Consuelo Mata-Salazar v. Nancy A. Berryhill, No. 2:2017cv02530 - Document 21 (C.D. Cal. 2018)
Court Description: DECISION AND ORDER by Magistrate Judge Victor E Bianchini. IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that: Judgment be entered REVERSING the Commissioner's Decision and REMANDING this matter for further proceedings consistent with this Decision and Order. (See document for further details.) (sbou)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Consuelo Mata-Salazar v. Nancy A. Berryhill Doc. 21 Q" 3 4 " 5 " Sept. 30, 2018 JR " 6 WPKVGF"UVCVGU"FKUVTKEV"EQWTV" 7 EGPVTCN"FKUVTKEV"QH"ECNKHQTPKC" 8 9 : ; 32 33 34 " EQPUWGNQ"OCVC/UCNC¥CT." " """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""Rnckpvkhh." " xu0" " PCPE["DGTT[JKNN."Cevkpi" Eqookuukqpgt"qh"Uqekcn"Ugewtkv{." " """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""Fghgpfcpv0" " Ecug"Pq0"4<39/EX/24752"*XGD+" " " " FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT" " " 35 " 36 K0"KPVTQFWEVKQP"" 37 38 39 " Kp"Fgegodgt"qh"4234."Rnckpvkhh"Eqpuwgnq"Ocvc/Ucnc|ct"crrnkgf"hqt"Fkucdknkv{" Kpuwtcpeg" dgpghkvu" cpf" Uwrrngogpvcn" Ugewtkv{" Kpeqog" dgpghkvu" wpfgt" vjg" Uqekcn" Ugewtkv{"Cev0"Vjg"Eqookuukqpgt"qh"Uqekcn"Ugewtkv{"fgpkgf"vjg"crrnkecvkqpu0" 3: 3; 42 1 FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"OCVC/UCNC¥CT"x"DGTT[JKNN"4<39/EX/24752" " " Dockets.Justia.com 3 " Rnckpvkhh."d{"cpf"vjtqwij"jgt"cvvqtpg{."Rcvtkekc"N0" OeEcdg." Gus0"eqoogpegf" 4 vjku"cevkqp"uggmkpi"lwfkekcn"tgxkgy"qh"vjg"EqookuukqpgtÓu"fgpkcn"qh"dgpghkvu"rwtuwcpv" 5 vq"64"W0U0E0"¸¸"627"*i+"cpf"35:5"*e+*5+0""" 6 " 7 *Fqemgv" Pq0" 34." 35+0" Qp" Oc{" 43." 423:." vjku" ecug" ycu" tghgttgf" vq" vjg" wpfgtukipgf" 8 rwtuwcpv"vq"Igpgtcn"Qtfgt"27/290"*Fqemgv"Pq0"42+0"" 9 " Vjg"rctvkgu"eqpugpvgf"vq"vjg"lwtkufkevkqp"qh"c"Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu"Ocikuvtcvg"Lwfig0" KK0"DCEMITQWPF" : ; " Rnckpvkhh" crrnkgf" hqt" dgpghkvu" qp" Fgegodgt" 32." 4234." cnngikpi" fkucdknkv{" 32 dgikppkpi"Qevqdgt"36."42330"*V"cv"48+03""Vjg"crrnkecvkqpu"ygtg"fgpkgf"kpkvkcnn{"cpf" 33 qp" tgeqpukfgtcvkqp0" " Rnckpvkhh" tgswguvgf" c" jgctkpi" dghqtg" cp" Cfokpkuvtcvkxg" Ncy" 34 Lwfig"*ÐCNLÑ+0""" 35 " 36 Rnckpvkhh" crrgctgf" ykvj" jgt" cvvqtpg{" cpf" vguvkhkgf0" *V" cv" 73/84+0" " Vjg" CNL" cnuq" 37 tgegkxgf"vguvkoqp{"Pkem"Eqtuq."c"xqecvkqpcn"gzrgtv0"*V"cv"84/89+0" 38 """ 39 hqt" dgpghkvu0" " *V" cv" 42/62+0" " Vjg" CNLÓu" fgekukqp" dgecog" vjg" EqookuukqpgtÓu" hkpcn" Qp" Lwpg" 4." 4237." c" jgctkpi" ycu" jgnf" dghqtg" CNL" Dctdctc" Fwpp0" *V" cv" 68+0"" Qp"Lwn{"44."4237."vjg"CNL"kuuwgf"c"ytkvvgp"fgekukqp"fgp{kpi"vjg"crrnkecvkqpu" 3: 3; 42 "Ekvcvkqpu"vq"*ÐVÑ+"tghgt"vq"vjg"cfokpkuvtcvkxg"tgeqtf"vtcpuetkrv"cv"Fqemgv"Pq0"3:0" 2 FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"OCVC/UCNC¥CT"x"DGTT[JKNN"4<39/EX/24752" " " 3 fgekukqp"qp"Lcpwct{"49."4239."yjgp"vjg"Crrgcnu"Eqwpekn"fgpkgf"RnckpvkhhÓu"tgswguv" 4 hqt"tgxkgy0"*V"cv"3/:+0" 5 " 6 cevkqp"uggmkpi"lwfkekcn"tgxkgy"qh"vjg"EqookuukqpgtÓu"fgpkcn"qh"dgpghkvu0"*Fqemgv"Pq0" 7 3+0" Vjg" Eqookuukqpgt" kpvgtrqugf" cp" Cpuygt" qp" Ugrvgodgt" 8." 42390" *Fqemgv" Pq0" 8 39+0""Vjg"rctvkgu"hkngf"c"Lqkpv"Uvkrwncvkqp"qp"Fgegodgt"3."42390"*Fqemgv"Pq0"3;+0" 9 " : vjku"Eqwtv"hkpfu"vjcv"vjg"EqookuukqpgtÓu"fgekukqp"owuv"dg"tgxgtugf"cpf"vjku"ecug"dg" ; tgocpfgf"hqt"hwtvjgt"rtqeggfkpiu0" 32 Qp" Octej" 53." 4239." Rnckpvkhh." cevkpi" d{" cpf" vjtqwij" jgt" eqwpugn." hkngf" vjku" Chvgt" tgxkgykpi" vjg" rngcfkpiu." Lqkpv" Uvkrwncvkqp." cpf" cfokpkuvtcvkxg" tgeqtf." " KKK0"FKUEWUUKQP" 33 34 C0"" Ugswgpvkcn"Gxcnwcvkqp"Rtqeguu" 35 " Vjg" Uqekcn" Ugewtkv{" Cev" *Ðvjg" CevÑ+" fghkpgu" fkucdknkv{" cu" vjg" Ðkpcdknkv{" vq" 36 gpicig" kp" cp{" uwduvcpvkcn" ickphwn" cevkxkv{" d{" tgcuqp" qh" cp{" ogfkecnn{" fgvgtokpcdng" 37 rj{ukecn"qt"ogpvcn"korcktogpv"yjkej"ecp"dg"gzrgevgf"vq"tguwnv"kp"fgcvj"qt"yjkej"jcu" 38 ncuvgf" qt" ecp" dg" gzrgevgf" vq" ncuv" hqt" c" eqpvkpwqwu" rgtkqf" qh" pqv" nguu" vjcp" vygnxg" 39 oqpvju0Ñ" 64" W0U0E0" ¸¸" 645*f+*3+*C+." 35:4e*c+*5+*C+0" Vjg" Cev" cnuq" rtqxkfgu" vjcv" c" 3: enckocpv"ujcnn"dg"fgvgtokpgf"vq"dg"wpfgt"c"fkucdknkv{"qpn{"kh"cp{"korcktogpvu"ctg"qh" 3; uwej" ugxgtkv{" vjcv" jg" qt" ujg" ku" pqv" qpn{" wpcdng" vq" fq" rtgxkqwu" yqtm" dwv" ecppqv." 