Heidy E. Collins v. Nancy A. Berryhill, No. 5:2017cv02302 - Document 30 (C.D. Cal. 2019)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER by Magistrate Judge Karen L. Stevenson. IT IS ORDERED that the decision of the Commissioner is REVERSED, and this case is REMANDED for further proceedings consistent with this Memorandum Opinion and Order. (see document for details) (hr)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Heidy E. Collins v. Nancy A. Berryhill Doc. 30 " " 3 " 4 " 5 " 6 " 7 " 8 February 5, 2019 CSI " 9 " : WPKVGF"UVCVGU"FKUVTKEV"EQWTV" EGPVTCN"FKUVTKEV"QH"ECNKHQTPKC" ; " 32 +" PQ0"GFEX"39/4524/MU" " JGKF["E03." +" """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""Rnckpvkhh." """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" +" """"""""""""""""x0" +" OGOQTCPFWO"QRKPKQP"CPF"QTFGT" " +" PCPE["C0"DGTT[JKNN."Cevkpi" +" Eqookuukqpgt"qh"Uqekcn"Ugewtkv{."""" +" Fghgpfcpv0"" +" aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa" +" " " KPVTQFWEVKQP" 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 3: 3; " 42 Jgkf{"E0"*ÐRnckpvkhhÑ+"hkngf"c"Eqornckpv"qp"Pqxgodgt"35."4239."uggmkpi"tgxkgy"qh"vjg" 43 fgpkcn" qh" jgt" crrnkecvkqpu" hqt" c" rgtkqf" qh" fkucdknkv{." fkucdknkv{" kpuwtcpeg" *ÐFKÑ+." cpf" 44 uwrrngogpvcn"ugewtkv{"kpeqog"*ÐUUKÑ+0""Qp"Lcpwct{"39."423:."vjg"rctvkgu"eqpugpvgf."rwtuwcpv" 45 vq"4:"W0U0E0"¸"858*e+."vq"rtqeggf"dghqtg"vjg"wpfgtukipgf"Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu"Ocikuvtcvg"Lwfig0""*Fmv0" 46 Pqu0"33/350+""Qp"Pqxgodgt"49."423:."vjg"rctvkgu"hkngf"c"Lqkpv"Uvkrwncvkqp"*ÐLqkpv"Uvkr0Ñ+0""*Fmv0" 47 Pq0" 480+" " Rnckpvkhh" uggmu" cp" qtfgt" tgxgtukpi" vjg" EqookuukqpgtÓu" fgekukqp" cpf" qtfgtkpi" vjg" 48 rc{ogpv"qh"dgpghkvu"qt."kp"vjg"cnvgtpcvkxg."tgocpfkpi"hqt"hwtvjgt"rtqeggfkpiu0""*Lqkpv"Uvkr0"cv" 49 4: """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" "" Rctvkcnn{"tgfcevgf"kp"eqornkcpeg"ykvj"Hgfgtcn"Twng"qh"Ekxkn"Rtqegfwtg"704*e+*D+"cpf"vjg"tgeqoogpfcvkqp"qh"vjg" Eqookvvgg"qp"Eqwtv"Cfokpkuvtcvkqp"cpf"Ecug"Ocpcigogpv"qh"vjg"Lwfkekcn"Eqphgtgpeg"qh"vjg"Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu0"" 3 3" " " Dockets.Justia.com " " 3 470+""Vjg"Eqookuukqpgt"tgswguvu"vjcv"vjg"CNLÓu"fgekukqp"dg"chhktogf"qt."kp"vjg"cnvgtpcvkxg." 4 tgocpfgf" hqt" hwtvjgt" rtqeggfkpiu0"" *See CT" 480+"" Vjg" Eqwtv" jcu" vcmgp" vjg" ocvvgt" wpfgt" 5 uwdokuukqp"ykvjqwv"qtcn"ctiwogpv0" " 6 UWOOCT["QH"CFOKPKUVTCVKXG"RTQEGGFKPIU" 7 8 " 9 Kp"Lwpg"4235."Rnckpvkhh."yjq"ycu"dqtp"qp"Oc{"3;."3;87."rtqvgevkxgn{"hkngf"crrnkecvkqpu" : hqt"c"rgtkqf"qh"fkucdknkv{."FK."cpf"UUK04""*See Cfokpkuvtcvkxg"Tgeqtf"*ÐCTÑ+"3:5/4360+""Rnckpvkhh" ; cnngigf" fkucdknkv{" eqoogpekpi" Crtkn" 37."422:"fwg" vq<"" hkdtqo{cnikc=" j{rqvj{tqkfkuo=" KDU=" 32 fkcdgvgu="cpf"fgrtguukqp0""*CT"429."4480+""Rnckpvkhh"uwdugswgpvn{"cogpfgf"vjg"cnngigf"qpugv" 33 fcvg"vq"jgt"crrnkecvkqp"fcvg"Î"Lwpg"52."4235"Î"cpf"fkuokuugf"jgt"encko"hqt"c"rgtkqf"qh"fkucdknkv{" 34 cpf"FK0""*CT"650+""Rnckpvkhh"rtgxkqwun{"yqtmgf"cu"c"fgpvcn"cuukuvcpv"*FQV"29;0583/23:+0""*CT" 35 52."45:0+""Chvgt"vjg"Eqookuukqpgt"fgpkgf"RnckpvkhhÓu"crrnkecvkqpu"kpkvkcnn{"*CT":6.":7+"cpf"qp" 36 tgeqpukfgtcvkqp" *CT" 334." 335+." Rnckpvkhh" tgswguvgf" c" jgctkpi" *CT" 354/55+0"" Cfokpkuvtcvkxg" 37 Ncy"Lwfig"Lqcp"Jq"*ÐCNLÑ+"jgnf"c"jgctkpi"qp"Octej"39."42380""*CT"5:0+""Rnckpvkhh."yjq"ycu" 38 tgrtgugpvgf"d{"eqwpugn."vguvkhkgf"dghqtg"vjg"CNL"cu"fkf"xqecvkqpcn"gzrgtv"*ÐXGÑ+"Nwku"Ocu0"" 39 *CT"5:/7:0+""Qp"Lwpg"37."4238."vjg"CNL"kuuwgf"cp"wphcxqtcdng"fgekukqp."fgp{kpi"RnckpvkhhÓu" 3: crrnkecvkqpu0""*CT"43/540+""Qp"Ugrvgodgt"3:."4239."vjg"Crrgcnu"Eqwpekn"fgpkgf"RnckpvkhhÓu" 3; tgswguv"hqt"tgxkgy0""*CT"3/90+" 42 " UWOOCT["QH"CFOKPKUVTCVKXG"FGEKUKQP" 43 44 " 45 Vjg"CNL"hqwpf"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"jcf"pqv"gpicigf"kp"uwduvcpvkcn"ickphwn"cevkxkv{"ukpeg"jgt" 46 Lwpg"52."4235"crrnkecvkqp"fcvg0""*CT"450+""Vjg"CNL"fgvgtokpgf"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"jcf"vjg"hqnnqykpi" 47 ugxgtg" korcktogpvu<"" Ðhkdtqo{cnikc=" fgigpgtcvkxg" fkue" fkugcug" qh" vjg" egtxkecn" urkpg=" oknf" 48 49 4: """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" " Rnckpvkhh"ycu"64"{gctu"qnf"qp"vjg"cnngigf"qpugv"fcvg"cpf"vjwu"ogv"vjg"cigpe{Óu"fghkpkvkqp"qh"c"{qwpigt"kpfkxkfwcn0"" See" 42" E0H0T0" ¸¸" 62603785*e+." 6380;85*e+0" " Rnckpvkhh" jcu" ukpeg" ejcpigf" cig" ecvgiqtkgu" cpf" ku" pqy" c" rgtuqp" enqugn{" crrtqcejkpi"cfxcpegf"cig0""See id."