Ruben Mendoza v. Nancy A. Berryhill, No. 5:2018cv01206 - Document 17 (C.D. Cal. 2019)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER by Magistrate Judge Alicia G. Rosenberg. IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that the decision of the Commissioner is affirmed. (see document for details) (hr)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Ruben Mendoza v. Nancy A. Berryhill Doc. 17 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 : WPKVGF"UVCVGU"FKUVTKEV"EQWTV ; EGPVTCN"FKUVTKEV"QH"ECNKHQTPKC 32 33 TWDGP"O0. 34 Rnckpvkhh. 35 36 37 x0 PCPE["C0"DGTT[JKNN."Cevkpi Eqookuukqpgt"qh"Uqekcn"Ugewtkv{. Fghgpfcpv0 38 39 + Pq0"GFEX"3:/3428"CIT" + + + + OGOQTCPFWO"QRKPKQP"CPF"QTFGT +""""""""" + + + + + Rnckpvkhh3"hkngf"vjku"cevkqp"qp"Lwpg"7."423:0""Rwtuwcpv"vq"4:"W0U0E0"¸"858*e+."vjg 3: rctvkgu"eqpugpvgf"vq"rtqeggf"dghqtg"vjg"ocikuvtcvg"lwfig0""*Fmv0"Pqu0";."320+""Qp 3; Hgdtwct{"43."423:."vjg"rctvkgu"hkngf"c"Lqkpv"Uvkrwncvkqp"*ÐLUÑ+"vjcv"cfftguugf"vjg 42 fkurwvgf"kuuwgu0""Vjg"eqwtv"jcu"vcmgp"vjg"ocvvgt"wpfgt"uwdokuukqp"ykvjqwv"qtcn 43 ctiwogpv0 44 45 Jcxkpi"tgxkgygf"vjg"gpvktg"hkng."vjg"eqwtv"chhktou"vjg"fgekukqp"qh"vjg Eqookuukqpgt0 46 47 48 49 4: """""3""RnckpvkhhÓu"pcog"jcu"dggp"rctvkcnn{"tgfcevgf"kp"eqornkcpeg"ykvj"Hgf0"T0"Ekx0"R0 704*e+*4+*D+"cpf"vjg"tgeqoogpfcvkqp"qh"vjg"Eqookvvgg"qp"Eqwtv"Cfokpkuvtcvkqp"cpf Ecug"Ocpcigogpv"qh"vjg"Lwfkekcn"Eqphgtgpeg"qh"vjg"Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu0 Dockets.Justia.com 3 K0 4 RTQEGFWTCN"DCEMITQWPF 5 Rnckpvkhh"hkngf"cp"crrnkecvkqp"hqt"fkucdknkv{"kpuwtcpeg"dgpghkvu"qp"Fgegodgt"39. 6 4236"cpf"cnngigf"cp"qpugv"fcvg"qh"Oc{"34."42360""Cfokpkuvtcvkxg"Tgeqtf"*ÐCTÑ+"390" 7 Vjg"crrnkecvkqp"ycu"fgpkgf"kpkvkcnn{"cpf"qp"tgeqpukfgtcvkqp0""CT"39.";7."3280""Rnckpvkhh 8 tgswguvgf"c"jgctkpi"dghqtg"cp"Cfokpkuvtcvkxg"Ncy"Lwfig"*ÐCNLÑ+0""Qp"Hgdtwct{"32. 9 4239."vjg"CNL"eqpfwevgf"c"jgctkpi"cv"yjkej"Rnckpvkhh"cpf"c"xqecvkqpcn"gzrgtv"*ÐXGÑ+ : vguvkhkgf0""CT"57/:50""Qp"Cwiwuv"44."4239."vjg"CNL"kuuwgf"c"fgekukqp"fgp{kpi"dgpghkvu0" ; CT"36/490""Qp"Oc{"6."423:."vjg"Crrgcnu"Eqwpekn"fgpkgf"tgxkgy0""CT"4/80""Vjku"cevkqp 32 hqnnqygf0 33 KK0 34 UVCPFCTF"QH"TGXKGY 35 Rwtuwcpv"vq"64"W0U0E0"¸"627*i+."vjku"eqwtv"jcu"cwvjqtkv{"vq"tgxkgy"vjg 36 EqookuukqpgtÓu"fgekukqp"vq"fgp{"dgpghkvu0""Vjg"fgekukqp"yknn"dg"fkuvwtdgf"qpn{"kh"kv"ku"pqv 37 uwrrqtvgf"d{"uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg."qt"kh"kv"ku"dcugf"wrqp"vjg"crrnkecvkqp"qh"kortqrgt 38 ngicn"uvcpfctfu0""Moncada v. Chater."82"H05f"743."745"*;vj"Ekt0"3;;7+"*rgt"ewtkco+= 39 Drouin v. Sullivan.";88"H04f"3477."3479"*;vj"Ekt0"3;;4+0 3: ÐUwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpegÑ"ogcpu"Ðoqtg"vjcp"c"ogtg"uekpvknnc"dwv"nguu"vjcp"c 3; rtgrqpfgtcpeg"Î"kv"ku"uwej"tgngxcpv"gxkfgpeg"vjcv"c"tgcuqpcdng"okpf"okijv"ceegrv"cu 42 cfgswcvg"vq"uwrrqtv"vjg"eqpenwukqp0Ñ""Moncada."82"H05f"cv"7450""Kp"fgvgtokpkpi"yjgvjgt 43 uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"gzkuvu"vq"uwrrqtv"vjg"EqookuukqpgtÓu"fgekukqp."vjg"eqwtv"gzcokpgu 44 vjg"cfokpkuvtcvkxg"tgeqtf"cu"c"yjqng."eqpukfgtkpi"cfxgtug"cu"ygnn"cu"uwrrqtvkpi 45 gxkfgpeg0""Drouin.";88"H04f"cv"34790""Yjgp"vjg"gxkfgpeg"ku"uwuegrvkdng"vq"oqtg"vjcp 46 qpg"tcvkqpcn"kpvgtrtgvcvkqp."vjg"eqwtv"owuv"fghgt"vq"vjg"EqookuukqpgtÓu"fgekukqp0" 47 Moncada."82"H05f"cv"7450 48 49 4: 4 3 KKK0 4 FKUEWUUKQP 5 C0 Fkucdknkv{ 6 C"rgtuqp"swcnkhkgu"cu"fkucdngf."cpf"vjgtgd{"gnkikdng"hqt"uwej"dgpghkvu."