John Victor Medeiros v. Nancy A. Berryhill, No. 5:2017cv01011 - Document 23 (C.D. Cal. 2019)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER by Magistrate Judge Sheri Pym. IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that Judgment shall be entered AFFIRMING the decision of the Commissioner denying benefits, and dismissing the complaint with prejudice. (sbou)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
John Victor Medeiros v. Nancy A. Berryhill Doc. 23 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 : WPKVGF"UVCVGU"FKUVTKEV"EQWTV ; EGPVTCN"FKUVTKEV"QH"ECNKHQTPKC 32 LQJP"O0. 33 Rnckpvkhh. 34 x0 35 PCPE["C0"DGTT[JKNN."Cevkpi Eqookuukqpgt"qh"Uqekcn"Ugewtkv{ 36 Cfokpkuvtcvkqp. 37 38 """"""""""""""""""""" Fghgpfcpv0 + + + + + + + + + + + + Ecug"Pq0"GF"EX"39/3233/UR OGOQTCPFWO"QRKPKQP"CPF QTFGT 39 K0 3: KPVTQFWEVKQP 3; Qp"Oc{"43."4239."rnckpvkhh"Lqjp"O0"hkngf"c"eqornckpv"cickpuv"fghgpfcpv."vjg 42 Eqookuukqpgt"qh"vjg"Uqekcn"Ugewtkv{"Cfokpkuvtcvkqp"*ÐEqookuukqpgtÑ+."uggmkpi"c 43 tgxkgy"qh"c"fgpkcn"qh"c"rgtkqf"qh"fkucdknkv{"cpf"fkucdknkv{"kpuwtcpeg"dgpghkvu 44 *ÐFKDÑ+0""Vjg"eqwtv"fggou"vjg"ocvvgt"uwkvcdng"hqt"cflwfkecvkqp"ykvjqwv"qtcn 45 ctiwogpv0 46 Rnckpvkhh"rtgugpvu"qpg"kuuwg"hqt"fgekukqp."yjgvjgt"vjg"Cfokpkuvtcvkxg"Ncy 47 Lwfig"*ÐCNLÑ+"rtqrgtn{"eqpukfgtgf"vjg"qrkpkqp"qh"rnckpvkhhÓu"gzcokpkpi"rj{ukekcp. 48 Ft0"Lcem"Cmocmlkcp."O0F0""Ogoqtcpfwo"kp"Uwrrqtv"qh"Eqornckpv"*ÐR0"Ogo0Ñ+"cv 49 7/32="see"Ogoqtcpfwo"kp"Uwrrqtv"qh"FghgpfcpvÓu"Cpuygt"*ÐF0"Ogo0Ñ+"cv"4/70 4: 3 Dockets.Justia.com 3 Jcxkpi"ectghwnn{"uvwfkgf"vjg"rctvkguÓ"ogoqtcpfc."vjg"Cfokpkuvtcvkxg 4 Tgeqtf"*ÐCTÑ+."cpf"vjg"fgekukqp"qh"vjg"CNL."vjg"eqwtv"eqpenwfgu"vjcv"vjg"CNL 5 gttgf"kp"tglgevkpi"c"rqtvkqp"qh"Ft0"CmocmlkcpÓu"qrkpkqp"ykvjqwv"gzrncpcvkqp."dwv 6 uwej"gttqt"ycu"jctonguu0""Eqpugswgpvn{."vjg"eqwtv"chhktou"vjg"fgekukqp"qh"vjg 7 Eqookuukqpgt"fgp{kpi"dgpghkvu0 8 KK0 9 HCEVWCN"CPF"RTQEGFWTCN"DCEMITQWPF : Rnckpvkhh"jcu"cp"gngxgpvj"itcfg"gfwecvkqp"cpf"ycu"hkhv{"*72+"{gctu"qnf"qp"jku ; cnngigf"fkucdknkv{"qpugv"fcvg0""CT"cv"58."790""Jg"jcu"rcuv"tgngxcpv"yqtm"cu"c 32 rtqfwevkqp"ocpcigt0""Id."cv"750 33 Qp"Ugrvgodgt"34."4235."rnckpvkhh"hkngf"cp"crrnkecvkqp"hqt"c"rgtkqf"qh 34 fkucdknkv{"cpf"FKD."cnngikpi"fkucdknkv{"fwg"vq"fgrtguukqp."cpzkgv{."nqygt"dcem"rckp. 35 nqygt"jkr"rckp."ejtqpke"rckp."ygcmpguu."ejtqpke"hcvkiwg."kpuqopkc."pkijvoctgu. 