Yowel v. Commonwealth of Virginia et al, No. 7:2013cv00223 - Document 19 (W.D. Va. 2013)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 06/20/2013. (kab)

Download PDF
@ FpK:OF Ij>j , 'Y X QRr. ' 9ej(. D1 ,' ,S . . ' . AT 8OANOKE, VA i1.. --: JL I THE UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FOR THE W ESTERN DI STRI O F VI NI CT RGI A ROANOKE DI SI VI ON H A BAK K U K E.BEN Y O W EL, JULI A BY; DE 23 1 EX CLERK CL ERK CA SE NO .7: 13CV 00223 Pl nt f , ai i f N. M EM OM NDUM OPI O N NI CO M M O NW EA LTH O F V I G I I , R N A U K , By:J me C. k a s Tur Se or U nied St e D it i tJudge ni t at s s r c Dee fndants. t) Habn kkuk E.Be Yowel aVigi ai t pr e ngpr K ,fld t scvi rg s n , r ni nma e oce di o ie hi i l i ht a to pzs a t o4 U. C. 1 8 , le igt tt Co n at a dd z nso h rofc r, cin l u n t 2 S. 9 9 3 algn ha he mmo we 1 n o e f e fies r h i l ng t gove nora t e ie ge r a s mbl ha vi a e hi co tt tona rght. nc udi he r nd he ntr ne al s e y, ve olt d s nsiu i l i s The c tg a e Y ow e ' a i a i n t pr e w ihoutpr pa e oft flng f e unde 28 our r nt d l s pplc t o o oc ed t e ym nt he ii e r U. C.j1 wiht pr viot tt ssauscoul bervo di t c tf t tYowe S. 915, t he o s ha hi tt d e ke f he our ound ha l ha pr vi l hadt e c e dimi s d asfi ous malci , f f iur t sa ea ca m . d e ousy hr e as s s s e rvol , i ous or or al e o tt li Upon r e oft c tsr or a t c eviw he our ' ec ds nd he ompli ,t c tfndst tYowe doesnot ant he our i ha l qua iy t pr e w ih t sa i wihoutpr pa e oft f e. The e or t cour r voke lf o oce d t hi cton t e ym nt he e r f e, he te s Yo lsi f r pa p rssausu d rj1 5b a ds mma i d s se t a to p ru n we ' n o ma u e i tt n e 91 ( ) n u rl imis s he cin, u s a t y t 28U. C.j1 5( . o S. 91 g) Se ton 1 5( rquie t c tt a s sa ns i ge i tst $ 00flng ci 91 b) e r s he our o ses gai t ndi nt nmae he 350. ii f ef a cvi aci n,b a s alowst m t pa t sf et ough i t lm e swihhel fom e or i l to ut lo l he o y hi e hr nsa l nt t d r Yowel v. Commonwealth of Virginia et al Doc. 19 t ri t a cou sa t ca epr ese .Seci 1 5( de est i tlme pa nt hei nmae c nt s he s ogr s s ton 91 g) ni he nsal nt yme m e hod t t e prs r who ha S hr e sr ke ' - t e pr s ne sw ho ha ha t e t o hos i one s ve ç e ti s ' - hos i o r t ve d hr e pr vi c esora al dimis d asfi ous m a ii ,orf f itr t sa eacli . Eve e ous as ppt s s s e rvol , lcous or a lle o t t am n Dockets.Justia.com a pr s r ltga wih t ee s rkesm a qua iy t pr e unde t i t lm e pa entpl n i i one ii nt t hr t i y lf o oce d r he ns a l nt ym a f h dsi i n n d n e o sro p ysc l nu y. j 91 () e s n mmie t a g r f eius h ia ij r ' 1 5 g . i ' Cour r or i ca e t tY ow e ha f l d a l a tt e prorci la tons i f m a t ec ds ndi t ha l s ie t e s hr e i vi c i , n or pa pe i,t twe edim is d asm ai i ,fi ous orf f iur t sa ea cam ; Yowe v. u rs ha r s s e lcous rvol , or a l e o t t li l J h o No 2:4-v- 47( D. . rl 3 2 0 )( imisda fi lu pzs a to o ns n, . 