42 3 FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"OCVC/UCNC¥CT"x"DGTT[JKNN"4<39/EX/24752" " " 3 eqpukfgtkpi" jku" qt" jgt" cig." gfwecvkqp" cpf" yqtm" gzrgtkgpegu." gpicig" kp" cp{" qvjgt" 4 uwduvcpvkcn"yqtm"yjkej"gzkuvu"kp"vjg"pcvkqpcn"geqpqo{0"64"W0U0E0"¸¸"645*f+*4+*C+." 5 35:4e*c+*5+*D+0" Vjwu." vjg" fghkpkvkqp" qh" fkucdknkv{" eqpukuvu" qh" dqvj" ogfkecn" cpf" 6 xqecvkqpcn"eqorqpgpvu0"Edlund v. Massanari."475"H05f"3374."3378"*;vj"Ekt0"4223+0" 7 " 8 hqt"fgvgtokpkpi"yjgvjgt"c"rgtuqp"ku"fkucdngf0"42"E0H0T0"¸¸"62603742."6380;420"Uvgr" 9 qpg" fgvgtokpgu" kh" vjg" rgtuqp" ku" gpicigf" kp" uwduvcpvkcn" ickphwn" cevkxkvkgu0" Kh" uq." : dgpghkvu" ctg" fgpkgf0" 42" E0H0T0" ¸¸" 6260" 3742*c+*6+*k+." 6380;42*c+*6+*k+0" Kh" pqv." vjg" ; fgekukqp"ocmgt"rtqeggfu"vq"uvgr"vyq."yjkej"fgvgtokpgu"yjgvjgt"vjg"enckocpv"jcu"c" 32 ogfkecnn{" ugxgtg" korcktogpv" qt" eqodkpcvkqp" qh" korcktogpvu0" 42" E0H0T0" ¸¸" 33 62603742*c+*6+*kk+."6380;42*c+*6+*kk+0" " 34 " 35 korcktogpvu." vjg" fkucdknkv{" encko" ku" fgpkgf0" Kh" vjg" korcktogpv" ku" ugxgtg." vjg" 36 gxcnwcvkqp"rtqeggfu"vq"vjg"vjktf"uvgr."yjkej"eqorctgu"vjg"enckocpvÓu"korcktogpv*u+" 37 ykvj" c" pwodgt" qh" nkuvgf" korcktogpvu" cempqyngfigf" d{" vjg" Eqookuukqpgt" vq" dg" uq" 38 ugxgtg" cu" vq" rtgenwfg" uwduvcpvkcn" ickphwn" cevkxkv{0" 42" E0H0T0" ¸¸" 62603742*c+*6+*kkk+." 39 6380;42*c+*6+*kkk+=" 42" E0H0T0" ¸" 626" Uwdrv0" R" Crr0" 30" Kh" vjg" korcktogpv" oggvu" qt" 3: gswcnu" qpg" qh" vjg" nkuvgf" korcktogpvu." vjg" enckocpv" ku" eqpenwukxgn{" rtguwogf" vq" dg" 3; fkucdngf0" Kh" vjg" korcktogpv" ku" pqv" qpg" eqpenwukxgn{" rtguwogf" vq" dg" fkucdnkpi." vjg" 42 4 Vjg" Eqookuukqpgt" jcu" guvcdnkujgf" c" hkxg/uvgr" ugswgpvkcn" gxcnwcvkqp" rtqeguu" " " " " " Kh" vjg" enckocpv" fqgu" pqv" jcxg" c" ugxgtg" korcktogpv" qt" eqodkpcvkqp" qh" FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"OCVC/UCNC¥CT"x"DGTT[JKNN"4<39/EX/24752" " " 3 gxcnwcvkqp" rtqeggfu" vq" vjg" hqwtvj" uvgr." yjkej" fgvgtokpgu" yjgvjgt" vjg" korcktogpv" 4 rtgxgpvu"vjg"enckocpv"htqo"rgthqtokpi"yqtm"yjkej"ycu"rgthqtogf"kp"vjg"rcuv0"Kh"vjg" 5 enckocpv" ku" cdng" vq" rgthqto" rtgxkqwu" yqtm." jg" qt" ujg" ku" fggogf" pqv" fkucdngf0" 42" 6 E0H0T0"¸¸"62603742*c+*6+*kx+."6380;42*c+*6+*kx+0"Cv"vjku"uvgr."vjg"enckocpvÓu"tgukfwcn" 7 hwpevkqpcn"ecrcekv{"*THE+"ku"eqpukfgtgf0"Kh"vjg"enckocpv"ecppqv"rgthqto"rcuv"tgngxcpv" 8 yqtm."vjg"hkhvj"cpf"hkpcn"uvgr"kp"vjg"rtqeguu"fgvgtokpgu"yjgvjgt"jg"qt"ujg"ku"cdng"vq" 9 rgthqto"qvjgt"yqtm"kp"vjg"pcvkqpcn"geqpqo{"kp"xkgy"qh"jku"qt"jgt"tgukfwcn"hwpevkqpcn" : ecrcekv{."cig."gfwecvkqp."cpf"rcuv"yqtm"gzrgtkgpeg0"42"E0H0T0"¸¸"62603742*c+*6+*x+." ; 6380;42*c+*6+*x+="Bowen v0"Yuckert."6:4"W0U0"359"*3;:9+0"" " " " 32 " Vjg"kpkvkcn"dwtfgp"qh"rtqqh"tguvu"wrqp"vjg"enckocpv"vq"guvcdnkuj"c"prima facie" 33 ecug"qh"gpvkvngogpv"vq"fkucdknkv{"dgpghkvu0"Rhinehart v. Finch."65:"H04f";42.";43"*;vj" 34 Ekt0"3;93+="Meanel v. Apfel."394"H05f"3333."3335"*;vj"Ekt0"3;;;+0"Vjg"kpkvkcn"dwtfgp" 35 ku" ogv"qpeg"vjg"enckocpv" guvcdnkujgu"vjcv"c" ogpvcn"qt"rj{ukecn"korcktogpv"rtgxgpvu" 36 vjg" rgthqtocpeg" qh" rtgxkqwu" yqtm0" Vjg" dwtfgp" vjgp" ujkhvu." cv" uvgr" hkxg." vq" vjg" 37 Eqookuukqpgt" vq" ujqy" vjcv" *3+" rnckpvkhh" ecp" rgthqto" qvjgt" uwduvcpvkcn" ickphwn" 38 cevkxkv{"cpf"*4+""c"Ðukipkhkecpv"pwodgt"qh"lqdu"gzkuv"kp"vjg"pcvkqpcn"geqpqo{Ñ"vjcv"vjg" 39 enckocpv"ecp"rgthqto0"Kail v. Heckler."944"H04f"36;8."36;:"*;vj"Ekt0"3;:6+0" " 3: 3; 42 5 FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"OCVC/UCNC¥CT"x"DGTT[JKNN"4<39/EX/24752" " " 3 D0" Uvcpfctf"qh"Tgxkgy" 4 " Eqpitguu"jcu"rtqxkfgf"c"nkokvgf"ueqrg"qh"lwfkekcn"tgxkgy"qh"c"EqookuukqpgtÓu" 5 fgekukqp0" 64" W0U0E0" ¸" 627*i+0" C" Eqwtv" owuv" wrjqnf" c" EqookuukqpgtÓu" fgekukqp." 6 ocfg" vjtqwij" cp" CNL." yjgp" vjg" fgvgtokpcvkqp" ku" pqv" dcugf" qp" ngicn" gttqt" cpf" ku" 7 uwrrqtvgf"d{"uwduvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg0"See Jones v. Heckler."982"H04f";;5.";;7"*;vj"Ekt0" 8 3;:7+="Tackett v. Apfel."3:2"H05f"32;6."32;9"*;vj"Ekt0"3;;;+0"" 9 " : wrjgnf" kh" vjg" hkpfkpiu" qh" hcev" ctg" uwrrqtvgf" d{" uwduvcpvkcn" gxkfgpeg0Ñ" Delgado v. ; Heckler." 944" H04f" 792." 