In Re: Prempro Products et al, No. 4:2003cv01507 - Document 1993 (E.D. Ark. 2009)

Court Description: ORDER denying without prejudice 1959 Motion to Dismiss; For all the cases listed in Exhibit A, a reasonably adequate Fact Sheet must be served on defendants by 5 p.m., Monday, April 13, 2009, and if such Fact Sheet is not submitted, the case will b e dismissed with prejudice. If there are motions for voluntary dismissal filed during this 45 day period, in any of the cases subject to this Order, such dismissals must be with prejudice, absent highly unusual circumstances. Additionally, Plaintiffs counsel will not be permitted to withdraw as counsel during this 45 day period. Signed by Judge William R. Wilson, Jr on 2/27/09. (mkf)

Download PDF

In Re: Prempro Products et al Doc. 1993 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF ARKANSAS WESTERN DIVISION : : : : IN RE: PREMPRO PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION MDL DOCKET NO. 4:03-CV-1507-WRW ALL CASES LISTED IN EXHIBIT A1 ORDER I. BACKGROUND I have issued at least four orders providing that completed Fact Sheets must be served on defendants “within 90 days after the Conditional Transfer Order becomes final.”2 Each of the plaintiffs affected by this Order was included in either Conditional Transfer Order (“CTO”) 141, 142, 143, or 145. Each of these CTOs became final between late July and August, 2008,3 and the completed Fact Sheets were due by October 20, 2008,4 October 27, 2008,5 November 6, 2008, and November 26, 2008, respectively. However, the parties agreed to a one-month extension of time.6 1 Exhibit A lists the cases to which this Order applies. However, the Clerk of the Court need not file this Order in each case. 2 Doc. Nos. 201, 494, 1093, and 1948. 3 CTO 141 was filed on July 21, 2008 (Doc. No. 1823); CTO 142 was filed on July 28, 2008, (Doc. No. 1826); CTO 143 was filed on August 8, 2008 (Doc. No. 1838); and CTO 145 was filed on August 28, 2008 (Doc. No. 1850). 4 Day ninety, October 19, 2008, was a Sunday, making the due date the next working day. 5 Day ninety, October 26, 2008, was a Sunday, making the due date the next working day. 6 Chitty v. Wyeth, 4:08-CV-00730 (E.D. Ark. Aug. 11, 2008) (Doc. No. 8). 1 Dockets.Justia.com On December 10, 2008, Wyeth filed a Motion for Order to Show Cause because Plaintiffs’ Fact Sheets provided “will supplement” to most of the questions on the Fact Sheets.7 Wyeth asserted that this issue was a repeated problem with the plaintiffs represented by the Bailey & Galyen firm, and could involve over 500 cases.8 My December 17, 2008 Order reads: Plaintiffs represented by the Bailey & Galyen law firm have repeatedly submitted Fact Sheets that say “will supplement.” In a December 11, 2008 Letter, I expressed my intention to give Plaintiffs’ counsel “until 5 p.m., Monday, February 2, 2009, within in which to get these Fact Sheets completed properly and served.” Plaintiff did not address this deadline in her response, so I assume counsel concedes the issue. Accordingly, Defendant’s PPO 3 Motion to Dismiss is DENIED without prejudice. However, all Bailey & Galyen plaintiffs included in CTOs 141, 142, 143, and 145 must serve their completed -- “will supplement” doesn’t cut it -- Fact Sheets by 5 p.m. Monday, February 2, 2009.9 On February 4, 2009, Wyeth filed its second motion concerning Fact Sheets submitted by Bailey & Galyen plaintiffs.10 Wyeth noted that hundreds of fact sheets had not been served by the February 2, 2009 deadline, and that hundreds of those that had been served remained incomplete, since Plaintiff simply replaced “will supplement” with “I do not recall and do not have reasonable access to the information that would be responsive to this question without undue burden or cost.” Wyeth also noted that in the amended Fact Sheets, the “Verification” page included the signature from the original fact sheet, and simply “typed in over the old date.”11 7 The motion was filed in Chitty v. Wyeth, 4:08-CV-00730 (E.D. Ark. Aug. 11, 2008) (Doc. No. 8), but referenced Bailey & Galyen cases from CTOs 141, 142, 143, and 145. 8 Chitty v. Wyeth, 4:08-CV-00730 (E.D. Ark. Aug. 11, 2008) at Doc. No. 8. 9 Id. at Doc. No. 11 (emphasis added). 10 Doc. No. 1959. 11 Plaintiff Joan P. Sandman’s Fact Sheet is one example. See Doc. No. 1960, Ex. 9. 2 In response, Plaintiffs contend that: (1) “Plaintiffs’ Fact Sheets were served timely upon Wyeth”; (2) the “information provided in each fact sheet is full and complete based upon each plaintiff’s ability to recall and respond”; and (3) “[e]ach verified fact sheet is properly verified and each plaintiff is aware of her continuing duty to provide new responsive information . . . .”12 Plaintiffs also assert that they “made good faith attempts to comply with the Court’s Orders and directives.”13 II. DISCUSSION Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 37(b), a district court may issue “just orders,” when a party “fails to obey an order to provide or permit discovery.”14 The United States Supreme Court has interpreted “fails to obey” as “failing to comply.”15 “[D]ismissal may be considered as a sanction only if there is (1) an order compelling discovery, (2) a willful violation of that order, and (3) prejudice to the other party.”16 Each of these factors is present in these cases listed in Exhibit A.. I seriously considered dismissing all cases in Exhibits 1 and 2 and some of them in Exhibit 3 of Wyeth’s Reply brief,17 without prejudice with the proviso that if a case was refiled, it must have a reasonably accurate Fact Sheet attached, and that sanctions against counsel would likely be imposed if additional Fact Sheets were attached with nonsense answers. In this order I 12 Doc. No. 1970. 