Vnus Medical Technologies Inc. v. Biolitec, Inc. et al, No. 3:2008cv03129 - Document 364 (N.D. Cal. 2010)

Court Description: ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE. Signed by Judge Maxine M. Chesney on October 15, 2010. (mmclc1, COURT STAFF) (Filed on 10/15/2010)

Download PDF

Vnus Medical Technologies Inc. v. Biolitec, Inc. et al 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Matthew B. Lehr (Bar No. 213139) Diem-Suong T. Nguyen (Bar No. 237557) David J. Lisson (Bar No. 250994) Chung G. Suh (Bar No. 244889) Jeremy Brodsky (Bar No. 257674) DAVIS POLK & WARDWELL LLP 1600 El Camino Real Menlo Park. California 94025 Telephone: (650) 752-2000 Facsimile: (650) 752-2111 Doc. 364 Michael A. Albert (pro hac vice) Michael Rader (pro hac vice) Charles T. Steenburg (pro hac vice) WOLF GREENFIELD & SACKS, PC 600 Atlantic Avenue Boston, Massachusetts 02210 Telephone: (617) 646-8000 Facsimile: (617) 646-8646 Attorneys for Defendant biolitec, Inc. Attorneys for Plaintiff Tyco Healthcare Group LP d/b/a VNUS Medical Technologies 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 John K. Buche (Bar No. 239477) Sean M. Sullivan (Bar No. 254372) BUCHE & ASSOCIATES, PC 875 Prospect, Suite 305 La Jolla, California 92037 Telephone: (858) 812-2840 Facsimile: (858) 459-9120 Attorneys for Defendant Total Vein Solutions, LLC d/b/a Total Vein Systems James W. Geriak (Bar No. 32871) Allan W. Jansen (Bar No. 81992) Mark Stirrat (Bar No. 229448) ORRICK HERRINGTON & SUTCLIFF LLP 4 Park Plaza, Suite 1600 Irvine, California 92614 Telephone: (949) 567-6700 Facsimile: (949) 567-6710 Attorneys for Defendant New Star Lasers, Inc. d/b/a CoolTouch, Inc. UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA SAN FRANCISCO DIVISION LEAD CASE NO. C08-03129 MMC TYCO HEALTHCARE GROUP LP d/b/a ) VNUS MEDICAL TECHNOLOGIES, ) Plaintiff, ) [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING v. ) JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO BIOLITEC, INC. and NEW STAR LASERS, ) ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO INC. d/b/a COOLTOUCH, INC., ) EVIDENCE ) ) ) Judge: The Honorable Maxine M. Chesney ) Date: October 18, 2010 Defendants. ) Time: 9:00 a.m. ) ) CASE NO. C08-04234 MMC TYCO HEALTHCARE GROUP LP d/b/a ) (consolidated with C08-03129 MMC) VNUS MEDICAL TECHNOLOGIES, ) Plaintiff, ) v. ) TOTAL VEIN SOLUTIONS, LLC d/b/a ) TOTAL VEIN SYSTEMS, ) ) Defendant. [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE – CASE NOS. C08-03129 MMC & C08-04234 MMC Dockets.Justia.com 1 Plaintiff Tyco Healthcare Group LP d/b/a VNUS Medical Technologies and defendants 2 biolitec, Inc., New Star Lasers, Inc. d/b/a CoolTouch, Inc. and Total Vein Solutions, LLC d/b/a 3 Total Vein Systems have jointly moved the Court for an order admitting certain exhibits into 4 evidence in this case. 5 Having considered the papers submitted by the parties, the Joint Stipulated Motion to Admit 6 Certain Exhibits into Evidence is GRANTED. The exhibits admitted by this order are listed in the 7 chart attached hereto as Exhibit A. 8 9 10 11 IT IS SO ORDERED. Dated: October 15, 2010 Honorable Maxine M. Chesney United States District Court Judge 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 1 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE – CASE NOS. C08-03129 MMC & C08-04234 MMC Exhibit A UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA CASE NOS: C-08-03129 MMC (LEAD CASE) C-08-4234 MMC TYCO HEALTHCARE GROUP LP d/b/a VNUS MEDICAL TECHNOLOGIES DATE: October 18, 2010 vs. BIOLITEC, INC., NEW STAR LASERS, INC. d/b/a COOLTOUCH, INC., and TOTAL VEIN SOLUTIONS, LLC d/b/a TOTAL VEIN SYSTEMS EXHIBIT LIST (X) Plaintiff Exhibit Marked (X) Defendant Admitted Sponsoring Witness Description Ribbon copy of U.S. Patent No. 6,258,084 B1 PTX 1 X X Method for Applying Energy to Biological Tissue Including the Use of Tumescent Tissue Compression (Goldman, Weiss, Zikorus, Chandler) Ribbon copy of U.S. Patent No. 6,752,803 B2 PTX 2 X X Method and Apparatus for Applying Energy to Biological Tissue Including the Use of Tumescent Tissue Compression (Goldman, Weiss, Zikorus, Chandler) Ribbon copy of U.S. Patent No. 6,769,433 B2 PTX 3 X X Expandable Vein Ligator Catheter Having Multiple Electrode Leads, and Method (Zikorus, Parker, Jones, Petty, Farley, Tartaglia) Ribbon copy of U.S. Patent No. 7,406,970 PTX 4 X X Method of Using Expandable Vein Ligator Catheter Having Multiple Electrode Leads (Zikorus, Parker, Jones, Petty, Farley, Tartaglia) Ribbon copy of U.S. Patent No. 7,396,355 PTX 5 X X Method and Apparatus for Applying Energy to Biological Tissue Including the Use of Tumescent Compression (Goldman, Weiss, Zikorus, Chandler) File Wrapper for 6,258,084 PTX 6 X X *Irrelevant portions eliminated per Pretrial Preparation Order VNUS_000001 – VNUS_000174 A-1 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE – CASE NOS. C08-03129 MMC & C08-04234 MMC Exhibit Marked Admitted Sponsoring Witness Description File Wrapper for 6,752,803 PTX 7 X X *Irrelevant portions eliminated per Pretrial Preparation Order VNUS 000341 – VNUS 000536 File Wrapper for 6,769,433 PTX 8 X X *Irrelevant portions eliminated per Pretrial Preparation Order VNUS 000537 – VNUS 000756 File Wrapper for 7,406,970 PTX 9 X X *Irrelevant portions eliminated per Pretrial Preparation Order VNUS_148525 – VNUS149094 File Wrapper for 7,396,355 PTX 10 X X *Irrelevant portions eliminated per Pretrial Preparation Order VNUS_147830 – VNUS_148502 PTX 12 X X PTX 13 X X VNUS Closure® Plus kit biolitec, Micro Introducer Kit BIO002956 PTX 14 X X biolitec, Fiber BIO002957 PTX 15 X X biolitec 810, 980 and 1470 Ceralas laser console images *Compilation exhibit of separate documents (BIO000297, BIO000280, BIO000303) PTX 16 X X CoolTouch, Micro Introducer Kit C0010252 PTX 17 X X CoolTouch, Long Introducer Kit C0010249 PTX 18 X X CoolTouch, SaphFire Fiber X CoolTouch 1320 (NS-160) and CoolLipo TRIO laser console images PTX 19 X *Compilation exhibit of separate documents A-2 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE – CASE NOS. C08-03129 MMC & C08-04234 MMC Sponsoring Witness Exhibit Marked Admitted PTX 20 X X TVS Long Introducer Kit TVS3105 SS PTX 21 X X TVS Kingsley Pack TVS4008K PTX 22 X X TVS Endovenous Pack TVS 4003J TVSB13483 PTX 23 X X TVS Ravi Pack TVS 4012NI TVSB13482 PTX 24 X X TVS Short Introducer Kit TVS 2004 TVSB13478 PTX 25 X X TVS 600 Micron Fiber TVSB13480 PTX 26 X X TVS 400 Micron Fiber TVSB13479 X TVS 980 and 1470 laser console images *Compilation exhibit of separate documents PTX 27 X Description (screenshot of TVSB12672 and TVSB12674) PTX 28 X X ELVeS Procedure Kit – Endovascular Laser Venous System, Instructions for Use PI-024 Rev. A BIO004915 – BIO004920 PTX 29 X X ELVeS Procedure Kit – Endo Laser Vein System, Instructions for Use PI-044 Rev. A BIO004973 – BIO004976 PTX 30 X X ELVeS Procedure Kit – Endo Laser Vein System, Instructions for Use PI-045 Rev. A BIO000005 – BIO000008 PTX 31 X X ELVeS Procedure Kit – Endo Laser Vein System, Instructions for Use PI-045 Rev. B A-3 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE – CASE NOS. C08-03129 MMC & C08-04234 MMC Exhibit Marked Admitted Sponsoring Witness Description BIO001485 – BIO001488 PTX 32 X X ELVeS Procedure Kit – Endo Laser Vein System, Instructions for Use PI-045 Rev. C BIO002958 – BIO002961 PTX 33 Ceralas D15 810nm – Fiber-Coupled Diode Laser System, User’s Manual X X LA-0740 Rev. E BIO004544 – BIO004593 PTX 34 X X Ceralas D15 980nm – Fiber-Coupled Diode Laser System, User’s Manual LA-0766 Rev. D BIO000017 – BIO000042 PTX 35 X X Ceralas E15 1470nm – Fiber-Coupled Diode Laser System LA-0882 Rev. C BIO002908 – BIO002951 CoolTouch CTEV Safe Start Protocol – Endovenous Laser Treatment PTX 36 X X 7030-0009 Rev. D (1-25-05) C0007092 – C0007099 CoolTouch CTEV Safe Start Protocol – Endovenous Laser Treatment PTX 37 X X 7030-0009 Rev. E (6-02-05) C0007774 – C0007781 PTX 38 X X CoolTouch CTEV Treatment Guidelines – Endovenous Laser Procedure 7035-0006 Rev. B (9-2007) C0005731 – C0005738 PTX 39 CoolTouch CTEV Treatment Guidelines – Endovenous Laser Procedure X X 7035-0006 Rev. C (3/27/2009) C0020044 – C0020051 A-4 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE – CASE NOS. C08-03129 MMC & C08-04234 MMC Exhibit PTX 40 Marked Admitted Sponsoring Witness Description Laser Endovenous Treatment for Varicose Veins – Owner’s Reference Guide X X *Multimedia Files may be shortened for presentation at trial C0006620 PTX 42 X X VNUS Closure Catheter – Instructions For Use RM55-285-01 Rev. E VNUS_140196 – VNUS_140238 PTX 43 X X VNUS Vessel and Tissue Coagulation Device – Instructions For Use RM55-430-01 Rev 2 VNUS 97087 – VNUS 97092 Art Zikorus Lab Notebook No. 005 VNUS 004475 – VNUS 004569 PTX 45 X X VNUS 047526 – VNUS 047533 *Compilation exhibit of separate documents PTX 56 X X 01/20/97 Handwritten notes from Art Zikorus Lab Notebook No. 005 VNUS_004511 – VNUS_004512 PTX 59 X X 10/20/97 Handwritten notes from A. Zikorus Lab Notebook 005 VNUS_087543 – VNUS_087544 PTX 71 X X biolitec Master Price List FM09-125 Rev. A (Approved: 01/08/07, Effective: 1/08/07) BIO002902 – BIO002903 TVS Product Catalog PTX 72 X X TVSB01842 – TVSB01845 *Redacted Total Vein System’s Product Catalog February 2004 PTX 73 X X TVSB01944 – TVSB01957 *Redacted PTX 74 X X Total Vein Systems’ Product Catalog October 2004 TVSB01958 – TVSB01977 A-5 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE – CASE NOS. C08-03129 MMC & C08-04234 MMC Exhibit Marked Admitted Sponsoring Witness Description *Redacted PTX 75 X X Total Vein Systems’ 2007 Product Catalog TVS20683 – TVS20697 PTX 76 X X Total Vein Systems’ Product Catalog Fall 2007 TVS25342 – TVS25369 PTX 77 X X Total Vein Systems’ Product Catalog 2008 TVSB00188 – TVSB00210 PTX 78 X X Total Vein Systems’ Product Catalog 2009 produced as TVSB01987 – TVSB02014 PTX 79 X X Total Vein Systems’ Product Catalog 2010 TVSB13998 – TVSB14024 PTX 80 X X TVS Procedure Packs Catalog TVSB00246 – TVSB00263 PTX 82 X X 10/17/08 letter from J. Kahan to R. Felten *Irrelevant portions eliminated per Pretrial Preparation Order BIO001793 – BIO001874 PTX 84 X X 04/06/04 letter from D. Johnson to the Office of Device Evaluation re: 510(k) Premarket Notification for Additional Indication for the CoolTouch NS-160 Nd:YAG Laser System *Irrelevant portions eliminated per Pretrial Preparation Order *Redacted C0007128 – C0007309 10/25/04 letter from T. Schiek to C. Shirk PTX 85 X X TVSB01802 – TVSB01803 *Redacted PTX 86 X X ThermaLite™ 1470 – FDA Clearance Number: K083613 TVSB12670 PTX 87 X X 06/13/02 biolitec Press Release, “biolitec’s New ELVeS™ Vein Treatment” VNUS_145888 – VNUS_145893 PTX 88 X X Brochure entitled, “ELVeS™ PL – Endo Laser Vein System A-6 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE – CASE NOS. C08-03129 MMC & C08-04234 MMC Exhibit Marked Admitted Sponsoring Witness Description – The gentle standard in Endovenous Therapies” VNUS_145861 – VNUS_145866 PTX 89 X X Brochure entitled, “ELVeS™ – Endo Laser Vein System: A unique and complete solution for treatment of the cause and results of venous incompetence” VNUS_145867 – VNUS_145872 PTX 90 X X Brochure entitled, “A Patient’s Guide to Gentle Treatment for Laser Vein Therapy” BIO000260 – BIO000261 PTX 91 X X Presentation entitled, “ELVeS® PL Laser – Sales Selling Points” BIO010816 – BIO010820 PTX 93 X X Brochure entitled, “ELVeS™ – A Unique and Complete Solution for Treatment of Venous Incompetence” VNUS_145873 – VNUS_145878 PTX 94 X X CoolTouch Press Release entitled, “CoolTouch Inc. Introduces New Saphfire 2.5F Fiber” dated May 16, 2006 VNUS_146247 – VNUS_146248 PTX 95 X X Brochure entitled, “CoolTouch CTEV – Laser Endovenous Treatment for Varicose Veins” C0002449 – C00002450 PTX 97 X X Brochure entitled, “Why Choose