James Nagy v. Nancy A. Berryhill, No. 5:2018cv01199 - Document 21 (C.D. Cal. 2019)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER by Magistrate Judge Karen L. Stevenson. The Court finds that the Commissioner's decision is supported by substantial evidence and free from material legal error. Neither reversal of the ALJ's decision nor re mand is warranted. Accordingly, IT IS ORDERED that Judgment shall be entered affirming the decision of the Commissioner of the Social Security Administration. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the Clerk of the Court shall serve copies of this Memorandum Opinion and Order and the Judgment on counsel for Plaintiff and for Defendant 5 17 (SEE ORDER FOR FURTHER INFORMATION) (gr)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
James Nagy v. Nancy A. Berryhill Doc. 21 " " 3 " 4 " 5 " 6 " 7 " 8 " 9 " : WPKVGF"UVCVGU"FKUVTKEV"EQWTV" EGPVTCN"FKUVTKEV"QH"ECNKHQTPKC" ; " 32 +" PQ0"GF"EX"3:/33;;/MU" " LCOGU"P0.3" +" """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""Rnckpvkhh." """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" +" """"""""""""""""x0" +" OGOQTCPFWO"QRKPKQP"CPF"QTFGT" " +" CPFTGY"O0"UCWN."Eqookuukqpgt"" +" qh"Uqekcn"Ugewtkv{."""" +" Fghgpfcpv0"" +" aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa" +" " " KPVTQFWEVKQP" 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 3: 3; " 42 Rnckpvkhh" hkngf" c" Eqornckpv" qp" Lwpg" 6." 423:." uggmkpi" tgxkgy" qh" vjg" fgpkcn" qh" jku" 43 crrnkecvkqp" hqt" Uwrrngogpvcn" Ugewtkv{" Kpeqog" *ÐUUKÑ+" rwtuwcpv" vq" Vkvng" ZXK" qh" vjg" Uqekcn" 44 Ugewtkv{"Cev0""*Fmv0"Pq0"30+""Vjg"rctvkgu"jcxg"eqpugpvgf."rwtuwcpv"vq"4:"W0U0E0"¸"858*e+."vq" 45 rtqeggf"dghqtg"vjg"wpfgtukipgf"Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu"Ocikuvtcvg"Lwfig0""*Fmv0"Pqu0"32."33."350+""Qp" 46 Hgdtwct{"3."423;."vjg"rctvkgu"hkngf"c"Lqkpv"Uvkrwncvkqp0""*Fmv0"Pq0"3;"*ÐLqkpv"Uvkr0Ñ+0+""Rnckpvkhh" 47 uggmu" cp" qtfgt" tgxgtukpi" vjg" EqookuukqpgtÓu" fgekukqp" ykvj" gkvjgt" cp" cyctf" qh" fkucdknkv{" 48 """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 49 4: " " Rctvkcnn{" tgfcevgf" kp" eqornkcpeg" ykvj" Hgfgtcn" Twng" qh" Ekxkn" Rtqegfwtg" 704*e+*4+*D+" cpf" vjg" tgeqoogpfcvkqp" qh" vjg" Eqookvvgg" qp" Eqwtv" Cfokpkuvtcvkqp" cpf" Ecug" Ocpcigogpv" qh" vjg" Lwfkekcn" Eqphgtgpeg"qh"vjg"Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu0" 3 3" " " Dockets.Justia.com " " 3 dgpghkvu"qt"c"tgocpf"qh"vjg"ecug"hqt"hwtvjgt"cfokpkuvtcvkxg"rtqeggfkpiu0""*Lqkpv"Uvkr0"cv"3:0+""Vjg" 4 Eqookuukqpgt" tgswguvu" vjcv" vjg" CNLÓu" fgekukqp" dg" chhktogf" qt." kp" vjg" cnvgtpcvkxg." vjcv" vjg" 5 ocvvgt" dg" tgocpfgf" hqt" hwtvjgt" cfokpkuvtcvkxg" rtqeggfkpiu0"" *Id." cv" 3:/3;0+"" Vjg" Eqwtv" jcu" 6 vcmgp"vjg"ocvvgt"wpfgt"uwdokuukqp"ykvjqwv"qtcn"ctiwogpv0" " 7 UWOOCT["QH"CFOKPKUVTCVKXG"RTQEGGFKPIU" 8 9 " : Qp" Qevqdgt" 42." 4236." Rnckpvkhh" hkngf" cp" crrnkecvkqp" hqt" UUK0" " *Cfokpkuvtcvkxg" Tgeqtf" ; *ÐCTÑ+" 37." 365/740+" " Rnckpvkhh" cnngigf" fkucdknkv{" dgikppkpi" qp" Lcpwct{" 3." 4232" dgecwug" qh" 32 fgrtguukqp."uejk|qrjtgpkc."cpzkgv{."rcpke"cvvcemu."cpf"c"vj{tqkf"eqpfkvkqp0""*CT"790+4""Chvgt" 33 vjg"Eqookuukqpgt"fgpkgf"RnckpvkhhÓu"crrnkecvkqp"kpkvkcnn{"*CT"78+"cpf"qp"tgeqpukfgtcvkqp"*CT" 34 87+."Rnckpvkhh"tgswguvgf"c"jgctkpi"*CT":8/::+0""" 35 " 36 Cv" c" jgctkpi" jgnf" qp" Lcpwct{" 52." 4239." cv" yjkej" Rnckpvkhh" crrgctgf" ykvj" eqwpugn." cp" 37 Cfokpkuvtcvkxg"Ncy"Lwfig"*ÐCNLÑ+"jgctf"vguvkoqp{"htqo"Rnckpvkhh"cpf"c"xqecvkqpcn"gzrgtv0"" 38 *CT"53/690+""Qp"Oc{"46."4239."vjg"CNL"kuuwgf"cp"wphcxqtcdng"fgekukqp"fgp{kpi"RnckpvkhhÓu" 39 crrnkecvkqp"hqt"UUK0""*CT"37/470+""Qp"Crtkn"34."423:."vjg"Crrgcnu"Eqwpekn"fgpkgf"RnckpvkhhÓu" 3: tgswguv"hqt"tgxkgy0""*CT"3/80+" 3; " UWOOCT["QH"CFOKPKUVTCVKXG"FGEKUKQP" 42 43 " 44 Crrn{kpi" vjg" hkxg/uvgr" ugswgpvkcn" gxcnwcvkqp" rtqeguu." vjg" CNL" ocfg" vjg" hqnnqykpi" 45 hkpfkpiu0" " Vjg" CNL" hqwpf" cv" uvgr" qpg" vjcv" Rnckpvkhh" jcf" pqv" gpicigf" kp" uwduvcpvkcn" ickphwn" 46 cevkxkv{"ukpeg"jku"crrnkecvkqp"fcvg"qh"Qevqdgt"42."42360""*CT"390+""Cv"uvgr"vyq."vjg"CNL"hqwpf" 47 vjcv" Rnckpvkhh" jcf" vjg" hqnnqykpi" ugxgtg" korcktogpv<" uejk|qchhgevkxg" fkuqtfgt0" " *Id0+" " Cv" uvgr" 48 49 4: """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" ""Rnckpvkhh"ycu"68"{gctu"qnf"qp"jku"crrnkecvkqp"fcvg"*CT"46+"cpf"vjwu"ogv"vjg"cigpe{Óu"fghkpkvkqp"qh"c" {qwpigt"rgtuqp0""See 42"E0H0T0"¸"6380;85*e+0" 4 4" " " " " 3 vjtgg."vjg"CNL"hqwpf"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"fkf"pqv"jcxg"cp"korcktogpv"qt"eqodkpcvkqp"qh"korcktogpvu" 4 vjcv"ogv"qt"ogfkecnn{"gswcngf"vjg"ugxgtkv{"qh"cp{"korcktogpvu"nkuvgf"kp"42"E0H0T0"rctv"626." 