0 c 001 E. Va Ap i 2 , 0 4 d s se s rvoo s l u n t r Prs rLii tonReor Acl Robi o v.Gimor No. 6663,1 U. App. ione tgai f m t; ns n l e, 99999 S. LEXI S 296 ( hCi. 42 4t r Nov.1 1 (i i t a a fi ous; i onv.Gimoe, 2: c 0, 999) fndng he ppe l rvol ) Robns l r No. 99-v0053 ( D. Ma 4,1 ( s se asfi ouspurua t Prs rLii tonReo m 4 E. Va. y 999) dimis d rvol s nt o ione tgai fr Ac) Ro i o v. mmo we lh No 79 -v 0 21 ( . Va M a .1 1 9 )( s s ig t; bns n Co n at , . :6 c - 0 2 W D. . r , 9 6 dimisn unde 28U. C.j1 5( )(1 :,af' No.96-387,1 U. App. r S. 91 d 996 fd, 6 996 S. LEXI 1 21 ( h Ci. S 9 0 4t r Aug. 1 .Se aloYo v. r ni De rme ofCore tons Ca eNo.7:0-v5, 996) e s wel Vigi a pa t nt rci , s 1 c 00040 ( . Va)(imisn j 1 8 a to wi u p eu ieu e j1 5 g f rtr esrk s. W D. . d s si g 9 3 cin t t rj dc nd r 91 ( ) o h e tie )l ho Theeor t rj1 5( ) hei bardfom flngacviaci i t sc twihoutprpa ng rf e,mde 91 g , s re r ii i l ton n hi our t e yi t flng f i f lunl s he de he ii ee n ul e s monsr t st thei i i i ntda rofphysca hn ta e ha s n mm ne nge i l nn r l t d t hi c ains ea e o s l r . I hi pr s ntco pl nt Yow e alege û e i r t M a i i D e a ofN e o og c n s ee m ai , l l s r lbe a e lc ous ni l ur l i al M edialCa e a Se vcePr a Pos Sur r ... lbe a eM a ii De a of c r nd r i e nd t ge y De i r t lc ous ni l S ii a/ l i u Fre o Beif a tc wih u p n s me t. .a d Deie aeM aii u p rt l i o s e d m l gr cie t o t u ih n .ln l l rt l o s u Re g e b c I lci l jCr lAndUnus lPu s nt Theco antca bes nfiton of ue ua nibme . mpli n ummaiydimis d rl s s e u e 2 U. C. 1 5 b ( ) b c u ei fist saea yf csi s p o t ft e ecamso t nd r 8 S. j 91 A()1 , e a s t al o tt n a t n u p r o h s li r o de c i c s rbe onduc by a oft i vi lde e t ny he ndi dua f ndan si vi a i ofYowelsrg s See t n olton ' i ht . Vi daev.Gi ,550F. 926,928( , Ci.977)(i ngt tunde j 1 çibiiywil nne bbs 2d 4t r1 h tndi ha r 983,ta lt l l 1 l t opi on dim i i t scas , t courtnot t tYowelpr n he ni s ssng hi e he ed ha oceeded undert s he ame i at num be ,#145224,i t eprorcourtpr eedi ,butattm esuse anot name,Barhol e nm e r n hes i oc ngs i d her t om w Robi on. ns 2 onl 1ewhe ei i af m ai l s yi r t s fr tvey hown t tt ofi ilc r d a t d pe s ly i t ha he fca ha ge c e r ona l n he d p i ai no tep an itçqrg t' (nena ctto o te ) M o e v r b c u etecams e rv to f h litfls ih s' i tr l i ins mitd . r o e, e a s h li ) a j i mutp ed f n a t i o ec mplit h tp e e t mulpl camsc n en n s p rt lg l o n lil ee d n s n n o an t a rs n s t e li o c r i g e aae e a i que to ,bas d o ditnc eve sa m uli eprs n f clte ,t c si ns e n si