Ðqpn{"kh"jku 7 rj{ukecn"qt"ogpvcn"korcktogpv"qt"korcktogpvu"ctg"qh"uwej"ugxgtkv{"vjcv"jg"ku"pqv"qpn{ 8 wpcdng"vq"fq"jku"rtgxkqwu"yqtm"dwv"ecppqv."eqpukfgtkpi"jku"cig."gfwecvkqp."cpf"yqtm 9 gzrgtkgpeg."gpicig"kp"cp{"qvjgt"mkpf"qh"uwduvcpvkcn"ickphwn"yqtm"yjkej"gzkuvu"kp"vjg : pcvkqpcn"geqpqo{0Ñ""Barnhart v. Thomas."762"W0U0"42."43/44"*4225+"*ekvcvkqp"cpf ; swqvcvkqp"octmu"qokvvgf+0 32 D0 Vjg"CNLÓu"Hkpfkpiu 33 Vjg"CNL"hqwpf"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"ogv"vjg"kpuwtgf"uvcvwu"tgswktgogpvu"vjtqwij 34 Fgegodgt"53."42420""CT"3;0""Hqnnqykpi"vjg"hkxg/uvgr"ugswgpvkcn"cpcn{uku"crrnkecdng"vq 35 fkucdknkv{"fgvgtokpcvkqpu."Lounsburry v. Barnhart."68:"H05f"3333."3336"*;vj"Ekt0"4228+.4 36 vjg"CNL"hqwpf"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"jcf"vjg"ugxgtg"korcktogpvu"qh"fgigpgtcvkxg"fkue"fkugcug"qh 37 vjg"egtxkecn"cpf"nwodct"urkpg"ykvj"jkuvqt{"qh"nwodct"ncokpgevqo{"kp"3;;5."nwodct"hwukqp 38 kp"3;;7."egtxkecn"hwukqp"kp"4226"cpf"egtxkecn"hwukqp"jctfyctg"tgoqxcn"kp"4229="oknf 39 dkncvgtcn"ectrcn"vwppgn"u{pftqog="cpf"qdgukv{0""CT"3;0"" 3: Vjg"CNL"hqwpf"vjcv."vjtqwij"vjg"fcvg"ncuv"kpuwtgf."Rnckpvkhh"jcu"vjg"tgukfwcn 3; hwpevkqpcn"ecrcekv{"*ÐTHEÑ+"vq"rgthqto"nkijv"yqtm"gzegrv"vjcv"jg"eqwnf"nkhv1ectt{1rwuj1rwnn 42 wr"vq"42"rqwpfu"qeecukqpcnn{"cpf"wr"vq"32"rqwpfu"htgswgpvn{="ukv1uvcpf1ycnm"hqt"ukz 43 jqwtu"kp"cp"gkijv/jqwt"yqtmfc{"ykvj"c"ukv1uvcpf"qrvkqp"uq"vjcv"jg"eqwnf"ejcpig"rqukvkqpu 44 crrtqzkocvgn{"gxgt{"42/52"okpwvgu="qeecukqpcnn{"enkod"ncffgtu."tqrgu"cpf"uechhqnfu= 45 htgswgpvn{"dcncpeg="qeecukqpcnn{"rgthqto"qvjgt"rquvwtcn"cevkxkvkgu="cpf"htgswgpvn{ 46 47 48 49 4: """""4""Vjg"hkxg/uvgr"ugswgpvkcn"cpcn{uku"gzcokpgu"yjgvjgt"vjg"enckocpv"gpicigf"kp uwduvcpvkcn"ickphwn"cevkxkv{."yjgvjgt"vjg"enckocpvÓu"korcktogpv"ku"ugxgtg."yjgvjgt"vjg korcktogpv"oggvu"qt"gswcnu"c"nkuvgf"korcktogpv."yjgvjgt"vjg"enckocpv"ku"cdng"vq"fq"jku qt"jgt"rcuv"tgngxcpv"yqtm."cpf"yjgvjgt"vjg"enckocpv"ku"cdng"vq"fq"cp{"qvjgt"yqtm0" Lounsburry."68:"H05f"cv"33360 5 3 rgthqto"hkpg"cpf1qt"itquu"ocpkrwncvkqp"dkncvgtcnn{0""Jg"ycu"tguvtkevgf"htqo"yqtmkpi"cv 4 wprtqvgevgf"jgkijvu="yqtmkpi"ctqwpf"oqxkpi"ocejkpgt{"cpf"qvjgt"jc|ctfu="cpf 5 rgthqtokpi"cp{"qxgtjgcf"yqtm"ykvj"jku"wrrgt"gzvtgokvkgu0""CT"420""Rnckpvkhh"ku"wpcdng"vq 6 rgthqto"jku"rcuv"tgngxcpv"yqtm"dwv"vjgtg"ctg"lqdu"vjcv"gzkuv"kp"ukipkhkecpv"pwodgtu"kp"vjg 7 pcvkqpcn"geqpqo{"vjcv"jg"eqwnf"rgthqto"uwej"cu"ecujkgt."uvqtcig"hceknkv{"tgpvcn"engtm"cpf 8 rncuvke"rctvu"cuugodngt0""CT"47/480 9 E0 : Ft0"Jcvej"rgthqtogf"cp"citggf"ogfkecn"gzcokpcvkqp"qp"Lwn{"33."42380""CT"8;4/ ; Ft0"JcvejÓu"Yqtmgtu"Eqorgpucvkqp"Qrkpkqp 9890""Ft0"Jcvej"qrkpgf"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"ycu"rtgenwfgf"htqo"jgcx{"yqtm="rtqnqpigf 32 ukvvkpi1uvcpfkpi="rtqnqpigf"rqukvkqpkpi"qh"jku"jgcf"kp"cymyctf"rqukvkqpu="xgt{"hqteghwn 33 cevkxkvkgu="cpf"rtqnqpigf"v{rkpi1mg{dqctfkpi1hkpg"ocpkrwncvkqp0""Rnckpvkhh"eqwnf"pqv"tgvwtp 34 vq"jku"wuwcn"cpf"ewuvqoct{"fwvkgu"cu"cp"gngevtkecn"ogejcpke0""CT"9830 35 Rnckpvkhh"ctiwgu"vjcv"Ft0"JcvejÓu"qrkpkqp"Ðengctn{"fkhhgtgf"htqo"vjg"CNLÓu"qyp 36 hkpfkpiu1eqpenwukqpu.