5 uwdrctv"R."crrgpfkz"3"*42"E0H0T0"¸¸"6380;42*f+."6380;47."6380;48+0""*CT"3:0+""Vjg"CNL"vjgp" 6 fgvgtokpgf"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"jcf"vjg"tgukfwcn"hwpevkqpcn"ecrcekv{"*ÐTHEÑ+"vq"rgthqto"yqtm"Ðcv"cnn" 7 gzgtvkqpcn"ngxgnu"dwv"ykvj"vjg"hqnnqykpi"pqpgzgtvkqpcn"nkokvcvkqpu<""jg"ecp"rgthqto"wpumknngf" 8 yqtm="cpf"jg"ecp"qeecukqpcnn{"kpvgtcev"ykvj"qvjgtu0Ñ""*CT"3;0+""Cv"uvgr"hqwt."vjg"CNL"hqwpf" 9 vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"eqwnf"rgthqto"jku"rcuv"tgngxcpv"yqtm"cu"c"engcpgt0""*CT"460+""Kp"vjg"cnvgtpcvkxg." : cv"uvgr"hkxg."vjg"CNL"hqwpf"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"eqwnf"rgthqto"qvjgt"yqtm"kp"vjg"pcvkqpcn"geqpqo{." ; eqpukuvkpi"qh"vjg"qeewrcvkqpu"qh"jqwug"engcpgt."ucnxcig"ncdqtgt."cpf"jcpf"rcemcigt0""*CT"470+"" 32 Ceeqtfkpin{." vjg" CNL" eqpenwfgf" vjcv" Rnckpvkhh" ycu" pqv" fkucdngf" ykvjkp" vjg" ogcpkpi" qh" vjg" 33 Uqekcn"Ugewtkv{"Cev0""*Id0+""" 34 " 35 UVCPFCTF"QH"TGXKGY" 36 " 37 Wpfgt"64"W0U0E0"¸"627*i+."vjku"Eqwtv"tgxkgyu"vjg"EqookuukqpgtÓu"fgekukqp"vq"fgvgtokpg" 38 yjgvjgt"kv"ku"htgg"htqo"ngicn"gttqt"cpf"uwrrqtvgf"d{"uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"kp"vjg"tgeqtf"cu"c" 39 yjqng0""Orn v. Astrue."6;7"H05f"847."852"*;vj"Ekt0"4229+0""ÐUwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"ku"Òoqtg"vjcp" 3: c"ogtg"uekpvknnc"dwv"nguu"vjcp"c"rtgrqpfgtcpeg="kv"ku"uwej"tgngxcpv"gxkfgpeg"cu"c"tgcuqpcdng"okpf" 3; okijv"ceegrv"cu"cfgswcvg"vq"uwrrqtv"c"eqpenwukqp0ÓÑ""Gutierrez v. Comm’r of Soc. Sec0."962" 42 H05f"73;."744/45"*;vj"Ekt0"4236+"*ekvcvkqpu"qokvvgf+0""ÐGxgp"yjgp"vjg"gxkfgpeg"ku"uwuegrvkdng" 43 vq" oqtg" vjcp" qpg" tcvkqpcn" kpvgtrtgvcvkqp." yg" owuv" wrjqnf" vjg" CNLÓu" hkpfkpiu" kh" vjg{" ctg" 44 uwrrqtvgf"d{"kphgtgpegu"tgcuqpcdn{"ftcyp"htqo"vjg"tgeqtf0Ñ""Molina v. Astrue."896"H05f"3326." 45 3333"*;vj"Ekt0"4234+"*ekvcvkqp"qokvvgf+0" 46 " 47 Cnvjqwij"vjku"Eqwtv"ecppqv"uwduvkvwvg"kvu"fkuetgvkqp"hqt"vjg"EqookuukqpgtÓu."vjg"Eqwtv" 48 pqpgvjgnguu"owuv"tgxkgy"vjg"tgeqtf"cu"c"yjqng."Ðygkijkpi"dqvj"vjg"gxkfgpeg"vjcv"uwrrqtvu"cpf" 49 vjg"gxkfgpeg"vjcv"fgvtcevu"htqo"vjg"EqookuukqpgtÓu"eqpenwukqp0Ñ""Lingenfelter v. Astrue."726" 4: H05f"324:."3257"*;vj"Ekt0"4229+"*ekvcvkqp"qokvvgf+="Desrosiers v. Sec’y of Health & Human 5" " " " " 3 Servs0." :68" H04f" 795." 798" *;vj" Ekt0" 3;::+" *ekvcvkqp" qokvvgf+0" " ÐVjg" CNL" ku" tgurqpukdng" hqt" 4 fgvgtokpkpi" etgfkdknkv{." tguqnxkpi" eqphnkevu" kp" ogfkecn" vguvkoqp{." cpf" hqt" tguqnxkpi" 5 codkiwkvkgu0Ñ""Andrews v. Shalala."75"H05f"3257."325;"*;vj"Ekt0"3;;7+"*ekvcvkqp"qokvvgf+0" 6 " 7 Vjg"Eqwtv"yknn"wrjqnf"vjg"EqookuukqpgtÓu"fgekukqp"yjgp"vjg"gxkfgpeg"ku"uwuegrvkdng"vq" 8 oqtg"vjcp"qpg"tcvkqpcn"kpvgtrtgvcvkqp0""Burch v. Barnhart."622"H05f"898."89;"*;vj"Ekt0"4227+" 9 *ekvcvkqp"qokvvgf+0""Jqygxgt."vjg"Eqwtv"oc{"tgxkgy"qpn{"vjg"tgcuqpu"uvcvgf"d{"vjg"CNL"kp"jku" : fgekukqp"Ðcpf"oc{"pqv"chhkto"vjg"CNL"qp"c"itqwpf"wrqp"yjkej"jg"fkf"pqv"tgn{0Ñ""Orn."6;7"H05f" ; cv"852"*ekvkpi"Connett v. Barnhart."562"H05f":93.":96"*;vj"Ekt0"4225++0""Vjg"Eqwtv"yknn"pqv" 32 tgxgtug"vjg"EqookuukqpgtÓu"fgekukqp"kh"kv"ku"dcugf"qp"jctonguu"gttqt."yjkej"gzkuvu"kh"vjg"gttqt" 33 ku"ÐÒkpeqpugswgpvkcn"vq"vjg"wnvkocvg"pqpfkucdknkv{"fgvgtokpcvkqp.Ó"qt"vjcv."fgurkvg"vjg"ngicn"gttqt." 34 Òvjg"cigpe{Óu"rcvj"oc{"tgcuqpcdn{"dg"fkuegtpgf0ÓÑ""Brown-Hunter v. Colvin.":28"H05f"6:9." 35 6;4"*;vj"Ekt0"4237+"*ekvcvkqpu"qokvvgf+0" " 36 FKUEWUUKQP" 37 38 " 39 Vjg" rctvkgu" tckug" vyq" kuuwgu<" *3+" yjgvjgt" vjg" CNL" rtqrgtn{" eqpukfgtgf" vjg" vtgcvkpi" 3: ru{ejkcvtkuvÓu"qrkpkqp"qt"ujqwnf"jcxg"tgeqpvcevgf"jko"hqt"enctkhkecvkqp="cpf"*4+"yjgvjgt"vjg" 3; CNL"rtqrgtn{"fgxgnqrgf"vjg"tgeqtf"tgictfkpi"RnckpvkhhÓu"ogpvcn"eqpfkvkqp0""*Lqkpv"Uvkr0"cv"40+" " 42 K0" 43 Vjg"CNL"Rtqrgtn{"Eqpukfgtgf"Vjg"Vtgcvkpi"Ru{ejkcvtkuvÓu"Qrkpkqp"*Kuuwg"Qpg+0" 44 " 45 Kp" Kuuwg" Qpg." Rnckpvkhh" enckou" vjcv" vjg" CNL" hckngf" vq" rtqrgtn{" eqpukfgt" vjg" vtgcvkpi" 46 ru{ejkcvtkuvÓu"qrkpkqp"cpf"ujqwnf"jcxg"tgeqpvcevgf"vjg"vtgcvkpi"ru{ejkcvtkuv"hqt"enctkhkecvkqp0"" 47 *Lqkpv"Uvkr0"cv"5/80+"""" 48 111" 49 111" 4: 111" 6" " " " " 3 C0" Ngicn"Uvcpfctf0" 4 " 5 Vjgtg"ctg"vjtgg"ecvgiqtkgu"qh"rj{ukekcpu<"vtgcvkpi"rj{ukekcpu."gzcokpkpi"rj{ukekcpu."cpf" 6 pqpgzcokpkpi" rj{ukekcpu0" " Lester v. Chater." :3" H05f" :43." :52" *;vj" Ekt0" 3;;7+0" " Vtgcvkpi" 7 rj{ukekcp"qrkpkqpu"ujqwnf"dg"ikxgp"oqtg"ygkijv"vjcp"gzcokpkpi"qt"pqpgzcokpkpi"rj{ukekcp" 8 qrkpkqpu0""Orn."6;7"H05f"cv"8540""Vjku"ku"dgecwug"c"vtgcvkpi"rj{ukekcp"Ðku"gornq{gf"vq"ewtg"cpf" 