Gibson v. Western Virginia Regional Jail Authority, No. 7:2017cv00134 - Document 9 (W.D. Va. 2017)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 5/8/2017. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
cl ' oF l u. olmcoun# - s, FcE s s ERx . .=. ,oKkv :,k ,A , . . I THE UNI STATESDI TRI COURT N TED S CT FOR THE W ESTERN DI STRI OF W RGI A CT M ROANOKE DI S ON W I iuo M) 22 2 1 # 27 u= àJ .c! 'D s: ( - JESSE W I AM GI LLI BSON, Pli tf, an if v . W ES TERN W RGI A REGI NI ONAI , J L AUTHORI AI TY, ' De e f ndant . ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) CASE NO.7: 17CV00134 M EM ORANDUM OPI ON NI By:Ho Gln E. nr d n. e Co a ChifUniedSt e Dit c Judge e t ats srit J s W ila Gi on,aVig ni i t pr e ng pr K ,fl tls c vi rght a ton es e lim bs r i a nma e oce di o ied li i l i s c i . u d r 4 U.. j1 3 a ans te W etr Vigna Re in l J i Auho iy (te j i n e 2 SC. 98 g i t h sen r i i go a al t rt çh al t a to if'. Gi o alg st a ( )whe h ake f rme ia te t n o h sHe ttsC,a uh rt ) bs n l e h t 1 e n e s d o dc l r ame t f i paii nu s p a t in ra t ej i t l hm ta hslb r s t ween r l b tr f s d t s o hi re r ci o e t h al od i h t i a eul r o ma, u eu e o h w m t s t o er s lso t ar n ef rhi t s e t l fo o tiet ej i' a d ()o fcasha eno h s e ut r o ra g o m o e k t p r m u sd h al; n 2 fiil v t he ' al we hm t u iie te g iv n e p o e p e ( mp .2,ECF No.1) Asr l f h s e s lo d i o tlz h re a c r c d r . Co l . ei , e e k e mone a y da a s Upon r vi w of t c t r m ge . e e he ompl i ,t co tc ude t t Gi on has not ant he ur oncl s ha bs sae a yva ej1 8 cam a d te eo e wil imist sc s wi u p eu ie ttd n ibl 9 3 li n ,h r f r , l ds s hi a e t t rj d c . ho Un e 2 U. C. 1 1 ( ( )1,hec u t s ds s a y j1 8 a to S t r s c d r 8 S. j 9 5A)b ( ) t o r mu t imis n 9 3 cin G h epe t wi t p io c ndto . .ft ec u t sstsidt a tea to i fi oo s maiiu ,gr f i t o rs n o i ns . i h o r i aife h t h cin s rv lu , l o s o ) al o i c s sae a c am upon whi h r le ca be g a t d. A c tt li c e if n r ne ' ' ompl i mus be dim is d i i doesnot ant t s se f t al geGe le tnough f c st sa eac am t r i t ti plusbl on isf e. Gi ra a v. ohns n, a t o t t l i o elef ha s a i e t ac ' a r t no J ' o Gibson v. Western Virginia Regional Jail Authority Doc. 9 521 F. 298 302 ( h Ci.2008)( i BelAt.Cor v.Twombl 550 U. 544,570 3d , 4t r quotng l l p. v, S. ( 0 7) Th r fr ,a p an ifmus G le e f css fkin t sae alt ee n s o gh l 2 0 ). eeo e litf t t lg a t u f e t o tt l he lme t f te a cam. Ba sv. I Du o td Ne t s& Co.3 4F.d7 , 6 (t Ci. 0 ) li ' s E.. p n e moz ' r , 2 3 61 7 5 4h r 20 3 . Dockets.Justia.com Se ton 1 3 pe misa a i d pa t t fl a cvi a ton agans ape s n f aci ns ci 98 r t n ggreve ry o ie i l c i i t r o or to t ke unde c oro sae lw t tvi ae hi c tt i lrg s Se Coo rv.She ha 735 a n r ol f t t a ha ol td s onsiutona i ht . e pe e n, F.d 1 3 1 8(t Ci. 01 ) Top o ta ag v r me tle t y s c a alc l al uhoiy 3 5 , 5 4 h r 2 3 . rve h t o en n a n i , u h s o a j i a t rt, t i la l t e j1 8 f rc n t uin l oain c mmitdb ise o e s t panifmu t s ibe md r 9 3 o o si to a vilto s o te y t mply e ,he litf s t s t tt e tt spolc wa ç hem o ng f c oft c tt i lvi a i ' Pol Coun v how ha he n iy' iy s s t vi or e he onsiutona olton. ' k t v Do s n, 4 U. 31 3 6 ( 9 ) Gwc lg v r n b de . . a b s e dr cl u e . d o 45 S. 2, 2 1 81. do a o enig o is . c n e u d ie ty nd r l 51 8 frmo eay d caao y o ijmcie rle wh r ... h a to ta i alg d t b 9 3 o n tr , e lr tr , r nt tv eif ee t e ci n h t s l e o e e unco tt i li e e s o e c e a polc sa e nt or na ,r gulton,or de ii nsiutona mplm nt r xe ut s iy t t me , di nce e é i c son ofi i l a pt a pr fcaly do ed nd omul a e by t tbod sof e s' M one lv.Ne Yor Civ De tof g td ha y' fc r . ' l w k t p' S c S r . 