¸¸"62603785*f+."6380;85*f+0""" 4 4" " " " " 3 quvgqctvjtkvku"qh"vjg"dkncvgtcn"mpggu="oknf"fgigpgtcvkxg"fkue"fkugcug"cv"vjg"okf"vjqtceke"urkpg=" 4 cpf" dkncvgtcn" o{qrkc." cuvkiocvkuo." rtgud{qrkc." cpf" oqfgtcvg" pqp/rtqnkhgtcvkxg" fkcdgvke" 5 tgvkpqrcvj{"ykvj"ocewnct"gfgoc0Ñ""*CT"460+""Kp"tgcejkpi"vjku"eqpenwukqp."vjg"CNL"hqwpf"vjcv" 6 Rnckpvkhh"jcf"qvjgt"ogfkecnn{"fgvgtokpcdng"korcktogpvu"dwv"vjg{"ygtg"pqv"Ðugxgtg0Ñ""*CT"460+" 7 Vjg"CNL"eqpenwfgf"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"fkf"pqv"jcxg"cp"korcktogpv"qt"eqodkpcvkqp"qh"korcktogpvu" 8 vjcv" ogv" qt" ogfkecnn{" gswcngf" vjg" ugxgtkv{" qh" cp" korcktogpv" nkuvgf" kp" 42" E0H0T0" rctv" 626." 9 uwdrctv"R."crrgpfkz"3"*42"E0H0T0"¸¸"62603742*f+."62603747."62603748."6380;42*f+."6380;47." : 6380;48+0""*CT"470+""Vjg"CNL"fgvgtokpgf"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"jcf"vjg"tgukfwcn"hwpevkqpcn"ecrcekv{" ; *ÐTHEÑ+"vq"rgthqto"vjg"hqnnqykpi<""" 32 " 33 ]Q_eecukqpcnn{"nkhv"cpf1qt"ectt{"42"rqwpfu="htgswgpvn{"nkhv"cpf1qt"ectt{"32"rqwpfu=" 34 uvcpf"cpf1qt"ycnm"hqt"8"jqwtu"kp"cp":/jqwt"yqtmfc{="ukv"hqt"8"jqwtu"kp"cp":/jqwt" 35 yqtmfc{="qeecukqpcnn{"enkod"tcoru1uvcktu."ncffgtu."tqrgu."qt"uechhqnfu."dcncpeg." 36 uvqqr."mpggn."etqwej."cpf"etcyn="cpf"nkokvgf"vq"yqtm"vjcv"fqgu"pqv"tgswktg"jkijn{" 37 cewvg"xkukqp0" 38 " 39 *CT"480+""" 3: " 3; Vjg"CNL"hqwpf"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"ycu"wpcdng"vq"rgthqto"jgt"rcuv"tgngxcpv"yqtm"cu"c"fgpvcn" 42 cuukuvcpv" *FQV" 29;0583/23:+0" " *CT" 520+" " Jqygxgt." vjg" CNL" cnuq" hqwpf" vjcv." eqpukfgtkpi" 43 RnckpvkhhÓu" cig." gfwecvkqp."yqtm"gzrgtkgpeg." cpf" tgukfwcn" hwpevkqpcn" ecrcekv{." vjgtg"ctg" lqdu" 44 vjcv"gzkuv"kp"ukipkhkecpv"pwodgtu"kp"vjg"pcvkqpcn"geqpqo{"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"ecp"rgthqto."kpenwfkpi" 45 vjg"tgrtgugpvcvkxg"qeewrcvkqpu"qh"vkemgv"vcmgt"*FQV"5660889/232+."ecujkgt"KK"*FQV"4330684/ 46 232+."cpf"ejgemgt"K"*FQV"44408:9/232+0""*CT"530+""Ceeqtfkpin{."vjg"CNL"fgvgtokpgf"vjcv" 47 Rnckpvkhh" jcf" pqv" dggp" wpfgt" c" fkucdknkv{." cu" fghkpgf" kp" vjg" Uqekcn" Ugewtkv{" Cev." htqo" vjg" 48 crrnkecvkqp"fcvg"vjtqwij"vjg"fcvg"qh"vjg"CNLÓu"fgekukqp0""*CT"540+" 49 ^^" 4: ^^" 5" " " " " UVCPFCTF"QH"TGXKGY" 3 4 " 5 Wpfgt"64"W0U0E0"¸"627*i+."vjku"Eqwtv"tgxkgyu"vjg"EqookuukqpgtÓu"fgekukqp"vq"fgvgtokpg" 6 yjgvjgt"kv"ku"htgg"htqo"ngicn"gttqt"cpf"uwrrqtvgf"d{"uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"kp"vjg"tgeqtf"cu"c" 7 yjqng0""Orn v. Astrue."6;7"H05f"847."852"*;vj"Ekt0"4229+0""ÐUwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"ku"Òoqtg"vjcp" 8 c"ogtg"uekpvknnc"dwv"nguu"vjcp"c"rtgrqpfgtcpeg="kv"ku"uwej"tgngxcpv"gxkfgpeg"cu"c"tgcuqpcdng"okpf" 9 okijv"ceegrv"cu"cfgswcvg"vq"uwrrqtv"c"eqpenwukqp0ÓÑ""Gutierrez v. Comm’r of Soc. Sec.."962" : H05f" 73;." 744/45" *;vj" Ekt0" 4236+" *kpvgtpcn" ekvcvkqpu" qokvvgf+0"" ÐGxgp" yjgp" vjg" gxkfgpeg" ku" ; uwuegrvkdng"vq"oqtg"vjcp"qpg"tcvkqpcn"kpvgtrtgvcvkqp."yg"owuv"wrjqnf"vjg"CNLÓu"hkpfkpiu"kh"vjg{" 32 ctg"uwrrqtvgf"d{"kphgtgpegu"tgcuqpcdn{"ftcyp"htqo"vjg"tgeqtf0Ñ""Molina v. Astrue."896"H05f" 33 3326."3332"*;vj"Ekt0"4234+0" 34 " 35 Cnvjqwij"vjku"Eqwtv"ecppqv"uwduvkvwvg"kvu"fkuetgvkqp"hqt"vjg"EqookuukqpgtÓu."vjg"Eqwtv" 36 pqpgvjgnguu"owuv"tgxkgy"vjg"tgeqtf"cu"c"yjqng."Ðygkijkpi"dqvj"vjg"gxkfgpeg"vjcv"uwrrqtvu"cpf" 37 vjg"gxkfgpeg"vjcv"fgvtcevu"htqo"vjg"]EqookuukqpgtÓu_"eqpenwukqp0Ñ""Lingenfelter v. Astrue."726" 38 H05f"324:."3257"*;vj"Ekt0"4229+"*kpvgtpcn"swqvcvkqp"octmu"cpf"ekvcvkqp"qokvvgf+="Desrosiers v. 39 Sec’y of Health and Hum. Servs..":68"H04f"795."798"*;vj"Ekt0"3;::+0""ÐVjg"CNL"ku"tgurqpukdng" 3: hqt" fgvgtokpkpi" etgfkdknkv{." tguqnxkpi" eqphnkevu" kp" ogfkecn" vguvkoqp{." cpf" hqt" tguqnxkpi" 3; codkiwkvkgu0Ñ""Andrews v. Shalala."75"H05f"3257."325;"*;vj"Ekt0"3;;7+0" 42 " 43 Vjg"Eqwtv"yknn"wrjqnf"vjg"EqookuukqpgtÓu"fgekukqp"yjgp"vjg"gxkfgpeg"ku"uwuegrvkdng"vq" 44 oqtg" vjcp" qpg" tcvkqpcn" kpvgtrtgvcvkqp0"" Burch v. Barnhart." 622" H05f" 898." 89;" *;vj" Ekt0" 45 4227+0""Jqygxgt."vjg"Eqwtv"oc{"tgxkgy"qpn{"vjg"tgcuqpu"uvcvgf"d{"vjg"CNL"kp"jku"fgekukqp" 46 Ðcpf"oc{"pqv"chhkto"vjg"CNL"qp"c"itqwpf"wrqp"yjkej"jg"fkf"pqv"tgn{0Ñ""Orn."6;7"H05f"cv"852=" 47 see also Connett v. Barnhart."562"H05f":93.":96"*;vj"Ekt0"4225+0""Vjg"Eqwtv"yknn"pqv"tgxgtug" 48 vjg" EqookuukqpgtÓu" fgekukqp" kh" kv" ku" dcugf" qp" jctonguu" gttqt." yjkej" gzkuvu" kh" vjg" gttqt" ku" 49 ÐÒkpeqpugswgpvkcn"vq"vjg"wnvkocvg"pqpfkucdknkv{"fgvgtokpcvkqp.Ó"qt"kh"fgurkvg"vjg"ngicn"gttqt."