Eric Savoy v. Collectors Universe, Inc. et al, No. 8:2020cv00632 - Document 34 (C.D. Cal. 2020)
Court Description: ORDER GRANTING STIPULATED PROTECTIVE ORDER by Magistrate Judge Autumn D. Spaeth re Stipulation for Protective Order 33 . [See Order for Specifics.] (et)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Eric Savoy v. Collectors Universe, Inc. et al ' ( ) * + , . / '& '' '( ') '* '+ ', ''. '/ (& (' (( () (* (+ (, (- Doc. 34 =QU`T 3% 3``XQ_Qe !D4@ ',.*-&" WM``XQ_Qe2M``XQ_Qe_`[^Y%O[Y <[TZ B% HM^P !D4@ (-*./+" VcM^P2M``XQ_Qe_`[^Y%O[Y 3EE>7D7I g DEAC?# >>B ''' BMOURUOM# DaU`Q '*& ;^bUZQ# 53 /(,'. EQX0 !-'*" +&.$*/*/ 8Md0 !-'*" +&.$&&'+ 3``[^ZQe_ R[^ 6QRQZPMZ` 5[XXQO`[^j_ FZUbQ^_Q# ;ZO% ;52:.- 9:*:.9 -29:82,: ,6;8: ,.5:8*3 -29:82,: 6/ ,*32/6852* 7C;5 D3GAI# MZ UZPUbUPaMX# [Z TU_ [cZ " ,*9. 56#) ()%$UDRU$$'&% -6, !*-9S" " NQTMXR MZP [Z NQTMXR [R MXX [`TQ^_ " _UYUXM^Xe _U`aM`QP# " 68-.8 08*5:250 9:27;3*:." 786:.,:2<. 68-.8 BXMUZ`URR# " " b_% " 5A>>75EACjD F@;G7CD7# ;@5%# PNM " " BCA87DD;A@3> DBACED " 3FE:7@E;53EAC# M 6QXMcM^Q " O[^¥[^M`U[Z1 BH55 ?M^WQ`¥XMOQ# >>5# " MZ A^QS[Z O[^¥[^M`U[Z1 C;5= " BCA4DE7;@# MZ UZPUbUPaMX# PNM " BCA4DE7;@'()# MZP 6A7D ' `T^[aST " (&# UZOXa_UbQ# " " 6QRQZPMZ`_% " " (. BMSQ ' 9:27;3*:.- 786:.,:2<. 68-.8 Dockets.Justia.com ETQ 5[a^`# TMbUZS ^QMP `TQ D`U¥aXM`QP B^[`QO`UbQ A^PQ^ QZ`Q^QP UZ`[ Ne BXMUZ`URR ' ( ) * + 7^UO DMb[e !9BRLT" MZP 6QRQZPMZ`_ 5[XXQO`[^_ FZUbQ^_Q# ;ZO% !,LJJFDPLNO"# BH55 ?M^WQ`¥XMOQ# >>5 !7=,,"# MZP CUOW B^[N_`QUZ !7NLCOPFIK"'# MZP S[[P OMa_Q M¥¥QM^UZS `TQ^QR[^# TQ^QNe [^PQ^_ M_ R[XX[c_0 , ;E ;D :7C74I AC67C76 E:3E0 . '% ETQ BM^`UQ_ YMe YM^W P[OaYQZ`_ [^ [`TQ^ PU_O[bQ^e ^Q_¥[Z_Q_ [^ YM`Q^UMX_ M_ / h5[ZRUPQZ`UMX E^MPQ DQO^Q` ;ZR[^YM`U[Z%i 8a^`TQ^# `TQ BM^`UQ_ MZP `TQU^ O[aZ_QX '& YMe UZPUOM`Q Pa^UZS PQ¥[_U`U[Z_# [^ UZ M c^U`UZS PQXUbQ^QP `[ MXX [R `TQ BM^`UQ_ '' cU`TUZ `QZ !'