Mayton v. Dillman, No. 7:2013cv00284 - Document 8 (W.D. Va. 2013)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 6/19/2013. (tvt)

Download PDF
r FRK' OFFI u. nf cour a S CE s. sm AT qcANoK:, VA FIED L I THE UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FO R TH E W ESTERN D I STRICT O F W R G I I N A R O A NO K E D I I O N V SI ROBERT M AYTON, J 19 2 1 0N 23 JULK BY; CASE NO .7: 3CV00284 1 Pe ii tt oner , V. M EM O R AN D U M O PI I N N O JEFFREY DI LLM AN,W ARDEN, By: Gl n E. e Conr ad C hi fU nie St t sD i t c Judge e t d a e s ri t R espondent . Robe tM a on,aVigi a i t pr e ngpr K , ie t spe ii n f ram i of r yt r ni nma e oce di o fld hi tto o t ha sc us pt s ntt 28U. C. 2254, algi t tt Vigi aPa ol Boa dha bea om , l ua o 1 le ng ha he r ni r e r s r S. j vi aedhi rghtt d pr es by wr uly de ng hi a ia i f dic e i ypa ol ol t s i o ue oc s ongf l nyi s pplc tons or s r tonar r e t re tm e . Upon r viw oft r c d,t c tsl ma iy dimi s t peii n,ba e on hiten i s e e he e or he our lm rl s s es he tto sd M a on' f itr t e us s a e co tr m e esz yt s a lle o xha t t t ur e di . I M a on wasc ced i 1 ofc pialmur r frtde eemur r a me r r a yt onvit n 987 a t de , is gr de , r d obbe y, nd t e r l t fr r c r s r a e t t s t de t oft m e dtrng api a so e hr e e aed iea ms ha ge , elt d o he ho gun a hs wo n li zz t r r obbe y i M adi on Hei s V igi a. M a on i s r i t o lf s t nc pl 31 ye r i r n s ght , r ni yt s e v ng w ie en e es us as n prs f t s c i e Hedi notc le hi c c i ors ntnce on a ion or he e rm s. d ha lnge s onvitons e e s ppea ort z l h ough ha a c puspr ee ngs be s or oc di . Mayton v. Dillman Doc. 8 1 Pettone orgi l fied hi ac i i t Unie St t D ititCour f t Easer Diti ii r i naly l s ton n he t d a es src t or he t n srct ofV igi a.I w astansered her becauset cour ofconvi i i l ed i t sditi and pettoner r ni t r f r e he t cton s ocat n hi srct ii i confned her s i e. 2 Und rRul 4 b)oft RulsGo r i j22 Ca e ,hec ur ma s e e( he e ve nng 54 s s t o t y umma iydimisa rl s s j2 4peii E ifipli y a pe r fom t peiin a da y atc e e i t t tt peii e i n t 25 tton çq t anl p as r he tto n n ta h d xhbis ha he tton r s o g e il t r i i t dititcour . ntted o elef n he src t' ' Dockets.Justia.com CL RK l hi j225 peii 3M a on alge t f l nggr n s 4 tton, yt le s he olowi oundsf rle or ei: 1 . ThePa ol Boa d hasa ed isdic e i r powe i r vi ng r e r bus t s r tona y r n e ewi peiin rseii l yf rp r l rla eb fii t f lo Va Co ejj t o e ' l bit o aoe ee s y al o ol w . d t g i ng 53. - 36,53.- ,53.11 1 251 1 252,a 53.- 55 a by denyi pettone ' nd 1 1 nd ng ii r s pa ol bas d on a f c o t twilne c ng a t tdoesnotconsiu e r e e a t r ha l ver ha e nd ha tt t ar tonalr as f denil ai e on or a; TheProl Boa dha vi aedpe ii r spr ed a duepr es rght e r s ol t ttone ' oc ur l oc s i s by f lngt f l w Vigi a s ut r ar ng dic e i r pa ol r l as aii o olo r ni ut es eg di s r tona y r e e e e ei biiy, a epe ii rm e t a 1r uie t f pa ol r l a e; lgi lt bec us ttone e s 1 eq r men s or r e e e s 3. Asa idt peii r Va.Codej53.- 55c tmt a e pos f t pple o ttone , 1 1 onsi es n x t aco lw,a i ha be n a i r toaci l t de i peii rofhi lbe t a s t s e ppled er tvey o prve ttone s i ry i e e ti af i pa ol he rng. nt r s n ar r e a i M a on i c t t thehasneve pr s nt d t e ca mst a sa ecour i pos- onvi i yt ndia es ha r e e e hes li o ny tt t n tc cton pr ee ngs Asr i i t sa ton,M a on s kshi i e ae r l s fom confne e . oc di . elef n hi ci yt ee s mm di t eea e r l m nt 1 1 Und r2 U. C. 2 4 1 afd r l o r c n o g a t h b a p tto u ls t e 8 S. j 25 (9, e ea c u t a n t r n a a e s eiin ne s he pe ii rhase use t r m e esa l ei t c t oft sa ei whi h hewas ttone xha t d he e di vaiabl n he ours he tt n c convit d.The e usi r quie e i s tsi by s eki r vi w oft cai si t hi s ce xha ton e r m nt s a ifed e ng e e he l m n he ghe t saec u t t mid ci nt c nsd r h cams S eO' u l a v Bo rk l5 6U. 8 8 tt o r wi s ito o o i e t e li . e S li n . ec e, 2 S. 3 , hj v 8 ( 999) I Vigi a, n i t c e us hi saecour rme esr r ngpaol is 45 1 . n r ni a nmae an xha t s tt t e di egadi r e sues i o oft ways Fis, c n fl a saehabe pe ii wih t Cic tCour whe ehewa n ne wo . r t he a ie t t as tton t he r ui t r s 3 M ayt a s a tm pt t brng hi cl m s smulaneousl asaci l i sacton unde 42 s ai , i t on 1o te s o i y, vi rght i r U. C.