794" *;vj" Ekt0" 3;:5+*ekvkpi" 64" W0U0E0" ¸" 627*i++0" Uwduvcpvkcn" 32 gxkfgpeg"ku"oqtg"vjcp"c"ogtg"uekpvknnc."Sorenson v. Weinberger."736"H04f"3334."333;" 33 p"32"*;vj"Ekt0"3;97+."dwv"nguu"vjcp"c"rtgrqpfgtcpeg0"McAllister v. Sullivan.":::"H04f" 34 7;;." 823/24" *;vj" Ekt0" 3;:;+0" Uwduvcpvkcn" gxkfgpeg" Ðogcpu" uwej" gxkfgpeg" cu" c" 35 tgcuqpcdng" okpf" okijv" ceegrv" cu" cfgswcvg" vq" uwrrqtv" c" eqpenwukqp0Ñ" Richardson v. 36 Perales." 624" W0U0" 5:;." 623" *3;93+*ekvcvkqpu" qokvvgf+0" Ð]U_wej" kphgtgpegu" cpf" 37 eqpenwukqpu" cu" vjg" ]Eqookuukqpgt_" " oc{" tgcuqpcdn{" ftcy" htqo" vjg" gxkfgpegÑ" yknn" 38 cnuq"dg"wrjgnf0"Mark v. Celebreeze."56:"H04f"4:;."4;5"*;vj"Ekt0"3;87+0"Qp"tgxkgy." 39 vjg" Eqwtv" eqpukfgtu" vjg" tgeqtf" cu" c" yjqng." pqv" lwuv" vjg" gxkfgpeg" uwrrqtvkpi" vjg" 3: fgekukqp" qh" vjg" Eqookuukqpgt0" Weetman v. Sullivan." :99" H04f" 42." 44" *;vj" Ekt0" 3; 3;:;+*swqvkpi"Kornock v. Harris."86:"H04f"747."748"*;vj"Ekt0"3;:2++0" " 42 ÐVjg" ]EqookuukqpgtÓu_" fgvgtokpcvkqp" vjcv" c" rnckpvkhh" ku" pqv" fkucdngf" yknn" dg" " 6 FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"OCVC/UCNC¥CT"x"DGTT[JKNN"4<39/EX/24752" " " 3 " Kv" ku" vjg" tqng" qh" vjg" Eqookuukqpgt." pqv" vjku" Eqwtv." vq" tguqnxg" eqphnkevu" kp" 4 gxkfgpeg0""Richardson."624"W0U0"cv"6220"Kh"gxkfgpeg"uwrrqtvu"oqtg"vjcp"qpg"tcvkqpcn" 5 kpvgtrtgvcvkqp." vjg" Eqwtv" oc{" pqv" uwduvkvwvg" kvu" lwfiogpv" hqt" vjcv" qh" vjg" 6 Eqookuukqpgt0"Tackett."3:2"H05f"cv"32;9="Allen v. Heckler."96;"H04f"799."79;"*;vj" 7 Ekt0" 3;:6+0" Pgxgtvjgnguu." c" fgekukqp" uwrrqtvgf" d{" uwduvcpvkcn" gxkfgpeg" yknn" uvknn" dg" 8 ugv"cukfg"kh"vjg"rtqrgt"ngicn"uvcpfctfu"ygtg"pqv"crrnkgf"kp"ygkijkpi"vjg"gxkfgpeg"cpf" 9 ocmkpi"vjg"fgekukqp0"Brawner v. Secretary of Health and Human Services.":5;"H04f" : 654." 655" *;vj" Ekt0" 3;:9+0" Vjwu." kh" vjgtg" ku" uwduvcpvkcn" gxkfgpeg" vq" uwrrqtv" vjg" ; cfokpkuvtcvkxg"hkpfkpiu."qt"kh"vjgtg"ku"eqphnkevkpi"gxkfgpeg"vjcv"yknn"uwrrqtv"c"hkpfkpi" 32 qh"gkvjgt"fkucdknkv{"qt"pqp/fkucdknkv{."vjg"hkpfkpi"qh"vjg"Eqookuukqpgt"ku"eqpenwukxg0" 33 Sprague v. Bowen.":34"H04f"3448."344;/52"*;vj"Ekt0"3;:9+0"""" 34 E0" EqookuukqpgtÓu"Fgekukqp" 35 " Vjg" CNL" fgvgtokpgf" vjcv" Rnckpvkhh" jcf" pqv" gpicigf" kp" uwduvcpvkcn" ickphwn" 36 cevkxkv{" ukpeg" Qevqdgt" 36." 4233." vjg" cnngigf" qpugv" fcvg." cpf" ogv" vjg" kpuwtgf" uvcvwu" 37 tgswktgogpvu"qh"vjg"Uqekcn"Ugewtkv{"Cev"vjtqwij"Fgegodgt"53."4236"*vjg"Ðfcvg"ncuv" 38 kpuwtgfÑ+0" *V" cv" 4;+0" " Vjg" CNL" hqwpf" vjcv" RnckpvkhhÓu" vjqtceke" cpf" nwodct" urkpg" 39 fgigpgtcvkxg" fkue" fkugcug." nghv" ujqwnfgt" quvgqctvjtkvku." dkncvgtcn" mpgg" quvgqctvjtkvku." 3: j{rgtvgpukqp."qdgukv{."fkcdgvgu"ognnkvwu."nghv"ujqwnfgt"cfjgukxg"ecruwnkvku."vgpfkpquku" 3; 42 7 FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"OCVC/UCNC¥CT"x"DGTT[JKNN"4<39/EX/24752" " " 3 ykvj"nqy/itcfg"rctvkcn"vgctkpi"qh"vjg"uwrtcurkpcvwu"vgpfqp."cpf"nghv"gct"vkppkvwu"ygtg" 4 ÐugxgtgÑ"korcktogpvu"wpfgt"vjg"Cev0"*Vt0"4;+0""" 5 " 6 eqodkpcvkqp" qh" korcktogpvu" vjcv"ogv" qt" ogfkecnn{" gswcngf" qpg" qh" vjg" korcktogpvu" 7 ugv"hqtvj"kp"vjg"Nkuvkpiu0"*V"cv"54+0""" 8 " 9 *ÐTHEÑ+" vq" rgthqto" nkijv" yqtm." cu" fghkpgf" kp" 42" EHT" ¸" 62603789" *d+." cu" hqnnqyu<" : nkhvkpi1ectt{kpi" wr" vq" 32" rqwpfu" htgswgpvn{" cpf" wr" vq" 42" rqwpfu" qeecukqpcnn{=" ; ukvvkpi1uvcpfkpi1ycnmkpi" wr" vq" 8" jqwtu" kp" cp" :/jqwt" yqtmfc{=" pq" enkodkpi" qh" 32 ncffgtu1tqrgu1uechhqnfu=" pq" yqtm" ctqwpf"jc|ctfqwu" eqpfkvkqpu=" qeecukqpcn" enkodkpi" 33 qh"tcoru1uvcktu."qeecukqpcn"rgthqtocpeg"qh"rquvwtcn"oqxgogpvu."qeecukqpcn"qxgtjgcf" 34 tgcejkpi"ykvj"vjg"nghv"wrrgt"gzvtgokv{="cpf"pq"yqtm"vcumu"ctqwpf"gzeguukxg"pqkug0"*V" 35 cv"54+0" 36 " 37 ugykpi"ocejkpg"qrgtcvqt"cpf"uocnn"rtqfwevu"cuugodngt0"*V"cv"57+0""Ceeqtfkpin{."vjg" 38 CNL" fgvgtokpgf" vjcv" Rnckpvkhh" ycu" pqv" fkucdngf" ykvjkp" vjg" ogcpkpi" qh" vjg" Uqekcn" 39 Ugewtkv{" Cev" dgvyggp" Qevqdgt" 36." 4233" *vjg" cnngigf" qpugv" fcvg+"cpf" Lwn{" 44." 