&" PMe_ R[XX[cUZS `TQ PQ¥[_U`U[Z# `TM` OQ^`MUZ `Q_`UY[Ze [^ OQ^`MUZ '( ') P[OaYQZ`_ ¥^[PaOQP M^Q 5[ZRUPQZ`UMX E^MPQ DQO^Q` ;ZR[^YM`U[Z% '* '+ (% 3XX 6U_O[bQ^e ^Q_¥[Z_Q_ MZP YM`Q^UMX_ UZ `TU_ OM_Q PQ_USZM`QP M_ 5[ZRUPQZ`UMX ', E^MPQ DQO^Q` ;ZR[^YM`U[Z _TMXX NQ YMUZ`MUZQP [Z MZ hM``[^ZQe_j QeQ_ [ZXei ''. NM_U_# `[ NQ ^QbUQcQP MY[ZS `TQ BM^`UQ_j M``[^ZQe_ !,LQKOFJ" MZP `TQ R[XX[cUZS0 '/ M% QY¥X[eQQ_ [R 5[aZ_QX `[ cT[Y U` U_ ^QM_[ZMNXe ZQOQ__M^e `[ PU_OX[_Q `TQ (& UZR[^YM`U[Z R[^ `TU_ XU`USM`U[Z1 (' N% UZPUbUPaMX BM^`UQ_ cT[ TMbQ _USZQP `TQ h3S^QQYQZ` `[ 4Q 4[aZP Ne (( () B^[`QO`UbQ A^PQ^i !.SHICIP *"1 (* O% QdQOa`UbQ_ [R QZ`U`e BM^`UQ_ cT[ TMbQ _USZQP `TQ h3S^QQYQZ` `[ 4Q (+ (, ((. DMb[e# 5[XXQO`[^_# BH55# MZP B^[N_`QUZ _TMXX NQ ^QRQ^^QP UZPUbUPaMXXe M_ M h7BNPTi [^ O[XXQO`UbQXe M_ `TQ h7BNPIFO%i 5[XXQO`[^_# BH55# MZP B^[N_`QUZ _TMXX NQ ^QRQ^^QP `[ O[XXQO`UbQXe M_ h-FGFKEBKPO ' BMSQ ( 9:27;3*:.- 786:.,:2<. 68-.8 4[aZP Ne B^[`QO`UbQ A^PQ^i !.SHICIP *"1 ' ( P% Qd¥Q^`_ QZSMSQP Ne [^ R[^ 5[aZ_QX `[ cT[Y PU_OX[_a^Q U_ ^QM_[ZMNXe ) ZQOQ__M^e R[^ `TU_ XU`USM`U[Z MZP cT[ TMbQ _USZQP `TQ h3S^QQYQZ` `[ 4Q * 4[aZP Ne B^[`QO`UbQ A^PQ^i !.SHICIP *"1 + , - Q% `TQ 5[a^` MZP U`_ ¥Q^_[ZZQX !_aNVQO` `[ `TQ ^Q_`^UO`U[Z_ UZ BM^MS^M¥T * NQX[c"1 . / R% O[a^` ^Q¥[^`Q^_# `TQU^ _`MRR_# MZP ¥^[RQ__U[ZMX bQZP[^_ `[ cT[Y PU_OX[_a^Q '& U_ ^QM_[ZMNXe ZQOQ__M^e R[^ `TU_ XU`USM`U[Z MZP cT[ TMbQ _USZQP `TQ '' h3S^QQYQZ` `[ 4Q 4[aZP Ne B^[`QO`UbQ A^PQ^i !.SHICIP *"1 '( ') '* S% MZ Ma`T[^ [^ UZ`QZPQP ^QOU¥UQZ` !Q%S%# ¥Q^_[Z_ hOOjPi [^ hNOOjPi" [R `TQ P[OaYQZ` [^ `TQ [^USUZMX _[a^OQ [R `TQ UZR[^YM`U[Z% '+ ', '- )% 7dOQ¥` M_ ¥Q^YU``QP UZ BM^MS^M¥T ( MN[bQ# `TQ BM^`UQ_# 5[aZ_QX# MZP `TQ '. _USZM`[^UQ_ `[ `TQ 3S^QQYQZ` `[ 4Q 4[aZP Ne B^[`QO`UbQ A^PQ^ MS^QQ `TM` `TQe '/ _TMXX Z[` PU_`^UNa`Q# PU__QYUZM`Q# PU_OX[_Q# ¥aNXU_T# ¥[_`# `^MZ_YU`# [^ [`TQ^cU_Q (& (' (( () (* _TM^Q `TQ PU_O[bQ^e YM`Q^UMX_# [^ MZe O[¥UQ_ `TQ^Q[R# YM^WQP M_ 5[ZRUPQZ`UMX E^MPQ DQO^Q` ;ZR[^YM`U[Z [^ MZe ¥[^`U[Z `TQ^Q[R MN_QZ` Ra^`TQ^ [^PQ^ [R `TQ 5[a^`% (+ *% ;Z `TQ QbQZ` M BM^`e cU_TQ_ `[ a_Q MZe PU_O[bQ^e YM`Q^UMX_ PQ_USZM`QP M_ (, 5[ZRUPQZ`UMX E^MPQ DQO^Q` ;ZR[^YM`U[Z# [^ MZe ¥M¥Q^_ O[Z`MUZUZS [^ YMWUZS ((. ^QRQ^QZOQ `[ `TQ O[Z`QZ`_ [R `TQ PU_O[bQ^e YM`Q^UMX_ PQ_USZM`QP M_ 5[ZRUPQZ`UMX BMSQ ) 9:27;3*:.