 8& $=$"<!"1%D <$* 8$ !1$ < % $:! < 0= / ! :%* %1D% :51%3 !"< 8$/!9%$ $=$"<!"1% 5!2$ $=9%$< 10 /$!%$ 15$ "H9 09% !/1 2 1 $% //0 < ":*&3 15$ 09 1 !@! <% $1,709,250 " 15$ !)09"1 0= N 3 3 /\ / ! :%* %1 %1!1910 & <!)!:$% 9"<$ 15$ 1 2' %& 3 ( , 18 U.S.C. § 1030(g) *! "1 == / ! :%* %1 )02$% =0 ! -$ )!"$"1 "H9"/1 0" -9 %9!"1 10 15$ 6 3 ? M '!( !"< 15$ 3 ? M '8(' ( >1 % !-- 0- !1$ 10 %%9$ !" "H9"/1 0" !% -! 1 0= ! <$=!9*1 H9<:)$"1 & 3 6 3 A' ! 3 6 9-- < 3 1103 /\ ' !* ( 40 081! " ! -$ )!"$"1 "H9"/1 0"3 ! -*! "1 == )9%1 %50@ E' ( 15!1 % 5!% %9==$ $< !" $-! !8*$ "H9 &A ' ( 15!1 $)$< $% !2! *!8*$ !1 *!@3 %9/5 !% )0"$1! & <!)!:$%3 ! $ "!<$J9!1$ 10 /0)-$"%!1$ =0 15!1 "H9 &A ' ( 15!13 /0"% <$ ": 15$ 8!*!"/$ 0= 5! <%5 -% 8$1@$$" 15$ -*! "1 == !"< <$=$"<!"13 ! $)$<& " $J9 1& % @! !"1$<A !"< ' ( 15!1 15$ -98* / "1$ $%1 @09*< "01 8$ < %%$ 2$< 8& ! -$ )!"$"1 "H9"/1 0" F ! ' 3 6 < 3 ' 15 ( #$ $3 *! "1 == / ! :%* %1 5!% !**$:$< 15!1 $=$"<!"1%D /0"<9/1 5!% <!)!:$< / ! :%* %13 !"< /!9%$< !"< /0"1 "9$% 10 /!9%$ II 3 $-! !8*$ !"< "/!*/9*!8*$ 5! ) !"< "H9 & 10 / ! :%* %1 0 $02$ 3 / ! :%* %1 5!% %9==$ $< *0%1 $-91!1 0" !"< :00<@ ** !"< 5!% *0%1 9%$ % !% = 9%1 !1 0" @ 15 15$ )-!/1% = 0) $=$"<!"1%D ) %/0"<9/1 5!% : 0@" !"< / ! :%* %1 5!% %1 9::*$< 10 %10- 15$) II / ! :%* %1 /0"1$"<% 15!1 = "01 -$ )!"$"1*& $"H0 "$<3 $=$"<!"1% @ ** /0"1 "9$ 10 2 0*!1$ / ! :%* %1D% :51% 0"%$J9$"1*&3 15$ 09 1 = "<% 15!1 "H9"/1 2$ $* $= % !-- 0- !1$ 9"<$ 15$ / /9)%1!"/$% //0 < ":*&3 15$ 09 1 4 $ , , 4 / ! :%* %1D% $J9$%1 =0 ! -$ )!"$"1 "H9"/1 0" -$ $- *! "1 == / ! :%* %1 )02$% =0 !" 0 <$ < $/1 ": 15$ 1 !"%=$ 0= <0)! " "!)$% 15!1 $=$"<!"1% 9%$ 10 /0"<9/1 15$ **$:!* / ! :%* %1 $*!1$< !/1 2 1 $% ;5$ $ 1 % * .$*& 15!1 $=$"<!"1% @ ** /0"1 "9$ 10 9%$ @$8% 1$% !"< 0 <0)! "% 10 $G!/$ 8!1$ 15$ 5! ) 10 ! -*! "1 ==3 /09 1% 5!2$ 9%$< 15$ "5$ $"1 !9150 1& 10 $"=0 /$ 15$ 0@" 0 <$ % !"< 0 <$ $< 15$ 1 !"%=$ 0= 15$ <0)! " "!)