4237" 3: *vjg" fcvg" qh" vjg" fgekukqp+" cpf" ycu" vjgtghqtg" pqv" gpvkvngf" vq" dgpghkvu0" *V" cv" 58+0" Cu" Jqygxgt." vjg" CNL" eqpenwfgf" vjcv" Rnckpvkhh" fkf" pqv" jcxg" cp" korcktogpv" qt" Vjg" CNL" fgvgtokpgf" vjcv" Rnckpvkhh" tgvckpgf" vjg" tgukfwcn" hwpevkqpcn" ecrcekv{" Vjg" CNL" eqpenwfgf" vjcv" Rnckpvkhh" eqwnf" rgthqto" jgt" rcuv" tgngxcpv" yqtm" cu" c" 3; 42 8 FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"OCVC/UCNC¥CT"x"DGTT[JKNN"4<39/EX/24752" " " 3 pqvgf"cdqxg."vjg"CNLÓu"fgekukqp"dgecog"vjg"EqookuukqpgtÓu"hkpcn"fgekukqp"yjgp"vjg" 4 Crrgcnu"Eqwpekn"fgpkgf"RnckpvkhhÓu"tgswguv"hqt"tgxkgy0"*V"cv"3/:+0" 5 F0" Fkurwvgf"Kuuwgu" 6 " Cu"ugv"hqtvj"kp"vjg"Lqkpv"Uvkrwncvkqp"*Fqemgv"Pq0"3;+."Rnckpvkhh"qhhgtu"vjtgg"*5+" 7 ockp"ctiwogpvu"kp"uwrrqtv"qh"jgt"encko"vjcv"vjg"EqookuukqpgtÓu"fgekukqp"ujqwnf"dg" 8 tgxgtugf0""Hktuv."ujg"eqpvgpfu"vjcv"vjg"CNLÓu"uvgr"vyq"cpcn{uku"ycu"hncygf0""Ugeqpf." 9 Rnckpvkhh" qdlgevu" vq" vjg" CNLÓu" THE" fgvgtokpcvkqp0" " Vjktf." Rnckpvkhh" ejcnngpigu" vjg" : CNLÓu"etgfkdknkv{"fgvgtokpcvkqp0""Vjku"Eqwtv"yknn"cfftguu"gcej"ctiwogpv"kp"vwtp0" ; " KX0"CPCN[UKU" 32 33 C0" Uvgr"Vyq"Cpcn{uku" 34 " Cv" uvgr" vyq" qh" vjg" ugswgpvkcn" gxcnwcvkqp" rtqeguu." vjg" CNL" owuv" fgvgtokpg" 35 yjgvjgt" vjg" enckocpv" jcu" c" ÐugxgtgÑ" korcktogpv0" Ugg" 42" E0H0T0" ¸¸" 62603742*e+." 36 6380;42*e+0" " Vjg" hcev" vjcv" c" enckocpv" jcu" dggp" fkcipqugf" ykvj" cpf" vtgcvgf" hqt" c" 37 ogfkecnn{" fgvgtokpcdng" korcktogpv" fqgu" pqv" pgeguuctkn{" ogcp" vjg" korcktogpv" ku" 38 Ðugxgtg.Ñ" cu" fghkpgf" d{" vjg" Uqekcn" Ugewtkv{" Tgiwncvkqpu0" See, e.g.." Fair v. Bowen." 39 ::7"H04f"7;9."825"*;vj"Ekt0"3;:;+="Key v. Heckler."976"H04f"3767."376;/72"*;vj"Ekt0" 3: 3;:7+0" Vq" guvcdnkuj" ugxgtkv{." vjg" gxkfgpeg" owuv" ujqy" vjg" fkcipqugf" korcktogpv" 3; 42 9 FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"OCVC/UCNC¥CT"x"DGTT[JKNN"4<39/EX/24752" " " 3 ukipkhkecpvn{"nkokvu"c"enckocpv)u"rj{ukecn"qt"ogpvcn"cdknkv{"vq"fq"dcuke"yqtm"cevkxkvkgu" 4 hqt"cv"ngcuv"34"eqpugewvkxg"oqpvju0"42"E0H0T0"¸"6380;42*e+0""" 5 " 6 eqornckpvu0"Smolen v. Chater.":2"H05f"3495."34;2"*;vj"Ekt0"3;;8+0"Ð]C_p"korcktogpv" 7 ku"hqwpf"pqv"ugxgtg"0"0"0"yjgp"ogfkecn"gxkfgpeg"guvcdnkujgu"qpn{"c"unkijv"cdpqtocnkv{" 8 qt"c"eqodkpcvkqp"qh"unkijv"cdpqtocnkvkgu"yjkej"yqwnf"jcxg"pq"oqtg"vjcp"c"okpkocn" 9 ghhgev"qp"cp"kpfkxkfwcnÓu"cdknkv{"vq"yqtm0Ñ"Yuckert v. Bowen.":63"H04f"525"*;vj"Ekt0" : 3;::+"*swqvkpi"UUT":7/4:+0""Vjg"enckocpv"dgctu"vjg"dwtfgp"qh"rtqqh"cv"vjku"uvcig"cpf" ; vjg"Ðugxgtkv{"tgswktgogpv"ecppqv"dg"ucvkuhkgf"yjgp"ogfkecn"gxkfgpeg"ujqyu"vjcv"vjg" 32 rgtuqp" jcu" vjg" cdknkv{" vq" rgthqto" dcuke" yqtm" cevkxkvkgu." cu" tgswktgf" kp" oquv" lqdu0Ñ" 33 UUT":7/4:0"" 34 " 35 rwnnkpi." tgcejkpi." ectt{kpi." qt" jcpfnkpi=" uggkpi." jgctkpi." urgcmkpi=" wpfgtuvcpfkpi." 36 ectt{kpi" qwv" cpf" tgogodgtkpi" ukorng" kpuvtwevkqpu=" tgurqpfkpi" crrtqrtkcvgn{" vq" 37 uwrgtxkukqp."eqyqtmgtu."cpf"wuwcn"yqtm"ukvwcvkqpu0Ñ"Id." 38 " 39 fkue" fkugcug." nghv" ujqwnfgt" quvgqctvjtkvku." dkncvgtcn" mpgg" quvgqctvjtkvku." j{rgtvgpukqp." 3: qdgukv{." fkcdgvgu" ognnkvwu." nghv" ujqwnfgt" cfjgukxg" ecruwnkvku." vgpfkpquku" ykvj" nqy/ Vjg"uvgr"vyq"cpcn{uku"ku"c"uetggpkpi"fgxkeg"fgukipgf"vq"fkurqug"qh"de minimis" Dcuke" yqtm" cevkxkvkgu" kpenwfg<" Ðycnmkpi." uvcpfkpi." ukvvkpi." nkhvkpi." rwujkpi." Jgtg." vjg" CNL" hqwpf" vjcv" RnckpvkhhÓu" vjqtceke" cpf" nwodct" urkpg" fgigpgtcvkxg" 3; 42 10 FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"OCVC/UCNC¥CT"x"DGTT[JKNN"4<39/EX/24752" " " 3 itcfg"rctvkcn"vgctkpi"qh"vjg"uwrtcurkpcvwu"vgpfqp."cpf"nghv"gct"vkppkvwu"ygtg"ÐugxgtgÑ" 4 korcktogpvu"wpfgt"vjg"Uqekcn"Ugewtkv{"Cev0"*Vt0"4;+0""" 5 " 6 fgrtguukqp"cu"ugxgtg"korcktogpvu0" 7 " 30" 8 " Vjg" CNL" tgeqipk|gf" RnckpvkhhÓu" fkcdgvgu" cu" c" ugxgtg" korcktogpv0" *V" cv" 53+0"" 9 Vjg" CNL" pgxgtvjgnguu" hqwpf" Ðpq" gxkfgpeg" qh" cp{" ejtqpke" eqornkecvkqp" fwg" vq" È" : fkcdgvguÑ" cpf" Ðpq" gxkfgpeg" ]vjcv" fkcdgvgu_" kpvgthgtgf" ykvj" ]RnckpvkhhÓu_" rtgxkqwu" ; cdknkv{"vq"uwuvckp"yqtm"cevkxkv{0Ñ"*V"cv"55+0""" Rnckpvkhh" ctiwgu" vjcv" vjg" CNL" ujqwnf" jcxg" kpenwfgf" pgwtqrcvj{." cpzkgv{." cpf" Pgwtqrcvj{" 32 " Jqygxgt." kp" Cwiwuv" qh" 4233." Rnckpvkhh" ycu" fkcipqugf" ykvj" rgtkrjgtcn" 33 pgwtqrcvj{"*c"rckphwn"pgtxg"eqpfkvkqp"cuuqekcvgf"ykvj"fkcdgvgu"vjcv"ecwugu"ygcmpguu." 