2013 New York Consolidated Laws
CPL - Criminal Procedure
Part 2 - THE PRINCIPAL PROCEEDINGS
Title M - PROCEEDINGS AFTER JUDGMENT
Article 470 - (470.05 - 470.60) APPEALS--DETERMINATION THEREOF
470.15 - Determination of appeals by intermediate appellate courts; scope of review.


NY Crim Pro L § 470.15 (2012) What's This?
 
  §  470.15  Determination  of  appeals  by intermediate appellate courts;
               scope of review.
    1. Upon an appeal to an intermediate appellate court from a  judgment,
  sentence or order of a criminal court, such intermediate appellate court
  may  consider  and  determine  any  question  of  law  or  issue of fact
  involving error or defect in the criminal court  proceedings  which  may
  have adversely affected the appellant.
    2.  Upon  such an appeal, the intermediate appellate court must either
  affirm or reverse or modify the criminal  court  judgment,  sentence  or
  order.  The  ways in which it may modify a judgment include, but are not
  limited to, the following:
    (a) Upon a determination that the trial evidence adduced in support of
  a verdict is not legally sufficient to establish the  defendant's  guilt
  of  an  offense  of  which he was convicted but is legally sufficient to
  establish his guilt of a lesser included offense, the court  may  modify
  the judgment by changing it to one of conviction for the lesser offense;
    (b)  Upon  a  determination  that  the  trial  evidence is not legally
  sufficient to establish the defendant's guilt of  all  the  offenses  of
  which  he was convicted but is legally sufficient to establish his guilt
  of one or more of such offenses, the court may modify  the  judgment  by
  reversing  it  with  respect  to  the  unsupported  counts and otherwise
  affirming it;
    (c) Upon  a  determination  that  a  sentence  imposed  upon  a  valid
  conviction  is  illegal  or unduly harsh or severe, the court may modify
  the judgment by reversing  it  with  respect  to  the  sentence  and  by
  otherwise affirming it.
    3.  A reversal or a modification of a judgment, sentence or order must
  be based upon a determination made:
    (a) Upon the law; or
    (b) Upon the facts; or
    (c) As a matter of discretion in the interest of justice; or
    (d) Upon any two or all three of the  bases  specified  in  paragraphs
  (a), (b) and (c).
    4.  The  kinds of determinations of reversal or modification deemed to
  be upon the law include, but are not limited to, the following:
    (a) That a ruling or instruction of the court, duly protested  by  the
  defendant,  as  prescribed  in  subdivision  two of section 470.05, at a
  trial resulting in a judgment, deprived the defendant of a fair trial;
    (b) That evidence adduced at a trial resulting in a judgment  was  not
  legally  sufficient  to establish the defendant's guilt of an offense of
  which he was convicted;
    (c) That a sentence was unauthorized, illegally imposed  or  otherwise
  invalid as a matter of law.
    5.  The  kinds of determinations of reversal or modification deemed to
  be on the facts include, but are not limited to, a determination that  a
  verdict  of conviction resulting in a judgment was, in whole or in part,
  against the weight of the evidence.
    6. The kinds of determinations of reversal or modification  deemed  to
  be  made  as  a matter of discretion in the interest of justice include,
  but are not limited to, the following:
    (a) That an error or defect  occurring  at  a  trial  resulting  in  a
  judgment,  which  error  or  defect  was  not duly protested at trial as
  prescribed in subdivision two of section  470.05  so  as  to  present  a
  question of law, deprived the defendant of a fair trial;
    (b) That a sentence, though legal, was unduly harsh or severe.

Disclaimer: These codes may not be the most recent version. New York may have more current or accurate information. We make no warranties or guarantees about the accuracy, completeness, or adequacy of the information contained on this site or the information linked to on the state site. Please check official sources.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.