SONG V. HOLDER, No. 06-73299 (9th Cir. 2012)

Annotate this Case

Download PDF

Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã®Ã© Ã®Ã°Ã¯Ã® Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã´ ¿Ã²µÃ²¿Ã² Ã §±«²¹ Ã ±²¹Ã´ ¿Ã²µÃ²¿Ã² Ã §±«²¹ Ã »±«´ Ã ±²¹ ¿²¼ Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã´ Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã² Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã´ Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã²Ã Ã² Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã ±Ã² Ã°ÃªÃ³Ã©ÃÃ®Ã§Ã§ Ã ¹»²½§ Ã ±-Ã² Ã Ã°Ã©Ã¯Ã³Ã©Ã§Ã°Ã³Ã¬Ã°Ã Ã Ã°Ã©Ã©Ã³Ã¯ÃªÃªÃ³Ã©Ã¨Ã© Ã »¬·¬·±²»®-Ã´ ªÃ² Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã² Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã´ Ã ®Ã²Ã´ Ã ¬¬±®²»§ Ã »²»®¿´Ã´ Ã »-°±²¼»²¬Ã² Ã »º±®»Ã¦ Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã´ Ã Ã² Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã´ ¿²¼ Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã´ Ã ·®½«·¬ Ã «¼¹»-Ã² Ã ² Ã ¿®½¸ ÃÃ°Ã´ Ã®Ã°Ã¯Ã®Ã´ ¬¸» Ã ±¿®¼ ±º Ã ³³·¹®¿¬·±² Ã °°»¿´- ®»±°»²»¼ ¬¸» °®±½»»¼·²¹- ·² ¬¸·- ½¿-» ¿- ¬± Ã · Ã Ã ±²¹Ã² Ã »½¿«-» ¬¸»®» ·- ²± ´±²¹»® ¿ º·²¿´ ±®¼»® ±º ®»³±ª¿´ º±® Ã -Ã² Ã ±²¹Ã´ ©» ©·¬¸¼®¿© ¬¸» ³»³±®¿²¼«³ ¼·-°±-·¬·±² º·´»¼ ±² Ã ½¬±¾»® ÃªÃ´ Ã®Ã°Ã¯Ã¯Ã² Ã ®»°´¿½»³»²¬ ³»³±®¿²¼«³ ¼·-°±-·¬·±² ©·´´ ¾» º·´»¼ ½±²½«®®»²¬´§ ©·¬¸ ¬¸·- ±®¼»®Ã² Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã®Ã© Ã®Ã°Ã¯Ã® Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã² Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã´ Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã²Ã Ã² Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã´ ¿Ã²µÃ²¿Ã² Ã §±«²¹ Ã ±²¹Ã´ ¿Ã²µÃ²¿Ã² Ã §±«²¹ Ã »±«´ Ã ±²¹Ã¥ Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã´ Ã ±Ã² Ã°ÃªÃ³Ã©ÃÃ®Ã§Ã§ Ã ¹»²½§ Ã ±-Ã² Ã Ã°Ã©Ã¯Ã³Ã©Ã§Ã°Ã³Ã¬Ã°Ã Ã Ã°Ã©Ã©Ã³Ã¯ÃªÃªÃ³Ã©Ã¨Ã© Ã »¬·¬·±²»®-Ã´ Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã¶ ªÃ² Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã² Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã´ Ã ®Ã²Ã´ Ã ¬¬±®²»§ Ã »²»®¿´Ã´ Ã »-°±²¼»²¬Ã² Ã ² Ã »¬·¬·±² º±® Ã »ª·»© ±º ¿² Ã ®¼»® ±º ¬¸» Ã ±¿®¼ ±º Ã ³³·¹®¿¬·±² Ã °°»¿´Ã «¾³·¬¬»¼ Ã »°¬»³¾»® Ã®Ã©Ã´ Ã®Ã°Ã¯Ã¯Ã¶Ã¶ Ã »º±®»Ã¦ Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã´ Ã Ã² Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã´ ¿²¼ Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã´ Ã ·®½«·¬ Ã «¼¹»-Ã² Ã §±²¹ Ã »±´ Ã ±²¹ ¿²¼ Ã · Ã Ã ±²¹Ã´ ²¿¬·ª»- ¿²¼ ½·¬·¦»²- ±º Ã ±«¬¸ Ã ±®»¿Ã´ °»¬·¬·±² º±® ®»ª·»© ±º ¬¸» Ã ±¿®¼ ±º Ã ³³·¹®¿¬·±² Ã °°»¿´-Å½ Ã¸ ¢Ã Ã Ã Å Ã· ±®¼»® ¼·-³·--·²¹ ¬¸»·® ¿°°»¿´ º®±³ ¿² ·³³·¹®¿¬·±² ¶«¼¹»Å½- ®»³±ª¿´ ±®¼»®Ã² Ã «® ¶«®·-¼·½¬·±² ·- Ã¶ Ã ¸·- ¼·-°±-·¬·±² ·- ²±¬ ¿°°®±°®·¿¬» º±® °«¾´·½¿¬·±² ¿²¼ ·- ²±¬ °®»½»¼»²¬ »¨½»°¬ ¿- °®±ª·¼»¼ ¾§ Ã§¬¸ Ã ·®Ã² Ã Ã² ÃÃªÃ³ÃÃ² Ã¶Ã¶ Ã ¸» °¿²»´ «²¿²·³±«-´§ ½±²½´«¼»- ¬¸·- ½¿-» ·- -«·¬¿¾´» º±® ¼»½·-·±² ©·¬¸±«¬ ±®¿´ ¿®¹«³»²¬Ã² Ã »» Ã »¼Ã² Ã Ã² Ã °°Ã² Ã Ã² ÃÃ¬Ã¸¿Ã·Ã¸Ã®Ã·Ã² ¹±ª»®²»¼ ¾§ Ã¨ Ã Ã²Ã Ã²Ã Ã² y Ã¯Ã®Ã«Ã®Ã² Ã » ®»ª·»© º±® -«¾-¬¿²¬·¿´ »ª·¼»²½» ¬¸» ¿¹»²½§Å½º·²¼·²¹- ±º º¿½¬Ã² Ã ·³ ªÃ² Ã ±´¼»®Ã´ ÃªÃ°Ã Ã Ã²Ã¼ Ã¯Ã¯Ã°Ã°Ã´ Ã¯Ã¯Ã°Ã® Ã¸Ã§¬¸ Ã ·®Ã² Ã®Ã°Ã¯Ã°Ã·Ã² Ã » ¼·-³·-¬¸» °»¬·¬·±² º±® ®»ª·»© ¿- ¬± Ã · Ã Ã ±²¹Ã´ Ã ¹»²½§ Ã ±Ã² Ã Ã°Ã©Ã©Ã³Ã¯ÃªÃªÃ³Ã©Ã¨Ã©Ã² Ã » ¼»²§ ·² °¿®¬ ¿²¼ ¼·-³·-- ·² °¿®¬ ¬¸» °»¬·¬·±² º±® ®»ª·»© ¿- ¬± Ã §±²¹ Ã »±´ Ã ±²¹Ã´ Ã ¹»²½§ Ã ±Ã² Ã Ã°Ã©Ã¯Ã³Ã©Ã§Ã°Ã³Ã¬Ã°ÃÃ² Ã ² Ã ¿®½¸ ÃÃ°Ã´ Ã®Ã°Ã¯Ã®Ã´ ¬¸» Ã Ã Ã ®»±°»²»¼ ¬¸» °®±½»»¼·²¹- ·² ¬¸·- ½¿-» ¿- ¬± Ã · Ã Ã ±²¹Ã² Ã » ¬¸»®»º±®» ¼·-³·-- ¬¸» °»¬·¬·±² º±® ®»ª·»© ¿- ¬± Ã · Ã Ã ±²¹ ¾»½¿«-» ¬¸»®» ·- ²± ´±²¹»® ¿ º·²¿´ ±®¼»® º±® ¸»® ®»³±ª¿´Ã² Ã »» Ã¨ Ã Ã²Ã Ã²Ã Ã² y Ã¯Ã®Ã«Ã®Ã¸¿Ã·Ã¸Ã¯Ã·Ã² Ã - ¬± Ã §±²¹ Ã »±´ Ã ±²¹Ã´ -«¾-¬¿²¬·¿´ »ª·¼»²½» -«°°±®¬- ¬¸» ¿¹»²½§Å½- º·²¼·²¹ ±º ®»³±ª¿¾·´·¬§ ¾§ ½´»¿® ¿²¼ ½±²ª·²½·²¹ »ª·¼»²½»Ã² Ã »» ·¼Ã² ¿¬ Ã¯Ã¯Ã°ÃÃ² Ã §±²¹ Ã »±´ Ã ±²¹ ´¿½µ- -¬¿²¼·²¹ ¬± ¿--»®¬ ¸·- »¯«¿´ °®±¬»½¬·±² ½±²¬»²¬·±² ¾»½¿«-» ¸» ¢¼±Ã »-Ã ²±¬ ¾»´±²¹ ¬± ¬¸» ½´¿-- ±º ®»¬«®²·²¹ Ã Ã ¿©º«´ Ã »®³¿²»²¬ Ã »-·¼»²¬-Ã ©¸± ¿®» ¿´´»¹»¼´§ -·³·´¿®´§ -·¬«¿¬»¼ ¬± ¿°°´·½¿²¬- º±® ¿¼³·--·±²Ã²Å Ã ¼Ã² ¿¬ Ã¯Ã¯Ã°Ã¬Ã² Ã §±²¹ Ã »±´ Ã ±²¹Å½- ®»³¿·²·²¹ ½±²¬»²¬·±² ·- ²±¬ °»®-«¿-·ª»Ã² Ã - ¬± Ã · Ã Ã ±²¹Ã´ Ã ¹»²½§ Ã ±Ã² Ã Ã°Ã©Ã©Ã³Ã¯ÃªÃªÃ³Ã©Ã¨Ã©Ã¦ Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã² Ã - ¬± Ã §±²¹ Ã »±´ Ã ±²¹Ã´ Ã ¹»²½§ Ã ±Ã² Ã Ã°Ã©Ã¯Ã³Ã©Ã§Ã°Ã³Ã¬Ã°ÃÃ¦ Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã ·² °¿®¬Ã¥ Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã Ã ·² °¿®¬Ã² Ã® Ã°ÃªÃ³Ã©ÃÃ®Ã§Ã§

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.