Òvjg" 4: 6" " " " " 3 cigpe{Óu"rcvj"oc{"tgcuqpcdn{"dg"fkuegtpgf0ÓÑ""Brown-Hunter v. Colvin.":28"H05f"6:9."6;4" 4 *;vj"Ekt0"4237+"*kpvgtpcn"ekvcvkqpu"qokvvgf+0" " 5 FKUEWUUKQP" 6 7 " Vjgtg"ctg"vyq"kuuwgu"kp"fkurwvg<""*3+"yjgvjgt"vjg"CNL"rtqrgtn{"gxcnwcvgf"vjg"etgfkdknkv{" 8 qh"RnckpvkhhÓu"uvcvgogpvu"cdqwv"vjg"ugxgtkv{"qh"jgt"u{orvqou"cpf"nkokvcvkqpu="cpf"*4+"yjgvjgt" 9 vjg" CNLÓu" cuuguuogpv" qh" RnckpvkhhÓu" tgukfwcn" hwpevkqpcn" ecrcekv{" ku" uwrrqtvgf" d{" uwduvcpvkcn" : gxkfgpeg0""*Lqkpv"Uvkr0"cv"60+" ; " K0" 32 Vjg"CNLÓu"Gxcnwcvkqp"qh"vjg"Etgfkdknkv{"qh"RnckpvkhhÓu"Uvcvgogpvu" 33 " 34 C0" RnckpvkhhÓu"Uvcvgogpvu" 35 36 1. October 10, 2013 Adult Function Report 37 " 38 Qp"Qevqdgt"32."4235."Rnckpvkhh"eqorngvgf"cp"Cfwnv"Hwpevkqp"Tgrqtv"qp"yjkej"ujg"ocfg" 39 vjg"hqnnqykpi"uvcvgogpvu0""*CT"479/860+""Rnckpvkhh"uvcvgf"vjcv"ujg"ecppqv"ukv"qt"uvcpf"hqt"nqpi" 3: rgtkqfu"qh"vkog"fwg"vq"rckp"kp"jgt"cpmngu."mpggu."cpf"jkru0""*CT"4790+""Jgt"ogfkecvkqpu"dtkpi" 3; jgt"rckp"fqyp"htqo"c"ngxgn"32"vq"c"8/90""*CT"4790+""Jqygxgt."jgt"ogfkecvkqpu"ikxg"jgt"fk||{" 42 urgnnu"cpf"kpvgthgtg"ykvj"jgt"eqpegpvtcvkqp0""*CT"4790+""RnckpvkhhÓu"rckp"cnuq"kpvgthgtgu"ykvj"jgt" 43 unggr0""*CT"47:0+""" 44 " 45 Fwtkpi" vjg" eqwtug" qh" c" fc{." Rnckpvkhh" igvu" jgt" 32" {gct" qnf" uqp" qhh" vq" uejqqn." ocmgu" 46 dtgcmhcuv."fqgu"uqog"nkijv"jqwugyqtm."cpf"igvu"itqegtkgu"kh"pggfgf"hqt"fkppgt0""*CT"4790+""Ujg" 47 uvcvgf"vjcv"jgt"42"{gct"qnf"fcwijvgt"uqogvkogu"jgnru"d{"ftkxkpi"vjg"32"{gct"qnf"vq"cpf"htqo" 48 uejqqn"cpf"d{"ocmkpi"fkppgt"yjgp"Rnckpvkhh"ku"pqv"hggnkpi"ygnn0""*CT"47:0+""Rnckpvkhh"ku"cdng"vq" 49 fq"cnn"rgtuqpcn"ectg"cevkxkvkgu."cnvjqwij"uqog"okijv"vcmg"jgt"nqpigt"vjcp"vjg{"fkf"dghqtg0""*CT" 4: 47:0+""Rnckpvkhh"rtgrctgu"ogcnu"fckn{<""uqwru="ucpfykejgu="uqog"htq|gp"fkppgtu="cpf."gxgt{"qpeg" 7" " " " " 3 kp"c"yjkng."c"eqorngvg"fkppgt"ykvj"jgnr"htqo"jgt"cfwnv"fcwijvgt0""*CT"47;0+""Kv"vcmgu"Rnckpvkhh" 4 vyq"vq"vjtgg"jqwtu"vq"rtgrctg"vjgug"ogcnu0""*CT"47;0+""RnckpvkhhÓu"jqwugyqtm"eqpukuvu"qh"fqkpi" 5 vjg"ncwpft{"cpf"fqkpi"uqog"engcpkpi"cpf"eqqmkpi"yjgp"ujg"ku"hggnkpi"ygnn0""*CT"47;0+""Ujg" 6 uvcvgf"vjcv"jgt"fcwijvgt"jgnru"jgt"fq"uqog"fckn{"ejqtgu."kpenwfkpi"ectt{kpi"vjg"ncwpft{"wr"cpf" 7 fqyp"vjg"uvcktu"cpf"eqqmkpi0""*CT"47;0+""Rnckpvkhh"uvcvgf"vjcv"ujg"fqgu"pqv"fq"cp{"{ctf"yqtm" 8 cpf"qpn{"iqgu"qwvukfg"kh"kv"ku"Ðcduqnwvgn{"pgeguuct{.Ñ"i.e.."vq"rkem"wr"jgt"uqp"htqo"uejqqn"qt"vq" 9 iq"ujqrrkpi0""*CT"4820+""Jqygxgt."ujg"cnuq"uvcvgf"vjcv"ujg"fqgu"pqv"iq"ujqrrkpi"cnqpg"dgecwug" : jgt"ogfkecvkqpu"ecwug"jgt"vq"hggn"ftqyu{"cpf"gzrgtkgpeg"fk||{"urgnnu0""*CT"4820+""Rnckpvkhh" ; uvcvgf"vjcv"ujg"vtkgu"pqv"vq"iq"cp{yjgtg"dgecwug"qh"jgt"KDU"cpf"vjg"ogfkecvkqp"ukfg"ghhgevu0"" 32 *CT" 4830+" " Yjgp" ujg" fqgu" iq" ujqrrkpi." Rnckpvkhh" ujqru" hqt" hqqf." enqvjgu" hqt" jgt" uqp." 33 ogfkecvkqpu."cpf"Ðjqwugjqnf"pgeguukvkgu0Ñ""*CT"4820+""Ujg"uvcvgf"vjcv"ujg"iqgu"ujqrrkpi"qpeg" 34 qt"vykeg"c"yggm"hqt"307"jqwtu"cv"c"vkog0""*CT"4820+""Rnckpvkhh"ycvejgu"VX"fckn{0""*CT"4830+"" 35 Rnckpvkhh"kpfkecvgf"vjcv"jgt"eqpfkvkqpu"chhgev"jgt"cdknkv{"vq"nkhv."enkod"uvcktu."uvcpf."mpggn."ycnm." 36 uswcv."ukv."eqpegpvtcvg."tgogodgt."cpf"eqorngvg"vcumu0""*CT"4840+""Ujg"uvcvgf"vjcv"ujg"ecp"ycnm" 37 hqt"qpg"dnqem"dghqtg"pggfkpi"vq"uvqr"cpf"tguv"hqt"c"hgy"okpwvgu0""*CT"4840+""Ujg"uvcvgf"vjcv" 38 ujg"ecp"rc{"cvvgpvkqp"hqt"42/52"okpwvgu"cv"c"vkog"dwv"fqgu"pqv"cnyc{u"hkpkuj"yjcv"ujg"uvctvu" 39 *g0i0."eqpxgtucvkqpu."ejqtgu."tgcfkpi."ycvejkpi"c"oqxkg+0""*CT"4840+""Ujg"uvcvgf"vjcv"yjgp"ujg" 3: ku"wpfgt"uvtguu"ujg"gzrgtkgpegu"cpzkgv{"cvvcemu0""*CT"4850+""Rnckpvkhh"nkuvgf"jgt"ogfkecvkqpu"cu" 3; icdcrgpvkp"*c"pgtxg"rckp"ogfkecvkqp+."ugtvtcnkpg"*cp"cpvkfgrtguucpv+."cpf"rktqzkeco"*cp"cpvk/ 42 kphncoocvqt{"ftwi+0""*CT"4860+" 43 44 2. March 17, 2016 Hearing Testimony 45 " 46 Rnckpvkhh"cnuq"vguvkhkgf"cv"vjg"Octej"39."4238"jgctkpi."crrtqzkocvgn{"vyq"cpf"c"jcnh"{gctu" 47 chvgt"ujg"eqorngvgf"vjg"Cfwnv"Hwpevkqp"Tgrqtv0""*CT"5;0+""Rnckpvkhh"vguvkhkgf"vjcv"ujg"ycu"wpcdng" 48 vq" yqtm" dgecwug" ujg" jcu" eqpuvcpv" owueng" cpf" lqkpv" cejgu." fk||{"urgnnu." cpf" kttkvcdng" dqygn" 49 u{pftqog"*ÐKDUÑ+"vjcv"eqwnf"Ðeqog"qp"cv"cp{"oqogpv0Ñ""*CT"6:0+""Ujg"vguvkhkgf"vjcv"ujg"fkf" 4: pqv"vjkpm"ujg"eqwnf"tgvwtp"vq"yqtmkpi"cu"c"fgpvcn"cuukuvcpv"dgecwug"ujg"yqwnf"dg"wpcdng"vq"dg" 8" " " " " 3 qp"jgt"hggv"hqt"nqpi"rgtkqfu"cpf"vq"ukv"hqt"nqpi"rgtkqfu"fwtkpi"rtqegfwtgu"cpf"dgecwug"qh"jgt" 4 fk||kpguu" cpf" ftqyukpguu" ujg" fkf" pqv" vjkpm" vjcv" ujg" yqwnf" dg" cdng" vq" yqtm" rtqrgtn{" ykvj" 5 rcvkgpvu"cpf"ujctr"kpuvtwogpvu0""*CT"6;0+""Ujg"cnuq"vguvkhkgf"vjcv"ujg"jcu"c"nqv"qh"kuuwgu"ykvj" 6 