- 786:.,:2<. 68-.8 ' E^MPQ DQO^Q` ;ZR[^YM`U[Z# UZ MZe ¥XQMPUZS [^ P[OaYQZ` RUXQP cU`T `TQ 5[a^` UZ ( `TU_ MO`U[Z# `TQ BM^`UQ_ _TMXX R[XX[c `TQ ¥^[OQPa^Q_ [a`XUZQP UZ `TQ >[OMX CaXQ_ ) R[^ `TQ 5QZ`^MX 6U_`^UO` [R 5MXUR[^ZUM# CaXQ -/$+%(%(% * + +% , 5[aZ_QX _TMXX YMUZ`MUZ MZ MOOa^M`Q MZP O[Y¥XQ`Q ^QO[^P [R MXX ¥Q^_[Z_ MZP QZ`U`UQ_ cT[Y `TQe TMbQ ¥Q^YU``QP `[ bUQc `TQ PU_O[bQ^e YM`Q^UMX_ PQ_USZM`QP . M_ 5[ZRUPQZ`UMX E^MPQ DQO^Q` ;ZR[^YM`U[Z# UZOXaPUZS `TQ ¥Q^_[Zj_ [^ QZ`U`ej_ / O[Z`MO` UZR[^YM`U[Z MZP M PQ_O^U¥`U[Z [R `TQ PU_O[bQ^e PQ_USZM`QP M_ '& 5[ZRUPQZ`UMX E^MPQ DQO^Q` ;ZR[^YM`U[Z `TM` `TQe cQ^Q _T[cZ% ETQ 5[a^` [Z U`_ '' [cZ Y[`U[Z# [^ [Z `TQ Y[`U[Z [R MZe BM^`e# YMe ^Q]aU^Q `TQ ¥^[PaO`U[Z [R `TQ '( ') ^QO[^P_ PQ_O^UNQP UZ `TU_ ¥M^MS^M¥T R[^ UZ_¥QO`U[Z Ne `TQ 5[a^` MZP `TQ BM^`UQ_% '* '+ ,% ', 7dOQ¥`UZS M BM^`ej_ [cZ 5[ZRUPQZ`UMX E^MPQ DQO^Q` ;ZR[^YM`U[Z# cU`TUZ _QbQZ !-" PMe_ [R `TQ RUZMX PU_¥[_U`U[Z [R `TU_ MO`U[Z !cTQ`TQ^ Ne VaPSYQZ`# ''. M¥¥QMX# _Q``XQYQZ`# [^ [`TQ^cU_Q" MXX [R `T[_Q UZ ¥[__Q__U[Z [R MZ[`TQ^ BM^`ej_ '/ PU_O[bQ^e YM`Q^UMX_ PQ_USZM`QP M_ 5[ZRUPQZ`UMX E^MPQ DQO^Q` ;ZR[^YM`U[Z# (& UZOXaPUZS MZe O[¥UQ_ `TQ^Q[R# _TMXX ¥Q^YMZQZ`Xe PQ_`^[e `TQ PU_O[bQ^e YM`Q^UMX_ (' PQ_USZM`QP M_ 5[ZRUPQZ`UMX E^MPQ DQO^Q` ;ZR[^YM`U[Z# MZP MXX O[¥UQ_ `TQ^Q[R# MZP (( () SUbQ `TQ BM^`e cT[ PQ_USZM`QP `TQ PU_O[bQ^e YM`Q^UMX_ M_ 5[ZRUPQZ`UMX E^MPQ (* (+ DQO^Q` ;ZR[^YM`U[Z c^U``QZ Z[`UOQ [R U`_ PQ_`^aO`U[Z cU`TUZ _QbQZ !-" PMe_ [R U`_ (, PQ_`^aO`U[Z% ((. -% F¥[Z MZ MXXQSQP bU[XM`U[Z [R `TU_ D`U¥aXM`QP B^[`QO`UbQ A^PQ^# `TQ 5[a^`# [Z BMSQ * 9:27;3*:.- 786:.,:2<. 68-.8 ' U`_ [cZ Y[`U[Z# [^ [Z `TQ Y[`U[Z [R MZe BM^`e [^ Z[Z$¥M^`e# YMe S^MZ` ^QXUQR M_ ( U` PQQY_ M¥¥^[¥^UM`Q UZ XMc [^ Q]aU`e% ) * + , . / '& '' '( ') '* .