Hannah v. Mardavich et al, No. 7:2012cv00320 - Document 4 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 07/19/2012. (kab)

Download PDF
r FRKS OFFI U. DI COUA d CE S. SX AT ROANOKE, VA FI. rD ! I TH E U N I N TED STA TE S D I STR I T C O U R T C FO R TH E W E STER N DI STR I T O F V I G I I C R N A R O A N O K E D IV ISIO N D ER W IN K E N DA LL H A N N A H , JUL !8 2 1 . 22 J A C., - CLERK ULt ' . BY; op' t E r kvc C i lA ct on N o.7: vi i 12cv00320 Pl ntff ai i , M EM O M N DU M O PI I N N O FR A N K E.M A R D A V ICH et al, . D efendants. By:Sam uelG .W ison l Uni St esD i t ctJudge ted at s ri Pl i ifD e wi H a h, V i gi a i a e pr ee ngpr s ha tl t sa ton a ntf r n nna a r ni nm t oc di o e, s i ed hi c i purua t 42U. C.j1 agans sxdee t, 1ofwhom a art bee oye soft s nto S. 983 i t i fndans a1 ppe o mpl e he D a le A dul De e i C e e ,c ai i i t r i t c tt i lvi a i a s e ng nvil t t nton nt r l m ng nde e m na e ons iutona ol tons nd e ki d ma e a dij n tv r le .Be a eHa n h h sn tpe fcsi s p r o hi cams t e a g s n n u cie eif c us n a a o ld a t n u po t f s li ,h c u t ldimisHa na sc mpan wih u p eu iet r fln o r wil s s n h' o lit t o t rj d c o eiig. A c pl i m us a l ge t nough f t t s a e a cl i t r le t ti pl us bl on is om a nt t le d e ac s o t t a m o e i f ha s a i e t f e. Gi rtnov.J hns 521F. 298,302(t Ci. )( i BelAt.Cop.v. ac ' araa ' o on, 3d 4h r 2008 quotng l l Twombl 550U. 5 570( v, S. 44, 2007).Howe r t fmii r e ofpla ngaeg e ty ) ve,he a lar uls e di r r al r l xe f pr s pl i i f ,a lt g t w ih m ert i cl i s s ul notbe s ym i d by e a d oï o e a nt f s nd ii an s t ior ous a m ho d t e t hnialrquieme s Se Bea tv.CiyofHa on,775F. 1 1 ec c e r nt. e udet t mpt 2d 274, 277-78( h Ci. 4t r 1 5) Stl,t r lxai oft nzesi notwihoutlmis A cour mus,a mi mum, a e 98 . il he ea ton he l s t i t. t t t ni be bl t dice n f om t c pl ntt pa tesbei s d a t a l ged c o s r r he om ai he ri ng ue nd he le onduc on w hi h ea h c a m t c c li r t . Though r a es s el xed,t s a r s ilde a g ne a cohe e e, i doe notr qui e he t nda d tl m nds e r l r nc and t s e r c u t toc n u eu q e to n ve s u rl p e e tdt t e ' I a 1 8 Ditit o rs o rs s o j r p u sins e r q aey r s ne o h m. d. t 27 . src c u t t ' a e r quied t r vi w pr s r c pl i s f com pla e w ih t ba i r esofpl a ng, nd i r e r o e e i one om a nt or i nc t he s c ul e di a n doi s t c t us eihert de i y c za e c a m s ordi m i s t c pl i ... ft ng o, he our m t t d ntf ogni bl l i i s s he om a nt i he co ant...al t sat acam uponwhihr i ma beg a e ' 28U. C.j1 5A( . mpli fis o t e li c elef y r ntd. ' S. 91 b) Hee, nna hastldac aitdi de i ot e cli (1 t ta uns cfe r Ha h ie ompl n vi d nt hre ams: ) ha n pe iid dee ntt hi pe s lpr t ( t theS e ei dac r f ar orwhihwass d fnda ook s rona opery,2) ha ç c ve hage or az r c ol o t fc n e n, n ta c ul (lfc ( ilrla ed t, a d ()t a a u p cfe d fn a t u o a te a d h t o d a fe t hs ee s ae' n 3 h t n ns e iid ee d n ' haase hi c usnghi me a a s a e ina sr s ( r s d m, a i m ntl nguih nd moto l tes. Compl2,ECF No.1)The . . co pli tdoesnotelbor t a t how orwhe a ha as mentocc r t cr um sa s m an a ae s o n ny r s ured, he ic t nce s r ur oundi hi di c plna y c ge, ha pr ry t de e nt t a underw ha f c ua ng s s i i r har w t ope t he f nda s ook nd t at l cic sa est t i,whi de e nt pa tcpa e i whi h c s ofc r um tnc hey ook t ch f nda s ri i t d n c our es onduc ,o wha t r t s cii rgh st def nda sha vi aed. Theco ti t r f eunabl t r ibl dic r a pe fc i t he e nt ve ol t ur s he e or e o ela y s e n ny pa tc a cons iutonalvi a i fom t com pl ntort d e m i w he he a vi bl cl i s ri ul r tt i ol ton r he ai o et r ne t r ny a e a m lea i tany i vi lde e nt .W hiet pl di r l sdo noti i gans ndi dua f nda s l he ea ng u e mpos a e c i e n xa tng s a r on H n h,a w hie t c ti i f c s i t ofhi c a m s a w illbe a l t nda d nna nd l he our s n a t olcious s l i nd l i r ly c t u a pl a ng t he tl i t f ur ,he m us of e s m e f hol on whi h t ons r e ny e di hat i es n he ut e t fr o oot d c he de enda t c n ba e a ans e o on whi h t c tc ba e a de i i 1 A c or ngl , t f ns a s n w r r c he our an s c s on. c di y he c u t ldimisHn na sc mpan wi u p eu iep ru n t 2 U. C.j1 5 e( )B) o r wil s s n h' o lit t t rj d c u s a t o 8 S. ho 91 ()2 ( f f l et sa eacli . or aiur o t t am EN TER :Jul 19,201 y 2. / / f s ' . ux e e . * z'T . ,' . v j,-e , , . .+ UN I TED STATES D I STRI J D GE CT U 'Ha nnahhasfld as tlte i whih hesaest thehasuns es uly r que t t de e nt f l ie hor etr n c tt ha ucc sf l e sed he f nda s' ul namesfo t die t oft D a leA dul Deen i Cen e .Thec ti notdim isngHanna sc pli f r m he r cor he nvil t t ton t r our s s si h' om ant or f ii t pr de t de e t 'f lna es a lng o ovi he f ndan s ul m .

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.