#1 3,se ngij ci rle oreighi rla efom c fn me t Ii weletbls dta S. 98 eki nun tve eif d rn s ee s r onie n. ts l sa ihe h t twhen as a epri ri chalengi t ver f ordur i ofhi physcali ionm e ,a t r i ç t t sone s l ng he y act aton s i mprs nt nd he elef he s eksi a det mi ton t the i enttedt i edit r eas ora s di r eas fom t t e s er na i ha s il o mm a e el e pee er el e r ha i ionm e ,hi s e f alr mprs nt s ol eder emedy i awrtofhabe cor .' Pr s v.Rodrguez,411U . 475, s i as pus' eier i S. 50 ( 97 .l fl t sa to M a o s e hi i dit r la efo c nfne nt Ac or n y, 0 1 3) n ii hi cin, ytn e ks s mme ae ee s r m o i me . c digl ng hi camsa eno a to bl un rj 1 3 a dhi mo inss e ngt p r u hi c amsu rj 1 3i s li r t cina e de 98 , n s to e ki o u s e s l i nde 98 n t scas w ilbe deni hi e l ed. M a oni a vie t ts mec le ge t p r ep o e u e ma b a to bl un rj 1 3 yt s d s d ha o haln s o a ol r c d r s y e cina e de 98 whe et r ifs r he ele oughti nott i at sr eas To brng s cl m s however M a on mus fr t s he nm e' el e. i uch ai , , yt t is com pl w ih necess y pr y t ar ocedur f flng aprs rci lrght ac i i f alc t See28 U. C. es or ii ione vi i s ton n eder our . S. j1 5(e r ngpa me toffln fe ;4 U. C. 1 7ea (e r nge a to ofa mi srtve 9l rgadi y n iig e ) 2 S. j 99 () r gadi xh usin d nitai rme e ) e dis. co c e wih a a a ofa ad re de ii t t Supr m eCour ofVigi a. Va. nvit d, t n ppe l n ve s c son o he e t r ni Code j8016 4()1 ; 1 141 .l t atr aie hec nfl asaeha e speiind rcl wi . - 5 a( ) j 7.- 1 n he len tv , a ie tt b a t o ie ty t t h t eS p e Co r o Vigna Va Co ej8016 4()1 .W l c e e r u eh f l ws h h u rme u t f r ii. . d . - 5 a( ) l h v r o t e ol , e i o mus uli a ey pr s nthi cai st t Supr me Cou tofVigi abe or af der lditit t tm t l e e s l m o he e r r ni f e e a src c r c nc n i e teme iso h scamsu d rj2 4. ou t a o sd r h rt f i li n e 25 M a t 's yt s ubmisonsc e ry i c e t theha sa eco t e e e silaval bl t m si l a l ndiat ha s tt ur r m dis tl ia e o hi , m ey,Cic tCour ha spr e ngsa a s e nta alt t Supr m eCour of m na l r ui t bea oc edi nd ubs que ppe o he e t Vig ni i t Cic tCour pe ii i de e orape ii f rawrtofhabe c pusi t r i a f he r ui t tton s ni d, tton o i as or n he SuprmeCou tofVigi a.Thus t c tmus dimisM ayt sj2254peii wihout e r r ni ,he our t s s on' tton t p eudc frfizet e ha s saec u te dis4 Se Slvt v S t , 0 U. 5 , 4 rj ie o alr o x u t tt o r r me e . e a on mi 4 4 S. 3 5 l h . ( 9 )(id n t a j2 5 h b a peiinmus beds se wi o t eudc i p tto rh s 1 71 fn i g h t 2 4 a e s tto t imis d t u prj ie f ei ne a h i n t r s ne h scamst tea p o raesaec u t n c u dsil os ) Ana p o rae o p e e td i li o h p r p it tt o r a d o l tl d o . p r p it or rwilis t sda de l s ue hi y. TheClr i die t d t s ndco esoft sm e andum opi on a ac ompa ng ek s rce o e pi hi mor ni nd c nyi or rt peii ne . de o tto r ENTER:Thi t N d yo Jme 2 3 s 6 a f t , 01 . ChifUnie St t sDititJ e t d a e src udge The courtnot t ti M a on i di a ifed wih t out ome ofsat cour pr es ha f yt s ss ts i t he c te t oceedi on ngs hi pa oecamsa wihe t rt r t t sc ur wihaj225 p tto hemus pr vies cfc s r l li nd s s o eu n o hi o t t 4 e iin, t o d pe ii i or a i conc ni t rulngsoft Par e Boa d t the i chalengi H i c r petton f l t nf m ton er ng he i he ol r ha s l ng. s urent ii ais o pr de s i or i ovi uch nf maton.

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.