36 cpf"ogoqt{"kuuwgu0""Id."cv"79/7:0""Vjg"Eqookuukqpgt"fgpkgf"rnckpvkhhÓu 37 crrnkecvkqp"kpkvkcnn{"cpf"wrqp"tgeqpukfgtcvkqp."chvgt"yjkej"rnckpvkhh"hkngf"c"tgswguv 38 hqt"c"jgctkpi0""Id."cv":/33.";2/3240 39 Qp"Lwn{"44."4237."rnckpvkhh"crrgctgf"cpf"vguvkhkgf"cv"c"jgctkpi"dghqtg"vjg 3: CNL0""Id. cv"55/780""Vjg"CNL"cnuq"jgctf"vguvkoqp{"htqo"xqecvkqpcn"gzrgtv"Oct{ 3; Lgueq0""Id0"cv"73/780""Qp"Ugrvgodgt"37."4237."vjg"CNL"fgpkgf"rnckpvkhhÓu"enckou"hqt 42 dgpghkvu0""Id."cv"36/490 43 Crrn{kpi"vjg"hkxg/uvgr"ugswgpvkcn"gxcnwcvkqp"rtqeguu."vjg"CNL"hqwpf."cv"uvgr 44 qpg."vjcv"rnckpvkhh"jcf"pqv"gpicigf"kp"uwduvcpvkcn"ickphwn"cevkxkv{"ukpeg"Ugrvgodgt 45 47."4234."vjg"cnngigf"fkucdknkv{"qpugv"fcvg0""Id."cv"380 46 Cv"uvgr"vyq."vjg"CNL"hqwpf"rnckpvkhh"uwhhgtgf"htqo"vjg"hqnnqykpi"ugxgtg 47 korcktogpvu<""fgigpgtcvkxg"fkue"fkugcug"kpxqnxkpi"vjg"nwodct"urkpg"ykvj 48 tcfkewnqrcvj{"qp"vjg"nghv"ukfg."fkuqtfgt"qh"vjg"nghv"jkr."qdgukv{."hkdtqo{cnikc."cpf 49 fgrtguukqp0""Id. 4: 4 3 Cv"uvgr"vjtgg."vjg"CNL"hqwpf"rnckpvkhhÓu"korcktogpvu."yjgvjgt"kpfkxkfwcnn{ 4 qt"kp"eqodkpcvkqp."fkf"pqv"oggv"qt"ogfkecnn{"gswcn"qpg"qh"vjg"nkuvgf"korcktogpvu 5 ugv"hqtvj"kp"42"E0H0T0"rctv"626."Uwdrctv"R."Crrgpfkz"30""Id0 6 Vjg"CNL"vjgp"cuuguugf"rnckpvkhhÓu"tgukfwcn"hwpevkqpcn"ecrcekv{"*ÐTHEÑ+.3 7 cpf"fgvgtokpgf"jg"jcf"vjg"THE"vq"rgthqto"ogfkwo."ykvj"vjg"nkokvcvkqpu"vjcv 8 rnckpvkhh"eqwnf<""nkhv"cpf"ectt{"pq"oqtg"vjcp"37"rqwpfu"qeecukqpcnn{"cpf"32"rqwpfu 9 htgswgpvn{."cpf"rwuj"cpf"rwnn"ykvjkp"vjqug"ygkijv"nkokvu="uvcpf"cpf"ycnm"hqwt : jqwtu"qwv"qh"cp"gkijv/jqwt"fc{."ykvj"pq"rtqnqpigf"uvcpfkpi"qt"ycnmkpi"itgcvgt ; vjcp"52"okpwvgu"cv"c"vkog"ykvj"vjg"cdknkv{"vq"wug"c"ecpg"kh"pggfgf="cpf"ukv"hqt"ukz 32 jqwtu"qwv"qh"cp"jqwt/jqwt"yqtmfc{0""Id."cv"3:0""Vjg"CNL"rtgenwfgf"rnckpvkhh"htqo<" 33 enkodkpi"ncffgtu."tqrgu."qt"uechhqnfu="yqtm"cv"wprtqvgevgf"jgkijvu"qt"ctqwpf 34 fcpigtqwu"wpiwctfgf"oqxkpi"ocejkpgt{="cpf"ftkxkpi"eqoogtekcn"xgjkengu0""Id." 35 Vjg"CNL"hwtvjgt"fgvgtokpgf"vjcv."ogpvcnn{."rnckpvkhh"ku"nkokvgf"vq"pqp/eqorngz 36 vcumu"tgswktkpi"pq"oqtg"vjcp"qeecukqpcn"eqpvcev"ykvj"vjg"igpgtcn"rwdnke. 