9 jcu"c"itgcvgt"qrrqtvwpkv{"vq"mpqy"cpf"qdugtxg"vjg"rcvkgpv"cu"cp"kpfkxkfwcn0Ñ""Magallanes v. : Bowen."::3"H04f"969."973"*;vj"Ekt0"3;:;+"*ekvcvkqp"qokvvgf+0""Kh"vjg"vtgcvkpi"rj{ukekcpÓu"qrkpkqp" ; ku"pqv"eqpvtcfkevgf"d{"cpqvjgt"fqevqt."kv"oc{"dg"tglgevgf"qpn{"kh"vjg"CNL"rtqxkfgu"Ðengct"cpf" 32 eqpxkpekpi"tgcuqpu"uwrrqtvgf"d{"uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"kp"vjg"tgeqtf0Ñ""Orn."6;7"H05f"cv"8540""Kh" 33 vjg"vtgcvkpi"rj{ukekcpÓu"qrkpkqp"ku"eqpvtcfkevgf"d{"cpqvjgt"fqevqt."kv"oc{"dg"tglgevgf"qpn{"d{" 34 Ðurgekhke"cpf"ngikvkocvg"tgcuqpu"uwrrqtvgf"d{"uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"kp"vjg"tgeqtf0Ñ""Id0""" 35 " 36 Jgtg."vjg"vtgcvkpi"ru{ejkcvtkuvÓu"qrkpkqp"ycu"eqpvtcfkevgf"d{"vjg"qrkpkqpu"qh"vyq"uvcvg" 37 cigpe{"ru{ejkcvtkuvu0""*CT"74."820+""Vjwu."vjg"CNL"eqwnf"pqv"tglgev"vjg"vtgcvkpi"ru{ejkcvtkuvÓu" 38 qrkpkqp"ykvjqwv"uvcvkpi"urgekhke"cpf"ngikvkocvg"tgcuqpu"uwrrqtvgf"d{"uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"kp" 39 vjg"tgeqtf0" 3: " 3; D0" 42 " Dcemitqwpf0" 43 " RnckpvkhhÓu" vtgcvkpi" ru{ejkcvtkuv" ycu" Ft0" Mctk" Gpig0" " *CT" 4:70+" " Ft0" Gpig" fkcipqugf" 44 Rnckpvkhh"ykvj"c"uejk|qchhgevkxg"fkuqtfgt."fgrtguukxg"v{rg0""*CT"5270+""Rnckpvkhh"xkukvgf"Ft0"Gpig" 45 crrtqzkocvgn{"gxgt{"vjtgg"oqpvju"cpf"ycu"rtguetkdgf"Tkurgtkfqpg0""*CT"5:."4:7."4;9."5350+"" 46 Fwtkpi"jku"xkukvu"ykvj"Ft0"Gpig."Rnckpvkhh"uvcvgf"vjcv"jg"ycu"fqkpi"Ðrtgvv{"iqqf.Ñ"Ðqm.Ñ"Ðhkpg.Ñ" 47 qt"Ðpqv"dcf0Ñ""*CT"4:8/;2."4;8."536."539."53;/430+""Ft0"Gpig"tgrqtvgf"vjcv"RnckpvkhhÓu"ru{ejquku" 48 ycu"wpfgt"eqpvtqn"ykvj"vtgcvogpv0""*CT"4:9/;2."536."538."53:/430+"""""""""""" 49 111" 4: 111" 7" " " " " 3 " Kp"Oc{"4238."Ft0"Gpig"eqorngvgf"c"ÐOgfkecn"Qrkpkqp"Tg<"Cdknkv{"vq"Fq"Yqtm"Tgncvgf" 4 Cevkxkvkgu"*Ogpvcn+0Ñ""*CT"524/250+""Ft0"Gpig"ytqvg"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"yqwnf"jcxg"Ðpq"wughwn"cdknkv{" 5 vq"hwpevkqpÑ"qt"yqwnf"dg"Ðwpcdng"vq"oggv"eqorgvkvkxg"uvcpfctfuÑ"kp"ugxgtcn"ctgcu"qh"ogpvcn" 6 hwpevkqpkpi0""*Id0+""Rnckpvkhh"yqwnf"jcxg"Ðpq"wughwn"cdknkv{"vq"hwpevkqpÑ"kp"hkxg"ctgcu<""cdknkv{"vq" 7 ockpvckp" cvvgpvkqp" hqt" c" vyq/jqwt" ugiogpv." cdknkv{" vq" eqorngvg" c" pqtocn" yqtmfc{" cpf" 8 yqtmyggm"ykvjqwv"kpvgttwrvkqpu"htqo"ru{ejqnqikecnn{"dcugf"u{orvqou."cdknkv{"vq"igv"cnqpi" 9 ykvj"eq/yqtmgtu"qt"rggtu"ykvjqwv"wpfwn{"fkuvtcevkpi"vjgo"qt"gzjkdkvkpi"dgjcxkqtkcn"gzvtgogu." : cdknkv{" vq" ectt{" qwv" fgvckngf" kpuvtwevkqpu." cpf" cdknkv{" vq" vtcxgn" kp" wphcoknkct" rncegu0" " *Id0+"" ; Rnckpvkhh" yqwnf" dg" Ðwpcdng" vq" oggv" eqorgvkvkxg" uvcpfctfuÑ" kp" pkpg" qvjgt" ctgcu<" " cdknkv{" vq" 32 ockpvckp"tgiwnct"cvvgpfcpeg"cpf"dg"rwpevwcn"ykvjkp"ewuvqoct{."wuwcnn{"uvtkev"vqngtcpegu="cdknkv{" 33 vq"uwuvckp"cp"qtfkpct{"tqwvkpg"ykvjqwv"urgekcn"uwrgtxkukqp="cdknkv{"vq"ceegrv"kpuvtwevkqpu"cpf" 34 tgurqpf"crrtqrtkcvgn{"vq"etkvkekuo"htqo"uwrgtxkuqtu="cdknkv{"vq"fgcn"ykvj"pqtocn"yqtm"uvtguu=" 35 cdknkv{"vq"wpfgtuvcpf"cpf"tgogodgt"fgvckngf"kpuvtwevkqpu="cdknkv{"vq"ugv"tgcnkuvke"iqcnu"qt"ocmg" 36 rncpu"kpfgrgpfgpvn{"qh"qvjgtu="cdknkv{"vq"fgcn"ykvj"uvtguu"qh"ugokumknngf"cpf"umknngf"yqtm="cdknkv{" 37 vq"kpvgtcev"crrtqrtkcvgn{"ykvj"vjg"igpgtcn"rwdnke="cpf"cdknkv{"vq"ockpvckp"uqekcnn{"crrtqrtkcvg" 38 dgjcxkqt0""*Id0+""" 39 " 3: Cv"vjg"gpf"qh"vjg"qrkpkqp."Ft0"Gpig"ytqvg"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"Ðjcu"uejk|qrjtgpkc"cpf"dgeqogu" 3; xgt{"wpeqohqtvcdng"ctqwpf"itqwru"qh"rgqrng0""Vjku"korcktu"jku"cvvgpvkqp0""Cnuq"igvu"fkuvtcevgf" 42 d{"xqkegu0Ñ""*CT"5250+""Ft0"Gpig"hwtvjgt"ytqvg"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"Ðjcu"dggp"hktgf"htqo"5"qt"6"lqdu" 43 kp"vjg"rcuv"dgecwug"qh"nkokvcvkqpu"htqo"ogpvcn"knnpguuÑ"cpf"vjcv"Ðjg"yqwnf"rtqdcdn{"ujqy"wr" 44 hqt"yqtmÑ"dwv"yqwnf"dg"Ðwpcdng"vq"rgthqto"vjg"lqd0Ñ""*Id0+""Vjg"CNL"icxg"Ðnkvvng"ygkijvÑ"vq"Ft0" 45 GpigÓu"qrkpkqp"ykvj"vjg"hqnnqykpi"gzrncpcvkqp<" 46 " 47 K"ikxg"nkvvng"ygkijv"vq"vjku"qrkpkqp"dgecwug"kv"ku"dtkgh."eqpenwuqt{."cpf"kpcfgswcvgn{" 48 uwrrqtvgf" d{" vjg" qdlgevkxg" hkpfkpiu0" " Vjg" ru{ejkcvtkuv" fkf" pqv" rtqxkfg" cp" 49 gzrncpcvkqp"hqt"vjku"cuuguuogpv0""Jg"rtkoctkn{"uwooctk|gf"kp"vjg"vtgcvogpv"pqvgu" 4: ]RnckpvkhhÓu_" uwdlgevkxg" eqornckpvu." fkcipqugu." cpf" vtgcvogpv." ]cpf_" hckngf" vq" 8" " " " " 3 rtqxkfg" ogfkecnn{" ceegrvcdng" enkpkecn" hkpfkpiu" vq" uwrrqtv" vjg" hwpevkqpcn" 4 cuuguuogpv0""Vjku"qrkpkqp"ku"kpeqpukuvgpv"ykvj"vjg"qdlgevkxg"ogfkecn"gxkfgpeg"cu" 5 c"yjqng"cntgcf{"fkuewuugf"kp"vjku"fgekukqp."yjkej"ujqyu"]Rnckpvkhh_"tgegkxgf"qpn{" 6 tqwvkpg" cpf" eqpugtxcvkxg" vtgcvogpv0" " Kv" ku" cnuq" kpeqpukuvgpv" ykvj" ]RnckpvkhhÓu_" 7 cfokvvgf"cevkxkvkgu"qh"fckn{"nkxkpi0" 8 " 9 *CT"44/450+""" : " ; " 32 " 33 " 34 " 35 " 36 eqpenwuqt{."cpf"kpcfgswcvgn{"uwrrqtvgf"d{"vjg"qdlgevkxg"hkpfkpiu.