Ñ"urgekhkecnn{"cu"vq"vjg"tguvtkevkqp"cickpuv"jgcx{"nkhvkpi0""*LU"cv"7."90+ 37 Vjg"CNL"cempqyngfigf"Ft0"JcvejÓu"hwpevkqpcn"tguvtkevkqpu0""CT"450""Cnvjqwij"vjg 38 CNL"fkf"pqv"gzrtguun{"cuukip"vjg"ygkijv"jg"icxg"Ft0"JcvejÓu"qrkpkqpu."vjku"ku"pqv 39 pgeguuctkn{"c"dcuku"hqt"tgocpf0""See Magallanes v. Bowen."::3"H04f"969."977"*;vj"Ekt0 3: 3;:3+"*ÐKv"ku"vtwg"vjcv"vjg"CNL"fkf"pqv"tgekvg"vjg"ocike"yqtfu."ÒK"tglgev"Ft0"HqzÓu"qrkpkqp 3; cdqwv"vjg"qpugv"fcvg"dgecwug"0"0"0"0Ó""Dwv"qwt"ecugu"fq"pqv"tgswktg"uwej"cp"kpecpvcvkqp0" 42 Cu"c"tgxkgykpi"eqwtv."yg"ctg"pqv"fgrtkxgf"qh"qwt"hcewnvkgu"hqt"ftcykpi"urgekhke"cpf 43 ngikvkocvg"kphgtgpegu"htqo"vjg"CNLÓu"qrkpkqp0""Kv"ku"rtqrgt"hqt"wu"vq"tgcf"vjg"rctcitcrj 44 fkuewuukpi"Ft0"RqpvÓu"hkpfkpiu"cpf"qrkpkqp."cpf"ftcy"kphgtgpegu"tgngxcpv"vq"Ft0"HqzÓu 45 hkpfkpiu"cpf"qrkpkqp."kh"vjqug"kphgtgpegu"ctg"vjgtg"vq"dg"ftcyp0Ñ+0"" 46 Eqpvtct{"vq"RnckpvkhhÓu"ctiwogpv."vjgtg"ku"pq"kpfkecvkqp"kp"vjg"CNLÓu"fgekukqp"vjcv 47 vjg"CNL"tglgevgf"Ft0"JcvejÓu"qrkpkqpu0""Cp"CNL"ku"tgswktgf"vq"ugv"hqtvj"urgekhke"cpf 48 ngikvkocvg"tgcuqpu"uwrrqtvgf"d{"uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"kp"vjg"tgeqtf"qpn{"yjgp"vjg"CNL 49 tglgevu"qt"fkueqwpvu"c"rj{ukecpÓu"qrkpkqp0""See Matthews v. Shalala."32"H05f"89:."8:2/ 4: :3"*;vj"Ekt0"3;;5+0""Qrkpkqpu"eqwejgf"kp"yqtmgtu"eqorgpucvkqp"vgtokpqnqi{"Ðrtgugpv"cp 6 3 gzvtc"ejcnngpig0""Vjg"CNL"owuv"ÒvtcpuncvgÓ"vgtou"qh"ctv"eqpvckpgf"kp"uwej"ogfkecn 4 qrkpkqpu"kpvq"vjg"eqttgurqpfkpi"Uqekcn"Ugewtkv{"vgtokpqnqi{"kp"qtfgt"vq"ceewtcvgn{ 5 cuuguu"vjg"kornkecvkqpu"qh"vjqug"qrkpkqpu"hqt"vjg"Uqekcn"Ugewtkv{"fkucdknkv{ 6 fgvgtokpcvkqp0Ñ""Booth v. Barnhart."3:3"H0"Uwrr0"4f"32;;."3328"*E0F0"Ecn0"4224+0""Ð]V_jg 7 CNLÓu"fgekukqp"pggf"pqv"eqpvckp"cp"gzrnkekv"Òvtcpuncvkqp0ÓÑ""Id.""ÐKp"cpcn{|kpi"ogfkecn 8 qrkpkqpu"wukpi"uvcvg"yqtmgtuÓ"eqorgpucvkqp"vgtokpqnqi{."vjg"CNL"Òku"gpvkvngf"vq"ftcy 9 kphgtgpegu"Ðnqikecnn{"hnqykpi"htqo"vjg"gxkfgpeg0ÑÓÑ""Id."*ekvcvkqp"qokvvgf+0"" : ; Vjg"CNL"eqwnf"tgcuqpcdn{"kpvgtrtgv"Ft0"JcvejÓu"qrkpkqp"cu"eqpukuvgpv"ykvj"jku THE"cuuguuogpv0""Ceeqtfkpi"vq"RnckpvkhhÓu"vguvkoqp{."jku"rcuv"yqtm"tgswktgf"nkhvkpi"72"vq 32 322"rqwpfu"cpf"dgkpi"qp"jku"hggv"ukz"jqwtu"rgt"fc{0""CT"67/680""Wpfgt"Ecnkhqtpkc 33 yqtmgtu"eqorgpucvkqp"vgtokpqnqi{."Ðc"enckocpv"kpecrcdng"qh"rgthqtokpi"Òjgcx{Ó"yqtm 34 oc{"dg"ecrcdng"qh"rgthqtokpi"Ònkijv.Ó"ugok/ugfgpvct{.Ó"qt"Òugfgpvct{Ó"yqtm0""Desrosiers 35 v. Sec’y.":68"H04f"795."798"*;vj"Ekt0"3;::+0""ÐPqpg"qh"vjgug"vjtgg"ecvgiqtkguÑ"Î"nkijv. 36 ugok/ugfgpvct{"qt"ugfgpvct{"Î"Ðku"dcugf"qp"uvtgpivj0""Tcvjgt."vjg{"vwtp"qp"yjgvjgt"c 37 enckocpv"ukvu."uvcpfu."qt"ycnmu"hqt"oquv"qh"vjg"fc{0""Gcej"gpvcknu"c"Òokpkowo"qh 38 fgocpfu"hqt"rj{ukecn"ghhqtv0ÓÑ""Id."*ekvkpi"Uejgfwng"hqt"Tcvkpi"Rgtocpgpv"Fkucdknkvkgu. 39 Iwkfgnkpgu"hqt"Yqtm"Ecrcekv{."3/C"*Ncdqt"Eqfg"qh"vjg"Uvcvg"qh"Ecnkhqtpkc+0+05""Rnckpvkhh 3: jcu"pqv"ujqyp"cp"kpeqpukuvgpe{"ykvj"vjg"CNLÓu"THE"cuuguuogpv"qh"nkijv"yqtm0""See 3; Macri v. Chater.";5"H05f"762."766"*;vj"Ekt0"3;;8+"*hkpfkpi"CNL"yjq"cuuguugf"THE"qh 42 nkijv"yqtm"fkf"pqv"gtt"kp"tgn{kpi"qp"qrkpkqpu"vjcv"enckocpv"ycu"rtgenwfgf"htqo"jgcx{ 43 yqtm"cpf"nkokvgf"vq"nkijv"yqtm"kp"yqtmgtu"eqorgpucvkqp"eqpvgzv+="Holloway v. Berryhill. 