Juarez et al v. Asher et al, No. 2:2020cv00700 - Document 91 (W.D. Wash. 2020)
Court Description: ORDER DENYING 22 MOTION FOR A TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER signed by Judge James L. Robart. (cc: ICE via email)(ST)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Juarez et al v. Asher et al 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 : " " " " " " " " " " " " " " ; 32 33 34 35 " WPKVGF"UVCVGU"FKUVTKEV"EQWTV" YGUVGTP"FKUVTKEV"QH"YCUJKPIVQP" CV"UGCVVNG" LQUWG"ECUVC¢GFC"LWCTG¥."gv"cn0." " " " Rgvkvkqpgtu/Rnckpvkhhu." " " x0" " PCVJCNKG"CUJGT."gv"cn0." " " " Tgurqpfgpvu/Fghgpfcpvu0" " K0" 36 39 ECUG"PQ0"E42/2922LNT/ONR" " QTFGT"FGP[KPI"OQVKQP"HQT" VGORQTCT["TGUVTCKPKPI"QTFGT" " KPVTQFWEVKQP" Dghqtg"vjg"eqwtv"ku"Rgvkvkqpgt/Rnckpvkhhu"Lqug"Ecuvc‚gfc"Lwctg|."Yknhtgfq"Hcxgnc"Cxgpfc‚q. 37 38 Doc. 91 "L.A.M."cpf"Pcggo"MjcpÓu"*eqnngevkxgn{."ÐRgvkvkqpgtuÑ+"oqvkqp"hqt"c"vgorqtct{" tguvtckpkpi" qtfgt" *ÐVTQÑ+" *VTQ" Oqv0" *Fmv0" %44+0+" Tgurqpfgpv/Fghgpfcpvu" Pcvjcnkg" Cujgt." Ocvvjgy" V0" Cndgpeg." Uvgxgp" Ncpihqtf." cpf" Wpkvgf" Uvcvgu" Kookitcvkqp" cpf" Ewuvqou" 3: GphqtegogpvÓu"*ÐKEGÑ+"*eqnngevkxgn{."ÐTgurqpfgpvuÑ+"qrrqug"RgvkvkqpgtuÓ"VTQ"oqvkqp0"*See Tgur0" 3; *Fmv0"%84+0+" 42 43 11" " 11" 44 " 45 11" QTFGT"Î"3" " Dockets.Justia.com 3 " " " Vjg" eqwtv" jcu" tgxkgygf" RgvkvkqpgtuÓ" oqvkqp." vjg" tgurqpug." vjg" rgvkvkqp" cpf" eqornckpv3" 4 *Eqorn0" *Fmv0" %3++." vjg" rctvkguÓ" uwdokuukqpu" tgncvgf" vq" vjg" oqvkqp." vjg" tgngxcpv" rqtvkqpu" qh" vjg" 5 tgeqtf."vjg"crrnkecdng"ncy."cpf"jgctf"qtcn"ctiwogpv"qp"Oc{"49."42420""Dgkpi"hwnn{"cfxkugf."vjg" 6 eqwtv"FGPKGU"RgvkvkqpgtuÓ"oqvkqp"hqt"c"VTQ0" KK0" 7 DCEMITQWPF" C0" Rtqegfwtcn"Dcemitqwpf" 8 9 Rnckpvkhhu"ctg"vjtgg4"kpfkxkfwcnu"jgnf"kp"ekxkn"fgvgpvkqp"d{"KEG"cv"vjg"Vceqoc"Pqtvjyguv" : Fgvgpvkqp"Egpvgt"*ÐPYFEÑ+5"kp"Vceqoc."Ycujkpivqp0"*See Eqorn0" "5;/880+"Qp"Oc{":."4242." ; Rgvkvkqpgtu" hkngf"vjgkt"rgvkvkqp." uggmkpi" c"ytkv" qh" jcdgcu" eqtrwu." qt"kp"vjg" cnvgtpcvkxg." kplwpevkxg" 32 tgnkgh."cickpuv"Tgurqpfgpvu0"*Id0+"Rgvkvkqpgtu"tgrtgugpv"vjcv"vjg{"ctg"Ðxwnpgtcdng"vq"ugtkqwu"ogfkecn" 33 eqornkecvkqpu"htqo"EQXKF/3;"cpf"ctg"cv"tkum"qh"ugtkqwu"knnpguu"cpf"fgcvj"uq"nqpi"cu"vjg{"ctg"jgnf" 34 kp"fgvgpvkqpÑ"fwg"vq"vjgkt"ogfkecn"eqpfkvkqpu0"*Id. ";70+""Qp"Oc{"33."4242."Rgvkvkqpgtu"hkngf"vjg" 35 rtgugpv" oqvkqp" uggmkpi" Ðkoogfkcvg" tgngcugÑ" htqo" fgvgpvkqp" cu" vjg{" cyckv" cflwfkecvkqp" qh" vjgkt" 36 kookitcvkqp"ecugu0"*VTQ"Oqv0"cv"90+"Rgvkvkqpgtu"ctiwg"vjcv"dgecwug"Fghgpfcpvu"ecppqv"tgogf{"vjg" 37 itcxg"tkum"qh"jcto"vjg{"hceg"htqo"EQXKF/3;."vjgkt"eqpvkpwgf"fgvgpvkqp"cv"vjg"PYFE"xkqncvgu" 38 vjgkt"Hkhvj"Cogpfogpv"tkijvu0"*Id."cv"360+"" 39 11" 11" 3: 3; 42 43 44 45 """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" "Rgvkvkqpgt/RnckpvkhhuÓ"kpkvkcn"hknkpi"ku"c"Ðrgvkvkqp"hqt"ytkv"qh"jcdgcu"eqtrwu"0"0"0"cpf"encuu"cevkqp" eqornckpv"hqt"kplwpevkxg"cpf"fgenctcvqt{"tgnkgh0Ñ"*See Eqorn0"cv"30+"Hqt"ukornkekv{Óu"ucmg."vjg"eqwtv" tghgtu" vq" vjg" rctvkgu" cu" ÐRgvkvkqpgtuÑ" cpf" ÐTgurqpfgpvuÑ" cpf" vjg" rgvkvkqp/eqornckpv" cu" vjg" Ðrgvkvkqp0Ñ" """ 4 " Tgurqpfgpvu" eqphkto" vjcv" Rgvkvkqpgt" L0C0O0" ycu" tgegpvn{" tgngcugf." ngcxkpi" qpn{" vjtgg" pcogf" Rgvkvkqpgtu" kp" vjku" cevkqp<" Ot0" Ecuvc‚gfc" Lwctg|." Ot0" Cxgfc‚q."cpf" Ot0" Mjcp0" " *Dquvqem" Fgen0" *Fmv0"%85+" "9;0+" " 5 " Vjg" PYFE" ku" cnuq" tghgttgf" vq" cu" vjg" Pqtvjyguv" KEG" Rtqeguukpi" Egpvgt" *ÐPYKREÑ+0" " *See Dquvqem"Fgen0" "30+" 3 QTFGT"Î"4" " 3 " " " Chvgt" jgctkpi" qtcn" ctiwogpv." vjg" eqwtv" hqwpf" vjcv" TgurqpfgpvuÓ" hcknwtg" vq" eqpfwev" 4 eqortgjgpukxg"vguvkpi"jcf"nghv"c"etkvkecn"hcevwcn"swguvkqpÏyjgvjgt"EQXKF/3;"ku"cntgcf{"rtgugpv" 5 cv" vjg" hceknkv{Ïvq" rwtg" urgewncvkqp." fgurkvg" vjg" hcev" vjcv" Tgurqpfgpvu" eqphktogf" vjg{" jcf" vjg" 6 tguqwtegu"cpf"ecrcdknkv{"vq"cfftguu"vjku"hwpfcogpvcn"hcevwcn"swguvkqp0"*See 714:142"Qtfgt"*Fmv0" 7 %9:+" cv" 90+"Ceeqtfkpin{." vjg" eqwtv" qtfgtgf" Tgurqpfgpvu" vq" ujqy" ecwug" gzrnckpkpi" yj{" KEG." kp" 8 eqpuwnvcvkqp"ykvj"kvu"eqpvtcevqt"vjg"IGQ"Itqwr"*ÐIGQÑ+."eqwnf"pqv"koogfkcvgn{"*c+"dgikp"vguvkpi" 9 fgvckpggu"cv"vjg"Pqtvjyguv"Fgvgpvkqp"Egpvgt"*ÐPYFEÑ+"qp"c"xqnwpvct{"dcuku="cpf"*d+"korngogpv" : c"rncp"hqt"vjqug"vjcv"tghwug"vguvkpi0"*Id0+"" ; Kp"tgurqpug"vq"vjg"eqwtvÓu"Oc{"4:."4242."ujqy"ecwug"qtfgt."Tgurqpfgpvu"hkngf"c"Fgenctcvkqp" 32 htqo" Uvgrjgp" Ncpihqtf." vjg" PYFE" hceknkv{" cfokpkuvtcvqt." uvcvkpi" vjcv" KEG" korngogpvgf" vjg" 33 ÐEQXKF/3;"Eqnngevkqp"cpf"Vguvkpi"Qrgtcvkqpcn"RncpÑ"vq"dgikp"eqortgjgpukxg"vguvkpi"qh"vjg"785" 34 fgvckpggu"ewttgpvn{"jqwugf"cv"vjg"PYFE0"*4f"Ncpihqtf"Fgen0"*Fmv0"%:4+0+"Tgurqpfgpvu"cnuq"hkngf" 35 c" ogoqtcpfwo" fcvgf" Oc{" 4:." 