13 Id. 14 Fed. R. Civ. P. 37(b)(2)(A). 15 Societe Internationale Pour Participations Industrielles Et Commercialies, S.A., etc., v. Rogers, 357 U.S. 197, 207-08 (1958). 16 Schoffstall v. Henderson, 223 F.3d 818, 823 (8th Cir. 2000). 17 Doc. No. 1991. 3 would have given counsel 45 days in which to accomplish this, else the cases would have been dismissed with prejudice. Since this procedure would require the entry of a ground slide load of dismissal orders in this Court -- as well as hundreds of cases being refiled in Minnesota and the MDL Panel having to transfer the cases again -- I have decided not to enter any type of dismissal order at this point. Plaintiffs’ counsel have 45 days within which to serve a reasonably adequate Fact Sheet in each case, and if such Fact Sheet is not submitted, the case will be dismissed with prejudice. Of course, defense counsel will be required to bring to my attention any alleged inadequate Fact Sheets. If I find that a Fact Sheet is not reasonably adequate, it is quite likely that the case will be dismissed with prejudice, and that sanctions may well be imposed, including, but not necessarily limited to, reasonable lawyers’ fees for defense counsel. If there are motions for voluntary dismissal filed during this 45 day period, in any of the cases subject to this Order, such dismissals must be with prejudice, absent highly unusual circumstances. Additionally, Plaintiffs’ counsel will not be permitted to withdraw as counsel during this 45 day period. CONCLUSION The deadline for complying with this order is 5 p.m., Monday, April 13, 2009. I repeat, the deadline for complying with this order is 5 p.m., Monday, April 13, 2009. Based on the findings of fact and conclusions of law above, Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss Cases for Failure to Serve Complete Fact Sheets (Doc. No. 1959) is DENIED without prejudice. IT SO ORDERED this 27th day of February, 2009. /s/ Wm. R. Wilson, Jr._____________ UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE 4 EXHIBIT A (Plaintiffs in this section are from Wyeth’s Reply (Doc. No. 1991), Exhibit 1.) Abaya v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Abney v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Adams v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Alexander v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Alsop v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Archer v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Bachman v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Bailey v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Ball v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Bascom v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Beauchamp v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Bello v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Bishop v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Blackburn v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Bolanos v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Brewster v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Brown v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Bruce v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Campbell v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Carnesecca v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Carrasco v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Casey v. Wyeth et al. Chesnut v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Chitty v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Christensen v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Christiansen v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Cook v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Cummings v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Cummings v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Daniels v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Davis v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Davis v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Dean v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Dean v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Dennis v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Devlin v. Wyeth Pharm, et al. Dietzschold v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Dinopoli v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Dixon v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Dobson v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Donaldson v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Downing v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Driver v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Duff v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01313-WRW 4:08-cv-01174-WRW 4:08-cv-03112-WRW 4:08-cv-01533-WRW 4:08-cv-01532-WRW 4:08-cv-00802-WRW 4:08-cv-01168-WRW 