44 4239"W0U0"Fkuv0"NGZKU"3;2325.",33/,34"*E0F0"Ecn0"Pqx0"38."4239+"*hkpfkpi"rtgenwukqp 45 htqo"jgcx{"yqtm"kp"yqtmgtu"eqorgpucvkqp"eqpvgzv"ku"pqv"kpeqpukuvgpv"ykvj"THE"hqt"nkijv 46 yqtm+="Cerritos v. Colvin."4238"W0U0"Fkuv0"NGZKU"7779;.",32"*E0F0"Ecn0"Crt0"47."4238+ 47 *pqvkpi"rtkqt"fghkpkvkqp"qh"jgcx{"nkhvkpi"kp"yqtmgtu"eqorgpucvkqp"eqpvgzv"ogcpv"enckocpv 48 49 4: """""5""Vjg"Uejgfwng"hqt"Tcvkpi"Rgtocpgpv"Fkucdknkvkgu"ku"kuuwgf"rwtuwcpv"vq"vjg"cwvjqtkv{ kp"Ecn0"Ncd0"Eqfg"¸"68820 7 3 eqwnf"pqv"nkhv"oqtg"vjcp"42"rqwpfu"dwv"ewttgpv"uejgfwng"fqgu"pqv"fghkpg"jgcx{"nkhvkpi+= 4 Glass v. Workers’ Comp. Appeals Bd.."327"Ecn0"Crr0"5f"4;9."524"p03"*3;:2+"*pqvkpi 5 rtgxkqwu"fghkpkvkqp"qh"fkucdknkv{"rtgenwfkpi"jgcx{"yqtm"Ð]e_qpvgorncvgu"vjg"kpfkxkfwcn"jcu 6 nquv"crrtqzkocvgn{"jcnh"qh"jku"rtg/kplwt{"ecrcekv{"hqt"rgthqtokpi"uwej"cevkxkvkgu"cu 7 dgpfkpi."uvqqrkpi."nkhvkpi."rwujkpi."rwnnkpi."cpf"enkodkpi"qt"qvjgt"cevkxkvkgu"kpxqnxkpi 8 eqorctcdng"rj{ukecn"ghhqtvÑ+0""Pqt"ku"vjgtg"cp{"crrctgpv"kpeqpukuvgpe{"dgvyggp"Ft0 9 JcvejÓu"qvjgt"tguvtkevkqpu"cpf"vjg"CNLÓu"THE"cuuguuogpv"nkokvkpi"Rnckpvkhh"vq"c"ukv1uvcpf : qrvkqp"cv"ngcuv"gxgt{"42/52"okpwvgu6"ykvj"pq"qxgtjgcf"yqtm"cpf"pq"oqtg"vjcp"htgswgpv ; hkpg"qt"itquu"ocpkrwncvkqp0 32 Rnckpvkhh"cnuq"eqornckpu"vjcv"vjg"CNL"kortqrgtn{"tglgevgf"c"32/rqwpf"tguvtkevkqp"qp 33 jku"cdknkv{"vq"nkhv1ectt{1rwuj1rwnn0""Vjg"CNL"tglgevgf"vjku"tguvtkevkqp"kp"c"ogfkecn"qrkpkqp 34 htqo"Ft0"Ocvvct"kp"Crtkn"4237"dgecwug"kv"ycu"pqv"uwrrqtvgf"d{"jku"enkpkecn"hkpfkpiu0""CT 35 470""Ft0"Ocvvct"fqgu"pqv"gzrnckp"vjg"dcuku"hqt"jku"qrkpkqp"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"eqwnf"tgvwtp"vq 36 yqtm"ykvj"c"32/rqwpf"tguvtkevkqp"qp"nkhvkpi1rwnnkpi1rwujkpi0""CT"7660""Ft0"Ocvvct"tgrqtvgf 37 vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"ycu"kp"pq"crrctgpv"fkuvtguu"cpf"jku"egtxkecn"rquvwtg"ycu"rtgugtxgf0""Jg 38 jcf"fgetgcugf"tcpig"qh"oqvkqp"d{"72'0""CT"75;0""Vjg"tgockpfgt"qh"vjg"gzcokpcvkqp"qh 39 vjg"ujqwnfgtu."gndqyu."ytkuvu"cpf"jcpfu"ygtg"pqtocn0""CT"762/640""Pgwtqxcuewnct 3: vguvkpi"ycu"pqtocn"cpf"oqvqt"uvtgpivj"ycu"6170""CT"7650""Urgekcn"vguvkpi"ycu"pgicvkxg0" 3; CT"75;/640""Vjg"CNL"eqpenwfgf"vjcv"Ft0"Ocvvct"oc{"jcxg"dggp"kphnwgpegf"d{"RnckpvkhhÓu 42 fkucitggogpv"vjcv"jg"eqwnf"tgvwtp"vq"yqtm."yjkej"ecwugf"Ft0"Ocvvct"vq"tghgt"Rnckpvkhh"vq 43 cpqvjgt"rj{ukekcp0""CT"44."47="see"CT"7660""Vjg"CNL"icxg"rctvkcn"ygkijv"vq"vjg"qrkpkqpu 44 qh"Ft0"Ugfij."yjq"qrkpgf"kp"Oc{"4237"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"ycu"ecrcdng"qh"nkhvkpi"wr"vq"42 45 rqwpfu"qeecukqpcnn{"cpf"32"rqwpfu"htgswgpvn{0""CT"46."6590""Vjg"CNL"cnuq"pqvgf"vjcv 46 Rnckpvkhh"ogv"ykvj"jku"rckp"ocpcigogpv"urgekcnkuv"kp"4238"cpf"uvcvgf"jg"ycu"cdng"vq 47 hwpevkqp"ykvj"ogfkecvkqp0""CT"44"*ekvkpi"CT":25.":2;.":37.":43*pqvkpi"72'"kortqxgogpv 48 kp"rckp++0""Vjg"CNLÓu"tgcuqpu"hqt"fkueqwpvkpi"Ft0"OcvvctÓu"32/rqwpf"tguvtkevkqp"ycu 49 4: """""6""Rnckpvkhh"vguvkhkgf"vjcv"jg"eqwnf"ukv"qt"uvcpf"37/42"okpwvgu0""CT"6;0 8 3 uwrrqtvgf"d{"uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg0""Orn v. Astrue."6;7"H05f"847."854"*;vj"Ekt0"4229+= 4 see"also"Carmickle v. Comm'r."755"H05f"3377."3386"*;vj"Ekt0"422:+. ÐYjgp"vjgtg"ku 5 eqphnkevkpi"ogfkecn"gxkfgpeg."vjg"Ugetgvct{"owuv"fgvgtokpg"etgfkdknkv{"cpf"tguqnxg"vjg 6 eqphnkev0Ñ""Thomas v. Barnhart."49:"H05f";69.";78/79"*;vj"Ekt0"4224+"*ekvcvkqp"cpf 7 swqvcvkqp"octmu"qokvvgf+0 8 F0 Etgfkdknkv{ 9 ÐVq"fgvgtokpg"yjgvjgt"c"enckocpvÓu"vguvkoqp{"tgictfkpi"uwdlgevkxg"rckp"qt : u{orvqou"ku"etgfkdng."cp"CNL"owuv"gpicig"kp"c"vyq/uvgr"cpcn{uku0Ñ""Lingenfelter v. ; Astrue."726"H05f"324:."3257/58"*;vj"Ekt0"4229+0""Cv"uvgr"qpg."