Ñ"cpf"vjcv"Ft0"Gpig"hckngf"vq" 37 rtqxkfg"Ðcp"gzrncpcvkqp"hqt"vjku"cuuguuogpv0Ñ""*CT"450+""Vjg"CNL"hwtvjgt"gncdqtcvgf"vjcv"Ft0" 38 Gpig" Ðrtkoctkn{" uwooctk|gf" kp" vjg" vtgcvogpv" pqvgu" ]RnckpvkhhÓu_" uwdlgevkxg" eqornckpvu." 39 fkcipqugu."cpf"vtgcvogpv."]cpf_"hckngf"vq"rtqxkfg"ceegrvcdng"enkpkecn"hkpfkpiu"vq"uwrrqtv"vjg" 3: hwpevkqpcn"cuuguuogpv0Ñ""*CT"450+" 3; " 42 " 43 vjg"CNLÓu"tgcuqpkpi0""Ft0"GpigÓu"qrkpkqp"ycu"dtkgh."eqpenwuqt{."cpf"kpcfgswcvgn{"uwrrqtvgf" 44 d{"qdlgevkxg"hkpfkpiu."yjkej"tghngev"vjcv"RnckpvkhhÓu"ru{ejquku"ycu"wpfgt"cfgswcvg"eqpvtqn"ykvj" 45 vtgcvogpv0" " *CT" 4:9/;2." 536." 538." 53:/430+" " Ft0" GpigÓu" vtgcvogpv" pqvgu" cnuq" tghngevgf" vjcv" 46 Rnckpvkhh"ocfg"uwdlgevkxg"uvcvgogpvu"vjcv"jg" ycu"fqkpi"Ðrtgvv{"iqqf.Ñ"Ðqm.Ñ"Ðhkpg.Ñ"qt"Ðpqv" 47 dcf0Ñ""*CT"4:8/;2."4;8."536."539."53;/430+""Ft0"GpigÓu"enkpkecn"hkpfkpiu"fkf"pqv"uwduvcpvkcnn{" 48 uwrrqtv" jgt" qrkpkqp" vjcv" Rnckpvkhh" jcf" pq" wughwn" cdknkv{" vq" hwpevkqp" qt" ycu" wpcdng" vq" oggv" 49 eqorgvkvkxg" uvcpfctfu" kp" 36" ctgcu" qh" ogpvcn" hwpevkqpkpi0" " Vjwu." vjku" ycu" c" urgekhke" cpf" 4: ngikvkocvg"tgcuqp"uwrrqtvgf"d{"uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"hqt"vjg"CNL"vq"ikxg"nkvvng"ygkijv"vq"vjg" E0" Cpcn{uku0" " 30" Dtkgh."eqpenwuqt{."cpf"kpcfgswcvgn{"uwrrqtvgf0" Vjg"CNLÓu"hktuv"tgcuqp"vq"ikxg"nkvvng"ygkijv"vq"Ft0"GpigÓu"qrkpkqp"ycu"vjcv"kv"ycu"Ðdtkgh." Vjg"EqwtvÓu"tgxkgy"qh"vjg"tgeqtf"qp"vjg"yjqng"tgxgcnu"uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"vq"uwrrqtv" 9" " " " " 3 vtgcvkpi"ru{ejkcvtkuvÓu"qrkpkqp0""See."e.g.."Tonapetyan v. Halter."464"H05f"3366."336;"*;vj"Ekt0" 4 4223+"*Ð]C_p"CNL"pggf"pqv"ceegrv"c"vtgcvkpi"rj{ukekcpÓu"qrkpkqp"vjcv"ku"eqpenwuqt{"cpf"dtkgh" 5 cpf"wpuwrrqtvgf"d{"enkpkecn"hkpfkpiu0Ñ+"*ekvkpi"Matney v. Sullivan.";:3"H04f"3238."323;"*;vj" 6 Ekt0"3;;4++0""" 7 " 8 " 9 cpf"42380""*Lqkpv"Uvkr0"cv"60+""Cu"Rnckpvkhh"rqkpvu"qwv."ogfkecn"pqvgu"htqo"vjcv"vkog"ujqygf"vjcv" : jg" uwhhgtgf" htqo" u{orvqou" uwej" cu" cwfkvqt{" jcnnwekpcvkqpu." cpzkqwu" oqqf." cpzkqwu" chhgev." ; fkhhkewnv{"ykvj"eqipkvkqp"cpf"cvvgpvkqp."cxgtcig"ogoqt{."hncv"chhgev."rctcpqkc."qpiqkpi"cwfkvqt{" 32 jcnnwekpcvkqpu."cpf"dnwpvgf"chhgev0""*Id0"]ekvkpi"CT"52;."537/38_0+""Dwv"vjku"gxkfgpeg"fqgu"pqv" 33 tgpfgt" vjg" CNLÓu" hkpfkpi" gttqpgqwu" qt" wpuwrrqtvgf" d{" uwduvcpvkcn" gxkfgpeg0" " Vjg" ucog" 34 gxkfgpeg"ekvgf"d{"Rnckpvkhh"cnuq"ujqygf"vjcv"jg"pggfgf"ogfkecvkqp"uwrrqtv"ugtxkegu"*CT"52;+." 35 vjcv"jg"jcf"pq"eqornckpvu"*CT"537+."vjcv"jg"ycu"Ðockpvckpkpi"qwvrcvkgpv"hwpevkqpkpi"kp"hcokn{" 36 ugvvkpiÑ"*id0+."vjcv"jg"ycu"fktgevgf"vq"hqnnqy/wr"kp"vjtgg"oqpvju"*id0+."vjcv"jku"ru{ejquku"ycu" 37 Ðwpfgt"cfgswcvg"eqpvtqnÑ"*CT"538+."cpf"vjcv"jg"ycu"Ðuvcdng"cv"dcugnkpgÑ"*id0+0""Nkmgykug."qvjgt" 38 gxkfgpeg" htqo" vjg" ucog" rgtkqf." 4237" cpf" 4238." ujqygf" vjcv" Rnckpvkhh" jcf" pq" kpetgcug" kp" 39 u{orvqou" *CT" 537+." jcf" pq" pgy" rtqdngou" qt" eqpegtpu" *CT" 538/39+." cpf" ycu" uvcdng" ykvj" 3: qpiqkpi"vtgcvogpv"*CT"53:/3;."543+0""Ikxgp"vjku"gxkfgpeg."vjg"CNL"tgcuqpcdn{"hqwpf"vjcv"Ft0" 3; GpigÓu"qrkpkqp"ycu"vqq"gzvtgog"ikxgp"vjg"enkpkecn"hkpfkpiu0""See Edlund v. Massanari."475" 42 H05f" 3374." 3378" *;vj" Ekt0" 4223+" *ÐKh" gxkfgpeg" ku" uwuegrvkdng" vq" oqtg" vjcp" qpg" tcvkqpcn" 43 kpvgtrtgvcvkqp." vjg" eqwtv" oc{" pqv" uwduvkvwvg" kvu" lwfiogpv" hqt" vjcv" qh" vjg" Eqookuukqpgt0Ñ+" 44 *ekvcvkqpu"qokvvgf+0"""""""""""""" 45 " 46 " 47 dghqtg"tglgevkpi"jgt"qrkpkqp"cu"wpuwrrqtvgf"d{"enkpkecn"hkpfkpiu0""*Lqkpv"Uvkr0"cv"6/70+""Cp"CNLÓu" 48 fwv{" vq" uggm" cffkvkqpcn" kphqtocvkqp" htqo" c" vtgcvkpi" rj{ukekcp" ku" vtkiigtgf" Ðqpn{" yjgp" vjg" 49 gxkfgpeg" htqo" vjg" vtgcvkpi" ogfkecn" uqwteg" ku" kpcfgswcvg" vq" ocmg" c" fgvgtokpcvkqp" cu" vq" vjg" 4: enckocpvÓu"fkucdknkv{0Ñ""See Thomas v. Barnhart."49:"H05f";69.";7:"*;vj"Ekt0"4224+0""Jgtg."vjg" Rnckpvkhh"fkurwvgu"vjku"tgcuqp"d{"rqkpvkpi"vq"gxkfgpeg"qh"qdlgevkxg"hkpfkpiu"htqo"4237" Rnckpvkhh"hwtvjgt"eqpvgpfu"vjcv"vjg"CNL"ujqwnf"jcxg"tgeqpvcevgf"Ft0"Gpig"hqt"enctkhkecvkqp" :" " " " " 3 CNL"fkf"pqv"ocmg"c"hkpfkpi"vjcv"Ft0"GpigÓu"qrkpkqp"ycu"kpcfgswcvg"vq"ocmg"c"fgvgtokpcvkqp" 4 tgictfkpi"RnckpvkhhÓu"fkucdknkv{"encko0""Kpfggf."Ð]v_jgtg"ycu"pqvjkpi"wpengct"qt"codkiwqwu"cdqwv" 5 yjcv"]Ft0"Gpig_"uckf0Ñ""See McLeod v. Astrue."862"H05f"::3."::6"*;vj"Ekt0"4233+0""Tcvjgt."vjg" 6 CNL"hqwpf"vjcv"Ft0"GpigÓu"qrkpkqp"ycu"wpuwrrqtvgf"d{"enkpkecn"hkpfkpiu."yjkej"ku"pqv"vjg"ucog" 7 cu"ejctcevgtk|kpi"kv"cu"wpengct."codkiwqwu."qt"kpcfgswcvg"vq"ocmg"c"fkucdknkv{"fgvgtokpcvkqp0"" 8 See Bayliss v. Barnhart." 