4242." qwvnkpkpi" vjg" rtqegfwtgu" wpfgt" vjku" rncp" hqt" vguvkpi" cnn" 36 fgvckpggu"yjq"eqpugpvgf"vq"c"vguv"cpf"ugvvkpi"hqtvj"rtqvqeqn"kp"vjg"gxgpv"vjcv"c"fgvckpgg"tghwugf" 37 vguvkpi0"*4f"Nkrrctf"Fgen0"*Fmv0"%:2+"Gz0"C0+"" D0" Eqpfkvkqpu"cv"vjg"PYFE" 38 39 Vjg"rctvkgu"tgn{"qp"c"ugtkgu"qh"fgenctcvkqpu"kp"uwrrqtv"qh"cpf"kp"qrrqukvkqp"vq"RgvkvkqpgtuÓ" 3: oqvkqp0"Rgvkvkqpgtu"tgn{"rtkoctkn{"qp"*3+"kpfkxkfwcn"fgenctcvkqpu"qh"Rgvkvkqpgtu"cpf"qvjgt"ewttgpv" 3; cpf"hqtogt"PYFE"fgvckpggu"*see, e.g.. Ecuvc‚gfc"Lwctg|"Fgen0"*Fmv0"%:+="Cxgpfc‚q"Fgen0"*Fmv0" 42 %9+="L0C0O0"Fgen0"*Fmv0"%33+="Mjcp"Fgen0"*Fmv0"%;+="Dqpctqx"Fgen0"*Fmv0"%36+="Tg{gu"Fgen0"*Fmv0" 43 %32+="Iqp|cng|"Fgen0"*Fmv0"%34+="Pw‚g|"Fgen0"*Fmv0"%35++="*4+"gzrgtv"fgenctcvkqpu"htqo"kphgevkqwu" 44 fkugcug"urgekcnkuvu."ogfkecn"rtqhguukqpcnu."cpf"cfokpkuvtcvqtu"ykvj"gzrgtvkug"kp"ekxkn"cpf"etkokpcn" 45 fgvgpvkqp"u{uvgou"*see, e.g.. Coqp"Fgen0"*Fmv0"%5+="OeMgp|kg"Fgen0"*Fmv0"%6+="Iqnqd"Fgen0"*Fmv0" QTFGT"Î"5" " 3 " " " %7+=" Uejtktq"Fgen0"*Fmv0"%8++="cpf"*5+"fgenctcvkqpu" htqo" eqwpugn" yjq"jcxg"xkukvgf"vjgkt"enkgpvu." 4 kpenwfkpi"Rgvkvkqpgtu."cv"vjg"PYFE"qxgt"vjg"rcuv"oqpvj"*see, e.g.."Cwiwuvkpg"Fgen0"*Fmv0"%38+=" 5 Pgtjgko"Fgen0"*Fmv0"%37+="Piq"Fgen0"*Fmv0"%45++0""" 6 Tgurqpfgpvu" tgn{" rtkoctkn{" qp" vjg" fgenctcvkqpu" qh" *3+" Ftgy" J0" Dquvqem." vjg" Qhhkegt" kp" 7 Ejctig"ykvj"vjg"W0U0"Fgrctvogpv"qh"Jqogncpf"Ugewtkv{"*ÐFJUÑ+."KEG."Gphqtegogpv"cpf"Tgoqxcn" 8 Qrgtcvkqpu"kp"vjg"Ugcvvng"Hkgnf"Qhhkeg"*ÐGTQ"UgcvvngÑ+"*Dquvqem"Fgen0"*Fmv0"%85++="*4+"PYFE" 9 Hceknkv{"Cfokpkuvtcvqt"Uvgrjgp"Ncpihqtf"*Ncpihqtf"Fgen0"*Fmv0"%89++="*5+"Enkpkecn"Fktgevqt"hqt"vjg" : KEG"Jgcnvj"Ugtxkegu"Eqtru"*ÐKJUEÑ+"Ujgtk"Ocncmjqxc"*3uv"Ocncmjqxc"Fgen0"*Fmv0"%86++="cpf"*6+" ; Nkgwvgpcpv"Eqoocpfgt"qh"KJUE."Tcpc{"[qpmgtu"*[qpmgtu"Fgen0"*Fmv0"%87++0" 32 30" Fgvckpgg"Vguvkpi"cpf"EQXKF/3;/Rqukvkxg"Fgvckpggu" 33 Rtkqt" vq" Oc{" 4:." 4242." EQXKF/3;" vguvu" ygtg" cfokpkuvgtgf" cv" vjg" PYFE" dcugf" qp" 34 iwkfcpeg"kuuwgf"d{"vjg"EFE0"Vjku"iwkfcpeg"fktgevu"enkpkekcpu"vq"wug"vjgkt"lwfiogpv"kp"fgvgtokpkpi" 35 kh"c"rcvkgpv"jcu"ukipu"cpf"u{orvqou"eqpukuvgpv"ykvj"EQXKF/3;0"*3uv"Ocncmjqxc"Fgen0" "45."470+" 36 Cp{"fgvckpgg"yjq"ycu"rqukvkxg"qt"Ðrtguworvkxgn{"rqukvkxgÑ"ycu"rncegf"kp"cp"kpfkxkfwcn"wpkv"kp"vjg" 37 Ogfkecn"Jqwukpi"Wpkv"*ÐOJWÑ+0""*Id. "480+"Vjg"OJW"jcu"gkijv"kuqncvkqp"tqqou."yjkej"kpenwfg" 38 hqwt"pgicvkxg"rtguuwtg"tqqou"fgukipgf"vq"jgnr"rtgxgpv"vjg"urtgcf"qh"cktdqtpg"rctvkengu0"Vyq"gorv{" 39 jqwukpi"wpkvu"ctg"cnuq"fgukipcvgf"cu"ogfkecn"qxgthnqy"wpkvu"kp"vjg"gxgpv"vjcv"urceg"twpu"qwv"cv"vjg" 3: OJW0" 3; Dgvyggp"Oc{"4:"cpf"Lwpg"4."4242."KEG"cpf"IGQ"vguvgf"cnn"fgvckpggu"cv"vjg"PYFE"yjq" 42 eqpugpvgf"vq"c"EQXKF/3;"vguv0"*4f"Ncpihqtf"Fgen0"cv"40+"Qp"Lwpg":."4242."Tgurqpfgpvu"tgrqtvgf" 43 vjg"tguwnvu"qh"vjg"eqortgjgpukxg"vguvkpi0"Qh"vjg"783"fgvckpggu"jqwugf"cv"vjg"PYFE."66;"qh"vjg" 44 672"fgvckpggu"vguvgf"pgicvkxg"hqt"EQXKF/3;."cpf"333"fgvckpggu"tghwugf"vguvkpi0"*4f"Ocncmjqxc" 45 Fgen0"*Fmv0"%:;+" "50+"Vjg"qpg"fgvckpgg"vjcv"vguvgf"rqukvkxg"cttkxgf"cv"vjg"PYFE"qp"Oc{"4;."4242." QTFGT"Î"6" " 3 " " " cpf"ycu"uvknn"kp"jku"36/fc{"swctcpvkpg"rgtkqf"kp"vjg"Pgy"Kpvcmg"Oqpkvqtkpi"Wpkv"cv"vjg"vkog"qh" 4 vguvkpi0" *Id." " 60+" Chvgt" tgegkxkpi" vjg" rqukvkxg" vguv" tguwnv." KEG" oqxgf" vjg" EQXKF/3;/rqukvkxg" 5 fgvckpgg"vq"vjg"OJW"hqt"qdugtxcvkqp0"Jku"egnnocvg."yjq"vguvgf"pgicvkxg"hqt"vjg"xktwu."yknn"tgockp" 6 kp"vjg"kpvcmg"wpkv"hqt"36"oqtg"fc{u0" 7 40" Pgyn{/cttkxgf"Fgvckpggu" 8 Cu"qh"Octej"42."4242."pgy"fgvckpggu"cttkxkpi"cv"vjg"PYFE"ctg"jqwugf"dcugf"qp"vjgkt"fcvg" 9 qh" cttkxcn" cpf" tkum" encuukhkecvkqp" ngxgn0" *Dquvqem" Fgen0" " 420+" Vjg" pgyn{/cttkxgf" fgvckpggu" ctg" : jqwugf"coqpi"vjtgg"ugrctcvg"jqwukpi"wpkvu"hqt"c"36/fc{"qdugtxcvkqpcn"rgtkqf"cpf"pqv"rgtokvvgf"vq" ; eqokping" ykvj" qvjgt" fgvckpggu0" Vjg" vjtgg" jqwukpi" wpkvu" eqpvckp" kpfkxkfwcn" egnnu" vq" jqwug" pgy" 32 fgvckpgguÏqpg" hqt" hgocng" fgvckpggu" cpf" vyq" hqt" ocng" fgvckpggu0" Tgurqpfgpvu" enctkhkgf" cv" qtcn" 33 ctiwogpv" vjcv" ugrctcvg" egnnu" ykvjkp" jqwukpi" wpkvu" jqnf" wr" vq" hqwt" fgvckpggu." ogcpkpi" vjcv" 34 pgyn{/cttkxgf"fgvckpggu"ykvj"pq"u{orvqou"qh"EQXKF/3;"ctg"jqwugf"ykvj"pq"oqtg"vjcp"vjtgg"qvjgt" 35 rgqrng0"*Oc{"49."4242"Oqvkqp"Jgctkpi"Vtcpuetkrv"*ÐOqv0"Jti0"Vt0Ñ+"cv"3;<35/380+"Chvgt"vjg"36/fc{" 36 