Barbati v. Warden, USP Lee County, No. 7:2013cv00048 - Document 44 (W.D. Va. 2013)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 07/05/2013. (kab)

Download PDF
e pv s OFFI U. , sT. lr a CE s Dl m I AT ROANOKE, VA FI LED -. ,, J !. 2 1 UL 15 93 I THE UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FO R TH E W ESTER N DISTW CT O F V I G I A R M R O AN O K E DI I O N V SI N I O LA S BA R BAT I CH , Jutl C. A BY: DEP Y, CLERK GL ERK CA SE N O .7: 3CV 00048 1 Pe i i r, t tone M EM O R AN D U M O PI I N N O . VS. W A RD EN ,U SP L EE CO UN TY , By: G l n E.C onrad e C hi U nied St es Di tri Judge ef t at s ct R espondent . N ihol sBa ba i af r li t pr e ngpr K ,fl t spe ii f awrtof c a r t, ede a nma e oce di o ied hi tton or i . ha scor , s ntt 28U. C.j2241 a srt t tt cac ai ofhi tnnof bea pus purua o S. , se i ha he lulton ng se c i me byt Btr uofPrs (t 'doe noti l prorc t c e tt wlihhe onfne nt he lea ions : BOP' s ncude i usody r di o lc ) he e r he our oncl s ha r t a l o t t a t i e il 1 Upon r viw oft r co d, t c tc ude t tBa ba if ist s a e f c son s ntted. e e whihhei enildt ha asr le t rj2241. c s tte o be eif mde I A ut r te i V ol i Co y,Fl i ar e t d B a ba ion J y 2,2009,f pos e s on of ho ii s n us a unt orda r s e r t ul or s s i coc ne pos e so ofna c i e pme ,a de i ng s ai , s s i n r otc qui nt nd rvi uppor fom pr tt i i Cas No. tr osiuton n e 1 Ba b t fldt sj2 p ttoni t Unie SaesDititCou t o t eM idl Dititof r a i ie hi 241 eii n he td tt src r f r h d e src Barbati v. Warden, USP Lee County Fl i and i wastans e r t t Unied Sàt Diti Cour f t Sout n Diti ofW es orda, t r f r ed o he t es srct t or he her srct t V igi a becaus pe ii wasconfne brefy i t tdititwhie i tanst On Febr y 5,2013,t r ni, e ttoner i d i l n ha src l n r i. uar he cas waskansered t t scourtbe e Bar iwast confned a t Unied St esPe t i y i e f r o hi caus bat hen i t he t at nientar n Doc. 44 Le Cou t CC Le Cou t', r ni wihnt sc ur'j idito Thi c ur sbsiue t e ny USP e ny' Vigi w ti hi o ts urs cin. s o t u tttd he ) w a den ofUSP Le Count ast r pondentand r r a r pons t Bar t ' petton. Bar iwas r e y he es equied es e o ba is ii bat lt tans ered t USP At t ri Calf ni and i curenty confned t r a er r f r o wa e n ior a s r l i he e. Or n rl t peiine ' c nvn c t dini t pr e r po ntt a j22 p tto Se dia iy,he tto rs u t uso a s he op r es nde o 41 e iin. e Ru f l v. dil,5 2U. 4 ( 00 .Thewade o USP Le Co t ha n tr ie a obe ton msed Pa la 4 S. 26 2 4) r nf e un y s o as d ny j ci rgadigj idito a ha fldamoint dimis Mor v rbe a s Babai c fne i t e r n urs cin nd s ie to o s s. eo e, c ue r twas oni d n he W eser Diti ofVigi aatt tm et scour r ved hi pe ii t cour concl t hi t n srct r ni he i hi t ecei s tton, he t udes hat s s squ n ta frt Caiori ddno dee thic r'j idci t a rs hi j22 cams L= ube e trnse o lf na i t fa t s ou t ursiton o ddes s 41 li . d. s at442443. Dockets.Justia.com 1 03361 cFA Es. H e w a r l s d on bond t ts m e day. Count