37 rgthqtogf"kp"c"uvcvke"gpxktqpogpv."cpf"pq"oqtg"vjcp"qeecukqpcn"vcumu"yjkej 38 tgswktg"vgcoyqtm0""Id. 39 Cv"uvgr"hqwt."vjg"CNL"fgvgtokpgf"vjcv"rnckpvkhh"ku"kpecrcdng"qh"rgthqtokpi 3: jku"rcuv"tgngxcpv"yqtm"cu"c"rtqfwevkqp"ocpcigt0""Id."cv"480 3; Cv"uvgr"hkxg."vjg"CNL"hqwpf"vjcv"vjgtg"ygtg"lqdu"vjcv"gzkuvgf"kp"ukipkhkecpv 42 pwodgtu"kp"vjg"pcvkqpcn"geqpqo{"vjcv"rnckpvkhh"eqwnf"rgthqto."kpenwfkpi"uocnn 43 rctvu"cuugodngt."inwgt."cpf"vgzvkng"cuugodngt0""Id."cv"48/490""Eqpugswgpvn{."vjg"CNL 44 eqpenwfgf"vjcv"rnckpvkhh"fkf"pqv"uwhhgt"htqo"c"fkucdknkv{"cu"fghkpgf"d{"vjg"Uqekcn 45 46 47 48 49 4: """""3 Tgukfwcn"hwpevkqpcn"ecrcekv{"ku"yjcv"c"enckocpv"ecp"fq"fgurkvg"gzkuvkpi gzgtvkqpcn"cpf"pqpgzgtvkqpcn"nkokvcvkqpu0""Cooper v. Sullivan."::2"H04f"3374."3377/ 78"p07/9"*;vj"Ekt0"3;:;+0""ÐDgvyggp"uvgru"vjtgg"cpf"hqwt"qh"vjg"hkxg/uvgr"gxcnwcvkqp. vjg"CNL"owuv"rtqeggf"vq"cp"kpvgtogfkcvg"uvgr"kp"yjkej"vjg"CNL"cuuguugu"vjg enckocpvÓu"tgukfwcn"hwpevkqpcn"ecrcekv{0Ñ""Massachi v. Astrue."6:8"H05f"336;."3373 p04"*;vj"Ekt0"4229+0 5 3 Ugewtkv{"Cev0""Id."cv"490 4 Rnckpvkhh"hkngf"c"vkogn{"tgswguv"hqt"tgxkgy"qh"vjg"CNLÓu"fgekukqp."yjkej"ycu 5 fgpkgf"d{"vjg"Crrgcnu"Eqwpekn0""Id."cv"3/60""Vjg"CNLÓu"fgekukqp"uvcpfu"cu"vjg"hkpcn 6 fgekukqp"qh"vjg"Eqookuukqpgt0 7 KKK0 8 UVCPFCTF"QH"TGXKGY 9 Vjku"eqwtv"ku"gorqygtgf"vq"tgxkgy"fgekukqpu"d{"vjg"Eqookuukqpgt"vq"fgp{ : dgpghkvu0""64"W0U0E0"¸"627*i+0""Vjg"hkpfkpiu"cpf"fgekukqp"qh"vjg"Uqekcn"Ugewtkv{ ; Cfokpkuvtcvkqp"owuv"dg"wrjgnf"kh"vjg{"ctg"htgg"qh"ngicn"gttqt"cpf"uwrrqtvgf"d{ 32 uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg0""Mayes v. Massanari."498"H05f"675."67:/7;"*;vj"Ekt0"4223+ 33 *cu"cogpfgf+0""Dwv"kh"vjg"eqwtv"fgvgtokpgu"vjg"CNLÓu"hkpfkpiu"ctg"dcugf"qp"ngicn 34 gttqt"qt"ctg"pqv"uwrrqtvgf"d{"uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"kp"vjg"tgeqtf."vjg"eqwtv"oc{ 