Barr v. Nash et al, No. 7:2013cv00279 - Document 7 (W.D. Va. 2013)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 6/21/2013. (tvt)

Download PDF

W w :rFc:u s y : a po i xoouv A RAi v T o N l,A FlED t JUN 21 2 1 13 I TH E U NI N TED STATES DISTRI T C O UR T C FO R TH E W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI NI CT RGI A ROANO KE DI SI VI ON M LPH D O R ELL BA RR , JULA ,* L CL I 1. EY, ERK ' BY; CA SE N O .7: 3CV 00279 1 Pl ntff ai i , N. M EM O M ND U M O PINIO N OFFI CER NAS c K , H, By:Ja sC. k me Tur Seni U nied St D i t ctJudge or t ates s ri De e f ndants. t) Ral Do elBa aVigi a i t pr e ngpr K ,fld t scvi rg sa to ph r l m r ni nma e oce di o ie hi i l i ht c in pzs a t o4 U. C. 1 8 , le igt t al fiilh sveb lya u e a haa s dhm l u n t 2 S. j 9 3 algn ha aj i o fca a r al b s d nd rs e i r bec us ofhi r c Upon r viw oft r c d,t c tfndst tt aci m us be s a e s a e. e e he e or he our i ha he ton t umm a iy rl dim is s s ed. I Ba ri i r e ae a t SouhwetVigi aRe o lJ i Auhort (E A' fciiy r s ncac r td the t s r ni gina al t iy S SVRJ ' a lt ) i Abi n ngdon,Vigi a ns r ni.l uppor ofhi j1 3cams Baralge t f lwi e nt: t s 98 li , r le s he olo ng ve s Thsa1 tre o e atto o my (e tf r am o aG n e e aeF a 'wi i l sa td v r ato n lf) o e r f l fd r t lg' t co h t dne k'writnjab i.In awhiemana OfkerNah i abl kman l Re c ' lte ove t m t nd f s s ac ( t Sl uglf'tto e o hi lf fr am) Heha writn meu a wih l- ie'ato d n s e t o e r . -h s g e ) p nd t h r sse men meo stme f rfio o ssu f Ofie Nah h sma e a a ll d u r u i s o rv l u tf. fc r s a d gj st e a dc mme t,nfo t fohe imae .I g s g te t t ep i t g e tl s n o n s i r n o t r n ts t ha) otn o h o n I r we r (i)t g t se pwh n Ofie Na hi o d t Du t Ofie Na h' ay sc o o o le e fc r s s n uy. e o fc r s s aci ns 1m s r d ar md bl k pe e 1f a wha hei a et do t m e to , ' ca e ot ac opl . e r t s bl o o , Ee c us lk Ofie Nah sae ,Ã§ c n d wh tv r1 n a dt j iwil b la e ie fc r s ttd t a o ae e wa t n he Ã¢l l l bac meup. k ' ' Barr v. Nash et al Compl 3- Ba rs yst thehasbr . 4. r a ha oughtt pr e ofNas sver labus a ha as men he oblm h' ba e nd r s t Doc. 7 t t a t nton ofSVR J of i a s butno a ton ha be n t ke t pr ven t pr bl m f om o he te i A fci l , ci s e a n o e t he o e r c i ng.Asr le i t sa ton,Barseksmonear dn sa ij tverle t pr tc ontnui eif n hi ci r e t y mage nd n unci eif o oe t h ss ft a t ej i. i aey t h al Dockets.Justia.com 1 1 Thecour i r quie t dimisa a ton orcli fld by aprs t s e r d o s s ny c i a m ie ionera ns a gai t g r e ale iy orof i e i t cou tde e m i st ac i n o c ai i fi ous m a i i , ove nm nt ntt f c r f he r t r ne he t o r l m s rvol , lc ous o fist saeacam o whihr le ma b g a td 2 U. C. 1 5 b ( ) I o d rt r al o tt li n c eif y e r ne . 8 S. j 91 A( )1. n r e o sae ac am ,< compl i m us c an s fcintf c m a tr a e ed a t e, o Ã§t t a tt li $ a ant t ont i ufi e a mal te , cc pt s nz t sae cai ofr i t ti plusbl on isfc ''As r tv.I l 556U. 662,678( l m elef ha s a i e t a e.' hc of gba, S. 2009)( tng quoi BelAt. p. Twombl 550U. 5 570( ). l lCor v. y, S. 44, 2007) Seci n 1 t sdesg t pr deaco pr he i r m e f t de i ton of to 983 Ã§ i i ned o ovi m e nsve e dy or he prva i consiui lrght. Smihv. tttona i s' t Hnmpt Tr i ngSc f Ntre ,360F. 577,581(t Ci. ' on ani h.or ls s 2d 4h r 1 . saeacli unde j1983,$ pli ifmus esa iht e elme s...:()t 966)To tt am r Ã§ antf t tbls hre e nt a 1 he de i tonofarghts cu e byt Consiutonoraf rlsaut;( by apes ( a tng