649" H05f" 3433." 3439" *;vj" Ekt0" 4227+" *hkpfkpi" vjcv" c" vtgcvkpi" 9 rj{ukekcpÓu"qrkpkqp"vjcv"vjg"CNL"tglgevgf"dgecwug"kv"ycu"eqpvtcfkevgf"d{"enkpkecn"pqvgu"ycu"pqv" : vjg"ucog"cu"cp"ÐcodkiwqwuÑ"qt"ÐkpuwhhkekgpvÑ"qrkpkqp"vjcv"tgswktgf"vjg"CNL"vq"tgeqpvcev"vjg" ; vtgcvkpi"ru{ejqnqikuv+="see also"Thomas."49:"H05f"cv";7:"*tgeqipk|kpi"vjcv"c"Ðeqpvtcfkevqt{Ñ" 32 qrkpkqp"d{"c"vtgcvkpi"rj{ukekcp"ku"pqv"vjg"ucog"cu"cp"ÐkpcfgswcvgÑ"qpg+0""Vjwu."vjg"CNL"ycu" 33 pqv"tgswktgf"vq"tgeqpvcev"Ft0"Gpig"hqt"enctkhkecvkqp0" 34 " 35 " 36 rtqxkfg"cp"gzrncpcvkqpÑ"hqt"jgt"qrkpkqp."Ft0"Gpig"fkf"kp"hcev"rtqxkfg"uwej"cp"gzrncpcvkqp0"" 37 *Lqkpv"Uvkr0"cv"70+""Cu" Rnckpvkhh"rqkpvu"qwv."Ft0"Gpig"uvcvgf"ownvkrng"vkogu"vjcv" Rnckpvkhh"ycu" 38 kpecrcdng"qh"eqorgvkvkxg"gornq{ogpv."dqvj"kp"jgt"qrkpkqp"kvugnh"cpf"kp"jgt"vtgcvogpv"pqvgu0""Kp" 39 jgt"qrkpkqp."Ft0"Gpig"ytqvg"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"Ðjcu"uejk|qrjtgpkc"cpf"dgeqogu"xgt{"wpeqohqtvcdng" 3: ctqwpf"itqwru"qh"rgqrng0""Vjku"korcktu"jku"cvvgpvkqp0""Cnuq"igvu"fkuvtcevgf"d{"xqkegu0Ñ""*CT" 3; 5250+""Ft0"Gpig"hwtvjgt"ytqvg"kp"jgt"qrkpkqp"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"Ðjcu"dggp"hktgf"htqo"5"qt"6"lqdu"kp" 42 vjg"rcuv"dgecwug"qh"nkokvcvkqpu"htqo"ogpvcn"knnpguuÑ"cpf"vjcv"Ðjg"yqwnf"rtqdcdn{"ujqy"wr"hqt" 43 yqtmÑ"dwv"yqwnf"dg"Ðwpcdng"vq"rgthqto"vjg"lqd0Ñ""*Id0+""Cpf"kp"jgt"vtgcvogpv"pqvgu."Ft0"Gpig" 44 ytqvg" vjcv" Rnckpvkhh" Ðhwpevkqpu" kp" c" jqog" ugvvkpi." dwv" kp" c" yqtm" gpxktqpogpv" jku" ru{ejqvke" 45 u{orvqou"0"0"0"yqwnf"swkemn{"yqtugp."jku"eqpegpvtcvkqp"yqwnf"uwhhgt."cpf"jg"yqwnf"dg"nkmgn{" 46 vq" dgeqog" cikvcvgf" cpf" kttkvcdng0Ñ" " *CT" 53:0+" " Ukoknctn{." Ft0" Gpig" ytqvg" gnugyjgtg" kp" jgt" 47 vtgcvogpv" pqvgu" vjcv" Rnckpvkhh" Ðyqwnf" pqv" dg" cdng" vq" ockpvckp" gornq{ogpv" ykvjqwv" 48 fgeqorgpucvkpiÑ"*CT"4;7+"cpf"Ðyqwnf"pqv"dg"cdng"vq"jqnf"c"lqdÑ"*CT"536+0" 49 111" 4: 111" Hkpcnn{." Rnckpvkhh" eqpvgpfu" vjcv." eqpvtct{" vq" vjg" CNLÓu" hkpfkpi" vjcv" Ft0" Gpig" Ðfkf" pqv" ;" " " " " 3 " C"vtgcvkpi"rj{ukekcpÓu"qrkpkqp"qp"vjg"wnvkocvg"kuuwg"qh"yjgvjgt"c"enckocpv"ecp"yqtm"ku" 4 eqorgvgpv"gxkfgpeg"vjcv"cp"CNL"owuv"eqpukfgt0""See Reddick v. Chater."379"H05f"937."947"*;vj" 5 Ekt0"3;;:+="Uqekcn"Ugewtkv{"Twnkpi"*ÐUUTÑ+";8/7R."3;;8"YN"5963:5."cv",7"*ÐUwej"qrkpkqpu" 6 qp"vjgug"kuuwgu"owuv"pqv"dg"fkutgictfgf0Ñ+0""Jgtg."jqygxgt."vjg"CNL"fkf"eqpukfgt"Ft0"GpigÓu" 7 eqpenwukqp"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"ycu"kpecrcdng"qh"eqorgvkvkxg"gornq{ogpv"dwv"icxg"vjcv"eqpenwukqp" 8 nkvvng" ygkijv" dgecwug" kv" ycu" kpcfgswcvgn{" gzrnckpgf0" " Cu" pqvgf." Ft0" GpigÓu" vtgcvogpv" pqvgu" 9 eqpvckpgf"uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"vjcv."ykvj"vtgcvogpv."Rnckpvkhh"ycu"fqkpi"ygnn"cpf"jku"ogpvcn" : u{orvqou"ygtg"cfgswcvgn{"eqpvtqnngf0""Ft0"GpigÓu"tcvkqpcng"vjcv"vjku"rqukvkxg"qwveqog"yqwnf" ; ejcpig" kh" Rnckpvkhh" vtkgf" vq" yqtm" ycu" tgcuqpcdn{" tglgevgf" cu" wpuwrrqtvgf" eqplgevwtg0" " ÐC" 32 vtgcvkpi"rj{ukekcpÓu"gxcnwcvkqp"qh"c"rcvkgpvÓu"cdknkv{"vq"yqtm"oc{"dg"c"wughwn"qt"uwiiguvkxg"qh" 33 wughwn"kphqtocvkqp."dwv"c"vtgcvkpi"rj{ukekcp"qtfkpctkn{"fqgu"pqv"eqpuwnv"c"xqecvkqpcn"gzrgtv"qt" 34 jcxg"vjg"gzrgtvkug"qh"qpg0Ñ""McLeod."862"H05f"cv"::60""ÐVjg"tgncvkqpujkr"dgvyggp"korcktogpv" 35 cpf"fkucdknkv{"tgockpu"dqvj"eqorngz"cpf"fkhhkewnv."kh"pqv"korquukdng."vq"rtgfkev"0"0"0"Vjg"ucog" 36 ngxgn"qh"kplwt{"ku"kp"pq"yc{"rtgfkevkxg"qh"cp"chhgevgf"kpfkxkfwcnÓu"cdknkv{"vq"rctvkekrcvg"kp"oclqt" 37 nkhg" hwpevkqpu" *kpenwfkpi" yqtm+0Ñ" " Id0" *ekvcvkqp" cpf" kpvgtpcn" swqvcvkqp" octmu" qokvvgf+0" " Ft0" 38 GpigÓu"rtgfkevkqp"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"yqwnf"dg"wpcdng"vq"ockpvckp"eqorgvkvkxg"gornq{ogpv"ycu"pqv" 39 uwduvcpvkcnn{"uwrrqtvgf"d{"vjg"qdlgevkxg"enkpkecn"hkpfkpiu0""Vjwu."vjg"CNL"rtqrgtn{"tglgevgf"Ft0" 3: GpigÓu"qrkpkqp"cdqwv"RnckpvkhhÓu"cdknkv{"vq"yqtm"cu"kpcfgswcvgn{"gzrnckpgf0""""""""""""""""""""" 3; " 42 " 43 " 44 " 45 Ðkpeqpukuvgpv"ykvj"vjg"qdlgevkxg"ogfkecn"gxkfgpeg"cu"c"yjqng"cntgcf{"fkuewuugf"kp"vjku"fgekukqp." 