Ðvjg"CNL"owuv"fgvgtokpg 32 yjgvjgt"vjg"enckocpv"jcu"rtgugpvgf"qdlgevkxg"ogfkecn"gxkfgpeg"qh"cp"wpfgtn{kpi 33 korcktogpv"Òyjkej"eqwnf"tgcuqpcdn{"dg"gzrgevgf"vq"rtqfweg"vjg"rckp"qt"qvjgt 34 u{orvqou"cnngigf0ÓÑ" Id0"*swqvkpi"Bunnell v. Sullivan.";69"H04f"563."566"*;vj"Ekt0"3;;3+ 35 *gp"dcpe++0""Vjg"CNL"hqwpf"vjcv"RnckpvkhhÓu"ogfkecnn{"fgvgtokpcdng"korcktogpvu"eqwnf 36 tgcuqpcdn{"dg"gzrgevgf"vq"ecwug"uqog"qh"vjg"cnngigf"u{orvqou0""CT"450 37 Ugeqpf."yjgp"cp"CNL"eqpenwfgu"vjcv"c"enckocpv"ku"pqv"ocnkpigtkpi"cpf"jcu 38 ucvkuhkgf"vjg"hktuv"uvgr."Ðvjg"CNL"oc{"Òtglgev"vjg"enckocpvÓu"vguvkoqp{"cdqwv"vjg"ugxgtkv{ 39 qh"jgt"u{orvqou"qpn{"d{"qhhgtkpi"urgekhke."engct"cpf"eqpxkpekpi"tgcuqpu"hqt"fqkpi"uq0ÓÑ 3: Brown-Hunter v. Colvin.":28"H05f"6:9."6;5"*;vj"Ekt0"4237+"*ekvcvkqp"qokvvgf+="Burrell v. 3; Colvin."997"H05f"3355."3358/59"*;vj"Ekt0"4236+0""ÐC"hkpfkpi"vjcv"c"enckocpvÓu"vguvkoqp{"ku 42 pqv"etgfkdng"Òowuv"dg"uwhhkekgpvn{"urgekhke"vq"cnnqy"c"tgxkgykpi"eqwtv"vq"eqpenwfg"vjg 43 cflwfkecvqt"tglgevgf"vjg"enckocpvÓu"vguvkoqp{"qp"rgtokuukdng"itqwpfu"cpf"fkf"pqv 44 ctdkvtctkn{"fkuetgfkv"c"enckocpvÓu"vguvkoqp{"tgictfkpi"rckp0ÓÑ""Brown-Hunter.":28"H05f"cv 45 6;5"*ekvcvkqp"qokvvgf+0""ÐÒIgpgtcn"hkpfkpiu"ctg"kpuwhhkekgpv="tcvjgt."vjg"CNL"owuv"kfgpvkh{ 46 yjcv"vguvkoqp{"ku"pqv"etgfkdng"cpf"yjcv"gxkfgpeg"wpfgtokpgu"vjg"enckocpvÓu 47 eqornckpvu0ÓÑ""Id0"*ekvcvkqp"qokvvgf+0 48 Vjg"CNL"fgvgtokpgf"vjcv"RnckpvkhhÓu"Ðuvcvgogpvu"eqpegtpkpi"vjg"kpvgpukv{. 49 rgtukuvgpeg"cpf"nkokvkpi"ghhgevu"qh"vjgug"u{orvqou"ctg"pqv"gpvktgn{"eqpukuvgpv"ykvj"vjg 4: ogfkecn"gxkfgpeg"cpf"qvjgt"gxkfgpeg"kp"vjg"tgeqtf0Ñ""CT"450""Vjg"CNL"tgnkgf"rtkoctkn{ 9 3 qp"vyq"tgcuqpu<""*3+"qdlgevkxg"ogfkecn"gxkfgpeg"fkf"pqv"uwrrqtv"vjg"cnngigf"fgitgg"qh 4 fkucdknkv{="cpf"*4+"kpeqpukuvgpv"uvcvgogpvu"cdqwv"jku"ngxgn"qh"hwpevkqpkpi0""CT"43/460"" 5 Vjg"CNLÓu"tgcuqpu"ctg"uwrrqtvgf"d{"uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg0""ÐCnvjqwij"ncem"qh 6 ogfkecn"gxkfgpeg"ecppqv"hqto"vjg"uqng"dcuku"hqt"fkueqwpvkpi"rckp"vguvkoqp{."kv"ku"c"hcevqt 7 vjcv"vjg"CNL"ecp"eqpukfgt"kp"jku"etgfkdknkv{"cpcn{uku0Ñ""Burch v. Barnhart."622"H05f"898. 8 8:3"*;vj"Ekt0"4227+0""Vjku"tgcuqp"ku"uwrrqtvgf"d{"uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"hqt"vjg"tgcuqpu 9 fkuewuugf"cdqxg0 : ; Vjg"CNL"cnuq"kfgpvkhkgf"kpeqpukuvgpekgu"kp"RnckpvkhhÓu"uvcvgogpvu"cdqwv"jku"ngxgn"qh hwpevkqpkpi0""Rnckpvkhh"ctiwgu"vjcv"jg"jcf"c"ygnn"rc{kpi"lqd"cu"cp"cxkcvkqp"gngevtkecn 32 ogejcpke"hqt"enqug"vq"52"{gctu0""Vjg"CNL"citggf"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"eqwnf"pqv"tgvwtp"vq"jku 33 rcuv"tgngxcpv"yqtm."yjkej"ycu"encuukhkgf"cu"ogfkwo"yqtm0""CT"470""Jqygxgt."vjg"CNL 34 hqwpf"vjcv"RnckpvkhhÓu"vguvkoqp{"vjcv"jg"urgpv"hqwt"vq"hkxg"jqwtu"rgt"fc{"n{kpi"fqyp"qt 35 tgenkpkpi"ycu"kpeqpukuvgpv"ykvj"jku"uvcvgogpvu"kp"vjg"tgeqtf"vjcv"jg"iqgu"qwv"qhvgp"cpf 36 ftkxgu"vq"igv"jku"pgyurcrgt"cpf"dtgcmhcuv="iqgu"qwv"vq"igv"hqqf"cpf"itqegtkgu="tgcfu. 