34 pwodpguu." cpf" rckp" kp" vjg" jcpfu" cpf" hggv+" cpf" rtguetkdgf" Pgwtqpvkp." c" rckp" 35 ogfkecvkqp" qhvgp" wugf" vq" vtgcv" vjg" eqpfkvkqp0" *V" cv" 568+0" " C" rtqitguu" pqvg" htqo" 36 Ugrvgodgt"qh"4234"fqewogpvgf"eqornckpvu"qh"dwtpkpi"hqqv"rckp"cpf"c"fkcipquku"qh" 37 pgwtqrcvj{0"*V"cv"576+0""C"fkcipquku"qh"rgtkrjgtcn"pgwtqrcvj{"ycu"pqvgf"kp"Octej"qh" 38 42350"*V"cv"56:+0""Kp"Lwpg"qh"4235."c"rtqitguu"pqvg"fguetkdgf"RnckpvkhhÓu"fkcdgvgu"cu" 39 dgkpi"rqqtn{"eqpvtqnngf"cpf"cickp"kpfkecvgf"c"fkcipquku"qh"pgwtqrcvj{0"*V"cv"735+0""Kp" 3: Pqxgodgt" qh" 4236." Rnckpvkhh" ycu" vtgcvgf" hqt" c" hqqv" ngukqp." ykvj" jgt" fkcipquku" qh" 3; rgtkrjgtcn"pgwtqrcvj{"cickp"tghgtgpegf0"*V"cv"782+0""Kp"Lcpwct{"qh"4237."Rnckpvkhh"ycu" 42 11 FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"OCVC/UCNC¥CT"x"DGTT[JKNN"4<39/EX/24752" " " 3 rtguetkdgf" Ðfkcdgvke" ujqguÑ" vq" jgnr" ykvj" umkp" dtgcmfqyp" kp" jgt" hggv0" *V" cv" 77:+0"" 4 Rnckpvkhh"vguvkhkgf"cu"vq"rckphwn"uqtgu"qp"jgt"hggv."cu"ygnn"cu"pwodpguu"cpf"vkpinkpi"kp" 5 jgt"jcpfu"cpf"hggv0"*V"cv"76."7:/82+0" 6 " 7 vjcv"vjgtg"ycu"Ðpq"gxkfgpeg"qh"cp{"ejtqpke"eqornkecvkqp"fwg"vq"È"fkcdgvgu0Ñ"*V"cv" 8 55+0" " Kpfggf." RnckpvkhhÓu" rgtkrjgtcn" pgwtqrcvj{." c" ejtqpke" eqornkecvkqp" fwg" vq" 9 fkcdgvgu."ku"ygnn/fqewogpvgf0""" : " ; pgwtqrcvj{"yqwnf"kpvgthgtg"ykvj"RnckpvkhhÓu"cdknkv{"vq"rgthqto"dcuke"yqtm"cevkxkvkgu." 32 vjgtg"ycu"oqtg"vjcp"uwhhkekgpv"gxkfgpeg"vq"vtkiigt"c"fwv{"qp"vjg"rctv"qh"vjg"CNL"vq" 33 hwtvjgt" fgxgnqr" vjg" tgeqtf04" " Vjg" CNLÓu" hcknwtg" vq" enctkh{" vjg" gzvgpv" qh" nkokvcvkqp" 34 ecwugf"d{"RnckpvkhhÓu"rgtkrjgtcn"pgwtqrcvj{"ycu"rctvkewnctn{"ukipkhkecpv"dgecwug"vjg" 35 fgpkcn"qh"dgpghkvu"ycu"tqqvgf"kp"vjg"eqpenwukqp"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"eqwnf"rgthqto"jgt"rcuv" 36 tgngxcpv" yqtm" cu" c" ugykpi" ocejkpg" qrgtcvqt" cpf" uocnn" rtqfwevu" cuugodngt" Î" 37 qeewrcvkqpu" vjcv" yqwnf" crrgct" vq" tgswktg" htgswgpv" jcpfnkpi" cpf" qvjgt" hkpg" oqvqt" Vjg"gxkfgpeg"qwvnkpgf"cdqxg"ecppqv"dg"tgeqpekngf"ykvj"vjg"CNLÓu"eqpenwukqp" Yjkng" vjg" tgeqtf" fqgu" pqv" ocmg" engct" vjg" gzvgpv" vq" yjkej" rgtkrjgtcn" 38 39 "Vjgtg"ku"pq"swguvkqp"vjcv"Ðvjg"CNL"jcu"c"fwv{"vq"cuukuv"kp"fgxgnqrkpi"vjg"tgeqtf0Ñ"Armstrong v. 3; Commissioner of Soc. Sec. Admin0."382"H05f"7:9."7:;"*;vj"Ekt0"3;;:+="42"E0H0T0"¸¸"62603734*f+/ *h+="see also Sims v. Apfel."752"W0U0"325."332/33."369"N0"Gf0"4f":2."342"U0"Ev0"42:2"*4222+"*ÐUqekcn" Ugewtkv{"rtqeggfkpiu"ctg"kpswkukvqtkcn"tcvjgt"vjcp"cfxgtuctkcn0"Kv"ku"vjg"CNLÓu"fwv{"vq"kpxguvkicvg"vjg" hcevu"cpf"fgxgnqr"vjg"ctiwogpvu"dqvj"hqt"cpf"cickpuv"itcpvkpi"dgpghkvu"0"0"0"0Ñ+0""" 42 12 3: FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"OCVC/UCNC¥CT"x"DGTT[JKNN"4<39/EX/24752" " " 3 cevkxkvkgu."i.e. rtgekugn{"vjg"cevkxkvkgu"qpg"yqwnf"gzrgev"vq"dg"korcevgf"d{"rgtkrjgtcn" 4 pgwtqrcvj{0"" 5 " 6 uwrrqtvgf" d{" uwduvcpvkcn" gxkfgpeg" cpf" pggfu" vq" dg" tgxkukvgf" qp" tgocpf0" " Kp" 7 rctvkewnct."hwtvjgt"fgxgnqrogpv"qh"vjg"tgeqtf"ku"pgeguuct{"vq"fgvgtokpg"vjg"gzvgpv"vq" 8 yjkej." kh" cv" cnn." RnckpvkhhÓu" cdknkv{" vq" rgthqto" dcuke" yqtm" cevkxkvkgu" ku" nkokvgf" d{" 9 rgtkrjgtcn"pgwtqrcvj{0" : " 40" ; " Yjgp" gxcnwcvkpi" vjg" ugxgtkv{" qh" ogpvcn" korcktogpvu." vjg" tgiwncvkqpu" tgswktg" Ceeqtfkpin{." vjku" Eqwtv" hkpfu" vjcv" vjku" curgev" qh" vjg" uvgr" vyq" cpcn{uku" ku" pqv" Cpzkgv{"cpf"Fgrtguukqp" 32 vjg"CNL"vq"crrn{"c"Ðurgekcn"vgejpkswgÑ"cv"vjg"ugeqpf"cpf"vjktf"uvgru"qh"vjg"tgxkgy."kp" 33 cffkvkqp" vq" vjg" ewuvqoct{" ugswgpvkcn" cpcn{uku0" " 42" E0H0T0" ¸" 62603742c0" " Vjg" 34 vgejpkswg" hktuv" tgswktgu" c" fgvgtokpcvkqp" qh" yjgvjgt" vjg" enckocpv" jcu" c" ogfkecnn{" 35 fgvgtokpcdng"ogpvcn"korcktogpv0"42"E0H0T0"¸"62603742c*d+*3+0"Vjgp."vjg"CNL"owuv" 36 tcvg"vjg"fgitgg"qh"vjg"enckocpvÓu"hwpevkqpcn"nkokvcvkqp"tguwnvkpi"htqo"vjg"korcktogpv" 37 kp"hqwt"ctgcu<"*3+"cevkxkvkgu"qh"fckn{"nkxkpi="*4+"uqekcn"hwpevkqpkpi="*5+"eqpegpvtcvkqp." 38 rgtukuvgpeg." qt" rceg=" cpf" *6+" grkuqfgu" qh" fgeqorgpucvkqp0" Ugg" 42" E0H0T" ¸" 39 62603742c*e+*5+0"Vjgug"ctgcu"ctg"tcvgf"qp"c"uecng"qh"Ðpqpg."oknf."oqfgtcvg."octmgf." 