35 tglgev"vjg"hkpfkpiu"cpf"ugv"cukfg"vjg"fgekukqp"vq"fgp{"dgpghkvu0" Aukland v. 36 Massanari."479"H05f"3255."3257"*;vj"Ekt0"4223+="Tonapetyan v. Halter."464"H05f 37 3366."3369"*;vj"Ekt0"4223+0 38 ÐUwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"ku"oqtg"vjcp"c"ogtg"uekpvknnc."dwv"nguu"vjcp"c 39 rtgrqpfgtcpeg0Ñ""Aukland."479"H05f"cv"32570""Uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"ku"uwej 3: Ðtgngxcpv"gxkfgpeg"yjkej"c"tgcuqpcdng"rgtuqp"okijv"ceegrv"cu"cfgswcvg"vq"uwrrqtv 3; c"eqpenwukqp0Ñ""Reddick v. Chater."379"H05f"937."942"*;vj"Ekt0"3;;:+="Mayes."498 42 H05f"cv"67;0""Vq"fgvgtokpg"yjgvjgt"uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"uwrrqtvu"vjg"CNLÓu 43 hkpfkpi."vjg"tgxkgykpi"eqwtv"owuv"tgxkgy"vjg"cfokpkuvtcvkxg"tgeqtf"cu"c"yjqng. 44 Ðygkijkpi"dqvj"vjg"gxkfgpeg"vjcv"uwrrqtvu"cpf"vjg"gxkfgpeg"vjcv"fgvtcevu"htqo"vjg 45 CNLÓu"eqpenwukqp0Ñ""Mayes."498"H05f"cv"67;0""Vjg"CNLÓu"fgekukqp"ÐÒecppqv"dg 46 chhktogf"ukorn{"d{"kuqncvkpi"c"urgekhke"swcpvwo"qh"uwrrqtvkpi"gxkfgpeg0ÓÑ" 47 Aukland."479"H05f"cv"3257"*swqvkpi"Sousa v. Callahan."365"H05f"3462."3465"*;vj 48 Ekt0"3;;:++0""Kh"vjg"gxkfgpeg"ecp"tgcuqpcdn{"uwrrqtv"gkvjgt"chhktokpi"qt"tgxgtukpi 49 vjg"CNLÓu"fgekukqp."vjg"tgxkgykpi"eqwtv"ÐÒoc{"pqv"uwduvkvwvg"kvu"lwfiogpv"hqt"vjcv 4: 6 3 qh"vjg"CNL0ÓÑ""Id."*swqvkpi"Matney v. Sullivan.";:3"H04f"3238."323:"*;vj"Ekt0 4 3;;4++0 5 KX0 6 FKUEWUUKQP 7 Ft0"Lcem"J0"Cmocmlkcp."cp"qtvjqrgfke"uwtigqp."gzcokpgf"rnckpvkhh"qp 8 Lcpwct{"39."4236"kp"vjg"eqpvgzv"qh"jku"yqtmgtuÓ"eqorgpucvkqp"encko0""CT"cv"37530" 9 Ykvj"tgurgev"vq"yqtm"tguvtkevkqpu."Ft0"Cmocmlkcp"qrkpgf"rnckpvkhh"ujqwnf<""dg"cdng : vq"ejcpig"rqukvkqpu"cu"pggfgf="fq"pq"jgcx{"nkhvkpi"tgictfkpi"vjg"egtxkecn"qt ; nwodct"urkpg="cpf"fq"pq"tgrgvkvkxg"yqtm"qxgtjgcf"hqt"vjg"egtxkecn"urkpg0""Id."cv 32 375;0""Vjg"CNL"fkuewuugf"Ft0"CmocmlkcpÓu"hkpfkpiu."kpenwfkpi"vjg"qrkpkqp"lwuv 33 uvcvgf0""Id."cv"42/430""Dwv"vjg"CNL"fkf"pqv"kpeqtrqtcvg"cnn"qh"vjgug"nkokvcvkqpu"kpvq 34 jgt"THE"fgvgtokpcvkqp0""See id."cv"3:0 35 