37 ycvejgu"VX"cpf"dtqyugu"vjg"kpvgtpgv="xkukvu"ykvj"qvjgtu="cpf"iqgu"vq"jku 38 itcpffcwijvgtÓu"uqeegt"icogu0""CT"424/270""Eqpvtct{"vq"RnckpvkhhÓu"ctiwogpv."vjg"CNL 39 oc{"rtqrgtn{"tgn{"qp"cevkxkvkgu"qh"fckn{"nkxkpi"vjcv"wpfgtokpg"vjg"ugxgtkv{"qh"vjg"cnngigf 3: u{orvqou0""Molina v. Astrue."896"H05f"3326."3335"*;vj"Ekt0"4234+"*pqvkpi"fckn{"cevkxkvkgu 3; Ðoc{"dg"itqwpfu"hqt"fkuetgfkvkpi"vjg"enckocpvÓu"vguvkoqp{"vq"vjg"gzvgpv"vjcv"vjg{ 42 eqpvtcfkev"enckou"qh"c"vqvcnn{"fgdknkvcvkpi"korcktogpvÑ+0""Vjg"CNL"cnuq"pqvgf"uvcvgogpvu"kp 43 vjg"tgeqtf"vjcv"jku"u{orvqou"kortqxgf"72'"ykvj"ogfkecvkqp."yjkej"oc{"dg"eqpukfgtgf 44 kp"cuuguukpi"etgfkdknkv{0""See Warre v. Comm’r."65;"H05f"3228"*;vj"Ekt0"4228+0""Yjgp 45 uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"uwrrqtvu"vjg"CNLÓu"etgfkdknkv{"hkpfkpi."Ðyg"oc{"pqv"gpicig"kp 46 ugeqpf/iwguukpi0Ñ""Thomas."49:"H05f"cv";7;0""Rnckpvkhh"jcu"pqv"ujqyp"gttqt0 47 G0 Xqecvkqpcn"Gzrgtv 48 Cp"CNL"oc{"tgn{"qp"c"xqecvkqpcn"gzrgtvÓu"vguvkoqp{"kp"tgurqpug"vq"c"j{rqvjgvkecn 49 vjcv"eqpvckpu"cnn"qh"vjg"nkokvcvkqpu"vjg"CNL"hqwpf"etgfkdng"cpf"uwrrqtvgf"d{"uwduvcpvkcn 4: gxkfgpeg"kp"vjg"tgeqtf0""Bayliss v. Barnhart."649"H05f"3433."3439"*;vj"Ekt0"4227+0""ÐC : 3 XGÓu"tgeqipk|gf"gzrgtvkug"rtqxkfgu"vjg"pgeguuct{"hqwpfcvkqp"hqt"jku"qt"jgt"vguvkoqp{0" 4 Vjwu."pq"cffkvkqpcn"hqwpfcvkqp"ku"tgswktgf0Ñ""Id."cv"343:="see also Buck v. Berryhill.":8; 5 H05f"3262."3273"*;vj"Ekt0"4239+"*swqvkpi"Bayliss+0"" 6 Rnckpvkhh"ctiwgu"vjcv"vjg"CNL"gttgf"kp"tgn{kpi"qp"vjg"XGÓu"vguvkoqp{"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh 7 eqwnf"rgthqto"vjg"tgrtgugpvcvkxg"qeewrcvkqpu"qh"ecujkgt."uvqtcig"hceknkv{"tgpvcn"engtm"cpf 8 rncuvke"rctvu"cuugodngt0""Vjg"XG"vguvkhkgf"vjcv"vjg"ukv1uvcpf"qrvkqp"cpf"qxgtjgcf 9 tgcejkpi"ku"pqv"eqxgtgf"kp"vjg"Fkevkqpct{"qh"Qeewrcvkqpcn"Vkvngu0""Jgt"vguvkoqp{"ycu : vjgtghqtg"dcugf"qp"jgt"57"{gctuÓ"gzrgtkgpeg"Ðyqtmkpi"ykvj"gornq{gtu"fqkpi"qpukvg"lqd ; cpcn{uku"cpf"lqd"fguetkrvkqpu0Ñ7""CT"890""Vjg"XG"vguvkhkgf"vjcv"vjg"ecujkgt"rqukvkqp"cpf 32 cuugodngt"rqukvkqp"jcu"c"uvqqn"cxckncdng"uq"c"ukv1uvcpf"qrvkqp"cv"yknn"yqwnf"pqv"dg"c 33 rtqdngo0""CT"96."990""Vjg"XG"gtqfgf"vjg"pwodgt"qh"lqdu"hqt"ecujkgt"cpf"cuugodngt"d{ 34 72'"vq"ceeqooqfcvg"vjg"ukv1uvcpf"qrvkqp0""CT"86/870""Vjg"XG"fkf"pqv"gtqfg"vjg 35 pwodgt"qh"uvqtcig"hceknkv{"tgpvcn"engtm"lqdu"dgecwug"vjcv"yqtm"ku"rgthqtogf"oquvn{"kp"c 36 ugcvgf"rqukvkqp0""CT"870""Vjg"CNL"ycu"pqv"tgswktgf"vq"kpswktg"hwtvjgt0""Ð]C_v"ngcuv"kp"vjg 37 cdugpeg"qh"cp{"eqpvtct{"gxkfgpeg."c"XGÓu"vguvkoqp{"ku"qpg"v{rg"qh"lqd"kphqtocvkqp"vjcv 38 ku"tgictfgf"cu"kpjgtgpvn{"tgnkcdng="vjwu."vjgtg"ku"pq"pggf"hqt"cp"CNL"vq"cuuguu"kvu 39 tgnkcdknkv{0Ñ""Buck.":8;"H05f"cv"32730 3: H0 Itkf"Twng 3; Rnckpvkhh"ctiwgu"vjcv"kh"jg"ygtg"nkokvgf"vq"ugfgpvct{"yqtm."jg"yqwnf"dg"fggogf 42 fkucdngf"wpfgt"vjg"ogfkecn"xqecvkqpcn"iwkfgnkpgu"*ÐItkfuÑ+0""42"E0H0T0"rv0"626."uwdrv0"R. 43 crr04"¸"4230340""Kh"jg"ygtg"ecrcdng"qh"c"hwnn"tcpig"qh"nkijv"yqtm."jg"yqwnf"pqv"dg 44 fggogf"fkucdngf"wpfgt"vjg"Itkfu0""Id."