% ETU_ D`U¥aXM`QP B^[`QO`UbQ A^PQ^ _TMXX ^QYMUZ UZ QRRQO` MZP _TMXX O[Z`UZaQ `[ NQ NUZPUZS R[^QbQ^# UZOXaPUZS MR`Q^ `TQ RUZMX PU_¥[_U`U[Z [R `TU_ MO`U[Z# aZXQ__ `Q^YUZM`QP Ne !M" _`U¥aXM`U[Z QdQOa`QP Ne `TQ BM^`UQ_ MZP ^QXQbMZ` Z[Z$¥M^`UQ_ [^ `TQU^ ^Q_¥QO`UbQ 5[aZ_QX1 [^ !N" 5[a^` [^PQ^ R[^ S[[P OMa_Q _T[cZ% /% F¥[Z PU_O[bQ^e [R MZe aZMa`T[^UfQP PU_OX[_a^Q [R PU_O[bQ^e YM`Q^UMX_ PQ_USZM`QP M_ 5[ZRUPQZ`UMX E^MPQ DQO^Q` ;ZR[^YM`U[Z Ne `TQ BM^`UQ_# 5[aZ_QX# MZP `TQ _USZM`[^UQ_ `[ `TQ 3S^QQYQZ` `[ 4Q 4[aZP Ne B^[`QO`UbQ A^PQ^# _MUP ¥Q^_[Z_ _TMXX UYYQPUM`QXe Z[`URe `TQ BM^`UQ_ [R _aOT aZMa`T[^UfQP PU_OX[_a^Q% ;Z '+ `TQ QbQZ` MZe bU[XM`U[Z [R `TU_ D`U¥aXM`QP B^[`QO`UbQ A^PQ^ U_ MXXQSQP# `TQ BM^`UQ_ ', MS^QQ `TM` `TQe cUXX RU^_` `^e `[ ^Q_[XbQ MZe PU_¥a`Q UZ S[[P RMU`T [Z MZ UZR[^YMX ''. NM_U_% ;R UZR[^YMX ^Q_[Xa`U[Z U_ Z[` RQM_UNXQ# `TQ BM^`UQ_ TMbQ `TQ ^UST` `[ _QQW '/ R^[Y `TQ 5[a^` M ^Q_[Xa`U[Z MZP ^QYQPe R[^ `TQ MXXQSQP bU[XM`U[Z# UZOXaPUZS MXX (& (' (( () (* (+ (, ((. [R `TQ _MZO`U[Z_ MbMUXMNXQ aZPQ^ 8QPQ^MX XMc% 7MOT BM^`e# `TQ _USZM`[^UQ_ `[ `TQ 3S^QQYQZ` `[ 4Q 4[aZP Ne B^[`QO`UbQ A^PQ^# MZP 5[aZ_QX _TMXX [ZXe NQ ^Q_¥[Z_UNXQ R[^ `TQU^ [cZ ^Q_¥QO`UbQ N^QMOT!Q_" [R `TU_ D`U¥aXM`QP B^[`QO`UbQ A^PQ^% '&% @[`TUZS UZ `TU_ D`U¥aXM`QP B^[`QO`UbQ A^PQ^ _TMXX NQ O[Z_`^aQP M_ cMUbUZS `TQ BM^`UQ_j ^UST`_ `[ [NVQO` MZP Z[` ^Q_¥[ZP `[ PU_O[bQ^e PQYMZP_# UZ`Q^^[SM`[^UQ_# BMSQ + 9:27;3*:.- 786:.,:2<. 68-.8 ' MZP ]aQ_`U[Z_ ¥[_QP M` PQ¥[_U`U[Z_ O[ZOQ^ZUZS ¥^[`QO`QP `^MPQ _QO^Q` ( UZR[^YM`U[Z [^ [`TQ^ ¥^UbUXQSQP YM`Q^UMX_% ) * + , - ''% DT[aXP MZe BM^`e [NVQO` `[ MZe P[OaYQZ` PQYMZP MZP QXQO` Z[` `[ ^Q_¥[ZP `[ `TQ PQYMZP NM_QP [Z M ¥^UbUXQSQ# `TQ BM^`e _TMXX ¥^[PaOQ M B^UbUXQSQ >[S cU`T U`_ PU_O[bQ^e ^Q_¥[Z_Q_% ETQ B^UbUXQSQ >[S _TMXX UZOXaPQ `TQ R[XX[cUZS . UZR[^YM`U[Z0 !'" PM`Q [R P[OaYQZ`1 !(" UPQZ`U`e MZP ¥[_U`U[Z [R ^QOU¥UQZ`_1 !)" / UPQZ`U`e MZP ¥[_U`U[Z [R Ma`T[^1 !*" P[OaYQZ` PQ_O^U¥`U[Z1 !