Richard DeProspo v. Stern Brothers and Co. et al, No. 2:2018cv10315 - Document 24 (C.D. Cal. 2019)
Court Description: ORDER GRANTING STIPULATED PROTECTIVE ORDER by Magistrate Judge Alicia G. Rosenberg re Stipulation for Protective Order 22 .(see document for details) (hr)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Richard DeProspo v. Stern Brothers and Co. et al Doc. 24 " 3" 4" 5" 6" 7" 8" 9" :" ;" 32" 33" 34" Lcxkgt"H0"Ictekc."Dct"Pq0"4;8:68" LIctekcBrgtmkpueqkg0eqo" RGTMKPU"EQKG"NNR" 3:::"Egpvwt{"Rctm"G0."Uwkvg"3922" Nqu"Cpigngu."Ecnkhqtpkc";2289/3943" Vgngrjqpg<""53209::0;;22" Hceukokng<""53209::055;;" Cvvqtpg{u"hqt"Fghgpfcpvu" UVGTP"DTQVJGTU"("EQ0" " CNGZCPFGT"MTCMQY"-"INKEM"NNR" Octxkp"G0"Mtcmqy"*Uvcvg"Dct"Pq0":344:+" Cognkc"Cnxctg|"*Uvcvg"Dct"Pq0"532266+" 3;22"Cxgpwg"qh"vjg"Uvctu."Uwkvg";22" Nqu"Cpigngu."Ecnkhqtpkc";2289" V<"532"5;6"2:::"~"H<"532"5;6"2:33" G<"omtcmqyBcminnr0eqo~"G<" ccnxctg|Bcminnr0eqo" " Cvvqtpg{u"hqt"Rnckpvkhh"TKEJCTF"FGRTQURQ"" " WPKVGF"UVCVGU"FKUVTKEV"EQWTV" 35" EGPVTCN"FKUVTKEV"QH"ECNKHQTPKC" 36" 37" 38" TKEJCTF"FGRTQURQ."cp" kpfkxkfwcn." 39" Rnckpvkhh." x0" 3:" 3;" 42" " UVGTP"DTQVJGTU"("EQ0."c" Okuuqwtk"eqtrqtcvkqp."cpf"Fqgu"3/72." kpenwukxg." Fghgpfcpvu0" 43" 44" Ecug"Pq0""4<3:/ex/32537"OYH*CITz+" Assigned to the Hon. Michael W. Fitzgerald, Courtroom 5A QTFGT"ITCPVKPI"UVKRWNCVGF" RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" " " Uvcvg"Eqornckpv"Hkngf<""Qevqdgt"33."423:" Fcvg"qh"Tgoqxcn<""Fgegodgt"35."423:" Vtkcn"Fcvg<""Hgdtwct{"6."4242" " 45" 46" " 47" " 48" " 49" " " 4:" " " "" " QTFGT"ITCPVKPI"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Ecug"Pq0<""4<3:/ex/32537"OYH*CITz+" Dockets.Justia.com " 3" " Rwtuwcpv"vq"Hgf0"T0"Ekx0"R0"48*e+."vjg"rctvkgu"vq"vjku"ncyuwkv."vjtqwij" 4" wpfgtukipgf"eqwpugn."lqkpvn{"uwdokv"vjku"Uvkrwncvgf"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt"vq"iqxgtp"vjg" 5" jcpfnkpi"qh"kphqtocvkqp"cpf"ocvgtkcnu"rtqfwegf"kp"vjg"eqwtug"qh"fkueqxgt{"qt"hkngf" 6" ykvj"vjg"Eqwtv"kp"vjku"cevkqp0" 7" 30" C0" RWTRQUGU"CPF"NKOKVCVKQPU" Fkueqxgt{"kp"vjku"cevkqp"ku"nkmgn{"vq"kpxqnxg"rtqfwevkqp"qh"eqphkfgpvkcn." 8" 9" rtqrtkgvct{"qt"rtkxcvg"kphqtocvkqp"hqt"yjkej"urgekcn"rtqvgevkqp"htqo"rwdnke" :" fkuenquwtg"cpf"htqo"wug"hqt"cp{"rwtrqug"qvjgt"vjcp"rtqugewvkpi"vjku"nkvkicvkqp"oc{" ;" dg"ycttcpvgf0"Ceeqtfkpin{."vjg"rctvkgu"jgtgd{"uvkrwncvg"vq"cpf"rgvkvkqp"vjg"Eqwtv"vq" 32" gpvgt"vjg"hqnnqykpi"Uvkrwncvgf"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt0"Vjg"rctvkgu"cempqyngfig"vjcv"vjku" 33" Qtfgt"fqgu"pqv"eqphgt"dncpmgv"rtqvgevkqpu"qp"cnn"fkuenquwtgu"qt"tgurqpugu"vq" 34" fkueqxgt{"cpf"vjcv"vjg"rtqvgevkqp"kv"chhqtfu"htqo"rwdnke"fkuenquwtg"cpf"wug"gzvgpfu" 35" qpn{"vq"vjg"nkokvgf"kphqtocvkqp"qt"kvgou"vjcv"ctg"gpvkvngf"vq"eqphkfgpvkcn"vtgcvogpv" 36" wpfgt"vjg"crrnkecdng"ngicn"rtkpekrngu0"" 37" D0" 38" Vjku"cevkqp"ku"nkmgn{"vq"kpxqnxg"ugpukvkxg"vjktf/rctv{"rgtuqppgn"kphqtocvkqp." 39" ewuvqogt"nkuvu."cpf"qvjgt"xcnwcdng"fgxgnqrogpv."eqoogtekcn."hkpcpekcn."vgejpkecn" 3:" cpf1qt"rtqrtkgvct{"kphqtocvkqp"hqt"yjkej"urgekcn"rtqvgevkqp"htqo"rwdnke"fkuenquwtg" 3;" cpf"htqo"wug"hqt"cp{"rwtrqug"qvjgt"vjcp"rtqugewvkqp"qh"vjku"cevkqp"ku"ycttcpvgf0" 42" Uwej"eqphkfgpvkcn"cpf"rtqrtkgvct{"ocvgtkcnu"cpf"kphqtocvkqp"eqpukuv"qh."coqpi"qvjgt" 43" vjkpiu."*c+"eqphkfgpvkcn"dwukpguu"qt"hkpcpekcn"kphqtocvkqp."kphqtocvkqp"tgictfkpi" 44" eqphkfgpvkcn"dwukpguu"rtcevkegu."qt"qvjgt"eqphkfgpvkcn"tgugctej."fgxgnqrogpv."qt" 45" eqoogtekcn"kphqtocvkqp"*kpenwfkpi"kphqtocvkqp"kornkecvkpi"rtkxce{"tkijvu"qh"vjktf" 46" rctvkgu+."*d+"hkpcpekcn."eqorgpucvkqp."gornq{ogpv."dgpghkvu."cpf"vcz"fqewogpvu" 47" dgnqpikpi"vq"rnckpvkhh"cpf"pqp/rctvkgu"vq"vjku"nkvkicvkqp."*e+"rgtuqppgn"kphqtocvkqp" 48" kpenwfkpi"fkuekrnkpct{"cevkqpu"cpf"rgthqtocpeg"tcvkpiu"qh"pqp/rctvkgu"vq"vjku" 49" nkvkicvkqp="*f+"rgtuqpcn"kfgpvkh{kpi"kphqtocvkqp."kpenwfkpi"dwv"pqv"nkokvgf"vq"vjg" 4:" jqog"cfftguugu."vgngrjqpg"pwodgtu."cigu"qh"rcuv"qt"rtgugpv"gornq{ggu"qh" " IQQF"ECWUG"UVCVGOGPV" " "" /4/" QTFGT"ITCPVKPI"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Ecug"Pq0<""4<3:/ex/32537"OYH*CITz+" " 3" Fghgpfcpv="cpf"*g+"kphqtocvkqp"qvjgtykug"igpgtcnn{"wpcxckncdng"vq"vjg"rwdnke."qt" 4" yjkej"oc{"dg"rtkxkngigf"qt"qvjgtykug"rtqvgevgf"htqo"fkuenquwtg"wpfgt"uvcvg"qt" 5" hgfgtcn"uvcvwvgu."eqwtv"twngu."ecug"fgekukqpu."qt"eqooqp"ncy0"" 6" Ceeqtfkpin{."vq"gzrgfkvg"vjg"hnqy"qh"kphqtocvkqp."vq"hceknkvcvg"vjg"rtqorv" 7" tguqnwvkqp"qh"fkurwvgu"qxgt"eqphkfgpvkcnkv{"qh"fkueqxgt{"ocvgtkcnu."vq"cfgswcvgn{" 8" rtqvgev"kphqtocvkqp"vjg"rctvkgu"ctg"gpvkvngf"vq"mggr"eqphkfgpvkcn."vq"gpuwtg"vjcv"vjg" 