3: cpf"gzvtgog0Ñ"42"E0H0T0"¸¸"62603742c*e+*6+="6380;42c*e+*6+0""" 3; 42 13 FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"OCVC/UCNC¥CT"x"DGTT[JKNN"4<39/EX/24752" " " 3 " C"ogpvcn"korcktogpv"ku"igpgtcnn{"hqwpf"pqv"ugxgtg"kh"vjg"fgitgg"qh"nkokvcvkqp" 4 kp"vjg"hktuv"vjtgg"ctgcu"ku"oknf"qt"dgvvgt"cpf"vjgtg"ctg"pq"grkuqfgu"qh"fgeqorgpucvkqp0" 5 42"E0H0T0"¸"62603742c*f+*3+0"Vjg"CNL"owuv"Ðfqewogpv"c"urgekhke"hkpfkpi"cu"vq"vjg" 6 fgitgg"qh"nkokvcvkqp"kp"gcej"qh"vjg"hwpevkqpcn"ctgcu0Ñ"42"E0H0T0"¸"62603742c*g+*4+0""" 7 " 8 fqewogpvgf" kp" vjg" tgeqtf." dwv" ecwugf" qpn{" oknf" tguvtkevkqp" kp" cevkxkvkgu" qh" fckn{" 9 nkxkpi."uqekcn"hwpevkqpkpi."cpf"eqpegpvtcvkqp."rgtukuvgpeg."cpf"rceg."ykvj"pq"grkuqfgu" : qh"fgeqorgpucvkqp0"*V"cv"53+0""Cu"uwej."vjg"CNL"hqwpf"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"fkf"pqv"jcxg"c" ; ugxgtg"ogpvcn"jgcnvj"korcktogpv0"*V"cv"53+0" Jgtg." vjg" CNL" eqpenwfgf" vjcv" RnckpvkhhÓu" cpzkgv{" cpf" fgrtguukqp" ygtg" 32 " Vjku" Eqwtv" hkpfu" vjku" curgev" qh" vjg" CNLÓu" fgekukqp" uwrrqtvgf" d{" uwduvcpvkcn" 33 gxkfgpeg0" " Cnvjqwij" vjg" tgeqtf" fqewogpvu" uwdlgevkxg" u{orvqou" qh" cpzkgv{" cpf" 34 fgrtguukqp."cpf"rctvkewnct"fkhhkewnvkgu"ykvj"crrgvkvg"eqpvtqn."vjgtg"ycu"pq"gxkfgpeg"qh" 35 kprcvkgpv" qt" qwvrcvkgpv" vtgcvogpv" d{" c" ogpvcn" jgcnvj" rtqhguukqpcn0" " Ft0" Yknnkco" 36 Iqnfuokvj" rgthqtogf" c" eqpuwnvcvkxg" ru{ejkcvtke" gxcnwcvkqp" kp" Oc{" qh" 42350" " Ft0" 37 Iqnfuokvj"fkcipqugf"f{uvj{oke"fkuqtfgt"*oknf+"cpf"cuukipgf"c"Inqdcn"Cuuguuogpv" 38 qh"Hwpevkqpkpi"*ÐICHÑ+"ueqtg5"qh"84"*V"cv"663+0""ÐC"ICH"qh"83/92"kpfkecvgu"Ò]u_qog" 39 oknf" u{orvqou" *g0i0." fgrtguugf" oqqf" cpf" oknf" kpuqopkc+" qt" uqog" fkhhkewnv{" kp" 3: "ÐC"ICH"ueqtg"ku"c"tqwij"guvkocvg"qh"cp"kpfkxkfwcn)u"ru{ejqnqikecn."uqekcn."cpf"qeewrcvkqpcn" 3; hwpevkqpkpi"wugf"vq"tghngev"vjg"kpfkxkfwcn)u"pggf"hqt"vtgcvogpv0$"Vargas v. Lambert."37;"H05f"3383." 3386"p04"*;vj"Ekt0"3;;:+0" 42 14 FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"OCVC/UCNC¥CT"x"DGTT[JKNN"4<39/EX/24752" " " 3 uqekcn."qeewrcvkqpcn."qt"uejqqn"hwpevkqpkpi"*g0i0."qeecukqpcn"vtwcpe{."qt"vjghv"ykvjkp" 4 vjg" jqwugjqnf+." dwv" igpgtcnn{" hwpevkqpkpi" rtgvv{" ygnn." jcu" uqog" ogcpkpihwn" 5 kpvgtrgtuqpcn" tgncvkqpujkru0ÓÑ" Tagger v. Astrue." 758" H0" Uwrr0" 4f" 3392." 3396" p0:" 6 *E0F0" Ecn0" 422:+0" " Ft0" Iqnfuokvj" hqwpf" pq" yqtm/tgncvgf" nkokvcvkqpu" ctkukpi" htqo" 7 RnckpvkhhÓu"ogpvcn"jgcnvj"u{orvqou0"*V"cv"663/64+0"""Kp"Pqxgodgt"qh"4235."Ft0"R0O0" 8 Dcnuqp." c" pqp/gzcokpkpi" Uvcvg" Cigpe{" tgxkgy" rj{ukekcp." qrkpgf" vjcv" RnckpvkhhÓu" 9 ogpvcn"jgcnvj"korcktogpvu"ygtg"pqp/ugxgtg0""*V"cv"32;+0" : " ; uwduvcpvkcn" gxkfgpeg" yjgp" vjg" qrkpkqpu" ctg" eqpukuvgpv" ykvj" kpfgrgpfgpv" enkpkecn" 32 hkpfkpiu" qt" qvjgt" gxkfgpeg" kp" vjg" tgeqtf0Ñ" Thomas v. Barnhart." 49:" H05f" ;69." ;79" 33 *;vj"Ekt0"4224+= see also see also 42"EHT"¸"62603749"*h+*4+*k+*ÐUvcvg"cigpe{"ogfkecn" 34 cpf" ru{ejqnqikecn" eqpuwnvcpvu" cpf" qvjgt" rtqitco" rj{ukekcpu." ru{ejqnqikuvu." cpf" 35 qvjgt" ogfkecn" urgekcnkuvu" ctg" jkijn{" swcnkhkgf" rj{ukekcpu." ru{ejqnqikuvu." cpf" qvjgt" 36 ogfkecn"urgekcnkuvu"yjq"ctg"cnuq"gzrgtvu"kp"Uqekcn"Ugewtkv{"fkucdknkv{"gxcnwcvkqp0Ñ+0" 37 " 38 cuuguuogpv"qh"vjg"ugxgtkv{"qh"RnckpvkhhÓu"ogpvcn"jgcnvj"korcktogpvu0" 39 D0" THE" 3: " Cp" CNLÓu" cuuguuogpv" qh" vjg" enckocpvÓu" tgukfwcn" hwpevkqpcn" ecrcekv{" *ÐTHEÑ+" 3; owuv" dg" wrjgnf" kh" vjg" CNL" jcu" crrnkgf" vjg" rtqrgt" ngicn" uvcpfctf" cpf" uwduvcpvkcn" 42 15 ÐVjg" qrkpkqpu" qh" pqp/vtgcvkpi" qt" pqp/gzcokpkpi" rj{ukekcpu" oc{"È" ugtxg" cu" Ceeqtfkpin{." vjku" Eqwtv" hkpfu" pq" tgxgtukdng" gttqt" ykvj" tgictf" vq" vjg" CNLÓu" FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"OCVC/UCNC¥CT"x"DGTT[JKNN"4<39/EX/24752" " " 3 gxkfgpeg" kp" vjg" tgeqtf" uwrrqtvu" vjg" fgekukqp0" Bayliss v. Barnhart." 649" H05f" 3433." 4 3439"*;vj"Ekt0"4227+0"Vjg"CNL"owuv"eqpukfgt"cnn"vjg"ogfkecn"gxkfgpeg"kp"vjg"tgeqtf" 5 cpf"Ðgzrnckp"kp"]jgt_"fgekukqp"vjg"ygkijv"ikxgp"vq"0"0"0"]vjg_"qrkpkqpu"htqo"vtgcvkpi" 6 uqwtegu." pqpvtgcvkpi" uqwtegu." cpf" qvjgt" pqpgzcokpkpi" uqwtegu0Ñ" 42" E0H0T0" ¸" 7 62603749*g+*4+*kk+=" ugg" cnuq" ¸" 62603767*c+*3+0" " Kp" fgvgtokpkpi" vjg" enckocpvÓu" THE." 8 vjg"CNL"eqpukfgtu"vjqug"nkokvcvkqpu"hqt"yjkej"vjgtg"ku"uwrrqtv"kp"vjg"tgeqtf"cpf"pggf" 9 pqv" eqpukfgt" rtqrgtn{" tglgevgf" gxkfgpeg" qt" uwdlgevkxg" eqornckpvu0" See Bayliss." 