jgt"xkukqp"cpf"ecppqv"ugg"vjkpiu"enqug"wr."yjkej"ujg"yqwnf"pggf"vq"dg"cdng"vq"fq"vq"yqtm"cu"c" 7 fgpvcn"cuukuvcpv0""*CT"6;0+""Ujg"vguvkhkgf"vjcv"ujg"dgnkgxgf"ujg"eqwnf"dg"qp"jgt"hggv"hqt"oc{dg" 8 32"okpwvgu"cv"c"vkog0""*CT"720+""Ujg"vguvkhkgf"vjcv"ujg"uggu"c"rckp"ocpcigogpv"urgekcnkuv"yjq" 9 ycu"vt{kpi"fkhhgtgpv"ogfkecvkqpu"cpf"jcf"ikxgp"jgt"c"ujqv"kp"jgt"pgem"vjcv"jcf"gcugf"jgt"rckp" : hqt"oc{dg"vjtgg"oqpvju0""*CT"720+"" " ; 32 Rnckpvkhh"vguvkhkgf"vjcv"jgt"cfwnv"fcwijvgt"jgnru"jgt"ycuj"fkujgu."ocmg"fkppgt."cpf"twp" 33 gttcpfu" yjgp" Rnckpvkhh" ku" pqv" hggnkpi" ygnn0" " *CT" 730+" " Ujg" vguvkhkgf" vjcv" fwtkpi" vjg" fc{" ujg" 34 urgpfu"Ðswkvg"c"hgy"jqwtuÑ"n{kpi"fqyp"cpf"unggru"Ðc"nqv0Ñ""*CT"730+""Rnckpvkhh"vguvkhkgf"vjcv"jgt" 35 cpzkgv{"uqogvkogu"ecwugu"jgt"vq"ngcxg"Ðvjg"octmgvÑ"dgecwug"ujg"uwffgpn{"ÐeqwnfpÓv"dg"vjgtg0Ñ"" 36 *CT"760+" " 37 D0" Crrnkecdng"Ncy" 38 " 39 3: Cp"CNL"owuv"ocmg"vyq"hkpfkpiu"dghqtg"fgvgtokpkpi"vjcv"c"enckocpvÓu"rckp"qt"u{orvqo" 3; vguvkoqp{"ku"pqv"etgfkdng0""Treichler v. Comm’r of Soc. Sec.."997"H05f"32;2."3324"*;vj"Ekt0" 42 4236+0""ÐHktuv."vjg"CNL"owuv"fgvgtokpg"yjgvjgt"vjg"enckocpv"jcu"rtgugpvgf"qdlgevkxg"ogfkecn" 43 gxkfgpeg"qh"cp"wpfgtn{kpi"korcktogpv"yjkej"eqwnf"tgcuqpcdn{"dg"gzrgevgf"vq"rtqfweg"vjg"rckp" 44 qt"qvjgt"u{orvqou"cnngigf0Ñ""Id."*swqvkpi"Lingenfelter."726"H05f"cv"3258+0""ÐUgeqpf."kh"vjg" 45 enckocpv" jcu" rtqfwegf" vjcv" gxkfgpeg." cpf" vjg" CNL" jcu" pqv" fgvgtokpgf" vjcv" vjg" enckocpv" ku" 46 ocnkpigtkpi." vjg" CNL" owuv" rtqxkfg" urgekhke." engct" cpf" eqpxkpekpi" tgcuqpu" hqt" tglgevkpi" vjg" 47 enckocpvÓu"vguvkoqp{"tgictfkpi"vjg"ugxgtkv{"qh"vjg"enckocpvÓu"u{orvqouÑ"cpf"vjqug"tgcuqpu" 48 owuv"dg"uwrrqtvgf"d{"uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"kp"vjg"tgeqtf0""Id.="see also"Marsh v. Colvin."9;4" 49 H05f"3392."3396"p04"*;vj"Ekt0"4237+="Carmickle v. Comm’r of Soc. Sec.."755"H05f"3377."3383" 4: 9" " " " " 3 *;vj"Ekt0"422:+"*eqwtv"owuv"fgvgtokpg"Ðyjgvjgt"vjg"CNLÓu"cfxgtug"etgfkdknkv{"hkpfkpi"0"0"0"ku" 4 uwrrqtvgf"d{"uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"wpfgt"vjg"engct"cpf"eqpxkpekpi"uvcpfctfÑ+.""" 5 " 6 Kp"ygkijkpi"c"rnckpvkhhÓu"etgfkdknkv{."vjg"CNL"oc{"eqpukfgt"ocp{"hcevqtu."kpenwfkpi<""Ð*3+" 7 qtfkpct{"vgejpkswgu"qh"etgfkdknkv{"gxcnwcvkqp."uwej"cu"vjg"enckocpvÓu"tgrwvcvkqp"hqt"n{kpi."rtkqt" 8 kpeqpukuvgpv"uvcvgogpvu"eqpegtpkpi"vjg"u{orvqou."cpf"qvjgt"vguvkoqp{"0"0"0"vjcv"crrgctu"nguu" 9 vjcp"ecpfkf="*4+"wpgzrnckpgf"qt"kpcfgswcvgn{"gzrnckpgf"hcknwtg"vq"uggm"vtgcvogpv"qt"vq"hqnnqy" : c"rtguetkdgf"eqwtug"qh"vtgcvogpv="cpf"*5+"vjg"enckocpvÓu"fckn{"cevkxkvkgu0Ñ""Tommasetti v. Astrue." ; 755"H05f"3257."325;"*;vj"Ekt0"422:+0""Jqygxgt."Ðuwdlgevkxg"rckp"vguvkoqp{"ecppqv"dg"tglgevgf" 32 qp"vjg"sole"itqwpf"vjcv"kv"ku"pqv"hwnn{"eqttqdqtcvgf"d{"qdlgevkxg"ogfkecn"gxkfgpeg0Ñ""Rollins v. 33 Massanari."483"H05f":75.":79"*;vj"Ekt0"4223+"*gorjcuku"cffgf+"*ekvcvkqp"qokvvgf+0" " 34 35 E0" CNLÓu"Cuuguuogpv"Cpf"Cpcn{uku" 36 " 37 Vjg"CNL"hqwpf"vjcv"RnckpvkhhÓu"ogfkecnn{"fgvgtokpcdng"korcktogpvu"eqwnf"tgcuqpcdn{"dg" 38 gzrgevgf" vq" ecwug" vjg" cnngigf" u{orvqou." dwv" RnckpvkhhÓu" uvcvgogpvu" cdqwv" vjg" kpvgpukv{." 39 rgtukuvgpeg." cpf" nkokvkpi" ghhgevu" qh" vjqug" u{orvqou" ygtg" pqv" eqpukuvgpv" ykvj" vjg" ogfkecn" 3: gxkfgpeg"cpf"qvjgt"gxkfgpeg"qh"tgeqtf0""*CT"4;0+""Hktuv."vjg"CNL"uvcvgf"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"jcu"pqv" 3; igpgtcnn{" tgegkxgf" vjg" v{rg" qh" ogfkecn" vtgcvogpv" qpg" yqwnf" gzrgev" hqt" c" vqvcnn{" fkucdngf" 42 kpfkxkfwcn"dgecwug<""vjgtg"ygtg"ukipkhkecpv"icru"kp"RnckpvkhhÓu"jkuvqt{"qh"vtgcvogpv="Rnckpvkhh" 43 ocfg"tgncvkxgn{"kphtgswgpv"vtkru"vq"vjg"fqevqt"hqt"cnngigfn{"fkucdnkpi"u{orvqou="cpf"RnckpvkhhÓu" 44 Ðwug"qh"ogfkecvkqpu"fqgu"pqv"uwiiguv"vjg"rtgugpeg"qh"korcktogpvu"yjkej"ku"oqtg"nkokvkpi"vjcp" 45 hqwpf"kp"]vjg"CNLÓu_"fgekukqp0Ñ""*CT"4;0+""Ugeqpf."vjg"CNL"uvcvgf"vjcv"RnckpvkhhÓu"cevkxkvkgu"qh" 46 fckn{" nkxkpi" ygtg" Ðuqogyjcv" pqtocnÑ" cpf" tgswktgf" uqog" qh" vjg" ucog" rj{ukecn" cpf" ogpvcn" 47 cdknkvkgu"cpf"uqekcn"kpvgtcevkqpu"cu"vjqug"pgeguuct{"hqt"qdvckpkpi"cpf"ockpvckpkpi"gornq{ogpv0"" 48 *CT" 4;0+" " Urgekhkecnn{." vjg" CNL" ekvgf" RnckpvkhhÓu" cdknkv{" vq" rgthqto" rgtuqpcn" ectg" cevkxkvkgu." 