Kp"fgvgtokpkpi"yjgvjgt"c"enckocpv"jcu"c"ogfkecnn{"fgvgtokpcdng 36 korcktogpv."coqpi"vjg"gxkfgpeg"vjg"CNL"eqpukfgtu"ku"ogfkecn"gxkfgpeg0""42 37 E0H0T0"¸¸"62603749*d+."6380;49*d+04""Kp"gxcnwcvkpi"ogfkecn"qrkpkqpu."vjg 38 tgiwncvkqpu"fkuvkpiwkuj"coqpi"vjtgg"v{rgu"qh"rj{ukekcpu<""*3+"vtgcvkpi"rj{ukekcpu= 39 *4+"gzcokpkpi"rj{ukekcpu="cpf"*5+"pqp/gzcokpkpi"rj{ukekcpu0""42"E0H0T0 3: ¸¸"62603749*e+."*g+"6380;49*e+.*5+="Lester v. Chater.":3"H05f":43.":52"*;vj"Ekt0 3; 3;;8+"*cu"cogpfgf+0""ÐIgpgtcnn{."c"vtgcvkpi"rj{ukekcpÓu"qrkpkqp"ecttkgu"oqtg 42 ygkijv"vjcp"cp"gzcokpkpi"rj{ukekcpÓu."cpf"cp"gzcokpkpi"rj{ukekcpÓu"qrkpkqp 43 ecttkgu"oqtg"ygkijv"vjcp"c"tgxkgykpi"rj{ukekcpÓu0Ñ""Holohan v. Massanari."468 44 H05f"33;7."3424"*;vj"Ekt0"4223+="42"E0H0T0"¸¸"62603749*e+*3+/*4+."6380;49*e+*3+/ 45 *4+0""Vjg"qrkpkqp"qh"vjg"vtgcvkpi"rj{ukekcp"ku"igpgtcnn{"ikxgp"vjg"itgcvguv"ygkijv 46 dgecwug"vjg"vtgcvkpi"rj{ukekcp"ku"gornq{gf"vq"ewtg"cpf"jcu"c"itgcvgt"qrrqtvwpkv{"vq 47 wpfgtuvcpf"cpf"qdugtxg"c"enckocpv0" Smolen v. Chater.":2"H05f"3495."34:7"*;vj 48 49 """""4 Cnn"ekvcvkqpu"vq"vjg"Eqfg"qh"Hgfgtcn"Tgiwncvkqpu"tghgt"vq"tgiwncvkqpu 4: crrnkecdng"vq"enckou"hkngf"dghqtg"Octej"49."42390 7 3 Ekt0"3;;8+="Magallanes v. Bowen."::3"H04f"969."973"*;vj"Ekt0"3;:;+0 4 Pgxgtvjgnguu."vjg"CNL"ku"pqv"dqwpf"d{"vjg"qrkpkqp"qh"vjg"vtgcvkpi"rj{ukekcp0" 5 Smolen.":2"H05f"cv"34:70""Kh"c"vtgcvkpi"rj{ukekcpÓu"qrkpkqp"ku"wpeqpvtcfkevgf."vjg 6 CNL"owuv"rtqxkfg"engct"cpf"eqpxkpekpi"tgcuqpu"hqt"ikxkpi"kv"nguu"ygkijv0""Lester. 7 :3"H05f"cv":520""Kh"vjg"vtgcvkpi"rj{ukekcpÓu"qrkpkqp"ku"eqpvtcfkevgf"d{"qvjgt 8 qrkpkqpu."vjg"CNL"owuv"rtqxkfg"urgekhke"cpf"ngikvkocvg"tgcuqpu"uwrrqtvgf"d{ 9 uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"hqt"tglgevkpi"kv0""Id. cv":520""Nkmgykug."vjg"CNL"owuv"rtqxkfg : urgekhke"cpf"ngikvkocvg"tgcuqpu"uwrrqtvgf"d{"uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"kp"tglgevkpi"vjg ; eqpvtcfkevgf"qrkpkqpu"qh"gzcokpkpi"rj{ukekcpu0" Id."cv":52/530" Vjg"qrkpkqp"qh"c 32 pqp/gzcokpkpi"rj{ukekcp."uvcpfkpi"cnqpg."ecppqv"eqpuvkvwvg"uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg0" 