kuqncvkqp" rgtkqf" ku" eqorngvg." fgvckpggu" ykvjqwv" u{orvqou" qh" EQXKF/3;" ctg" tgngcugf" kpvq" vjg" 37 igpgtcn"PYFE"rqrwncvkqp0"*Dquvqem"Fgen0" "420+" 38 Uvctvkpi"Lwpg"6."4242."cnn"fgvckpggu"cttkxkpi"cv"vjg"PYFE"yjq"eqpugpv"vq"vguvkpi"yknn"dg" 39 vguvgf" hqt" EQXKF/3;" cu" rctv" qh" vjgkt" kpvcmg" uetggpkpi0" *4f" Ocncmjqxc" Fgen0" " 70+" Cp{" 3: pgyn{/cttkxgf"fgvckpgg"yjq"vguvu"rqukvkxg"hqt"EQXKF/3;"cv"kpvcmg"yknn"dg"vtcpuhgttgf"vq"vjg"OJW" 3; hqt"oqpkvqtkpi0"*Id0+" 42 50" Uqekcn"Fkuvcpekpi"Ogcuwtgu" 43 Vjg" PYFE" jcu" vjg" ecrcekv{" vq" jqwug" 3.797" fgvckpggu" cpf" jkuvqtkecnn{" qrgtcvgu" pgct" 44 ecrcekv{0"*Dquvqem"Fgen. "80+"Jqygxgt."cu"qh"Oc{"39."4242."vjg"PYFE"jqwugf"qpn{"867"fgvckpggu" 45 cpf"ku"ewttgpvn{"qrgtcvkpi"cv"620;'"qh"kvu"v{rkecn"ecrcekv{0""*Id. "90+"Cu"qh"Lwpg":."4242."vjg"fgvckpgg" QTFGT"Î"7" " 3 " " " rqrwncvkqp" ycu" hwtvjgt" tgfwegf" vq" 7830" *4f" Ocncmjqxc" Fgen0" " 5+0" Kp" cffkvkqp" vq" tgfwekpi" vjg" 4 fgvckpgg"rqrwncvkqp."KEG"jcu"tgfkuvtkdwvgf"vjg"rqrwncvkqp"coqpi"jqwukpi"wpkvu"vq"cnnqy"hqt"itgcvgt" 5 uqekcn"fkuvcpekpi0"*Dquvqem"Fgen0" "8."32."52/530+"Qh"vjg"hkhvggp"wpkvu"eqpvckpkpi"fgvckpggu."IGQ" 6 jcu"urtgcf"qwv"vjg"rqrwncvkqp"cpf"tgswktgf"jgcf/vq/hqqv"unggrkpi"cttcpigogpvu"vq"oczkok|g"uqekcn" 7 fkuvcpekpi0"*Id.+"Uvctvkpi"vjg"yggm"qh"Crtkn"8."4242."KEG"cpf"IGQ"uvctvgf"kpvgtxkgykpi" egtvckp" 8 jkij/tkum"fgvckpggu"vq"ugg"kh"vjg{"yqwnf"citgg"vq"urgekcn"ceeqooqfcvkqpu"uwej"cu"ukping"egnnu"qt" 9 oqtg" urctugn{/rqrwncvgf" wpkvu0" *Dquvqem" Fgen0" "570+" Kp" cffkvkqp" vq" urtgcfkpi" qwv" vjg" fgvckpgg" : rqrwncvkqp" cetquu" vjg" hceknkv{." Tgurqpfgpvu" jcxg" cvvgorvgf" vq" okpkok|g" eqookpinkpi" dgvyggp" ; fkhhgtgpv"jqwukpi"wpkvu"d{"cuukipkpi"urgekhke"vkogu"hqt"tgetgcvkqp."tgnkikqwu"ugtxkegu."cpf"wug"qh"vjg" 32 ncy"nkdtct{0"*Id."cv" "5:/5;0+"Fgvckpggu"ctg"cnuq"rgtokvvgf"vq"gcv"cv"vjgkt"dgfu"vq"rtcevkeg"itgcvgt" 33 uqekcn"fkuvcpekpi"tcvjgt"vjcp"ukv"pgzv"vq"gcej"qvjgt"cv"vcdngu"fwtkpi"ogcnvkogu0"*Id. cv" "57/590+"" 34 Pqvykvjuvcpfkpi" vjg" tgfwegf" fgvckpgg" rqrwncvkqp." fgvckpggu" tgrqtv" ujctkpi" nkokvgf" 35 dcvjtqqo."dcvjkpi."cpf"jcpfycujkpi"hceknkvkgu"ykvj"vjqug"kp"vjgkt"jqwukpi"wpkvu."cu"ygnn"cu"vcdngvu." 36 gzgtekug"gswkrogpv."rjqpgu."cpf"xctkqwu"qvjgt"uwthcegu"vjtqwijqwv"vjg"fc{0"*Lwctg|"Fgen0" "5/8=" 37 Cxgfc‚q"Fgen0" ";/340+"Gxgp"kh"vjg{"tgvwtp"vq"gcv"cv"vjgkt"dgfu."fgvckpggu"owuv"uvcpf"kp"nkpgu"fwtkpi" 38 ogcnvkogu"qt"vq"oketqycxg"vjgkt"hqqf0"*Fmv0"%34"*Iqp|cng|"Fgen0+"cv" "8="Fmv0"%;"*Mjcp"Fgen0+"cv" 39 ":0+"Qvjgt"cevkxkvkgu."kpenwfkpi"cvvgpfkpi"kookitcvkqp"eqwtv."yckvkpi"hqt"ogfkecn"crrqkpvogpvu."qt" 3: rctvkekrcvkpi"kp"fckn{"qpg/jqwt"tgetgcvkqp"vkogu."rncegu"fgvckpggu"kpvq"enqug"eqpvcev0"*Lwctg|"Fgen0" 3; ";/32="Cxgfc‚q"Fgen0" "35="Iqp|cng|"Fgen0" "70+"Rgvkvkqpgtu"jcxg"cnuq"rtgugpvgf"gxkfgpeg"vjcv." 42 dcugf"qp"vjg"urcvkcn"cttcpigogpvu"ykvjkp"PYFE"jqwukpi"wpkvu"cu"fguetkdgf"kp"vjg"Ncpihqtf"cpf" 43 Dquvqem"fgenctcvkqpu."kv"ku"rj{ukecnn{"korquukdng"hqt"fgvckpggu"vq"eqpukuvgpvn{"ockpvckp"ukz"hggv"qh" 44 fkuvcpeg"htqo"qpg"cpqvjgt0"*See"OeGygp"Fgen0"*Fmv0"%94+"Gz0"D0+" 45 11" QTFGT"Î"8" " 3 " " " 60" J{ikgpg"Ogcuwtgu" 4 Wpfgt"KEGÓu"ewttgpv"rtqvqeqnu"hqt"EQXKF/3;" tgurqpug."jkij/vqwej"ctgcu"cv"vjg"PYFE" 5 owuv" dg" engcpgf" cpf" fkukphgevgf" ownvkrng" vkogu" rgt" fc{0" *Dquvqem" Fgen0" "440+" IGQ" jcu" cnuq" 6 korngogpvgf"gpjcpegf"ogcuwtgu"kp"jqwukpi"wpkvu."hqqf"rtgrctcvkqp"cpf"ugtxkeg"ctgcu."cpf"kpvcmg" 7 tqqou0"*Id. "45"*ÐKp"tgurqpug"vq"EQXKF/3;."IGQ"jcu"kphqtogf"KEG"vjcv"kv"jcu"gpjcpegf"engcpkpi" 8 kp"cnn"jqwukpi"wpkvu."hqqf"rtgrctcvkqp"cpf"ugtxkeg"ctgc."kpvcmg"tqqou"cpf"qvjgt"yqtm"egpvgtu"ykvj" 9 kpetgcugf" gorjcuku" qp" engcpkpi" eqpvcev" ctgcu" ykvj" fkukphgevcpv" engcpgtu" crrtqxgf" cu" ghhgevkxg" : cickpuv"EQXKF/3;0Ñ+0+"" ; IGQ"fgngicvgu"tgurqpukdknkv{"hqt"ockpvckpkpi"vjg"engcpnkpguu"qh"kvu"hceknkvkgu"vq"fgvckpggu." 32 yjq"ctg"gpicigf"cu"rctv"qh"vjg"PYFEÓu"Xqnwpvct{"Yqtm"Rtqitco0"*Id." "450+""C"IGQ"Ucpkvcvkqp" 33 Qhhkegt"ku"tgurqpukdng"hqt"oqpkvqtkpi"vjg"fgvckpgg"yqtmgtu."cpf"IGQ"jcu"gptqnngf"cpf"vtckpgf"vyq" 34 cffkvkqpcn"yqtmgtu"rgt"jqwukpi"wpkv"vq"eqpfwev"gpjcpegf"engcpkpi0"*Id.