9" rctvkgu"ctg"rgtokvvgf"tgcuqpcdng"pgeguuct{"wugu"qh"uwej"ocvgtkcn"kp"rtgrctcvkqp"hqt" :" cpf"kp"vjg"eqpfwev"qh"vtkcn."vq"cfftguu"vjgkt"jcpfnkpi"cv"vjg"gpf"qh"vjg"nkvkicvkqp."cpf" ;" ugtxg"vjg"gpfu"qh"lwuvkeg."c"rtqvgevkxg"qtfgt"hqt"uwej"kphqtocvkqp"ku"lwuvkhkgf"kp"vjku" 32" ocvvgt0"Kv"ku"vjg"kpvgpv"qh"vjg"rctvkgu"vjcv"kphqtocvkqp"yknn"pqv"dg"fgukipcvgf"cu" 33" eqphkfgpvkcn"hqt"vcevkecn"tgcuqpu"cpf"vjcv"pqvjkpi"dg"uq"fgukipcvgf"ykvjqwv"c"iqqf" 34" hckvj"dgnkgh"vjcv"kv"jcu"dggp"ockpvckpgf"kp"c"eqphkfgpvkcn."pqp/rwdnke"ocppgt."cpf" 35" vjgtg"ku"iqqf"ecwug"yj{"kv"ujqwnf"pqv"dg"rctv"qh"vjg"rwdnke"tgeqtf"qh"vjku"ecug0" E0" 36" CEMPQYNGFIGOGPV"QH"RTQEGFWTG"HQT"HKNKPI"WPFGT" UGCN" 37" Vjg"rctvkgu"hwtvjgt"cempqyngfig."cu"ugv"hqtvj"kp"Ugevkqp"3405."dgnqy."vjcv"vjku" 38" 39" Uvkrwncvgf"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt"fqgu"pqv"gpvkvng"vjgo"vq"hkng"eqphkfgpvkcn"kphqtocvkqp" 3:" wpfgt"ugcn="Nqecn"Ekxkn"Twng"9;/7"ugvu"hqtvj"vjg"rtqegfwtgu"vjcv"owuv"dg"hqnnqygf" 3;" cpf"vjg"uvcpfctfu"vjcv"yknn"dg"crrnkgf"yjgp"c"rctv{"uggmu"rgtokuukqp"htqo"vjg"eqwtv" 42" vq"hkng"ocvgtkcn"wpfgt"ugcn0" 43" Vjgtg"ku"c"uvtqpi"rtguworvkqp"vjcv"vjg"rwdnke"jcu"c"tkijv"qh"ceeguu"vq"lwfkekcn" 44" rtqeggfkpiu"cpf"tgeqtfu"kp"ekxkn"ecugu0"Kp"eqppgevkqp"ykvj"pqp/fkurqukvkxg"oqvkqpu." 45" iqqf"ecwug"owuv"dg"ujqyp"vq"uwrrqtv"c"hknkpi"wpfgt"ugcn0"See Kamakana v. City and 46" County of Honolulu."669"H05f"3394."3398"*;vj"Ekt0"4228+."Phillips v. Gen. Motors 47" Corp.."529"H05f"3428."3432/33"*;vj"Ekt0"4224+."Makar-Welbon v. Sony Electrics, 48" Inc.."3:9"H0T0F0"798."799"*G0F0"Yku0"3;;;+"*gxgp"uvkrwncvgf"rtqvgevkxg"qtfgtu" 49" tgswktg"iqqf"ecwug"ujqykpi+."cpf"c"urgekhke"ujqykpi"qh"iqqf"ecwug"qt"eqorgnnkpi" 4:" tgcuqpu"ykvj"rtqrgt"gxkfgpvkct{"uwrrqtv"cpf"ngicn"lwuvkhkecvkqp."owuv"dg"ocfg"ykvj" " " "" /5/" QTFGT"ITCPVKPI"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Ecug"Pq0<""4<3:/ex/32537"OYH*CITz+" " 3" tgurgev"vq"Rtqvgevgf"Ocvgtkcn"vjcv"c"rctv{"uggmu"vq"hkng"wpfgt"ugcn0"Vjg"rctvkguÓ"ogtg" 4" fgukipcvkqp"qh"Fkuenquwtg"qt"Fkueqxgt{"Ocvgtkcn"cu"EQPHKFGPVKCN"fqgu"pqvÏ" 5" ykvjqwv"vjg"uwdokuukqp"qh"eqorgvgpv"gxkfgpeg"d{"fgenctcvkqp."guvcdnkujkpi"vjcv"vjg" 6" ocvgtkcn"uqwijv"vq"dg"hkngf"wpfgt"ugcn"swcnkhkgu"cu"eqphkfgpvkcn."rtkxkngigf."qt" 7" qvjgtykug"rtqvgevcdngÏeqpuvkvwvg"iqqf"ecwug0" Hwtvjgt."kh"c"rctv{"tgswguvu"ugcnkpi"tgncvgf"vq"c"fkurqukvkxg"oqvkqp"qt"vtkcn." 8" 9" vjgp"eqorgnnkpi"tgcuqpu."pqv"qpn{"iqqf"ecwug."hqt"vjg"ugcnkpi"owuv"dg"ujqyp."cpf" :" vjg"tgnkgh"uqwijv"ujcnn"dg"pcttqyn{"vcknqtgf"vq"ugtxg"vjg"urgekhke"kpvgtguv"vq"dg" ;" rtqvgevgf0"See Pintos v. Pacific Creditors Ass’n0."827"H05f"887."899/9;"*;vj"Ekt0" 32" 4232+0"Hqt"gcej"kvgo"qt"v{rg"qh"kphqtocvkqp."fqewogpv."qt"vjkpi"uqwijv"vq"dg"hkngf" 33" qt"kpvtqfwegf"wpfgt"ugcn"kp"eqppgevkqp"ykvj"c"fkurqukvkxg"oqvkqp"qt"vtkcn."vjg"rctv{" 34" uggmkpi"rtqvgevkqp"owuv"ctvkewncvg"eqorgnnkpi"tgcuqpu."uwrrqtvgf"d{"urgekhke"hcevu" 35" cpf"ngicn"lwuvkhkecvkqp."hqt"vjg"tgswguvgf"ugcnkpi"qtfgt0"Cickp."eqorgvgpv"gxkfgpeg" 36" uwrrqtvkpi"vjg"crrnkecvkqp"vq"hkng"fqewogpvu"wpfgt"ugcn"owuv"dg"rtqxkfgf"d{" 37" fgenctcvkqp0" Cp{"fqewogpv"vjcv"ku"pqv"eqphkfgpvkcn."rtkxkngigf."qt"qvjgtykug"rtqvgevcdng"kp" 38" 39" kvu"gpvktgv{"yknn"pqv"dg"hkngf"wpfgt"ugcn"kh"vjg"eqphkfgpvkcn"qt"kfgpvkh{kpi" 3:" rqtvkqpu1kphqtocvkqp"ecp"dg"tgfcevgf0"Kh"fqewogpvu"ecp"dg"tgfcevgf."vjgp"c"tgfcevgf" 3;" xgtukqp"hqt"rwdnke"xkgykpi."qokvvkpi"qpn{"vjg"eqphkfgpvkcn."rtkxkngigf."qt"qvjgtykug" 42" rtqvgevcdng"rqtvkqpu"qh"vjg"fqewogpv."ujcnn"dg"hkngf0"Cp{"crrnkecvkqp"vjcv"uggmu"vq" 43" hkng"fqewogpvu"wpfgt"ugcn"kp"vjgkt"gpvktgv{"ujqwnf"kpenwfg"cp"gzrncpcvkqp"qh"yj{" 44" tgfcevkqp"ku"pqv"hgcukdng0" 45" 40" FGHKPKVKQPU" 46" 403""Cevkqp<"vjku"rgpfkpi"hgfgtcn"ncyuwkv0"" 47" 404""Ejcnngpikpi"Rctv{<"c"Rctv{"qt"Pqp/Rctv{"vjcv"ejcnngpigu"vjg"fgukipcvkqp" 48" qh"kphqtocvkqp"qt"kvgou"wpfgt"vjku"Qtfgt0" 49" 1"1"1" 4:" 1"1"1" " " "" /6/" QTFGT"ITCPVKPI"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Ecug"Pq0<""4<3:/ex/32537"OYH*CITz+" " 405""ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"Kphqtocvkqp"qt"Kvgou<"kphqtocvkqp"*tgictfnguu"qh" 3" 4" jqy"kv"ku"igpgtcvgf."uvqtgf"qt"ockpvckpgf+"qt"vcpikdng"vjkpiu"vjcv"swcnkh{"hqt" 5" rtqvgevkqp"wpfgt"Hgfgtcn"Twng"qh"Ekxkn"Rtqegfwtg"48*e+."cpf"cu"urgekhkgf"cdqxg"kp" 6" vjg"Iqqf"Ecwug"Uvcvgogpv0" 406""Eqwpugn<"Qwvukfg"Eqwpugn"qh"Tgeqtf"cpf"Kp/Jqwug"Eqwpugn"*cu"ygnn"cu" 7" 8" vjgkt"uwrrqtv"uvchh+0" 407""Fgukipcvkpi"Rctv{<"c"Rctv{"qt"Pqp/Rctv{"vjcv"fgukipcvgu"kphqtocvkqp"qt" 9" :" kvgou"vjcv"kv"rtqfwegu"kp"fkuenquwtgu"qt"kp"tgurqpugu"vq"fkueqxgt{"cu" ;" ÐEQPHKFGPVKCN0Ñ" 408""Fkuenquwtg"qt"Fkueqxgt{"Ocvgtkcn<"cnn"kvgou"qt"kphqtocvkqp."tgictfnguu"qh" 32" 33" vjg"ogfkwo"qt"ocppgt"kp"yjkej"kv"ku"igpgtcvgf."uvqtgf."qt"ockpvckpgf"*kpenwfkpi." 