33 Widmark v. Barnhart."676"H05f"3285."3289"p04"*;vj"Ekt0"4228+="Morgan v. 34 Comm’r."38;"H05f"7;7."824"*;vj"Ekt0"3;;;+="see also Erickson v. Shalala.";"H05f 35 :35.":3:"p09"*;vj"Ekt0"3;;5+0 36 Jgtg."vjg"CNL"fkf"pqv"ctvkewncvg"cp{"tgcuqpu"hqt"tglgevkpi"rctv"qh"Ft0 37 CmocmlkcpÓu"qrkpkqp0""Fghgpfcpv"ctiwgu"kv"ku"crrctgpv"vjcv"ujg"tglgevgf"vjg 38 qrkpkqp"cu"kpeqpukuvgpv"ykvj"vjg"qvjgt"ogfkecn"gxkfgpeg."ikxgp"jgt"fkuewuukqp"qh 39 vjg"tgeqtf0""Vjcv"oc{"ygnn"jcxg"dggp"vjg"CNLÓu"tgcuqpkpi."dwv"ujg"hckngf"vq"uq 3: uvcvg0""Vjg"CNL"fkf"pqv"rtqxkfg"vjcv"qt"cp{"qvjgt"tgcuqp"hqt"tglgevkpi"Ft0 3; CmocmlkcpÓu"qrkpkqp0""Vjg"eqwtvÓu"tgxkgy"ku"nkokvgf"vq"vjg"tgcuqpu"cevwcnn{"ikxgp 42 d{"vjg"CNL."pqv"vjqug"ujg"eqwnf"jcxg"ikxgp0""See Orn v. Astrue."6;7"H05f"847."852 43 *;vj"Ekt0"4229+"*ÐYg"tgxkgy"qpn{"vjg"tgcuqpu"rtqxkfgf"d{"vjg"CNL"kp"vjg"fkucdknkv{ 44 fgvgtokpcvkqp"cpf"oc{"pqv"chhkto"vjg"CNL"qp"c"itqwpf"wrqp"yjkej"jg"fkf"pqv 45 tgn{0Ñ"*ekvcvkqp"qokvvgf++0"" 46 Pqpgvjgnguu."vjg"CNLÓu"gttqt"kp"tglgevkpi"rctv"qh"Ft0"CmocmlkcpÓu"qrkpkqp 47 ykvjqwv"tgcuqp"ycu"jctonguu0""Rnckpvkhh"ctiwgu"kv"ycu"pqv"jctonguu"gttqt. 48 eqpvgpfkpi"Ft0"CmocmlkcpÓu"qrkpkqp"vjcv"rnckpvkhh"Ðujqwnf"dg"cdng"vq"ejcpig 49 rqukvkqpu"cu"pggfgfÑ"wpfgtokpgu"vjg"CNLÓu"uvgr"hkxg"hkpfkpi0""R0"Ogo0"cv";/320" 4: 8 3 Rnckpvkhh"ctiwgu"Ft0"CmocmlkcpÓu"qrkpkqp"ku"guugpvkcnn{"vjcv"rnckpvkhh"ujqwnf"dg"cdng 4 vq"ukv."uvcpf."qt"ycnm"cv"yknn."pqv"lwuv"jcxg"c"ukv1uvcpf"qrvkqp0""Id.""Vjku"ku"pqv"c"hckt 5 kpvgtrtgvcvkqp"qh"Ft0"CmocmlkcpÓu"qrkpkqp0 6 Cu"tgngxcpv"jgtg."vjg"CNL"fgvgtokpgf"rnckpvkhhÓu"THE"kpenwfgf"vjg"cdknkv{"vq 7 uvcpf"qt"ycnm"hqt"hqwt"jqwtu"qwv"qh"gkijv."ykvj"pq"rtqnqpigf"uvcpfkpi"qt"ycnmkpi 8 itgcvgt"vjcp"vjktv{"okpwvgu"cv"c"vkog."cpf"vjg"cdknkv{"vq"ukv"ukz"jqwtu"qwv"qh"gkijv0" 9 CT"cv"3:0""Vjg"xqecvkqpcn"gzrgtv"*ÐXGÑ+"vguvkhkgf"vjcv"uqogqpg"ykvj"vjku"THE : eqwnf"rgthqto"vjg"lqdu"qh"uocnn"rctvu"cuugodngt."inwgt."cpf"vgzvkng"cuugodngt0""Id. ; cv"760""Vjg"CNL"kpenwfgf"pq"qrvkqp"vq"ejcpig"rqukvkqpu"cu"pggfgf"kp"jgt"THE 32 fgvgtokpcvkqp."eqpvtct{"vq"Ft0"CmocmlkcpÓu"qrkpkqp0""Dwv"cv"vjg"jgctkpi."rnckpvkhhÓu 33 eqwpugn"cumgf"vjg"XG"yjgvjgt"c"rgtuqp"yjq"pggfgf"c"ukv/uvcpf"cv"yknn"qrvkqp 34 eqwnf"rgthqto"vjg"lqdu"ekvgf"d{"vjg"XG."cpf"vjg"XG"vguvkhkgf"kp"vjg"chhktocvkxg. 