4 6 U..6 ,6 0 ( 9 8 . Gis n sae n fcs l kng t alg d d n a o o . e v, 3 S 58 9 1 7 ) b o tts o a t i i he le e e il f n m e c c r whe e he i pr s nty co i d t a s cfcpolc orde i i G fc a l a pt ' dial a e r s e e l nfne o pe ii iy c son s ii ly do ed' of b t g v r i bo y o t ej i a to i Theeo e he fist sae a a to a l cam y he o enng d f h al uh rt y. rf r , al o tt n cin b e li agans t s e iy,t onl de e nt t t he ha pr pery i ntfed i t he di of ii i t hi ntt he y f nda ha s o l de ii n he a ng ls c mpan .' c r i gy t c u tmu tsl rl ds s t i a to wih u p eu iet e o lit Ac o dn l, he o r s t mmaiy imis h s cin t o t rj dc md r j1 5 b ( ) 91 A( )1. I a dto t t ej i a t o iy Gi o lsss v r ln me i t eb d o h sc mplit n d i n o h al u h rt , bs n it e e a a s n h o y f i o an i wh aen tce ry ie tfe a d fn a t:M ao A. e t Ca ti C.Kelr Ama aDo s o r o la l d n iid s e e d n s j r Trn , pan l , nd s e (he d o me ia',Amy Br me Ro is n (h iin a ssa t,Lia Fegu o ( t s ) a d E a f dc l) ç ' e t bn o p ysca sitn) s r s n nl e, n r Se gea t J. Ke y. Be a e Gi on doe notha a ssa e fo a a t e i flng tls r n nne 1 c us bs s ve s it nc r m n tom y n ii li ac i n, t c t c d consnz hi s i s on as a t m ptng t s a e c ai s aga ns t s to he our oul t e s ubm s i te i o t t l m i t he e i vi s Hi al ai ,howe r donotsaea acina ej1 3 cam ag ns a ndi dual. s leg tons ve , tt ny to bl 98 li ai t nyone . 1Gi onsae t tKelra Ke ne t dhm t tKf( qp s et fl a1 3E qwil o bs tts ha le nd n y ol i ha i he uru o ie 98 he l blw E s f to fa te wil talw ( m t gotr ght gre nc p oc du e' ( mp . ) hil oo f nd h y lno lo hi o h ou he iva e r e r . Co l 2. ' 2 Onl E d ei rt id fee c t a imae ss ro me ia n e sc n t ue c e a d y ç l l ae n ifrn e o n n t' eius dc l e d o si ts nll n g be t u u u l u l h n u e t eEihhAme d n 'J c s nv. c te 7 F.d 1 0 1 8(t n s a p ri me t nd r h g t s n me t' a k o Lih sv, 75 3 7 , 7 4 h Ci.2 4 (iig Esel v.Ga l,4 9 U. 9 , 1 5 ( 9 6 Obe tvey,t i maes r 01 ) ctn tl e mb e 2 S. 7 0 1 7 :. jci l he n t ' m e c c ton m us be Cs rous'i t s ns t ti l be dignos d by a physc a a dial ondii t te i ' n he e e ha t t has en a e i in s m a tng te t nt or ...i s obvi us t t e n a 1 pe s n woul e sl r c z t nda i r a me s o o ha ve ay r o d a iy e ogni e he nec s iy f adoc o ' a tnto ' d. To pr de i r t i fe e e,Gi o mus s e st or t r s te i n.'I ove lbe a e ndif r nc bs n t how t t ha , s be t ey e c d fnd n p io o fca ha G cu l...k o e g o b t t e i maes u j ci l, a h e e a t rs n fiil d G ta v a n wld e f oh h n t ' s ro s me ia c n i o a d t e e c si e rs po e b t o f a' gwl a to o eiu d c l o dt n n h x e sv ik s d y he fkils o ' ci n r i l ia t n. I .a 1 8 (iig Fa rv.Br r n,51 U. 8 5 8 7 ( 9 4 ) Th sc mp n n n ci ' d t 7 ctn nne o ' ema 1 S. 2 , 3 1 9 ). i o o e t rq ie p o fo itn b y n mee n gi e c ,er r i j d me t i d re to e sg t,o e ur s r o f n e t e o d r e lg