46 yjkej"ujqyu"]Rnckpvkhh_"tgegkxgf"qpn{"tqwvkpg"cpf"eqpugtxcvkxg"vtgcvogpv0Ñ""*CT"44/450+""Cu" 47 pqvgf."RnckpvkhhÓu"vtgcvogpv"eqpukuvgf"rtkoctkn{"qh"Tkurgtkfqpg"*qt"Tkurgtfcn+."cp"cpvkru{ejqvke" 48 ogfkecvkqp" wugf" vq" vtgcv" uejk|qchhgevkxg" fkuqtfgtu0" " *CT" 5:."4:7."4;9."5350+"" Jqygxgt." vjg" 49 Eqwtv" eqpewtu" ykvj" qvjgt" fkuvtkev" eqwtvu" vjcv" jcxg" hqwpf" cpvkru{ejqvke" ogfkecvkqpu" uwej" cu" 4: Tkurgtkfqpg"fq"pqv"swcnkh{"cu"tqwvkpg"qt"eqpugtxcvkxg"vtgcvogpv0""See Faber v. Berryhill."4239" " 40" Tqwvkpg"cpf"eqpugtxcvkxg"vtgcvogpv0" Vjg" CNLÓu" ugeqpf" tgcuqp" vq" ikxg"nkvvng" ygkijv" vq" Ft0" GpigÓu" qrkpkqp" ycu" vjcv" kv" ycu" 32" " " " " 3 YN"8983;58."cv",32"*U0F0"Ecn0"Fge0"4;."4239+="Carden v. Colvin."4236"YN":5;333."cv",5" 4 *E0F0"Ecn0"Oct0"6."4236+="see also Gidley v. Colvin."4235"YN"8;2;392."cv",;"*P0F0"Kpf0"Fge0" 5 52."4235+"*ÐKv"ku"pqv"engct"vjcv"]vjg"CNL_"yqwnf"jcxg"tgcejgf"vjg"ucog"eqpenwukqp"vjcv"]vjg" 6 enckocpv_" jcf" eqpugtxcvkxg" vtgcvogpv" kh" jg" eqpukfgtgf" cnn" qh" ]vjg" enckocpvÓu_" ogfkecvkqpuÑ" 7 kpenwfkpi" Tkurgtfcn+0" " Cnvjqwij" vjg" tgeqtf" fqgu" ujqy" vjcv" Rnckpvkhh" ycu" cdng" vq" eqpvtqn" jku" 8 u{orvqou"ykvj"Tkurgtkfqpg."uwej"vtgcvogpv"fqgu"pqv"swcnkh{"cu"eqpugtxcvkxg0""Vjwu."vjku"ycu" 9 pqv"c"urgekhke"cpf"ngikvkocvg"tgcuqp"vq"tglgev"Ft0"GpigÓu"qrkpkqp0""" : " ; " 32 " 33 " 34 kpeqpukuvgpv"ykvj"RnckpvkhhÓu"Ðcfokvvgf"cevkxkvkgu"qh"fckn{"nkxkpi0Ñ""*CT"450+""Gnugyjgtg"kp"vjg" 35 qrkpkqp."vjg"CNL"tgrgcvgfn{"pqvgf"vjcv"RnckpvkhhÓu"cfokvvgf"cevkxkvkgu"qh"fckn{"nkxkpi"kpenwfgf" 36 iqkpi"hqt"ycnmu."rtgrctkpi"ogcnu."rgthqtokpi"jqwugjqnf"ejqtgu."ftkxkpi."ujqrrkpi"kp"uvqtgu." 37 twppkpi"gttcpfu."ocpcikpi"jku"qyp"hkpcpegu."ugnnkpi"iqqfu"qp"gDc{."cpf"ycvejkpi"vgngxkukqp0"" 38 *CT"3:."42."43="see also"CT"5;/63."39:/9;."45;/620+""" 39 """""" 3: " 3; qh"vjg"enckocpvÓu"fckn{"cevkxkvkgu0""See Rollins v. Massanari."483"H05f":75.":78"*;vj"Ekt0"4223+" 42 *hkpfkpi" vjg" vtgcvkpi" rj{ukekcpÓu" qrkpkqp" Ðkpeqpukuvgpv" ykvj" vjg" ngxgn" qh" cevkxkv{" vjcv" ]vjg" 43 enckocpv_" gpicigf" kp" d{" ockpvckpkpi" c" jqwugjqnf" cpf" tckukpi" vyq" {qwpi" ejknftgp." ykvj" pq" 44 ukipkhkecpv"cuukuvcpeg"htqo"jgt"gz"jwudcpfÑ+0""Jgtg."Ft0"GpigÓu"qrkpkqp"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"jcf"Ðpq" 45 wughwn" cdknkv{" vq" hwpevkqpÑ" kp" ctgcu" uwej" cu" ockpvckpkpi" cvvgpvkqp" hqt" c" vyq" jqwt" ugiogpv." 46 ectt{kpi" qwv" fgvckngf" kpuvtwevkqpu." qt" vtcxgnkpi" kp" wphcoknkct" rncegu" *CT" 524/25+" ycu" 47 kpeqpukuvgpv"ykvj"RnckpvkhhÓu"uvcvgogpvu"vjcv"jg"ecp"rgthqto"jqwugjqnf"ejqtgu."ujqr"kp"uvqtgu." 48 twp"gttcpfu."ocpcig"jku"qyp"hkpcpegu."cpf"ugnn"iqqfu"qp"gDc{"*CT"5;/63."39:/9;."45;/62+0"" 49 Vjwu." vjku" ycu" c" urgekhke" cpf" ngikvkocvg" tgcuqp" dcugf" qp" uwduvcpvkcn" gxkfgpeg" vq" ikxg" nkvvng" 4: ygkijv"vq"vjg"vtgcvkpi"ru{ejkcvtkuvÓu"qrkpkqp0" " 50" Cevkxkvkgu"qh"fckn{"nkxkpi0" Vjg" CNLÓu" hkpcn" tgcuqp" vq" ikxg" nkvvng" ygkijv" vq" Ft0" GpigÓu" qrkpkqp" ycu" vjcv" kv" ycu" Cp"CNL"oc{"fkueqwpv"c"vtgcvkpi"rj{ukekcpÓu"qrkpkqp"vjcv"ku"kpeqpukuvgpv"ykvj"gxkfgpeg" 33" " " " " 3 " Rnckpvkhh" fkurwvgu" vjku" tgcuqp" d{" ctiwkpi" vjcv" vjg" CNL" hckngf" Ðvq" rtqxkfg" cp" ceewtcvg" 4 rkevwtg"qh"jqy"nkokvgf"vjgug"]cevkxkvkgu_"ctgÑ"dgecwug."hqt"gzcorng."Rnckpvkhh"pggfgf"tgokpfgtu" 5 vq" rgthqto" ejqtgu0" " *Lqkpv" Uvkr0" cv" 70+" " Dwv" gxgp" kh" RnckpvkhhÓu" ejctcevgtk|cvkqp" qh" jku" fckn{" 6 cevkxkvkgu" ygtg" eqttgev." kv" yqwnf" pqv" kpxcnkfcvg" vjg" CNLÓu" tgcuqpkpi0" " RnckpvkhhÓu" cdknkv{" vq" 7 rgthqto" uwej" cevkxkvkgu." gxgp" qp" c" nkokvgf" dcuku." yqwnf" ujqy" vjcv" jg" jcf" cv" ngcuv" c" Ðwughwn" 8 cdknkv{"vq"hwpevkqpÑ"kp"ctgcu"uwej"cu"ockpvckpkpi"cvvgpvkqp"hqt"vyq"jqwtu."ectt{kpi"qwv"fgvckngf" 9 kpuvtwevkqpu." cpf" vtcxgnkpi" kp" wphcoknkct" rncegu." yjkej" ycu" kpeqpukuvgpv" ykvj" Ft0" GpigÓu" : qrkpkqp"vjcv"jg"jcf"Ðpq"wughwn"cdknkv{"vq"hwpevkqpÑ"kp"vjqug"ctgcu"*CT"524/25+0""Vjwu."gxkfgpeg" ; qh"RnckpvkhhÓu"fckn{"cevkxkvkgu."gxgp"qp"c"nkokvgf"dcuku."ycu"c"urgekhke"cpf"ngikvkocvg"itqwpf"vq" 32 ikxg"nkvvng"ygkijv"vq"Ft0"GpigÓu"jkijn{"tguvtkevkxg"qrkpkqp0""See Rollins."483"H05f"cv":780" 33 """""""""""""""""" 34 F0" Eqpenwukqp0" 35 " 36 Vjg" CNLÓu" ejctcevgtk|cvkqp" qh" RnckpvkhhÓu" vtgcvogpv" ykvj" Tkurgtkfqpg" cu" tqwvkpg" cpf" 37 eqpugtxcvkxg"fkf"pqv"rtqxkfg"c"urgekhke"cpf"ngikvkocvg"tgcuqp"vq"tglgev"vjg"vtgcvkpi"ru{ejkcvtkuvÓu" 38 qrkpkqp0""Jqygxgt."vjg"gttqt"ycu"jctonguu"dgecwug"vjg"CNL"qvjgtykug"uvcvgf"vyq"urgekhke"cpf" 39 ngikvkocvg"tgcuqpu."dcugf"qp"ncem"qh"enkpkecn"uwrrqtv"cpf"gxkfgpeg"qh"RnckpvkhhÓu"fckn{"cevkxkvkgu0"" 3: See Molina v. Astrue."896"H05f"3326."3337"*;vj"Ekt0"4234+"*Ð]Y_g"jcxg"cfjgtgf"vq"vjg"igpgtcn" 3; rtkpekrng" vjcv" cp" CNLÓu" gttqt" ku" jctonguu" yjgtg" kv" ku" kpeqpugswgpvkcn" vq" vjg" wnvkocvg" 42 pqpfkucdknkv{"fgvgtokpcvkqpÑ+"*ekvcvkqp"cpf"kpvgtpcn"swqvcvkqp"octmu"qokvvgf+0""Vjwu."Kuuwg"Qpg" 43 fqgu"pqv"ycttcpv"tgxgtucn0" 44 " 45 KK0" 46 " 47 " 48 