State of South Dakota v. Robert Leroy Anderson 2003 SD 65

In The  Supreme Court

Of The

State of South Dakota

STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA
Plaintiff and Appellee,
 vs.
Robert Leroy Anderson
Defendant and Appellant
 
[2003 SD 65]

The Court having received proof that defendant committed suicide on March 30, 2003, while incarcerated in the South Dakota State Penitentiary and while awaiting the out come of this appeal, and

Whereas the issuance of the decision in this appeal was delayed at the request of defendant so that the Court could consider his additional arguments based on new authority, and

            Whereas the decision in this matter would have been handed down before defendant’s death had the matter not been delayed at his request, and

            Whereas defendant elected to take his own life before the issuance of the decision in this case and one ought not to be able to erase a criminal conviction through suicide, and

            Whereas the crux of defendant’s appellate arguments challenged the procedure and law pertaining to his death penalty sentence, which issues are now moot, and regardless of the death penalty questions, this Court would have affirmed defendant’s criminal convictions, now, therefore, in  these circumstances, the Court in the exercise of its discretion, herby

            ORDERS that the appeal in this case is hereby dismissed, but defendant’s judgment of conviction for the kidnapping and murder of Larisa Dumansky and the rape and murder of Piper Streyle shall neither be vacated nor abated.

            DATED at Pierre, South Dakota, this 30 day of May, 2003.