¸"4240350""Rnckpvkhh"eqpvgpfu"vjcv"jg"hcnnu"dgvyggp 45 vyq"Itkf"twngu"cpf"vjg"CNL"gttgf"kp"pqv"hkpfkpi"jko"fkucdngf0 46 47 48 49 4: """""7""Rnckpvkhh"ctiwgu"vjcv"vjg"XGÓu"vguvkoqp{"cdqwv"jku"cdknkv{"vq"rgthqto"vjg"lqd"qh"vkemgv vcmgt"ycu"dcugf"qp"rgtuqpcn"gzrgtkgpeg"cv"oqxkg"vjgcvgtu"cu"qrrqugf"vq"rtqhguukqpcn qdugtxcvkqp0""Dgecwug"vjg"CNL"fkf"pqv"kpenwfg"vkemgv"vcmgt"cu"c"tgrtgugpvcvkxg"lqd."vjg XGÓu"vguvkoqp{"cdqwv"vjcv"lqd"ku"kttgngxcpv"vq"vjg"cpcn{uku0 ; 3 Ð]Y_jgp"c"enckocpvÓu"gzgtvkqpcn"nkokvcvkqp"hgnn"dgvyggp"vyq"itkf"twngu."vjg"CNL 4 hwnhknnu"jku"qdnkicvkqp"vq"fgvgtokpg"vjg"enckocpvÓu"qeewrcvkqpcn"dcug"d{"eqpuwnvkpi"c 5 xqecvkqpcn"gzrgtv"tgictfkpi"yjgvjgt"c"rgtuqp"ykvj"enckocpvÓu"rtqhkng"eqwnf"rgthqto 6 uwduvcpvkcn"ickphwn"yqtm"kp"vjg"geqpqo{0Ñ""Thomas."49:"H05f"cv";82"*ekvkpi"Uqekcn 7 Ugewtkv{"Twnkpi"*UUT+":5/34+0""Cu"vjg"Pkpvj"Ektewkv"jcu"fguetkdgf."vjg"rgtvkpgpv"rqtvkqp 8 qh"UUT":5/34"rtqxkfgu"cu"hqnnqyu< 9 40 Kh"vjg"gzgtvkqpcn"ngxgn"hcnnu"dgvyggp"vyq"twngu"yjkej"fktgev"qrrqukvg : eqpenwukqpu."k0g0"ÐPqv"fkucdngfÑ"cv"vjg"jkijgt"gzgtvkqpcn"ngxgn"cpf"ÐFkucdngfÑ ; cv"vjg"nqygt"gzgtvkqpcn"ngxgn."eqpukfgt"cu"hqnnqyu< 32 c0 Cp"gzgtvkqpcn"ecrcekv{"vjcv"ku"qpn{"unkijvn{"tgfwegf"kp"vgtou"qh"vjg 33 tgiwncvqt{"etkvgtkc"eqwnf"kpfkecvg"c"uwhhkekgpv"tgockpkpi"qeewrcvkqpcn 34 dcug"vq"ucvkuh{"vjg"okpkocn"tgswktgogpvu"hqt"c"hkpfkpi"qh"ÐPqv 35 fkucdngf0Ñ 36 d0 Qp"vjg"qvjgt"jcpf."kh"vjg"gzgtvkqpcn"ecrcekv{"ku"ukipkhkecpvn{"tgfwegf 37 kp"vgtou"qh"vjg"tgiwncvqt{"fghkpkvkqp."kv"eqwnf"kpfkecvg"nkvvng"oqtg"vjcp 38 vjg"qeewrcvkqpcn"dcug"hqt"vjg"nqygt"twng"cpf"eqwnf"lwuvkh{"c"hkpfkpi"qh 39 ÐFkucdngf0Ñ 3: e0 Kp"ukvwcvkqpu"yjgtg"vjg"twngu"yqwnf"fktgev"fkhhgtgpv"eqpenwukqpu."cpf 3; vjg"kpfkxkfwcnÓu"gzgtvkqpcn"nkokvcvkqpu"ctg"uqogyjgtg"Òkp"vjg"okffngÓ"kp 42 vgtou"qh"vjg"tgiwncvqt{"etkvgtkc"hqt"gzgtvkqpcn"tcpigu"qh"yqtm."oqtg 43 fkhhkewnv"lwfiogpvu"ctg"kpxqnxgf"cu"vq"vjg"uwhhkekgpe{"qh"vjg"tgockpkpi 44 xqecvkqpcn"dcug"vq"uwrrqtv"c"eqpenwukqp"cu"vq"fkucdknkv{0""Ceeqtfkpin{. 45 ]XG_"cuukuvcpeg"ku"cfxkucdng"hqt"vjgug"v{rgu"qh"ecugu0 46 47 Moore v. Apfel."438"H05f":86.":92"*;vj"Ekt0"4222+"*swqvkpi"UUT":5/34+0 Nkmg"vjg"enckocpv"kp"Moore."Rnckpvkhh"ctiwgu"vjcv"vjg"CNL"ujqwnf"jcxg"hqwpf"vjcv 48 vjg"nkijv"yqtm"Ðycu"uq"tgfwegf"vjcv"kv"ycu"guugpvkcnn{"gswkxcngpv"vq"vjg"nqygt"ecvgiqt{. 49 Òugfgpvct{Ó"yqtm."yjkej"yqwnf"jcxg"ogcpv"jg"ycu"encuukhkgf"cu"Òfkucdngf0ÓÑ""Id."*hqqvpqvg 4: qokvvgf+0""Eqpvtct{"vq"RnckpvkhhÓu"ctiwogpv."vjg"eqwtv"kp"Moore"pqvgf"vjcv"UUT":5/34 32 3 fqgu"pqv"ocpfcvg"c"hkpfkpi"qh"fkucdngf"yjgp"vjg"jkijgt"gzgtvkqpcn"ngxgn"ku"Ðukipkhkecpvn{ 4 tgfwegfÑ"dwv"tcvjgt"ocpfcvgu"vjg"wug"qh"c"xqecvkqpcn"gzrgtv0""Id."cv":930""Oqtgqxgt. 5 gxgp"cuuwokpi"vjg"gxkfgpeg"eqwnf"uwrrqtv"gkvjgt"eqpenwukqp"*fkucdngf"qt"pqv"fkucdngf+. 6 vjg"CNLÓu"eqpenwukqp"owuv"dg"wrjgnf"kh"kv"ku"uwrrqtvgf"d{"uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg0""Id." 7 Vjg"CNL"hqwpf"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"eqwnf"rgthqto"vjg"tgrtgugpvcvkxg"lqdu"qh"ecujkgt. 8 uvqtcig"hceknkv{"tgpvcn"engtm"cpf"rncuvke"rctvu"cuugodngt0""CT"47/480""Vjg"XG"vguvkhkgf"vjcv 9 gcej"qh"vjgug"lqdu"ku"nkuvgf"cu"nkijv"yqtm08""CT"86/870""Kh"Vjg"XG"gtqfgf"vjg"pwodgt"qh : ecujkgt"rqukvkqpu"d{"72'"vq"ceeqooqfcvg"c"ukv1uvcpf"qrvkqp"hqt"c"vqvcn"qh"872.222"lqdu ; pcvkqpcnn{0""CT"86/870""Vjg"XG"gtqfgf"vjg"pwodgt"qh"rncuvke"rctvu"cuugodngt"lqdu"d{ 32 72'"vq"ceeqooqfcvg"c"ukv1uvcpf"qrvkqp"hqt"c"vqvcn"qh"337.222"lqdu"pcvkqpcnn{0""Vjg"XG 33 fkf"pqv"gtqfg"vjg"pwodgt"qh"lqdu"hqt"vjg"uvqtcig"hceknkv{"tgpvcn"engtm"rqukvkqp"*336.222 34 lqdu"pcvkqpcnn{+"dgecwug"Ðvjg"yqtm"ku"igpgtcnn{"rgthqtogf"oquv"qh"vjg"fc{"kp"c"ugcvgf 