34" coqpi"qvjgt"vjkpiu."vguvkoqp{."vtcpuetkrvu."cpf"vcpikdng"vjkpiu+."vjcv"ctg"rtqfwegf" 35" qt"igpgtcvgf"kp"fkuenquwtgu"qt"tgurqpugu"vq"fkueqxgt{"kp"vjku"ocvvgt0" 409""Gzrgtv<"c"rgtuqp"ykvj"urgekcnk|gf"mpqyngfig"qt"gzrgtkgpeg"kp"c"ocvvgt" 36" 37" rgtvkpgpv"vq"vjg"nkvkicvkqp"yjq"jcu"dggp"tgvckpgf"d{"c"Rctv{"qt"kvu"eqwpugn"vq"ugtxg"cu" 38" cp"gzrgtv"ykvpguu"qt"cu"c"eqpuwnvcpv"kp"vjku"Cevkqp0" 39" 40:""Kp/Jqwug"Eqwpugn<"cvvqtpg{u"yjq"ctg"gornq{ggu"qh"c"rctv{"vq"vjku" 3:" Cevkqp0"Kp/Jqwug"Eqwpugn"fqgu"pqv"kpenwfg"Qwvukfg"Eqwpugn"qh"Tgeqtf"qt"cp{"qvjgt" 3;" qwvukfg"eqwpugn0" 40;""Pqp/Rctv{<"cp{"pcvwtcn"rgtuqp."rctvpgtujkr."eqtrqtcvkqp."cuuqekcvkqp"qt" 42" 43" qvjgt"ngicn"gpvkv{"pqv"pcogf"cu"c"Rctv{"vq"vjku"cevkqp0" 44" 4032""Qwvukfg"Eqwpugn"qh"Tgeqtf<"cvvqtpg{u"yjq"ctg"pqv"gornq{ggu"qh"c"rctv{" 45" vq"vjku"Cevkqp"dwv"ctg"tgvckpgf"vq"tgrtgugpv"qt"cfxkug"c"rctv{"vq"vjku"Cevkqp"cpf"jcxg" 46" crrgctgf"kp"vjku"Cevkqp"qp"dgjcnh"qh"vjcv"rctv{"qt"ctg"chhknkcvgf"ykvj"c"ncy"hkto"vjcv" 47" jcu"crrgctgf"qp"dgjcnh"qh"vjcv"rctv{."cpf"kpenwfgu"uwrrqtv"uvchh0" 4033""Rctv{<"cp{"rctv{"vq"vjku"Cevkqp."kpenwfkpi"cnn"qh"kvu"qhhkegtu."fktgevqtu." 48" 49" gornq{ggu."eqpuwnvcpvu."tgvckpgf"gzrgtvu."cpf"Qwvukfg"Eqwpugn"qh"Tgeqtf"*cpf"vjgkt" 4:" uwrrqtv"uvchhu+0" " " "" /7/" QTFGT"ITCPVKPI"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Ecug"Pq0<""4<3:/ex/32537"OYH*CITz+" " 4034""Rtqfwekpi"Rctv{<"c"Rctv{"qt"Pqp/Rctv{"vjcv"rtqfwegu"Fkuenquwtg"qt" 3" 4" Fkueqxgt{"Ocvgtkcn"kp"vjku"Cevkqp0" 4035""Rtqhguukqpcn"Xgpfqtu<"rgtuqpu"qt"gpvkvkgu"vjcv"rtqxkfg"nkvkicvkqp"uwrrqtv" 5" 6" ugtxkegu"*g0i0."rjqvqeqr{kpi."xkfgqvcrkpi."vtcpuncvkpi."rtgrctkpi"gzjkdkvu"qt" 7" fgoqpuvtcvkqpu."cpf"qticpk|kpi."uvqtkpi."qt"tgvtkgxkpi"fcvc"kp"cp{"hqto"qt"ogfkwo+" 8" cpf"vjgkt"gornq{ggu"cpf"uwdeqpvtcevqtu0" 4036""Rtqvgevgf"Ocvgtkcn<"cp{"Fkuenquwtg"qt"Fkueqxgt{"Ocvgtkcn"vjcv"ku" 9" :" fgukipcvgf"cu"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCN0Ñ" 4037""Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{<"c"Rctv{"vjcv"tgegkxgu"Fkuenquwtg"qt"Fkueqxgt{"Ocvgtkcn" ;" 32" htqo"c"Rtqfwekpi"Rctv{0" 33" 50"" UEQRG" 34" Vjg"rtqvgevkqpu"eqphgttgf"d{"vjku"Uvkrwncvkqp"cpf"Qtfgt"eqxgt"pqv"qpn{" 35" Rtqvgevgf"Ocvgtkcn"*cu"fghkpgf"cdqxg+."dwv"cnuq"*3+"cp{"kphqtocvkqp"eqrkgf"qt" 36" gzvtcevgf"htqo"Rtqvgevgf"Ocvgtkcn="*4+"cnn"eqrkgu."gzegtrvu."uwooctkgu."qt" 37" eqorkncvkqpu"qh"Rtqvgevgf"Ocvgtkcn="cpf"*5+"cp{"vguvkoqp{."eqpxgtucvkqpu."qt" 38" rtgugpvcvkqpu"d{"Rctvkgu"qt"vjgkt"Eqwpugn"vjcv"okijv"tgxgcn"Rtqvgevgf"Ocvgtkcn0" 39" Cp{"wug"qh"Rtqvgevgf"Ocvgtkcn"cv"vtkcn"ujcnn"dg"iqxgtpgf"d{"vjg"qtfgtu"qh"vjg"vtkcn" 3:" lwfig0"Vjku"Qtfgt"fqgu"pqv"iqxgtp"vjg"wug"qh"Rtqvgevgf"Ocvgtkcn"cv"vtkcn0" 3;" 60" FWTCVKQP" Qpeg"c"ecug"rtqeggfu"vq"vtkcn."kphqtocvkqp"vjcv"ycu"fgukipcvgf"cu" 42" 43" EQPHKFGPVKCN"qt"ockpvckpgf"rwtuwcpv"vq"vjku"rtqvgevkxg"qtfgt"wugf"qt" 44" kpvtqfwegf"cu"cp"gzjkdkv"cv"vtkcn"dgeqogu"rwdnke"cpf"yknn"dg"rtguworvkxgn{"cxckncdng" 45" vq"cnn"ogodgtu"qh"vjg"rwdnke."kpenwfkpi"vjg"rtguu."wpnguu"eqorgnnkpi"tgcuqpu" 46" uwrrqtvgf"d{"urgekhke"hcevwcn"hkpfkpiu"vq"rtqeggf"qvjgtykug"ctg"ocfg"vq"vjg"vtkcn" 47" lwfig"kp"cfxcpeg"qh"vjg"vtkcn0"See Kamakana."669"H05f"cv"33:2/:3"*fkuvkpiwkujkpi" 48" Ðiqqf"ecwugÑ"ujqykpi"hqt"ugcnkpi"fqewogpvu"rtqfwegf"kp"fkueqxgt{"htqo" 49" Ðeqorgnnkpi"tgcuqpuÑ"uvcpfctf"yjgp"ogtkvu/tgncvgf"fqewogpvu"ctg"rctv"qh"eqwtv" 4:" " " "" /8/" QTFGT"ITCPVKPI"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Ecug"Pq0<""4<3:/ex/32537"OYH*CITz+" " 3" tgeqtf+0"Ceeqtfkpin{."vjg"vgtou"qh"vjku"rtqvgevkxg"qtfgt"fq"pqv"gzvgpf"dg{qpf"vjg" 4" eqoogpegogpv"qh"vjg"vtkcn0" 5" 70" FGUKIPCVKPI"RTQVGEVGF"OCVGTKCN" 703" 6" Gzgtekug"qh"Tguvtckpv"cpf"Ectg"kp"Fgukipcvkpi"Ocvgtkcn"hqt"Rtqvgevkqp0" 7" Gcej"Rctv{"qt"Pqp/Rctv{"vjcv"fgukipcvgu"kphqtocvkqp"qt"kvgou"hqt"rtqvgevkqp"wpfgt" 8" vjku"Qtfgt"owuv"vcmg"ectg"vq"nkokv"cp{"uwej"fgukipcvkqp"vq"urgekhke"ocvgtkcn"vjcv" 9" swcnkhkgu"wpfgt"vjg"crrtqrtkcvg"uvcpfctfu0"Vjg"Fgukipcvkpi"Rctv{"owuv"fgukipcvg"hqt" :" rtqvgevkqp"qpn{"vjqug"rctvu"qh"ocvgtkcn."fqewogpvu."kvgou"qt"qtcn"qt"ytkvvgp" ;" eqoowpkecvkqpu"vjcv"swcnkh{"uq"vjcv"qvjgt"rqtvkqpu"qh"vjg"ocvgtkcn."fqewogpvu." 