49 ejknfectg." jqwugyqtm." rtgrctkpi" ogcnu." ncwpft{." engcpkpi." eqqmkpi." rc{kpi" dknnu." ycvejkpi" 4: oqxkgu"cpf"vgngxkukqp."ftkxkpi."ujqrrkpi."cpf"urgpfkpi"vkog"ykvj"qvjgtu0""*CT"4;0+" :" " " " " 3 1. Plaintiff’s Medical Treatment 4 " 5 Vjg"CNLÓu"hktuv"tgcuqp"hqt"hkpfkpi"Rnckpvkhh"nguu"vjcp"hwnn{"etgfkdng"Î"vjg"v{rg"qh"ogfkecn" 6 vtgcvogpv"ujg"jcu"tgegkxgf"Î"ku"pqv"engct."eqpxkpekpi."cpf"uwrrqtvgf"d{"uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"kp" 7 vjg"tgeqtf0""Vjg"CNL"uvcvgu"vjcv"vjgtg"ctg"Ðukipkhkecpv"icruÑ"kp"RnckpvkhhÓu"jkuvqt{"qh"vtgcvogpv0"" 8 *CT" 4;0+" " Vjg" CNL" fqgu" pqv" kfgpvkh{" cp{" ukipkhkecpv" icru." cpf" vjg" EqwtvÓu" tgxkgy" qh" vjg" 9 cfokpkuvtcvkxg"tgeqtf"fqgu"pqv"tgxgcn"Ðukipkhkecpv"icru0Ñ""Vjg"ogfkecn"tgeqtf"ujqyu"vjcv."kp" : vjg" {gctu" dgvyggp" RnckpvkhhÓu" Lwpg" 52." 4235" crrnkecvkqp" fcvg" cpf" Octej" 39." 4238" jgctkpi." ; Rnckpvkhh"uwhhgtgf"htqo"ownvkrng"eqpfkvkqpu"pgeguukvcvkpi"xkukvu"vq"c"o{tkcf"qh"fkhhgtgpv"ectg" 32 rtqxkfgtu."kpenwfkpi"tjgwocvqnqikuvu."gpfqetkpqnqikuvu."ru{ejkcvtkuvu."vjgtcrkuvu."kpvgtpkuvu."cpf" 33 icuvtqgpvgtqnqikuvu."tguwnvkpi"kp"oqtg"vjcp"52"ogfkecn"crrqkpvogpvu"kp"nguu"vjcp"vjtgg"{gctu0"" 34 Vjg" nqpiguv" icr" dgvyggp" ogfkecn" crrqkpvogpvu" ycu" crrtqzkocvgn{" 8" oqpvju" dgvyggp" 35 RnckpvkhhÓu"Qevqdgt"45."4235"hqnnqy"wr"crrqkpvogpv"ykvj"Ft0"Dcdcm"¥coktk."c"tjgwocvqnqikuv." 36 cpf"jgt"Crtkn"4;."4236"hqnnqy"wr"crrqkpvogpv"ykvj"vjg"Yguv"Icuvtqgpvgtqnqi{"Itqwr0""Vq"vjg" 37 gzvgpv" vjcv" vjku" ukz" oqpvj" icr" ecp" dg" ejctcevgtk|gf" cu" Ðukipkhkecpv.Ñ" kv" ku" pqv" c" eqpxkpekpi" 38 tgcuqp" hqt" hkpfkpi" Rnckpvkhh" nguu" vjcp" hwnn{" etgfkdng0" " Dghqtg" RnckpvkhhÓu" Qevqdgt" 45." 4235" 39 crrqkpvogpv"ykvj"Ft0"¥coktk."ujg"jcf"cntgcf{"tgegkxgf"fkcipqugu"hqt"hkdtqo{cnikc"cpf"ctvjtkvku" 3: *see CT"629+"cpf"hqt"ownvkrng"icuvtqgpvgtqnqikecn"eqpfkvkqpu"*see CT"765"*tguwnvu"qh"Cwiwuv" 3; 37."4235"xkfgq"ecruwng"gpvgtqueqr{"tgrqtv"ujqykpi"fgnc{gf"icuvtke"gorv{kpi"uwiiguvkxg"qh" 42 icuvtqrctguku" cpf" Ðgzvtgogn{" eqpiguvgfÑ" icuvtke" owequc" cuuqekcvgf" ykvj" jgoqttjcike" 43 icuvtkvku++0""Vjgtg"ku"pq"kpfkecvkqp"vjcv"RnckpvkhhÓu"rj{ukekcpu"cfxkugf"jgt"vq"wpfgtiq"cffkvkqpcn" 44 vguvu"qt"vtgcvogpv"fwtkpi"vjg"ukz"oqpvj"rgtkqf"kp"swguvkqp."cpf."rgtjcru"oqtg"ukipkhkecpvn{." 45 vjgtg"ku"pq"kpfkecvkqp"vjcv"jgt"eqpfkvkqp"yqwnf"jcxg"kortqxgf"jcf"ujg"ocfg"cffkvkqpcn"ogfkecn" 46 crrqkpvogpvu"fwtkpi"vjcv"vkog0""Cffkvkqpcnn{."Rnckpvkhh"fkf"cvvgpf"c"ru{ejkcvtke"gxcnwcvkqp"cv" 47 vjg"tgswguv"qh"vjg"Eqookuukqpgt"fwtkpi"vjg"ukz"oqpvj"rgtkqf"*see CT"657"*31;14236++"cpf"ujg" 48 eqpvkpwgf"vq"hqnnqy"jgt"vtgcvogpv"tgikogp"d{"vcmkpi"jgt"rtguetkdgf"ogfkecvkqpu."yjkej."cv"vjcv" 49 vkog." kpenwfgf<" " icdcrgpvkp" *Pgwtqpvkp+." c" pgtxg" rckp" ogfkecvkqp=" ugtvtcnkpg" *¥qnqhv+." hqt" 4: fgrtguukqp"cpf"cpzkgv{="ecpcinkhnq|kp"*Kpxqmcpc+."hqt"fkcdgvgu="cpf"ngxqvj{tqzkpg"*Ngxqz{n+." ;" " " " " 3 hqt" j{rqvj{tqkfkuo0" " *CT" 66:0+" " Kp" uwo." ikxgp" vjg" pcvwtg" qh" RnckpvkhhÓu" eqpfkvkqpu" cpf" jgt" 4 rtguetkdgf"vtgcvogpv"rncpu."vjg"ukz"oqpvj"icr"dgvyggp"RnckpvkhhÓu"tjgwocvqnqi{"crrqkpvogpv" 5 ykvj"Ft0"¥coktk"kp"Qevqdgt"4235"cpf"jgt"icuvtqgpvgtqnqi{"crrqkpvogpv"kp"Crtkn"4236"ycu"pqv" 6 c"eqpxkpekpi"tgcuqp"hqt"hkpfkpi"RnckpvkhhÓu"uvcvgogpvu"nguu"vjcp"hwnn{"etgfkdng0" 7 " 8 Ukoknctn{." vjg" Eqwtv" ku" pqv" rgtuwcfgf" vjcv" RnckpvkhhÓu" eqornckpvu" ygtg" pqv" etgfkdng" 9 dgecwug"ujg"ocfg"Ðtgncvkxgn{"kphtgswgpv"vtkru"vq"vjg"fqevqt"hqt"cnngigfn{"fkucdnkpi"u{orvqou0Ñ"" : *See"CT"4;0+""Cu"uvcvgf"cdqxg."Rnckpvkhh"cvvgpfgf"oqtg"vjcp"52"ogfkecn"crrqkpvogpvu"kp"nguu" ; vjcp"5"{gctu."ucy"c"ykfg"tcpig"qh"urgekcnkuvu."cpf"uqogvkogu"ucy"ownvkrng"ectg"rtqxkfgtu"kp"c" 32 ukping"oqpvj0""*See, e.g., CT"6:4/:5"*3413214237"gpfqetkpqnqi{"crrqkpvogpv+."6:3"*341614237" 33 ru{ejkcvtke" crrqkpvogpv+=" CT" 69:" *915314237" ru{ejkcvtke" crrqkpvogpv+." ;77" *crrqkpvogpv" 34 ykvj"hcokn{"vjgtcrkuv+."842"*91514237"gogtigpe{"tqqo"cfokuukqp"hqt"ngukqp"qp"hqqv"tgncvgf"vq" 35 fkcdgvgu++=" CT" ;79" *813514237" crrqkpvogpv" ykvj" hcokn{" vjgtcrkuv+." 748" *icuvtqgpvgtqnqi{" 36 crrqkpvogpv+."676/79"*81:14237"rtg/qrgtcvkxg"crrqkpvogpv"ykvj"kpvgtpkuv"kp"cfxcpeg"qh"ectrcn" 37 vwppgn"tgngcug"uwtigt{+0+""Ceeqtfkpin{."uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"kp"vjg"tgeqtf"fqgu"pqv"uwrrqtv"vjg" 38 CNLÓu"hkpfkpi"vjcv"RnckpvkhhÓu"vtkru"vq"vjg"fqevqt"ygtg"Ðtgncvkxgn{"kphtgswgpv0Ñ""Oqtgqxgt."vjgtg" 39 ku" pq" kpfkecvkqp" vjcv" RnckpvkhhÓu" fqevqtu" ygtg" wtikpi" jgt" vq" uejgfwng" oqtg" htgswgpv" 3: crrqkpvogpvu"qt"jcf"gxgt"uwiiguvgf"vjcv"ujg"yqwnf"dgpghkv"htqo"oqtg"htgswgpv"crrqkpvogpvu0"" 3; Vq"vjg"eqpvtct{."RnckpvkhhÓu"tjgwocvqnqikuv."Ft0"¥coktk."igpgtcnn{"cumgf"Rnckpvkhh"vq"uejgfwng" 42 hqnnqy"wr"xkukvu"gxgt{"hkxg"vq"ukz"oqpvju0""*See, e.g., CT"5;;."624."6280+""Vjwu."vjg"htgswgpe{" 43 qh" RnckpvkhhÓu" ogfkecn" crrqkpvogpvu" ctg" pqv" c" eqpxkpekpi" tgcuqp" hqt" hkpfkpi" RnckpvkhhÓu" 44 uvcvgogpvu"nguu"vjcp"hwnn{"etgfkdng0" 45 " 46 Vjg"CNL"cnuq"ekvgf"RnckpvkhhÓu"Ðwug"qh"ogfkecvkqpuÑ"cu"dgkpi"kpeqpukuvgpv"ykvj"nkokvcvkqpu" 47 itgcvgt"vjcp"vjqug"hqwpf"d{"vjg"CNL0""*CT"4;0+""Kv"ku"wpengct"yjcv"curgev"qh"RnckpvkhhÓu"gzvgpukxg" 48 ogfkecvkqp" wug" ycu" kpeqpukuvgpv" ykvj" RnckpvkhhÓu" uvcvgogpvu" cdqwv" jgt" u{orvqou" cpf" 49 nkokvcvkqpu0"""Cv"vkogu."Rnckpvkhh"ycu"vcmkpi"vgp"qt"oqtg"fkhhgtgpv"rtguetkrvkqp"ogfkecvkqpu"fckn{." 