Hart v. Commonwealth Of Virginia et al, No. 7:2013cv00165 - Document 5 (W.D. Va. 2013)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 05/06/2013. (kab)

Download PDF
CLERK : OFFI t, DS GOURT CE JS. ST, ATR- OKE, VA FIED L I TH E U N I N TED STA TES D I STR I C O U RT CT FOR THE W ESTERN DI STRI O F VI CT RGI A NI R O A NO K E D I SI N VI O JEFFE RY ALL EN H AR T, MA 2 6 2 1 t 23 J A / DUDLM C UL C. E # e 1 BY; . z . : # '. ; 'J : z'n? , zl. ' .. ( ' C L CA SE NO .7: 3CV 00165 1 Pe ii r, ttone M EM OR AN D U M O PI I N N O V. C O M M O NW EA LTH O F TA ZEW E LL C O U NTY ,VI G I A , R NI By: G l E.C onrad en Chi fUni e St e D i t i Judge e t d at s s r ct R es pondent . J f e y A le H ar,a V i g ni i a e pr e ng nr K ,fl pl adi t tt s c t efr ln t r i a nm t oce di o ied e ngs ha hi our c t e a apeii f awrtofha asc onsnzd s tton or i be omus pms ntt 28U. C.j225 Ha tno , ua o S. 4. r w o j cst t c u tsc nsnzto o h smo in rter a o h r i sae t c u t b e t o he o r' o t cin f i to .Fo h e s ns e en ttd,he o r d s se Hatsp tt nwih u p eu ie imiss r' eii t o t rj d c . o H M ha fl hi pe ii t i i t s c r . He i ta l fl a G O TI TO s ied s tton w ce n hi ou t nii ly ied C M ON V A CA TE A C OI AB I I O 'CON VI ON AN D SEN TEN CE PU RSUA N T TO V A . V D N TI CTI CODE j8. - * J 22, 2.Theco tc tu da co to ly fl t s 014285on une 201 ur onsr e nd ndiinal ied hi s sin a aj2254ha asc puspeii bec us Hatspladi c lnge t vai t ubmiso s be or tton, a e r' e ng hale d he ldiy o h sc nfn me tmd raci n l u g n e tr da ans hm b teTa e l Co ny f i o ie n t e rmia j d me t nee g i t i y h z wel u t Ci c tCour . H M v. r ui t Com m onwea t ofTa e el Count V igi a,Ca e N o.7: 2CV 00277 lh zw l v. r ni s 1 ( . Va. 2) Thec t iidHM o isi e i t ad es hi peii unde j2254i W D. 201 . our notte f t ntnton o dr s s tton r f h d dn t be t S eCatov UntdS ae , 40U. 3 5 38 ( 0 3 .HM o j ce He e i o o j c. e sr . ie tts 5 S. 7 , 1 2 0 ) be td. sae t thedi no wa hi pla nga ese asaj2254ha aspeii a di itdt t ttd ha d t nt s e di ddr s d be tton, n. nsse ha t c tadd e shi pl a ng t de V i g ni l w i t a Fi ng no a hort t de V igi a he our r s s e di m r r i a a ns e d. ndi ut iy m r r ni l alowi t sc tt r viw t vai t ofHar' contne e tunde asa ec tc i i l aw l ng hi our o e e he ldiy ts i m n r t t our rm na j udgme t t c t s sedt aci wiho prj ce. n,he our dimis he ton t ut eudi . . , Ha t he fld smia m o i i t Supr m eCour ofVigi a a i t Ta ewel r t n ie i lr tons n he e t r ni nd n he z l Co m t Cic tCour , hi h w e e de e I Apr l201 H M s bm it d c pi ofa 1t s t y r ui tw c r ni d. n i 3, u te o es 1 hi pa wor t t sco t aongwih apla ng syld a aû i eofAppe . Hes ekst ha per k o hi ur, l t e di t e s s e Not al' ' e o ve h ssaec n cin v c tda dh v t ec a g sta se rdt a oh r u idito f rtil