$% " 15$ $2$"1 15$ 09 1 = "<% 1 * .$*& 15!1 ! <$=$"<!"1 @ ** "01 /0)-*& @ 15 15$ /09 1D% 0 <$ $< "H9"/1 2$ $* $= ! ** + 3 0 + /2 # #' 7 /108$ ( 3 ) % ( 'C9<:)$"1( 69 15$ )0 $3 15$ $: %1 ! % 0= 15$ <0)! " "!)$% !1 %%9$ 5!2$ !: $$< 15 09:5 15$ /0"1 !/19!* 08* :!1 0"% @ 15 45$ >"1$ "$1 0 -0 !1 0" =0 %% :"$< !)$% !"< 9)8$ % 'E> F( 15!1 15$& @ ** /0)-*& @ 15 ! /09 1 0 <$ < $/1 ": 15$ /!"/$**!1 0"3 1 !"%=$ 0 /5!":$ " <0)! " "!)$% >"1$ "$1 0 - =0 %% :"$< !)$% !"< 9)8$ %3 ? I '8( ' /1 511-+ @@@ /!"" 0 : $" <"< 9< - -0* /& 51) '*!%1 2 % 1$< /1 3 3 (3 ( >" * :51 0= 15$ =!/1 15!1 $=$"<!"1% 5!2$ -$ % %1$< " 0-$ !1 ": 15$ / ! :%* %1 $*!1$< @$8% 1$%3 !"< ! $ * .$*& 10 :"0 $ !" "H9"/1 0" !:! "%1 15$ 9%$ 0= %9/5 <0)! "%3 15$ 09 1 = "<% 15!1 1 % !-- 0- !1$ 10 0 <$ 15$ 1 !"%=$ 0= 15$ $*$2!"1 <0)! " "!)$% 10 / ! :%* %1 //0 < ":*& 15$ 09 1 0 <$ % 15$ 1 !"%=$ 10 / ! :%* %1 @ 15 " 0= 15 % <!&% 0= $/$ 2 ": "01 /$ <$ 15$ <0)! " "!)$% E/*!<:$" 9% /0)3F E-2!:$" 9% /0)3F E-2!%9-$ )!" /0)F !"< !** 015$ <0)! " "!)$% 0@"$<3 0-$ !1$<3 0 $: %1$ $< 8& $=$"<!"1% 15!1 /0"1! " E/*F3 E/ ! :F 0 E/ ! :%* %1F 0 15!1 ! $ 9%$< 10 0==$ 0 %$** / ! :%* %1 1$*$-50"$ 2$ = $< !//09"1%3 4 # %0*2 ": - 0<9/1% 0 %$ 2 /$%3 0 - 0<9/1% 0 %$ 2 /$% 15!1 -$ ) 1 15$ -0%1 ": 0= /0"1$"1 0" / ! :%* %1 @ 15091 $!/5 !< 8$ ": )!"9!**& -0%1$< 8& 15$ 9%$ 5 && + $ * & *! "1 == / ! :%* %1 )02$% =0 !" !@! < 0= !110 "$&%D =$$% !"< /0%1% /09 1 )!&3 " 1% < %/ $1 0"3 E!@! < $!%0"!8*$ !110 "$&D% =$$% 10 15$ - $2! * ": -! 1& F ? M '8(' ( #$ $3 *! "1 == / ! :%* %1 $J9$%1% !110 "$&%D =$$% 101!* ": N !"< /0%1% 101!* ": N 3 3 45$ =$$% "/*9<$ @0 . $*!1$< 10 -*$!< ":%3 "2$%1 :!1 0" 0= $=$"<!"1%D !/1 2 1 $%3 %$ 2 /$3 <9$ 10 $=$"<!"1%D $==0 1% 10 $2!<$ <$1$/1 0"3 !"< )01 0" - !/1 /$ 45$ 09 1 = "<% 15$ $J9$%1$< =$$% !"< /0%1% $!%0"!8*$ " * :51 0= 15$ @0 . -$ =0 )$< //0 < ":*&3 15$ 09 1 !@! <% !110 "$&%D =$$% !"