4: kpenwfkpi" icdcrgpvkp." Pqteq" *c" jkijn{" cffkevkxg" pcteqvke+." cnrtc|qnco" *Zcpcz+." ugtvtcnkpg" 32" " " " " 3 *¥qnqhv+." dcenqhgp" *c" owueng" tgnczcpv+." fkenqhgpce" *cpvk/kphncoocvqt{" ftwi+." rktqzkeco" *c" 4 ugeqpf" cpvk/kphncoocvqt{+." Kpxqmcpc." ngxqvj{tqzkpg." ogvhqtokp" *c" ugeqpf" cpvk/fkcdgvke" 5 ogfkecvkqp+."cpf"rcpvqrtc|qng"*c"rtqvqp"rwor"kpjkdkvgt"hqt"icuvtqguqrjcigcn"tghnwz"fkugcug+0"" 6 *See, e.g., CT" 6:4" *nkuv" qh" ewttgpv" ogfkecvkqpu" cu" qh" 3413214237+." 6:8" *nkuv" qh" ewttgpv" 7 ogfkecvkqpu" cu" qh" :14814237+0+" " RnckpvkhhÓu" pggf" hqt" vjku" ocp{"fckn{" ogfkecvkqpu." kpenwfkpi" 8 vjtgg"fkhhgtgpv"rckp"tgnkgxgtu."c"pgtxg"rckp"ogfkecvkqp."c"owueng"tgnczcpv."cpf"dqvj"Zcpcz"cpf" 9 ¥qnqhv."yqwnf"uggo"vq"uwrrqtv."tcvjgt"vjcp"wpfgtokpg."jgt"cnngicvkqpu"qh"fkucdnkpi"nkokvcvkqpu0"" : Ceeqtfkpin{." vjg" CNLÓu" fgvgtokpcvkqp" vjcv" Rnckpvkhh" jcf" pqv" Ðtgegkxgf" vjg" v{rg" qh" ogfkecn" ; vtgcvogpv" qpg" yqwnf" gzrgev" hqt" c" vqvcnn{" fkucdngf" kpfkxkfwcnÑ" ku" pqv" c" eqpxkpekpi" tgcuqp" 32 uwrrqtvgf"d{"uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"hqt"hkpfkpi"RnckpvkhhÓu"uvcvgogpvu"cdqwv"jgt"u{orvqou"cpf" 33 nkokvcvkqp"nguu"vjcp"hwnn{"etgfkdng0" " 34 35 2. Plaintiff’s Activities of Daily Living 36 " 37 Vjg"CNLÓu"ugeqpf"tgcuqp"hqt"hkpfkpi"RnckpvkhhÓu"uvcvgogpvu"nguu"vjcp"hwnn{"etgfkdng"ku"vjcv" 38 Rnckpvkhh"rgthqtogf"cevkxkvkgu"qh"fckn{"nkxkpi"vjcv"ygtg"Ðuqogyjcv"pqtocnÑ"cpf"tgswktgf"uqog" 39 qh" vjg" ucog" rj{ukecn" cpf" ogpvcn" cdknkvkgu" cpf" uqekcn" kpvgtcevkqpu" cu" vjqug" pgeguuct{" hqt" 3: qdvckpkpi" cpf" ockpvckpkpi" gornq{ogpv0" " *CT" 4;0+" " Urgekhkecnn{." vjg" CNL" ekvgf" RnckpvkhhÓu" 3; cdknkv{" vq" rgthqto" rgtuqpcn" ectg" cevkxkvkgu." ejknfectg." jqwugyqtm." rtgrctkpi" ogcnu." ncwpft{." 42 engcpkpi." eqqmkpi." rc{kpi" dknnu." ycvejkpi" oqxkgu" cpf" vgngxkukqp." ftkxkpi." ujqrrkpi." cpf" 43 urgpfkpi"vkog"ykvj"qvjgtu0""*CT"4;0+" 44 " 45 Cp" CNL" oc{" tgn{" qp" c" rnckpvkhhÓu" fckn{" cevkxkvkgu" vq" uwrrqtv" cp" cfxgtug" etgfkdknkv{" 46 fgvgtokpcvkqp"qpn{"yjgp"vjqug"cevkxkvkgu"gkvjgt<""Ðeqpvtcfkev"]vjg"rnckpvkhhÓu_"qvjgt"vguvkoqp{Ñ=" 47 qt"Ðoggv"vjg"vjtgujqnf"hqt"vtcpuhgtcdng"yqtm"umknnuÑ"Î"vjcv"ku."yjgtg"vjg"rnckpvkhh"Ðku"cdng"vq" 48 urgpf"c"uwduvcpvkcn"rctv"qh"jku"qt"jgt"fc{"rgthqtokpi"jqwugjqnf"ejqtgu"qt"qvjgt"cevkxkvkgu"vjcv" 49 ctg"vtcpuhgtcdng"vq"c"yqtm"ugvvkpi0Ñ""Orn."6;7"H05f"cv"85;="Smolen v. Chater.":2"H05f"3495." 4: 34:6"p0"9"*;vj"Ekt0"3;;8+0""Vjg"CNL"fqgu"pqv"kpfkecvg"vjcv"RnckpvkhhÓu"cevkxkvkgu"qh"fckn{"nkxkpi" 33" " " " " 3 eqpvtcfkev" jgt" vguvkoqp{." qpn{" vjcv" Ðuqog" qh" vjg" rj{ukecn" cpf" ogpvcn" cdknkvkgu" cpf" uqekcn" 4 kpvgtcevkqpu"tgswktgf"kp"qtfgt"vq"rgthqto"vjgug"cevkxkvkgu"ctg"vjg"ucog"cu"vjqug"pgeguuct{"hqt" 5 qdvckpkpi"cpf"ockpvckpkpi"gornq{ogpv0Ñ""*CT"4;0+""Vjku"ku"pqv"vjg"uvcpfctf0""Vjg"CNL"fkf"pqv" 6 hkpf"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"Ðku"cdng"vq"urgpf"c"uwduvcpvkcn"rqtvkqp"qh"]jgt_"fc{"rgthqtokpi"0"0"0"cevkxkvkgu" 7 vjcv"ctg"vtcpuhgtcdng"vq"c"yqtm"ugvvkpi0Ñ""See Orn."6;7"H05f"cv"85;0""Pqt"eqwnf"ujg0""Rnckpvkhh" 8 kpfkecvgu"vjcv."fwtkpi"cp"cxgtcig"fc{."ujg"ftkxgu"jgt"uqp"vq"cpf"htqo"uejqqn."rtgrctgu"dtgcmhcuv." 9 nwpej."cpf"fkppgt"Î"wuwcnn{"uqwru."ucpfykejgu."qt"htq|gp"ogcnu"Î"cpf"fqgu"vjg"ncwpft{"cpf" : uqog"engcpkpi0""*CT"479/7;0+""Jqygxgt."ujg"cnuq"kpfkecvgu"vjcv"ujg"tgegkxgu"jgnr"htqo"jgt" ; cfwnv"fcwijvgt"kp"ceeqornkujkpi"vjgug"vcumu0""*See id.