Essex Insurance Company and Genesee General Agency, Inc. v. Southern Cleaning Service, Inc.
Annotate this CaseIn appeal no. 1140870, Southern Cleaning Service, Inc. ("SCSI"), appealed the grant of summary judgment entered favor of Essex Insurance Company and Genesee General Agency, Inc. (collectively, "the insurance defendants"), on SCSI's claims stemming from Essex's refusal to provide SCSI coverage under a commercial general-liability policy based on an alleged failure to timely notify Essex of the facts leading to the claim for coverage. In appeal no. 1140918, the insurance defendants cross-appealed the trial court's denial of their requests for costs. Winn-Dixie Montgomery, LLC entered into a contract with SCSI for provide floor-care and general janitorial services to multiple grocery stores in central Alabama. SCSI entered into a subcontract with Phase II Maintenance Systems, LLC, whereby Phase II became responsible for providing those services. That subcontract required Phase II to carry a minimum level of liability insurance and to list both SCSI and Winn-Dixie as "additional insureds" on such policies. Phase II contacted Alabama Auto Insurance Center ("Alabama Auto") for a policy; Alabama Auto in turn contacted Genesee, a managing general agency located in Georgia that connected independent agents like Alabama Auto with different insurance companies that provided the type of coverage being sought by the independent agent's customer. Ultimately, Genesee sent Alabama Auto a quote for a commercial general-liability policy issued by Essex that would meet Phase II's needs, and Alabama Auto presented that quote to Phase II. Phase II accepted the quote; Alabama Auto transmitted notice of that acceptance to Genesee; and Genesee, which held issuing authority for Essex, then issued Phase II the desired policy on behalf of Essex. In 2011, Beverly Paige was shopping at a Phase II-serviced Winn-Dixie in Montgomery when she allegedly slipped on a wet floor, fell, and was injured. A Phase II employee on duty at the store at the time of the fall reported the incident to Phase II's owner and president, William Wedgeworth, that same day, and Wedgeworth has given sworn testimony indicating that he separately notified both SCSI and Alabama Auto of the incident on the next available business day,and further specifically asked Alabama Auto to notify Genesee of the incident. After review of the trial court record, the Supreme Court concluded the trial court erred in granting summary judgment, citing several disputes of material fact that should have precluded the court's ultimate decision. As such, the Supreme Court reversed and remanded the outcome for further proceedings. The cross appeal was rendered moot.
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.