32" kvgou"qt"eqoowpkecvkqpu"hqt"yjkej"rtqvgevkqp"ku"pqv"ycttcpvgf"ctg"pqv"uygrv" 33" wplwuvkhkcdn{"ykvjkp"vjg"codkv"qh"vjku"Qtfgt0" Ocuu."kpfkuetkokpcvg"qt"tqwvkpk|gf"fgukipcvkqpu"ctg"rtqjkdkvgf0"Fgukipcvkqpu" 34" 35" vjcv"ctg"ujqyp"vq"dg"engctn{"wplwuvkhkgf"qt"vjcv"jcxg"dggp"ocfg"hqt"cp"kortqrgt" 36" rwtrqug"*g0i0."vq"wppgeguuctkn{"gpewodgt"vjg"ecug"fgxgnqrogpv"rtqeguu"qt"vq" 37" korqug"wppgeguuct{"gzrgpugu"cpf"dwtfgpu"qp"qvjgt"rctvkgu+"oc{"gzrqug"vjg" 38" Fgukipcvkpi"Rctv{"vq"ucpevkqpu0" 39" Kh"kv"eqogu"vq"c"Fgukipcvkpi"Rctv{Óu"cvvgpvkqp"vjcv"kphqtocvkqp"qt"kvgou"vjcv"kv" 3:" fgukipcvgf"hqt"rtqvgevkqp"fq"pqv"swcnkh{"hqt"rtqvgevkqp."vjcv"Fgukipcvkpi"Rctv{"owuv" 3;" rtqorvn{"pqvkh{"cnn"qvjgt"Rctvkgu"vjcv"kv"ku"ykvjftcykpi"vjg"kpcrrnkecdng"fgukipcvkqp0" 704""Ocppgt"cpf"Vkokpi"qh"Fgukipcvkqpu0"Gzegrv"cu"qvjgtykug"rtqxkfgf"kp" 42" 43" vjku"Qtfgt"*ugg."g0i0."ugeqpf"rctcitcrj"qh"ugevkqp"704*c+"dgnqy+."qt"cu"qvjgtykug" 44" uvkrwncvgf"qt"qtfgtgf."Fkuenquwtg"qt"Fkueqxgt{"Ocvgtkcn"vjcv"swcnkhkgu"hqt"rtqvgevkqp" 45" wpfgt"vjku"Qtfgt"owuv"dg"engctn{"uq"fgukipcvgf"dghqtg"vjg"ocvgtkcn"ku"fkuenqugf"qt" 46" rtqfwegf0" Fgukipcvkqp"kp"eqphqtokv{"ykvj"vjku"Qtfgt"tgswktgu<" 47" *c+" 48" hqt"kphqtocvkqp"kp"fqewogpvct{"hqto"*g0i0."rcrgt"qt"gngevtqpke" 49" fqewogpvu."dwv"gzenwfkpi"vtcpuetkrvu"qh"fgrqukvkqpu"qt"qvjgt"rtgvtkcn"qt"vtkcn" 4:" rtqeggfkpiu+."vjcv"vjg"Rtqfwekpi"Rctv{"chhkz"cv"c"okpkowo."vjg"ngigpf" " " "" /9/" QTFGT"ITCPVKPI"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Ecug"Pq0<""4<3:/ex/32537"OYH*CITz+" " 3" ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"*jgtgkpchvgt"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCN"ngigpfÑ+."vq"gcej"rcig"vjcv" 4" eqpvckpu"rtqvgevgf"ocvgtkcn0"Kh"qpn{"c"rqtvkqp"qh"vjg"ocvgtkcn"qp"c"rcig"swcnkhkgu"hqt" 5" rtqvgevkqp."vjg"Rtqfwekpi"Rctv{"cnuq"owuv"engctn{"kfgpvkh{"vjg"rtqvgevgf"rqtvkqp*u+" 6" *g0i0."d{"ocmkpi"crrtqrtkcvg"octmkpiu"kp"vjg"octikpu+0" 7" C"Rctv{"qt"Pqp/Rctv{"vjcv"ocmgu"qtkikpcn"fqewogpvu"cxckncdng"hqt"kpurgevkqp" 8" pggf"pqv"fgukipcvg"vjgo"hqt"rtqvgevkqp"wpvkn"chvgt"vjg"kpurgevkpi"Rctv{"jcu"kpfkecvgf" 9" yjkej"fqewogpvu"kv"yqwnf"nkmg"eqrkgf"cpf"rtqfwegf0"Fwtkpi"vjg"kpurgevkqp"cpf" :" dghqtg"vjg"fgukipcvkqp."cnn"qh"vjg"ocvgtkcn"ocfg"cxckncdng"hqt"kpurgevkqp"ujcnn"dg" ;" fggogf"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCN0Ñ"Chvgt"vjg"kpurgevkpi"Rctv{"jcu"kfgpvkhkgf"vjg" 32" fqewogpvu"kv"ycpvu"eqrkgf"cpf"rtqfwegf."vjg"Rtqfwekpi"Rctv{"owuv"fgvgtokpg" 33" yjkej"fqewogpvu."qt"rqtvkqpu"vjgtgqh.""swcnkh{""hqt""rtqvgevkqp""wpfgt""vjku""Qtfgt0"" 34" Vjgp."dghqtg"rtqfwekpi"vjg"urgekhkgf"fqewogpvu."vjg"Rtqfwekpi"Rctv{"owuv"chhkz"vjg" 35" ÐEQPHKFGPVKCN"ngigpfÑ"vq"gcej"rcig"vjcv"eqpvckpu"Rtqvgevgf"Ocvgtkcn0"Kh"qpn{"c" 36" rqtvkqp"qh"vjg"ocvgtkcn"qp"c"rcig"swcnkhkgu"hqt"rtqvgevkqp."vjg"Rtqfwekpi"Rctv{"cnuq" 37" owuv"engctn{"kfgpvkh{"vjg"rtqvgevgf"rqtvkqp*u+"*g0i0."d{"ocmkpi"crrtqrtkcvg"octmkpiu" 38" kp"vjg"octikpu+0" 39" *d+" hqt"vguvkoqp{"ikxgp"kp"fgrqukvkqpu"vjcv"vjg"Fgukipcvkpi"Rctv{" 3:" kfgpvkhkgu"vjg"Fkuenquwtg"qt"Fkueqxgt{"Ocvgtkcn"qp"vjg"tgeqtf."dghqtg"vjg"enqug"qh" 3;" vjg"fgrqukvkqp"cnn"rtqvgevgf"vguvkoqp{0" *e+" 42" hqt"kphqtocvkqp"rtqfwegf"kp"uqog"hqto"qvjgt"vjcp"fqewogpvct{" 43" cpf"hqt"cp{"qvjgt"vcpikdng"kvgou."vjcv"vjg"Rtqfwekpi"Rctv{"chhkz"kp"c"rtqokpgpv"rnceg" 44" qp"vjg"gzvgtkqt"qh"vjg"eqpvckpgt"qt"eqpvckpgtu"kp"yjkej"vjg"kphqtocvkqp"ku"uvqtgf"vjg" 45" ngigpf"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCN0Ñ"Kh"qpn{"c"rqtvkqp"qt"rqtvkqpu"qh"vjg"kphqtocvkqp" 46" ycttcpvu"rtqvgevkqp."vjg"Rtqfwekpi"Rctv{."vq"vjg"gzvgpv"rtcevkecdng."ujcnn"kfgpvkh{"vjg" 47" rtqvgevgf"rqtvkqp*u+0" 705"Kpcfxgtvgpv"Hcknwtgu"vq"Fgukipcvg0"Kh"vkogn{"eqttgevgf."cp"kpcfxgtvgpv" 48" 49" hcknwtg"vq"fgukipcvg"swcnkhkgf"kphqtocvkqp"qt"kvgou"fqgu"pqv."uvcpfkpi"cnqpg."yckxg" 4:" vjg"Fgukipcvkpi"Rctv{Óu"tkijv"vq"ugewtg"rtqvgevkqp"wpfgt"vjku"Qtfgt"hqt"uwej" " " "" /:/" QTFGT"ITCPVKPI"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Ecug"Pq0<""4<3:/ex/32537"OYH*CITz+" " 3" ocvgtkcn0"Wrqp"vkogn{"eqttgevkqp"qh"c"fgukipcvkqp."vjg"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"owuv"ocmg" 4" tgcuqpcdng"ghhqtvu"vq"cuuwtg"vjcv"vjg"ocvgtkcn"ku"vtgcvgf"kp"ceeqtfcpeg"ykvj"vjg" 5" rtqxkukqpu"qh"vjku"Qtfgt0" 6" 80" EJCNNGPIKPI"EQPHKFGPVKCNKV["FGUKIPCVKQPU" 7" 803""Vkokpi"qh"Ejcnngpigu0"Cp{"Rctv{"qt"Pqp/Rctv{"oc{"ejcnngpig"c" 8" fgukipcvkqp"qh"eqphkfgpvkcnkv{"cv"cp{"vkog"vjcv"ku"eqpukuvgpv"ykvj"vjg"EqwtvÓu" 9" Uejgfwnkpi"Qtfgt0" 804""Oggv"cpf"Eqphgt0"Vjg"Ejcnngpikpi"Rctv{"ujcnn"kpkvkcvg"vjg"fkurwvg" :" ;" tguqnwvkqp"rtqeguu"wpfgt"Nqecn"Twng"59/3"gv"ugs0" 805"Vjg"dwtfgp"qh"rgtuwcukqp"kp"cp{"uwej"ejcnngpig"rtqeggfkpi"ujcnn"dg"qp" 32" 33" vjg"Fgukipcvkpi"Rctv{0"Htkxqnqwu"ejcnngpigu."cpf"vjqug"ocfg"hqt"cp"kortqrgt" 