RnckpvkhhÓu"ogpvcn"eqpfkvkqp."yjkej"ycu"tgngxcpv"vq"vjg"kuuwgu"qh"RnckpvkhhÓu"THE"cpf"uwdlgevkxg" 49 u{orvqo"vguvkoqp{0""*Lqkpv"Uvkr0"cv"32/360+""" 4: 111" Vjg"CNL"Fkf"Pqv"Gtt"D{"Hcknkpi"Vq"Fgxgnqr"Vjg"Tgeqtf"*Kuuwg"Vyq+0" Kp"Kuuwg"Vyq."Rnckpvkhh"enckou"vjcv"vjg"CNL"gttgf"d{"hcknkpi"vq"fgxgnqr"vjg"tgeqtf"cdqwv" 34" " " " " 3 " 4 " C0" Ngicn"Uvcpfctf0" 5 Kv"ku"ygnn/guvcdnkujgf"vjcv"vjg"CNL"jcu"c"urgekcn"fwv{"vq"hwnn{"cpf"hcktn{"fgxgnqr"vjg"tgeqtf" 6 vq" cuuwtg" vjcv" vjg" enckocpvÓu" kpvgtguvu" ctg" eqpukfgtgf." cpf" vjcv" vjku" urgekcn" fwv{" gzkuvu" gxgp" 7 yjgp"vjg"enckocpv"ku"tgrtgugpvgf"d{"eqwpugn0""See Brown v. Heckler."935"H04f"663."665"*;vj" 8 Ekt0"3;:5+="see also Garcia v. Commissioner of Social Sec0."98:"H05f";47.";52"*;vj"Ekt0"4236+0"" 9 ÐCp"CNLÓu"fwv{"vq"fgxgnqr"vjg"tgeqtf"hwtvjgt"ku"vtkiigtgf"0"0"0"yjgp"vjgtg"ku"codkiwqwu"gxkfgpeg" : qt"yjgp"vjg"tgeqtf"ku"kpcfgswcvg"vq"cnnqy"hqt"rtqrgt"gxcnwcvkqp"qh"vjg"gxkfgpeg0Ñ""See Mayes ; v. Massanari."498"H05f"675."67;/82"*;vj"Ekt0"4223+0" 32 " 33 " 34 " 35 " 36 gzgtvkqpcn"ngxgnu"dwv"ykvj"vjg"hqnnqykpi"pqpgzgtvkqpcn"nkokvcvkqpu<""jg"ecp"rgthqto"wpumknngf" 37 yqtm="cpf"jg"ecp"qeecukqpcnn{"kpvgtcev"ykvj"qvjgtu0Ñ""*CT"3;0+""Vjg"CNL"cnuq"tglgevgf"RnckpvkhhÓu" 38 uwdlgevkxg" u{orvqo" cnngicvkqpu." rctvkewnctn{" dgecwug" qh" vjg" pcvwtg" qh" jku" ogpvcn" jgcnvj" 39 vtgcvogpv0""*CT"43/440+""Rnckpvkhh"eqpvgpfu"vjcv"vjgug"hkpfkpiu"ygtg"gttqpgqwu"dgecwug"vjg"CNL" 3: hckngf"vq"fgxgnqr"vjg"tgeqtf0" 3; " 42 " 43 fgxgnqrgf" vjg" tgeqtf" d{" eqpuwnvkpi" c" ogpvcn" jgcnvj" rtqhguukqpcn." uwej" cu" cp" gzcokpkpi" 44 rj{ukekcp"qt"c"ogfkecn"gzrgtv."yjq"eqwnf"jcxg"ikxgp"cp"gzrgtv"qrkpkqp"cdqwv"RnckpvkhhÓu"ogpvcn" 45 nkokvcvkqpu0""*Lqkpv"Uvkr0"cv"33."360+""Dwv"vjg"tgeqtf"fkf"eqpvckp"gzrgtv"qrkpkqpu"d{"ogpvcn"jgcnvj" 46 rtqhguukqpcnu0""Vyq"uvcvg"cigpe{"ru{ejkcvtkuvu"hqwpf"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"fkf"pqv"jcxg"c"ugxgtg"ogpvcn" 47 korcktogpv"ykvj"oqtg"vjcp"c"okpkocn"ghhgev"qp"jku"ecrcekv{"vq"fq"dcuke"yqtm"cevkxkv{0""*CT" 48 74."820+""Vjg"CNL"hqwpf"vjg"uvcvg"cigpe{"ru{ejkcvtkuvuÓ"qrkpkqpu"vq"dg"kpuwhhkekgpvn{"tguvtkevkxg" 49 *CT" 45+" cpf" vjwu" hqwpf" vjcv" Rnckpvkhh" jcf" c" ugxgtg" ogpvcn" korcktogpv" vjcv" ycttcpvgf" 4: pqpgzgtvkqpcn" nkokvcvkqpu" eqpukuvkpi" qh" c" nkokvcvkqp" vq" wpumknngf" yqtm" ykvj" qeecukqpcn" D0" Cpcn{uku0" Vjg"CNL"fgvgtokpgf."cu"pqvgf"cdqxg."vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"jcf"cp"THE"vq"rgthqto"yqtm"Ðcv"cnn" Rnckpvkhh" eqpvgpfu" vjcv" vjg" CNL" korgtokuukdn{" Ðrnc{gf" fqevqtÑ" cpf" ujqwnf" jcxg" 35" " " " " 3 kpvgtcevkqp" ykvj" qvjgtu" *CT" 3;+0" " Kv" ku" kpceewtcvg" vq" uc{" wpfgt" vjgug" ektewouvcpegu" vjcv" pq" 4 ogpvcn"jgcnvj"rtqhguukqpcn"rtqxkfgf"c"dcuku"hqt"vjg"CNLÓu"THE"fgvgtokpcvkqp"qt"vjcv"vjg"CNL" 5 ocfg"uwej"c"fgvgtokpcvkqp"qwv"qh"yjqng"enqvj0" 6 " 7 " 8 ogpvcn" THE" fgvgtokpcvkqp" jgtg." hqt" wpumknngf" yqtm" cpf" qeecukqpcn" kpvgtcevkqp" ykvj" qvjgtu0"" 9 *CT"3;0+""Dwv"vjku"fkf"pqv"ogcp"vjcv"vjg"CNL"ycu"tgswktgf"vq"qdvckp"gxkfgpeg"htqo"vjg"ogfkecn" : uqwtegu"Rnckpvkhh"uwiiguvu."uwej"cu"cp"gzcokpkpi"rj{ukekcp"qt"c"ogfkecn"gzrgtv."vq"uwrrqtv"vjg" ; THE"fgvgtokpcvkqp0""*Lqkpv"Uvkr0"cv"360+""Cp"THE"ku"cp"Ðcfokpkuvtcvkxg"hkpfkpi.Ñ"cpf"vjg"hkpcn" 32 tgurqpukdknkv{"hqt"fgvgtokpkpi"cp"kpfkxkfwcnÓu"THE"ku"tgugtxgf"vq"vjg"Eqookuukqpgt0""See"UUT" 33 ;8/7r."3;;8"YN"5963:5."cv",7"*Ð]C_"ogfkecn"uqwteg"uvcvgogpv"owuv"pqv"dg"gswcvgf"ykvj"cp" 34 cfokpkuvtcvkxg" hkpfkpi" mpqyp" cu" vjg" THE" cuuguuogpv0Ñ+=" Lynch Guzman v. Astrue." 587" H0" 35 CrrÓz":8;." :92" *;vj"Ekt0" 4232+"*ÐTgukfwcn" hwpevkqpcn" ecrcekv{" ku" cp" cfokpkuvtcvkxg" hkpfkpi" 36 tgugtxgf"vq"vjg"Eqookuukqpgt0Ñ+0""Rnckpvkhh"jcu"pqv"ekvgf"cp{"dkpfkpi"ngicn"cwvjqtkv{"hqt"vjg" 37 rtqrqukvkqp"vjcv"cp"CNLÓu"THE"fgvgtokpcvkqp"owuv"dg"kfgpvkecn"vq"cp"qrkpkqp"d{"c"ogfkecn" 38 rtqhguukqpcn."rctvkewnctn{"yjgtg."cu"jgtg."vjg"tgeqtf"eqpvckpu"ogfkecn"qrkpkqpu"uvcvkpi"vjcv"c" 39 enckocpv"ku"oqtg"ecrcdng"vjcp"vjg"CNLÓu"THE"fgvgtokpcvkqp"tghngevu0""Cf. Mokbel-Aljahmi v. 3: Commissioner of Social Security."954"H0"CrrÓz"5;7."623"*8vj"Ekt0"423:+"*ÐYg"jcxg"rtgxkqwun{" 3; tglgevgf"vjg"ctiwogpv"vjcv"c"tgukfwcn"hwpevkqpcn"ecrcekv{"fgvgtokpcvkqp"ecppqv"dg"uwrrqtvgf"d{" 42 uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"wpnguu"c"rj{ukekcp"qhhgtu"cp"qrkpkqp"eqpukuvgpv"ykvj"vjcv"qh"vjg"CNL0Ñ+" 43 *ekvcvkqpu"qokvvgf+="Winn v. Commissioner, Social Security Administration.":;6"H05f";:4.";:9" 44 *:vj"Ekt0"423:+"*ÐVjg"CNL"ycu"pqv"tgswktgf"vq"ceegrv"cp{"rj{ukekcpÓu"qrkpkqp"tgictfkpi"vjku" 45 gngogpv"qh"YkppÓu"THE0""Gxgp"vjqwij"vjg"THE"cuuguuogpv"ftcyu"htqo"ogfkecn"uqwtegu"hqt" 