the CoolTouch CTEV for Your Varicose Vein Treatment?” C0002451 – C00002452 PTX 98 X X Brochure entitled, “CoolLipo Trio – Laser Assisted Liplysis & Skin Tightening” C0010088 – C0010089 PTX 100 X X Brochure entitled, “CoolTouch CTEV™ - 1320 nm Laser Endovenous Treatment for Varicose Veins” C0002453 – C0002458 PTX 101 X X Presentation entitled, “CoolTouch CTEV™ - CoolTouch EndoVenous Varicose Vein Therapy” C078026 – C078046 PTX 102 X X Collection of letters from R. Puddu to various doctors reintroducing the TVS product line (2005) A-7 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE – CASE NOS. C08-03129 MMC & C08-04234 MMC Exhibit Marked Admitted Sponsoring Witness Description TVSB01870 – TVSB01932 *Redacted PTX 104 X X Collection of customer contact information from the International Vein Congress in Miami, FL (April 20-22, 2006) TVS21268 – TVS21305 PTX 106 X X TVS flier entitled, “Please Save the Date!” (July 14, 2007 Symposium) TVS20712 PTX 108 X X Flier entitled, “Customize Your Own Endovenous Pack” TVSB00751 – TVSB00753 PTX 109 X X Flier entitled, “Customize Your Own Endovenous Pack” TVS01525 PTX 110 X X Draft mailer from D. Centanni with reviews from doctors (April 7, 2008) TVSB00158 PTX 111 X X Flier entitled, “All TVS Introducers…are compatible with all TVS Laser Fibers” TVS20695 PTX 112 X X Entry by R. Puddu re: Dr. R. Corpus TVSB01611 PTX 113 X X Collection of various TVS fliers and price lists TVS01497 – TVS01507 PTX 114 X X Flier entitled, “Why Use Sterile Endovenous Packs?” TVS01504 PTX 116 X X TVS flier entitled, “What Our Customers Have to Say” TVSB00056 PTX 117 X X TVS flier entitled, “Get Superior Results at a Fraction of the Cost!” VNUS2_083531 – VNUS2_083532 PTX 120 X X 10/30/08 Sales Quote for Carestation Health Centre BIO072093 – BIO072095 PTX 122 X X Presentation entitled, “Experience with Endovenous Laser A-8 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE – CASE NOS. C08-03129 MMC & C08-04234 MMC Exhibit Marked Admitted Sponsoring Witness Description Ablation for Varicose Veins” by Dr. P. Do BIO098328 – BIO098349 PTX 123 X X CoolTouch CTEV – Endovenous Surgical Procedure Presentation (2004) C0010255 – C0010272 PTX 130 X X 03/18/08 Consulting Agreement between biolitec, Inc. and Dr. J. Mauriello Mauriello Deposition Exhibit 178 PTX 131 X X PTX 132 X X 02/02/09 E-mail from J. Furcht to B. Foley BIO037543 – BIO037544 09/24/09 Letter from D. Centanni to Dr. N. Rattehali TVSB13921 PTX 135 X X List of doctors’ contact information TVS20659 – TVS20661 Flier entitled, “We’re Celebrating March Madness!!” PTX 137 X X TVSB01801 *Redacted PTX 139 X X 04/30/02 E-mail from B. Appling to B. Skutnik BIO100089 PTX 141 X X 07/16/08 E-mail from C. Estes to S. Digby, M. Tessier and C. Crossland BIO016002 – BIO016005 PTX 142 X X 07/22/08 E-mail from K. Moran to W. Neuberger and S. Spaniol BIO051838 – BIO051841 PTX 143 X X 07/24/08 E-mail from C. Estes to J. Ushinski, K. Diaz, N. Smith, L. Marchman, K. Rossner, T. Steele and T. Stock BIO010991 – BIO0100994 PTX 144 X X 07/29/08 E-mail from C. Estes to L. Marchman, T. Stock and K. Moran BIO015457 PTX 145 X X 07/30/08 E-mail from C. Estes to K. Moran and T. Stock BIO016207 – BIO016208 PTX 146 X X 08/07/08 E-mail from J. Mauriello to C. Crossland, K. A-9 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE – CASE NOS. C08-03129 MMC & C08-04234 MMC Exhibit Marked Admitted Sponsoring Witness Description Moran and T. Stock BIO086326 PTX 147 X X 08/13/08 E-mail from C. Estes to K. Moran BIO014327 – BIO014329 PTX 148 X X 08/18/08 E-mail from C. Estes to N. Smith BIO017108 PTX 153 X X 10/12/08 E-mail from C. Estes to J. Knudsen BIO016419 PTX 154 X X 10/14/08 E-mail from C. Estes to K. Moran BIO011541 PTX 155 X X 10/14/08 E-mail from C. Estes to Dr. Vanderpool and L. Marchman BIO017381 PTX 157 X X 01/13/09 E-mail from J. Furcht to C. Estes and M. Meade BIO072189 PTX 159 X X 02/11/09 E-mail from C. Estes to B. Foley, M. Sabado, B. Skutnik and T. Driscoll BIO011175 – BIO011176 PTX 163 X X 04/13/09 E-mail from C. Estes to B. Foley BIO017161 – BIO017163 PTX 164 X X 06/08/09 E-mail from C. Sagnak to J. Furcht and W. Neuberger BIO070367 PTX 171 X X 03/04/04 Facsimile from T. Schiek/D. Centanni and J. Kingsley TVS0922 – TVS0923 PTX 173 X X 05/27/04 Letter from T. Schiek Dr. Manjoney TVS01737 PTX 174 X X 10/27/04 Letter from T. Schiek to S. Eason TVS24492 PTX 178 X X 09/15/05 Facsimile from R. Puddu to S. Elias TVSB01606 – TVSB01607 PTX 186 X X Declaration of Dave Centanni, dated June 27, 2007 A-10 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE – CASE NOS. C08-03129 MMC & C08-04234 MMC Exhibit Marked Admitted Sponsoring Witness Description submitted in Diomed, Inc. v. Total Vein Solutions, LLC, U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts, Case No. 04-10686 NMG TVSB005779 – TVSB05781 *Redacted PTX 188 X X Flier entitled, “Total Vein Systems Means Value” TVSB01261 PTX 189 X X biolitec Radially Emitting Fiber x 6F ELVeS® Kit – Validation Sheets (101030 Rev. A) BIO001619 – BIO001648 PTX 190 X X 12/09/08 E-mail from K. Moran to J. Furcht, W. Neuberger and C. Estes BIO051322 – BIO051323 PTX 218 X X 09/28/04 510(k) Summary CoolTouch NS-160 Nd:YAG Laser System (K040921) C0007979 – C0007983 PTX 219 X X CoolTouch Inc. Nd:YAG Laser System 510(k) Premarket Notification Treatment of Varicose Veins Indication C0007140 – C0007153 *Redacted PTX 222 X X U.S. Patent No. 4,564,011 Laser Optic Device and Method (Goldman) PTX 223 X X U.S. Patent No. 4,643,186 Percutaneous Transluminal Microwave Catheter Angioplasty (Rosen and Walinsky) PTX 224 X X U.S. Patent No. 4,854,320 Laser Healing Method and Apparatus (Dew, Hsu and Halpern) PTX 225 X X U.S. Patent No. 5,196,004 Infrared Laser Catheter System (Sinofsky) PTX 226 X X U.S. Patent No. 5,531,739 Method of Treating Veins (Trelles) PTX 227 X X U.S. Patent No. 5,827,268 A-11 