34" rwtrqug"*g0i0."vq"jctcuu"qt"korqug"wppgeguuct{"gzrgpugu"cpf"dwtfgpu"qp"qvjgt" 35" rctvkgu+"oc{"gzrqug"vjg"Ejcnngpikpi"Rctv{"vq"ucpevkqpu0"Wpnguu"vjg"Fgukipcvkpi" 36" Rctv{"jcu"yckxgf"qt"ykvjftcyp"vjg"eqphkfgpvkcnkv{"fgukipcvkqp."cnn"rctvkgu"ujcnn" 37" eqpvkpwg"vq"chhqtf"vjg"ocvgtkcn"kp"swguvkqp"vjg"ngxgn"qh"rtqvgevkqp"vq"yjkej"kv"ku" 38" gpvkvngf"wpfgt"vjg"Rtqfwekpi"Rctv{Óu"fgukipcvkqp"wpvkn"vjg"Eqwtv"twngu"qp"vjg" 39" ejcnngpig0" 3:" 90" CEEGUU"VQ"CPF"WUG"QH"RTQVGEVGF"OCVGTKCN" 3;" 903""Dcuke"Rtkpekrngu0"C"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"oc{"wug"Rtqvgevgf"Ocvgtkcn"vjcv"ku" 42" fkuenqugf"qt"rtqfwegf"d{"cpqvjgt"Rctv{"qt"d{"c"Pqp/Rctv{"kp"eqppgevkqp"ykvj"vjku" 43" Cevkqp"qpn{"hqt"rtqugewvkpi."fghgpfkpi"qt"cvvgorvkpi"vq"ugvvng"vjku"Cevkqp0"Uwej" 44" Rtqvgevgf"Ocvgtkcn"oc{"dg"fkuenqugf"qpn{"vq"vjg"ecvgiqtkgu"qh"rgtuqpu"cpf"wpfgt"vjg" 45" eqpfkvkqpu"fguetkdgf"kp"vjku"Qtfgt0"Yjgp"vjg"Cevkqp"jcu"dggp"vgtokpcvgf."c" 46" Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"owuv"eqorn{"ykvj"vjg"rtqxkukqpu"qh"ugevkqp"35"dgnqy"*HKPCN" 47" FKURQUKVKQP+0" Rtqvgevgf"Ocvgtkcn"owuv"dg"uvqtgf"cpf"ockpvckpgf"d{"c"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"cv"c" 48" 49" nqecvkqp"cpf"kp"c"ugewtg"ocppgt"vjcv"gpuwtgu"vjcv"ceeguu"ku"nkokvgf"vq"vjg"rgtuqpu" 4:" cwvjqtk|gf"wpfgt"vjku"Qtfgt0" " " "" /;/" QTFGT"ITCPVKPI"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Ecug"Pq0<""4<3:/ex/32537"OYH*CITz+" " 3" 904""Fkuenquwtg"qh"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"Kphqtocvkqp"qt"Kvgou0"Wpnguu" 4" qvjgtykug"qtfgtgf"d{"vjg"eqwtv"qt"rgtokvvgf"kp"ytkvkpi"d{"vjg"Fgukipcvkpi"Rctv{."c" 5" Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"oc{"fkuenqug"cp{"kphqtocvkqp"qt"kvgo"fgukipcvgf" 6" ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"qpn{"vq<" 7" *c+" vjg"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{Óu"Qwvukfg"Eqwpugn"qh"Tgeqtf"kp"vjku"Cevkqp." 8" cu"ygnn"cu"gornq{ggu"qh"uckf"Qwvukfg"Eqwpugn"qh"Tgeqtf"vq"yjqo"kv"ku"tgcuqpcdn{" 9" pgeguuct{"vq"fkuenqug"vjg"kphqtocvkqp"hqt"vjku"Cevkqp=" *d+" :" ;" 32" vjg"qhhkegtu."fktgevqtu."cpf"gornq{ggu"*kpenwfkpi"Jqwug" Eqwpugn+"qh"vjg"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"vq"yjqo"fkuenquwtg"ku"tgcuqpcdn{"pgeguuct{"hqt"vjku" Cevkqp=" *e+" 33" Gzrgtvu"*cu"fghkpgf"kp"vjku"Qtfgt+"qh"vjg"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"vq" 34" yjqo"fkuenquwtg"ku"tgcuqpcdn{"pgeguuct{"hqt"vjku"Cevkqp"cpf"yjq"jcxg"ukipgf"vjg" 35" ÐCempqyngfiogpv"cpf"Citggogpv"vq"Dg"DqwpfÑ"*Gzjkdkv"C+=" 36" *f+" vjg"eqwtv"cpf"kvu"rgtuqppgn=" 37" *g+" eqwtv"tgrqtvgtu"cpf"vjgkt"uvchh=" 38" *h+" rtqhguukqpcn"lwt{"qt"vtkcn"eqpuwnvcpvu."oqem"lwtqtu."cpf" 39" Rtqhguukqpcn"Xgpfqtu"vq"yjqo"fkuenquwtg"ku"tgcuqpcdn{"pgeguuct{"hqt"vjku"Cevkqp" 3:" cpf"yjq"jcxg"ukipgf"vjg"ÐCempqyngfiogpv"cpf"Citggogpv"vq"Dg"DqwpfÑ"*Gzjkdkv" 3;" C+=" *i+" 42" 43" vjg"cwvjqt"qt"tgekrkgpv"qh"c"fqewogpv"eqpvckpkpi"vjg"kphqtocvkqp" qt"c"ewuvqfkcp"qt"qvjgt"rgtuqp"yjq"qvjgtykug"rquuguugf"qt"mpgy"vjg"kphqtocvkqp=" *j+" 44" fwtkpi"vjgkt"fgrqukvkqpu."ykvpguugu."cpf"cvvqtpg{u"hqt"ykvpguugu." 45" kp"vjg"Cevkqp"vq"yjqo"fkuenquwtg"ku"tgcuqpcdn{"pgeguuct{"rtqxkfgf<"*3+"vjg" 46" fgrqukpi"rctv{"tgswguvu"vjcv"vjg"ykvpguu"ukip"vjg"hqto"cvvcejgf"cu"Gzjkdkv"3"jgtgvq=" 47" cpf"*4+"vjg{"yknn"pqv"dg"rgtokvvgf"vq"mggr"cp{"eqphkfgpvkcn"kphqtocvkqp"wpnguu"vjg{" 48" ukip"vjg"ÐCempqyngfiogpv"cpf"Citggogpv"vq"Dg"DqwpfÑ"*Gzjkdkv""C+."wpnguu" 49" qvjgtykug"citggf"d{"vjg"Fgukipcvkpi"Rctv{"qt"qtfgtgf"d{"vjg"eqwtv0"Rcigu"qh" 4:" vtcpuetkdgf"fgrqukvkqp"vguvkoqp{"qt"gzjkdkvu"vq"fgrqukvkqpu"vjcv"tgxgcn"Rtqvgevgf" " " "" /32/" QTFGT"ITCPVKPI"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Ecug"Pq0<""4<3:/ex/32537"OYH*CITz+" " 3" Ocvgtkcn"oc{"dg"ugrctcvgn{"dqwpf"d{"vjg"eqwtv"tgrqtvgt"cpf"oc{"pqv"dg"fkuenqugf"vq" 4" cp{qpg"gzegrv"cu"rgtokvvgf"wpfgt"vjku"Uvkrwncvgf"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt="cpf" *k+" 5" cp{"ogfkcvqt"qt"ugvvngogpv"qhhkegt."cpf"vjgkt"uwrrqtvkpi" 6" rgtuqppgn."owvwcnn{"citggf"wrqp"d{"cp{"qh"vjg"rctvkgu"gpicigf"kp"ugvvngogpv" 7" fkuewuukqpu0" 8" :0" RTQVGEVGF"OCVGTKCN"UWDRQGPCGF"QT"QTFGTGF"RTQFWEGF" 9" KP"QVJGT"NKVKICVKQP" :" Kh"c"Rctv{"ku"ugtxgf"ykvj"c"uwdrqgpc"qt"c"eqwtv"qtfgt"kuuwgf"kp"qvjgt"nkvkicvkqp" ;" 32" vjcv"eqorgnu"fkuenquwtg"qh"cp{"kphqtocvkqp"qt"kvgou"fgukipcvgf"kp"vjku"Cevkqp"cu" ÐEQPHKFGPVKCN.