prvai i e r d he tt i edea tt e 2) ron; 3) ci t e c lro saelw. Jnkn v Me f r ,1 9F.d 1 5 1 5 - 0( t Ci. 9 7 . md r o o f tt a ' e is . d o d 1 3 1 6, 1 9 6 4 h r 1 9 ) ' TheEq lPr eci Cl eprvi st tÃ§g o Stt s l ...de t a pe s wihi ua ot ton aus o de ha Ã§nl ae hal ny o ny ron t n is t id cintee u l r tcino t elws' U. Co s. me . V,j1 Animae t jl s ito h q a p oe to f h a . S. n t n nd XI r ' . n t cai i r c dic i i ton i vi aton o equa pr e ton Ã» tfrtde onsr t t theha l m ng a e s rm na i n ol i f l ot c i k mus is m tae ha s be n te t d dif r nty fom ot r w ih whom hei sm iary st t d a t tt uneq l e r ae fee l r he s t s i l l iua e nd ha he ua te t ntwa t r ul ofi e i lo pu pos uldic i naton. Ve y v.W yc ,293 F.d r a me s he es t ntntona r r ef s rmi i ' ne ' he 3 7 , 3 (t Ci. 0 )(mit i tr a q oains.tAl s n s mefcua e d n e( f 26 7 0 4h r 20 2 o ti nen l u tto ) t b e t o a t l vie c o ng l ds rmiain ,hec u t lno lo b hn ted tr n to so p io o fcaso me e ici n to ) t o r wil t o k e id h ee miain f rs n fi il n r ac us tonst t a er i l m otvae ' Cha a v.Re ds 378 F.Su 11 11 c a i hat hey r acaly i td. ' pm n ynol , pp. 37, 40 ( . Va.1 .Pli ifS tpl ds t e f t t s tsye c r quie nt'i or rt W D. 974) antf Ã» mus ea ufkint acs o aif a h e rme ' n de o sae ac am . Vene 293 F. a 731 Aleg tonsofve bala eandha asm e by g r , tt li y, 3d t . l a i r bus r s nt ua ds wihoutm or ,do nots a e a c tt i lcl i . H e l e v.Le i ,1 Fe App' 1 1 t e t t ny ons iutona a m ns e w s 53 d. x 79, 79 2 (t Ci. 0 ) Ke sv. t o Al n , 9 F. u p. 1 7@ . N. 1 8 )( t h u eo 4h r 2 05 ; ye Ciy f ba y 5 4 S p 1 4 D. Y. 9 4 1Tl e s f i v l a da u ieln a eg ldngr ca e ih t)nomatrh w a h re to rp e e i l, ie n b sv a gu g i u i a il pt es, nc te o b o rn r e rh nsbe ca f m t ba i f aj1 c1i ' . nnot or he ss or 983 am.' ) Ba rha noa tonabl cli unde j1 baedmeel onNah' de ogaoyco nt r s ci e am r 983 s ry s s r tr mme s a uthi r ce ore hni he ia bo sa t c rt ge.W hie ofi i l 'c m e son s h m a t r m a be l tc a s om nt uc te s y unpr es i ,ofe i ,a e n dit bi ve bala esmpl doe no rs t t l ve ofa of sonal f nsve nd ve sur ng, r bus i y s t ie o he e l c tt i ons iutonalde i ton. The e or ,t t e e Bar s N a h f ve ba ha as m e ,t prva i r f e o he xt nt r ues s or r l r s nt he c u t imis sh scamst e j1 5 b)a lg l fi oo s o r d s se i li md r 91 A( s e al rv lu . y Bar' al ga i a ealo i ufi e t sae a c am t tNas dic i naed a i t rs le tons r s ns fcint o t t ny l i ha h s rmi t gans Ba rbe a eofhi r ce.Ba rsc l or r f r est Na h' c r c us sa r ' oncus y e e enc o s s omm e sa S ieups' r nt nd t t wr 'a e nots fce t saeaplusbl j 1 cam t tNa hte t Ba rdifr ntyt not r ufiint o tt a i e 983 li ha s raed r fe e l ha he i a es ort tt di c plna y cha gesN a h wr t aga ns Ba rw e em otva e by Ba r sr c nm t , ha he s i i r r s oe i t r r i td r ' a e. Acc di y,Barfist saefc ss ri aj 1 cai ofr edicrmi tono or ngl r al o tt a t uppo tng 983 l m ac s i nai r haa s n , n tec u t imis sti cam wi o t rj dc t e j1 5 b ( ) r sme t a d h o r ds se h s li t u p eu ie md r 91 A( )1. h F rt ra o sae t c u t imis sBarsc mplitwih u p eu ie pts n o he e s ns ttd,he o r ds se r' o an to t rj d c , t ua t r t j1 5 b ( ) Th Clr i d rce t s n c pe o t sme r n u o i ina d o 91 A( )1. e ek s ie td o e d o is f hi moa d m p no n a co pa ng or rt pl ntf. c m nyi de o ai if E E :T i ?J dyo Jn,03 NT R hs v- fue2 1. a Se ' nied St t Diti J e or t aes srct u

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.