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE – CASE NOS. C08-03129 MMC & C08-04234 MMC Exhibit Marked Admitted Sponsoring Witness Description Device for the Treatment of Patent Ductus Arteriosus and Method of Using the Device (Laufer) VNUS_041027 – VNUS_041042 PTX 228 X X Berlien et al., “Lasers in Pediatric Surgery,” 25 PROGRESS IN PEDIATRIC SURGERY (1990) DMA-KS-000525 – DMA-KS-000542 PTX 229 X X Bing Liem and Mead, “Microwave Linear Ablation of the Isthmus Between the Inferior Vena Cava and Tricuspid Annulus,” 21 PACE 2079-2086 (November 1998) VNUS2_084132 – VNUS2_084139 PTX 230 X X Cheong et al., “Laser Balloon Angioplasty,” CRITICAL REVIEWS IN BIOMEDICAL ENGINEERING, 19(2,3):113-146 (1991) VNUS_0140328 – VNUS_140361 PTX 231 X X PTX 232 X X Gorisch & Boergen, “Laser Related Heat Effects on Blood Vessels,” Lasers in Biology and Medicine, Plenum Press, NY (1980) Harada et al., “Microwave Surgical Treatment of Diseases of Prostate,” UROLOGY. 1985 Dec;26(6):572-6 VNUS2_084071 – VNUS2_084075 PTX 233 X X Lin, “Catheter Microwave Ablation Therapy for Cardiac Arrhythmias,” 20 BIOELECTROMAGNETICS (1999) 120-132 VNUS2_084161 – VNUS2_084173 PTX 234 X X O’Reilly et al., “Transcatheter Fiberoptic Laser Coagulation of Blood Vessels,” RADIOLOGY 142:777-780, March 1982 BIO007184 – BIO007187 PTX 235 X X Sharp et al., “Microwaves for Menorrhaglia: A New Fast Technique for Eudometrial Ablation,” LANCET 1995; 346 (8981): 1003-1004 VNUS2_083994 – VNUS2_083996 PTX 236 X X Smith et al., “Microwave Thermal Balloon Angioplasty in the Normal Rabbit,” AMERICAN HEART JOURNAL 123(6); 1516-1521 (June 1992) VNUS2_084414 – VNUS2_084419 PTX 238 X X Ryan et al., “Experimental Brain Hyperthermia: Techniques for Heat Delivery and Thermometry,” I. J. RADIATION A-12 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE – CASE NOS. C08-03129 MMC & C08-04234 MMC Exhibit Marked Admitted Sponsoring Witness Description ONCOLOGY 20(4): 739-750 (April 1991) VNUS2_084302 – VNUS2_084313 PTX 239 X X Whayne et al., “Microwave Catheter Ablation of Myocardium in Vitro,” CIRCULATION 1994;89;2390-2395 VNUS2_083908 – VNUS2_083914 PTX 240 X X Wonnell et al., “Evaluation of Microwave and Radio Frequency Catheter Ablation in a Myocardium-Equivalent Phantom Model,” IBEE TRANSACTIONS ON BIOMEDICAL ENGINEERING 39(10) 1086-1095 (October 1992) VNUS2_084450 – VNUS2_084459 PTX 241 X X Compilation of biolitec’s Responses to VNUS’s Requests for Admission *Excerpted and redacted PTX 242 X X Compilation of CoolTouch’s Responses to VNUS’s Requests for Admission *Excerpted and redacted PTX 243 X X Compilation of TVS’s Responses to VNUS’s Requests for Admission *Excerpted and redacted PTX 244 X X Compilation of biolitec’s Responses to VNUS’s Interrogatories *Excerpted and redacted PTX 245 X X Compilation of CoolTouch’s Responses to VNUS’s Interrogatories *Excerpted and redacted PTX 246 X X Compilation of TVS’s Responses to VNUS’s Interrogatories *Excerpted and redacted PTX 252 X X VNUS presentation entitled, “The Competitive Landscape” (National Sales Meeting, February 2005) VNUS_126331 – VNUS_126351 PTX 253 X X American College Phlebology Final Program of 21st Annual Congress (November 8-11, 2007) VNUS_825256 – VNUS_825298 PTX 254 X X VNUS presentation entitled, “Selling Against the Competition” by M. Abelmann A-13 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE – CASE NOS. C08-03129 MMC & C08-04234 MMC Exhibit Marked Admitted Sponsoring Witness Description VNUS_140126 – VNUS_140158 PTX 257 X X VNUS® Closure System – Sales Training Manual CJ_01406 – CJ_01883 PTX 258 X X 04/01/02 Supply and Distribution Agreement between AngioDynamics, Inc. and biolitec, Inc. BIO003977 – BIO004002 PTX 259 X X 12/29/08 E-mail from C. Estes to J. Furcht BIO016007 PTX 262 X X CoolTouch Executive Summary (05/14/04) C0089137 – C0089143 PTX 263 X X CoolTouch Executive Summary (08/05/04) C0088568 – C0088573 PTX 264 X X 09/30/04 CoolTouch press release entitled, “CoolTouch CTEV™ 1320 nm Laser Gets FDA Clearance for Endovenous Treatment of the Greater Saphenous Vein” VNUS_146251 – VNUS_146252 PTX 267 X X CoolTouch Company Profile C0087368 PTX 268 X X CoolTouch Company Overview C0087358 – C0087359 PTX 283 X X 1/14/09 E-Mail from K. Moran to A. Henneberger and B. Foley BIO033259 PTX 284 X X TVS flier entitled, “EVLT, ELVeS, ELAS and VNUS – Why use Sterile Endovenous Packs?” TVS1472 PTX 288 X X FRE 1006 Summary (List of Asserted Claims) PTX 290 X X FRE 1006 Summary (chart depicting accused biolitec product sales and margin calculations prepared by Julie Davis) A-14 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE – CASE NOS. C08-03129 MMC & C08-04234 MMC Sponsoring Witness Exhibit Marked Admitted PTX 291 X X FRE 1006 Summary (chart depicting accused CoolTouch product sales and margin calculations prepared by Julie Davis) PTX 292 X X FRE 1006 Summary (chart depicting CoolTouch accused fiber revenue compared to fiber, parts and accessories revenue prepared by Julie Davis) PTX 293 X X FRE 1006 Summary (chart depicting accused TVS product sales and margin calculations prepared by Julie Davis) PTX 294 X X FRE 1006 Summary (chart depicting VNUS operating income statement prepared by Julie Davis) PTX 295 X X FRE 1006 Summary (chart depicting incremental margin on VNUS products prepared by Julie Davis) PTX 296 X X FRE 1006 Summary (chart depicting Defendants’ laser and fiber sales as % of VNUS generator and catheter sales from 2002-2010 prepared by Julie Davis) PTX 297 X X FRE 1006 Summary (chart depicting Defendants’ laser and fiber sales as % of VNUS generator and catheter sales from 2005-2010 prepared by Julie Davis) PTX 300 X X FRE 1006 Summary (chart of claims as construed by the Court in its Markman Ruling) PTX 301 X X Description 06/12/01 E-Mail from Wolfneuber@aol.com to W.Rauschning and C. Morello BIO100163 – BIO100165 DTX 501 X X biolitec Radial-Emitting Laser Fiber (e.g., Defendants' Depo. Ex. 