Ñ"vjcv"Rctv{"owuv<" *c+" 33" 34" rtqorvn{"pqvkh{"kp"ytkvkpi"vjg"Fgukipcvkpi"Rctv{0"Uwej" pqvkhkecvkqp"ujcnn"kpenwfg"c"eqr{"qh"vjg"uwdrqgpc"qt"eqwtv"qtfgt=" *d+" 35" rtqorvn{"pqvkh{"kp"ytkvkpi"vjg"rctv{"yjq"ecwugf"vjg"uwdrqgpc"qt" 36" qtfgt"vq"kuuwg"kp"vjg"qvjgt"nkvkicvkqp"vjcv"uqog"qt"cnn"qh"vjg"ocvgtkcn"eqxgtgf"d{"vjg" 37" uwdrqgpc"qt"qtfgt"ku"uwdlgev"vq"vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt0"Uwej"pqvkhkecvkqp"ujcnn"kpenwfg" 38" c"eqr{"qh"vjku"Uvkrwncvgf"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt="cpf" *e+" 39" 3:" eqqrgtcvg"ykvj"tgurgev"vq"cnn"tgcuqpcdng"rtqegfwtgu"uqwijv"vq"dg" rwtuwgf"d{"vjg"Fgukipcvkpi"Rctv{"yjqug"Rtqvgevgf"Ocvgtkcn"oc{"dg"chhgevgf0" Kh"vjg"Fgukipcvkpi"Rctv{"vkogn{"uggmu"c"rtqvgevkxg"qtfgt."vjg"Rctv{" 3;" 42" ugtxgf"ykvj"vjg"uwdrqgpc"qt"eqwtv"qtfgt"ujcnn"pqv"rtqfweg"cp{"kphqtocvkqp" 43" fgukipcvgf"kp"vjku"cevkqp"cu"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"dghqtg"c"fgvgtokpcvkqp"d{"vjg"eqwtv" 44" htqo"yjkej"vjg"uwdrqgpc"qt"qtfgt"kuuwgf."wpnguu"vjg"Rctv{"jcu"qdvckpgf"vjg" 45" Fgukipcvkpi"Rctv{Óu"rgtokuukqp0"Vjg"Fgukipcvkpi"Rctv{"ujcnn"dgct"vjg"dwtfgp"cpf" 46" gzrgpug"qh"uggmkpi"rtqvgevkqp"kp"vjcv"eqwtv"qh"kvu"eqphkfgpvkcn"ocvgtkcn"cpf"pqvjkpi" 47" kp"vjgug"rtqxkukqpu"ujqwnf"dg"eqpuvtwgf"cu"cwvjqtk|kpi"qt"gpeqwtcikpi"c"Tgegkxkpi" 48" Rctv{"kp"vjku"Cevkqp"vq"fkuqdg{"c"ncyhwn"fktgevkxg"htqo"cpqvjgt"eqwtv0" 49" 1"1"1" 4:" 1"1"1" " " "" /33/" QTFGT"ITCPVKPI"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Ecug"Pq0<""4<3:/ex/32537"OYH*CITz+" " 3" ;0" C"PQP/RCTV[ÓU"RTQVGEVGF"OCVGTKCN"UQWIJV"VQ"DG" RTQFWEGF"KP"VJKU"NKVKICVKQP" 4" *c+" 5" Vjg"vgtou"qh"vjku"Qtfgt"ctg"crrnkecdng"vq"kphqtocvkqp"rtqfwegf" 6" d{"c"Pqp/Rctv{"kp"vjku"Cevkqp"cpf"fgukipcvgf"cu"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCN0Ñ"Uwej" 7" kphqtocvkqp"rtqfwegf"d{"Pqp/Rctvkgu"kp"eqppgevkqp"ykvj"vjku"nkvkicvkqp"ku"rtqvgevgf" 8" d{"vjg"tgogfkgu"cpf"tgnkgh"rtqxkfgf"d{"vjku"Qtfgt0"Pqvjkpi"kp"vjgug"rtqxkukqpu" 9" ujqwnf"dg"eqpuvtwgf"cu"rtqjkdkvkpi"c"Pqp/Rctv{"htqo"uggmkpi"cffkvkqpcn"rtqvgevkqpu0" *d+" :" Kp"vjg"gxgpv"vjcv"c"Rctv{"ku"tgswktgf."d{"c"xcnkf"fkueqxgt{" ;" tgswguv."vq"rtqfweg"c"Pqp/Rctv{Óu"eqphkfgpvkcn"kphqtocvkqp"kp"kvu"rquuguukqp."cpf"vjg" 32" Rctv{"ku"uwdlgev"vq"cp"citggogpv"ykvj"vjg"Pqp/Rctv{"pqv"vq"rtqfweg"vjg"Pqp/Rctv{Óu" 33" eqphkfgpvkcn"kphqtocvkqp."vjgp"vjg"Rctv{"ujcnn<" *3+" 34" rtqorvn{"pqvkh{"kp"ytkvkpi"vjg"Tgswguvkpi"Rctv{"cpf"vjg" 35" Pqp/Rctv{"vjcv"uqog"qt"cnn"qh"vjg"kphqtocvkqp"tgswguvgf"ku"uwdlgev"vq"c" 36" eqphkfgpvkcnkv{"citggogpv"ykvj"c"Pqp/Rctv{=" *4+" 37" rtqorvn{"rtqxkfg"vjg"Pqp/Rctv{"ykvj"c"eqr{"qh"vjg" 38" Uvkrwncvgf"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt"kp"vjku"Cevkqp."vjg"tgngxcpv"fkueqxgt{"tgswguv*u+."cpf"c" 39" tgcuqpcdn{"urgekhke"fguetkrvkqp"qh"vjg"kphqtocvkqp"tgswguvgf="cpf" *5+" 3:" 3;" ocmg"vjg"kphqtocvkqp"tgswguvgf"cxckncdng"hqt"kpurgevkqp" d{"vjg"Pqp/Rctv{."kh"tgswguvgf0" *e+" 42" Kh"vjg"Pqp/Rctv{"hcknu"vq"uggm"c"rtqvgevkxg"qtfgt"htqo"vjku"eqwtv"ykvjkp" 43" 36"fc{u"qh"tgegkxkpi"vjg"pqvkeg"cpf"ceeqorcp{kpi"kphqtocvkqp."vjg"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{" 44" oc{"rtqfweg"vjg"Pqp/Rctv{Óu"eqphkfgpvkcn"kphqtocvkqp"tgurqpukxg"vq"vjg"fkueqxgt{" 45" tgswguv0"Kh"vjg"Pqp/Rctv{"vkogn{"uggmu"c"rtqvgevkxg"qtfgt."vjg"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"ujcnn" 46" pqv"rtqfweg"cp{"kphqtocvkqp"kp"kvu"rquuguukqp"qt"eqpvtqn"vjcv"ku"uwdlgev"vq"vjg" 47" eqphkfgpvkcnkv{"citggogpv"ykvj"vjg"Pqp/Rctv{"dghqtg"c"fgvgtokpcvkqp"d{"vjg"eqwtv0" 48" Cdugpv"c"eqwtv"qtfgt"vq"vjg"eqpvtct{."vjg"Pqp/Rctv{"ujcnn"dgct"vjg"dwtfgp"cpf" 49" gzrgpug"qh"uggmkpi"rtqvgevkqp"kp"vjku"eqwtv"qh"kvu"Rtqvgevgf"Ocvgtkcn0" 4:" 1"1"1" " " "" /34/" QTFGT"ITCPVKPI"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Ecug"Pq0<""4<3:/ex/32537"OYH*CITz+" " 3" 320" WPCWVJQTK¥GF"FKUENQUWTG"QH"RTQVGEVGF"OCVGTKCN" Kh"c"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"ngctpu"vjcv."d{"kpcfxgtvgpeg"qt"qvjgtykug."kv"jcu"fkuenqugf" 4" 5" Rtqvgevgf"Ocvgtkcn"vq"cp{"rgtuqp"qt"kp"cp{"ektewouvcpeg"pqv"cwvjqtk|gf"wpfgt"vjku" 6" Uvkrwncvgf"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt."vjg"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"owuv"koogfkcvgn{"*c+"pqvkh{"kp" 7" ytkvkpi"vjg"Fgukipcvkpi"Rctv{"qh"vjg"wpcwvjqtk|gf"fkuenquwtgu."*d+"wug"kvu"dguv" 8" ghhqtvu"vq"tgvtkgxg"cnn"wpcwvjqtk|gf"eqrkgu"qh"vjg"Rtqvgevgf"Ocvgtkcn."