aut ii ar e t d 009 8 2 s e ea e ha n y hortes r s e Ba baia i o Oc obe 15, r t ga n n t r 2009, elt d t t s me c s andagan,r l s d hi on bond t r a e o he n a e, i eea e m he smeda OnAprl20,201 t Vol i CounyCic ts ntnc Babait sxmont ( 0 n y. i 0,he usa t rui e e ed r t o i hs 18 da )i prs f t sstofc r . Babair c ve t da ofprorc t cedit r ys n ion or hi e hages3 r t e ei d wo ys i usody r t owad t ssntnce f J y2a Ocobe 1 2009(heda whe hewa ar tda r e ed) hi e e , or ul nd t r 5, t ys n s rese nd elas . Vol i Cot y a horte r ese Ba ba ion M a c 1 201 f G usa mt ut iis td r t r h 2, 0, or s domesi vi e ei tc olnc n CaeNo. 01 0 40 0M M AES. M . s Ex. , t 6 Hewa c n itdo t i c a g a d s 2 0 3 3 ' Dim. 1 a ! . ' s o vce n h s h r e n s nt nc d o M a 5,201 t 55 da i pr s tw ih c edi f tm e s r d f dom e tc ba t r e e e n y 0, o ys n i on, ç t r t or i e ve or s i te y i Cas N o. 201 034030M MAES.4 JLa !(. n e , - t k , I 0 - Fe a a t ii t r d'Ba ba iunde a wrtofhabe c pusadpr e ndum der l u hortes t owe ' r t bor r i as or os que on M a 13, y 2010,s t the coul f ce f de a cha ge i t U nied St t Di t i tCour f t o ha d a e r l r s n he t a es sr c t or he M i eDiti ofFl i W hieBa baiwast G l n't f de ala hortes t r ei d ddl srct orda. l r t hus l oa ' o e r ut ii , hey ec ve on 2 Thewar haspr de t i or a i s marzed he e r di Bar iscour den ovi d he nf m ton um i r egar ng bat' t pr oceedi i r i ngs, n elance on a afi vi fom a corectonalpr amsspeci itw ih t BOP' n fda t r r i ogr als t he s de i ai a s ne ec uttonc n e;Ba b t' Pr sntnc I si to Re or CTS ', ih sgn ton nd e tnc omp a i e tr r ais e e e e nvetgain p t R' whc ) hasnotbeen pr ded t t courq and ot s ovi o he her upportng docum e aton.W hieBa ba isalegatons i nt i l r t' l i diput s s e ome f t fom t ss mar asnot t diput f t a enotmat i t t cour ' ac s r hi um y, ed, he s ed ac s r eral o he ts det mi ton t Bar isf t alega i f lt demonsr t i opercal a i ofBa ba ispror er na i hat bat' acual l tons ai o t ae mpr culton r t' i cusody cr tby f alofk i s. Ther or t cour fndsno need t expand t r d by r rng t edi eder l al ef e, he ti o he ecor equii t wa de t s i t PSR orany ot a tonaldocum e aton. he r n o ubm t he her ddii nt i 3 A lhough Bar iass rt t the wasa ted oft oft t ee c gest war n des i t bat e s ha cquit wo he hr har he de crbes i t sc e,Bar t doesnotdiput t l h oft s ence i n hi as ba i s e he engt he ent mpos ort s enci dat t war ed he ent ng e he den pr desf t cas ovi or he e. 4 Thewar sdoc den' umentton i ca est t scas concer a c get Ba ba ihad a i ndi t hat hi e ned har hat r t vi ae p e a r la ec ndii .M . s . 1 Ata h. a 7( No. 4- .Ag i ho ve, oltd r lil ee s o tons Dim Ex. , tc B, t ECF 3 3) an, we r Bar idoesnotdi et l ngt oft s e i pos ort s nt ng da et war pr des bat sput he e h he ent nce m ed he e enci t he den ovi f t case. or he 2 i or ton i c tng t thi sa es nt nc ha e r on Aug t26, 201 5 OnNovembe nf ma i ndia i ha s tt e e e d xpied us r 0. 