4:08-cv-01530-WRW 4:08-cv-00807-WRW 4:08-cv-00830-WRW 4:08-cv-00837-WRW 4:08-cv-03099-WRW 4:08-cv-01181-WRW 4:08-cv-01498-WRW 4:08-cv-00838-WRW 4:08-cv-01866-WRW 4:08-cv-00832-WRW 4:08-cv-00831-WRW 4:08-cv-02451-WRW 4:08-cv-01657-WRW 4:08-cv-00995-WRW 4:08-cv-01656-WRW 4:08-cv-01278-WRW 4:08-cv-00730-WRW 4:08-cv-01529-WRW 4:08-cv-02481-WRW 4:08-cv-01428-WRW 4:08-cv-00965-WRW 4:08-cv-00975-WRW 4:08-cv-02764-WRW 4:08-cv-00785-WRW 4:08-cv-02828-WRW 4:08-cv-00773-WRW 4:08-cv-00763-WRW 4:08-cv-00792-WRW 4:08-cv-01081-WRW 4:08-cv-00805-WRW 4:08-cv-01042-WRW 4:08-cv-01028-WRW 4:08-cv-01029-WRW 4:08-cv-01096-WRW 4:08-cv-01047-WRW 4:08-cv-00762-WRW 4:08-cv-00803-WRW 5 Duff v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Duncan v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Eirk v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Estes v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Ezell v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Fox v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Frazier v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Gibbons v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Gillispie v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Gipson v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Glumske v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Goerlitz v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Goldsmith v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Goldstein v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Gorke v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Graves v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Grayson v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Gregory v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Grimes v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Gurges v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Guthrie-Wallace v. Wyeth, et al. Hall v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Hangge v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Harrison v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Huber v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Ivey v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Jenkins v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Jensen v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Joseph v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Killion v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Kuyers v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Laird v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Leijha v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Livingston v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Mills v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Moore v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Newton v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Olson v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Piatti v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Pipia v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Porter v. Wyeth et al. Pressentin-Ebbin v. Wyeth, et al. Ritter v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Roper v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Rouach v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Royal v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Rushton v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Salinas v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Salter v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00842-WRW 4:08-cv-01147-WRW 4:08-cv-03032-WRW 4:08-cv-01471-WRW 4:08-cv-01607-WRW 4:08-cv-01558-WRW 4:08-cv-01049-WRW 4:08-cv-01026-WRW 4:08-cv-01661-WRW 4:08-cv-01120-WRW 4:08-cv-01136-WRW 4:08-cv-01035-WRW 4:08-cv-01752-WRW 4:08-cv-01076-WRW 4:08-cv-01229-WRW 4:08-cv-00881-WRW 4:08-cv-00884-WRW 4:08-cv-00749-WRW 4:08-cv-00868-WRW 4:08-cv-01494-WRW 4:08-cv-01045-WRW 4:08-cv-03080-WRW 4:08-cv-02487-WRW 4:08-cv-00929-WRW 4:08-cv-00915-WRW 4:08-cv-02475-WRW 4:08-cv-01581-WRW 4:08-cv-01525-WRW 4:08-cv-01165-WRW 4:08-cv-01163-WRW 4:08-cv-01056-WRW 4:08-cv-00689-WRW 4:08-cv-00714-WRW 4:08-cv-01652-WRW 4:08-cv-02468-WRW 4:08-cv-00891-WRW 4:08-cv-01061-WRW 4:08-cv-01478-WRW 4:08-cv-03416-WRW 4:08-cv-02827-WRW 4:08-cv-01254-WRW 4:08-cv-03316-WRW 4:08-cv-01207-WRW 4:08-cv-03311-WRW 4:08-cv-01303-WRW 4:08-cv-01205-WRW 4:08-cv-03307-WRW 4:08-cv-01348-WRW 4:08-cv-01324-WRW 6 Sapp v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01383-WRW Schuchardt v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01343-WRW Scott v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01342-WRW Seal v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00927-WRW Selby v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01336-WRW Shanklin v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00900-WRW Shell v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00902-WRW Shipman v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01698-WRW Shippen v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01339-WRW Skelton v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01696-WRW Slover v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00904-WRW Smith v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00905-WRW Smith