< /0%1 " 15$ !)09"1 0= N 3 6 >4 > # O 4# 4+ *! "1 == / ! :%* %13 >"/ D% 5 %10-5$ $&$ 3 $!" $&$ !"< B 01 0" =0 $=!9*1 C9<:)$"1 !:! "%1 $=$"<!"1% 98* /!1 0"%3 >"/ % : !"1$< $=$"<!"1% 5 %10-5$ $&$ 3 $!" $&$ !"< B 98* /!1 0"%3 >"/ !"< 15$ !:$"1%3 %$ 2!"1%3 $)-*0&$$%3 !110 "$&%3 !== * !1$%3 < %1 8910 %3 %9//$%%0 % !"< !%% :"%3 !"< !"& 015$ -$ %0"% !/1 ": " /0"/$ 1 0 " -! 1 / -!1 0" @ 15 15$) ! $ "0@ !"< =0 $2$ $"H0 "$< = 0)+ '!( !"9=!/19 ":3 <$2$*0- ":3 / $!1 ":3 !<!-1 ":3 )0< =& ":3 $G/5!": ":3 0==$ ":3 < %1 891 ":3 %$** ":3 - 02 < ":3 )-0 1 ":3 1 !== /. ": "3 0 9% ": !"& !910)!1$< <$2 /$ 0 /0)-91$ - 0: !) ' "/*9< ":3 891 "01 * ) 1$< 103 !"& 1$/5"0*0:&3 - 0<9/13 %$ 2 /$3 <$2 /$3 /0)-0"$"13 0 -! 1 15$ $0=( 15!1 $"!8*$% -0%1 ":% 0" / ! :%* %1 @ 15091 $!/5 -0%1 ": 8$ ": $"1$ $< )!"9!**&A '8( !"9=!/19 ":3 <$2$*0- ":3 / $!1 ":3 !<!-1 ":3 )0< =& ":3 $G/5!": ":3 0==$ ":3 < %1 891 ":3 %$** ":3 - 02 < ":3 )-0 1 ":3 )!. ": !2! *!8*$3 1 !== /. ": "3 0 9% ": /0"1$"1 15!1 9%$% !910)!1$< )$!"% ' "/*9< ":3 891 "01 * ) 1$< 103 %- <$ %3 0801%3 / !@*$ %3 <!1! ) " ": 100*%3 !"< <!1! %/ !- ": 100*%( 10 <0@"*0!< 0 015$ @ %$ 081! " <!1! = 0) / ! :%* %1A '/( ":!: ": " !"& !/1 2 1& 15!1 < % 9-1%3 < ) " %5$% 15$ J9!* 1& 0=3 "1$ =$ $% @ 15 15$ -$ =0 )!"/$ 0=3 0 )-! % 15$ =9"/1 0"!* 1& 0= / ! :%* %1D% %$ 2 /$% 0 15$ / ! :%* %1 @$8% 1$A '<( 0-& ":3 < %1 891 ":3 < %-*!& ":3 / $!1 ": <$ 2!1 2$ @0 .% 0 015$ @ %$ 9% ": - 01$/1$< $*$)$"1% 0= / ! :%* %1D% /0-& :51$< @$8% 1$ '*0/!1$< !1 @@@ / ! :%* %1 0 :(3 "/*9< ":3 891 "01 * ) 1$< 103 15$ @$8% 1$D% -0%1 10 /*!%% = $<%3 !//09"1 $: %1 !1 0" !"< !//09"1 *0: " $G- $%% 0"% !"< /0)- *!1 0"%3 !"< = 0) "<9/ ":3 $"/09 !: ":3 /!9% ": 0 )!1$ !**& /0"1 891 ": 10 !"& 015$ -$ %0" 0 $"1 1& <0 ": 15$ %!)$A '$( /9)2$"1 ": 1$/5"0*0: /!* )$!%9 $% 15!1 /0"1 0* !//$%% 10 / ! :%* %1D% /0-& :51$< @$8% 1$ !"< 0 -0 1 0"% 15$ $0= ' "/*9< ":3 891 "01 * ) 1$< 103 4 # % !"< 4 # %(3 !"