Makdessi v. Unnamed Defendants, No. 7:2013cv00537 - Document 5 (W.D. Va. 2013)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 11/25/2013. (kab)

Download PDF
- m ŠsOFFI U. DI COUr CE S. SX AT ROANOKE, VA FI LED N0# 2 5 2 1 23 I THE UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FOR THE W ESTERN DI STRI OF W RGI A CT NI R O AN O K E DI I O N V SI ADI EDDI RAM EZ M AK DESSI B E , JULI C. A BY: DEP ï ' 'CLERK 'W ' . . . /' C ERK CASE NO.7: 36+ 00537 1 Pl nt f , ai i f M EM O M N D U M O PI IO N N UNNAM ED DEFENDANTS, AL , ;I By: Gln E. n a e Co r d ChifUnied St e Dit c Judge e t at s srit Defnda t) e nts. Adi Eddi Rnme M a b e z kdes i a Vigi a i ae pr e ng pr K ,fld t saci n asa s, r ni nm t oce di o ie hi to . i i f or r of pr eci n' i hi pe ng ci l rg s a ton, Ca e No. 7: 3CV00079, G on or de mot ot to ' n s ndi vi i ht c i s 1 s ki a c tor r dieci prs of i l t r tai hi i a c ran wa t pr t c hi ee ng our de r tng ion ûc as o esr n m n e ti y, o o e t s lgalma e i s a t pl c hi i a pr e tve c t t tot rt n Ri rNorh,onet ti e t ral, nd o a e m n ot c i usody mi he ha ve t ha s G aea fe fom a gangses' ( o . ) Thec tdie tdt cekt r moveM a sis k f nd re r ny s tr. M t 3. ' our rce he lr o e kde s' m oton fom t ol r pe ng ac i a t o n i asa ne cvi rght a ton pur ua t 42 i r he de , ndi ton nd o pe t w i l i s ci s nt o U.. j1 8 , s e i i dae ijmcie r l f Afe rv e ng M a d sis moin, SC. 9 3 e kng mme it nt tv ei . tr e iwi e k e s' to ho weve ,t c tc l r he our oncudest thef ist sa ef c ss ha a l o tt a t uppori i tng mposto oft i eroc o y ii n he nt l ut r r le he s e . The e o e,t cour wil s ma iy de hi m oton a dim is t e ie ei f e ks r f r he t l um rl ny s i nd s s he ntr a to wih u p eu ie cin t o t rj d c . Bac ound kzr Ma d sifld hi moin wh l i c re ae i t e p oe tve c so y C ' l i a k e s ie s to ie n ac rtd n h r tci u td TC' l t t )n Ke n M omii Cor cin lCe tr e t n re to a ne .Healg d ta a o lc rtee tl hi tW j e ( e l e h t n fi e h r o d m,ç h n Ke n e g Mo mtijmo e a1 r tci c so yimae . .oRie No t p io b t e No e e 1t t an v s 1 p oe t u td n ts . t v r rh rs n ewe n v mb r S ve knd)9 201 s o t ga sest tatmptd t mmde g a s i a W al Ri e a * 3, ome f he ng tr ha te e o r M kde s) t lens dg prs n wilb tee a p oe tv c td a d as s me o te d fn a t fo ( ilp e iu io l e h r t r tci e uso y n lo o f h ee d n s r m h s r vo s lws i a ewatn f r( a d s i a Ii rNo t p io . ( o .1) Th I n me o f ras a ut r i g o M k e s) t tve rh rs n' M t . e l n d fke lo i ' n a lge y t d M a s t tde e n ofk e sf o t spe ng l ws tt l c ran g ngse s le dl ol kdes i ha f nda t f r r m hi ndi a ui o d e ti a t r i t Ke n M ounti PC t tt M akde s i a s th who s d be kild,once al t s n he e an mi hat s i s nic houl le 1 he e i aesr c Ri rNorh. Theofi e sa lge y ga t g t r aco ofM a s ' lte nm t ea h ve t fc r le dl ve he angse s py kdes is e tr t p io a miitao s a kn t h vec rani mae a d dt hi t ne ls. ( o . t 1) o rs n d n srt r, s ig o a e ti n ts d e o s l my it' M tAt. . e ' M a s i a s f r t ti he c kde s lo ea s ha f ompli a ans boutt ga t r a Ri r Norh,ofk i s he ngse s t ve t t al t r wilalo t ga t r t r mai i pr e tve cusody a pl e hi i s gr ga i i he e l l w he ngse s o e n n ot c i t nd ac m n e e ton n r t lai f hi ltg to e f t. He a s t ofk i s know t ts gr ga i i dt tr 'f e ai ton or s ii a i n fors s ers t al ha e e ton s lort e' or t hi be a ehe i G a tophobi.' ( o.2. Healgest tofiil i t patha tke m, c us s t usr cl c' M t ) le ha fcas n he s ve a n ç d a tg o tlswe k e so ( s a d al wld t esx la sul a da su t a db tte y l v na e f l n n s f hi) n lo e ) h e ua sa t n sa ls n a l r a i s l o (i . ( o .2) F n l M a d s icams s me n wa n d hm t t Gh y'wo l n h mq' M t . i al ' y, k e s li o o e r e i ha ç e ' ud t i e to l ty t desr y hi t ee bo s of l l ma e i s a r nty dtrng t ta f r nt n i naly r o to s hr xe ega t ral, ppa e l li he r nse pr c s.