v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01352-WRW Stanberry-Baker v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-02090-WRW Standley v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-02464-WRW Stepp v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00907-WRW Stevens v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01588-WRW Stewart v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01420-WRW Stickney v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01516-WRW Taylor v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01208-WRW Taylor v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01368-WRW Teague v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00695-WRW Tichenor v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01373-WRW Tietz v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-03320-WRW Timbrook v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01538-WRW VanDoren v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01110-WRW Violet v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01121-WRW Waddell v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01124-WRW Wade v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-02087-WRW Wagner v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01699-WRW Walker v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00740-WRW Wallace v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01597-WRW Way-Jones v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01210-WRW Weldon v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01518-WRW Whiddon v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01357-WRW White v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01688-WRW Whorton v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00765-WRW Wilemon v. Wyeth et al. 4:08-cv-00789-WRW Williams v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00908-WRW Williams v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00752-WRW Williams v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01401-WRW Williams v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00706-WRW Wilson v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00692-WRW Wilson v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00889-WRW Wimberley v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01616-WRW Woodard v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00719-WRW Woods v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01202-WRW Yarborough v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01315-WRW Yost v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00754-WRW 7 Young v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Yourd v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Ziemski v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00712-WRW 4:08-cv-00888-WRW 4:08-cv-00885-WRW (Plaintiffs in this section are from Wyeth’s Reply (Doc. No. 1991), Exhibit 2.) Abaya v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01313-WRW Abney v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01174-WRW Adams v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-03112-WRW Alexander v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01533-WRW Alsop v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01532-WRW Archer v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00802-WRW Bachman v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01168-WRW Bailey v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01530-WRW Ball v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00807-WRW Bascom v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00830-WRW Beauchamp v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00837-WRW Bello v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-03099-WRW Bishop v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01181-WRW Blackburn v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01498-WRW Bolanos v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00838-WRW Brewster v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01866-WRW Brown v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00832-WRW Bruce v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00831-WRW Campbell v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-02451-WRW Carnesecca v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01657-WRW Carrasco v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00995-WRW Casey v. Wyeth et al. 4:08-cv-01656-WRW Chesnut v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01278-WRW Chitty v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00730-WRW Christensen v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01529-WRW Christiansen v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-02481-WRW Cook v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01428-WRW Cummings v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00965-WRW Cummings v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00975-WRW Daniels v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-02764-WRW Davis v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00785-WRW Davis v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-02828-WRW Dean v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00773-WRW Dean v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00763-WRW Dennis v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00792-WRW Devlin v. Wyeth Pharm. Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01081-WRW Dietzschold v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00805-WRW Dinopoli v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01042-WRW Dixon v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01028-WRW Dobson v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01029-WRW Donaldson v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01096-WRW Downing v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01047-WRW Driver v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00762-WRW Duff v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00803-WRW 8 Duff v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00842-WRW Duncan v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01147-WRW Eirk v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-03032-WRW Estes v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01471-WRW Ezell v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01607-WRW Fox v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01558-WRW Frazier v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01049-WRW Gibbons v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01026-WRW Gillispie v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01661-WRW Gipson v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01120-WRW Glumske v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01136-WRW Goerlitz v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01035-WRW Goldsmith v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01752-WRW Goldstein v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01076-WRW Gorke v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01229-WRW Graves v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00881-WRW Grayson v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00884-WRW Gregory v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00749-WRW Grimes v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00868-WRW Gurges v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01494-WRW Guthrie-Wallace v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01045-WRW Hall v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-03080-WRW Hangge v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-02487-WRW Harrison v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00929-WRW Huber v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00915-WRW Ivey v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-02475-WRW Jenkins v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01581-WRW Jensen v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01525-WRW Joseph v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01165-WRW Killion v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01163-WRW Kuyers v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01056-WRW Laird v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00689-WRW Leijha v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00714-WRW Livingston v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01652-WRW Mills v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-02468-WRW Moore v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00891-WRW Newton v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01061-WRW Olson v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01478-WRW Piatti v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-03416-WRW Pipia v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-02827-WRW Porter v. Wyeth et al. 4:08-cv-01254-WRW Pressentin-Ebbin v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-03316-WRW Ritter v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01207-WRW Roper v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-03311-WRW Rouach v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01303-WRW Royal v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01205-WRW Rushton v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-03307-WRW Salinas v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01348-WRW Salter v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01324-WRW 9 Sapp v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01383-WRW Schuchardt v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01343-WRW Scott v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01342-WRW Seal v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00927-WRW Selby v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01336-WRW Shanklin v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00900-WRW Shell v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00902-WRW Shipman v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01698-WRW Shippen v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01339-WRW Skelton v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01696-WRW Slover v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00904-WRW Smith v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00905-WRW Smith v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01352-WRW Stanberry-Baker v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-02090-WRW Standley v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-02464-WRW Stepp