*e+"kphqto"vjg" 9" rgtuqp"qt"rgtuqpu"vq"yjqo"wpcwvjqtk|gf"fkuenquwtgu"ygtg"ocfg"qh"cnn"vjg"vgtou"qh" :" vjku"Qtfgt."cpf"*f+"tgswguv"uwej"rgtuqp"qt"rgtuqpu"vq"gzgewvg"vjg"ÐCempqyngfiogpv" ;" cpf"Citggogpv"vq"Dg"DqwpfÑ"vjcv"ku"cvvcejgf"jgtgvq"cu"Gzjkdkv"C0" 32" 330" KPCFXGTVGPV"RTQFWEVKQP"QH"RTKXKNGIGF"QT"QVJGTYKUG" 33" RTQVGEVGF"OCVGTKCN" 34" Yjgp"c"Rtqfwekpi"Rctv{"ikxgu"pqvkeg"vq"Tgegkxkpi"Rctvkgu"vjcv"egtvckp" 35" kpcfxgtvgpvn{"rtqfwegf"ocvgtkcn"ku"uwdlgev"vq"c"encko"qh"rtkxkngig"qt"qvjgt" 36" rtqvgevkqp."vjg"qdnkicvkqpu"qh"vjg"Tgegkxkpi"Rctvkgu"ctg"vjqug"ugv"hqtvj"kp"Hgfgtcn" 37" Twng"qh"Ekxkn"Rtqegfwtg"48*d+*7+*D+0"Vjku"rtqxkukqp"ku"pqv"kpvgpfgf"vq"oqfkh{" 38" yjcvgxgt"rtqegfwtg"oc{"dg"guvcdnkujgf"kp"cp"g/fkueqxgt{"qtfgt"vjcv"rtqxkfgu"hqt" 39" rtqfwevkqp"ykvjqwv"rtkqt"rtkxkngig"tgxkgy0"Rwtuwcpv"vq"Hgfgtcn"Twng"qh"Gxkfgpeg" 3:" 724*f+"cpf"*g+."kpuqhct"cu"vjg"rctvkgu"tgcej"cp"citggogpv"qp"vjg"ghhgev"qh"fkuenquwtg" 3;" qh"c"eqoowpkecvkqp"qt"kphqtocvkqp"eqxgtgf"d{""vjg""cvvqtpg{/enkgpv""rtkxkngig""qt"" 42" yqtm"rtqfwev"rtqvgevkqp."vjg"rctvkgu"oc{"kpeqtrqtcvg"vjgkt"citggogpv"kp"vjg" 43" uvkrwncvgf"rtqvgevkxg"qtfgt"uwdokvvgf"vq"vjg"eqwtv0" 44" 340" 3403" Tkijv"vq"Hwtvjgt"Tgnkgh0"Pqvjkpi"kp"vjku"Qtfgt"cdtkfigu"vjg"tkijv"qh"cp{" 45" 46" OKUEGNNCPGQWU" rgtuqp"vq"uggm"kvu"oqfkhkecvkqp"d{"vjg"Eqwtv"kp"vjg"hwvwtg0" 47" 3404" Tkijv"vq"Cuugtv"Qvjgt"Qdlgevkqpu0"D{"uvkrwncvkpi"vq"vjg"gpvt{"qh"vjku" 48" Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt."pq"Rctv{"yckxgu"cp{"tkijv"kv"qvjgtykug"yqwnf"jcxg"vq"qdlgev"vq" 49" fkuenqukpi"qt"rtqfwekpi"cp{"kphqtocvkqp"qt"kvgo"qp"cp{"itqwpf"pqv"cfftguugf"kp" 4:" vjku"Uvkrwncvgf"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt0"Ukoknctn{."pq"Rctv{"yckxgu"cp{"tkijv"vq"qdlgev"qp" " " "" /35/" QTFGT"ITCPVKPI"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Ecug"Pq0<""4<3:/ex/32537"OYH*CITz+" " 3" cp{"itqwpf"vq"wug"kp"gxkfgpeg"qh"cp{"qh"vjg"ocvgtkcn"eqxgtgf"d{"vjku"Rtqvgevkxg" 4" Qtfgt0" 5" 3405" Hknkpi"Rtqvgevgf"Ocvgtkcn0"C"Rctv{"vjcv"uggmu"vq"hkng"wpfgt"ugcn"cp{" 6" Rtqvgevgf"Ocvgtkcn"owuv"eqorn{"ykvj"Nqecn"Ekxkn"Twng"9;/70"Rtqvgevgf"Ocvgtkcn" 7" oc{"qpn{"dg"hkngf"wpfgt"ugcn"rwtuwcpv"vq"c"eqwtv"qtfgt"cwvjqtk|kpi"vjg"ugcnkpi"qh"vjg" 8" urgekhke"Rtqvgevgf"Ocvgtkcn"cv"kuuwg0"Kh"c"Rctv{Óu"tgswguv"vq"hkng"Rtqvgevgf"Ocvgtkcn" 9" wpfgt"ugcn"ku"fgpkgf"d{"vjg"eqwtv."vjgp"vjg"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"oc{"hkng"vjg"kphqtocvkqp" :" kp"vjg"rwdnke"tgeqtf"wpnguu"qvjgtykug"kpuvtwevgf"d{"vjg"eqwtv0""Vjg"rctvkgu"citgg"vq" ;" oggv"cpf"eqphgt"vq"fgvgtokpg"kh"pqp/ocvgtkcn"kphqtocvkqp"ecp"dg"tgfcevgf"vq"rtqvgev" 32" vjg"kfgpvkv{"qh"vjktf"rctvkgu"yjkej"yqwnf"cnnqy"hqt"vjg"hknkpi"qh"ugpukvkxg"vjktf"rctv{" 33" kphqtocvkqp"*k0g0."tgfcev"pcogu"cpf"cfftguugu+0""" 34" 350" HKPCN"FKURQUKVKQP" Chvgt"vjg"hkpcn"fkurqukvkqp"qh"vjku"Cevkqp."cu"fghkpgf"kp"rctcitcrj"6."ykvjkp"82" 35" 36" fc{u"qh"c"ytkvvgp"tgswguv"d{"vjg"Fgukipcvkpi"Rctv{."gcej"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"owuv" 37" tgvwtp"cnn"Rtqvgevgf"Ocvgtkcn"vq"vjg"Rtqfwekpi"Rctv{"qt"fguvtq{"uwej"ocvgtkcn0"Cu" 38" wugf"kp"vjku"uwdfkxkukqp."Ðcnn"Rtqvgevgf"OcvgtkcnÑ"kpenwfgu"cnn"eqrkgu."cduvtcevu." 39" eqorkncvkqpu."uwooctkgu."cpf"cp{"qvjgt"hqtocv"tgrtqfwekpi"qt"ecrvwtkpi"cp{"qh"vjg" 3:" Rtqvgevgf"Ocvgtkcn0"Yjgvjgt"vjg"Rtqvgevgf"Ocvgtkcn"ku"tgvwtpgf"qt"fguvtq{gf."vjg" 3;" Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"owuv"uwdokv"c"ytkvvgp"egtvkhkecvkqp"vq"vjg"Rtqfwekpi"Rctv{"*cpf."kh" 42" pqv"vjg"ucog"rgtuqp"qt"gpvkv{."vq"vjg"Fgukipcvkpi"Rctv{+"d{"vjg"82"fc{"fgcfnkpg"vjcv" 43" *3+"kfgpvkhkgu"*d{"ecvgiqt{."yjgtg"crrtqrtkcvg+"cnn"vjg"Rtqvgevgf"Ocvgtkcn"vjcv"ycu" 44" tgvwtpgf"qt"fguvtq{gf"cpf"*4+"chhktou"vjcv"vjg"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"jcu"pqv"tgvckpgf"cp{" 45" eqrkgu."cduvtcevu."eqorkncvkqpu."uwooctkgu"qt"cp{"qvjgt"hqtocv"tgrtqfwekpi"qt" 46" ecrvwtkpi"cp{"qh"vjg"Rtqvgevgf"Ocvgtkcn0"Pqvykvjuvcpfkpi"vjku"rtqxkukqp."Eqwpugn" 47" ctg"gpvkvngf"vq"tgvckp"cp"ctejkxcn"eqr{"qh"cnn"rngcfkpiu."oqvkqp"rcrgtu."vtkcn." 48" fgrqukvkqp."cpf"jgctkpi"vtcpuetkrvu."ngicn"ogoqtcpfc."eqttgurqpfgpeg."fgrqukvkqp" 49" cpf"vtkcn"gzjkdkvu."gzrgtv"tgrqtvu."cvvqtpg{"yqtm"rtqfwev."cpf"eqpuwnvcpv"cpf"gzrgtv" 4:" yqtm"rtqfwev."gxgp"kh"uwej"ocvgtkcnu"eqpvckp"Rtqvgevgf"Ocvgtkcn0"Cp{"uwej"ctejkxcn" " " "" /36/" QTFGT"ITCPVKPI"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Ecug"Pq0<""4<3:/ex/32537"OYH*CITz+" " 3" eqrkgu"vjcv"eqpvckp"qt"eqpuvkvwvg"Rtqvgevgf"Ocvgtkcn"tgockp"uwdlgev"vq"vjku"Rtqvgevkxg" 4" Qtfgt0" 5" 360"XKQNCVKQP" Cp{"xkqncvkqp"qh"vjku"Qtfgt"oc{"dg"rwpkujgf"d{"crrtqrtkcvg"ogcuwtgu" 6" 7" kpenwfkpi."ykvjqwv"nkokvcvkqp."eqpvgorv"rtqeggfkpiu"cpf1qt"oqpgvct{"ucpevkqpu0" 8" " 9" " :" HQT"IQQF"ECWUG"UJQYP."KV"KU"UQ"QTFGTGF0" ;" FCVGF<""Qevqdgt"32."423;" 32" " 33" aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa" aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa Cnkekc"I0"Tqugpdgti" Cnkekc I0 Tqugpdgti Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu"Ocikuvtcvg"Lwfig" " 