357) DTX 502 X X Percutaneous Introducer (e.g., Defendants' Depo. Ex. 358) DTX 503 X X 1994 Article by Whayne et al re: "Microwave catheter ablation of myocardium in vitro. Assessment of the characteristics of issue heating and injury" (VNUS_140612 VNUS_140618) DTX 505 X X 1996 Syllabus from 10th Annual Congress of the North American Society of Phlebology (VNUS_033404 VNUS_033416) DTX 506 X X 1997 Program from the 11th Annual Congress of the North American Society of Phlebology (VNUS_033438 VNUS_033518) DTX 514 X X Apr. 12, 1999 Memo from Chris Jones and Liz Newman to Various Recipients re: "Trip Report - Dr. Goldman: Closure A-15 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE – CASE NOS. C08-03129 MMC & C08-04234 MMC Exhibit Marked Admitted Sponsoring Witness Description Patient #2 Treated on Friday, April 9, 1999" (CJ_03948 CJ_03949) DTX 517 X X Apr. 1999 Correspondence Between VNUS Personnel and Dr. Goldman (VNUS_041733 - VNUS_041735) DTX 518 X X Apr. 2, 2001 Email from Doug Petty to Various Recipients re: "Confirmation Order Letter 01188" (VNUS_418949 VNUS_418951) DTX 519 X X Apr. 2004 VNUS Slides re: "Marketing/International/Reimbursement MIR April 2004 Update" (VNUS_677355 - VNUS_677444) DTX 520 X X Apr. 24, 2001 VNUS Slides re: "Patent Status: Current States & Claims Expansion" (VNUS_053279 VNUS_053290) DTX 521 X X Apr. 24, 2002 VNUS Slides re: "VNUS Medical Technologies Board of Directors Meeting" (VNUS_795663 VNUS_795697) DTX 522 X X Apr. 25, 1997 VNUS Slides re: "VNUS Medical Technologies Board of Directors Meeting" (VNUS_885628 VNUS_885663) DTX 523 X X Apr. 25, 2006 Email from Brian Farley to Martha Stephens re: "Letter from Martha Stephens" (VNUS_249330 VNUS_249331) DTX 524 X X Apr. 28, 1999 Memo from Grace Schulz and Diane Villegas to Various Recipients re: "Goldman case reports, 4/15/99 and 4/21/99" (VNUS_025978 - VNUS_025980) DTX 527 X X Art Zikorus Lab Notebook (No. 005) (VNUS_004475 VNUS_004569) DTX 530 X X Aug. 14, 2007 Email from Parvinder Kalotia to Brian Farley re: "History of IFU's" (VNUS_672134 - VNUS_672135) DTX 532 X X Aug. 18, 2006 Email from Jim Fitzsimmons to Brian Farley re: "Proposed Medicare rates for Closure vs. EVL in 2007" (VNUS_966057 - VNUS_966058) DTX 533 X X Aug. 22, 2006 VNUS Slides re: "Meeting of the Board of Directors: Business Update" (VNUS_877163 VNUS_877241) DTX 535 X X Aug. 25, 1999 Memo from Chris Jones to Various Recipients re: CL-Fast Paint Alternative heating modalities (CJ_04176 - CJ_04177) DTX 536 X X Aug. 30, 2010 Screenshot of VNUS Webpage "Comparing A-16 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE – CASE NOS. C08-03129 MMC & C08-04234 MMC Exhibit Marked Admitted Sponsoring Witness Description Treatment Options" DTX 538 X X biolitec LA-0766 Rev. C (BIO004640 - BIO004663) DTX 539 X X biolitec ELVes Brochure ML-061 Rev. E (BIO000280 BIO000281) DTX 540 X X biolitec ELVeS PL Advertisement (BIO046045 BIO046046) DTX 541 X X biolitec ELVeS PL-1470 ML-290 Rev. E (BIO096358 BIO096363) DTX 542 X X biolitec IFU PI-024 Rev. A (BIO004915 - BIO004920) DTX 543 X X biolitec IFU PI-024 Rev. B (BIO099275 - BIO099278) DTX 544 X X biolitec IFU PI-024 Rev. C (BIO099245 - BIO0099274) DTX 545 X X biolitec IFU PI-044 Rev. A (BIO004973 - BIO004976) DTX 546 X X biolitec IFU PI-045 Rev A (BIO000005 - BIO000008) DTX 547 X X biolitec IFU PI-045 Rev. B (BIO001485 - BIO001488) DTX 548 X X biolitec IFU PI-045 Rev. C (BIO010435 - BIO010439) DTX 549 X X biolitec LA-0766 Rev E (BIO003401 - BIO003417) DTX 550 X X biolitec LA-0766 Rev. D (BIO000017 - BIO000042) DTX 551 X X biolitec LA-0777 Rev. A (BIO004774 - BIO004779) DTX 552 X X biolitec D15/810 Laser Manual ML-094 Rev A (BIO000297 - BIO000298) DTX 553 X X Chart re "Patents Related to VNUS-36322 (Restore) and Patents Related to VNUS-36323 (Closure)" (VNUS2_074350 - VNUS2_074350) DTX 554 X X CTEV 1320 nm Endovenous Laser Sales Video (C0010646 C0010646) DTX 555 X X CTEV Operation Manual -- Hennings Depo. Ex. 47 (C0007055 - C0007088) DTX 556 X X CTEV Treatment Guidelines - Endovenous Laser Procedure, 9-2007, 7035-006 (C0051129 - C0051137) DTX 561 X X Dec. 11, 1997 Fax from Douglas Petty to Carlos Betesh re: "Handouts from VNUS' recent presentation at the NASP meeting in Palm Springs" (MG 0000098 - MG 0000098) DTX 563 X X Dec. 13, 2005 VNUS Slides re: "VNUS Medical Technologies Meeting of the Board of Directors Business A-17 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE – CASE NOS. C08-03129 MMC & C08-04234 MMC Exhibit Marked Admitted Sponsoring Witness Description Update" (VNUS_837321 - VNUS_837370) DTX 566 X X Dec. 18, 1998 Email from Chris Jones to Various Recipients re: "Summary of Closure Treatment Temperatures and Catheter Pullback Speeds" (VNUS_019666 VNUS_019668) DTX 567 X X Dec. 19, 2005 Email from Maureen Bensing to Various Recipients re: "Dr. A. Dietzek - Veins not closed" (VNUS_535126 - VNUS_535127) DTX 571 X X Dec. 8, 2005 VNUS Meeting Minutes re: "Progress on the Investigation into Veins Not Closing" (VNUS_813637 VNUS_813637) DTX 574 X X Fall 2004 VNUS Slides re: "VNUS Medical Technologies, Inc. Initial Public Offering" (VNUS_107876 VNUS_107912) DTX 577 X X Feb. 14, 2001 Letter from Brian Farley to Celia Witten and James Dillard re: "A matter potentially affecting the protection of human subjects in a clinical study" (VNUS_051928 - VNUS_051930) DTX 584 X X Feb. 25, 2005 VNUS Slides re: "Town Meeting" (VNUS_115634 - VNUS_115676) DTX 597 X X Jan. 2001 VNUS Slides re: "The Closure Procedure vs. Vein Stripping and Ligation Surgery" (VNUS_050969 VNUS_050994) DTX 598 X X Jan. 2002 VNUS Closure Sales Training Manual (CJ_01406 - CJ_01883) DTX 606 X X Joseph Tartaglia Handwritten Notes from Nov. 1997 (VNUS_033266 - VNUS_033281) DTX 607 X X Jul. 11, 2001 Document Change Request for VNUS Closure IFU RM 55-285-01 Rev. D (VNUS_010344 VNUS_010432) DTX 612 X X Jul. 22, 1999 Memo from