649" : H05f"cv"34390" ; " Jgtg." vjg" CNL" fgvgtokpgf" vjcv" Rnckpvkhh" tgvckpgf" vjg" THE" vq" rgthqto" nkijv" 32 yqtm." cu" fghkpgf" kp" 42" EHT" ¸" 62603789" *d+." cu" hqnnqyu<" nkhvkpi1ectt{kpi" wr" vq" 32" 33 rqwpfu"htgswgpvn{"cpf"wr"vq"42"rqwpfu"qeecukqpcnn{="ukvvkpi1uvcpfkpi1ycnmkpi"wr"vq" 34 8" jqwtu" kp" cp" :/jqwt" yqtmfc{=" pq" enkodkpi" qh" ncffgtu1tqrgu1uechhqnfu=" pq" yqtm" 35 ctqwpf" jc|ctfqwu" eqpfkvkqpu=" qeecukqpcn" enkodkpi" qh" tcoru1uvcktu." qeecukqpcn" 36 rgthqtocpeg" qh" rquvwtcn" oqxgogpvu." qeecukqpcn" qxgtjgcf" tgcejkpi" ykvj" vjg" nghv" 37 wrrgt"gzvtgokv{="cpf"pq"yqtm"vcumu"ctqwpf"gzeguukxg"pqkug0"*V"cv"54+0" 38 " 39 qp" tgocpf0" " Cu" qwvnkpgf" cdqxg." vjg" CNL" fkf" pqv" uwhhkekgpvn{" fgxgnqr" vjg" tgeqtf" 3: tgictfkpi"RnckpvkhhÓu"rgtkrjgtcn"pgwtqrcvj{."c"eqpfkvkqp"vjcv"eqwnf"ecwug"nkokvcvkqpu" 3; ykvj"tgurgev"vq"c" enckocpvÓu"cdknkv{"vq"uvcpf."ycnm." cpf"rgthqto"jcpfnkpi"cpf"qvjgt" 42 16 Vjku" Eqwtv" hkpfu" vjcv" vjg" CNLÓu" THE" fgvgtokpcvkqp" yknn" pggf" vq" dg" tgxkukvgf" FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"OCVC/UCNC¥CT"x"DGTT[JKNN"4<39/EX/24752" " " 3 hkpg"oqvqt"cevkxkvkgu0""Yjkng"vjg"gzvgpv"qh"nkokvcvkqp"ecwugf"d{"rgtkrjgtcn"pgwtqrcvj{" 4 kp"vjku"rctvkewnct"ecug"ku"wpengct."vjg"CNLÓu"THE"fgvgtokpcvkqp"ecppqv"dg"uwuvckpgf" 5 wpvkn"vjcv"ncem"qh"enctkv{"ku"tguqnxgf"xkc"rtqrgt"fgxgnqrogpv"qh"vjg"tgeqtf0" 6 E0" Etgfkdknkv{" 7 " C" enckocpvÓu" uwdlgevkxg" eqornckpvu" eqpegtpkpi" jku" qt" jgt" nkokvcvkqpu" ctg" cp" 8 korqtvcpv"rctv"qh"c"fkucdknkv{"encko0"Batson v. Comm’r of Soc. Sec. Admin0."57;"H05f" 9 33;2."33;7"*;vj"Ekt0"4226+*ekvcvkqp"qokvvgf+0"Vjg"CNLÓu"hkpfkpiu"ykvj"tgictf"vq"vjg" : enckocpvÓu" etgfkdknkv{" owuv" dg" uwrrqtvgf" d{" urgekhke" eqigpv" tgcuqpu0" Rashad v. ; Sullivan." ;25" H04f" 344;." 3453" *;vj" Ekt0" 3;;2+0" Cdugpv" chhktocvkxg" gxkfgpeg" qh" 32 ocnkpigtkpi."vjg"CNLÓu"tgcuqpu"hqt"tglgevkpi"vjg"enckocpvÓu"vguvkoqp{"owuv"dg"Ðengct" 33 cpf" eqpxkpekpi0Ñ" Lester v. Chater." :3" H05f" :43." :56" *;vj" Ekt0" 3;;7+0" ÐIgpgtcn" 34 hkpfkpiu"ctg"kpuwhhkekgpv<"tcvjgt"vjg"CNL"owuv"kfgpvkh{"yjcv"vguvkoqp{"ku"pqv"etgfkdng" 35 cpf" yjcv" gxkfgpeg" wpfgtokpgu" vjg" enckocpvÓu" eqornckpvu0Ñ"Lestet." :3" H05f" cv" :56=" 36 Dodrill v. Shalala."34"H05f";37.";3:"*;vj"Ekt0"3;;5+0"" 37 " 38 hkpfkpi"qh"fkucdknkv{0"C"enckocpv"owuv"rtgugpv"ogfkecn"gxkfgpeg"qt"hkpfkpiu"vjcv"vjg" 39 gzkuvgpeg" qh" cp" wpfgtn{kpi" eqpfkvkqp" eqwnf" tgcuqpcdn{" dg" gzrgevgf" vq" rtqfweg" vjg" 3: u{orvqocvqnqi{"cnngigf0"Ugg"64"W0U0E0"¸¸645*f+*7+*C+."35:4e"*c+*5+*C+="42"E0H0T0" 3; ¸"6260374;*d+."6380;4;="UUT";8/9r0" 42 " Jqygxgt." uwdlgevkxg" u{orvqocvqnqi{" d{" kvugnh" ecppqv" dg" vjg" dcuku" hqt" c" 17 FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"OCVC/UCNC¥CT"x"DGTT[JKNN"4<39/EX/24752" " " 3 " Kp" vjku" ecug." Rnckpvkhh" vguvkhkgf" cu" hqnnqyu<" " Vjg" jkijguv" gfwecvkqp" ujg" 4 eqorngvgf"ycu"ugeqpf"itcfg."kp"Ogzkeq0""Ujg"ecog"vq"vjg"Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu"kp"3;9;"cpf" 5 vqqm" Gpinkuj" eqwtugu" rtkqt" vq" dgeqokpi" c" ekvk|gp0" *V" cv" 74+0" " Ujg" nkxgu" ykvj" jgt" 6 fcwijvgt0""Ujg"fqgu"pqv"ftkxg0""Ujg"uvqrrgf"yqtmkpi"kp"422;."yjgp"ujg"ycu"nckf"qhh0" 7 *V"cv"75+0""Kv"ku"fkhhkewnv"hqt"jgt"vq"nkhv"jgt"nghv"cto0""Ujg"jcu"vkpinkpi"kp"jgt"jcpfu"cpf" 8 hggv"cpf"hggnu"jgcv"kp"jgt"gzvtgokvkgu0"*V"cv"76+0""Cpzkgv{"ecwugu"qxgtgcvkpi0"*V"cv"76/ 9 77+0" " Jgt" fkcdgvgu" ku" wpeqpvtqnngf0" *V" cv" 78+0" " Ujg" ecppqv" ycnm" c" dnqem0" *V" cv" 79+0"" : Ujg"jcu"uqtgu"qp"jgt"jcpfu"cpf"hggv0"*V"cv"7:+0""Ogfkecvkqp"vq"cfftguu"vjg"vkpinkpi"kp" ; jgt"jcpfu"cpf"hggv"ecwugf"fk||kpguu"cpf"pcwugc0"*V"cv"82+0""Ujg"wugu"qtcn"ogfkecvkqp" 32 cpf"kpuwnkp0"*V"cv"667+0" 33 " 34 tgcuqpcdn{" dg" gzrgevgf" vq" ecwug" uqog" qh" vjg" cnngigf" u{orvqou." dwv" vjcv" jgt" 35 uvcvgogpvu"tgictfkpi"vjg"kpvgpukv{."rgtukuvgpeg."cpf"nkokvkpi"ghhgevu"qh"vjg"u{orvqou" 36 ygtg"pqv"hwnn{"etgfkdng0"*V"cv"55+0""" 37 " 38 Hktuv." vjg" CNL" hqwpf" RnckpvkhhÓu" vguvkoqp{" eqpvtcfkevgf" d{" vjg" qdlgevkxg" gxkfgpeg0"" 39 Jqygxgt."cu"pqvgf"cdqxg."vjg"CNL"tgcejgf"vjg"gttqpgqwu"eqpenwukqp"vjcv"vjgtg"ycu" 3: Ðpq" gxkfgpeg" qh" cp{" ejtqpke" eqornkecvkqpuÑ" fwg" vq" RnckpvkhhÓu" fkcdgvgu0" *V" cv" 55+0"" 3; RnckpvkhhÓu" rgtkrjgtcn" pgwtqrcvj{." c" ejtqpke" eqornkecvkqp" fwg" vq" fkcdgvgu." ku" ygnn/ 42 18 Vjg"CNL"eqpenwfgf"vjcv"RnckpvkhhÓu"ogfkecnn{"fgvgtokpcdng"korcktogpvu"eqwnf" Vjg" CNLÓu" etgfkdknkv{" fgvgtokpcvkqp" yknn" pggf" vq" dg" tgxkukvgf" qp" tgocpf0"" FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"OCVC/UCNC¥CT"x"DGTT[JKNN"4<39/EX/24752" " " 3 fqewogpvgf0" " Vjku" ku" eqpukuvgpv" ykvj" RnckpvkhhÓu" eqornckpvu" qh" pwodpguu." vkpinkpi." 