v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00907-WRW Stevens v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01588-WRW Stewart v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01420-WRW Stickney v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01516-WRW Taylor v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01208-WRW Taylor v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01368-WRW Teague v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00695-WRW Tichenor v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01373-WRW Tietz v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-03320-WRW Timbrook v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01538-WRW VanDoren v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01110-WRW Violet v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01121-WRW Waddell v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01124-WRW Wade v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-02087-WRW Wagner v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01699-WRW Walker v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00740-WRW Wallace v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01597-WRW Way-Jones v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01210-WRW Weldon v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01518-WRW Whiddon v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01357-WRW White v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01688-WRW Whorton v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00765-WRW Wilemon v. Wyeth et al. 4:08-cv-00789-WRW Williams v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00908-WRW Williams v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00752-WRW Williams v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01401-WRW Williams v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00706-WRW Wilson v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00692-WRW Wilson v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00889-WRW Wimberley v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01616-WRW Woodard v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00719-WRW Woods v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01202-WRW Yarborough v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01315-WRW Yost v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00754-WRW 10 Young v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Yourd v. Wyeth Inc., et al. Ziemski v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00712-WRW 4:08-cv-00888-WRW 4:08-cv-00885-WRW (Plaintiffs in this section are from Wyeth’s Reply (Doc. No. 1991), Exhibit 3.) Cecil v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00743-WRW Davis v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-00800-WRW Dockstader v. Wyeth Inc., et al. 4:08-cv-01032-WRW Cecil v. Wyeth, 4:08-cv-00743-WRW Espinosa v. Wyeth, et al, 4:08-cv-01430-WRW Sarvis v. Wyeth et al., 4:08-cv-00746-WRW Seaborn (Deceased) vs. Wyeth, et al. 4:08-cv-00844-WRW Sebolt vs. Wyeth, et al 4:08-cv-00849-WRW Smith vs. Wyeth, et al 4:08-cv-00906 WRW Sprouse vs. Wyeth, et al. 4:08-cv-01370-WRW Stalnaker vs. Wyeth, et al. 4:08-cv-01605-WRW Stewart v. Wyeth et al 4:08-cv-01514-WRW Stork v. Wyeth, et al 4:08-cv-01171-WRW Story vs. Wyeth, et al. 4:08-cv-01307-WRW Tavernellis vs. Wyeth, et al 4:08-cv-01762-WRW Tracey v. Wyeth, et al 4:08-cv-01507-WRW Tuttle v Wyeth, et al 4:08-cv-00897-WRW Vetsch vs. Wyeth, et al. 4:08-cv-1301-WRW Vinson v. Wyeth et al. 4:08-cv-00961-WRW Walden v. Wyeth, et al 4:08-cv-00680-WRW Walker vs. Wyeth, et al. 4:08-cv-02616-WRW Weber vs. Wyeth, et al. 4:08-cv-1331-WRW A. Williams v. Wyeth, et al 4:08-cv-00726-WRW G. Williams vs. Wyeth, et al. 4:08-cv-1606-WRW L. Williams vs. Wyeth, et al. 4:08-cv-00723-WRW Williamson vs. Wyeth, et al. 4:08-cv-01418 -WRW Winters v. Wyeth, et al 4:08-CV-01077 -WRW Wise v. Wyeth, et al 4:08-cv-00912-WRW Woolery vs. Wyeth, et al. 4:08-cv-01738 -WRW Worley vs. Wyeth, et al. 4:08-cv-1417 -WRW Wright vs. Wyeth, et al. 4:08-cv-1410 -WRW Wright vs. Wyeth, et al. 4:08-cv-01415-WRW Cummings vs. Wyeth, et al. 4:08-cv-1763 -WRW Fuller vs. Wyeth, et al. 4:08-cv-01085-WRW Mann (Deceased) vs. Wyeth, et al. 4:08-cv-02474 -WRW Markowitz vs. Wyeth, et al. 4:08-cv-02866 -WRW Matthews vs. Wyeth, et al. 4:08-cv-02832 -WRW Plummer vs. Wyeth, et al. 4:08-cv-02379 -WRW Reis vs. Wyeth, et al. 4:08-cv-02223 -WRW Robinson vs. Wyeth, et al. 4:08-cv-00899-WRW Farnham v. Wyeth, et al. 4:08-cv-00939-WRW Fretwell vs. Wyeth, et al. 4:08-cv-00937-WRW Gaddis vs. Wyeth, et al. 4:08-cv-01001-WRW 11 Gibbons vs. Wyeth, et al. Good vs. Wyeth, et al. Greer vs. Wyeth, et al. Haga vs. Wyeth, et a1. Hammett vs. Wyeth, et a1. Hearing vs. Wyeth, et al. Hollingsworth vs. Wyeth, et al. Hoover vs. Wyeth, et al. Renteria vs. Wyeth, et al. Russ v. Wyeth Inc., et al Shows vs. Wyeth, et al. Slavicek vs. Wyeth, et al. Sullivan vs. Wyeth, et al. Thompson v. Wyeth et al. Tavernellis vs. Wyeth, et al. 4:08-cv-01134-WRW 4:08-cv-00962-WRW 4:08-cv-00887-WRW 4:08-cv-00934-WRW 4:08-cv-00690-WRW 4:08-cv-01062-WRW 4:08-cv-01059-WRW 4:08-cv-01060-WRW 4:08-cv-01162-WRW 4:08-cv-00941-WRW 4:08-cv-01367-WRW 4:08-cv-01078-WRW 4:08-cv-00745 WRW 4:08-cv-00914-WRW 4:08-cv-01762-WRW 12

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.