30, 0, heDiti tCour i Fl i s nt nc Ba ba it t e co uren t msof48 mont 201 t src t n orda e e ed r t o hr e nc r t er hs i pr s f c n i on or onveyi f l e i or a i a hoa flng a f s c a m w ih t I e a Re nue ng a s nf m ton nd x, ii al e l i t he nt m l ve Se vie, ma ng af s dites c l r c and ki ale sr s al. Acc di t t wa de sevi nce f pu pos ofs nt ncec c ai Ba ba is or ng o he r n' de , or r es e e alul ton, r t' f de a s e c me e on t da ofhi f der ls nt nci N o mbe 30,201 a he e r l entnce om nc d he y s e a e e ng, ve r 0, nd be n s r i t ts nt nc on t tda e I a ton, r c ve 95 daysofprorc t cr di ga e vng ha e e e ha t . n ddii he e ei d i usody e t f tm e s r e fom A ug t27, 0, he da afe hi sa e s nt nc e r d,t tlN ove ber or i e v d r us 201 t y t r s t t e e e xpi e m i m 29 2 0 t ed ybeo eh sf d rls ne c c mme c d r aisc re t rj ce rla e , 01 ,h a f r i e ea e tn e o n e .Bab t' u r n p o e td ee s daei M a 24, 201 6 t s y 4. Li r lyconsnld, r t' j2241s si asett f l ngovelppi be al t e Ba bais ubmisons s r he olowi ra ng g omdsf rr l f ()teBt e uo Prs n (%OP' t a ul c mp tdh ssn e c ; b t r t o ei : a h l a f io s t ' mlwf ly o u e i e tn e ( ) he e r ) BOP t a ul d ne hm p irc so yce i; n ()t eBOPr v k do r f s dt ce i mlwf ly e id i ro u t d r dt a d c h e o e r e t e o r dt z hi wih g tme hee ne , ors ul ha e r dt rsa el 7 Ba ba ihasa s tl a m t ood i nr d l o ied ho d ve n ne mde t t aw. r t pla igsye a aû to f rsl r u g n . I hi s b si n , r ai s e t ta h e dn t ld s t in o l mo mmayj d me t' n s u miso s Ba b t a s rs h t e ' i entte t a addii l18 daysofpro c t c edi ag ns hi f de a s t nc bec us s ild o n tona 0 i r usody r t ai t s e r l en e e, a e a1 ofhi s a e a f de als nt nc w e e i pos d t r n co ur e l 1 s t t nd e r e e es r m e o u nc r nty.Se r t l he as e t pa a e y, s rs 5 A s nt e cal aton m e o ata d t t war sm oton i c est tf r ofi al e enc cul i m tche o he den' i ndiat ha ede al fci s verfe w ih sat ofi al by t e iid t t e fci s elphone t tBa ba issa e s ence ended on Augus 26,2010.M . ha r t' t t ent t Dim. 1 Ata h. a 7( No. 5- . s Ex. , tc D, t ECF 3 2) I i notcl rfom t r d wha ot f alcrmi s nt ts ea r he ecor t her eder i nal e encesBar t may have f d,i ba i ace n a ton t t t years e ati s he e. ddii o he woent nce s ue r 7 Thewar n as erst Bar if l t exhaus adm i s r i r de s t hat bat aied o t nitatve emedi ast t good es o he conduc cr tas tofhi petton. Ther e f m sa t hed t t petton r l ,however t t t edi pec s ii em dy or tac o he ii etect , ha Bar idi r s t is ofgood conduc tme durng t a i s r i r bat d aie he s ue ti i he dm nitatve emedi pr es Thus, he es oc s. t cour cannotfnd fom t r d t tt war n hasesabls l k ofe us i asa gr t i r he ecor ha he de t ihed ac xha ton ound f or di mi aloft sas tofBa ba iscl m . s ss hi pec r t' ai 3 t the sgnedpa r k i c tng t thi sa es nt nc e d on M a 13, 1 t day ha i pe wor ndia i ha s tt e e e nde y 20 0, he f de a ofk i sboco e r l t al wedhi on a wrt a ass h, s