+"Jqygxgt."fgvckpggu"tgrqtv" 35 vjcv"IGQ"cpf"KEG"hckn"vq"cfgswcvgn{"uwrgtxkug"vjg"engcpkpi"cpf."cu"c"tguwnv."eqooqp"ctgcu"cpf" 36 ujctgf"fgxkegu."nkmg"rjqpgu"cpf"vcdngvu."ctg"pqv"cnyc{u"cfgswcvgn{"engcpgf"dgvyggp"wugu0""*See, 37 e.g.."Mjcp"Fgen0" ":/;= Iqp|cng|"Fgen0" "34"*uvcvkpi"vjcv"rjqpgu"cpf"gzgtekug"gswkrogpv"ctg"qpn{" 38 engcpgf" Ðgxgt{" hgy" fc{uÑ+=" Pw‚g|" Fgen0" " 32" *ekvkpi" eqpegtpu" vjcv" vcdngvu" ctg" pqv" uwhhkekgpvn{" 39 ucpkvk|gf"dgvyggp"wugu+0+"Fgvckpggu"cnuq"tgrqtv"vjcv"vjg{"twp"qwv"qh"uwrrnkgu."uwej"cu"uqcr"cpf"rcrgt" 3: vqygnu0"*See, e.g.."Ecuvc‚gfc"Lwctg|"Fgen0" "8="Cfgmwpng"Fgen0" ":="Mjcp"Fgen0" "33/340+"" 3; 70" Xkukvqtu"cpf"Uvchh" 42 KEG" jcu" vgorqtctkn{" uwurgpfgf" uqekcn" xkukvcvkqp" cv" vjg" PYFE0" Jqygxgt." cvvqtpg{u." 43 eqpvtcevqtu." cpf" tgnkikqwu" ugtxkeg" rtqxkfgtu" uvknn" gpvgt" vjg" hceknkv{" cpf" kpvgtcev" ykvj" fgvckpggu0"" 44 *Dquvqem"Fgen0" "62/670+"Xkukvqtu"ctg"tgswktgf"vq"ygct"rgtuqpcn"rtqvgevkxg"gswkrogpv"*ÐRRGÑ+" 45 *see id.+."dwv"Rgvkvkqpgtu"rtqxkfg"cp"ceeqwpv"htqo"Cpftgy"Y0"Cwiwuvkpg."cp"cvvqtpg{"vguvkh{kpi"qp" QTFGT"Î"9" " 3 " " " dgjcnh"qh"rgvkvkqpgtu."yjkej"uvcvgu"vjcv"eqwpugn"ygtg"pqv"ygctkpi"RRG"kp"vjg"ockp"yckvkpi"ctgc"hqt" 4 vjg"kookitcvkqp"eqwtvtqqo"pqt"kp"vjg"xkfgq"vgngeqphgtgpeg"eqwtvtqqo0"*Cwiwuvkpg"Fgen0"*Fmv0"%38+" 5 "7/330+" 6 KEG"cpf"IGQ"uvchh"ctg"gpeqwtcigf"vq"xqnwpvctkn{"ygct"ocumu"dwv"ctg"pqv"tgswktgf"vq"fq"uq0" 7 *Dquvqem"Fgen. "6:/6;0+"Fgvckpggu"tgrqtv"vjcv"egtvckp"iwctfu"tghwug"vq"ygct"ocumu0"*See, e.g.ý" 8 Mjcp"Fgen0"cv" "35="Cxgfc‚q"Fgen0"cv" "38="Lwctg|"Fgen0"cv" "35/36"*ÐKh"K"qt"qvjgt"fgvckpggu"cum"vjg" 9 iwctfu"vq"rwv"qp"ocumu."vjg{"yknn"ncwij"cv"wu"cpf"vgnn"wu"vjcv"kv"ku"pqv"tgswktgf0Ñ+0+"Cpqvjgt"cvvqtpg{" : vguvkh{kpi"qp"dgjcnh"qh"Rgvkvkqpgtu."Octm"Pgtjgko."eqttqdqtcvgu"fgvckpgguÓ"ceeqwpvu"qh"IGQ"uvchhÓu" ; igpgtcn" tghwucn"vq" ygct"ocumu0"Urgekhkecnn{."Ot0"Pgtjgko"enckou" vjcv"jg"jcu"Ðykvpguugf"c"xgt{" 32 ecxcnkgt"cvvkvwfgÑ"d{"uqog"iwctfu"kp"vgtou"qh"cfjgtkpi"vq"EQXKF/3;"rtqvqeqnu."kpenwfkpi"tghwucn" 33 vq"eqorngvg"hceknkv{"gpvtcpeg"hqtou."kipqtkpi"uchg"fkuvcpekpi"rtqvqeqnu."cpf"tghwucn"vq"ygct"ocumu0"" 34 *Pgtjgko"Fgen0"*Fmv0"%37+" "7/80+"Cnvjqwij"IGQ"gornq{ggu"ctg"tgswktgf"vq"pqvkh{"vjgkt"gornq{gt" 35 kh"vjg{"vguv"rqukvkxg."IGQ"ku"pqv"tgswktgf"vq"pqvkh{"KEG"kh"cp{"qh"kvu"uvchh"ogodgtu"jcxg"dggp"vguvgf" 36 qt"fkcipqugf"ykvj"EQXKF/3;0"*Dquvqem"Fgen0" "6;0+" E0" Rgvkvkqpgtu"cpf"Vjgkt"Fgvgpvkqp"Uvcvwugu" 37 38 Ot0"Ecuvc‚gfc"Lwctg|"ku"58"{gctu"qnf"cpf"c"ekvk|gp"qh"Ogzkeq0"*Ecuvc‚gfc"Lwctg|"Fgen0" "30+"" 39 Jg" ycu" tgoqxgf" htqo" vjg" Wpkvgf" Uvcvgu" kp" 422;" cpf" cickp" kp" 4233" cpf" ycu" oquv" tgegpvn{" 3: crrtgjgpfgf"d{"KEG"qp"Octej"42."42420""*Dquvqem"Fgen0" "930+"Ot0"Ecuvc‚gfc"Lwctg|"jcu"c"rgpfkpi" 3; cu{nwo"encko"cpf"jcu"oqxgf"vq"tgqrgp"jku"422;"tgoqxcn"rtqeggfkpiu0""*Id." "960+"Cnvjqwij"jku" 42 ogfkecn" tgeqtf" nkuvu" c" fkcipquku" qh" Ðoknf" kpvgtokvvgpv" cuvjoc.Ñ" RgvkvkqpgtuÓ" gzrgtv" ykvpguu." Ft0" 43 Mcvjgtkpg"E0"OeMgp|kg."eqpenwfgu"vjcv"Ot0"Ecuvc‚gfc"Lwctg|"Ðyqwnf"swcnkh{"hqt"c"fkcipquku"qh" 44 oqfgtcvg"rgtukuvgpv"cuvjocÑ"dcugf"qp"vjg"ogfkecvkqpu"jg"vcmgu"vq"rtgxgpv"fckn{"cuvjoc"u{orvqou0" 45 *OeMgp|kg"Fgen0" "49="see also id.."Gz0"4"cv"70+"Jku"ogfkecn"tgeqtfu"cnuq"nkuv"c"fkcipquku"qh"oknf" QTFGT"Î":" " 3 " " " cqtvke"uvgpquku"kp"Hgdtwct{"4242."cpf"c"ogfkecn"jkuvqt{"qh"ejtqpke"cuvjoc0""*Id0+""Jg"ku"pqv"gnkikdng" 4 hqt"c"dqpf"jgctkpi"dgecwug"jg"ku"fgvckpgf"rwtuwcpv"vq":"W0U0E0"¸"3453*c+*8+.6"dwv"jg"yknn"dg"gnkikdng" 5 qpeg"fgvckpgf"hqt"3:2"fc{u0"See Florez Tejada v. Godfrey.";76"H05f"3467"*;vj"Ekt0"4242+0""KJUE" 6 kfgpvkhkgf"Ot0"Ecuvc‚gfc"Lwctg|"cu"jkijgt"tkum."cpf"jg"ceegrvgf"KEGÓu"qhhgt"vq"dg"jqwugf"kp"c"wpkv" 7 cv"590:'"ecrcekv{0""*Dquvkem"Fgen0" "970+"Kh"tgngcugf."Ot0"Ecuvc‚gfc"Lwctg|"uvcvgu"jg"yqwnf"tgvwtp" 8 vq"Xcpeqwxgt."Ycujkpivqp"vq"nkxg"ykvj"jku"urqwug"cpf"hkxg"ejknftgp"cv"vjgkt"crctvogpv0"*Ecuvc‚gfc" 9 Lwctg|"Fgen0" "420+" : Ot0"Hcxgnc"Cxgpfc‚q"ku"68"{gctu"qnf"cpf"c"ekvk|gp"qh"Ogzkeq0"*Hcxgnc"Cxgpfc‚q"Fgen0" ; "30+" Jg" uwhhgtu" htqo" oqfgtcvg" rgtukuvgpv" cuvjoc" cpf" wugu" cp" kpjcngt" vykeg" c" fc{0" *Id. " 6=" 32 OeMgp|kg"Fgen0" "480+"Jg"ku"ewttgpvn{"jqwugf"kp"c"wpkv"cv"790:'"ecrcekv{0""Ot0"Hcxgnc"Cxgpfc‚q" 33 ycu"eqpxkevgf"qh"Ftkxkpi"Wpfgt"vjg"Kphnwgpeg"kp"4236"cpf"cttguvgf"hqt"FWKu"kp"423;"cpf"42420" 34 *Dquvqem"Fgen0" "980+"Jg"ku"jgnf"wpfgt":"W0U0E0"¸"3448*c+"cpf"vjgtghqtg"uvcvwvqtkn{"gnkikdng"hqt"c" 35 dqpf"jgctkpi0"Kh"tgngcugf."jg"rncpu"vq"nkxg"ykvj"jku"dtqvjgt"kp"Hgfgtcn"Yc{."Ycujkpivqp0"*Hcxgnc" 36 Cxgpfc‚q"Fgen0" "420+" 37 Ot0"Mjcp"ku"69"{gctu"qnf."c"ekvk|gp"qh"Rcmkuvcp"cpf"c"Ncyhwn"Rgtocpgpv"Tgukfgpv"qh"vjg" 38 Wpkvgf" Uvcvgu0" *Mjcp" Fgen0" 30+" Jg" ku" fgvckpgf" cpf" uwdlgev" vq" tgoqxcn" dcugf" qp" jku" eqpvkpwgf" 39 xkqncvkqp"qh"c"fqoguvke"xkqngpeg"pq"eqpvcev"qtfgt"kuuwgf"d{"vjg"Upqjqokuj"Eqwpv{"Fkuvtkev"Eqwtv" 3: