Martin v. Britton, No. 7:2013cv00313 - Document 10 (W.D. Va. 2013)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 08/08/2013. (kab)

Download PDF
CLERKS OFFI t. . 8T. COURT CE ls Dl ATROANOKE, VA FIED L I TH E UN I N TED STA TES D I RI CO U R T ST CT FO R TH E W ESTER N D I STR I T O F V I G I I C R N A R O A N O K E D I SI N VI O Ak û 8 2 1 C 23 JUL DU LEM CL ERK BY; E t' CL lY ERK f JOHN PHI P M ARTI LLI N CASE NO.7:3CV00 3 1 31 Pl ntf , ai if V. M EM O M N D U M O PI I N N O STAN LEY BR I TO N,JR . T , By: Jam esC .Tur k Se or Uni e St esD i t i tJudge ni t d at src Dee fndants. t) J Philp M a t aVigi a i t pr e ng pr K ,fl t sci lrght ac i ohn li ri n, r ni nma e oce di o ied hi vi i s ton . purua t 42U. C.j1 3.M a tn' compl ntr dsa f lws vebai : s nt o S. 98 ri s ai ea s olo , r tm Upon 1 23/ 1 Hw y 360 W es H alf x Coun y,V igi a. St nl y Brton, r 0/ 201 t ia t r ni a e it J . pef me sej eupon Shel matnsRe seedVe ce.W ili Cour ror d lizur ia ri gitr hil tln t ta cit / 2 1 tsiidh h dn r a o f rsel u e Ev k d6h rns rp 2 2 /2 etfe e a o e s n o liz r . o e t Ame m e Spee ti l2/ / 3,5/ 1 6/ 13Alo c ofVA 1 2- nd nt dy ra 20 1 9/ 3, 3/ s ode 9. 243 Cour Da es tf r10 9t 1 h,111201 Upon 1 23 2011on Rt61 t t e o / h, 0t t 3 0/ / 3 trys i RdStnlyBrtonJ ra di ove cea sel dJ m Philp er brdge a e it r e che nt hil nd lize ol li M a tn' G pe s'orlc e outof1 p dtrng t r y s op. The M a e J r i s t r ' i ens pa a li e r t n c d ohn Philp M a tn li ri ( mpl 1) Asr l fM a t se mo ea yd ma e a dG ma cp to o c re tc n iim' Co . . ei , ri e ks n tr a g s n l n iain f u rn o dto ' e n e (d Thec tfndst tt a tonmus besl rl dimis df f ltet saef t L=) our ha he ci t lmmaiy s se or aitr o tt acs s t e t pr e apl i ecai f rlefunderj 1 ufkint o esnt ausbl l m or ei 983. Thec ti r quie t r viw prs rc pli sf c our s e r d o e e ione om a nt or omplanc wiht ba i nle of i e t he sc l s pl a ng a eihe çde iy c i a ecli so dimist compl nt ora pori oft e di nd t r l ntf ogn z bl am r s s he i ai , ny ton he c mp an (h t fist saeacam u nwh c rle c nb g a td. 2 U. C. o lit t al al o tt li po ih eif a e r ne ' 8 S. ' Martin v. Britton Doc. 10 j 1 5 b ( ) A c mplitmu t l g t n ug fcst saeacam t rle t a i pa i e 91 A( )1 . o an s al e t o h a t o tt li o eif h t s lusbl e e o isfce' Gi r tnov. ohns 5 F. 298,302( hCi.2008)( i BelAt. p. n t a .' aram J on, 21 3d 4t r quotng l lCor v. Two v,550U. 544,570( mbl S. 2007:.Coursmus lbeal co tuepl di fldbypr s t t i rly nsr ea ngs ie oe pli if t e ur t tm e etcl ca r zr m e sdo notf ecos pot nta l me iorous antf s o ns e ha r e mi l eqlie nt or l e e ily rt i Dockets.Justia.com cams Be u et Civo Hn tn, 7 F.d 1 7 ,1 7 - 8( t Ci.1 8 ) Ne e tee s t li . a d t v. t f mp o 7 5 2 2 4 2 7 7 4h r 9 5 . v rh ls ,he c tmus bea et dic m f o t c our t bl o s e r m he ompl ntt pa tesbeng s t al ge conduc on ai he ri i ued, he le d t whc e c cam rss a dt en t eo t ij r t b c mpe s td Ev n ap os p an ifs ih a h li e t, n h aur f he nu y o e o n ae . e r e litf û ta ta alg t nsmus b e o g t r iearg t or l fa o et es e ultv lv l'oo e tl cu l le ai g o t e n u h o as ih t ei b v h p c aie e e, t n e ' t ti û a i eon isf e, r t rt m e ey l onceva e. BelAt. p. Twom bl ha s t usbl pl t ac ' ahe h% ' rl i c i bl ' l l Cor v. ' v, 5 0U. 5 4 5 0( 0 7 . 