Brian Farley to All VNUS Distributors re: Discontinued "Support and Clinical Research of the Restore Catheter and Program" (VNUS_639084 VNUS_639085) DTX 616 X X Jul. 27, 1999 Memo from Christine Venture and Diane Villegas to Various Recipients re: "Dr. Goldman Case Reports" (VNUS_013655 - VNUS_013657) DTX 617 X X Jul. 27, 2001 Email from Jeffrey Frisbie to Various Recipients re: "Wrapless Compression" (VNUS_160528 - A-18 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE – CASE NOS. C08-03129 MMC & C08-04234 MMC Exhibit Marked Admitted Sponsoring Witness Description VNUS_160529) DTX 619 X X Jul. 3, 2007 Email from Brian Farley to Various Recipients re: "Dr. Harper's CLF Heating Model" (VNUS_474928 VNUS_474930) DTX 622 X X Jul. 7, 2001 Document Change Request re: VNUS Closure IFU RM 55-285-01 D (VNUS_010344 - VNUS_010432) DTX 628 X X Jun. 27, 1997 Memo from Chris Jones to Various Recipients re: "Proposed Experimental Plan for July 1, 1997 Animal Study at BAbCo" (CJ_04051 - CJ_04052) DTX 631 X X Jun. 30, 1999 Memo re: "Minutes from Patent/Research status meeting 6/29/99" (VNUS_038598 - VNUS_038599) DTX 633 X X Mar. 10, 1999 Email from Grace Schulz to Mitchell Goldman re: "Patent Application" (MG 0000386 - MG 0000386) DTX 639 X X Mar. 2005 Email Thread re: "SIR annual meeting sponsorship and May meeting support" (VNUS_366630 VNUS_366632) DTX 641 X X Mar. 24, 1998 Memo from Joe Tartaglia to Various Recipients re: "Product Development Review Meeting This Week in R&D - 3/23/98" (VNUS_040616 - VNUS_040620) DTX 647 X X Mar. 9, 1999 Email from Grace Schulz to Dr. Weiss re "Patent Application" (VNUS_041736 - VNUS_041739) DTX 670 X X Nov. 13, 2008 Letter from Jonathan Kahan to Richard Felton re: "Response to FDA's Comments Regarding the biolitec Ceralas D 1470nm Diode Laser" (BIO001649 - BIO001650) DTX 684 X X Objectives for 12/10/96 Animal Study (VNUS_023086 VNUS_023089) DTX 690 X X Oct. 17, 2005 Email from Bob McRae to Ignacio Cespedes re: "Clarification on laser consoles" (VNUS_266319 VNUS_266320) DTX 691 X X Oct. 20, 2006 Email from Rosenberg to Various Recipients re: "Hearing more and more of this unfortunately" (VNUS_966003 - VNUS_966006) DTX 693 X X Oct. 22, 1997 Memo from Chris Jones to Various Recipients re: "Closure Animal Results with preferred Treatment Method" (CJ_04270 - CJ_04272) DTX 701 X X Oct. 29,1998 Letter from Anita Zacherl et al to Mitchel Goldman re: "Closure human clinical research study" (MG A-19 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE – CASE NOS. C08-03129 MMC & C08-04234 MMC Exhibit Marked Admitted Sponsoring Witness Description 0000146 - MG 0000147) DTX 708 X X U.S. Patent No. 5,437,644 (BIO006974 - BIO006985) DTX 709 X X U.S. Patent No. 5,556,396 (BIO007547 - BIO007557) DTX 710 X X U.S. Patent No. 5,695,495 (BIO005154 - BIO005158) DTX 711 X X U.S. Patent No. 5,709,224 (BIO005045 - BIO005060) DTX 713 X X 1952 Vishnevsky "Collected Papers Volume V" (BIO006748 - BIO006789) DTX 714 X X 1953 Article by Nabatoff re: "A Complete Stripping of Varicose Veins Under Local Anesthesia" (BIO005205 BIO005208) DTX 715 X X 1956 Text by Vishnevsky re: "Local Anesthesia Via Creeping Infiltrate Technique" (BIO098354 - BIO098452) DTX 716 X X 1959 Article by Heijhol et al re: "Endovascular Electrocoagulation of Superficial Varices of the Lower Limbs" (BIO005061 - BIO005079) DTX 717 X X 1962 Article by Milostanov re: "Electrocoagulation as the Method of Choice for Surgical Treatment of Varicose Veins of the Lower Extremities" (BIO006543 - BIO006557) DTX 718 X X 1962 Article by Muranov re: "Electrocoagulation Treatment of Varicose Ceins of the Lower Extremities" (BIO006615 BIO006623) DTX 719 X X 1963 Article by Musaev re: "Intravascular Electrocoagulation of Subcutaneous Varicose Veins of the Lower Limbs" (BIO098580 - BIO098585) DTX 720 X X 1964 Article by Lamper re: "Electorcoagulation Method To Treat Varicose Veins of the Lower Extremity" (BIO006516 BIO006531) DTX 721 X X 1964 Article by Lamper re: "Electrocoagulation in the Treatment of Varicose Subcutaneous Veins of the Lower Extremities" (BIO006507 - BIO006515) DTX 722 X X 1966 Article by Milostanov re: "Endovascular Electrocoagulation: The Operation of Choice in Treating Varicose Veins of the Lower Extremities" (BIO006558 BIO006566) DTX 723 X X 1966 Article by Politowski and Zelazny re: "Complications and difficulties in electrocoagulation of varices of the lower extremities" (BIO005086 - BIO005088) A-20 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE – CASE NOS. C08-03129 MMC & C08-04234 MMC Sponsoring Witness Exhibit Marked Admitted Description DTX 724 X X 1966 Dissertation Abstract by Muranov re: "Treatment of Varcose Veins of the Lower Extremity by the Endovascular Electrocoagulation Method" (BIO006624 - BIO006647) DTX 725 X X 1967 Article by Lamper and Bogulavskaya re: "PathologicMorphological Changes in the Veins After Endovascular Electrocoagulation" (BIO006532 - BIO006542) DTX 727 X X 1970 Article by Frantsev and Yershov re: "The Use of Puncture Mono-Active Electrodes in the Treatment of Varicose Veins of the Lower Limbs" (BIO006481 BIO006490) DTX 728 X X 1973 Article by Frantsev et al re: "New Electrodes for Electrosurgical Treatment of Subcutaneous Varicose Veins" (BIO006500 - BIO006506) DTX 730 X X 1974 Article by Ershov (high quality) DTX 731 X X 1974 Article by Ershov re: "Multimodality Treatment of Varicosity with Electrocoaguation Medical Guidelines" (BIO006428 - BIO006455) DTX 732 X X 1974 Article by O'Reilly re: "Endovenous Diathermy Solerosis as a Unit of the Armamentarium for the Attack on Varicose Veins" (BIO005093 - BIO005093) DTX 734 X X 1977 Article by O'Reilly re: "Endovenous Diathermy Sclerosis of Varicose Veins" (BIO005083 - BIO005085) DTX 735 X X 1977 Article by Ziada and Mansour re: "Electro-Diathermy of the Long Saphenous Vein in Situ as an Alternative to Stripping" (BIO005130 - BIO005131) DTX 