cpf"etkokpcn"uvcnmkpi"qh"jku"gz/ykhg0"*Dquvqem"Fgen0" "9:="Mjcp"Fgen0" "40+"Cp"Kookitcvkqp"Lwfig" 3; itcpvgf" jko" ecpegnncvkqp" qh" tgoqxcn" hqt" egtvckp" tgukfgpvu" wpfgt" :" W0U0E0" ¸" 344;d*c+." dwv" FJU" 42 crrgcngf"vjg"fgekukqp0"Ot0"Mjcp"ku"jgnf"wpfgt":"W0U0E0"¸"3448*c+"yjkng"jku"crrgcn"ku"rgpfkpi0"Cp" 43 44 45 """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 6 "C"fgvckpgg"jgnf"wpfgt"vjku"rtqxkukqp"ku"Ðkpcfokuukdng"wpfgt"ugevkqp"33:4"qh"vjku"vkvng."tgoqxcdng" wpfgt"ugevkqp"3449*c+*3+*E+."3449*c+*4+."qt"3449*c+*6+"qh"vjku"vkvng"qt"yjq"jcu"dggp"fgvgtokpgf"d{" vjg"Cvvqtpg{"Igpgtcn"vq"dg"c"tkum"vq"vjg"eqoowpkv{"qt"wpnkmgn{"vq"eqorn{"ykvj"vjg"qtfgt"qh"tgoqxcn." oc{" dg" fgvckpgf" dg{qpf" vjg" tgoqxcn" rgtkqf" cpf." kh" tgngcugf." ujcnn" dg" uwdlgev" vq" vjg" vgtou" qh" uwrgtxkukqp"kp"rctcitcrj"*5+0Ñ"":"W0U0E0"¸"3453*c+*8+0" QTFGT"Î";" " 3 " " " Kookitcvkqp"Lwfig"fgpkgf"jko"dqpf"dcugf"qp"c"hkpfkpi"vjcv"jg"ycu"c"fcpigt"vq"vjg"eqoowpkv{"cpf" 4 c"hnkijv"tkum"dcugf"qp"jku"eqpvkpwgf"xkqncvkqp"qh"vjg"rtqvgevkxg"qtfgt0"*Id.="Dquvqem"Fgen0" "9:0+"Ot0" 5 Mjcp"ocpcigu"jku"fkcdgvgu"ykvj"qtcn"ogfkecvkqp"*OeMgp|kg"Fgen0" "46+."cpf"ku"jqwugf"kp"c"wpkv"cv" 6 590:'" ecrcekv{0" " Jg" enckou" vjcv" jg" eqwnf" ghhgevkxgn{" ocpcig" jku" fkcdgvgu" kp" uvcvg" ewuvqf{" dwv" 7 ecppqv" gcv" cpf" gzgtekug" crrtqrtkcvgn{" cv" vjg" PYFE." vjgtgd{" gzcegtdcvkpi" jku" fkcdgvgu0" *Mjcp" 8 Fgen0" "50+"Kh"tgngcugf."Ot0"Mjcp"yknn"uvc{"ykvj"jku"htkgpf"yjkng"jg"fgvgtokpgu"jku"nqpi/vgto"nkxkpi" 9 qrvkqpu0"*Id." "390+" KKK0" : CPCN[UKU" C0" Ngicn"Uvcpfctf"" ; 32 Vjg" uvcpfctf" hqt" kuuwkpi" c" VTQ" ku" vjg" ucog" cu" vjg" uvcpfctf" hqt" kuuwkpi" c" rtgnkokpct{" 33 kplwpevkqp0" See New Motor Vehicle Bd. of Cal. v. Orrin W. Fox Co.." 656" W0U0" 3567." 3569" p04" 34 *3;99+0"C"VTQ"ku"Ðcp"gzvtcqtfkpct{"tgogf{"vjcv"oc{"qpn{"dg"cyctfgf"wrqp"c"engct"ujqykpi"vjcv" 35 vjg"rnckpvkhh"ku"gpvkvngf"vq"uwej"tgnkgh0Ñ"Winter v. Nat. Res. Def. Council, Inc0."777"W0U0"9."46"*422:+0" 36 ÐVjg" rtqrgt"ngicn"uvcpfctf"hqt"rtgnkokpct{"kplwpevkxg"tgnkgh"tgswktgu"c"rctv{"vq"fgoqpuvtcvg"*3+" 37 Òvjcv"jg"ku"nkmgn{"vq"uweeggf"qp"vjg"ogtkvu."*4+"vjcv"jg"ku"nkmgn{"vq"uwhhgt"kttgrctcdng"jcto"kp"vjg" 38 cdugpeg" qh" rtgnkokpct{" tgnkgh." *5+" vjcv" vjg" dcncpeg" qh" gswkvkgu" vkru" kp" jku" hcxqt." cpf" *6+" vjcv" cp" 39 kplwpevkqp"ku"kp"vjg"rwdnke"kpvgtguv0ÓÑ"Stormans, Inc. v. Selecky."7:8"H05f"332;."3349"*;vj"Ekt0"422;+" 3: *ekvkpi"Winter."777"W0U0"cv"42+0"" 3; Cu"cp"cnvgtpcvkxg"vq"vjku"vguv."c"rtgnkokpct{"kplwpevkqp"ku"crrtqrtkcvg"kh"Ðugtkqwu"swguvkqpu" 42 iqkpi" vq" vjg" ogtkvu" ygtg" tckugf" cpf" vjg" dcncpeg" qh" vjg" jctfujkru" vkru" ujctrn{" kp" vjg" rnckpvkhhÓu" 43 hcxqt.Ñ" vjgtgd{" cnnqykpi" rtgugtxcvkqp" qh" vjg" uvcvwu" swq" yjgp" eqorngz" ngicn" swguvkqpu" tgswktg" 44 hwtvjgt"kpurgevkqp"qt"fgnkdgtcvkqp0"All. for the Wild Rockies v. Cottrell."854"H05f"3349."3356/57" 45 *;vj"Ekt0"4233+0"Jqygxgt."vjg"Ðugtkqwu"swguvkqpuÑ"crrtqcej"uwrrqtvu"vjg"eqwtvÓu"gpvt{"qh"c"VTQ" QTFGT"Î"32" " 3 " " " qpn{"kh"vjg"rnckpvkhh"cnuq"ujqyu"vjcv"vjgtg"ku"c"nkmgnkjqqf"qh"kttgrctcdng"kplwt{"cpf"vjcv"vjg"kplwpevkqp" 4 ku"kp"vjg"rwdnke"kpvgtguv0"Id. cv"33570"Vjg"oqxkpi"rctv{"dgctu"vjg"dwtfgp"qh"rgtuwcukqp"cpf"owuv" 5 ocmg"c"engct"ujqykpi"vjcv"kv"ku"gpvkvngf"vq"uwej"tgnkgh0"Winter."777"W0U0"cv"440"" 6 Hqt"vjg"tgcuqpu"ugv"hqtvj"dgnqy."vjg"eqwtv"FGPKGU"RgvkvkqpgtuÓ"oqvkqp"hqt"c"VTQ0" D0" Nkmgnkjqqf"qh"Uweeguu"qp"vjg"Ogtkvu"" 7 8 Vq"qdvckp"c"VTQ."Rgvkvkqpgtu"owuv"ocmg"c"engct"ujqykpi"vjcv"vjg{"ctg"nkmgn{"vq"uweeggf"qp" 9 vjg" ogtkvu" qt." cnvgtpcvkxgn{." jcxg" tckugf" ugtkqwu" swguvkqpu" iqkpi" vq" vjg" ogtkvu" qh" vjgkt" jcdgcu" : rgvkvkqp0" Vq" uweeggf" qp" c" jcdgcu" rgvkvkqp." Rgvkvkqpgtu" owuv" ujqy" vjcv" vjg{" ctg" Ðkp" ewuvqf{" kp" ; xkqncvkqp"qh"vjg"Eqpuvkvwvkqp"qt"ncyu"qt"vtgcvkgu"qh"vjg"Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu0Ñ"See 4:"W0U0E0"¸"44630"Jgtg." 32 Rgvkvkqpgtu"ctiwg"vjcv"vjgkt"eqpvkpwgf"fgvgpvkqp"kp"eqpfkvkqpu"vjcv"rtgugpv"cp"wptgcuqpcdng"tkum"qh" 33 ugtkqwu" knnpguu" qt" fgcvj" xkqncvg" vjgkt" Hkhvj" Cogpfogpv" uwduvcpvkxg" fwg" rtqeguu" tkijvu7" vq" *3+" 34 tgcuqpcdn{"uchg"eqpfkvkqpu"qh"eqphkpgogpv"cpf"*4+"eqpfkvkqpu"vjcv"fq"pqv"coqwpv"vq"rwpkujogpv0" 35 *VTQ"Oqv0"cv"36/3;0+"Hqt"vjg"tgcuqpu"uvcvgf"dgnqy."vjg"eqwtv"eqpenwfgu"vjcv"Rgvkvkqpgtu"jcxg"hckngf" 36 vq"ocmg"c"engct"ujqykpi"vjcv"vjg{"ctg"nkmgn{"vq"uweeggf"qp"vjg"ogtkvu"qh"vjgkt"Hkhvj"Cogpfogpv" 37 enckou."qt"vjcv"vjg{"jcxg"tckugf"ugtkqwu"swguvkqpu"iqkpi"vq"vjg"ogtkvu"qh"vjgkt"enckou0" 38 30" Tkijv"vq"Tgcuqpcdn{"Uchg"Eqpfkvkqpu" 39 Ð]Y_jgp"vjg"Uvcvg"vcmgu"c"rgtuqp"kpvq"kvu"ewuvqf{"cpf"jqnfu"jko"vjgtg"cickpuv"jku"yknn."vjg" 3: Eqpuvkvwvkqp"korqugu"wrqp"kv"c"eqttgurqpfkpi"fwv{"vq"cuuwog"uqog"tgurqpukdknkv{"hqt"jku"uchgv{" 3; cpf" igpgtcn" ygnn/dgkpi0Ñ" DeShaney v. Winnebago Cnty. Dep’t of Soc. Servs0." 