dr c vef r c e tfom M a m i, nd uc he houl e ei ede al r di r y 13t Augus 26, 0. I t ale a i , hea gues i hewa sils vi hi sae s nt nce o t 201 8 n he t m tve r ,f s tl er ng s t t e e durngt ttm e t rsat l w, wa e il t 60 da ofgood c i ha i , mde t e a he s ntted o ys onduc c edi a i tt t r t ga ns he sa etme,whi h wo d ha al d hi t c tt i c ul ve lowe m o ompl t t sa es nt nc s nert Augus 26, ee he tt e e e oo han t 9 t ae s o s s he tto 2010. The Unied St t s m ove t di m i st pe ii n, and Ba ba ihasr ponded,m aki t r t es ng he m a trrpe f c i r to te i or onsde a i n. 11 Thebr des ofBa ba isa gum e t f rprorc t cr di a s t t tbec us t oa t r t' r n s o i usody e t s ers ha a e he f r la sa es nt esa e E oncure , hes d r ceve c e ta ns li f r s nt nc ede a nd t t e enc r t c r nt' ' houl e i r di gai t ls ede al e e e fra1 h j itmeh s r e .Th fcso hi c s , o v r d no s p o thi cam. o 1t e al i e ev d e a t f s a e h we e , o t u p r t s li l af de als ntncei i pos d t nm co ure l wih a e si sa es ntnc t f e r e e sm e o nc r nty t n xitng t t e e e,he BOP m a desg t t tt i m a ewils vehi f de a s nt nc a t sa eprs f iiy y i nae ha he n t l er s e r l e e e t he tt ion aclt whe ehei s r i t sa es ntnc t alowi hi t a c u c e tagans bot s ntnce . r s e vng he t t e e e,hus l ng m o c r e r di i t h e e s S e 1 U. C. 3 21b ; e 8 S. j 6 ( ) BOP P oga S ae n 5 6 0 Th s cru tnc sddn taiei r rm ttme t 1 0.5. e e ic msa e i o rs n Ba baisca e. Hi f r s ntncewa i r t' s s ede al e e s mpos o Nove be 3 201 a trBa ba iha ed n m r 0, 0, fe r t d c plt d hi sa es nt nc a wasno l ri sa ec t y. M or ve , l t f de al om e e s tt e e es nd onge n tt usod eo r whie he e r j g n idc tsta t efd r l e tn e a et r nc n u rn l t e c oh r i d e n t ud me t n iae h t h e ea s n e c s r o u o c re ty o a h t e ,t o s o 8 I t adm i sr i r n he nitatve emedy f m sata or tched t Ba ba ispe ii , he as erst thi sat o r t' tton s t ha s t e s ne ee e onJ e2 201 j2 Pe. tc A, t3. e tnc nd d un 9, 0. 241 t Ata h. a 9 Babaia s rsi hi mo in frs r t se t n s to o ummayj dg ntt tbe a s hi o fns c nd tf on of r u me ha c u e s fe e o uc or e t sat c geswasaneces r Epal oft ofkns conduc 'f t f alc ge,he s d r ve he t e har sa y û ' he l e t t' or he eder har houl ecei cr tf t sat s e agai tt f der s e edi or he t e ent nce ns he e al ent nce.Thi alega i whi i notcl l desgna ed s l ton, ch s eary i t a asq rt cam i Bab t' p tin a p ast a srac aln et tev l i o tefd rl s e aae li n rais eio , p er o set h l g o h ai t f h e ea t e dy c cton and/ s enceasi pos Such acl m m us be r s d i a moton t vacat s asdeor onvi l or ent m ed. ai t ai e n i o e, et i c re tt s ntn eu e 28U. C. 2 i t s ntn ngc ur, eel r J ne , F.d328 3 o rc he e e c nd r S. j 255 n he e e ci o ts n e o s 226 3 , 33 (t Ci.000 , n wiln tbea d e sd h r . 