736 X X 1980 Article by Sedov and Aleksandrov re: "Reducing Complications from Electrosurgival Treatment of Varicose Veins of the Lower Limbs" (BIO006691 - BIO006697) DTX 737 X X 1981 Article by O'Reilly re: "A Technique of Diathermy Sclerosis of Varicose Veins" (BIO005444 - BIO005447) DTX 738 X X 1987 Article by Klein re: "The Tumescent Technique for Lipo-Suction Surgery" (BIO008015 - BIO008019) DTX 739 X X 1991 Article by Frantsev et al re: "Treatment of Varicose Disease" (BIO006491 - BIO006499) DTX 740 X X 1992 Article by Coleman and Klein re: "Use of the Tumescent Technique for Scalp Surgery, Dermabrasion, and Soft Tissue Reconstruction" (BIO005685 - BIO005690) DTX 741 X X 1992 Article by Cragg et al re: "Endovascular Diathermic A-21 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE – CASE NOS. C08-03129 MMC & C08-04234 MMC Exhibit Marked Admitted Sponsoring Witness Description Vessel Occlusion" (BIO005100 - BIO005105) DTX 742 X X 1994 Article by Goldman et al re: "Diagnosis and treatment of varicose veins: A review" (BIO005184 - BIO005204) DTX 743 X X 1994 Article by Gradman re: "Venoscopic Obliteration of Variceal Tributaries Using Monopolar Electrocautery" (BIO005138 - BIO005141) DTX 745 X X 1995 Article by Cohn, Seiger and Goldman re: "Ambulatory Phlebectomy Using the Tumescent Technique for Local Anesthesia" (BIO007193 - BIO007198) DTX 747 X X 1995 Text re Ambulatory Phlebectomy (Chapter 15 -- "High Ligation Division and Groin-to-Knee Stripping of the LSV: An Office Procedure") (BIO007212 - BIO007235) DTX 748 X X 1995 Text re Ambulatory Phlebectomy (Chapter 7 -"Anesthesia") (BIO005213 - BIO005219) DTX 750 X X 1996 Article by Crockett et al re: "Preliminary Experience with an Endovascular Catheter for Electrocoagulation of Peripheral Veins" (BIO005089 - BIO005092) DTX 752 X X 1997 Abstract by Sagoo et al re: Safe Plasma Prilocaine Concentrations (PPC) after Tumescence Local Anesthesia (TLA) in Varices Surgery (BIO098565 - BIO098571) DTX 753 X X 1997 Article by Sattler et al re: "Tumescent Technique for Local Anesthesia - Clinical Investigation to Examine the Pharmacokinetics of Prilocaine" (BIO007977 - BIO007989) DTX 754 X X 1997 Article by Sattler re: "Tumescence Anesthesia" (BIO098576 - BIO098578) DTX 756 X X 1998 Article by Proebstle et al re: "High Ligation and Stripping of the Long Saphenous Vein using the Tumescent Technique for Local Anesthesia" (BIO005220 - BIO005224) DTX 763 X X Oct. 7, 1972 Article by Watts re: "Endovenous Diathermy Destruction of Internal Saphenous" (BIO005150 BIO005150) DTX 764 X X PCT WO 97/32532 (BIO006795 - BIO006870) DTX 765 X X U.S. Patent No. 5,643,257 (BIO006986 - BIO006995) DTX 767 X X U.S. Patent No. 5,827,268 (VNUS_041027 VNUS_041042) DTX 768 X X U.S. Patent No. 6,165,172 (BIO007032 - BIO007058) DTX 769 X X U.S. Patent No. 6,200,312 (BIO007059 - BIO007085) A-22 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE – CASE NOS. C08-03129 MMC & C08-04234 MMC Sponsoring Witness Exhibit Marked Admitted Description DTX 780 X X Sept. 17, 1997 Email from Chris Jones to Various Recipients re: "Draft of Animal Studies Section of Technical File for LG-1/CL-504" (CJ_04197 - CJ_04198) DTX 783 X X Sept. 7, 2000 Document Change Request re: VNUS Closure IFU RM 55-285-01 Rev. A (VNUS_010115 VNUS_010125) DTX 787 X X Table 1 "Sales Units and Sales Revenue for biolitec Lasers and Disposables" from Stuckwisch Expert Report DTX 788 X X 2007 Procedure Packs Catalog (TVSB_04026 TVSB_04039) DTX 789 X X 2008 TVS Advertisements (TVSB_00112 - TVSB_00117) DTX 790 X X 2008 TVS Catalog (TVSB_00234 - TVSB_00265) DTX 791 X X 2008 TVS CYA Pack Advertisement (TVSB_00230 TVSB_00233) DTX 792 X X 2008 TVS Introducer Mailer (TVSB_00221 - TVSB_00221) DTX 793 X X 2008 TVS Laser Fiber Advertisements (TVSB_00226 TVSB_00229) DTX 794 X X 2008 TVS New Product Updates (TVSB_00218 TVSB_00220) DTX 795 X X 400 and 600 Micron Core Five Times Reusable Fiber Instructions for Use - (March 2007) (TVSB_13968 TVSB_13971) DTX 796 X X 400 Micron Surgical Laser Fiber Sample (TVSB_13479 TVSB_13479) DTX 805 X X 5F Introducer Kit 45 cm with 0.35 Guidewire Sample (TVSB_13481 - TVSB_13481) DTX 806 X X 5F One Step Introducer Sample (TVSB_13478 TVSB_13478) DTX 807 X X 600 Micron Fiber Sample (TVSB_13480 - TVSB_13480) DTX 808 X X Advertising Flyer (TVSB07697 - TVSB07697) DTX 813 X X Custom Pack No Introducer Sample (TVSB_13484 TVSB_13484) DTX 815 X X Customer Letter Re Purchase ThermaLite 1470 (TVSB_13921 - TVSB_13921) DTX 818 X X Email Correspondence - Brady Esch to Julie Gowett et al Re: TVS Fiber IFU (VNUS_469418 - VNUS_469418) A-23 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE – CASE NOS. C08-03129 MMC & C08-04234 MMC Exhibit DTX 834 Marked X Admitted X Sponsoring Witness Description FDA 510K (K022338) Premarket Notification - Indications for Use - Optical Integrity General Shaped Fiber (TVSB_14200 - TVSB_14208) * Redacted DTX 835 X X FDA 510K (K022338) SUMMARY Optical Integrity General Shaped Fibers (TVSB_14959 - TVSB_14959) DTX 839 X X FDA 510K (K083613) Letter to Quanta Re 510K Polysurge Diode Laser Family - Dec. 23, 2008 (TVSB_14947 - TVSB_14949) DTX 840 X X FDA 510K (K083613) Summary - Quanta System Polysurge Diode Laser Family - Dec. 23, 2008 (TVSB_14223 TVSB_14255) DTX 841 X X FDA 510K (K083613) THERMALITE 1470 FDA CLEARANCE (TVSB_14958 - TVSB_14958) DTX 851 X X FDA 510K Clearance for 1470 nm laser for lipolysis; (TVSB15169 - TVSB15172) DTX 852 X X FDA 510K for Optical Integrity General Shaped Fiber (K022338) (TVSB_13987 - TVSB_13987) DTX 854 X X FDA Letter to TVS (2004) (TVSB_14274 - TVSB_14275) DTX 855 X X Form Letter from Centanni Re Marketing Symposium (TVS_21958 - TVS_21958) DTX 859 X X Guidewire - Instruction for Use / Product Information Sheet (TVSB08685 - TVSB08685) DTX 860 X X Introducer Products - Instructions for Use / Product Information Sheet (TVSB_13955 - TVSB_13955) DTX 