6:;" W0U0" 3:;." 42 3;;/422"*3;:;+08"Vjg"iqxgtpogpv"vjwu"xkqncvgu"vjg"Fwg"Rtqeguu"Encwug"kh"kv"hcknu"vq"rtqxkfg"ekxkn" 43 44 45 """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" "Cu"hgfgtcn"ekxkn"fgvckpggu."Rgvkvkqpgtu"ctg"rtqvgevgf"d{"vjg"Hkhvj"Cogpfogpv0"See Zadvydas v. Davis."755"W0U0"89:."8;2"*4223+0" " 8 " Kp" DeShaney." vjg" Uwrtgog" Eqwtv" cpcn{|gf" vjg" rgvkvkqpgtuÓ" tkijvu" wpfgt" vjg" Hqwtvggpvj" Cogpfogpv0" " See 6:;" W0U0" cv" 3;6/;70" Hkhvj" Cogpfogpv" fwg" rtqeguu" enckou" cpf" Hqwtvggpvj" 7 QTFGT"Î"33" " 3 " " " fgvckpggu"ykvj"Ðhqqf."enqvjkpi."ujgnvgt."ogfkecn"ectg."cpf"tgcuqpcdng"uchgv{0Ñ""Id. cv"4220"Kp"vjg" 4 eqpvgzv"qh"c"Ðhcknwtg"vq"rtqvgevÑ"encko"wpfgt"vjg"Fwg"Rtqeguu"Encwug."vjg"Pkpvj"Ektewkv"cpcn{|gu" 5 iqxgtpogpv"eqpfwev"wpfgt"cp"qdlgevkxg"fgnkdgtcvg"kpfkhhgtgpeg"uvcpfctf0"See Castro v. Cty. of L.A0." 6 :55"H05f"3282."3293"*;vj"Ekt0"4238+"*gp"dcpe+"*cfqrvkpi"qdlgevkxg"fgnkdgtcvg"kpfkhhgtgpeg"uvcpfctf" 7 dcugf"qp"Kingsley v. Hendrickson."798"W0U0"5:;."357"U0"Ev0"4688"*4237+."vq"gxcnwcvg"hcknwtg"vq" 8 rtqvgev"encko"dtqwijv"d{"rtgvtkcn"fgvckpgg+0"Wpfgt"vjku"uvcpfctf."vjg"fghgpfcpvÓu"eqpfwev"Ðowuv"dg" 9 qdlgevkxgn{"wptgcuqpcdng."c"vguv"vjcv"yknn"pgeguuctkn{"vwtp"qp"vjg"hcevu"cpf"ektewouvcpegu"qh"gcej" : rctvkewnct" ecug0Ñ" Id." *kpvgtpcn" swqvcvkqpu" qokvvgf+0" Vq" fgoqpuvtcvg" qdlgevkxg" fgnkdgtcvg" ; kpfkhhgtgpeg."c"rnckpvkhh"owuv"ujqy<" 32 *k+"Vjg"fghgpfcpv"ocfg"cp"kpvgpvkqpcn"fgekukqp"ykvj"tgurgev"vq"vjg"eqpfkvkqpu" wpfgt"yjkej"vjg"rnckpvkhh"ycu"eqphkpgf="" " *kk+"Vjqug"eqpfkvkqpu"rwv"vjg"rnckpvkhh"cv"uwduvcpvkcn"tkum"qh"uwhhgtkpi"ugtkqwu"jcto="" " *kkk+"Vjg"fghgpfcpv"fkf"pqv"vcmg"tgcuqpcdng"cxckncdng"ogcuwtgu"vq"cdcvg"vjcv"tkum." gxgp"vjqwij"c"tgcuqpcdng"qhhkegt"kp"vjg"ektewouvcpegu"yqwnf"jcxg"crrtgekcvgf"vjg" jkij"fgitgg"qh"tkum"kpxqnxgfÏocmkpi"vjg"eqpugswgpegu"qh"vjg"fghgpfcpvÓu" eqpfwev"qdxkqwu="cpf"" " *kx+"D{"pqv"vcmkpi"uwej"ogcuwtgu."vjg"fghgpfcpv"ecwugf"vjg"rnckpvkhhÓu"kplwtkgu0" " 33 34 35 36 37 38 Id. 39 " 3: eqpvtcev" EQXKF/3;." TgurqpfgpvuÓ" hcknwtg" vq" vcmg" tgcuqpcdng" ogcuwtgu" vq" cdcvg" vjgkt" tkum" qh" 3; eqpvtcevkpi"vjg"xktwu"cv"vjg"PYFE"uwdlgevu"vjgo"vq"c"uwduvcpvkcn"tkum"qh"ugtkqwu"jcto0"*See VTQ" 42 Oqv0"cv"38/390+"Vjgug"cnngigf"cevkqpu"kpenwfg"eqpuvcpv"vtcpuhgt"qh"fgvckpggu"htqo"hceknkvkgu"ykvj" 43 mpqyp"EQXKF/3;"qwvdtgcmu."hcknwtg"vq"cfgswcvgn{"uetggp"uvchh"cpf"fgvckpggu"hqt"cu{orvqocvke" Rgvkvkqpgtu"ctiwg"vjcv"dgecwug"vjg{"ctg"cv"jkij"tkum"htqo"ugtkqwu"knnpguu"qt"fgcvj"kh"vjg{" 44 45 """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" Cogpfogpv"fwg"rtqeguu"enckou"ctg"cpcn{|gf"kp"vjg"ucog"yc{0"See Paul v. Davis."646"W0U0"8;5." 924"p05"*3;98+0" QTFGT"Î"34" " 3 " " " kphgevkqp."cpf"eqphkpgogpv"qh"Rgvkvkqpgtu"kp"eqpfkvkqpu"yjgtg"vjg{"ecppqv"rtcevkeg"cfgswcvg"uqekcn" 4 fkuvcpekpi"cpf"rtqrgt"j{ikgpg0"*Id."cv"38/390+"Cv"qtcn"ctiwogpv."Rgvkvkqpgtu"enctkhkgf"vjgkt"rqukvkqp" 5 vjcv" gxgp" kh" Tgurqpfgpvu" eqwnf" korngogpv" dgvvgt" j{ikgpg" ogcuwtgu." uqekcn" fkuvcpekpi" tgockpu" 6 korquukdng" cv" vjg" PYFE" d{" pcvwtg" qh" vjg" hceknkv{Óu" uvtwevwtcn" cpf" qrgtcvkqpcn" nkokvcvkqpu0" 7 Rgvkvkqpgtu"cnuq"ekvg"vq"rtgxkqwu"fgekukqpu"d{"vjku"eqwtv"vjcv"gxcnwcvgf"eqpfkvkqpu"cv"vjg"PYFE"cpf" 8 hqwpf."dcugf"qp"vjg"rctvkewnct"ektewouvcpegu"qh"vjg"rgvkvkqpgt."vjcv"tgnkgh"ycu"ycttcpvgf0"See, e.g.." 9 Pimentel-Estrada v. Barr."Pq0"E42/6;7"TUO/DCV."4242"YN"42;4652."cv",33/,38"*Y0F0"Ycuj0" : Crt0"4:."4242+"*kfgpvkh{kpi"Ðinctkpi"fghkekgpekguÑ"kp"vjg"IqxgtpogpvÓu"ghhqtvu"vq"rtqvgev"jkij/tkum" ; fgvckpggu"htqo"ugtkqwu"jcto+0"Rgvkvkqpgtu"encko"vjcv"vjg"ucog"Ðinctkpi"fghkekgpekguÑ"kfgpvkhkgf"kp" 32 Pimentel-Estrada"tgockp"wpcfftguugf"d{"Tgurqpfgpvu0"*VTQ"Oqv0"cv"380+" 33 " 34 gpvgtkpi"cpf"urtgcfkpi"cv"vjg"PYFE."kpenwfkpi"uetggpkpi"qh"pgyn{/cttkxgf"fgvckpggu."tgfwekpi" 35 vjg"rqrwncvkqp"vq"cnnqy"hqt"oqtg"ghhgevkxg"uqekcn"fkuvcpekpi."cpf"kortqxkpi"j{ikgpg"ogcuwtgu0"*See 36 Tgur0" cv"37/3;0+"Dcugf"qp"vjgug" gzvgpukxg" ogcuwtgu." Tgurqpfgpvu"eqpvgpf." Rgvkvkqpgtu" jcxg" pq" 37 dcuku"hqt"enckokpi"vjgkt"fgvgpvkqp"xkqncvgu"vjgkt"Hkhvj"Cogpfogpv"tkijv"vq"tgcuqpcdng"uchgv{0"*Id."cv" 38 3;0+" Pgxgtvjgnguu." Rgvkvkqpgtu" kpukuv" vjcv" KEG" cpf" IGQÓu" ogcuwtgu" ctg" Ðyqghwnn{" kpuwhhkekgpvÑ" 