n e ro s n u g n , na ve tn v rih s r dia ee e s a s gr m nt bout t prs r s te t nt pln. 1 A prs n ofi il i C lbe ae y he ione ' r a me a d. io fca s i i r t l de id fee t i h ç n wso a d dse adsErrs n sl e s n b y t )a e c sie rs t n ifrn' f e G o f n irg r o epo d mra o a l o n x e sv ik o ' k i ae he lh ors f t ' Fa me ,511U. a 837. nm t at a e y. r r ' S. t Gis n fis t sae f cs s o n t a a y n a t j i a td wi d lb rt b o al o tt a t h wig h t n o e t he al ce t ei eae h i fe e t as rousm e c lne d. W hieHe ttsC is l i as ro d s s ,Gi on does ndif r nce o e i di a e l pa ii t ef s e i us iea e bs notale t ta docor i t pas orr e l ha di gnos d hi c ntsa oft sdiea e lge ha ny t , n he t ec nty, s a e s uae t ge hi s s asm a tng te t nt a t stm e. l ed,he does no de c i a s nda i r a me t hi i nde t s rbe ny ympt s fom whi h om r c a nyone c d ha known t t te t e wa ne s a y. Thus Gi on f l t alege f c s oul ve ha r am nt s ce s r , bs ais o l at saiga y a to a l Eih hAme d n cam a ans a yo tej i' me ia saf ttn n ci n be g t n me t li g i t n f h als d c l tf. S p r io y p io p ro n laee tte t r l o t eme ia j dg n a d e p rie u e vs r rs n es n e r n ild o ey n h dc l u me t n x e t s of t med c pr es i l c r d wih a i ae' team e t a t whehe t m e c he i al of sona s ha ge t n nm t s r t n , s o t r he dial e l ton a te t e pr ded we e a opra et m e tt i t sc r ntm e c lne . vaua i nd r am nt ovi r ppr it o e hat nma e' ur e di a eds S e S ac a v S t ,71 F.d 1 2,1 7 (t Ci.1 9 ) l i n tt efmcin o t s p io e h l . mih k 3 6 6 4 h r 9 5 . t s o h l to f he e rs n a miitao s o t e c tt t sc n g e s t g o fi te t n d cso o t j i' d n sr tr, r h ou o e o d u s he o d at rame t e iins f he als h m e ca s a f l The adm i s r t s t m s l E ar ot be la e f t m e c l saf s di l t f . d. ni t a or he e ves t m c i bl or he di a t f da n si d cso s' n , n e d l a no s b tt t ter u g n f rame ia pr fsi n ls ig o tc e iin 'a d i d e ,G n t u siue h ij d me t o c dc l o e so a' p e c i im' M eo v.Ba h ir 3 2 F.d 8 5 8 (t Ci.20 2 (iain o te ) r srpto ' l y c mee, 0 3 4 , 49 8h r 0 ) ctto s mitd . Theeor t co t i stsid t t Gi on fis t sae a j1 3 cli ag ns a rf e, he ur s aife ha bs al o tt ny 98 am ai t ny s p r io yo fca rg r ighsme ia c r a t ej i. u e vs r fiil e a dn i d c l a e t h al Fial,Gi o h s n va l cam u d r j 1 8 a ans j i o fc r f rr f sng t n ly bs n a o ib e li n e 9 3 g i t al f es o e u i o p o i ehm a c s t t eg iv n e p o e t e . S eAda v Rie 40F.d 7 7 ( t Ci. r v d i c e s o h re a c r c dl s e r ms . c , 3 2, 5 4h r 1 9 )( E h Co ttto c e tsn e tte n t g iv nc p o e u e o a c s t a y s c 9 4 1T1 e nsiuin rae o n i me t o re a e r c d r s r c e s o n u h & l p o e t ev lmt l etbls e b asae' us t ec u t s sl rl d s s a ys c r c dl ot miy sa ih d y tt. r ).Th , h o r mu t l mmai imis n u h y ca m i t sa ton. li n hi c i Fort r as sa e t c tco l he e ons tt d, he our ncudes t t Gi on' s ha bs s ubmi so do notsa e'ny s i ns tt a cam o c n t uin lsg iia c a to be u d rj1 8 . Th r fr ,t ec u twilds s li f o si to a infc n e cina l n e 9 3 e eo e h o r l imis t t ea to wih u p eu ie p ls a tt j1 5 b ( ) h cin t o t rj dc , t u n o 91 A( )1. r ENTER :Ths %N d yo Ma 2017. i a f y , . f ChifUnied St t sDititJ e t a e src udge 4
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
