MELINDA GABRIELLA VALENZUELA v. DR. JAMES CORD
Annotate this Case
Download PDF
IN THE ARIZONA COURT OF APPEALS DIVISION TWO MELINDA GABRIELLA VALENZUELA, Plaintiff/Appellant, v. DR. JAMES CORD, Defendant/Appellee. No. 2 CA-CV 2016-0074 Filed September 7, 2016 THIS DECISION DOES NOT CREATE LEGAL PRECEDENT AND MAY NOT BE CITED EXCEPT AS AUTHORIZED BY APPLICABLE RULES. NOT FOR PUBLICATION See Ariz. R. Sup. Ct. 111(c)(1); Ariz. R. Civ. App. P. 28(a)(1), (f). Appeal from the Superior Court in Pinal County No. S1100CV201501069 The Honorable Stephen F. McCarville, Judge APPEAL DISMISSED Melinda G. Valenzuela, Buckeye In Propria Persona MEMORANDUM DECISION Presiding Judge Vásquez authored the decision of the Court, in which Chief Judge Eckerstrom and Judge Miller concurred. VALENZUELA v. CORD Decision of the Court V Á S Q U E Z, Presiding Judge: ¶1 Melinda Valenzuela appeals the trial court’s order dismissing this case without prejudice for failure to submit proof of service. Because we lack jurisdiction, we dismiss the appeal. Factual and Procedural Background ¶2 Valenzuela, an inmate in the Arizona Department of Corrections, filed a lawsuit against Dr. James Cord based on an incident in which she claims he “sexually assault[ed] her and then ripped out her surgically implanted tube.” Upon her failure to file proof of service as required by Rule 4(g), Ariz. R. Civ. P., the trial court dismissed the case without prejudice in a signed minute entry. The court ordered that its minute entry would “serve as the final order pursuant to Rule 54(c), of the Arizona Rules of Civil Procedure.” This appeal followed. Jurisdiction ¶3 This court has an independent duty to consider whether we have jurisdiction over an appeal and, if lacking, to dismiss the appeal. Robinson v. Kay, 225 Ariz. 191, ¶ 4, 236 P.3d 418, 419 (App. 2010). Our jurisdiction is statutory and is generally limited to appeals from final judgments. Camasura v. Camasura, 238 Ariz. 179, ¶¶ 5-6, 358 P.3d 600, 602 (App. 2015); see also A.R.S. § 12-2101(A)(1). We review de novo the trial court’s determination that a judgment is final. Robinson, 225 Ariz. 191, ¶ 4, 236 P.3d at 419; see also Madrid v. Avalon Care Ctr.-Chandler, L.L.C., 236 Ariz. 221, ¶¶ 3, 6, 338 P.3d 328, 330-31 (App. 2014). ¶4 In general, a dismissal without prejudice is not a final, appealable judgment. McMurray v. Dream Catcher USA, Inc., 220 Ariz. 71, ¶ 4, 202 P.3d 536, 539 (App. 2009). “[F]or that reason alone [an] appeal of [such an] order should be dismissed.” Id., quoting L.B. Nelson Corp. of Tucson v. W. Am. Fin. Corp., 150 Ariz. 211, 217, 722 P.2d 379, 385 (App. 1986) (alterations in McMurray). However, a dismissal without prejudice is appealable when the statute of limitations bars the timely refiling or the dismissal is entered without leave to amend. Canyon Ambulatory Surgery Ctr. v. SCF 2 VALENZUELA v. CORD Decision of the Court Ariz., 225 Ariz. 414, ¶ 14, 239 P.3d 733, 737-38 (App. 2010); see also § 12-2101(A)(3) (appeal may be taken from “order affecting a substantial right made in any action when the order in effect determines the action and prevents judgment from which an appeal might be taken”). ¶5 Valenzuela is appealing the trial court’s dismissal of this case without prejudice. She does not argue circumstances bar the refiling of her claims, such that the dismissal effectively determines the outcome of the action and prevents final judgment. Thus, the trial court’s order dismissing the case without prejudice is not appealable.1 See McMurray, 220 Ariz. 71, ¶ 4, 202 P.3d at 539. Disposition ¶6 For the reasons stated above, we dismiss this appeal for lack of jurisdiction. 1This is so notwithstanding the court’s reference to Rule 54(c). See Madrid, 236 Ariz. 221, ¶ 6, 338 P.3d at 331 (judgment not made final merely by inclusion of Rule 54(c) language). 3
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