39 dgecwug"*3+"EQXKF/3;"ku"cntgcf{"rtgugpv"cv"vjg"hceknkv{="*4+"nctig"pwodgtu"qh"ogfkecnn{"xwnpgtcdng" 3: fgvckpggu"tgockp"cv"vjg"hceknkv{."iwctcpvggkpi"vjg"hceknkv{"yknn"dg"qxgttwp"yjgp"cp"qwvdtgcm"qeewtu=" 3; *5+"Tgurqpfgpvu"jcxg"hckngf"vq"korngogpv"eqortgjgpukxg"vguvkpi="*6+"fgvckpggu"ecppqv"rtcevkeg" 42 uqekcn"fkuvcpekpi="cpf"*7+"j{ikgpg"cpf"ucpkvcvkqp"ogcuwtgu"ctg"kpcfgswcvg0"*VTQ"Tgrn{"*Fmv0"%8:+" 43 cv"6/330+"Hqt"vjgug"tgcuqpu."Rgvkvkqpgtu"ctiwg"vjcv"Tgurqpfgpvu"jcxg"hckngf"vq"vcmg"tgcuqpcdng"uvgru" 44 11" Kp"tgurqpug."Tgurqpfgpvu"jcxg"qwvnkpgf"vjgkt"uwduvcpvkcn"ghhqtvu"vq"rtgxgpv"EQXKF/3;"htqo" 45 QTFGT"Î"35" " " 3 " " " "vq"rtqvgev"vjgo"htqo"vjg"uwduvcpvkcn"tkum"qh"jcto"htqo"EQXKF/3;."cpf"vjgtghqtg"xkqncvg"vjgkt"Hkhvj" 4 Cogpfogpv"tkijvu0"*Id."cv"33/340+" 5 " 6 cv" 3293." vjg" eqwtv" hkpfu" Rgvkvkqpgtu" wpnkmgn{" vq" uweeggf" qp" vjgkt" encko" vjcv" Tgurqpfgpvu" jcxg" 7 xkqncvgf"vjgkt"Hkhvj"Cogpfogpv"tkijv"vq"tgcuqpcdng"uchgv{"cv"vjg"PYFE0"Dqvj"rctvkguÓ"ctiwogpvu" 8 jkpig" qp" eqpvtcfkevqt{"cuuworvkqpu"cu"vq"yjgvjgt"TgurqpfgpvuÓ"ghhqtvu"tgcuqpcdn{"rtgxgpv"cpf" 9 eqpvckp"vjg"urtgcf"qh"eqtqpcxktwu"vjtqwij"vjg"PYFE0"Cnvjqwij"Rgvkvkqpgtu"vcmg"vjg"rqukvkqp"vjcv" : vjg"xktwuÓ"gpvt{"kpvq"vjg"PYFE"ku"pqv"qpn{"nkmgn{"dwv"kpgxkvcdng."cpf."rgtjcru."jcu"cntgcf{"qeewttgf." ; Tgurqpfgpvu"eqwpvgt"vjcv"tkiqtqwu"uetggpkpi."vguvkpi."cpf"swctcpvkpg"ogcuwtgu"rwtuwcpv"vq"EFE" 32 rtqvqeqnu"tgcuqpcdn{"cdcvg"vjg"tkum0"*Compare"VTQ"Oqv0"cv"4"with Tgur0"cv"3:0+"Kp"uwrrqtv"qh"vjgkt" 33 tgurgevkxg"rqukvkqpu."rctvkgu"jcxg"rtqxkfgf"c"ugtkgu"qh"fgenctcvkqpu"yjgtgkp"Tgurqpfgpvu"fguetkdg" 34 xctkqwu" ogcuwtgu" korngogpvgf" hqt" fgvckpgg" vguvkpi." cu{orvqocvke" uetggpkpi." uqekcn" fkuvcpekpi." 35 j{ikgpg."cpf"okpkok|kpi"gzrquwtg"vq"xkukvqtu"cpf"uvchh."cpf"Rgvkvkqpgtu"kfgpvkh{"yjgtg"gcej"qh"vjgug" 36 ogcuwtgu"hcnnu"ujqtv0"*See supra."Ugevkqp"KK0D0+" Jcxkpi"eqpukfgtgf"vjg"rctvkewnct"hcevu"cpf"ektewouvcpegu"qh"vjku"ecug."see Castro.":55"H05f" 37 Pqy"vjcv"Tgurqpfgpvu"jcxg"vguvgf"oquv"qh"vjg"fgvckpgg"rqrwncvkqp"cv"vjg"PYFE."vjg"kuuwg" 38 qh"yjgvjgt"TgurqpfgpvuÓ"ogcuwtgu"tgcuqpcdn{"rtgxgpv"cpf"eqpvckp"vjg"xktwuÓ"urtgcf"vjtqwij"vjg" 39 fgvgpvkqp" egpvgt" ku" hct" nguu" urgewncvkxg0" Vjg" Lwpg" :." 4242." tgrqtv" rtqxkfgu" hcevwcn" uwrrqtv" hqt" 3: TgurqpfgpvuÓ"enckou"vjcv"vjgkt"ghhqtvu"ctg"uwhhkekgpv"vq"rtqvgev"fgvckpggu"htqo"eqpvtcevkpi"vjg"xktwu0" 3; *See 4f"Ocncmjqxc"Fgen0" "60+"Ykvj"qpn{"qpg"fgvckpgg"qwv"qh"672"vguvkpi"rqukvkxg."cpf"vjg"vguvgf" 42 rqrwncvkqp"eqortkukpi":2'"qh"vjg"vqvcn"fgvckpgg"rqrwncvkqp."vjg"eqwtv"ecppqv"tgcuqpcdn{"eqpenwfg" 43 vjcv"EQXKF/3;"ku"urtgcfkpi"wpfgvgevgf"vjtqwij"vjg"PYFE0"Hwtvjgtoqtg."eqpukfgtkpi"vjgug"vguv" 44 tguwnvu"kp"nkijv"qh"vjg"ogcuwtgu"vjcv"Tgurqpfgpvu"jcxg"korngogpvgf"vq" rtgxgpv"cpf" eqpvckp"vjg" 45 xktwuÓ"urtgcf."vjg"eqwtv"ecppqv"tgcuqpcdn{"hkpf"vjcv"cp"qwvdtgcm"qh"EQXKF/3;"cv"vjg"PYFE"ku" QTFGT"Î"36" " 3 " " " nkmgn{" vq" qeewt0" *Id." " 7" *gzrnckpkpi" korngogpvcvkqp" qh" xqnwpvct{" vguvkpi" qh" cnn" pgyn{/cttkxgf" 4 fgvckpggu"cv"vjg"PYFE+0+" 5 Ikxgp"vjku"gxkfgpeg."vjg"eqwtv"ecppqv"eqpenwfg"vjcv"ewttgpv"eqpfkvkqpu"cv"vjg"PYFE"rnceg" 6 Rgvkvkqpgtu"cv"tkum"qh"uwduvcpvkcn"jcto"qt"vjcv"TgurqpfgpvuÓ"ghhqtvu"hckn"vq"tgcuqpcdn{"cdcvg"vjg"tkum" 7 qh" kphgevkqp" hqt" xwnpgtcdng" fgvckpggu0" Ceeqtfkpin{." Rgvkvkqpgtu" jcxg" hckngf" vq" fgoqpuvtcvg" c" 8 nkmgnkjqqf"qh"uweeguu"qp"vjg"ogtkvu"qh"vjgkt"Hkhvj"Cogpfogpv"Ðtgcuqpcdng"uchgv{Ñ"encko"qt"vjcv" 9 vjg{"jcxg"tckugf"ugtkqwu"swguvkqpu"iqkpi"vq"vjg"ogtkvu"qh"vjgkt"encko0" : 40" Eqpfkvkqpu"Coqwpvkpi"vq"Rwpkujogpv" ; Vjg"eqwtv"yknn"pqy"cfftguu"RgvkvkqpgtuÓ"ctiwogpv"vjcv"vjgkt"eqpvkpwgf"fgvgpvkqp"xkqncvgu" 32 fwg" rtqeguu" dgecwug" kv" coqwpvu" vq" rwpkujogpv0" *See VTQ" Oqv0" cv" 3:0+" Vq" gxcnwcvg" vjg" 33 eqpuvkvwvkqpcnkv{"qh"c"rtgvtkcn"fgvgpvkqp"eqpfkvkqp"wpfgt"vjg"Hkhvj"Cogpfogpv."c"fkuvtkev"eqwtv"owuv" 34 fgvgtokpg"yjgvjgt"vjqug"eqpfkvkqpu"Ðcoqwpv"vq"rwpkujogpv"qh"vjg"fgvckpgg0Ñ"Bell"v. Wolfish."663" 35 W0U0"742."757"*3;9;+="see also Kingsley."357"U0"Ev0"cv"4695/96"*4237+0"Rwpkujogpv"oc{"dg"ujqyp" 36 vjtqwij"cp"gzrtguu"kpvgpv"vq"rwpkuj"qt"c"tguvtkevkqp"qt"eqpfkvkqp"vjcv"Ðku"pqv"tgcuqpcdn{"tgncvgf"vq"c" 37 ngikvkocvg"iqxgtpogpvcn"qdlgevkxg0Ñ"Bell."663"W0U0"cv"75;="see also Kingsley."357"U0"Ev0"cv"4695/96" 38 *enctkh{kpi" vjcv" Ðc" rtgvtkcn" fgvckpgg" ecp" rtgxckn" d{" rtqxkfkpi" qpn{" qdlgevkxg" gxkfgpeg" vjcv" vjg" 39 ejcnngpigf"iqxgtpogpvcn"cevkqp"ku"pqv"tcvkqpcnn{"tgncvgf"vq"c"ngikvkocvg"iqxgtpogpvcn"qdlgevkxg"qt" 