Martin v Palisades Collection, LLC

Annotate this Case
Download PDF
Martin v Palisades Collection, LLC 2012 NY Slip Op 31732(U) June 27, 2012 Sup Ct, New York County Docket Number: 116099/2010 Judge: Donna M. Mills Republished from New York State Unified Court System's E-Courts Service. Search E-Courts (http://www.nycourts.gov/ecourts) for any additional information on this case. This opinion is uncorrected and not selected for official publication. [* 1] SUPIIKME COURT O F THK STATE OF NKW YORK- NIZW YORK COUN'I'Y PRICSF~N'I': IWNNA M. MILLS Justice . .. /<'RANMAK'l'lN, Indii1idi,iul ~ ~ On d n Behnlf 'of 'All 0llzt.r. NCW York R(:sidtJnhWho l-kxvc ll3cen Sziud iii t h e NLW Y o r k Churls, o r I Iavc Bccn 'I'lireatened With S L I . Suit, C~ L3y I3cfcndants to Collcct on C'onsuiiicr-Credit C'ard l k b t oil (:rcdit ( h r d s Issued hy I Icritage C'hasc And As 'lo Which There ]Has I k e n No Credit C~u-d Activity in the Prior 'I'lirce Years, Llespitc thc Facl Ihat Such Lawsuits Are Time-Barred I.Jnder the Delaware Statute of I ,imitations As Made Applicable By New Y ork's Borrowing Statute, P1aintiff, -against- l)hl,IShI>ESC'OLLEC'TlON, LLC', and KIRSC'HENDALJM & l~l~ll,l,ll's, I).('., Dei'crldarlts . Notice of Mo tion/Order to Show C'ausc-Affidavits-- Exhibits.. .. 6 Aiisweriiig A l'litiavi Is-- Kxliibi~s - Replying Mlidavits / - C'R(_)SS-MOTION: YES .. NO LJpoii the loregoing papers, it is ordered [hat this niolion is: Check one: -. - FINAL I~ISPOSI'I~ION NON - t; I N A I., D I S P O S I'll(1N [* 2] (-:OUKTO F ' 'THE STATE OF NF,W YOF(T< COUNTY OF NEW Y O R K : TAS PART .58 SUE'REML ...................................... ,b'l<AN MAP'I'IN, Irii-livi d u a l l y a n d On l3cChal f of All Okher- New York Kcs i d e n t s Who H a v e Been Sued In t . h e N e w Y o r k COUI-!-.S, or Have Bccn Thr-etit.eric:d Wit.h Such Suit., Ry De f c 1-1cia 1.1 I.s t . o C C)1 1. E: ct 0r.1 C C) i?i: ~ I I I r ~ : : < I Credit Card D e l ) I? c ) I i ( J r e d iL Cards Issueci by H e r i t a g e Chase Arid A s Tc W l - i i . c : i T h e r e Has B e e n No C r e d i t Cclrc-1 A c t i v i t y i n t h e P r i o r T h r e e Year.:-;, r1e.spi.t.c t . h c k'act t - h a t . S U L ' ~ LawsuiLs Are T.irne-naI-red Under t.he L k l a w a r e S t a t u t e 01 L i m i t . a t i o n s A.s Made A p p 1 i cab1 c By Ncw Y o r k ' s Borrowinq S t a t u L e , P 1 1.i II1.. i. f f , 1 - X Iridex No. -1 16099/2010 DECTSTON AND ORDER ayain:I;t- PALISADES C O L L E C ' I ' I O N , L L C , a n d KTKSCIIENnATJM I PHTT,T,TPS, P.(3. , ; I lhese competing mot.ions t.o coinpcl d i sc:1 o s u r e , f o r a , p r o t e c t i v e o r d e r , a n d for lcclvc t o sCrvc: an(:1 r i l e a n amended [* 3] [* 4] [* 5] 4 [* 6] CPLK 902, captioned, " [o]r d c r a l l owing class d c t i o n WiLhin s i x t y d a y s a f t e r t h e t i m e t o s c r v c a r e s p o n s i v e p1cclding h a s e x p i r c d f o r a l l p c r s o n s nameti as d c l f c r i d a n t s i n ;in a c t i o n b r o u g h t . 3.5 a (: ;iss acctioii, t.he .I p l a i r - i k iff s h d 1 1 move f o r order L o d e t e r m i n c ! whetherit. i s to be s o m,?int.aineci. An o r d e r w n d e r [:his s e c t i o n may h e cont3i t i o n ; l l , arid may be a l l l e r e d or amcndetl b c f o r e t h e d e c i s i o n 011 t h e m e r i t s on t.he c : ( . ) L I L . ~ . ' s own m o t i o n or 011 m o t i o n o f t.he parti-e:;. The ac:Lion may be r n a i n t . a i n c d a s a class a c t . i o n or11 y if l.he c o u r t f i n d s !.l-iat t h e p r e r e q u i s i t e s u r i t l e r - :je(:tiorl 901 h ~ i v ehee1-1 s a t i s f i u d . Amoiig the m a t . t . e r s which t.he c o u I ' t shall c:onsi d e r i.n c l c t e r m i n i n g whether- i.he ac:I.ion may p r o c e e d ds c J a s s a(:I-.iori are: 5 [* 7] [* 8] 7 [* 9] 8 [* 10] [* 11] 1.0 [* 12] F E N T E R : 11

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.