34" 35" 36" 37" 38" 39" 3:" 3;" 42" 43" 44" 45" 46" 47" 48" 49" 4:" " " "" /37/" QTFGT"ITCPVKPI"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Ecug"Pq0<""4<3:/ex/32537"OYH*CITz+" " 3" GZJKDKV"C" 4" CEMPQYNGFIOGPV"CPF"CITGGOGPV"VQ"DG"DQWPF" 5" K."aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa"]rtkpv"qt"v{rg"hwnn"pcog_."qh" 6" aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa]rtkpv"qt"v{rg"hwnn"cfftguu_."fgenctg"wpfgt"rgpcnv{" 7" qh"rgtlwt{"vjcv"K"jcxg"tgcf"kp"kvu"gpvktgv{"cpf"wpfgtuvcpf"vjg"Uvkrwncvgf"Rtqvgevkxg" 8" Qtfgt"vjcv"ycu"kuuwgf"d{"vjg"Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu"Fkuvtkev"Eqwtv"hqt"vjg"Egpvtcn"Fkuvtkev"qh" 9" Ecnkhqtpkc"qp"]fcvg_"kp"vjg"ecug"qh"DeProspo v. Stern Brothers, Ecug"Pq0"4<3:/ex/ :" 32537"OYH*CITz+0""K"citgg"vq"eqorn{"ykvj"cpf"vq"dg"dqwpf"d{"cnn"vjg"vgtou"qh" ;" vjku"Uvkrwncvgf"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt"cpf"K"wpfgtuvcpf"cpf"cempqyngfig"vjcv"hcknwtg"vq"uq" 32" eqorn{"eqwnf"gzrqug"og"vq"ucpevkqpu"cpf"rwpkujogpv"kp"vjg"pcvwtg"qh"eqpvgorv0"K" 33" uqngopn{"rtqokug"vjcv"K"yknn"pqv"fkuenqug"kp"cp{"ocppgt"cp{"kphqtocvkqp"qt"kvgo" 34" vjcv"ku"uwdlgev"vq"vjku"Uvkrwncvgf"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt"vq"cp{"rgtuqp"qt"gpvkv{"gzegrv"kp" 35" uvtkev"eqornkcpeg"ykvj"vjg"rtqxkukqpu"qh"vjku"Qtfgt0" 36" K"hwtvjgt"citgg"vq"uwdokv"vq"vjg"lwtkufkevkqp"qh"vjg"Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu"Fkuvtkev"Eqwtv"hqt" 37" vjg"Egpvtcn"Fkuvtkev"qh"Ecnkhqtpkc"hqt"gphqtekpi"vjg"vgtou"qh"vjku"Uvkrwncvgf" 38" Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt."gxgp"kh"uwej"gphqtegogpv"rtqeggfkpiu"qeewt"chvgt"vgtokpcvkqp"qh" 39" vjku"cevkqp0" 3:" K"jgtgd{"crrqkpv"aaaaaaaaaaaaa"]rtkpv"qt"v{rg"hwnn"pcog_"qh"aaaaaaaaaaaa"]rtkpv" 3;" qt"v{rg"hwnn"cfftguu"cpf"vgngrjqpg"pwodgt_"cu"o{"Ecnkhqtpkc"cigpv"hqt"ugtxkeg"qh" 42" rtqeguu"kp"eqppgevkqp"ykvj"vjku"cevkqp"qt"cp{"rtqeggfkpiu"tgncvgf"vq"gphqtegogpv"qh" 43" vjku"Uvkrwncvgf"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt0" 44" Fcvg<"aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa" 45" Ekv{"cpf"Uvcvg"yjgtg"uyqtp"cpf"ukipgf<"aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa"" 46" Rtkpvgf"pcog<"aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa" 47" " 48" Ukipcvwtg<"aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa" 49" 4:" " " "" /38/" QTFGT"ITCPVKPI"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Ecug"Pq0<""4<3:/ex/32537"OYH*CITz+" " RTQQH"QH"UGTXKEG" 3" 4" K."Ogncpkg"N0"Fwpecp."fgenctg<" 5" K"co"c"ekvk|gp"qh"vjg"Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu"cpf"gornq{gf"kp"Nqu"Cpigngu"Eqwpv{." 6" Ecnkhqtpkc0""K"co"qxgt"vjg"cig"qh"gkijvggp"{gctu"cpf"pqv"c"rctv{"vq"vjg"ykvjkp/gpvkvngf" 7" cevkqp0""O{"dwukpguu"cfftguu"ku"3:::"Egpvwt{"Rctm"G0."Uwkvg"3922."Nqu"Cpigngu." 8" Ecnkhqtpkc";2289/39430""Qp"Qevqdgt";."423;."K"ugtxgf"c"eqr{"qh"vjg"ykvjkp" 9" fqewogpv*u+<" ]RTQRQUGF_"QTFGT"ITCPVKPI"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" :" Y d{"rncekpi"vjg"fqewogpv*u+"nkuvgf"cdqxg"kp"c"ugcngf"gpxgnqrg"ykvj"rquvcig" ;" vjgtgqp"hwnn{"rtgrckf."kp"vjg"Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu"ockn"cv"Nqu"Cpigngu."Ecnkhqtpkc" cfftguugf"cu"ugv"hqtvj"dgnqy0" 32" 33" d{"rncekpi"vjg"fqewogpv*u+"nkuvgf"cdqxg"kp"c"ugcngf"HgfZ"gpxgnqrg."chhkzkpi" c"rtg/rckf"ckt"dknn."ecwukpi"kv"vq"dg"fgnkxgtgf"vq"c"HgfZ"cigpv"hqt"fgnkxgt{0" 34" d{"vtcpuokvvkpi"xkc"g/ockn"qt"gngevtqpke"vtcpuokuukqp"vjg"fqewogpv*u+"nkuvgf" 35" cdqxg"vq"vjg"rgtuqp*u+"cv"vjg"g/ockn"cfftguu*gu+"ugv"hqtvj"dgnqy0" Cognkc"Cnxctg|."Gus0" Octxkp"Mtcmqy."Gus0" Cngzcpfgt"Mtcmqy"("Inkem"NNR" 3;22"Cxgpwg"qh"vjg"Uvctu."Uwkvg";22" Nqu"Cpigngu."EC";2289/6532" 36" 37" 38" 39" 3:" 3;" 42" 43" 44" 45" 46" 47" K"co"tgcfkn{"hcoknkct"ykvj"vjg"hktoÓu"rtcevkeg"qh"eqnngevkqp"cpf"rtqeguukpi" eqttgurqpfgpeg"hqt"ocknkpi0""Wpfgt"vjcv"rtcevkeg"kv"yqwnf"dg"fgrqukvgf"ykvj"vjg" W0U0"Rquvcn"Ugtxkeg"qp"vjcv"ucog"fc{"ykvj"rquvcig"vjgtgqp"hwnn{"rtgrckf"kp"vjg" qtfkpct{"eqwtug"qh"dwukpguu0""K"co"cyctg"vjcv"qp"oqvkqp"qh"vjg"rctv{"ugtxgf."ugtxkeg" ku"rtguwogf"kpxcnkf"kh"rquvcn"ecpegnncvkqp"fcvg"qt"rquvcig"ogvgt"fcvg"ku"oqtg"vjcp" qpg"fc{"chvgt"fcvg"qh"fgrqukv"hqt"ocknkpi"kp"chhkfcxkv0" K"fgenctg"vjcv"K"co"gornq{gf"kp"vjg"qhhkeg"qh"c"ogodgt"qh"vjg"dct"qh"vjku"eqwtv" cv"yjqug"fktgevkqp"vjg"ugtxkeg"ycu"ocfg0" Gzgewvgf"qp"Qevqdgt";."423;."cv"Nqu"Cpigngu."Ecnkhqtpkc0" 48" 49" Ogncpkg"N0"Fwpecp" 4:" " " 39" RTQQH"QH"UGTXKEG" " Ecug"Pq0<""4<3:/ex/32537"OYH*CITz+"
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