46 uwrrqtv." kv" ku" wnvkocvgn{" cp" cfokpkuvtcvkxg" fgvgtokpcvkqp" tgugtxgf" vq" vjg" Eqookuukqpgt0Ñ+" 47 *ekvcvkqp"cpf"kpvgtpcn"swqvcvkqp"octmu"qokvvgf+0""Vjg"CNL"gxcnwcvgf"kp"uwhhkekgpv"fgvckn"cnn"vjg" 48 rtqdcvkxg" ogfkecn" gxkfgpeg" kp" vjg" tgeqtf" dghqtg" fgvgtokpkpi" RnckpvkhhÓu" ogpvcn" nkokvcvkqpu0"" 49 Vjwu."vjg"CNL"fkf"pqv"hckn"vq"fgxgnqr"vjg"tgeqtf"kp"vjku"tgictf0"""" 4: 111" Vq"dg"uwtg."pq"ogpvcn"jgcnvj"rtqhguukqpcn"icxg"cp"qrkpkqp"vjcv"ycu"identical"vq"vjg"CNLÓu" 36" " " " " 3 Rnckpvkhh"ukoknctn{"eqpvgpfu"vjcv"vjg"CNL"ncemgf"vjg"swcnkhkecvkqpu"qh"c"ogfkecn"gzrgtv"vq" 4 cuuguu"RnckpvkhhÓu"vguvkoqp{"cdqwv"jku"ogpvcn"jgcnvj"vtgcvogpv0""*Lqkpv"Uvkr0"cv"350+""Vjg"CNL" 5 fkueqwpvgf"RnckpvkhhÓu"vguvkoqp{"kp"rctv"dgecwug"jku"ogpvcn"jgcnvj"vtgcvogpv."yjkej"eqpukuvgf" 6 qh"vjgtcr{"uguukqpu"gxgt{"vjtgg"oqpvju"cpf"Tkurgtkfqpg"*CT"5:+."ycu"pqv"Ðvjg"v{rg"qh"ogfkecn" 7 vtgcvogpv" qpg" yqwnf" gzrgevÑ" cpf" Rnckpvkhh" hckngf" vq" Ðqhhgt" c" uwhhkekgpv" gzrncpcvkqpÑ" hqt" pqv" 8 uggmkpi" oqtg" ciitguukxg" vtgcvogpv" *CT" 44+." " Kv" ku" wppgeguuct{." jqygxgt." vq" tguqnxg" vjg" 9 swguvkqp"qh"yjgvjgt"vjg"CNL"ycu"swcnkhkgf"vq"cuuguu"vjg"crrtqrtkcvgpguu"qh"RnckpvkhhÓu"vtgcvogpv" : dgecwug"vjg"qwveqog"yqwnf"pqv"ejcpig"gxgp"kh"vjg"CNL"ycu"pqv"swcnkhkgf0""Tgictfnguu"qh"vjg" ; CNLÓu"swcnkhkecvkqpu."vjg"Eqwtv"fkucitggu."cu"fkuewuugf"cdqxg."vjcv"cpvkru{ejqvke"ogfkecvkqpu" 32 uwej"cu"Tkurgtkfqpg"swcnkh{"cu"eqpugtxcvkxg"vtgcvogpv0""Vjwu."uwej"c"tcvkqpcng"yqwnf"pqv"dg"c" 33 engct" cpf" eqpxkpekpi" tgcuqp" vq" tglgev" RnckpvkhhÓu" vguvkoqp{0" " Dwv" vjg" CNL" uvcvgf" qvjgt." 34 kpfgrgpfgpv" tgcuqpu" vq" fkueqwpv" RnckpvkhhÓu" vguvkoqp{" *CT" 43/44+." cpf" Rnckpvkhh" fqgu" pqv" 35 cvvgorv"vq"fkurwvg"vjgo0""Urgekhkecnn{."vjg"CNL"fkueqwpvgf"RnckpvkhhÓu"vguvkoqp{"dgecwug"Ðykvj" 36 vtgcvogpv."]jg_"ycu"pqvgf"vq"dg"uvcdng.Ñ"cpf"dgecwug"RnckpvkhhÓu"Ðcevkxkvkgu"qh"fckn{"nkxkpi"]ygtg_" 37 kpeqpukuvgpv"ykvj"]jku_"uvcvgogpvu"eqpegtpkpi"vjg"cnngigf"kpvgpukv{."rgtukuvgpeg."cpf"nkokvkpi" 38 ghhgevu"qh"u{orvqou0Ñ""*CT"430+""Vjgug"ygtg"engct"cpf"eqpxkpekpi"tgcuqpu"vq"tglgev"RnckpvkhhÓu" 39 uwdlgevkxg"u{orvqo"cnngicvkqpu0""See Warre v. Comm’r of Soc. Sec. Admin0."65;"H05f"3223." 3: 3228"*;vj"Ekt0"4228+"*korcktogpvu"vjcv"ecp"dg"eqpvtqnngf"ghhgevkxgn{"ykvj"ogfkecvkqpu"ctg"pqv" 3; fkucdnkpi+="Valentine v. Commissioner Social Sec. Admin.."796"H05f"8:7."8;5"*;vj"Ekt0"422;+" 42 *ÐVjg"CNL"tgeqipk|gf"vjcv"vjku"gxkfgpeg"]qh"fckn{"cevkxkvkgu_"fkf"pqv"uwiiguv"Xcngpvkpg"eqwnf" 43 tgvwtp"vq"jku"qnf"lqd"0"0"0"."dwv"ujg"vjqwijv"kv"fkf"uwiiguv"vjcv"XcngpvkpgÓu"ncvgt"enckou"cdqwv"vjg" 44 ugxgtkv{"qh"jku"nkokvcvkqpu"ygtg"gzciigtcvgf0Ñ+0""" 45 " 46 Kp" uwo." cp{" gttqt" d{" vjg" CNL" kp" ejctcevgtk|kpi" RnckpvkhhÓu" ogpvcn" jgcnvj" vtgcvogpv" cu" 47 eqpugtxcvkxg"ycu"kpeqpugswgpvkcn"vq"vjg"CNLÓu"qvjgt"tgcuqpu"vq"fkueqwpv"RnckpvkhhÓu"vguvkoqp{0"" 48 See Carmickle v. Commissioner, Social Sec. Admin0." 755" H05f" 3377." 3385" *;vj" Ekt0" 422:+" 49 *jqnfkpi"vjcv"kpxcnkf"tgcuqpu"vq"tglgev"c"enckocpvÓu"vguvkoqp{"yknn"dg"jctonguu"gttqt"kh"vjg"CNL" 4: qvjgtykug"uvcvgf"xcnkf"tgcuqpu+0""Oqtgqxgt."dgecwug"vjg"CNL"uvcvgf"xcnkf"tgcuqpu"pqv"vq"etgfkv" 37" " " " " 3 RnckpvkhhÓu"vguvkoqp{."vjg"CNL"ycu"pqv"tgswktgf"vq"kpeqtrqtcvg"RnckpvkhhÓu"vguvkoqp{"kpvq"vjg" 4 THE" fgvgtokpcvkqp0" " See Bayliss." 649" H05f" cv" 3439" *yjgtg" cp" CNL" rtqrgtn{" tglgevgf" c" 5 enckocpvÓu" vguvkoqp{."vjg"THE"fgvgtokpcvkqp"pggf"pqv"fgrgpf"qp"vjg"enckocpvÓu"uwdlgevkxg" 6 eqornckpvu+0""Vjwu."vjku"kuuwg"fqgu"pqv"ycttcpv"tgxgtucn0"""""""" 7 " 8 EQPENWUKQP" 9 " : " ; uwrrqtvgf"d{"uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"cpf"htgg"htqo"ocvgtkcn"ngicn"gttqt0""Pgkvjgt"tgxgtucn"qh"vjg" Hqt" vjg" tgcuqpu" uvcvgf" cdqxg." vjg" Eqwtv" hkpfu" vjcv" vjg" EqookuukqpgtÓu" fgekukqp" ku" 32 CNLÓu"fgekukqp"pqt"tgocpf"ku"ycttcpvgf0" 33 " 34 " 35 vjg"Eqookuukqpgt"qh"vjg"Uqekcn"Ugewtkv{"Cfokpkuvtcvkqp0" 36 " 37 " 38 Ogoqtcpfwo"Qrkpkqp"cpf"Qtfgt"cpf"vjg"Lwfiogpv"qp"eqwpugn"hqt"Rnckpvkhh"cpf"hqt"Fghgpfcpv0"" 39 " 3: " 3; " 42 FCVG<""Lwn{"53."423;"" 43 " 44 45 Ceeqtfkpin{."KV"KU"QTFGTGF"vjcv"Lwfiogpv"ujcnn"dg"gpvgtgf"chhktokpi"vjg"fgekukqp"qh" KV" KU" HWTVJGT" QTFGTGF" vjcv" vjg" Engtm" qh" vjg" Eqwtv" ujcnn" ugtxg" eqrkgu" qh" vjku" NGV"LWFIOGPV"DG"GPVGTGF"CEEQTFKPIN[0" " " " " " " aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa"" """"""""MCTGP"N0"UVGXGPUQP"" """" " """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""WPKVGF"UVCVGU"OCIKUVTCVG"LWFIG" 46 47 48 49 4: 38" " "
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