4 cpf"uqtgu" qp"jgt"jcpfu"cpf"hggv0" " Vjg"CNLÓu"eqpenwukqp"vjcv"RnckpvkhhÓu"eqornckpvu" 5 ygtg"pqv"uwrrqtvgf"d{"vjg"gxkfgpeg"ycu"gttqpgqwu0""Vjku"fqgu"pqv"pgeguuctkn{"ogcp" 6 vjg" CNL" ycu" dqwpf" vq" ceegrv" RnckpvkhhÓu" uwdlgevkxg" nkokvcvkqpu" kp" hwnn." dwv" kv" fqgu" 7 ogcp"vjcv"vjg"eqpenwukqp"vjcv"jgt"vguvkoqp{"ycu"wpuwrrqtvgf"d{"qdlgevkxg"ogfkecn" 8 gxkfgpeg"ecppqv"dg"uwuvckpgf0" 9 " : fkueqwpvgf"jgt"enckou"qh"fkucdnkpi"fkcdgvke"u{orvqou"kp"rctv"dgecwug"vjgtg"ycu"Ðpq" ; gxkfgpeg"qh"vtgcvogpv"È"dg{qpf"ogfkecvkqp"cpf"nkhguv{ng"ejcpigu0Ñ"*V"cv"55+0""Kv"ku" 32 pqv"engct"yjcv"cffkvkqpcn"vtgcvogpv"vjg"CNL"dgnkgxgu"Rnckpvkhh"yqwnf"qt"ujqwnf"jcxg" 33 tgegkxgf" hqt" fkcdgvgu0" " See Perez v. Colvin." Pq" GFEX" 36/4848." 4238" W0U0" Fkuv0" 34 NGZKU"66452."cv",39"*E0F0"Ecn0"Oct0"53."4238+*ÐVjg"CNL"ecppqv"hcwnv"Rnckpvkhh"hqt" 35 hcknkpi" vq" rwtuwg" pqpeqpugtxcvkxg" vtgcvogpv" qrvkqpu" kh" pqpg" gzkuvgf0Ñ+*ekvkpi" 36 Lapeirre-Gutt v. Astrue." 5:4" H0" Crr)z" 884." 886" *;vj" Ekt0" 4232++0" " Kpfggf." kpuwnkp" 37 kplgevkqpu" cpf" nkhguv{ng" ejcpigu" ctg" vjg" uvcpfctf" ogvjqfu" hqt" vtgcvkpi" fkcdgvgu0" See 38 Crater v. Astrue." Pq0" GF" EX" 33/3745." 4234" WU" Fkuv" NGZKU" 32924;." cv" ,47/48" 39 *E0F0"Ecn0"Lwn{"52."4234+0" Ugeqpf." vjg" CNL" tgeqipk|gf" RnckpvkhhÓu" jkuvqt{" qh" fkcdgvgu" ognnkvwu." dwv" 3: 3; 42 19 FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"OCVC/UCNC¥CT"x"DGTT[JKNN"4<39/EX/24752" " " 3 " Hqt"vjgug"tgcuqpu."vjg"CNLÓu"etgfkdknkv{"fgvgtokpcvkqp"ecppqv"dg"uwuvckpgf"cpf" 4 yknn"pggf"vq"dg"tgxkukvgf"qp"tgocpf"chvgt"hwtvjgt"fgxgnqrogpv"qh"vjg"tgeqtf"tgictfkpi" 5 RnckpvkhhÓu"rgtkrjgtcn"pgwtqrcvj{0" 6 F0" Tgocpf" 7 " Kp" c" ecug" yjgtg" vjg" CNL)u" fgvgtokpcvkqp" ku" pqv" uwrrqtvgf" d{" uwduvcpvkcn" 8 gxkfgpeg"qt"ku"vckpvgf"d{"ngicn"gttqt."vjg"eqwtv"oc{"tgocpf"vjg"ocvvgt"hqt"cffkvkqpcn" 9 rtqeggfkpiu"qt"cp"koogfkcvg"cyctf"qh"dgpghkvu0"Tgocpf"hqt"cffkvkqpcn"rtqeggfkpiu" : ku"rtqrgt"yjgtg"*3+"qwvuvcpfkpi"kuuwgu"owuv"dg"tguqnxgf."cpf"*4+"kv"ku"pqv"engct"htqo" ; vjg"tgeqtf"dghqtg"vjg"eqwtv"vjcv"c"enckocpv"ku"fkucdngf0"See Benecke v. Barnhart."59;" 32 H05f"7:9."7;5"*;vj"Ekt0"4226+0""" 33 " 34 fkuewuugf"cdqxg."vjg"CNLÓu"cpcn{uku"qh"RnckpvkhhÓu"rgtkrjgtcn"pgwtqrcvj{"ycu"hncygf" 35 cpf" vjg" tgeqtf" tgictfkpi" vjcv" eqpfkvkqp" ycu" pqv" uwhhkekgpvn{" fgxgnqrgf0" " Ykvj" vjcv" 36 uckf." vjg" tgeqtf" ku" wpengct" cu" vq" vjg" gzvgpv" vq" yjkej" vjcv" eqpfkvkqp" ecwugu" yqtm/ 37 tgncvgf" nkokvcvkqpu" cpf." kh" uq." yjgvjgt" cp{" uwej" cffkvkqpcn" yqtm/tgncvgf" nkokvcvkqpu" 38 yqwnf"tgpfgt"Rnckpvkhh"fkucdngf"wpfgt"vjg"Uqekcn"Ugewtkv{"Cev0""Cu"uwej."c"tgocpf"hqt" 39 hwtvjgt"rtqeggfkpiu"ku"vjg"tkijv"tguwnv0"See Strauss v. Comm’r of Soc. Sec.."857"H05f" 3: 3357." 335:" *;vj" Ekt0" 4233+*ÐWnvkocvgn{." c" enckocpv" ku" pqv" gpvkvngf" vq" dgpghkvu" wpfgt" Jgtg." vjku" Eqwtv" hkpfu" vjcv" tgocpf" hqt" hwtvjgt" rtqeggfkpiu" ku" ycttcpvgf0" " Cu" 3; 42 20 FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"OCVC/UCNC¥CT"x"DGTT[JKNN"4<39/EX/24752" " " 3 vjg" uvcvwvg" wpnguu" vjg" enckocpv" ku." kp" hcev." fkucdngf." pq" ocvvgt" jqy" gitgikqwu" vjg" 4 CNLÓu"gttqtu"oc{"dg0Ñ+0" 5 " " X0"QTFGTU" 6 7 KV"KU"VJGTGHQTG QTFGTGF"vjcv<" 8 "" 9 TGOCPFKPI"vjku"ocvvgt"hqt"hwtvjgt"rtqeggfkpiu"eqpukuvgpv"ykvj"vjku"Fgekukqp"cpf" : Qtfgt."cpf"kv"ku"hwtvjgt"QTFGTGF"vjcv" ; "" Lwfiogpv" dg" gpvgtgf" TGXGTUKPI" vjg" EqookuukqpgtÓu" fgekukqp" cpf" Vjg"Engtm"qh"vjg"Eqwtv"hkng"vjku"Fgekukqp"cpf"Qtfgt."ugtxg"eqrkgu"wrqp"eqwpugn" 32 hqt" vjg" rctvkgu." cpf" ENQUG" vjku" ecug" ykvjqwv" rtglwfkeg" vq" c" vkogn{" crrnkecvkqp" hqt" 33 cvvqtpg{uÓ"hggu0" 34 " FCVGF"vjku"52vj"fc{"qh"Ugrvgodgt."423:." 35 " " " " " 36 " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " 1u1Xkevqt"G0"Dkcpejkpk" " " " " XKEVQT"G0"DKCPEJKPK" " " WPKVGF"UVCVGU"OCIKUVTCVG"LWFIG""""" 37 38 " """"""""""""" " " 39 3: 3; 42 21 FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"OCVC/UCNC¥CT"x"DGTT[JKNN"4<39/EX/24752" " "
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