< = 0) "<9/ ":3 $"/09 !: ":3 /!9% ": 0 )!1$ !**& /0"1 891 ": 10 !"& 015$ -$ %0" 0 $"1 1& <0 ": 15$ %!)$A '=( !"9=!/19 ":3 <$2$*0- ":3 / $!1 ":3 !<!-1 ":3 )0< =& ":3 $G/5!": ":3 0==$ ":3 %$** ":3 < %1 891 ":3 - 02 < ":3 / $!1 ":3 )-0 1 ":3 1 !== /. ": "3 0 9% ": 1$/5"0*0:&3 - 0<9/1%3 %$ 2 /$%3 <$2 /$%3 /0)-0"$"1%3 0 -! 1% 15$ $0=3 15!1 ! $ - )! *& <$% :"$< 0 - 0<9/$< =0 15$ -9 -0%$ 0= / /9)2$"1 ": 1$/5"0*0: /!* )$!%9 $% !"< 0 - 01$/1 0" !==0 <$< 8& 1$/5"0*0: /!* )$!%9 $% 15!1 /0"1 0* !//$%% 10 / ! :%* %1D% /0-& :51$< @$8% 1$ !"< 0 -0 1 0"% 15$ $0=3 !"< = 0) "<9/ ":3 $"/09 !: ":3 /!9% ": 0 )!1$ !**& /0"1 891 ": 10 !"& 015$ -$ %0" 0 $"1 1& <0 ": 15$ %!)$A ':( //$%% ": 0 !11$)-1 ": 10 !//$%% / ! :%* %1D% /0)-91$ %3 /0)-91$ %&%1$)%3 /0)-91$ "$1@0 .3 /0)-91$ - 0: !)%3 !"< <!1!3 @ 15091 !9150 7!1 0" 0 " $G/$%% 0= !9150 7$< !//$%%3 "/*9< ":3 891 "01 * ) 1$< 103 / $!1 ": !//09"1% 0 -0%1 ": /0"1$"1 0" 15$ / ! :%* %1 @$8% 1$3 !"< = 0) "<9/ ":3 $"/09 !: ":3 /!9% ":3 )!1$ !**& /0"1 891 ": 103 ! < ": 0 !8$11 ": !"& 015$ -$ %0" 0 $"1 1& 10 <0 15$ %!)$A '5( !"9=!/19 ":3 <$2$*0- ":3 / $!1 ":3 !<!-1 ":3 )0< =& ":3 $G/5!": ":3 0==$ ":3 %$** ":3 < %1 891 ":3 - 02 < ":3 )-0 1 ":3 1 !== /. ": "3 -9 /5!% ":3 !/J9 ":3 1 !"%=$ ":3 )! .$1 ": 0 9% ": !"& - 0: !)3 <$2 /$3 0 %$ 2 /$ <$% :"$< 10 - 02 <$ !" !910)!1$< )$!"% 0= !//$%% ": / ! :%* %1D% @$8% 1$3 !910)!1$< )$!"% 0= / $!1 ": / ! :%* %1 !//09"1%3 0 !910)!1$< )$!"% 0= -0%1 ": !<% 0 015$ /0"1$"1 0" / ! :%* %1D% @$8% 1$3 "/*9< ":3 891 "01 * ) 1$< 103 !"& - 0: !)3 <$2 /$3 0 %$ 2 /$ 15!1 %3 " @50*$ 0 " -! 13 <$% :"$< 10 / /9)2$"1 %$/9 1& )$!%9 $% 0" 15$ / ! :%* %1 @$8% 1$A '( $-$!1$<*& -0%1 ": 15$ %!)$ 0 % ) *! /0"1$"1 0" / ! :%* %13 -0%1 ": 15$ %!)$ 1$) 0 %$ 2 /$ " )0 $ 15!" 0"$ /!1$:0 & 0" / ! :%* %13 -0%1 ": 15$ %!)$ 1$) 0 %$ 2 /$ " )0 $ 15!" 0"$ :$0: !-5 / ! $! 0" / ! :%* %13 !"< = 0) "<9/ ":3 $"/09 !: ":3 /!9% ":3 !%% %1 ":3 ! < ":3 !8$11 ": 0 /0"1 891 ": 10 !"