35 uvcvkpi"Ðvjgug"rctvkewnct"lqdu"yqwnf"pqv"dg"gtqfgf0Ñ""Id."cv"770""Vjg"CNL 36 tgeqipk|gf"vjku"vguvkoqp{"kp"jgt"fgekukqp."uvcvkpi<""ÐGxgp"kh"vjg"cffkvkqpcn 37 nkokvcvkqpu"qh"cp"qrvkqp"vq"ukv"cpf"uvcpf"cv"yknn"cpf"c"nkokvcvkqp"vq"nqy"uvtguu"cu 38 rtqrqugf"d{"vjg"enckocpvÓu"tgrtgugpvcvkxg"ygtg"cfqrvgf."vjg"xqecvkqpcn"gzrgtv 39 vguvkhkgf"vjcv"vjg"enckocpv"eqwnf"uvknn"rgthqto"vjg"cnvgtpcvg"yqtm"cevkxkv{"fguetkdgf 3: dgnqy0Ñ""Id."cv"460 3; Rnckpvkhh"ctiwgu"vjku"fqgu"pqv"tgpfgt"vjg"CNLÓu"gttqt"kp"tglgevkpi"Ft0 42 CmocmlkcpÓu"qrkpkqp"jctonguu."dgecwug"Ft0"Cmocmlkcp"qrkpgf"rnckpvkhh"ujqwnf"dg 43 cdng"vq"ukv."uvcpf."or walk"cv"yknn."cpf"vjg"XGÓu"vguvkoqp{"fqgu"pqv"cfftguu"c"ycnm 44 cv"yknn"qrvkqp0""Vjg"eqwtv"fkucitggu"ykvj"rnckpvkhhÓu"kpvgtrtgvcvkqp"qh"Ft0 45 CmocmlkcpÓu"qrkpkqp0""Jku"qrkpkqp"ycu"lwuv"vjcv"rnckpvkhh"ujqwnf"dg"cdng"vq"ejcpig 46 rqukvkqpu0""C"ukv/uvcpf"cv"yknn"qrvkqp"hcktn{"gpeqorcuugu"vjku0""Vjgtg"ku"pq"dcuku"vq 47 hkpf"Ft0"Cmocmlkcp"qrkpgf"rnckpvkhh"cnuq"pggfgf"vq"ycnm"cv"yknn0 48 Ceeqtfkpin{."ikxgp"vjg"XGÓu"vguvkoqp{."yjkej"vjg"CNL"kpfkecvgf"ujg 49 ceegrvgf."vjg"CNLÓu"gttqt"kp"pqv"kpenwfkpi"c"ukv/uvcpf"cv"yknn"qrvkqp"kp"jgt"THE 4: 9 3 fgvgtokpcvkqp"ykvjqwv"jcxkpi"rtqxkfgf"urgekhke"cpf"ngikvkocvg"tgcuqpu"vq"tglgev 4 Ft0"CmocmlkcpÓu"qrkpkqp"ycu"jctonguu0""Jcf"ujg"kpenwfgf"uwej"cp"qrvkqp."ujg"uvknn 5 yqwnf"jcxg"eqpenwfgf"cv"uvgr"hkxg"vjcv"rnckpvkhh"ku"pqv"fkucdngf0 6 X0 7 EQPENWUKQP 8 KV"KU"VJGTGHQTG"QTFGTGF"vjcv"Lwfiogpv"ujcnn"dg"gpvgtgf 9 CHHKTOKPI"vjg"fgekukqp"qh"vjg"Eqookuukqpgt"fgp{kpi"dgpghkvu."cpf"fkuokuukpi : vjg"eqornckpv"ykvj"rtglwfkeg0 ; 32 FCVGF<""Octej"52."423; 33 34 """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" UJGTK"R[O Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu"Ocikuvtcvg"Lwfig 35 36 37 38 39 3: 3; 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 4: :
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