+""Kp"rctvkewnct."Rnckpvkhh"tgrqtvu"vjcv."yjgp" 32 ujg"ku"pqv"hggnkpi"ygnn."jgt"fcwijvgt"fqgu"xktvwcnn{"cnn"qh"vjgug"vcumu<""ftkxkpi"RnckpvkhhÓu"uqp"vq" 33 cpf"htqo"uejqqn="twppkpi"gttcpfu="ocmkpi"fkppgt="ycujkpi"fkujgu="ectt{kpi"ncwpft{"cpf"wr" 34 cpf"fqyp"vjg"uvcktu="cpf"fqkpi"uqog"engcpkpi0""*CT"73."479/7;0+""Ukoknctn{."Rnckpvkhh"kpfkecvgu" 35 vjcv"ujg"ujqru"hqt"itqegtkgu."enqvjgu"hqt"jgt"uqp."cpf"ogfkecvkqpu"qpeg"qt"vykeg"c"yggm"hqt"307" 36 jqwtu" cv" c" vkog." dwv" ujg" fqgu" pqv" iq" ujqrrkpi" cnqpg" dgecwug" qh" vjg" ukfg" ghhgevu" qh" jgt" 37 ogfkecvkqpu0""*CT"4820+""Rnckpvkhh"cnuq"vguvkhkgf"vjcv"fwtkpi"vjg"fc{"ujg"urgpfu"Ðswkvg"c"hgy" 38 jqwtuÑ"n{kpi"fqyp"cpf"unggru"Ðc"nqv0Ñ""*CT"730+""Ikxgp"RnckpvkhhÓu"tgrqtvgf"pggf"hqt"dqvj"jgnr" 39 cpf" tguv." vjg" tgeqtf" dghqtg" vjg" Eqwtv" fqgu" pqv" uwrrqtv" c" hkpfkpi" vjcv" Rnckpvkhh" urgpfu" c" 3: uwduvcpvkcn"rqtvkqp"qh"jgt"fc{"rgthqtokpi"cevkxkvkgu"vjcv"ctg"vtcpuhgtcdng"vq"c"yqtm"ugvvkpi0" 3; " 42 Hwtvjgtoqtg."vjg"Pkpvj"Ektewkv"jcu"tgrgcvgfn{"gorjcuk|gf"vjcv"ÐCNLu"owuv"dg"gurgekcnn{" 43 ecwvkqwu"kp"eqpenwfkpi"vjcv"fckn{"cevkxkvkgu"ctg"kpeqpukuvgpv"ykvj"vguvkoqp{"cdqwv"rckp."dgecwug" 44 korcktogpvu"vjcv"yqwnf"wpswguvkqpcdn{"rtgenwfg"yqtm"cpf"cnn"vjg"rtguuwtgu"qh"c"yqtmrnceg" 45 gpxktqpogpv" yknn" qhvgp" dg" eqpukuvgpv" ykvj" fqkpi" oqtg" vjcp" ogtgn{" tguvkpi" kp" dgf" cnn" fc{0Ñ"" 46 Garrison v. Colvin."97;"H05f";;7."3238"*;vj"Ekt0"4236+0""Kp"Smolen."hqt"gzcorng."vjg"Pkpvj" 47 Ektewkv" rqkpvgf" qwv" vjcv" Ðocp{" jqog" cevkxkvkgu" oc{" pqv" dg" gcukn{" vtcpuhgtcdng" vq" c" yqtm" 48 gpxktqpogpv"yjgtg"kv"okijv"dg"korquukdng"vq"tguv"rgtkqfkecnn{"qt"vcmg"ogfkecvkqp0Ñ" Smolen." 49 :2" H05f" cv" 34:9" p0" 9=" see also Fair v. Bowen." ::7" H04f" 7;9." 825" *;vj" Ekt0" 3;:;+" *ucog+0"" 4: Ukoknctn{." kp" Reddick." vjg" Pkpvj" Ektewkv" uvcvgf" vjcv" Ðfkucdknkv{" enckocpvu" ujqwnf" pqv" dg" 34" " " " " 3 rgpcnk|gf"hqt"cvvgorvkpi"vq"ngcf"pqtocn"nkxgu"kp"vjg"hceg"qh"vjgkt"nkokvcvkqpu0Ñ""379"H05f"cv"9440"" 4 Hwtvjgt."kp"Garrison."vjg"Pkpvj"Ektewkv"swqvgf"ykvj"crrtqxcn"vjg"Ugxgpvj"EktewkvÓu"cfoqpkvkqp" 5 vjcv<""" 6 " 7 ]v_jg" etkvkecn" fkhhgtgpegu" dgvyggp" cevkxkvkgu" qh" fckn{" nkxkpi" cpf" cevkxkvkgu" kp" c" 8 hwnn/vkog"lqd"ctg"vjcv"c"rgtuqp"jcu"oqtg"hngzkdknkv{"kp"uejgfwnkpi"vjg"hqtogt"vjcp" 9 vjg"ncvvgt."ecp"igv"jgnr"htqo"qvjgt"rgtuqpu"0"0"0."cpf"ku"pqv"jgnf"vq"c"okpkowo" : uvcpfctf" qh" rgthqtocpeg." cu" ujg" yqwnf" dg" d{" cp" gornq{gt0" " Vjg" hcknwtg" vq" ; tgeqipk|g"vjgug"fkhhgtgpegu"ku"c"tgewttgpv."cpf"fgrnqtcdng"hgcvwtg"qh"qrkpkqpu"d{" 32 cfokpkuvtcvkxg"ncy"lwfigu"kp"uqekcn"ugewtkv{"fkucdknkv{"ecugu0" 33 " 34 Garrison."97;"H05f"cv"3238"*swqvkpi"Bjornson v. Astrue."893"H05f"862."869"*9vj"Ekt0"4234++0" 35 " 36 Kp" nkijv" qh" vjg" hqtgiqkpi." vjg" Eqwtv" tglgevu" vjg" EqookuukqpgtÓu" cvvgorv" vq" fkuetgfkv" 37 RnckpvkhhÓu"uvcvgogpvu"uqngn{"dgecwug"Rnckpvkhh."c"ukping"oqo"qh"c"vjgp"rtg/vggp"dq{."jcf"pqv" 38 nquv"cnn"oqvkxcvkqp"cpf"rj{ukecn"ecrcekv{"hqt"dgkpi"c"oqvjgt"vq"jgt"uqp"cpf."kpuvgcf."rgtukuvgf." 39 vq" vjg" dguv" qh" jgt" cdknkv{." kp" rtqxkfkpi" hqqf." enqvjkpi." vtcpurqtvcvkqp" vq" uejqqn." cpf" c" engcp" 3: jqog"hqt"jgt"ejknf0""Vjwu."vjg"CNL"hckngf"vq"rtqxkfg"c"engct"cpf"eqpxkpekpi"tgcuqp"uwrrqtvgf" 3; d{"uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"hqt"hkpfkpi"RnckpvkhhÓu"uvcvgogpvu"cdqwv"jgt"u{orvqou"cpf"nkokvcvkqpu" 42 nguu"vjcp"hwnn{"etgfkdng0""Tgocpf"qp"vjku"kuuwg"ku"ycttcpvgf0" " 43 KK0" 44 Vjg"CNLÓu"Cuuguuogpv"qh"RnckpvkhhÓu"Tgukfwcn"Hwpevkqpcn"Ecrcekv{" " 45 46 Vjg" ugeqpf" kuuwg" kp" fkurwvg" ku" yjgvjgt" vjg" CNLÓu" cuuguuogpv" qh" RnckpvkhhÓu" tgukfwcn" 47 hwpevkqpcn" ecrcekv{" ku" uwrrqtvgf" d{" uwduvcpvkcn" gxkfgpeg0" " *CT" 60+" " Urgekhkecnn{." Rnckpvkhh" 48 eqpvgpfu"vjcv"vjg"CNL"gttgf"d{"hcknkpi"vq"qtfgt"c"eqpuwnvcvkxg"gzcokpcvkqp0""*See"Lqkpv"Uvkr0"cv" 49 3;/420+" " Rnckpvkhh" rqkpvu" qwv" vjcv." kp" vjg" cdugpeg" qh" c" rj{ukecn" THE" cuuguuogpv" htqo" cp" 4: gzcokpkpi"rj{ukekcp."vjg"CNL"tgnkgf"qp"vjg"4235"cpf"4236"qrkpkqpu"qh"vjg"tgxkgykpi"Uvcvg" 35" " " " " 3 cigpe{" ogfkecn" eqpuwnvcpvu." Ft0" Ejcp." cp" kpvgtpkuv." cpf" Ft0" Dcnnctf." c" hcokn{" qt" igpgtcn" 4 rtcevkvkqpgt."yjkej"ygtg"oqtg"vjcp"vyq"{gctu"qnf"cv"vjg"vkog"qh"vjg"CNLÓu"fgekukqp0""*Lqkpv" 5 Uvkr0"cv"52="see also CT"52.":6."3350+""Urgekhkecnn{."vjg"CNL"uvcvgf"vjcv"Ftu0"Dcnnctf"cpf"Ejcp" 6 Ðhqwpf"vjcv"]Rnckpvkhh_"ecp"qeecukqpcnn{"nkhv"cpf1qt"ectt{"42"rqwpfu="htgswgpvn{"nkhv"cpf1qt"ectt{" 7 32"rqwpfu="uvcpf"cpf1qt"ycnm"hqt"8"jqwtu"kp"cp":/jqwt"yqtmfc{="cpf"ukv"hqt"8"jqwtu"kp"cp":/ 8 jqwt" yqtmfc{0Ñ" " *CT" 520+" " " Vjg" CNL" cfqrvgf" vjg" cuuguuogpv" qh" Ftu0" Dcnnctf" cpf" Ejcp0"" 9 *Compare"CT"48"with"CT"8:.";70+" : " ; Ð]V_jg"Eqookuukqpgt"jcu"dtqcf"ncvkvwfg"kp"qtfgtkpi"c"eqpuwnvcvkxg"gzcokpcvkqp0Ñ""Reed 32 v. Massanari." 