t nt t tpl io a iiis he ompl i i c ant s omplt l e ey c n rr t t er srcinso j i d ro t eae d fn a t a dcamsi Rue 1 a d2 o tay o h e tito n o n e f mrltd ee d n s n li n ls 8 n 0. M os i pora l how e r Yow e ' co pl n s a esno f c s i ca i t the i i t m t nty, ve , l s m ai t t t a t ndi tng ha sn i mi ntda rofphysc har r l t t a ofhi cli s Acc di y, he c r fndst t m ne nge ial m e aed o ny s am . or ngl t ou t i ha Yo lsc mplitf i t stsyt eçmmie td n e'e c pint e j1 5 g , a d we' o an al o aif h i n n a g r' x e to md r 91 ( )2 n s i t r f e,Yow elm a no pr e w ihoutpr pa e oft flng f e a a a plc bl he e or y t oc ed t e ym nt he ii e nd ny p i a e ad i sr t f es Thec twilr vo isor ral nghi t pr e wihoutpr pa nt m nita e e . our l e ke t de lowi m o oc ed t e yme . Fu t r r ,h c u t l ds s ti a to wih u p eu ie p s n t j 1 5 g . rhemo e t e o r wil imis h s cin t o t rj dc , urua t o 91 ( ) TheCl k i die edt s nd c e oft sm e a er s r ct o e opi s hi mor ndum opi on a a compa ng ni nd c nyi o dert pl i if r o a ntf . ENTER :T i V% dyo Jn , 0 3 hs a fu e2 1. Z Se n' ie St t sDitit dge t d a e src 2 Y owe1movesse a el f t cour t appoi couns and t or prs of i al t pr de par t y or he to nt el o der ion fci s o ovi c esofuns fed docum ent f eeofchar asnee f Y owelsltgaton.l s opi pecii sr ge, ded or ' ii i n uppor ofhi t s m oton f appoi m entofcouns ,Yow elsa est i M ar orAprl201 he had s ge y i whi i or nt el t t hat n ch i 2, ur r n ch S newa c ta y i gi)ne kt e lr t s na c nney i a a tmp t ale aep i fo a s bo s u wa n h s c o n age he pi l ha l' n n te t o lvit an r m ' pi h dne v i t ta e ofhi b y.( No. - ,a l) I t a t p i a o h rs omsoft nc e r e n ha r a s od ECF 7 1 t . nse d,he an nd t e ympt he pi nched ne have goten wor e snce t s ger l Oct 201 prson ofi al alegedl rve t s i he ur y. n ober 2, i fci s l y di scontnue Y owelsneur pai m edi i a ha snce r fus t pr de any m edi car or i d ' o- n catons nd ve i e ed o ovi cal e s rvi r aed t hi pi e ces el t o s nched ne e. rv Y oweldoegnoti ca et tt e f w lnesi t ss a e moton f couns ar r eva t hi ndi t ha hes e i n hi epar t i or el e el nt o s j l 3cli .Eve i t c u t o d I r l c nsr ete ass c t y d no me tt rquie n s 98 ams n f he o r c ul i al o tu h m u h,he o t e he e r me t be y ofj 1 1 ( .Gi nt ep s a eo s v r lmonhsb t e t s e n sa t flngo ti a toni 9 5g) ve h a s g f e e a t e we n he e ve t nd he ii f h s ci n M ay 201 t y ar i uf i entt suppor a fndi t tY oweli i i i da 3, he e ns fci o t i ng ha s n mm nent ngerofphyscalha m i r r at t hi va cl m i t com pl ntt he hasbeen deni uns fed medi car t ough t el ed o s gue ai n he ai hat ed pecii cal e hr he uns fed ac i ofuni ii i vi s pecii tons dentfed ndi dual,

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.