4 h r2 ) a d l o d rse ee 4 i c t t tt f der ls nt nc ar t r n co ure l wih a s nt ncefom a he ndia e ha he e a e e es e o u nc r nty t ny e e r not r j rs ito Fo t e er a o s t efc ta o eo b t o Bab t' saes ne e wee u idcin. r h s e s n ,h a t h t n r o h f r ais tt e tnc s r i mpos d t r n conc r nty wih ot rs ntnc doe notafe tt caculton ofhi f r l e o u ure l t he e e es s f c he l a i s ede a s ence. ent Bar t ne a s rst thes d r c vec e ta i thi f de a s nt nc f a1tm e ba i xt s e t ha houl e ei r di ga ns s e r l e e e or 1 i s ve a t M a 1 201 whe f der la hortesi r d'hi t er d fer y 3, 0, n e a ut ii ç owe ' m mdert a pr e ndlm bor he d os que l wrt l e s nc Ba ba ia lgest tf r lofi i l,i cac ai t lngt ofhi tr of i. n s e e, r t le ha ede a fc as n lul tng he e h s em confne e unde t 1 da s ntnc i pos Aprl20, 0,f l t r ogni t thehad i m nt r he 80- y e e e m ed i 201 aied o ec ze ha sgne pa r k i c tng hi sae s nt nc wasc m plt asofM a 13,201 I t i d pe wor ndia i s tt e e e o ee y 0. n he at m ai he a gue t the s d havebe n c e t d wih good c le tve, r s ha houl e r die t onduc c e tundersae 1w t r di tt a t r duc t l ngt oft ss nt nc by 1 da f e r 30 da s r e o e e he e h hi e e e 0 ys or ve y ys e v d. To c c aewha ,i a addii lpe i ofprs tme s r edm us be c e t d alult t f ny, tona rods ion i e v t r die agans Bar t' f de a prs n s t nc ,t c tm us deer newhen t saer lnquihe i t ba is e r l io en e e he our t t mi he t t ei s d prmar cusody ofhi . I i wele t bls d t t i y t m t s l sa ihe ha ()fd r l e tn ed e no b gnt r n. . e ap io e i saec td i a e ea s ne c o s t e i o u . wh n rs n r n tt uso y s pr uc d f pr e uton i f de alc t s ntt a f r lwrtofha as od e or os c i n e r our pur ua o ede a i be c r sa pr s q e dl Rah r t esaerti p i r j rs ito o e t e opu d o e u n l m. te ,h tt eans rmay u idcin v r h prs ne ,a f r lc t c io r nd ede a usody omm e sonl whe t sae a horte nce y n he t t ut ii s r lnquiht prs ei s he ioneron s if c i oft sa eoblgai n. Se Thom a v. atsa ton he t t i to e s W hae 962F. 358,361n.3(t Ci.1 2) ln, 2d 4h r 99 . Untd Sae v. a , 5 F.d9 8 91 (t Ci.1 9 ) ûA)fd r l i o h b a c r usa ie tts Ev ns 1 9 3 0 , 2 4h r 9 8 . : e ea m t f a e s op d ( pr eq ndlm meey l nst prs rt f r a hortes'a doesnottr f ml1asae os ue l rl oa he ione o edeal ut ii ' nd t ansor t tt prs ne i oafde a prs r'I (iai o te . io r nt e r l ione ' d. cttons mitd) 5 Be us s eofi a sr e t d a deai d Ba baio M a ch 1 201 t sa eha ca e ut fcil se nd t ne r t n r 2, 0, he t t d p i t j rs ito o rhm u tlh c mpltdhssges ne e .0 M o e v r a jn a te rma. u id cin ve i n i e o ee i tt e tnc s1 y ro e , s o g s h saertie p i r c so y hec n iu dt s r eh ssaeo lg to s e e wh l s be t o tt ean d rmay u t d , o tn e o ev i tt bi ai n , v n ie u j c t t f de ala pr e nd wr t nl afe he co pl t d hi sa e s nt nc a s a e he e r d os que um i.O y t r m e e s t t e e es nd t t a ho ii sr lnq s dprm a y c t on Augus 26,201 di hi ofi i lde e i on t ut rte ei uihe i r usody t 0, d s fc a t nton he f de alc r s be n. e r ha ge ga Ba ba ihasno cl i t tBOP ofk i l m i c l ul t hi t r ofc i m e on t r t