& 015$ -$ %0" 0 $"1 1& <0 ": 15$ %!)$A 'H( 0%1 ": !<% 0" 8$5!*= 0= 015$ %3 /!9% ": !<% 10 8$ -0%1$< 0" 8$5!*= 0= 015$ %3 !"< !//$%% ": / ! :%* %1 10 =!/ * 1!1$ -0%1 ": !<% 0" 8$5!*= 0= 015$ %A '.( ?% ":3 0==$ ":3 %$** ": 0 015$ @ %$ - 02 < ": ! 15 < -! 1& !:$"13 %$ 2 /$3 0 "1$ )$< ! & 10 -0%1 /0"1$"1 10 / ! :%* %1A '*( %9% ": 0 !89% ": / ! :%* %13 15$ / ! :%* %1 @$8% 1$ !"< / ! :%* %1 %$ 2 /$% by " !"& @!&3 "/*9< ":3 891 "01 * ) 1$< 103 2 0*!1 ": 15$ / ! :%* %1 4 ?A /\ ')( //$%% ": 0 9% ": / ! :%* %1D% @$8% 1$ =0 !"& /0))$ / !* -9 -0%$ proscribed by the craigslist TOU; and @5!1%0$2$ A !"< /\ $=$"<!"1% %5!** 1 !"%=$ 10 / ! :%* %1 @ 15 " <!&% 0= $/$ 2 ": "01 /$ 0= 15 % <$ 15$ <0)! " "!)$% E/*!<:$" 9% /0)3F E-2!:$" 9% /0)3F E-2!%9-$ )!" /0)F !"< !** 015$ <0)! " "!)$% 0@"$<3 0-$ !1$<3 0 $: %1$ $< 8& $=$"<!"1% 15!1 /0"1! " E/*F3 E/ ! :F 0 E/ ! :%* %1F 0 15!1 ! $ 9%$< 10 0==$ 0 %$** / ! :%* %1 1$*$-50"$ 2$ = $< !//09"1%3 4 # %0*2 ": - 0<9/1% 0 %$ 2 /$%3 0 - 0<9/1% 0 %$ 2 /$% 15!1 -$ ) 1 15$ -0%1 ": 0= /0"1$"1 0" / ! :%* %1 @ 15091 $!/5 !< 8$ ": )!"9!**& -0%1$< 8& 15$ 9%$ @ 15 "01 /$ 0= 15 % / ! :%* %1 )!& %$ 2$ $=$"<!"1% <$ 8& $)! * >= $=$"<!"1% <0 "01 /0)-*& @ 15 15$ <$ @ 15 " <!&% 0= $/$ 2 ": "01 /$ 0= 15 % 0 <$ 15$ $: %1 ! % =0 15$ <0)! "% %5!** 1 !"%=$ 15$ <0)! "% 10 / ! :%* %1 C9<:)$"1 % $"1$ $< !:! "%1 <$=$"<!"1% 5 %10-5$ $&$ 3 $!" $1,844,409.80 98* /!1 0"%3 >"/ " 15$ !)09"1 0= N 3 3 45 % $- $%$"1%+ ? M $&$ !"< B 1!1910 & <!)!:$% =0 2 0*!1 0"% 0= 15$ : 1!* **$"" 9) 0-& :51 /13 $1,709,250 3 " 15$ %9) 0= N 3 3 A /\ $!%0"!8*$ !110 "$&%D =$$% !"< /0%1% " 15$ !)09"1 0= N 3 February 11, 2011 !1$<+ PPPPPPPPPPPPP PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP #0"0 !8*$ !G "$ 5$%"$& $%$"1$< 8&+ Q> > &+ % !" #$""$%%& !" #$""$%%& ' ( #$""$%%&,-$ . "%/0 $ /0) 110 "$&% =0 *! "1 == / ! :%* %13 >"/ PPP

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.