5 S. 4 , 7 2 0 ) Tosaeac us o a to u d r5 9 3, p an ifmu te tb ihta h h sb e tt a e f cin n e 1 8 a litf s sa ls h t e a e n de i d ofr g s g r nt e by t Cons iuton orl w soft Unied St t a t tt s pr ve i ht ua a e d he tt i a he t a es nd ha hi de i ton r s t fom co prva i e uled r nduc co mitd by ape s a tng t t m te r on c i mderc orofsae lw .W es ol tt a t v. k n , 7U.. 2( 9 8 . Ma t sc mpli t o sn t r vies fkin fcst saea y Ati s 48 S 4 1 8 ) ri o an d e o p o d u t e t a t o tt n n' plusbl cai aci bl unde j1 a i e l m tona e r 983.Fr m t s s deal hepr des t c tc nnot o he pare tis ovi ,he our n d tr n wh ted fnd n i, yhei s b e tt s i u d rj1 3 o Wh r t fn hi t eemie o h ee a t s wh s u jc o ut n e 98 , r ee o id m o s w epr e so hi .Theco ai alo o r sno i cai oft m n ri whih t e oc s n m mpl nt s fer ndi ton he nne n c he i ht . def nda ' a tonsm a ha vi a e pl i if s c tm tonalr g s l Thus t c pl i f is e nt s c i y ve ol t d a ntf ons i i a nt a l , he om t saea a tona ej 1 cai f mo tr dnmag agans Brto o tt ny ci bl 938 l m or neay es i t itn. Theco tc tu M a tn' de nd f rt m a i to ofc e c ton't bea ur onsr es ri s ma o t ncpai n e = nt ondii ' o r que tf r e e fo i r e ai n. W he a deai e c le e s or elas r m nca c r to n t ne ha lngest f tordtr ton ofhi he ac la i s dee i a cvi rght compl nti no t pr tnton, i l i s ai s t he operlgalr m e Pr ie v. Rodrmue 411U. e e dy. e s r i z, S. 4 5( 9 3 ; d v. s evle 71 F.d7 ( t Ci.1 8 ) d ti ema ries h 7 1 7 ) To d Ba k r il, 2 2 0 4h r 9 3 .A eane y as uc c l ng t li de en i n onl by flng a pe ii f a w rtofha msco pus f l i hale es o ts t t o y ii tton or i be r , olow ng 1 To t ext t M ari s he ent hat tn eeksdnm agesbas on a t yt tBrton' actonsconti ed i ed heor ha it s i rbut n s ome wa t hi unl ulares orde e i he i her advi t tcl m soft snat e ar not y o s awf r t t nton, s eby sed ha ai hi ur e a ton bl u rj1 3u e st r s tngc n ci sha b e ov ru ne o s ta i .Se . g. ci a e nde 98 nls he e uli o viton ve e n e tr d r e sde e e. He kv. mp e 51 U. 477 486 8 ( 9 4) Hei as a vie t tcamsun rj 1 3mus c Hu hry, 2 S. , - 7 1 9 . s lo d s d ha li de 98 t ge eal b fldwihi t yer oft asetdijr Se Va Cod An j8. -43a;Owe v. n rl e ie t n wo as he sre nuy. e . e n. 012 () ns y Ok e 48sU. 23 23 - (98 . ur, S. 5, 940 1 9) 2 e usi ofa ia es ec trmedi .J .seas 28U. C.j22544 (e r ng xha ton valbl ut our e es #=; e lo S. b) r gadi e h usi nrq ie n )2 Th s M a t c n o saeacam u e j 1 8 f rr la efo x a to e ur me t. u , ri n n t tt li nd r 9 3 o ee s r m n confnem ent i . F rt er a o sae t c u t s se Ma t sc mplitwi u p eu ie p rua t o h e s ns ttd,he o r dimis s ri o an t t rj dc , u s n n' ho t j 1 5 b ( ) f rfiu et saeacam.Th Clr i dr ce t s n c piso t s o 91 A( )1, o alr o tt li e ek s ie td o e d o e f hi me or ndlm o ni n and a co pa ng o de t pli if m a l pi o c m nyi r r o antf. EN TER ; 'hi F s ay ofA ugus,201 t 3. J Se Unie Stt sDititJ ni t d a e src udg 2 A sM a tn' submi i i cat t hi crm i pr ri s ssons ndi e hat s i nal oceedi a e cur enty pendi , t cour ngs r r l ng he t i s ifed t the hass e cour r s ats i ha ut t emedi yetavaiabl t hi . Ass es l eo m uch,he hasnotye s ts i t t a ifed he e usi r q rme un rj22 49.Ac o di y, h c ur wil tc nsr ehi s bmiso a a xha ton e uie nt de 54 1 c r ngl t e o t l no o tu s u s in s ha a peiin u e j2 4. be s tto nd r 25 3

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.