35 rqukvkqp0Ñ""CT"870""Vjg"pwodgt"qh"lqdu"kfgpvkhkgf"d{"vjg"XG"ku"uwhhkekgpv0""Gutierrez v. 36 Comm’r."962"H05f"73;."74:/4;"*;vj"Ekt0"4236+0""Vjg"XG"gzrnckpgf"vjcv"vjg"ukv1uvcpf 37 qrvkqp"ku"pqv"eqxgtgf"d{"vjg"FQV"cpf"vjcv"rqtvkqp"qh"jgt"vguvkoqp{"ycu"dcugf"qp"jgt"57 38 {gctuÓ"gzrgtkgpeg"yqtmkpi"ykvj"gornq{gtu"fqkpi"qpukvg"lqd"cpcn{uku"cpf"lqd 39 fguetkrvkqpu0""CT"890""Vjg"XG"pqvgf"vjcv."kp"Ecnkhqtpkc."ecujkgtu"igpgtcnn{"jcxg"ugcvkpi 3: cxckncdng0""CT"8:="see generally"Kilby v. CVS Pharmacy, Inc.."85"Ecn0"6vj"3"*4238+ 3; *fguetkdkpi"ugcvkpi"ncy"kp"Ecnkhqtpkc+0""Vjg"CNL"eqwnf"tgcuqpcdn{"tgn{"qp"vjku"vguvkoqp{0" 42 Cp"CNL"ku"Ðgpvkvngf"vq"tgn{"qp"vjg"gzrgtvÓu"Ògzrgtkgpeg"kp"lqd"rncegogpvÓ"vq"ceeqwpv"hqt"Òc 43 rctvkewnct"lqdÓu"tgswktgogpvu0ÓÑ""Gutierrez v. Colvin.":66"H05f":26.":2;"*;vj"Ekt0"4238+ 44 *ekvcvkqp"qokvvgf+="see Avilez v. Berryhill."899"Hgf0"Crrz0"595."596"*;vj"Ekt0"4239+ 45 *hkpfkpi"CNL"rtqrgtn{"tgnkgf"qp"XGÓu"wpeqpvtcfkevgf"qrkpkqp"dcugf"qp"42"{gctuÓ 46 gzrgtkgpeg"cpf"gzrncpcvkqp"vq"uwrrqtv"cp{"fgxkcvkqp"htqo"FQV+0 47 48 49 4: """""8""Kh"Rnckpvkhh"ygtg"nkokvgf"vq"nkhvkpi1ectt{kpi1rwujkpi1rwnnkpi"32"rqwpfu."vjg"XG"yqwnf gnkokpcvg"vjg"ecujkgt"cpf"uvqtcig"hceknkv{"tgpvcn"engtm"lqdu0""CT"87/880""Vjg"XG"yqwnf"pqv gnkokpcvg"vjg"rncuvke"rctvu"cuugodngt"rqukvkqp"dgecwug"kv"igpgtcnn{"kpxqnxgu"vwdkpi"qt qvjgt"kvgou"vjcv"fq"pqv"ygkij"oqtg"vjcp"32"rqwpfu0""CT"880 33 Rnckpvkhh"ekvgu"vq"c"Fgrctvogpv"qh"Ncdqt."Dwtgcw"qh"Ncdqt"Uvcvkuvkeu."Dgvc"Ncdu 3 4 qpnkpg"rwdnkecvkqp"vjcv"rwtrqtvgfn{"uvcvgu"vjcv"cnoquv";7'"qh"ecujkgt"lqdu"fq"pqv"cnnqy 5 hqt"c"ukv1uvcpf"qrvkqp0""*LU"cv"420+""Rnckpvkhh"fkf"pqv"rtqxkfg"c"eqr{"qh"vjg"rwdnkecvkqp"qt 6 vjg"vkvng."cpf"vjg"eqwtv"ycu"wpcdng"vq"tgvtkgxg"kv"qpnkpg"wukpi"vjg"ekvcvkqp"rtqxkfgf0" 7 Rnckpvkhh"fqgu"pqv"uwrrn{"c"fgenctcvkqp"vjcv"guvcdnkujgu"c"hqwpfcvkqp"hqt"vjku"kphqtocvkqp09 8 Vq"vjg"gzvgpv"Rnckpvkhh"kornkekvn{"cumu"vjg"eqwtv"vq"vcmg"lwfkekcn"pqvkeg."RnckpvkhhÓu"tgswguv 9 hqt"lwfkekcn"pqvkeg"ku"fgpkgf0""Hgf0"T0"Gxkf0"4230""C"eqwtv"oc{"lwfkekcnn{"pqvkeg"qpn{"Ðc"hcev : vjcv"ku"pqv"uwdlgev"vq"tgcuqpcdng"fkurwvg"dgecwug"kv<""*3+"ku"igpgtcnn{"mpqyp"ykvjkp"vjg ; vtkcn"eqwtvÓu"vgttkvqtkcn"lwtkufkevkqp="qt"*4+"ecp"dg"ceewtcvgn{"cpf"tgcfkn{"fgvgtokpgf"htqo 32 uqwtegu"yjqug"ceewtce{"ecppqv"tgcuqpcdn{"dg"swguvkqpgf0Ñ""Hgf0"T0"Gxkf0"423*d+0" 33 RnckpvkhhÓu"wpcwvjgpvkecvgf"kphqtocvkqp"kp"jku"dtkgh"fqgu"pqv"hcnn"ykvjkp"Twng"423*d+0" 34 Rnckpvkhh"jcu"pqv"ujqyp"gttqt0 35 "" KX0 QTFGT 36 KV"KU"JGTGD["QTFGTGF"vjcv"vjg"fgekukqp"qh"vjg"Eqookuukqpgt"ku"chhktogf0 37 38 39 3: 3; FCVGF<"Hgdtwct{"4:."423; 42 CNKEKC"I0"TQUGPDGTI CNKEKC I0 TQU UGPDGTI """""Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu"Ocikuvtcvg"Lwfig kv f Uv v O k v v L f 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 4: 9 ""Vjg"eqwtv"ycu"wpcdng"vq"nqecvg"vjg"uvcvkuvkeu"ekvgf"d{"Rnckpvkhh0""Cp"kphqtocvkqp ujggv"hqt"ucngu"cpf"tgncvgf"qeewrcvkqpu."yjkej"kpenwfkpi"ecujkgtu"cpf"qvjgt"lqdu."pqvgf vjcv"3:'"ctg"ugfgpvct{"cpf"580:'"ctg"nkijv"yqtm0 jvvru<11yyy0dnu0iqx1qtu1hcevujggv1qturtqhkngu0jvo0""Kp"vjg"cdugpeg"qh"cp"gzrgtv fgenctcvkqp"qt"qvjgt"cwvjgpvkecvgf"gxkfgpeg."vjg"eqwtv"fqgu"pqv"tgn{"qp"kpvgtpgv ugctejgu0 34
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