( o .1) o es M t . Si e flng t moton,M a nc ii he i kdes iha notfe t c r t ton Nove be 5,201 he s s ii d he ou t ha m r 3, wasta f re t Ri rNorh. Hi no ii ai di noti c t t thewa i dange t r fom r ns e r d o ve t s tfc ton d ndia e ha sn r he e r ga t r ,a hef r d,ort hi l ga m ae il hadbee desr yed. ngse s s ea e hat s e l tra s n to Di c s on s us i The c t i r quie t dim is a aci n or cli fl d by a prs r ag ns a our s e r d o s s ny to am ie ione ai t gove n t e iy orofk e i t c tde e mi st a ton orcli i fi ous malci , r men al ntt t r f he our t r ne he c i a m s rvol , i ous o fist sae a cam o whih rle ma be g a t d 2 U. C.j 1 5 b () Be a s r al o tt li n c eif y r ne . 8 S. 91 A()1 . c u e itro u o y ijmcie rle i a e ta r ia y rme y te p ry s e i te prl n r n elc t r n t tv eif s n x ro dn r e d , h a t e kng h ei a y mi ij cin mu tma e ace rs o n & 1 t a h i l ey t s c e o t emeis ( )h i nun to s k la h wig t ) h t e s i l o uc e d n h rt; 2 e s ( k lk l t s fr irp rb e h r i te a s n e o p ei n r rle ;( )ta t e b ln e o i ey o ufe re a a l am n h b e c f rlmi ay eif 3 h t h aa c f 2 e ute t i hs fv r a () a ijmcin i i te p bl itrs. Re lTrt Abo t q iis i n i a o ; nd 4 n nt to s n h u i ne et' a uh u ps c ' Ob ma I c v F 5 5F.d 3 2, 4 - ( t Ci. 0 9 ,v c t do ohe co nd , 5 U. n . n . . EC, 7 3 4 3 6 47 4h r 2 0 ) a ae n t r u s 5 9 S. 1 8 ( 01 ) ri Gtd i r lv n p r b 6 7 F.d 3 5 3 5( t Ci. 01 )(q o i W itrv. 0 9 2 0 , ens e n ee a t a t v 0 3 5 , 5 4h r 2 0 tu tng ne NaurlRe o re Dee e C n i.I . 5 5 U. 7,2 ( 0 :. Ea h o t e e f u f co s t a s u c s fns mu cl nc, 5 S. 0 20 8 c f h s o r a tr m us be s tsi d. I a 346. A m ova i no al we t de o tae onl a G sbiiy' of t ai fe d. t nt s t lo d o m nsr t y ç i lt ' pos irp r beh r b c us t a sa d r i tn o itn wi (h )c rceiain o ijmci e re aa l n m e a e h t tn ad s l c nsse t t t e haa trz to f n t tv i h r i as a e r or na y r medy t t m a onl be a r upon a c e r s elef n xta di r e ha y y wa ded l a howi t t t ng ha he pl i ifi e il d t s h r i ' I antf s ntte o uc elef' d. Totee tn ta M a d si v d fri daeij n tv rle t p e e tl sta se h x e t h t k e s mo e o mme it nu cie eif o r v n l rn fr i t Ri rNorh a t pos i ede tu ton ofhi l alma e i l i t c s oft tka f r hi o ve t nd he sbl sr c i s eg t ra s n he our e ha ns e , s r s i m oo e by hi ta f ron Nove be 5,201 Se W ila sv.Grfi 95 F. 8 eque t s td s r nse m r 3. e lim ifn, 2 2d 20, 8 ( t Ci.9 )(o dn ta p io rsta se rn ee mo th scamsf rij n t a d 23 4h r1 91 h l ig h t rs ne ' rn fr e d r d o i li o n u ci n ve d ca ao y rle M a e v.W aes 81 F.d 4 ,4 2 (t Ci.1 8 )(n ) Be a s t e lr tr eig; q e tr, 0 2 51 5 4h r 9 7 s me . c u e he c r c n no l rg a t r que t r i t pr ve t ta f rand pos i e smuln ou t a onge r nt he e sed elef o e nt he r nse sbl, i t neous it rer nc wih l lm ae il,M a s ism otonm us bede e asm oo . n e f e e t ega tra s kde s ' i t nid t The r emai r ofM a s is moton,s e ng a or r ofpr ec i fom ga t s i nde kde s ' i e ki n de ot ton ' r ngser n t Ri rNorh PC t twihoutpl c m e i s gr gai mus a s be de ed. l hi i ta he ve t mi t a e nt n e e ton, t lo ni n s nii l mo in M a d sio fr n t n mo eta c ne tr t th slf wo d b i d n e a Rie to , k e s fe s ohig r h n o j cu e ha i ie ul e n a g r t v r Norh. Fr t ofi rs al ge i or ton a utwha lni ntfe Ke n M ount n ofk il t om he fce ' le d nf ma i bo t l de ii d e ai t a s t dt ga tr a a ol he ngse s nd boutce t n ofi er now wor ng a Ri rNorh, a rai tc s ki t ve t M kdes iunr a o bl s e s na y s ult s t ti t PC t tt r ,t ga t r a f r r de e ntofk e s wilha a pec a e ha n he mi he e he ngse s nd o me f nda t r l ve n opporuniy t t eaen a orhn m hi . He f t r s c aes t ti he co pl ns t Ri r t t o hr t nd r m urhe pe ul t ha f m ai o ve Norh ofk il a t t a s bouts h tle t a orhn m,t s ofi il wilt o e t'hi by pl i hi uc lr as nd/ r he e fca s l G t c ' m pr acng m

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.