+" ¥^UbUXQSQ OXMUYQP1 '& '' '( ') '* MZP !," ¥^Q_QZ` X[OM`U[Z [R P[OaYQZ`% '(% @[ PU_O[bQ^e YM`Q^UMX_ ¥^[PaOQP UZ `TU_ OM_Q YMe NQ a_QP [a`_UPQ [R `TU_ OM_Q# UZOXaPUZS UZ MZe [`TQ^ XMc_aU`% '+ ', ''. ;E ;D DA AC67C76% 6M`QP0 <aZQLLL# 23 (&(& '/ (& (' (( /s/ Autumn D. Spaeth AUTUMN D. SPAETH F@;E76 DE3E7D MAGISTRATE <F697 () (* (+ (, ((. BMSQ , 9:27;3*:.- 786:.,:2<. 68-.8 ' .>12+2: * ( *08..4.5: :6 +. +6;5- +? 786:.,:2<. 68-.8 ) * + , - ;# LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL J¥^UZ` [^ `e¥Q RaXX ZMYQK# [R LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL J¥^UZ` [^ `e¥Q QY¥X[eQ^j_ ZMYQ MZP RaXX MPP^Q__K# PQOXM^Q aZPQ^ ¥QZMX`e [R ¥Q^Va^e `TM` ; TMbQ . ^QMP UZ U`_ QZ`U^Q`e MZP aZPQ^_`MZP `TQ D`U¥aXM`QP B^[`QO`UbQ A^PQ^ !9PIMQJBPFE 7NLPFDPIRF / 6NEFN" QZ`Q^QP Ne `TQ FZU`QP D`M`Q_ 6U_`^UO` 5[a^`# 5QZ`^MX 6U_`^UO` [R 5MXUR[^ZUM UZ `TQ '& '' '( ') '* OM_Q [R $/+) &(2.3 *1 (," 2" #.,,*)1./0 '-+2*/0*! %-)" *1 (,"# OM_Q Z[% .0(&lObl&&,)( 6A5 !36Dd" ; MS^QQ `[ O[Y¥Xe cU`T MZP `[ NQ N[aZP Ne MXX `TQ `Q^Y_ [R `TU_ D`U¥aXM`QP B^[`QO`UbQ '+ A^PQ^% ; aZPQ^_`MZP MZP MOWZ[cXQPSQ `TM` RMUXa^Q `[ _[ O[Y¥Xe O[aXP Qd¥[_Q YQ `[ ', Y[ZQ`M^e MZP Z[ZY[ZQ`M^e _MZO`U[Z_# UZOXaPUZS ¥aZU_TYQZ` UZ `TQ ZM`a^Q [R O[Z`QY¥`% ; ''. _[XQYZXe ¥^[YU_Q `TM` ; cUXX Z[` PU_OX[_Q UZ MZe YMZZQ^ MZe UZR[^YM`U[Z [^ U`QY `TM` U_ '/ _aNVQO` `[ `TQ D`U¥aXM`QP B^[`QO`UbQ A^PQ^ `[ MZe ¥Q^_[Z [^ QZ`U`e QdOQ¥` UZ _`^UO` (& (' (( () (* O[Y¥XUMZOQ cU`T `TQ ¥^[bU_U[Z_ [R `TQ D`U¥aXM`QP B^[`QO`UbQ A^PQ^% ; Ra^`TQ^ MS^QQ `[ _aNYU` `[ `TQ Va^U_PUO`U[Z [R `TQ FZU`QP D`M`Q_ 6U_`^UO` 5[a^`# 5QZ`^MX 6U_`^UO` [R 5MXUR[^ZUM R[^ `TQ ¥a^¥[_Q [R QZR[^OUZS `TQ `Q^Y_ [R `TU_ D`U¥aXM`QP B^[`QO`UbQ A^PQ^# QbQZ UR _aOT (+ QZR[^OQYQZ` ¥^[OQQPUZS_ [OOa^ MR`Q^ `TU_ MO`U[Z U_ `Q^YUZM`QP% (, DUSZM`a^Q0LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL ((. 6M`Q0LLLLLLLLLLLLLL 5U`e MZP D`M`Q cTQ^Q _USZQP0LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL BMSQ 9:27;3*:.- 786:.,:2<. 68-.8
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