862 X X Marketing Symposium - RSVP Sheet (July 2007) (TVSB09670 - TVSB09670) DTX 863 X X Marketing Symposium Flyer - July 14, 2007 (TVSB09666 TVSB09669) DTX 864 X X Marketing Symposum Flyer - Schedule - July 14, 2007 (TVSB09681 - TVSB09681) DTX 866 X X Optical Advantage Advertisement - Dec. 2008 (TVSB_00097 - TVSB_00098) DTX 867 X X Optical Integrity/TVS 600 Micron Safe Align Fibers Instructions for Use (TVSB07003 - TVSB07008) DTX 869 X X Quanta Systems 510K Premarket Notification – Quanta Diode Laser Family (TVSB_14960 - TVSB_15127) A-24 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE – CASE NOS. C08-03129 MMC & C08-04234 MMC Sponsoring Witness Exhibit Marked Admitted Description DTX 872 X X Surgical Supply Headquarters Flyer (TVSB07564 TVSB07564) DTX 874 X X ThermaShield 365 and 550 Micron Core Single Use Laser Fibers - Instructions for Use - Revision A (TVSB_13964 TVSB_13967) DTX 875 X X TVS - Introducer Products - Instructions for Use / Product Information Sheet (TVSB08686 - TVSB08686) DTX 876 X X TVS 2010 Product Catalog (TVSB_13998 - TVSB_14023) DTX 877 X X TVS 400 and 600 Micron Core Single Use Optical Laser Fibers - Instructions for Use (TVSB07001 - TVSB07002) DTX 878 X X TVS 400 and 600 Micron Core, Reuse Optical Laser Fibers Instructions for Use (March 2007) (TVSB07012 TVSB07015) DTX 879 X X TVS Advertisement - Quanta 1470 (TVSB12588 TVSB12588) DTX 880 X X TVS Advertisement - Thermalite 1470 (TVSB12584 TVSB12584) DTX 882 X X TVS Advertisement - Thermalite Laser Fiber Advertisement (TVSB12586 - TVSB12586) DTX 883 X X TVS Catalog - Universal & Custom Procedure Packs (TVSB09989 - TVSB09996) DTX 886 X X TVS Fiber IFU (VNUS_461299 - VNUS_461299) DTX 889 X X TVS Flyer - Laser Fibers with Spin Lock (VNUS_377903 VNUS_377903) DTX 890 X X TVS Flyer - Marked Introducers (TVSB10657 TVSB10657) DTX 891 X X TVS Flyer - Marked Introducers (TVSB10849 TVSB10849) DTX 892 X X TVS Mailer - Symposium Highlights (TVSB09930 TVSB09931) DTX 893 X X TVS March Madness Advertisement with BONUS Video (TVS_01516) DTX 894 X X TVS Optical Advantage 1500 - Quick Reference Guide (TVSB12593 - TVSB12596) DTX 895 X X TVS Optical Advantage 1500 - User Manual (TVSB12616 TVSB12644) A-25 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE – CASE NOS. C08-03129 MMC & C08-04234 MMC Sponsoring Witness Exhibit Marked Admitted Description DTX 900 X X TVS Symposium "Please Save the Date" Flyer - July 14, 2007 (TVSB07508 - TVSB07508) DTX 901 X X TVS Thermalite 550um Core Fibers - Instructions for Use (TVSB12612 - TVSB12615) DTX 902 X X TVS Thermashield Laser Fiber Advertisement (TVSB12591 - TVSB12592) DTX 903 X X Universal Pack Sample (TVSB_13483 - TVSB_13483) DTX 904 X X Universal Pack with Micro Introducers Sample (TVSB_13482 - TVSB_13482) DTX 910 X X VNUS Presentation - "Selling Against the Competition" (VNUS_140126 - VNUS_140158) DTX 913 X X U.S. Patent Application No. 08/927251 (VNUS_048352 VNUS_048395) DTX 926 X X Video (VNUS_90447A -- Def. Depo. Ex. 86) DTX 927 X X VNUS Closure Catheter IFU RM 55-285-01 Rev. F (VNUS_005548 - VNUS_005595) DTX 928 X X VNUS Closure IFU RM 55-171-01 Rev. C (VNUS_000961 - VNUS_000990) DTX 929 X X VNUS Closure IFU RM 55-245-01 Rev. A (VNUS_000757 - VNUS_000762) DTX 930 X X VNUS Closure IFU RM 55-245-01 Rev. D (VNUS_000874 - VNUS_000910) DTX 931 X X VNUS Closure IFU RM 55-285-01 Rev. A (VNUS_001123 - VNUS_001130) DTX 932 X X VNUS Closure IFU RM 55-285-01 Rev. B (VNUS_001133 - VNUS_01138) DTX 933 X X VNUS Closure IFU RM 55-285-01 Rev. C (VNUS_01143 VNUS_001181) DTX 934 X X VNUS Closure IFU RM 55-285-01 Rev. D (VNUS_01184 VNUS_01224) DTX 935 X X VNUS Closure IFU RM 55-285-01 Rev. G (VNUS_332402 - VNUS_332449) DTX 936 X X VNUS Closure IFU RM 55-357-01 Rev. D (VNUS_325405 - VNUS_325447) DTX 937 X X VNUS Closure Plus IFU RM 55-357-01 Rev. C (VNUS_585728 - VNUS_585734) A-26 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE – CASE NOS. C08-03129 MMC & C08-04234 MMC Sponsoring Witness Exhibit Marked Admitted Description DTX 939 X X VNUS ClosureFAST IFU RM 55-529-01 Rev C (VNUS_147588 - VNUS_147642) DTX 940 X X VNUS ClosureFAST IFU RM 55-529-01 Rev. A (VNUS_716222 - VNUS_716228) DTX 941 X X VNUS ClosureFAST IFU RM 55-529-01 Rev. B (VNUS_773118 - VNUS_773158) DTX 942 X X VNUS ClosurePLUS IFU RM 55-357-01 Rev E (VNUS_147471 - VNUS_147513) DTX 943 X X VNUS Growth Strategies - Short-Term and Mid-Term Review of Senior Staff and Board Discussions (VNUS_884955 - VNUS_884959) DTX 944 X X VNUS Medical Technologies Early Clinical Version Straight Ligator LG-1 Design History File (VNUS_038702 VNUS_039107) DTX 947 X X VNUS Medical Technologies Marketing Profile, Closure SS Intravascular Catheter for Ligation of the Long or Short Saphenous Systems (LSV & SSV) & Primary Junctions (SFJ & SPJ) (CJ_03165 - CJ_03177) DTX 948 X X VNUS Medical Technologies, Inc. "Intro to Venous Disease" United States Training Manual (VNUS_114349 VNUS_114388) DTX 949 X X VNUS Screenshots re: "VNUS ClosureRFS: Treats Perforator Vein Reflux" (BIO000699 - BIO000710) DTX 952 X X VNUS Slides re: "Knowing Your Customer: Vascular, General, IR" (VNUS_877758 - VNUS_877779) DTX 954 X X VNUS Slides re: "Procedural Improvements for $$$" (VNUS_191293 - VNUS_191309) DTX 956 X X VNUS Slides re: "VNUS Closure Products Current Platform and Product Pipeline" (VNUS_189314 - VNUS_189359) DTX 961 X X Jul. 30, 2008 Email from Lawrence Marchman to Trevor Stock et al re: "2nd case with Vanderpool" (BIO052344BIO052344) DTX 970 X X FRE 1006 Summary of VNUS's Responses to Defendants' Requests for Admission JTX 1000 X X List of stipulated facts, as per Stipulated Joint Jury Instruction Nos. 3 and 27 A-27 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING JOINT STIPULATED MOTION TO ADMIT CERTAIN EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE – CASE NOS. C08-03129 MMC & C08-04234 MMC

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.