a m ha t a s s a c a ed s e m ontne nt he sa es n e . BOP ofk i sha no r ponsbiiy o a hort f de e m i ngt a o mtof t t e t nce t al ve es i lt r ut iy or t r ni he m t good c onduc tm eunde s e lw t becr die a ns hi sa es nt e orf rfgtrngout ti r ut a o e t d gai t s t t e enc o i li whe hec n omplt d hi sa es nt e. Theoblga i t complt s h c l ultonsf lst e e s tt e enc 11 i ton o e e uc a c a i a l o a opraesaeofkil,ba e onr or fo t saec t a t saeprs orj l ppr it tt t as s d ec ds r m he tt ours nd he tt ions ais i ved i Ba ba issa ec i na pr ee ngsa c t nvol n r t' t t rmi l oc di nd usody. M or ve ,Ba baidoe no r f t eo r r t s t e u e t wa de se de ofsa ea ho ii s r por t BOP ofk il t tBaba issae s nt nc he r n' vi nce t t ut rte ' e t o t a s ha r t' t t e e e wasco plt d on Augus 26,201 BOP ofi i sc d rg f l r l on t ss nt e m ee t 0. fcal oul i htuly ey hi e enc c ompl ton da ea r pored t t m by sa ea horte . ei t s e t o he t t ut iis ThegitofBa ba ispeii n i t tt BOP di notgi hi alt prorc t c edi s r t' tto s ha he d ve m l he i usody r t t whih he wase tted. Thef ct hea lges howe r a enots t i ntt de o c n il a s le , ve , r ufk e o monsr t any tae micac a i unde t a ia ef r lsaut s s lul ton r he pplc bl ede a tt e . Ca c a i oft prorc t y c e tade e ntm a r cevea i thi f r l l ulton he i usod r di f nda y e i gans s ede a s ne c i g v m e b j3 8 ( ) whihsae : e tn e s o e d y 5 5 b , c tts 1 Ba ba ias erst he wasaresed on M ar h 1 , 2010,on bot sat and f r char . The 0 r t s t hat r t c 2 h te ede al ges po sbii t a h ha c a g sfo bohj rs cinsp ndnga t etmeofhi ar s,h ve , e no s i lt h t e d h r e r m t u idito e i t h i y s re t owe r do s t change t f tt Vol i Count ofk i sa r t and det ned hi on t dat gi ngt sat he ac hat usa y f al r esed ai m hat e, vi he t e pi r j rs cinov rhi rmay uidito e m. 1 B a ba iciesno aut iy i s 1 r t t hort n uppor ofhi vagu ass rton t tBOP of i al s d appl t s e e i ha fci s houl y good conduc tm e aut i unde Fl i 1w agai thi f r t m ofc i ti horzed r orda a ns s ede al er onfnement . 6 ( b) Cr tf prorcusody.- dee nts l be gi n ce tt r t edi or i t -A fnda hal ve rdi owad he s r i e of a t r of i prs e f a tm e he ha s nt i of i i e vc em m i onm nt or ny i s pe n f c al de e i prort t da e t s nt e co m enc t nton i o he t he e enc m es () 1 a a r s t of t ofe e f whih t s nt e was s eul he fns or c he e enc i mpos d'o e ,r () 2 a ars l o a oh rc ag f rwhc ted fn a twa s e ut f ny te h r e o ih h e e d n s a r s ed a tr t c m i s on of t of e e f r w li h t r e t fe he om s i he f ns o tc he s t nc wasi en e e mpos d; e t tha not en c e t d agans a t rs nt nc ha s be r die i t nohe e e e. 1 U. C.j 3585. I t s sci t 8 S. n hi e ton, ç congrs ma cla t ta dee ntc d notrc ve e s de e r ha fnda oul e ei d u ec e i f rhi d tni ntme' ie S ae v W is n 5 3U. 3 , 3 ( 9 2 .Th , o bl rdt o s ee to i . 