3: vjcv"kv"ku"gzeguukxg"kp"tgncvkqp"vq"vjcv"rwtrqugÑ+0""Rgvkvkqpgtu"tckug"qpn{"vjg"ugeqpf"vguv."ctiwkpi"vjcv" 3; vjg"tkum"vjg{" hceg" qh" ugtkqwu" knnpguu" qt" fgcvj" htqo" EQXKF/3;" gzeggfu"qt"ku"kpfgrgpfgpv"qh"vjg" 42 kpjgtgpv"fkueqohqtvu"qh"eqphkpgogpv"cpf"ku"pqv"tgcuqpcdn{"tgncvgf"vq"qt"ku"gzeguukxg"kp"tgncvkqp"vq" 43 c"ngikvkocvg"iqxgtpogpvcn"kpvgtguv0""*VTQ"Oqv0"cv"3:0"*ekvkpi"Unknown Parties v. Johnson."Pq0" 44 EX"37/472/VWE/FED."4238"YN":3::785."cv",7"*F0"Ctk|0"Pqx0"3:."4238+0+" 45 11" QTFGT"Î"37" " 3 " " " Jgtg."Rgvkvkqpgtu"jcxg"hckngf"vq"ocmg"c"engct"ujqykpi"vjcv"vjgkt"eqpvkpwgf"fgvgpvkqp"ku"pqv" 4 tgcuqpcdn{" tgncvgf" qt" gzeguukxg" vq" c" ngikvkocvg" iqxgtpogpv" kpvgtguv0" Vjg" Uwrtgog" Eqwtv" jcu" 5 tgeqipk|gf"c"ngikvkocvg"iqxgtpogpv"kpvgtguv"kp"gpuwtkpi"vjcv"pqp/ekvk|gpu"crrgct"hqt"vjgkt"tgoqxcn" 6 qt"fgrqtvcvkqp"rtqeggfkpiu"cpf"rtqvgevkpi"vjg"eqoowpkv{"htqo"jcto0"See Jennings v. Rodriguez." 7 ///"W0U0"///."35:"U0"Ev0":52.":58"*423:+="Demore v. Kim."75:"W0U0"732."742/44"*4225+="Zadvydas 8 v. Davis." 755" W0U0" cv" 8;2/;30" Cnvjqwij" Rgvkvkqpgtu" ctiwg" vjcv" vjg" kookpgpv" fcpigt" rqugf" d{" 9 EQXKF/3;" qwvygkiju" cp{" iqxgtpogpv" kpvgtguv" kp" ghhgevwcvkpi" tgoqxcn" cpf" rtqvgevkpi" vjg" : eqoowpkv{"*VTQ"Oqv0"cv"3:0+."vjg"eqwtv"ecppqv"eqpenwfg"vjcv"vjg"tkum"qh"EQXKF/3;"cv"vjg"PYFE" ; ku"Ðkookpgpv0Ñ"Kpfggf."TgurqpfgpvuÓ"uwduvcpvkcn"uvgru"vq"cdcvg"vjg"tkum"qh"EQXKF/3;"cpf"vjg"Lwpg" 32 :." 4242." tgrqtv" qp" vjg" tguwnvu" htqo" eqortgjgpukxg" vguvkpi" kpfkecvg" vjcv" TgurqpfgpvuÓ" ogcuwtgu" 33 jcxg"vjwu"hct"dggp"ghhgevkxg"cv"rtgxgpvkpi"c"EQXKF/3;"qwvdtgcm"cpf"eqpvckpkpi"vjg"xktwuÓ"urtgcf0" 34 Dcugf" qp" vjku" tgeqtf." vjg" eqwtv" ecppqv" eqpenwfg" vjcv" Rgvkvkqpgtu" hceg" kookpgpv" fcpigt" vjcv" 35 qwvygkiju" vjg" iqxgtpogpvÓu" kpvgtguvu" jgtg0" Ceeqtfkpin{." vjg" eqwtv" hkpfu" Rgvkvkqpgtu" wpnkmgn{" vq" 36 uweeggf"qp"vjgkt"Hkhvj"Cogpfogpv"fwg"rtqeguu"encko"vjcv"vjgkt"eqpvkpwgf"fgvgpvkqp"coqwpvu"vq" 37 rwpkujogpv0"" E0" Nkmgnkjqqf"qh"Kttgrctcdng"Jcto" 38 39 Vjg" eqwtv" cnuq" eqpenwfgu" vjcv" Rgvkvkqpgtu" jcxg" hckngf" vq" oggv" vjgkt" dwtfgp" vq" ujqy" vjcv" 3: Ðkttgrctcdng"jcto"ku"nkmgn{"kp"vjg"cdugpeg"qh"cp"kplwpevkqp0Ñ""Winter."777"W0U0"cv"440"Cu"fguetkdgf" 3; cdqxg." vjg" Lwpg" :." 4242." tguwnvu" htqo" vjg" EQXKF/3;" Eqnngevkqp" cpf" Vguvkpi" Qrgtcvkqpcn" Rncp" 42 kpfkecvg"vjcv"TgurqpfgpvuÓ"ogcuwtgu"jcxg."vjwu"hct."rtgxgpvgf"cp"qwvdtgcm"qh"EQXKF/3;"kp"vjg" 43 PYFEÓu" igpgtcn" rqrwncvkqp0" *See 4f" Ocncmjqxc" Fgen0" " 60+" Hwtvjgtoqtg." vq" vjg" gzvgpv" vjcv" 44 Rgvkvkqpgtu"encko"vjgtg"ku"c"hwvwtg"tkum"qh"EQXKF/3;"gpvgtkpi"vjg"PYFE"vjtqwij"cp"cu{orvqocvke" 45 qt" rtg/u{orvqocvke" pgy" cttkxcn." Tgurqpfgpvu" jcxg" tgcuqpcdn{" cfftguugf" vjku" eqpegtp" d{" QTFGT"Î"38" " 3 korngogpvkpi"xqnwpvct{"vguvkpi"qh"cnn"pgyn{/cttkxgf"fgvckpggu0"*Id." "70+""Fgvckpggu"yjq"tghwug" 4 vguvu"yknn" dg" jqwugf" ugrctcvgn{" kp"vjg" Pgy" Kpvcmg" Oqpkvqtkpi" Wpkvu" hqt"vjg" 36/fc{"qdugtxcvkqp" 5 rgtkqf"dghqtg"vjg{"ctg"kpvgitcvgf"kpvq"vjg"igpgtcn"rqrwncvkqp0"*Id.+"Eqpugswgpvn{."vjg"eqwtv"ecppqv" 6 eqpenwfg"htqo"vjg"ewttgpv"tgeqtf"vjcv"EQXKF/3;"ku"ewttgpvn{"urtgcfkpi"wpfgvgevgf"vjtqwij"vjg" 7 igpgtcn"fgvckpgg"rqrwncvkqp."pqt"vjcv"vjg"xktwuÓ"urtgcf"vq"fgvckpggu."kpenwfkpi"Rgvkvkqpgtu."ku"nkmgn{" 8 kp"nkijv"qh"TgurqpfgpvuÓ"ogcuwtgu0"Cu"vjku"eqwtv"rtgxkqwun{"cempqyngfigf"kp"Dawson v. Asher." 9 Ð]p_q"qpg"ecp"gpvktgn{"iwctcpvgg"uchgv{"kp"vjg"okfuv"qh"c"inqdcn"rcpfgoke0Ñ"Pq0"E42/262;LNT/ : OCV."4242"YN"3926546."cv",34"*Y0F0"Ycuj0"Crt0":."4242+0"[gv"vjg"crrnkecdng"uvcpfctf"qp"c" ; oqvkqp"hqt"c"VTQ"ku"nkmgnkjqqf"qh"kttgrctcdng"jctoÏpqv"iwctcpvggf"uchgv{Ïcpf"vjg"tgeqtf"dghqtg" 32 vjg"eqwtv"fqgu"pqv"oggv"vjcv"uvcpfctf09" 33 Ceeqtfkpin{."vjg"eqwtv"FGPKGU"RgvkvkqpgtuÓ"oqvkqp"hqt"c"VTQ0"" KX0 34 35 36 Hqt" vjg" hqtgiqkpi" tgcuqpu." vjg" eqwtv" FGPKGU" RgvkvkqpgtuÓ" oqvkqp" hqt" c" vgorqtct{"tguvtckpkpi"qtfgt"*Fmv0"%44+0" 37 Dated this 12th day of June, 2020 A 38 39 3: 3; 42 43 EQPENWUKQP Tgeqoogpfgf"hqt"Gpvt{" vjku"34vj"fc{"qh"Lwpg."42420" aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa" LCOGU"N0"TQDCTV" United States District Judge A OKEJGNNG"N0"RGVGTUQP" Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu"Ocikuvtcvg"Lwfig" 44 45 9 "Jcxkpi"eqpenwfgf"vjcv"Rgvkvkqpgtu"hckn"vq"oggv"vjg"hktuv"vyq"rtqpiu"qh"vjg"VTQ"uvcpfctf."vjg"eqwtv" hkpfu"kv"wppgeguuct{"vq"cfftguu"vjg"vjktf"cpf"hqwtvj"rtqpiu"cv"vjku"vkog0" QTFGT"Î"39"
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