i tt o vito s a ae n a e h h r e rn fre o n t e j rs cin o ra. Thec tc to lyfldt s ne s sinsasaj2254peiin a notfe HM ofhi our ondiinal ie he e w ubmiso tto nd iid s o p runt t o j c t t sc nsr cin p ru n t Ca to HM no o j csa isssta p o t i o b e t o hi o tu t , u s a t o sr . y o w b e t nd n it h t t c ts d a es hi s he our houl ddr s s ubmisonsa aç i t va a ea t d- b- nii m otont si s d on o c t voi a a to' i o mot va t ...mde Va. cae t r Codej8. - a as unde Ca s3( 1 )(i ,a as j 1 201428, nd lo r non' E) a scl nd lo 9. 1 CodeofVa. s 28U. C. j455.' et rj45 nora oft sae1 pr sons 53, Alo S. S. 'N ihe 51 ny he tt aw ovii cied by H a ta hor z t sf de a co t o r vi t va i t ofhi c a m st the i t r ut i es hi e r l ur t e ew he ldiy s l i ha s wr ulyconfne t rasaec tci naludg nt ongf l i d mde tt our rmi j me . Peh p HM b l ve t a t sc u t a rviw t ej d me t o tesaec u t d n i ra s ei s h thi o r c n e e h u g ns f h tt o rs e yng e hi motonst va at a( d-b- nii ' Ha ti mit n. Lowe f de alcoursdo no ha s i o c e û a a to. r s sake voi ' re r t t ve j rs ito t r ve t j dg nso saec u t o a pe l v e v M o r ,1 9F.d7 8 u id cin o e iw he u me t f tt o rs n p a.Pllr . o e 2 3 2 , 7 (t Ci. 9 )2 J rs ito f ra p laer ve o saec u tu g n sl se l i l 31 4h r 1 97 . u idcin o p elt e iw f tt o rj d me t i xcusvey e wih s pe i sa ec t and,uli t l wih t Unie St t sSupr m eCour t ough a t u ror tt ours tma ey, t he t d a e e t hr peiinf awrtofc ri mi unde c rancrumsa s I ;28U. C.j1 tto or i e tor , r e ti ic tnce . d. S. 257. 1 Thef alsat e on w hi Har r i cannotpr de gr eder t ut ch t eles ovi oundsf t r i he s . Sec i or he elef eeks ton 455c n e nst r s o i lt ofafdea j dg t diq alf hi el fo p e i n o ra y o c r he e p nsbiiy e r l u e o s u iy ms f r m r sdig ve n pr c e ngdnwhihhi i a taiymih r a o bybequ sin d. 28U. C. 45 a .Th r f r , o e di d i c s mp rilt g t e s na l e to e ' ' S. j 5() e e o e t ss i doesnotpr de aut iy f t scour t r ew t valdiy ofHar' sa ecourtconvi i hi ecton ovi hort or hi t o evi he i t ts t t cton or s nt e ence. 2 Se alo D i rc ofCol bi Ct App. Fed n, 0U. 4 2,4 2- 6 ( 98 ) Roo rv. e s stit um a . v. lma 46 S. 6 8 8 1 3 ; ke FieivTr s Co.26 U. 41 ,41 - 6( 9 ) d lt u t , 3 S. 3 5 1 1 23 . Fort r s sa e t c tfndsno gr mdon whi hHa ti e il d t t r le he he ea ons tt d,he our i ot c r s ntte o he e if se a dwil emiaet ej2 5 c s a dd s s Hatsmoin/ei o wih u p eu ie e ks n l tr n t h 2 4 a e n imis r' to p tt n t o t rj d c . i An a opra eor wili s t sda ppr it der l s ue hi y. TheClr i die t t s nd c esoft sm e a e k s r ced o e opi hi mor ndum o ni a ac om pa ng pi on nd c nyi or rt peii r de o ttone . E ER:T i Q NT hs dyo Ma, 0 3 a f y 2 1. Chi fU nie St t D i ti tJ e e t d a es sr c udg

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.