492" H05f" :5:." :64" *;vj" Ekt0" 4223+" *kpvgtpcn" swqvcvkqp" octmu" cpf" ekvcvkqp" 33 qokvvgf+0""Jqygxgt."uqog"ecugu"Ðpqtocnn{"tgswktg"c"eqpuwnvcvkxg"gzcokpcvkqp."kpenwfkpi"vjqug" 34 kp"yjkej"cffkvkqpcn"gxkfgpeg"pggfgf"ku"pqv"eqpvckpgf"kp"vjg"tgeqtfu"qh"vjg"enckocpvÓu"ogfkecn" 35 uqwtegu" cpf" vjqug" kpxqnxkpi" cp" codkiwkv{" qt" kpuwhhkekgpe{" kp" vjg" gxkfgpeg" vjcv" owuv" dg" 36 tguqnxgf0Ñ" "Id." *kpvgtpcn" swqvcvkqp" octmu" cpf"ekvcvkqpu" qokvvgf+0" " Vjg" Cigpe{Óu" tgiwncvkqpu" 37 uvcvg"vjcv"kv"Ðoc{Ñ"rwtejcug"c"eqpuwnvcvkxg"gzcokpcvkqp"Ðvq"vt{"vq"tguqnxg"cp"kpeqpukuvgpe{"kp" 38 vjg"gxkfgpegÑ"qt"yjgp"vjg"gxkfgpeg"ku"kpuwhhkekgpv"vq"uwrrqtv"c"fgvgtokpcvkqp0""42"E0H0T0"¸" 39 6380;3;c*d+0" " Vjg" Pkpvj" Ektewkv" jcu" hqwpf" vjcv" c" ecug" oc{" dg" tgocpfgf" yjgtg" vjg" CNLÓu" 3: tghwucn"vq"rwtejcug"c"eqpuwnvcvkxg"gzcokpcvkqp"hqt"c"enckocpv"ycu"Ðpqv"kp"ceeqtfcpeg"ykvj"vjg" 3; ncy0Ñ""Reed."492"H05f"cv":670" 42 " 43 Dgecwug"vjku"ocvvgt"owuv"dg"tgocpfgf"hqt"tgeqpukfgtcvkqp"qh"vjg"etgfkdknkv{"qh"RnckpvkhhÓu" 44 uvcvgogpvu"cdqwv"jgt"u{orvqou"cpf"nkokvcvkqpu."vjg"Eqwtv"gzgtekugu"kvu"fkuetgvkqp"pqv"vq"fgekfg" 45 yjgvjgt" vjg" CNLÓu" hcknwtg" vq" qtfgt" c" eqpuwnvcvkxg" gzcokpcvkqp" tgpfgtgf" jgt" cuuguuogpv" qh" 46 RnckpvkhhÓu"THE"wpuwrrqtvgf"d{"uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"kp"vjg"tgeqtf0""Pgxgtvjgnguu."qp"tgocpf." 47 vjg" CNL." chvgt" tgeqpukfgtkpi" vjg" etgfkdknkv{" qh" RnckpvkhhÓu" uvcvgogpvu." oc{" pggf" vq" tgcuuguu" 48 RnckpvkhhÓu"THE0""Kp"fqkpi"uq."vjg"CNL"ujqwnf"eqpukfgt"yjgvjgt."ikxgp"vjg"cdugpeg"qh"cp"THE" 49 cuuguuogpv" htqo" c" vtgcvkpi" rj{ukekcp." vjg" tgeqtf" yqwnf" dgpghkv" htqo" vjg" qrkpkqp" qh" cp" 4: gzcokpkpi" rj{ukekcp" yjq" eqwnf" ujgf" nkijv" qp" dqvj" vjg" crrctgpv" kpeqpukuvgpekgu" dgvyggp" 36" " " " " 3 RnckpvkhhÓu" uvcvgogpvu" cpf" vjg" qrkpkqpu" qh" Ftu0" Dcnnctf" cpf" Ejcp" cpf" qp" RnckpvkhhÓu" ewttgpv" 4 rj{ukecn"eqpfkvkqp."yjkej"vjg"pqy"hkxg"cpf"ukz"{gct"qnf"qrkpkqpu"qh"Ftu0"Dcnnctf"cpf"Ejcp"fq" 5 pqv"cfftguu0" 6 " KKK0" 7 Vjg"CNLÓu"Cuuguuogpv"qh"RnckpvkhhÓu"Tgukfwcn"Hwpevkqpcn"Ecrcekv{" " 8 9 Vjg"fgekukqp"yjgvjgt"vq"tgocpf"hqt"hwtvjgt"rtqeggfkpiu"qt"qtfgt"cp"koogfkcvg"cyctf"qh" : dgpghkvu"ku"ykvjkp"vjg"fkuvtkev"eqwtvÓu"fkuetgvkqp0""Harman v. Apfel."433"H05f"3394."3397/9:" ; *;vj"Ekt0"4222+0""Wpfgt"vjg"etgfkv/cu/vtwg"twng."c"fkuvtkev"eqwtv"oc{"tgocpf"hqt"cp"cyctf"qh" 32 dgpghkvu" yjgp" vjg" hqnnqykpi" vjtgg" eqpfkvkqpu" ctg" ucvkuhkgf<" " Ð*3+" vjg" tgeqtf" jcu" dggp" hwnn{" 33 fgxgnqrgf"cpf"hwtvjgt"cfokpkuvtcvkxg"rtqeggfkpiu"yqwnf"ugtxg"pq"wughwn"rwtrqug="*4+"vjg"CNL" 34 jcu" hckngf" vq" rtqxkfg" ngicnn{" uwhhkekgpv" tgcuqpu" hqt" tglgevkpi" gxkfgpeg." yjgvjgt" enckocpv" 35 vguvkoqp{"qt"ogfkecn"qrkpkqp="cpf"*5+"kh"vjg"kortqrgtn{"fkuetgfkvgf"gxkfgpeg"ygtg"etgfkvgf"cu" 36 vtwg."vjg"CNL"yqwnf"dg"tgswktgf"vq"hkpf"vjg"enckocpv"fkucdngf"qp"tgocpf0Ñ""Garrison."97;"H05f" 37 cv"32420""Vjg"vjktf"qh"vjgug"eqpfkvkqpu"Ðkpeqtrqtcvgu"0"0"0"c"fkuvkpev"tgswktgogpv"qh"vjg"etgfkv/ 38 cu/vtwg" twng." pcogn{" vjcv" vjgtg" ctg" pq" qwvuvcpfkpi" kuuwgu" vjcv" owuv" dg" tguqnxgf" dghqtg" c" 39 fgvgtokpcvkqp"qh"fkucdknkv{"ecp"dg"ocfg0Ñ""Id."p0480""Jqygxgt."gxgp"kh"vjqug"vjtgg"tgswktgogpvu" 3: ctg"ogv."vjg"Eqwtv"tgvckpu"Ðhngzkdknkv{Ñ"kp"fgvgtokpkpi"vjg"crrtqrtkcvg"tgogf{"cpf"oc{"tgocpf" 3; hqt"hwtvjgt"rtqeggfkpiu"Ðyjgp"vjg"tgeqtf"cu"c"yjqng"etgcvgu"ugtkqwu"fqwdv"cu"vq"yjgvjgt"vjg" 42 enckocpv"ku."kp"hcev."fkucdngf"ykvjkp"vjg"ogcpkpi"qh"vjg"Uqekcn"Ugewtkv{"Cev0Ñ""Burrell v. Colvin." 43 997"H05f"3355."3363"*;vj"Ekt0"4236+"*swqvkpi"Garrison."97;"H05f"cv"3243+0" 44 " 45 Jgtg."kv"ku"pqv"engct"htqo"vjg"tgeqtf"vjcv."kh"vjg"CNL"etgfkvgf"vjg"uvcvgogpvu"qh"Rnckpvkhh." 46 jg"yqwnf"dg"tgswktgf"vq"hkpf"Rnckpvkhh"fkucdngf"qp"tgocpf0""Ceeqtfkpin{."vjg"Eqwtv"tgocpfu" 47 hqt"hwtvjgt"fgxgnqrogpv"qh"vjg"tgeqtf."kpenwfkpi"vjg"rtqrgt"eqpukfgtcvkqp"qh"vjg"uvcvgogpvu"cpf" 48 vguvkoqp{"qh"Rnckpvkhh"cpf."kh"crrtqrtkcvg."vjg"rwtejcug"qh"c"eqpuwnvcvkxg"rj{ukecn"gzcokpcvkqp0" 49 ^^" 4: ^^" 37" " " " " 3 EQPENWUKQP" 4 " 5 " 6 ku" TGXGTUGF." cpf" vjku" ecug" ku" TGOCPFGF" hqt" hwtvjgt" rtqeggfkpiu" eqpukuvgpv" ykvj" vjku" 7 Ogoqtcpfwo"Qrkpkqp"cpf"Qtfgt0" 8 " " 9 " KV" KU" HWTVJGT" QTFGTGF" vjcv" vjg" Engtm" qh" vjg" Eqwtv" ujcnn" ugtxg" eqrkgu" qh" vjku" : Ogoqtcpfwo"Qrkpkqp"cpf"Qtfgt"cpf"vjg"Lwfiogpv"qp"eqwpugn"hqt"rnckpvkhh"cpf"hqt"fghgpfcpv0" ; " 32 " 33 " 34 FCVG<"Hgdtwct{"7."423;" 35 " 36 37 "Hqt"vjg"tgcuqpu"uvcvgf"cdqxg."KV"KU"QTFGTGF"vjcv"vjg"fgekukqp"qh"vjg"Eqookuukqpgt" " NGV"LWFIOGPV"DG"GPVGTGF"CEEQTFKPIN[" " " " " " " aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa" """"""""""MCTGP"N0"UVGXGPUQP"""""" " WPKVGF"UVCVGU"OCIKUVTCVG"LWFIG" 38 39 3: 3; 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 4: 38" " "
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