'Untd tts . lo , 0 S. 29 3 7 1 9 ) us by sa ut t BOP c nno gr ntprorc t c edi f tme s r d bef r c tt e, he n t a i usody r t or i e ve o e omm e me of nce nt t de e he f ndan ' f der l s nt nc , i t prs r ha r e ved c e t f t t c t t s e a e e e f he i one s ec i r di or ha us ody t a d ow r a t e sn e c .Uni dS ae v Br wn, 7 F.d 5 4,1 9 W L 2 7 7 , t*1( t Ci. 9 2 noh r e tn e t tts . o 9 7 2 7 9 2 e 3 2 5 a 4h r 1 9 ) ( n u ls e )(id n d fn a tma r c iece ia an th sfd r l e tnc f rtmes e ti u p b ih d fn i g ee d n y e ev r dt g is i e ea s n e e o i p n n ofi i de e i prort t da e hi s ntnc c fcal t nton i o he t s e e e omm e es t e s i has be n c edied a ns nc mls t e r t gai t a oh rsn e c ) n t e e tn e. Bar t' f r ls nt nc co me e on No mbe 30,201 t dae whe i was bais ede a e e e m nc d ve r 0, he t nt i o e . j3 8 () Un e j3 8 () h c udr c i ce ia ans hsfd r l e tn ef r mp s d 5 5 a . d r 5 5b , e o l e eve r dt g i t i e ea s ne c o a pe i ofofk i de e in s r d be or Novembe 30, ny rod t al t nto e ve f e r 2010,f whi h hedi notr ceve or c d e i sat s nt nc c e t co di t sa eofk i s r por t t BOP,Ba ba idi notco plt t e e e e r di.Ac r ng o tt t al' e t o he r t d m ee li sae s nt nc untlAugus 26, ls t t e e es i t 2010. Se dc ofhi sa es nt esbega upon hi a r s r e s tt e enc n s ret a c i d durng t tmebe we n M a 1 a Aug t26, 0,at h f de a ofk i s nd ontnue i he i t e y 3 nd us 201 lhoug e r l t al t n ha physc lc t ofBa ba iunde t wrtofha asc usadpr eque l .Be a e he d i a usody r t r he i be om os ndlm c us heha notde onsr t d t thedi no r ceve c edi a ns hi sa es nt nc f t tpe i s m ta e ha d t e i r t gai t s t t e e es or ha rod 7 oftme Ba baiha no de onsr t t thei e il d t r eve prorc t c e tagans hi i , r t s t m taed ha s ntte o ec i i usody r di i t s fd r l e tn efrt t ro 1 j? g (; e e a s n e c o ha peid.2 5 5j . ) Fort r as sa e t c t ncude t tBar t ha notsa e f t on whih he i he e ons tt d,he our co l s ha ba i s tt d ac s c s e ildt rlefunde j2241 The eor,t c t a st wrde smotont dimisand ntte o ei r . r f e he our gr nt he n' i o s s d n e Bab t' moin f rs mmm.j g n .Ana p o raeo d rwil n e t sd y e is r ais to o u y ud me t p r p it r e l e tr hi a . The Clr i die t t s nd co e oft sm e a um opi on a a ompa ng or rt e k s r ced o e pis hi mor nd ni nd cc nyi de o pe ii nera t c elofr co d f t r ponden . tto nd o ouns e r or he es t E TR Ti Gp dy f >& 1. N E : hs d aoJ , 3 : ChifUnie St t sDititJ e t d a e src udge 1 Babaic mpai t tt fd rlsne igj getl hi hewo drc i pirc so y 2 r t o l ns ha he e ea e tncn ud od m ul eeve ro utd cr tf tme s ved bet edi or i er ween M a 1 a Augus 26,2010.Beca et BOP, and nott dit itcour y 3 nd t us he he src q i gr nt aut iy t cal at t m sofcontnementa prorcusody cr t however aj ge' s a ed hort o cul e er i nd i t edi , ud s c mme t a ou s n e c ce tc nn te il Ba b t t r le un rj22 .Uni d S ae v. ilr 8 o n s b t e t n e r di a o ntte r ai o eif de 41 t tt s M le , 71 e F.d 48 , 9- 0( t Ci.1 9) 2 8 48 9 4h r 98 . 8

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.